Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Sikh of the True Guru · 12 May 2006

Please take my question seriously and reply only to what it projects, so that we can be at peace with ourselves even when we differ with others. Accepted, we should not speak against anyone. We have our differences with the Namdharis but what do we say of their Satguru, in view of his life, work and leadership. My question is simple. We have all indulged in arguments, for and against, but now I just wish to get some feedback from everyone on what they think of the Namdhari Satguru's positive attributes. Just that. Can we do that please, in good faith? After all our Baba Nanak asked for Sarbat da bhalla.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

dhan guru pyare · 13 May 2006

i do not kno much but this question ties in with a sakhi that i think i read somewhere on this phorum where someone was mentionin that during the time of guru patshah (dont kno which one) a snake came near guruji. other sikhs were about to kill it but then guruji stopped them and let the snake come near him. when the snake did come near guru sahib touched it with his foot and he died on the spot... the singhs asked guruji wat that was all about and then guruji told em to wait and listen to wat the snakes soul had to say. so the sould became visible to all present, and explained how it had in its previous life been a "guru" i.e. asked ppl to worship him... and as a result of that he got the lifeform of a snake... and the snake also had a lot of insects/parasites inside it the soul said that these peoplpe used to be his followers in the previous life. so moral being that even if u follow someone other human to b ur guru rather than sri guru granth sahib ji maharaj then thats where u r destined. bhul chuk maaf wjkk wjkf

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

some12 · 13 May 2006

I aint gonna praise a "guru" of some1 else, but i will say that, we have no right to do their nindia, they are'nt narakdharis yet.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

LK · 14 May 2006

He's a hardcore Raag-ist!

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

1 Positive Thing · 14 May 2006

His Dastar is quite neat.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Rashpal Singh · 14 May 2006

VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh Baba Ram Singh was a Tyaar bar Tyaar Khalsa. He was a Naam abyassi Singh and was Rehatvaan. Believe it or not he was actually a Sarab Loh Bibeki Singh as were most of the Namdharis in his time. Nowadays, Namdharis have gone so tille that they do not even see it necessary to use a Sarab Lohi batta in Amrit sanchar. He led the Kuka movement against the British and for this reason he was imprisoned. He was Panj Kakkara da dharni, Shastardhari and wore Bana. The reason why Namdharis are sometimes referred to as 'kuke' is because they would kookna Naam loudly, as in they were taught Saas Giraas jugti in Amrit sanchar. This proves beyond doubt that the Saas giraas method is not just something made up by Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh or AKJ. I have some 'hukamnamas' on computer that were issued by Baba Ram Singh to the Namdhari Sangat in the form of letters sent from Jail in Rangoon. These clearly state that Guru Granth Sahib is the Satguru and he is not. It also makes reference that all Sikhs should be Bibeki (discriminate food-wise). However, i'm not entirely sure how authentic these are because there is also reference to how to perform Havan. I can post these on the forum if anyone wishes to read them. In the end all I can say is that Baba Ram singh was a fully- fledged Khalsa and was very much against being labelled as Satguru. This title should only be reserved for Guru Granth Sahib ji. His jeevan was based on Naam and Rehat. What the Namdharis have done is pure manmat, they have tarnished the name of Baba Ram Singh and made him into a stereotype Nirankari/Radhaswami type figure. If they (namdharis) truley respected him then they would think twice about calling him Satguru, it is evident from his letters in jail that he encouraged the pooja of Gur-shabad only. VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh [%sig%]

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Sardar · 14 May 2006

How can you call a dehdari guru a SatGuru? That is my question. Can you answer it peacefully please?

