Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Da Vinci Code

Da Vinci Code

fresno sikh · 03 May 2006

WJKK WJKF Just want to share about the recent happening in the news Da Vinci Code book and the movie that will soon come out. Sikhs should be aware of these facts when approached by missionaries. This is the summary of the claimed facts by the author. Jesus is not God; he was only a man. Jesus was married to Mary Magdalene. She is to be worshiped as a goddess. Jesus got her pregnant, and the two had a daughter. That daughter gave rise to a prominent family line that is still present in Europe today. The Bible was put together by a pagan Roman emperor. Jesus was viewed as a man and not as God until the fourth century, when he was given the status of GOD by the emperor Constantine. The Gospels have been edited to support the claims of later Christians. In the original Gospels, Mary Magdalene rather than Peter was directed to establish the Church. There is a secret society known as the Priory of Sion that still worships Mary Magdalene as a goddess and is trying to keep the truth alive. The Catholic Church is aware of all this and has been fighting for centuries to keep it suppressed. It often has committed murder to do so. The Catholic Church is willing to and often has assassinated the descendents of Christ to keep his bloodline from growing. [%sig%]

Re: Da Vinci Code

A Singh · 03 May 2006

Dear "fresno sikh" - please go and read some authentic history - the Da Vinci Code is a myth, granted an exciting one, but a myth. The conclusions are rather like an infamous sikh website from the UK which has caused much uproar in certain circles about various "cover ups" and "suppressions of truth".

Re: Da Vinci Code

LK · 03 May 2006

lol, I don't think the Catholic Church is willing to assissnate his descendents now, even though they might have 200 years ago. Also all of the above are only theories based on the highly controversial gnostic texts which have been found, so don't think that the Entire Catholic church has been ripped apart lol

Re: Da Vinci Code

sanjo · 03 May 2006

i watched a documantry on the nostic texts n they support the idea that man can merge with god like sikhi teaches, n that perhaps god isnt a entity far far away like "modern" christianity preaches. it was interesting to watch. the da vinci code stuff is just alot of twisted history made to sound interesting so the author could make alot of money of the back of his book. the actual history of christianity is very interesting on how its been moulded to suite emperor constantines and romes needs.

Re: Da Vinci Code

Harcharan Singh · 03 May 2006

It is strange though, that the catholic church have and do deny the status of Mary Magdalene?? Also, why have they never acknowledged or promoted Mary's gospal? http://www.webcom.com/gnosis/library/marygosp.htm There are a lot of contradictions in the church, and I have always found the notion of a notorious Roman persecutor of the Christians having a dream/revelation and having the new testament revealed to him, when there were so many die hard Christians around at the time - as well as Jesus's own siblings, he had 2 brothers if I recall correctly. The other funny thing is that di vinci's painting clearly shows a woman at Jesus's side, yet they deny that also... Jesus was a man - even if divine, and most likely was married and had children, no reason why he wouldn't, as semetic prophets before and after him did. Not sure about other theories in the book though. Just some thoughts.

Re: Da Vinci Code

Robert Langdon · 03 May 2006

Its a myth but some believe it to be real and are chasing the grail, Dan Brown claims the grail is not the cup of Jesus but is actually the living descendant of Jesus, who in the book is called Sophie Neveau. How true it is, I dont know, but its a good book with good history and good story line.

Re: Da Vinci Code

lol · 03 May 2006

hmm what does gurbani say about jesus? .....i mean we are told about the main religions of the east but jesus is never mentioned? ...correct me if im wrong :P

Re: Da Vinci Code

singh · 04 May 2006

But all the facts, say this is all true, so maybe thats why the church did not want the book or movie made ?

Re: Da Vinci Code

singh · 04 May 2006

I really have a funny feeling that it is true ! weird I know.

