Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

A Singh · 21 May 2006

Introduction This is one such area I observe not many from our community have entered, accept a few. I observe many readers writing Sikhs have been shown as comic characters in Bollywood, I fully agree with it. But fortunately Bollywood has never shown Sikhs as villains. Many movies have shown Sikhs as powerful characters also. Even Zoroastrians are also shown as comic characters but at the same time they are known for their honesty and control several major businesses in India. On the contrary Brahmins and Pundits have been shown as cunning and corrupt. Bollywood write from the 1950s has produced movies based on castism. Unfortunately the foreign media has done more damage to the Sikh image. The famous James Bond movie “Octobussy” shows Kabir Bedi as a Sikh criminal opposite Roger Moore. Another movie the name I don’t recall shows Nicholas Cage humiliating a Sikh taxi driver in America. “Bhavani Junction” is another movie based on British Rule in India which to some extend demoralizes the Sikh faith. Compared to Hollywood the Pakistani Media is even worst. In many drama serials on Pakistan TV shows Sikhs as negative characters. Now the only solutions is we need to become filmmakers, directors, actors and scriptwriters to project a positive and correct image of the Sikh faith. Looking back Sikhs have so many success stories which need to be propaganda in dramatized form. This is a new challenge for all of us worldwide. We have to win this Media war with Strategies and Intelligence. Unfortunately many readers think a war is fought only in a battlefield and cannot think beyond swords and kirpans. One cannot expect any non-sikh to project a proper image of Sikh culture. We need to make movies showing Sikhs as powerful characters promoting universal brotherhood for other beliefs worldwide. Our global presence speaks for it. Subjects to explore The following subjects can be explored 1. To start with a serial on Sikh history could be made starting from Guru Nanak Dev Ji to Guru Gobind Singh Ji. 2. A serial on Rule of Maharaja Ranjit Singh Ji could be made. Maharaja Ranjit Singh was the first to introduce the concept of transfer of technology. The close association with the French Army. Bringing back the kohinoor diamond. Maharaja’s secular rule in Punjab. 3. The close association of Sikhs with the Royal British Army and their contribution in the 1st and 2nd World War. As per records 80 thousand Sikh soldiers lost their lives and over a lac handicapped. It is an irony despite the contribution of Sikh soldiers neither Hollywood nor the British film media has given any due consideration. Great Hollywood classics like “Guns of Navaron”, “Where Eagles Dire”, “Band of Brothers” do not contain a single Sikh character. 4. Sikhs are highly respected by the Zoroastrian community as well. Majority Sikh transporters prefer TATA vehicles and are respected for their brand honesty from decades. The company’s R&D division during new vehicle design & development consults Sikh transporters. Possibly a film can be made which would be a tribute to the Sikh truck drivers who ply vehicles to every part of the country through out their life. 5. The close association of Sikhs with Netaji Subhash Chander Bose. Shyam Benegal has produced a film “The Forgotten Hero” in 2005. As per history 60% of INA (Indian National Army) soldiers were Sikhs. The film shows in incorrect display of the Sikh characters that were close to Netaji. The film has been highly criticized by the media for misrepresentation of history. 6. Sikhs who migrated to foreign countries, their initial struggle and success stories. 7. The problems, which the Sikh community faced after the Sept 11, attacks and how they tried to cop up. 8. A biography in form of a documentary should be produced on Dr. Narindar Singh Kapnay (Father of Fibre Optics). The documentary could be part of the History, Discovery or National Geographic channels under the biographies section. Majority Sikh masses may not aware of the fact. 9. Apart from the above plays and drama should be organized based on Sikh history or present day youth problems. Acting in plays helps a lot in developing the character in terms of communication and presentation. Present Filmmakers “Bend it like Becham” was a good concept on problems related to racism. It was an excellent movie, but the only draw back was an incorrect display of the young generation in terms of the Sikh swaroop. We do need such filmmakers like Gurindar Chaddha who can promote Sikh image and encourage the younger generation. Another initiative taken by Jaspal Bhatti to present Indian corruption in a comic form speaks of a good sense of humor. Making people laugh is not easy. The best thing to appreciable is, maintaining his Sikh swaroop he has done so. Such initiatives need to be taken on a larger scale. He appears funny and sometimes cheap only when he acts under other banners. Well know novelist late Rajinder Singh Bedi has influenced many scripts writers in Bollywood. He was also awarded the Padmashree by the Govt of India for his works. He had produced and directed a film “Dastak” in the 60s. Unfortunately his works did not contribute to the Sikh Panth Ammtoj Mann has done a remarkable job in “Hawayeen”, by touching the topic of 84 riots in 2003. With justice delayed and denied this could provide some moral support to Sikh widows and other victims of the riots. It did raze many eyebrows in the Indian Parliament. There after many Non-Sikh filmmakers have been influenced to touch the same topic. Gulzar (Sampooran Singh) is another filmmaker who touched the topic on police brutalities in Punjab very well during the mid 90s through the film “Maachis”. People for all beliefs appreciated the movie. Many politicians opposed it. Gulzar possess the ability to display the truth on screen. There was another film “Aandhi” directed by him in the 70s, which portrayed the character of Indira Gandhi. The film was banned from filming in theaters. Sikh Characters in Bollywood Some of the Bolloywood Movies, which have showed Sikhs as powerful characters. - Jeevan Mritiu – A movie of late 60s Bolloywood Actor Dharmendra acts a Sikh to find all the culprits. - Kala Pather – A movie of late 70s shows Parikshat Sahni as a generous and humble Sikh truck driver who saves the life of mine workers. There is beautiful Punjabi song “Ishq Aur Mushq Kade Naa Chipde” pictured on him. - Silsila – A movie of early 80s based extra marital affairs shows a Sikh character in a small role who is a very close friend of Amitabh Bachchann. The movie’s most powerful dialogs are given to this Sikh character, which brings Amitabh back on track. - Vijeta – A movie of early 80s shows the struggle of a young Sikh Air Force officer played by Kunal Kapoor. - Border – A movie of mid 90s based on Indo-Pak war. Sony Deol acts as a Sikh major. A very motivating movie for the Sikh community. It also praises Guru Gobind Singh ji. - Kohram – A Sikh Colonel played by Amitabh Bachann. The movie shows how circumstances make him go away from Sikh faith and finally how he returns back. There is very beautiful dialog “A real Sikh will die but never cut his hairs”. A great compliment from filmmaker Mehul Kumar to the Sikh Panth. - Maachis – A movie that mentions of police harassment to the Punjab youth, which resulted in terrorism. There are many regional Punjabi films viz. Nanak Naam Jahaj, Guru Maaneo Granth, Savaa Lakh Se Ek Ladaaun, etc. produced in the late 60s and 70s. Most of these films show the Sikh character in proper Swaroop. Many Bollywood actors viz. Prithvi Raj Kapoor, Sunil Dutt, Prem Nath, Dara Singh, Balraj Sahni, Pran, etc have played as power full Sikh personalities in many Punjabi films. But the most unfortunate bitter truth is that neither the SGPC, the Punjab Government nor the Sikh masses ever recognized their works. The result of this is that Sikhs are not having a powerful and effective media of their own. The price paid for this is very heavy. Many talented Sikh personalities had to sacrifice their Sikh swaroop for their survival. Filmmaker Gulzar and Ghazal Singer Jagjit Singh are very good examples. If we could have encouraged Art in the 1950s and 60s, then possibly a person like Gulzar could have made many films & documentaries on Sikh history and Jagjit Singh could have excelled in singing Gurbani. Thanks to the RSS for misrepresenting the Sikh faith and Sept 11 incidents, which has opened the eyes of the Sikh Panth. Off late at least the SGPC and other Sikh organizations have realized the importance of propaganda. Strategy of Other filmmakers Before we work out our strategy, we need to study the strategies, which filmmakers all over the world adopt. Most filmmakers derive scripts and ideas from their own culture. Most Hollywood films are based on fiction, special effects, science & technology, etc. since western countries constitute a research oriented culture. Always innovating and exploring and inventing some thing new. Aliens, Abyss, Jurassic Park, Terminator, Titanic, Bond series, etc. are some of the prominent works in the present times produced by Steven Spielberg, James Cameroon, etc. With the advancement in special effects technology it has simplified the work of the filmmakers drastically. The impossible can be made possible on screen. Most Muslim filmmakers concentrate on effective use of Urdu since majority are excellent poets, musicians and singers. Bollywood films like Adaalat, Mere Mehboob, Mere Hazoor, Mirza Galib, Mugal-e-Azam, Pakeeza, Umra O Jaan, etc. are produced by some of the prominent film makers viz. Mehbood Khan, Kamal Amrohi, K Asif, Muzaffar Ali, etc. Majority Muslim singers & actors have a good control on language and clarity of thought. Other Bollywood filmmakers concentrate on human relationships, social problems, etc. Bollywood has contributed many filmmakers who concentrated on a particular trend of filmmaking. To name a few: 1. Bimal Roy concentrated on social problems – Do Beega Zamine, Sujata & Bandhini are some of his works. 2. Guru Dutt showed bitter realities of life – Pyaasa, Kagaz Ke Phool, Aar Paar, Mr & Mrs 55, etc. 3. B R Chopra concentrates on social problems of different subjects – Dhool Ka Phool, Waqkt, Insaaf Ka Taraazu, Nikaah, etc. 4. Yash Chopra concentrates on Love stories – Kabhi-Kabhi, Kala Pather, Silsila, Chandini, etc. 5. Rishikesh Mukharjee concentrates on to common man problems – Anaadi, Anand, Namak Haram, Gool Maal, Choti Si Baat, Baaton Baaton Mein, etc. 6. Shakti Samant concerntrates on women sacrifice – Araadhana, Amar Prem, etc. The Far East filmmakers concentrate on Martial arts, Buddhism, Religious discipline, etc. Bruce Lee, Jackie Chian, etc are some of the prominent film personalities. Drawbacks in films After viewing many films from diverse cultures it is observed that every one focuses on superiority in some from or the other. In order words most filmmaker try to display their own culture & achievements to quiet an extend at the cost of others. For example Hollywood film makers show Russians, Arabs, North Korean, Chinese, Sikhs, etc as negative characters. There are few Jewish filmmakers who have shown atrocities on Jews by the Germans during 2nd World War. “Schindler’s List” directed by Steven Spielberg is one such example. Films like “Ben Her” & “Ten Commandments” which show the atrocities on Jews by Romans and Egyptians are also directed and produced by Jewish filmmakers. Islamic media tries to show their superiority on others. In the Islamic media women have no say at all, except for objects of entertainment for men. Films like Pakeeza and Omrao Jaan speak for it. Because of the powerful music and dialogue delivery the negative aspects of the Islamic culture are completely over shadowed. In