SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 16 May 2006
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!!!!
some people will view this as good news, and some people will view it as a gross disappointment.
shabads referring to "santan" and "saadh jan" in Gurbani, previously translated as "The Saints" in SikhiToTheMax have now been re-translated as "The Guru."
Since when did "saadh jan" (saint servant) translate to Guru?
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefathehhhh !!!!
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 May 2006
SANT and GURU are INTERCHANGEABLE....
SANT and BRAHMGIANI are interchangeable...
SANT and SADH are interchangeable....
SANT and BHAGAT are interchangeable....
SANT..is WAHEGURU..SATGURU..GURU...SAADH SANGAT and GURSIKHS.
NO DERAWADEE "HUMAN DEH" is a SANT/BRAHMGIANI/BHAGAT/SATGURU/GURU..... one or two "may" be GURSIKHS...but not 110% sure about that too...( because they do Khasmeh braberi by calling themsleves SANT SRI 1008 Brahmgiani Vidya Maartand..and what not....when in PLAIN SIGHT...the Banee da Bohitha..Shaheedahn da sirtaaj..shanti de punj..Guru Arjun Ji sahib is plain"GURU" ..to call yourself a Vidya Maartand..Gyani of a million surajs..???? is plain HAUMAII and hankaar ego..personified
Sikhi to the Max has done the Correct thing..KUDOS. All those who still crave the old" wrong" translations can find a lot of "sant" related websites...they claim ownership of everything "gurmatt/gursikhi/gursikhi-jeewan/etc etc....as if all other Gursikhs are manmattis...
Anyone who wants to get a FREE Gurbani CD with the CORRECT TRANSLATION....contact the SIKH NAUJAWAN SABHA MALAYSIA....
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 17 May 2006
Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
Vaaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!
I have a lot of love and respect for the sevadaars of SikhiTotheMax and i think that what they have done is one of the top Sikhi inventions of the last 10 years, in the same line as live keertan broadcasts, and other technologies.
It is an amazing seva they have done over so many years and it has helped so many not tens, not hundreds, but THOUSANDS of gursikhs and non-sikhs around the world.
But this one thing... changing "Ham Santan Kee Rayn Pyaare" from "Oh Beloved, I am the dust of the feet of the Saints" to "Oh Beloved, I am the dust of the feet of the Satguru" is irresponsible and incorrect.
Santan is a plural word for "Saints" while Satguru is singular for "True Guru"
Saadh Jan is plural for "Saint Servants" while Satguru is singular for "True Guru".
but they have translated both Santan and Saadh Jan as Satguru, which is incorrect if you reference Prof. Sahib Singh Ji's Guru Granth Darpan and other texts, and it is irresponsible because this technology is SO POPULAR, so widely accepted and respected, and SO HELPFUL to so many people that one change like this will affect, again, not tens or hundreds but THOUSANDS of the readers of SikhiTotheMax.
I humbly request any Gursikhs who are reading this to humbly make benti to the Singhs - at their feet - not in anger but in pyaar - to change this. We should ask them with pyaar to change this as it is completely incorrect.
Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
Vaaheguroojeekeefathehhh !!!!!
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
Tarsem Singh · 17 May 2006
Pyario,
The new translation updates are by no means the finalised versions. As I have mentioned in the update post, this is an ongoing process.
There are a couple of translation changes which look a bit debatable (I must confess that Sant Singh's looked more correct in a few cases - but for now we have taken the update and will review each change as we continue updating). We have developed a reporting framework, where suggestions for improvement of a given pangthee's translation can be registered on the site. This is currently being tested and will be available shortly.
I would have to say that "Saadh Jan" in Gurbani can refer to Guru (and probably does in most cases). I hope everyone remembers that this update is based a lot around Sahib Singh's steek (just pointing this out, because the title of this thread does seem to suggest that non-sant believers are changing the face of all Gurbani translations!!). I am sure the AKJ nindaks have already got their arguments together for another round of happy slapping. Oh well, you can't please everyone.
Chardhee Kalaa!
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
Tarsem Singh · 17 May 2006
To "kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa",
I have briefly reviewed the translation and you are right, there are some serious flaws in some of the updates. I have checked against Sahib Singh's steek and some of the translation do not match his. I think our approach of updating the whole translation was wrong....so here's the plan.
We will put the old translation back where it is blatantly wrong or debatable and mark those pangthees with a flag (indicating that a new translation is suggested), so that each recommendation can be reviewed and then approved before it is updated.
Would you mind being involved in that seva. I hope others can help here too.
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
Well done STTM!!!! · 17 May 2006
This is very good to see, well done to STTM team for acting very fast on this.
It is very good to criticise when being a Internet Warrior like most people. But good suggestions and constructive criticisms always get heard and acted upon, in this case, it was on the next day. Sometimes we see things going along on websites for days and months before anything happens.