Re: Da Vinci Code

A Singh · 04 May 2006

Veer Harcharan Singh - the painting is of John the Baptiste, who always looks feminine is most of his paintings (including that of Mr Da Vinci), so this claim by Dan Brown is highly questionable. As per Mary Magdaline, this has been addressed quite a number of times with references by the Catholic Church, here is a quick write up from the icmonastary site: What is the Da Vinci Code? The Da Vinci Code is a novel. It is not a scholarly work on religion. It is not a history book. It is not a theological treatise. It is an Adventure-Mystery novel. The problem is, the novel is cleverly written to weave myth with truth, fact and fiction together, so that the myth and the fiction become believable. What is the premise of the Novel? The novel states that after the death of Jesus, a group of his followers took a boat and sailed to France . Among this group was Lazareth, whom Jesus raised from the dead, and Mary Magdalene. The premise continues. The book asserts that Mary Magdalene was not a repentant prostitute but the she was the wife of Jesus. She also she bore him a daughter. The novel goes on to say, that this truth was suppressed by the Catholic Church but handed down by a Secret Society. The most prominent member of Society was Leonardo Da Vinci. Da Vinci encoded this message in his paintings The premise continues. Mary Magdalene married into the Marovingian Line of French Kings. The descendants of Jesus live among French Nobility, to this day. Legend holds that the first Marovingian Queen was impregnated by a fish, the symbol for Christ. Now let us separate the myths and fiction from truth and historical fact. What are the Myths that are cleverly woven throughout this Novel? Myth #1: Mary Magdaline was married to Jesus. This concept is not mentioned anywhere in the Bible. It is not mentioned in the Gnostic Gospels or the Apocryphal Gospels. It is not mentioned in any verifiable historical Document. Mary Magdalene is not mentioned as a family member of Jesus anywhere. Every indication from Church Tradition suggests that Jesus was single. Even the Bible indicates that Jesus was single. In 1 Corinthians 9:5, St. Paul upholds the right to marry. “Don't we have the right to take a believing wife along with us, as do the other apostles and the Lord's brothers and Peter.” Had Jesus been married, He would have been Paul’s primary and most convincing reason to marry. Myth #2: Jesus was viewed as a man and not as God until the fourth century, when he was deified by the emperor Constantine. From the moment of the Resurrection, both Church and Secular history tell us that Jesus was viewed as God. The Heresy of Arianism denied Christ’s Divinity in the 4th Century. This premise, that Jesus was not viewed as God until the 4th century in Brown’s Book, is a modern day Heresy. Myth #3: Leonardo Da Vinci’s supports Brown’s Premise: A reclusive, illegitimate, possibly homosexual painter and sculptor, of the 15th Century, is Brown’s primary support. Dan Brown’s premise is that the Holy Grail is not the chalice of the Last Supper but rather it is Mary Magdalene herself. Brown states that Da Vinci depicted this in his painting of “The Last Supper”. There is no chalice in Da Vinci’s painting. Brown asserts that Da Vinci depicted the chalice as the figure at the right of Jesus. Brown claims that this figure is not St. John (the beloved disciple) but it is Mary Magdalene. Did Da Vinci, living in the 15th Century, have an historical understanding of what 1st Century Hebrews drank out of? Do you? In the 15th century, Florentines drank out of glasses. Glasses are depicted in the painting. The chalice of the Last Supper, was most likely a clay cup, long since lost. I cannot fathom how the absence of a Medieval chalice in a painting, indicates that Mary Magdalene is the Holy Grail. Myth #3 The Bible was put together by a pagan Roman emperor. St. Athanasius and the Eccumenical Councils of the Church put the Bible together. This is historical fact. St. Athanasius (Bishop of Alexandra) in 367AD, wrote a Pastoral Letter. In the letter he listed 27 Sacred Books as inspired by God or “Canonical.” They became “The New Testament.” Athanasius said, "In these (books) alone is proclaimed the Good News of the teaching of true religion." These 27 Books were confirmed by the Council of Hippo (393), the Council of Carthage (397) and finally the Council of Trent (1546). The Old Testament books were accepted as canonical by the Council of Trent. This gave us the Bible we have today. It contains 46 books in the Old Testament, 27 books on the New Testament, 73 books in all. Myth #4 There is a secret society known as the “Priory of Zion ” that still worships Mary Magdalene as a goddess and is trying to keep the truth alive. The only source for this premise is a document was found in 1960 in the French National Library. It was called “Dossiers Secret,” or “Secret Files.” This questionable document mentions a Secret