really also the Islamic media worldwide is powerful in positive propaganda despite their drawbacks. Pakistani media has shown the Islamic superiority on Sikhs. Examples – Ladki Punjaban, Khamosh Pani. Bollywood tries to show that men are superior then women. Then there is a set of women film makers (Deepa Mehta, Aparna Sen) who try to prove that all men are idiots, rather women are power full then men. Superiority complex among various castes, etc. In most of the films it is shown that it is the man who impresses a woman. In other words the male character is dominant in majority cases. Most Muslim filmmakers show poets, musicians or ghazal singers as lovers. If he fails to impress he goes to Mujjraas to seek mental peace. In reality such a person can never be satisfied in life. The film Mirza Galib is an example. Bollywood shows the one who sings in gardens or the one who can fight with several criminals at a time to save a woman from being raped. This makes a woman always man dependent, which majority women dislike. Because women dislike men doing favor on them. On the contrary the friendship between girl and boy always ends up in marriage, which I believe can be experimented in some other way. In present times women characters are used mostly for dance numbers. Similarly love in Hollywood movies is shown more of an open attitude. The entire Indian youth is following this trend blindly. In the Far East movies both lovers should be experts in Martial Arts. To some extend one can consider equally in both characters. Most films are stereotype. Coming to the Punjabi regional films, there are few things common in most films. Rivalry between zamindars in a village along cheap and sub standard music. Again women characters have a very limited role, in most cases shown as homemakers. Compared to the 60s and 70s Punjabi film industry has virtually contributed nothing specific in the last 25 years. In the present times most Bollywood filmmakers have started showing Sikh characters, perhaps with a distorted image. For example the father is with Sikh swaroop and the son is not. This could be very damaging for the Sikh youth. A recent film “Rang De Basanti” is such example. A good film from concept point of view. Majority Bollywood filmmakers are following similar trend in films; the reason being, by showing the son without a Sikh swaroop is an attempt to make the character acceptable to the mass audience. Our community is responsible for this with provides filmmakers possible inputs. Most of the above concepts are out dated and obsolete. All this ideas to quiet extend corrupt the minds of the audiences and make them run away from the reality of life rather facing it. Lets try something new. Our Strategy As filmmakers we can bridge all the gaps across all cultures by giving entry to the Sikh character. We can fill the voids and loopholes of various cultures. This is possible my watching films produced world wide and trying to realize a possible slot for a Sikh character. This is possible through our own experiences and observations. We can do justice to male and female characters simultaneously. We can show Sikhs as solution providers. It is a well-known fact that Sikhs are capable of doing any kind of profession. It is a Sikh who can be found in any part of the world. The famous saying “Sikhs or Potatoes, you find them every where” holds true. This is the main reason showing a Sikh should not be restricted to the Punjabi culture only. As a normal character a Sikh is the one who never complains and accepts God’s Hukum in every walk of like. A Sikh residing in any part of the world can contribution something different and new. What is love for a Sikh? A Sikh as a lover can add altogether a new dimension in filmmaking. Rather love for us should be based on Merit. In other words both Male and Female characters will have an equal say. A Sikh as lover never chases or tries to impress a woman. Rather a woman respects this man for his high character. Following this strategy we can do justice to both men and women characters. If a man chases or tries to impress to seek the love of a woman can be termed as a beggar. A Sikh is not a beggar. Similarly if a man says that I cannot live without her and takes up to alcohol speaks of a weak character. Such a person can never influence a successful marriage. A Sikh is not weak in mind and heart. Women in present times have the right to reject and accept a man. A man with a weak mind and heart doesn’t deserve to be a life partner. A Sikh man will not go to a woman to find solutions rather he will find his own ways by shear determination and dedication and vice versa because it is you and the God with you. In other words we need to show love considering the ground realities incorporated with entertainment. “Love is not an art to us, it is life to us” a sentence derived from the film “Ten Commandments” is our way of life. A Sikh is always cheerful during tough times and always tries to find a way ahead rather than running away from the situation or thinking of past glory. In order to provide a Sikh character a wide coverage of audience it is important to show the co-ordination of a Sikh with characters from other cultures. In other words filmmaking could be a bigger challenge for us in terms of portraying multiple cultures with accuracy. The film “Bend It Like Beckham” showed the multi cultural co-ordination between characters from Sikh, British and Irish origin. Last year low budget short films without songs in Bollywood were produced viz. “Black” and “Iqbal”. Iqbal had one song in background. These films were a great success last year. We can also follow similar strategies. Instead of building unnecessary Gurudwaras and wasting funds on high-class marble and gold, lets use the same funds for some thing constructive, which could benefit the Sikh Panth overall.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