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Truth · 14 May 2006

Isn't this the wrong place to be asking this question? Do you really want a Sikh of Guru Granth sahib to list the "good qualities" of someone who is a direct challenge to his Guru? Seriously, this is not the right place.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 May 2006

Anyone and Everyone can have a lot of good and bad attributes..no problem with that....as a person..leader..jagjit singh may have a lot of good attributes..so has the Pope, George Bush..even Ayatollah Khomeni..and Osama bin Laden.. BUT as a SIKH.. I have ONLY ONE SATGURU..and that is Shabad Guru Dhan Dhan Sri guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj. For me no human living can hold the titles of Guru,Satguru,Maharaj. I dont think i am at conflict with baba nanak's Sarbatt da Bhall if I beleive that...? No way. What has Sarbatt da Bhalla got to do with it ? I am NOT dissing jagjit singh, i am not plotting to assasinate him or harm him in any way..SARBATT DA BHALLA...yes for jagjit singh, for bush, for osama and khomeni as well...all of humanity. Thats all.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Charanjit · 15 May 2006

Baba Nanak?! Excuse me, get it right...Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji Mahraj. The namdhari leader is not a Satguru. He's a dedhari guru. The terminology in this posting makes me suspect that the poster 'Sikh of the True Guru' is a namdhari, trying to use a platform for their parchaar. You are on a Sikh forum, keep your discussion on promoting your leaders on the namdhari forum (where that is)

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Sikh of the True Guru · 16 May 2006

I humbly retract my question for I think it has caused what I didn't intend - misunderstanding. I am not a Namdhari and neither am I trying to promote Namdhari leaders. My Guru is Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Would I want to suffer the pangs of separation from Guru Granth Sahibs Ji by calling myself 'Sikh of the True Guru' and yet have some other agenda on my mind? I apologise for bringing up this question which is giving away wrong impressions about me. And Charanjit Ji, I stand corrected, indeed I should be refering to our beloved Nanak as Guru Nanak Dev Ji. The only reason I sometimes use Baba Nanak is because it creates a picture in my mind of someone so beloved (Sab te vadda Satguru Nanak, jin kal rakhi meri). I'm not a Namdhari, please do not label me that. I am an Amritdhari who only seeks to be a Sikh of the True Guru - Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. Bhul chuk maaf. Admin Ji, you can close the topic if you also concur with the feeling that my question has ulterior motives which is against this forum. I did not intend to upset so many Gurmukhs here, who show just how much love, respect and honour they have for our Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Finally, Charanjit Ji, from your post, I feel maybe I should not post on this forum anymore for I fear I have created the wrong picture about my intentions on this forum.I seek your humble forgiveness.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

A Singh · 16 May 2006

Rashpal Singh, You mentioned: <> and went on to say: <> I would like to discuss this with you, since this type of talk has occurred a lot on this forum and references and/or other historical support is extremely lacking in such assertions or proves to the contrary. Baba Ram Singh was indeed very rehitvaan and naam abyassi - likewise so is the current Namdhari Guru (in terms of simran, seva, bani etc), this much we'll leave aside for now, what we should discuss are the other claims: 1. Sarablohi Bibek - this is only asserted by the AKJ in their literature, no where else is there mention of Baba Ram Singh being a Sarablohia. This statement needs to be verified, since in actual fact the bibek that the (strict) Namdharis do (to this day practice) is simply not eating from the hands of other non-Namdharis (this includes Prashad and Langar at non-Namdhari Gurdwaras) for reasons similar to Sarablohia AKJ Singh/nees (i.e. the maryada is incomplete at these institutions). Moreover, there are other aspects of Namdhari lifestyle such as Sodh Ishnaan which are even more extreme in their bibek than Sarablohia Singhs. 2. Namdharis do make Amrit in a Sarabloh Bata - you are confusing the copper gurva for something else. 3. Shastardhari - this is something that people again and again refuse to accept, that Baba Ram Singh DID change a lot of Khalsa practice, not just the insistence on white clothing, but he replaced the Kirpan with a Laathi, he continued and expanded upon the Chandi Path Havans of the Nihangs and Udasis (which was later expanded by his successor Namdhari Guru in his Hukamnamas). The main shastar of the Namdharis was either a Laathi or an Axe (which employs similar fighting techniques). Just like the thread on the analysis of the Sikh Rehit Maryada by a chela of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh where such items were made by the author without any consideration of facts, again we are seeing the same thing here. There are many views and practices that Baba Ram Singh put in place that do not reconcile with wider Khalsa Maryada. Other misunderstandings that modern day Sikhs have is that Namdharis do not do paath, which is nonsense, Kukas are very diligent with their Nitnem which consists of 9-12 Banis in the mornings (like the Nihangs) and of course with their simran (which they do saas-giras as well). Interestingly, whilst the Kukas may have some argument for the blue colour and bana descending from the Moghuls, the funny thing I have always found is that their own bana (churdi-pyjama) is itself a Muslim dress, just like the Salwar Kameez is for ladies...