Society called, “The Priory of Zion .” It also lists Leonardo Da Vinci’s as a member. Where did this document come from? It mysteriously appeared in 1960. No one had seen it prior to 1960. The origin of this document is highly suspect. There is no indication where this document comes from? It was never “logged-into” the Museum’s document collection. Was it planted in this Museum to support this story? No other historical documents, in existence today, mention “The Priory of Zion .” Myth #5 The Catholic Church is aware of all this and has been fighting for centuries to keep it suppressed. It often has committed murder to do so. The Church has stated that the entire premise is ridiculous. Why would the Church murder someone to keep secret a myth secret that is know to so many people? It is like murdering to keep secret the myth of the Easter Bunny. To date, no one associated with the Catholic Church, has ever been arrested, charged with or convicted of any crime attempting to cover up, the Da Vinci Code. What are the truths or facts in the Book, “The Da Vinci Code” Truth #1: Mary Magdaline was not a prostitute. There is no indication in the Bible that Mary Magdalene was a prostitute. She was among a group of women who supported the ministry of Jesus. These women would prepare lodging, food, etc, for Jesus and His disciples. She also supported him financially. Why has she been seen as a prostitute for 2,000 years? She is depicted in the Bible as, “Having been possessed by devils and healed by Jesus.” In ancient times “being possessed by devils” meant, you had an illness. Ancient people did not understand disease. To be sick meant that you were possessed by devils. In scripture Mary is introduced right after a passage about a prostitute, whose sins were forgiven by Jesus. How did she become connected with prostitution? In the year 591 Pope Gregory, The Great gave an Easter Sermon. In this sermon he stated that Mary Magdalene was this repentant prostitute. Prior to the 6th Century there was no mention of Mary Magdalene being a prostitute. The Church corrected this misconception of Mary being a prostitute in 1969. Truth #2 There were other Gospels than those listed in the Bible: Discovered by archeologists are The Gospels of Thomas, The Gospel of Truth, The Gospel of Philip and even a Gospel of Mary Magdalene. These are acknowledged as written in Biblical times however, these writings are not canonical Gospels. What does that mean? In the years following the death of Jesus, many books or Gospels were written. With all of these writings concerning the Life of Jesus, the early Fathers had to determine which were inspired by God and which were not. The four Gospels of Mark, Matthew, Luke and John were declared “The inspired word of God.” The others were declared “of human origin” and rejected for inclusion in our Bible. The Gospel of Thomas was rejected because it depicted many elements that the Fathers did not believe. “Jesus became angry with his childhood friends and zapped them.” “Jesus made birds from mud, threw them in the air and they flew away.” The disciples brought Mary Magdalene to Jesus and said: “Only men can enter into the Kingdom of God , what about Mary.” Jesus answered, “Don’t worry, I will turn her into a man.” Truth #3: Mary Magdaline was a powerful leader in Early Church Fr. Richard McBrian (noted Scripture Scholar) says, “Mary Magdalene is one of the greatest saints in the Early Church .” She is the most frequently mentioned woman in the New Testament. She was at the foot of the Cross when Jesus died when all but one of his male followers had fled and hid. After his Resurrection, Jesus first appeared to Mary Magdalene. Recent finds are revealing Mary Magdalene’s position in the early Church. Truth #4: The Bible has been edited to support the claims of later Christians. The original Bible of St. Athanaius and the Church Councils, was edited by King James 6th of Scotland . James is an ancestor of mine as his grandmother was a Douglas in my Family Line. He produced the King James Version of the Bible to conform it to Protestant Theology. The books that he omitted are called “The Apocrypha” by Protestants to this day. In Summary: The book, “The Da Vinci Code” is a well written and entertaining novel. It contains all the suspense of a good murder mystery. You will find it hard to put it down. If you see the book as only a novel and fiction, you will have no problem, enjoy it. However if you see the novel as historical and allow its clever weaving of fact with fiction to effect your faith, then you will have a problem. I am certain the purpose for Mr. Brown’s writing this novel is not history or theology but profit. He has achieved that goal, one hundred fold. I have tried in this talk, to separate the myth from the truth in the “Da Vinci Code.” First, I wanted to allow you to enjoy this novel without having problems with your faith. Second, I would like to keep Mr. Brown from being burned at the stake.