satvinder · 23 May 2006

Getting off the topic a bit with reference to the fourth paragraph up from the last. I Think I get where this comes from and I just wished to say that the same should apply to women. You may have intended to say this anyway but it seemed a little obscured and I thought I'd articulate a little further. Sure we all have wishes but the essence of rehat in Sikhi involves self control and discipline. There's no need to for either man or woman to "chase" because ultimately the divine has it all planned out in the first place. The thing about men needing to be strong to make a marriage work I whole heartedly agree and if you're the same A.S. that reads my rubbish blog you'll know why I say this. At the same time I have to say that it's also important for women to be strong too because I know of many, even in our generation who have a lot of rubbish thown their way. They just have to stand strong and be who they have to be. I think education and financial independance is a big aid for women in marraiges. It puts them on an equal footing with their partners and means that they can stand their ground. Anyway, more importantly coming back to the subject at hand... With regard to the power of media influence in today's society and the importance of proportionate and accurate representation. I commend your views. Many people in our "community" fail to recognise the importance of this subject and steer their children / siblings away from such fields because they don't offer "stable careers" or because they think their children etc will be lead astray because of what they currently see. To this I would say educate your child / loved one or youngsters you know about the importance of retaining their values and identity and from there support them and have faith in them. It's amazing how people still wish their close ones to follow tried and tested paths rather than allow them to recognise the value of subjects which are slightly offbeat but nonetheless important. With regards to the embellished Gurudwara buildings.. I personally would like to see just a simple well designed building which is meaningful and approprately pays homeage to Guru ji; Which is asthetically pleasing and comfortable [this is important to make people want to visit]. [had to get the arechitecture in (",)] But you're right, Gurdwara buildings are not the key focus at the moment. It's no use designing wonderful buildings if the youth of today are going to follow media infulences and go to places other than Gurdwara Sahib anyway. I'm sorry if I've been arrogant in making any assumptions and I hope you don't mind me stopping to comment. Also I hope I haven't said anything to offend.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

Balbir Singh · 23 May 2006

Reading the article I feel Sikhs should certainly venture into film making. This would certainly help to counter negative propaganda.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

Gurpreet Kaur · 24 May 2006

I agreed 100 % with the article regarding Rang de Basanti, showing Sikhs with cut hair in films. I have observed similar trends being followed in many bollywood films. Certainly this should be stopped.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