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Jagjit Matharu · 16 May 2006

He's get £500 from every house he visits in the UK He fines his Sikhs for the most stupid reasons He forgives his pardhan for people smuggling He gets funky cars He hid really well during the problems of 84 onwards He well funded by Indian Govt and RSS He a manipulation king

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Rashpal Singh · 17 May 2006

VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh 1 - Sarab Loh Bibek - Baba Ram Singh was definately a Bibeki Singh, even in his own 'Hukamnama' that he issued from Rangoon whilst he was in prison he has said not to eat from non-Khalse. Here it is: '0 brethren of the Khalsa ! make use of the pure food and drink. 0 brethren it is the order of the Tenth Badshah ( Guru Gobind Singh) that eating with a person whose tenet of belief is not known or who does not practice the Gur-Mantar (mystic sectarian whisper) results in estranging the affection of God.' 2 - Can you explain to me what the Copper gurva is used for? Everything used in Amrit Sanchar, according to Maryada has to be SarabLoh. Jal has to be collected in Sarab Loh, Khanda is also made of Sarab Loh, Bata is Sarab Loh. This is not my own opinion, this is the Seena-Baseena Maryada that Singhs have been folowing since day1. 3 - Shastardhari means he bore arms as Khalsa >> Kirpan, Saffajang etc. I can't comment on the Lathi thing. I very much doubt that he did Havan because he himself has said: '0 Khalsa ! be firm in your morning worship of the creator, not only one but all other agonies will be removed. Be assured of this truth, for the Guru Sahib has said that ailments can be removed by the worship of the creator.' He said ask everything from Satguru- Guru Granth Sahib Ji, therefore, there was no need for him to do Havan to ask for Naam etc from Chandi. 'He who has received "Bhajan" (Naam) and then does not recite (meditate on it) is as per (Hukam) instructions - will have his face blackened in this world and in the next. Whosoever does not do his daily prayers and meditations he will suffer there and here.' There is no mention of he who does not perform Havan will have their face blackened etc. Clearly his focus was Gurbani abyass and Naam abyass. I don't think for a moment that he believed in this type of hocus-pocus. I can't really debate about Baba Ram Singh because I don't know much about him, nor do I have the time to debate. I have nothing more to say in this thread :) VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh [%sig%]

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Jagjit Matharu · 17 May 2006

A Singh wrote: > Baba Ram Singh was indeed very rehitvaan and naam abyassi - > likewise so is the current Namdhari Guru (in terms of simran, > seva, bani etc) Current Satguru thinks he's above gurbani.......how can he have loads of kamaae from bani then? They dont do saas giras naam simran. This is a totally inaccurate claim. They do mala very very very fast.....no techique involved You are mistaken about Nitnem aswell. The Namdhari Gukta is only for show and hidden with other Gutkas in Gurdwaras for pretence. They are only prescribed to do very very very fast malas!!! I dont think I would categorise changing kirpan to a laathi or axe as khalsa practice. Shaheeds have died for other Sikhs to have the right to wear kirpans and practice Sikhi. No shater exists for modern Namdharis, oh but a Namdhari will say that they always wear 5 kakaars. The kirpan is a tin cut out stuck ontop of their kanga. The reason why Namdharis are against blue is that a sect sprung out from Baba Ram Singh different from that started by Hari Matharu. They wore blue all the time and claimed they were next in line! Overall, A Singh, a very inaccurate posting