Re: Da Vinci Code

K S Dhillon Uk Wala · 04 May 2006

Some Thoughts... Semitic priests (rabbi’s) had to be married in order to be recognized as a rabbi (which is what Jesus was known as). The New Testament was complied; some say 80-200 years after the departure of Christ. Within this amount of time, any number of additions/subtractions could have been made to the original documents, but please do note that Jesus did not put quill to parchment, what has been in circulation for the past two thousand years are sakhi's.....stories written by followers or by people wanting to distort the truth (similar to our bhai bala janamsakhi...with mythological stories of Sir Guru Nanak Dev Ji) Da Vinci’s mural of the last supper does most definitely show a lady sitting next to Christ...most prophets/guru's/avatars were married, so this should/could not be too far from the truth? Within your own faith we have many sets of beliefs, we have those who profess to the sakhis as being as important as the Sir Guru Granth Sahib, we have those who want to ordain the so-called dasam granth as 100% Sir guru Gobind Singh Ji's bani, and those who deem our beloved guru's as being descendants of ram/krishna.... All said and done, I am looking forward to the movie based upon the book. I applaud the Christian people for letting both book and film, to be released. If this was about our Guru's, what would be our reaction? thanks

Re: Da Vinci Code

..... · 04 May 2006

anyone seen the conspiracy video on google video's, its about free masons & its got a pic of Harmandir Sahib...indicating free masons are everywhere & controlling many institutions... but its important to mention no other religious institutions were mentioned neither any pic of any other reigious places...

Re: Da Vinci Code

LK · 04 May 2006

From my understanding of Gurbani, he is, just like Christians state, son of Vaheguru

Re: Da Vinci Code

sikhsister · 04 May 2006

The word 'Kathaebee' is used many times in Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji to refer to holy scriptures of christians, jewish and muslims. Please search. baedh kathaebee bhaedh n jaathaa || The Vedas and the Bible do not know the mystery of God. Guru Nanak Dev Ji -Raag Maaroo - Ang 1021

Re: Da Vinci Code

fresno sikh · 04 May 2006

WJKK WJKF "Sant Ki Ninda Nanaka Bhaur Bhaur Avatar". As the quote states Whosoever says bad about sants will have to born again and again. My aim for the original post was to learn more about the Da Vinci Code mystery which has been a media frenzy it was not to say stuff about Jesus Christ. But I think A singh is a Christan missionary. Sikhs should be proud of the facts that original Adi Granth is still present to avoid any controversies among us. People in general are governed by 5 vices and anything they say or do shows that. Scriptures written by people rather than prophets themselves are one sided as shown by A singh posts that some Gospels were rejected and others were put together as bible by the "Early Fathers". But I thank A singh to shed light on this topic.

Re: Da Vinci Code

confused · 04 May 2006

we have the same problems i'm surprised we made it this far without mention of RAAGMALA....yes thats right, is Raagmala authentic...christians arent the only ones with photoshop problems...someone didnt do a good job

Re: Da Vinci Code

lol · 05 May 2006

LK, a humble benti can u get show me where in gurbani jesus is mentioned, much appreciated :) - coz im always confused on this concept ;P

Re: Da Vinci Code

A Singh · 05 May 2006

Christian Missionary! Are you sure Veer Jee - perhaps, you may wish to check with other members on this forum, as I'm sure I was previously some combination of RSS-Agent, come GOI Congressi Agent crossed with being a Brahmin and a Tarkhan simultaneously holding, supporting and practising hardcore Sanatan views and a undercover Radhasoami and Namdhari...

Re: Da Vinci Code

fresno sikh · 05 May 2006

WJKK WJKF

Re: Da Vinci Code

sanjo · 06 May 2006

there is an part in the gospel of judas, where it describes a instance where jesus is laughing at his disciples, as they are saying thank you to god before beginning to eat a meal. judas understands why jesus is laughing, it is because jesus's disciples are worshipping the "god" which made the world i.e brahma like hindus believe i think. jesus laughs because he knows this god is not worthy of worship only the true almighty god is i.e waheguru. judas is the only disciple who knows jesus's way of thinking. christians say jesus is god, but that decision was made by some emperors not by jesus himself. i think the only thing jesus said was "thou art thou" or something along the lines. people took it to mean "i am god", however it may msot likely mean as described in bandgi nama as "i am one with god". this is totally different to "i am god". daas found this very interesting because its very close to sikhi, as we believe one can merge with waheguru and be one with him. it was also mentioned in a documentary that the lost gospels like judas etc, are for advanced level teaching. the new testament is for the average man, whereas if the person climbs higher up the spiritual ladder and becomes more saintly then these other gospels become more relevant and the person can now understand the more abstract confusing concepts contained in these. if we went to a christian or muslim etc and tryed to explain the concept of merging with waheguru they would find it very hard to understand because they are very much so set in their ways in their belief that god is far away in some kingdom, but perhaps this is the message jesus was trying to get across all along??? who knows, maybe through mans own stupidness the true message of jesus has been lost, either way the religion still focuses on some heaven, whereas sikhi focuses on the higher plane of truth sachkand which is waheguru himself. but if these gospels are accurate n were meant to be included then there are some interesting similarities between sikhi n extinct forms of christianity. but i think its safe to say sikhi is the only path which leads to sahckand and waheguru. n i duno bout other religions putting emphasis on naam, but i think in the bible it mentioned how everything was created from the name of the lord or something. forgive daas, he isnt very knowledgable on these matters. waheguroo

Re: Da Vinci Code

A Singh · 09 May 2006

careful sanjo - fresno sikh will also accuse you of being a christian missionary!!!

