Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

people and their views?

people and their views?

AKALI NIHUNG · 22 Dec 2003

VAAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA VAAHEGURU JI KI FATEH! saad sangat jio... i am a amritdhari sikh and i have buddies that are both amritdhari and non-amritdhari. Some of my amritdhari friends dont want to engage with non amritdharis saying that they are bad people and that they are doing wrong. well i dont disagree with them, their not on the right path but you can always help a person and guide them through right. But why so much hate for people Guru ji has said to love everyone not only love the ones that are like them but love everyone and some people just think that they are always doing right and never wrong . Even though you are a amritdhari sikh and do what god says doenst mean you cant do wrong . well everyone makes mistakes. I have noticed some amritdhari gursikhs let other people down saying that their right and the opponent is wrong. Some people think too superior of themselves. Should gursikhs act that way? They should guide people bot ruin them and break them down and lead them to the wrong path. what are your views gursikhs? PLEASE SHARE VAAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA VAAHEGURU JI KI FATEH!

Re: people and their views?

kookar ram ko · 24 Dec 2003

Your amritdhari friends are right. You shouldb't engage/marry a non amritdhari. If the person that you will be engaged/marry truly loves you, then they will try to get pesh at the next amrit sanchaar. What if your friends got married and their wife/fiance dont want to become amritdhari? Then it is a big problem because if they decide to have kids, what religion will he take? If both parents are amritdhari, then the chances are that the kid will also be amritdhari. Another point-When you get married, if you have read the definitions of the lavaaN, then you will know that guru saahib talks about how there will always be 2 people to do naam abhiyaas with. How can a non amritdhari know how to do naam? Think about it. Hopefully you're convinced. if not, please say so.

Re: people and their views?

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 25 Dec 2003

>Then it is a big problem because if they decide to have kids, what religion will >he take? If both parents are amritdhari, then the chances are that the kid >will also be amritdhari. But should parents even be allowed to decide the religion of a child? I think letting people decide for themselves what religion to follow once they are mature enough themselves would probably be a better idea. [%sig%]

Re: people and their views?

fff · 25 Dec 2003

i think he meant engage as in.. engage in activities with... as in.. go to movies with, hang out with.. talk with.. that type of thing

Re: people and their views?

G · 25 Dec 2003

Yes he did mean engage by hanging out with them... and there is nothing wrong with that aslong as you are engageing in bad things.. like drinking smoking.. and others, we are all Guru ji's children weather we are Sikhs or not, and we are taught to teach other religions with respect... so why would we say other are bad... ninday about a non Gursikh is still ninday

Re: people and their views?

*** · 25 Dec 2003

this message is to R.Dorothy Wayneright, i believe that people shouldnt be forced to belive in something... your right parents shuoldnt decide these kind of things for kids........BUTT as sikh's it is our duty that when we have children we bring them up in a good spiritual environment. Sikhism is devotion. Sikhism is love Sikhism is purity Sikhism is learning its important to teach the child about the religion at a young age because with sikhism comes a beautiful history and the child becomes aware of how to improve as an individual and it does help the child mature aswell. we as parents should do our duty and be good parents who teach our children about their backround and religion its just a very important thing......espeically for the next generation to come. The belief's of sikhims make a person stronger in every day life and helps withthe choices that one has to make. if we do our duty and the child desides that this isnt the path he/she wants to take than thats understandable.....i mean u did ur duty as a good sikh shuold. but i really believe that teaching the child at a young age helps them to mature and it helps them with life itself.

Re: people and their views?