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Jaz · 17 May 2006

To Jagjit Singh ji, If you want to participate in this form, please use common sense. What does your post have to do with anything about the topic that is mentioned above. I have noticed that so many people have bashed you for your lack of knowledge. I personally thought this topic would be put to rest. I guess not. There are facts someone mentioned about Guru/Baba Ram Singh Ji/s Hukhamana that Guru/Baba Ram Singh Ji never claimed himself to be a Guru. If you look at the last form that was shut by the administrator, that question about Guru/Baba Ram Singh Ji stating he is not a Guru was a true but a gentleman from that form also wrote that no Guru ever said that there was a Guru. Basically it depends on how a person interrupts the meaning of that word. If you look at history of Sri Bhagwan Ram Chander Ji, even Ram Chander Never cliamed that he was Bhagawan but most Hindus know that he was. Wheather Sikhis Believe in Hindu Gods or not but the point is its all about how we interrupt things. To understand any type of religion or sect, individual research must be done instead of relying on hearsay evidence. Hearsay is good but it must be used only if its the last resource.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Sardar · 17 May 2006

>>>His Dastar is quite neat.<<<< What does have to do with the topic? Does outside appearance so much to you and not what that guy actually does? We claim narakdharis, so called "naamdharis", radaswamis, and all those other cults that want to wipe out Sikhi, as part of our Sikh family. K what is that?

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Charanjit · 18 May 2006

You hit the nail on the head Jagjit Matharu.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

A Singh · 18 May 2006

To the poster who styles himself as Jagjit Matharu, I would ask that you reconsider my comments before launching your anti-Kuka crusade against me – since I am (a) not a Kuka and (b) have been continuously challenging the innovations made by the Kukas even during the time that they were considered to be panthic (i.e. during the time of Baba Ram Singh) – since many people have a myopic vision and like to use anything and everything to prove their own tribal agenda. So to address each of your points: --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Current Satguru thinks he's above gurbani.......how can he have loads of kamaae from bani then? They dont do saas giras naam simran. This is a totally inaccurate claim. They do mala very very very fast.....no techique involved --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I never said anything about their ‘kamaae’ – that is not for me to judge in any event, the point is he does live and promote others to life a very rehitvaan life (again I am not suggesting that their concept of ‘rehit’ coincides with the Sikh Rehit Maryada, since it clearly doesn’t – they have their own rehitnama and their Guru promotes them to life according to this by following it himself. The fact remains that their rehit maryada stems from their first Guru and they follow they accordingly (of course we can all get caught up about his letters from exile and Guruship claims, however clearly if Baba Ram Singh was issuing full fledged Hukamnamas prior to this date, he no doubt did consider himself to have been the reincarnation of Guru Gobind Singh – most likely owing to the manipulated Sau Sakhis and their promotion by those around him). I am not supporting their divergence from the Sikh Panth, it is their maryada – and they have plenty of strict Namdharis who follow this to each other, as I know some myself, however just like we have slackers in all communities, they are no exception and the funny thing is that is the slackers within the Namdharis who have tended to get all worked up on Sikh issues and love to create issues with us, they are easily identifiable, since they usually wear a nokh pagh but change to the flat across the forehead when their Satgurus are around and usually indulge in meat eating and drinking too. As per saas giraas, this is a practice that can be found amongst the Kukas, but since you have made your conclusions solely derived from what you have observed amongst those you have met then that is your take on things, however a visit to Bhaini Sahib will show to the contrary. For the record, the manner they do it is not identical to what we as Sikhs today associate with Saas Giras simran (ala AKJ style), however your comment would be akin to those who are unaware of AKJ Naam Dhrir and on seeing the Jatha Singhs make derogatory remarks about them simply shouting the Gurmantr very fast and sounding like barking dogs (there are plenty of threads on this forum which illustrate the views of these people). --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- You are mistaken about Nitnem aswell. The Namdhari Gukta is only for show and hidden with other Gutkas in Gurdwaras for pretence. They are only prescribed to do very very very fast malas!!! --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- This is again what you may have observed amongst Namdharis – however their rehit maryada in terms of Bani requirements is not too different from that of Nanaksar/the Nihangs or the Taksal. If we wish to use the argument of how many follow it, then we should perhaps consider that many Nihangs today do the same with their Gutka Sahibs – this is hardly conclusive to discussing Nihang Maryada. The Namdhari Maryada is very clear on where it stands on the recitation of Paath, their Satguru like his predecessors also awakes for 3am Nitnem. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I dont think I would categorise changing kirpan to a laathi or axe as khalsa practice. Shaheeds have died for other Sikhs to have the right to wear kirpans and practice Sikhi. No shater exists for modern Namdharis, oh but a Namdhari will say that they always wear 5 kakaars. The kirpan is a tin cut out stuck ontop of their kanga. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Again, perhaps dear poster you would care to read my posts again more clearly – this is exactly my point, WHY did Baba Ram Singh, who non-Namdharis on this forum are referring to a “pooran Gursikh” and “Rehitvaan Khalsa” change so much of Khalsa practice – for the reasons you now repeat, I cannot consider this as acceptable or the use of Havans in the form common amongst other “Sanatan” orders. As per the tin cut out of a Kirpan, this is a charge we should also level on other groups who regard themselves as “Panthic” as well. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The reason why Namdharis are against blue is that a sect sprung out from Baba Ram Singh different from that started by Hari Matharu. They wore blue all the time and claimed they were next in line! --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The sect you refer to is the Neeldharis, their history is well known and today they are more aligned to Guru Granth Sahib than in their past. The Namdhari rationale for not wearing Blue can be easily found on their numerous websites and invariably boils down to their conclusions that blue and black are Moghul colours and hence “malech” and that these are the colours of Kaljug. It is in response to THEIR assertion that I have asked why they still wear a dress which itself is Muslim inspired. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Overall, A Singh, a very inaccurate posting --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- You are entitled to your opinions (as that’s all your post really is given the above), however I would add that overall, the poster you writes as Jagjit Matharu: Very inaccurate reading.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Jagjit Matharu · 18 May 2006