Re: Da Vinci Code

lisbis · 18 May 2006

I don't understand why if Jesus was married it should be considered such a debacle. After all the teachings are that God sent his only son to live as a man. The only "crisis" would be if there were lies to cover this fact up. Whether he was married or not he still has changed and impacted all of the years since his death. It does not negate all that was spiritual and devine about him. In fact it makes more sense.

Re: Da Vinci Code

IHPF · 19 May 2006

Christ did not come to His creation to find earthly pleasure but rather that His creation might find eternal pleasure in knowing Him. Marriage wasn't part of the "servant" mind that Jesus possessed, whereas fallen man has only his own pleasure in mind to fulfill. Christ had a divine mission and it did not involve setting up housekeeping and raising a family.

Re: Da Vinci Code

Sardar · 19 May 2006

Let Christians deal with this.

Re: Da Vinci Code

Daniel Katahdin · 20 May 2006

I believe that part of your statement is incorrect. I know of no effort to affect the "Worship" of Mary Magdelene as a "Goddess". I believe that most of the other points are facts. It has been proved that the "Christian Church" murdered in the past 2,000 yrs; IE: The killing of witches, priests, people, and distractors within the Church were killed as heretics and blasphemers. The early Catholic Church was evil and this evil reflected the ignorance of mankind; selfishness, greed, and power is reflected in the people who ascended to the Papacy and the Institution of the Church as a Power. Even recent events have exposed a "secret" in American Churches in the form of Homosexuality and crimes were committed upon young boys and so a "coverup" began which can be attributed as twofold: 1) The sanctity of the confessional, foregiveness for Individuals, and redemtion for Priests within the Church, contributed to the problem. 2) The fear of a public scandal, participation of authority figures, and fear of financial ruin and destruction to the church, that would result in permanent social ostracism in America and around the globe. Self Interest' governed all. Many of the points you raise are human failings and can be exibited in every religion which has placed it's own institution and dogma above the teachings of it's founders. If it were true that Jesus was married to "Mary Magdelene" and had a daughter, there is no doubt in my mind that the scenario fictionalized in this book and movie would be plausable. There is no doubt in my mind, in the light of all the other actions the Church was taking around the world and in it's backyard; that the Papacy would try to cover this fact up, even possibly for the good of the Church, as Jesus' line would continue as priests or Popes, etc. and the bloodline used for good. Fact is stranger than fiction, anything is possible.

Re: Da Vinci Code

Harjas Kaur Khalsa · 20 May 2006

[quote]John the Baptiste, who always looks feminine is most of his paintings (including that of Mr Da Vinci), so this claim by Dan Brown is highly questionable.[quote] I always have fun with history. What is true...is there is a lot of truth distorted in those myths. Suppressed, violently eliminated, half-buried...but still there. Underneath centuries of alteration and repainting of the image of John the beloved in Da Vinci's Last Supper...was this restored image, which is undeniably female and had been deliberately hidden underneath. http://www.press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/504271_john.html What happened to Mary Magdalen the Goddess? Lol, the Catholics simply replaced her with Mother Mary the almost Goddess. Early Christianity is very confused doctrinally. Thats why the history to suppress and deny these alterations were so violent. The Da Vinci Code takes liberties. But it is based on real conflicts within the early Christian Church, and exposes teachings which for centuries, simply knowing about would cost you death by torture. Jesus was a Jewish rabbi. And to be that, he would have to be a stable, married man. What is insinuated into Christianity, is Greco-Roman paganism. Their priests were often celibates, and there holy heroes were considered semi-divine sons of God. Ideas utterly foreign to Judaism, which is why Judaism rejected the early Christian sect as pagan rather than Jewish. In Judaism, there is no God but God. God does not give birth to semi-divine children. Pay attention to the name of the first Christian Church.... Roman...Catholic. Roman Mother Goddess, Diana. Roman Catholic Mother of God, Mary. Egyptian goddess Isis and infant god Horus. Mary and infant Jesus. Romanized statue of Isis with Horus. Early Christian Mary and child Christ. IHS remains distinctive in Catholic Churches. Stands for Iesous Hominus Santos Jesus the God-man. But originally it represented the earliest pagan trinity: Isis, Horus and Set. God the Mother. God the Father. And God the Son. [quote]Constantine's profession of Christianity was not an unmixed blessing to the church. Constantine used the church as an instrument of imperial policy, imposed upon it his imperial ideology, and thus deprived it of much of the independence which it had previously enjoyed. -An Online Encyclopedia of Roman Emperors, Constantine I (306 - 337 A.D.)[/quote] Emperor Constantine I, who made Christianity a Roman state religion [%sig%]