10th regiment · 24 May 2006

english patient? although it does show the singh doing the dirty with the gori

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

Balwant Singh · 24 May 2006

When our community doesn't treat women equally, it would be interesting see how equality on screen can be shown.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

Kulwindar S · 25 May 2006

I have seen the film Sawaa Lakh Se Ek Ladaoon. It is film of 1970s produced by Dara Singh. There is nothing objectional or incorrect against the Sikh faith. Infact comparing the way Sikh characters are shown today, it would still serve to be quiet inspiring for the Sikh youth today, if they watch this film. I heard this film had to face the wrath of the Akali parties and the Nihangs. If it is true, then it is very sad and unfortunate.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

satvinder · 28 May 2006

"When our community doesn't treat women equally, it would be interesting see how equality on screen can be shown." Good point... so what are we going to do about this? Are we going to continue with recognition of ailments without suggestion of remedy?

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

A Singh · 29 May 2006

"Good point... so what are we going to do about this? Are we going to continue with recognition of ailments without suggestion of remedy?" The film "Bend it Like Beckham" was a goof film from concept point of view. Documentries & films can be made on similar lines. Example - First Woman Indian Air Force polit is a Sikh First Sikh Woman to joint the Royal Canadian Mounted Police First Sikh Woman to joint US amry currenty serving in Kabul. There can be many more examples.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

Navdeep S · 30 May 2006

"A biography in form of a documentary should be produced on Dr. Narindar Singh Kapnay (Father of Fibre Optics). The documentary could be part of the History, Discovery or National Geographic channels under the biographies section. Majority Sikh masses may not aware of the fact." I am a constant watcher of Discovery , National Geog and History channels. This is great observation by A Singh Ji, Dr. Narindar Singh should feature in the above channels...... ...Such a great invention and no mention of Dr. Narindar is very sad affair. Hope to see some thing in future..... I have seen many Indian scientists working in western countries featuring in the above channels.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

Gurdeep Kaur · 04 Jun 2006

It is true that Sept 11 attacks have encouraged many young film makers to produce documentries on issues related to problems faced by Sikhs & Muslims staying in USA.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

A Singh · 06 Jun 2006

Gurpreet Ji, This is one such example http://valariekaur.blogspot.com/

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

satvinder · 06 Jun 2006

"The film "Bend it Like Beckham" was a goof film from concept point of view. Documentries & films can be made on similar lines" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ The concept was great, it's a shame that accurate portrayal or should I say ideal portrayal of Sikhi was not followed through but then I guess the film may have had a lesser appeal to a wider audience. I guess marketing comes into play now. With regard to inequality between men and women in reality... Again the medium of film is quite influential, why not use it to educate on this level too. The suggestion of film portrayal of women entering untapped career fields is great but it needs to go a bit deeper than that. Equality isn't just about doing the same jobs amongst other things it's about having equal rights to decision making within those jobs and that's what needs to be illustrated. Sorry this thread wasn't meant to be about women's rights it was about media portrayal of Sikhi. (",) Apologies for dilluting it with a different subject.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

A Singh · 06 Jun 2006

Satvinder Ji, In "Bend It Like Beckham" what was most annoying for me was the representaion of the young generation. If the film maker could have shown young generation with proper Sikh swaroop, I don't think it could have in any way affected the film's performance or earnings. Films representing any culture or any character are successfull based concept / story. In Hollywood there are many Afro American actors who are successfully, many for Asian and African orgin also. In other words the audience appreciate your work not your appearance. In the present era there are many successful families where both husband and wife balance their careers with proper time planning and are good parents as well. Many such couples can found in amoung Sikhs also. Many stories can be derived from it.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

Gurdeep Kaur · 08 Jun 2006

A Singh Ji, Some of my relatives attended the premier at Harvad for the Documentry "Divided We Fall". They also had the prevelage to meet the film producer Varline Kaur. She is a amazing lady. At such a young age she has taken a huge initiative. May Waheguru bless her with success.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

Gurman Singh · 20 Jun 2006

A Singh Ji, The article which you have wriiten is indeed a good piece of information. But to promote a Sikh in films calls for a media of our own. Plus I very agree with your point regarding the support of the Sikh masses. It is very important for us to support film making as part of prachar.

Re: Retaining Talent in Sikh Swaroop

Kulwindar S · 20 Jun 2006

Gurman Ji, I recent beauty contest held on Mr. Singh International is a step in right direction. Plus there is another Sikh Model Jaspal Singh who was first runner up a beauty show. http://www.indbazaar.com/fashion/index1.asp?artid=544&catid=1