Jaz wrote: > To Jagjit Singh ji, > > If you want to participate in this form, please use common > sense. What does your post have to do with anything about the > topic that is mentioned above. I have noticed that so many > people have bashed you for your lack of knowledge. > Jaz ji I was replying to the false statements made by A Singh within this thread. People try to make Namdharis out to be whiter than white. Well thats false and misrepresenting. So now we manipulate history even further by saying no Guru will call themselves a guru LOL! Thats why Baba Ram Singh wrote it in those letters, because he didnt want to show off!! Dont know about Ram Bhagwan but even Krishan Bhagwan showed Arjan his complete roop as per the Gita. Sri Guru Ramdas Ji proclaims in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji that Bani Guru Guru hai Bani, I wonder how many interpretations of this can people make?? Our Gurus and Gurbani is clear that Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the eternal Guru. Only confused or manipulating individuals misinterpretate meanings.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Jagjit Matharu · 19 May 2006

A Singh, Since this discussion has started on Tapoban, I have read SOOOO many posts like yours where the person says I am not a Namdhari however they are great!! Its black & white, Namdharis have a living Guru. They say he is Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji!! All your objective analysis is meaningless because Namdharis stink from the root! The rest is gloss and show. You can objectively analysis till the cows come home, but the truth is that their belief is fundementally different for other Sikh Jatha or Sampradas.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

A Singh · 19 May 2006

Again Mr Poster styling himself as Jagjit Matharu, if you were able to read and assess before jumping on your anti-Namdhari crusade, you'll see quite clearly that I far from even trying to paint the Namdharis as whiter than whiter. Modern day Sikhs speak about the Kuka movement as being entirely Panthic under Baba Ram Singh, there are clear episodes that go against this view - I have highlighted some, but no one seems to be able to answer those, instead all we have is "but he wrote in his letters that he is not the Guru" - we all know this and have moved on.... If you will allow, here is one further area to consider from the times of the initial Kuka movement. Following some of the infamous Kuka raids on Butchers, Samadhs, etc, on one occasion, blue clothing and a chakra was left behind as a result of which several Nihangs were excecuted by the British authorities (effectively having been set up for the crime)...these types of incidents are often overlooked by those who for their own personal agendas are keen to prove that the Kukas were Sarablohia Khalsas.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Harcharan Singh · 19 May 2006