Re: Da Vinci Code

Sanjo · 21 May 2006

IHPF said: "Christ did not come to His creation to find earthly pleasure but rather that His creation might find eternal pleasure in knowing Him. Marriage wasn't part of the "servant" mind that Jesus possessed, whereas fallen man has only his own pleasure in mind to fulfill. Christ had a divine mission and it did not involve setting up housekeeping and raising a family." <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<,, what about our satgurus. guru nanak dev ji came to earth with a divine mission, but all our gurus emphasise leading a family life and living your part in society while yet at the same time being detatched from illusion. so are you saying our gurus being married and having families meant they had their own pleasure in mind??? thats "blasphomy"! fact is being married n raising a family n living in society doesnt harm the divinity of someone. to be honest its just a stupid idea people have in their mind that "oh if someone had a wife n had children then they are not worthy to be "divine" or one with god". by this ideology we should all be celibate because otherwise we wnt reach waheguru. this ideology is no different to the ascetics who go live celibate lives away from society in jungles or mountains. the teachings of sikhi say stay in society n face your evils head on, raise a family work hard n share what u make. the fact nearly all our gurus were married never took any of their spirituality away frm them, they were still one with god. so if jesus was married then it wouldnt make him any less divine simple! its just a stupid idea in the heads of people high up in the catholic church that if he was married then oh he is no longer the "son of god". these people are blinded by maya,

Re: Da Vinci Code

Raj · 21 May 2006

im well confused lol... wen leonardo did paint that painting..how did he get the idea that it was a woman not a man? i mean if im not wrong he painted that painting in 1494 or sumthing..then how was that possible for him to work out the image of the last supper? and how could people believe such a paitning which was painted 300 - 400 years after the Jesus died?? and have any of you lot watched the film.....at the end where the muesem place is in Paris.....they show that Mary Madgelene's body lies beneath there.. think its called inverted pyramid or something.....the 1st thing that occured to me was that is tht true?? or is that just a fiction chosen spot to show this is where she was buried?? and has the original painting of the last supper survived which was actually painted by Leonardo?? also in the film there was a church somewhere in london where they had scriptures of Jesus's time...do they exist aswell?? and what is the painting Mona Lisa about..who is in that painting ..Mona lisa? hmmm alot of questions sorry....someone plz answer them lol! [%sig%]

Re: Da Vinci Code

Gandalf · 23 May 2006

I think that we should treat this movie as any movie that attacks our religion. (i.e. what do we do when a movie attacks Sikhi?? boycott it).

Re: Da Vinci Code

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 23 May 2006

Well said Bhai Sahib 'Sanjo' Jeeo.

Re: Da Vinci Code

Manmukh · 23 May 2006

Its true this film should be boycotted...it is appalling that it is allowed to be made. it is offensive.

Re: Da Vinci Code

JapnaamSingh · 24 May 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki Fateh jio Japnaam Waheguru

Re: Da Vinci Code

west london singh · 24 May 2006

The fact is that before Constantine made Christianity the offical religion of the Roman Empire there were a large number of competing sects that believed in Jesus. There were a number of writings called gospels which had different versions of the story of Jesus and his teachings. The recent documentary on the gospel of Judas showed that the selection of the gospels that are in the Bible was left in the hands of people who selected the ones that tallied with their sect's beliefs. Gospels in the Bible were written 70-150 years after Jesus. The ones that were not selected were burnt and destroyed. It is only with chance discoveries on the gnostic gospels and gospel of Judas that we have come to know just how present day Christianity is just one sect of Christ believers that got lucky and became the established church. It might have been that the sects which believed that Jesus was just a man might have become the official church and today the world would have been totally different.