Now the litmus test is that Bhai Sahib from STTM has asked for volunteers to help him, now is the time to come forward. I've seen several posts about STTM dissing it and then saying great things about it, why can these internet warriors help Bhai Sahib out???????? and do the seva they want done!!
However I think the best thing is whenever Bhai Sahib does something for the site is to check it and not to email him directly but publish it on a forum and let everyone know so that Bhai Sahib who might have spent hours on the update will have to do the work all over again without getting informed beforehand. Its amazing what a 5min post can do rather than a 5min email to STTM(sarcasm!!!!)
[%sig%]
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
Tarsem Singh · 17 May 2006
Ok everybody take a chill pill (do simran in Sikhi terms).
The translation was put back to the original about 8 and a half hours ago. The issue tracking framework will be introduced in the next couple of days so that we can run through each change one by one.
There are many good aspects of the new translation which obviously we have all become so narrow minded to because of one area we did not like.
I say this honestly, I did not notice that this interpretation that was mentioned in this thread and would not have uploaded it had I known.
It only affects a few pangthees of 16,000 updates. Work it out yourselves Singho. What about things like this in the current translation for "Dharm, Arth, Kaam and Mokh"
"He does not hesitate to bless me with Dharmic faith, wealth, sexual success and liberation. ||2|| "
this had been corrected to
"He does not hesitate to bless me with Virtue, Prosperity, Fulfilment and Salvation. ||2|| "
a much better translation. I admit it could be improved further, but the point was it highlighted an area for review. And there are many further examples of this.
So let's be patient and try again. Can't wait to get my head bitten off again hee heee!
Thanks for all your responses.
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 17 May 2006
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!
Bhai Tarsem Singh jee,
All love and respect for you Singhs. You are doing great seva. daas is happy to help in any way.
The "Dharm, Arth, Kaam and Mokh" came in the AKJ Rainsabhaee last weekend at Gurdwara Sahib Dasmesh Darbar... and it said "sexual success" for Kaam and I felt embarrased running the SikhiTotheMax because that is not the right translation as in this case Kaam means desire or wish, not lust - but you have fixed it. So that is great !
Saadhsangat jee - if the Singhs change the wordings then it is good. But I hope Bhai Tarsem Singh jee, you will change back shabads like "Ham Santan Kee RAyn Pyaarae" - that shabad reminds me of Baba Buddha Jee, Mata Khivi Jee, those are sachay suchay sant mahapurakhs and the shabad definately is about those type of sant bhagat - in that shabad Sant refers to Bhagat of Vaaheguroo, not Guru Maharaaj.
Other such shabads should be fixed wherever necessary...
bhul chuk maaf karnaa jee
Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefathehhhh !!!!!!
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 17 May 2006
Bhai Tarsem Singh jee,
Please forgive my knee-jerk reaction as I thought this was a final revision or new update to SikhiTotheMax and i did not think that it was somebody you would be willing to change.
I should have been more reasonable to first contact you in person and request the changes. I understand that many other translations have improved from their original form and that is great. I hope the translation of "saadh jan" and "santan" and "sant janaa" can be changed back to "Saints" or "Saint Servants"
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefathehhhhh !!!
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
ANOTHER UK SINGH · 17 May 2006
I agree with UK Singh, I will never use it again either, from doing some good sewa, the "sewadaars" have just gone wrong.
SikhitotheMax will never be the same after them taking a biased side on this controversial issue, it should have been left how it was!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
what in the world · 18 May 2006
Sant or no Sant doesn't matter, people who don't believe "Sant" is real or whatever, should keep their beliefs to themselves rather then changing Arth of Bani
That's MAJOR BEADBI and ANYONE THAT CHANGES BANI ARTH / english translation will suffer maha paap for it, unless they ask Guru Sahib for forgiveness for any galtee... I'm serious, and this whole STTM has really upset me.
I'm a bit confused about the legitamacy of STTM as well now, unless you guys are puran gyani jis that have studied Bani for years, lay off the modifications or please take it very slowly and get the guidance of REAL gyanis, or else you'll be making some really stupid mistakes and offending countless Gursikhs, as well as Guru Sahib ji's Bani
bhul chuk maaf.
akaaaal
sahae
Re: SikhiToTheMax has been DE-SANT'D !
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheeva · 18 May 2006
vaaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaaheguroojeekeefathehhhhh !!!!!!
brothers and sisters, please STOP DOING NINDA of these sevadaars, they have done more seva than most of the pakhandi Sikhs on the internet. People sit on their computers and point fingers like i did, and that was wrong. i should have e-mailed them. they have replaced some of the interpretations and hopefully they will fix this mistake throughout all of SikhiTotheMax and keep the new interpretations of other words, but leave the interpretation of "santan" and "sant janaa" or "saadh jan" as "Saint Servants" and "Saints". please do not make the same mistake i did - of criticizing in public without doing benti in private. i'm sure the sevadaars will fix it. please let them do their seva and go and do some seva yourself!
vaaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaaheguroojeekeefathehhhhh !!!!!!
[%sig%]