Jeeo, Baba Ram Singh did not replace the kirpan with a laathi, Baba Ji was Shastardhari, as were his predescers (not Guru's, but spiritual influences if you will), this is evidenced by the description of Baba Ajaypal Singh (who in my opinion was great rehitvaan Gursikh) in the "Ittihas De Anlikhe Pattar", Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha describes the character and interests of Baba Ajaypal Singh Ji - - which are clearly those of a fully fledged Khalsa. although this text is now not given any credibility due the Guru Gobind Singh Ji association, we can still identify much of the character and habits of the Khalsa of old from this writing. At the conclusion of the 2nd Anglo-Sikh war, the British ordered all Sikhs to surrender their weapons, including kirpans - as they did not want risk anymore uprisings. Baba Ram Singh Ji simply invented a way for the Khalsa to continue to be armed in the face of the new occupiers, in a way that would not result in further persecution in relation to carrying of arms. The Laathi then became the hall mark of Baba Ji and his sangat. Baba Ji was a spiritual, brave, experienced and honoured soldier in Ranjit Singhs army, above this he was a Khalsa, so he knew the value of Guru Gobind Singh Ji's hukum. I have also read somewhere that Baba Ji wore blue banaa, but can't recall where, maybe someone can enlighten. Please don't literally rely on anyone opinion or anyone text, there are mistakes in history, in oral tradition and spiritual culture everywhere, we should try and apply common sense and not discredit or form incorrect historical opinions of greaat Sikhs like Baba Ram Singh simply because we don't agree with their current followers. Baba Ji did great service for the panth in this dark period post the loss of Punjab, through keeping Guru's message strong via Kirtan, Simran, Parchaar, Seva, Politics, amrit sanchaars....he infused teh Lions spirit back in to the downtrodden people of Punjab. In my opinion, Kirtan was his biggest weapon, as is evidenced by Namdharis today. In my opinion his actions were somewhat comparable to the other great freedom fighter of the last century, Baba Jarnail Singh Ji. We should cease to judge an individual based on his following, great Gur-Sikh individuals do not ask for followings, but through their charisma, leadership and exemplary life style's, they recieve them. Unfortunately, in history, all followings detract (sometimes in a small way, sometimes in a big way) from the original message. Apologies for going off the topic. Wahe-Guru

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

real;ity check · 22 May 2006

Harcharan Singh - that is all well and good, however I believe it has been pointed out Baba Ram Singh made many changes from the use of Havans, color of clothing (you comments on his wearing blue are incorrect, he even turned away from Darbar Sahib for refusing to handle blue garments). Jagjit Matharu - keep up your posts! Also perhaps consider reading the other persons!!! You are right about people being ignorant of Namdhari beliefs, the think that the other posts clearly shows that people cover for their dehdhari gurus but also can't handle that history of Namdharis isn't as glossy as it is made out to be.

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Just some dude · 18 Jul 2006

To the person to refers himself as Jagjit Matharu: You said: "Sri Guru Ramdas Ji proclaims in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji that Bani Guru Guru hai Bani, I wonder how many interpretations of this can people make?? Our Gurus and Gurbani is clear that Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the eternal Guru. Only confused or manipulating individuals misinterpretate meanings" I guess what you're trying to say is Guru Ram Das Ji declared that the bani is the guru. Would this not mean that all gurus after him weren't really gurus since he already declared the GranthSahib as the guru? There is just one small point you missed... The line right after it. I'll try to enlighten you. "Bani guru guru hai bani vich bani amrit saray. Gurbani kahay, savek jun manay thus PARTAK guru nustaray" (notice the caps on Partak Guru) I always see Sikhs going on these anti-Namdhari crusades on forums/sites like this and they always seem to use the first half of the "Bani guru, guru hai bani" thuk to justify that the Granth Sahib is the guru. Please stop doing it because it makes you look like a dumb-ass. Thanks

Re: Serious Question on Namdhari Satguru

Super Singh · 18 Jul 2006

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" 'BUT as a SIKH.. I have ONLY ONE SATGURU..and that is Shabad Guru Dhan Dhan Sri guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj''' Apologies for going of topic, but i seem too remember from previous posts, by Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" , that you don't not believe in some of the bani's from the Sri Guru Granth Sahib. You can't be a amrithdhari sikh, taken amrit in the presence of the Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj, and later question the content and validity of the Guru Granth Sahib. That is the biggest sin. Main thing our Panth and our community need to remember first is, 'Guru Wale baniye' our complete faith in the Guru Granth Sahib, and then become initiated into the beloved Khalsa Panth