Re: Da Vinci Code

A Singh · 08 Jun 2006

West London Singh and my main man Gyani Fresno Singh, The point to bear in mind here is (1) this is a book for entertainment and (2) the story in terms of its historical conspiracy about the Catholic Church is no different to what Oberoi and certain websites claim about Sikhi pre-Singh Sabha movement...i.e. "The fact is that before Constantine made Christianity the offical religion of the Roman Empire there were a large number of competing sects that believed in Jesus" becomes..."The fact is that before 'SINGH Sabha' made the 'Akal Thakt Rehit Maryada' the offical 'version' there were a large number of competing sects that believed in Sikhi and in Guru Nanak. This can be done for all your statements and hence I hope that it is clear my motivations for what I stated above in my initial post given that ridiculing another religion is hardly going to improve the Panth or our personal Sikhi - just because others feel the needs to discredit our traditions, no need for us to stoop to their levels.

Re: Da Vinci Code

waheguru · 08 Jun 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh! If you read the aknowlegments infront of Da Vici Code you will notice that he has facts which he got from a variety of sources. In this book he hasn't said what is true or not but interpretted the facts into what he/or people have told him...understands. Everyone has a different view on things as the bible has been changed many times and the original teachings are forgotten. The chalice is not a women but an actual cup that held the blood of Jesus Christ. While jesus was upon the cross, he was dripping with blood; Mary Magdalen stood underneath Jesus Christ and caught his blood while it was dripping in a chalice. With regards to if mary was his wife and if he had a daughter or not....i'm not entirely sure but it has been known that he did indeed marry and have a child. hope this helps. bhal chuk maf karna Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh!

Re: Da Vinci Code

Harjas Kaur · 09 Jun 2006

I don't know about book Da Vinci Code as I haven't read it due to being fictionalized. I have studied gnosticism and am familiar with these "scandalous allegations." BTW, the scandals in the suppressed gospels are way bigger than anything in this Da Vinci Code. And historically people WERE murdered to hide them. I don't believe that to have knowledge of history is ridicule or scandal. The history is there. What is scandalous to the Christians is the idea that the Roman Catholic Church is killing people to suppress the hidden teachings. Well, probably they aren't today, but they certainly have in history. It's hardly scandalous for a characterization like that to be filmed. The roots of these "heresies" are deep within Christianity itself, and survived to fairly modern times. A lot of what Da Vinci Code is exposing are the medieval remnants of the Cathar legacy, which were the Christian sect believing in reincarnation btw. That's the Christian's problem. I'm not going to support the status quo of continued suppression and promotion only of orthodox teachings. What is happening today to the Christians is called karma. The bad history of persecutions is being revealed, and reflects poorly on them. I think Sikhs should just ignore it. But I don't believe we should defend them. Let them fight their own battles. I don't believe it's disrespectful to Jesus to tell the truth about the history of people who had a different sect of belief in him that goes all the way back to the original gospels anyway. How do we even know which sect was closest to Jesus true teachings? [quote]The Pope, Innocent III, called a formal crusade, appointing a series of leaders to head his holy army. There followed over forty years of war against the indigenous population. During this period some 500,000 Languedoc men women and children were massacred; the Counts of Toulouse and their vassels were dispossessed and humiliated, and their lands annexed to France. Educated and tolerant Languedoc rulers were replaced by relative barbarians; the Dominican Order was founded and the Inquisition was established to wipe out the last vestiges of resistance; persecutions of Languedoc Jews and other minorities were initiated; the high culture of the Troubadours was lost; lay learning was discouraged; tithes were enforced; the Languedoc started its economic decline, and the language of the area, Occitan, started its descent from one of the foremost languages in Europe to a regional dialect. At the end of the extirpation of the Cathars, the Church had convincing proof that a sustained campaign of genocide can work. It also had the precedent of an internal Crusade within Christendom, and the machinery of the first modern police state. This crusade was one of the greatest disasters ever to befall Europe. Catharism is often said to have been completely eradicated by the end of the fourteenth century. Yet there are more than a few vestiges even today, apart from the enduring memory of their martydom and the ruins of the famous "Cathar castles". There are even cathars alive today, or at least people claiming to be modern Cathars. http://www.languedoc-france.info/12_cathars.htm[/quote] [%sig%]