R. Dorothy Wayneright · 26 Dec 2003

>i believe that people shouldnt be forced to belive in something... your right parents >shuoldnt decide these kind of things for kids........BUTT as sikh's it is our duty >that when we have children we bring them up in a good spiritual environment. >Sikhism is devotion. >Sikhism is love >Sikhism is purity >Sikhism is learning I don't understand #2, could you explain it to me? >its important to teach the child about the religion at a young age because with sikhism >comes a beautiful history and the child becomes aware of how to improve as an individual >and it does help the child mature aswell. Since all humans are gods children, wouldn't it be better to expose them to world history? >we as parents should do our duty and be good parents who teach our children about their >backround and religion its just a very important thing......espeically for the next generation >to come. The belief's of sikhims make a person stronger in every day life and helps withthe >choices that one has to make. > >if we do our duty and the child desides that this isnt the path he/she wants to take than >thats understandable.....i mean u did ur duty as a good sikh shuold. but i really believe >that teaching the child at a young age helps them to mature and it helps them with life itself We pretty much agree, but we do differ a bit. I personally feel that instead of teaching a child to practice a certain religion, it is better to let them derive for themselves the tenants that most religions hold true. For example I think most religions believe in that stealing is wrong. So if a child asks you, why is stealing wrong, you can give them one of two answers: 1) God says so, don't question god, he is always right and if you cross him you will forever burn in hell. (exaggerated for humor) 2) Why is stealing wrong? What gives one individual the right to take something from another that they did not work for? Is this fair? What is fair? I feel that the second child would have an advantage over the first because if they ever encountered a urge to steal because instead of some book from antiquity telling them it was wrong, they derived that it was wrong for themselves. This would solve the problem I see many people bemoan about on this board "fake-sikhs". People that claim they practice Sikhi, but really don't. These people are "Sikhs" because that is what there parents told them was the right thing to do, and never told _why_ it was the right thing to do. But I guess you could solve the entire problem by teaching them Sikhi and having them question it at the same time, the results would be the same. But most people are not strong enough in their religion to be able to actively question it without feeling they are somehow betraying it. I think what I am trying to get at is this: it would probably be a good idea to assist your children in developing the mental faculties to determine for themselves what is right and wrong instead if force feeding them what is right and wrong. But then again, what do I know? I don't have any children of my own to run experiments on. :P

Re: my views

Wonderful Broadcast · 28 Dec 2003

Who cares man, in the end there is only one friend God. So make good choices mil satsangat koj dasaee(n) which sangat har prabh vasai jeo.. satsangat is always good, sangat of gursikhs is good without any doubt.. its mentioned in bani if your nonamritdhari friends do bad things like drugs and stuff, then you may want to avoid them? i don't know? but u should treat them nicely. because god is in everyone, god is all pervading....? Also, if ur friends just cut their hair then i guess its kinda okay to hang out with them because they are not bad people. they just choose to live a dif lifestyle. The impt thing is not 2 get attached 2 any friends. cuz only god will be ur true friend in the end.. It is ur choice, u choose what u do.

Re: people and their views?

Kulbir Singh · 31 Dec 2003

Other than business dealings or other arm-length dealings, we should avoid friendships with non-devotees of Guru Sahib. By the same token, if we think that a non-amritdhaari person is interested in Sikhi or has a potential to become an amritdhari, then it is okay to befriend him, to do parchaar. Guru Sahib has made it clear in Gurbani that friendship with non-devotees can have very negative consequences for gursikhs: SAAKAT SANG NAA KEEJIYE, DURAH JAAYEYE BHAAG|| BARSAN KARO PARSEEYE, TAAN KICHH LAAGO HAATH|| (Don't do sangat of a non-devotee and flee from his or her sangat. By touching a utencil used for cooking, one incurs black dirt. Same way by doing sangat of a non-devotee, one's mind gets dirty) In the light of hundreds of such quotes of Gurbani, no true Sikh can violate this hukam and befriend manmukhs. Please remember that a Sikh is not to hate anyone. A Sikh should have love for all devotees and non-devotees. Avoiding friendship with non-devotees is done not because of hatred for them but because it is a hukam of Guru Sahib. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: people and their views?

. · 31 Dec 2003

if we don't talk to "manmukhs", how will they ever come onto the path of sikhi?? thats why thousands of people who were once "moneh" became gurmukhs - other gurmukhs talked to them and gave them good sangat.