Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Frank Decostco · 23 May 2006

Dear Brothers and Sisters, It says in the Japjee Sahib that everything is under the command of the Lord: whether good or bad, happy or sad, making or breaking, up or down. Does that mean that the Sikh religion does not believe in the concept of free will? If all is under the command, then that means whatever we do is being done by the lord. Then why does it say to make and effort to recite the Naam? If it's gonna happen it will happen under the command n'est pas? Then why are we going to be held accountable for our actions if they are all under the command? I would appreciate some explaining of the Sikh thought. Thanks, Frank Decostco

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 23 May 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeefateh You seem not to understand the concept of free will, as even if Vaheguru Jee is in control of everyone in the world including sikhs then if they do whatever they want such as commit a sin, then they are trapped in an illusion of EGO. Even though Vaheguru Jee has control over everything we do, we cannot do whatever we want, which is having free will and this would mean one can commit a sin, but isn't this wrong. So, why would Vaheguru Jee accept this? Try and comprehend the deeper meaning; Vaheguru Jee has control over us, at the same time Vaheguru Jee is making some do bad and others good, and the bad go to hell, reincarnation etc, whereas the good to Saachkhand, or be reborn as a human being to reach Saachkhand. This is the play of Vaheguru Jee, and we have to learn to accept it, but accept it in the way that we may be humble and live to perform good - serve Vaheguru Jee and humanity in other words. There is no devil that is at the same level as God – it is wrong to think this – as God is in control over everything, but the fact is that Mohammed Jee would have taught this if he waited for the wisdom of Sikhi. Sikhi has a connection with every religion due to the fact that some Prophets, if not all, didn’t wait for such wisdom but just attained a little of it due to their lack of patience and humbleness. However, Guru Jee waited for the wisdom, and as a result attained the truth, Sikhi, every bit of purity. He waited with patience, which equals faith and love, and humbleness. Hope this helped. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Balbir Singh · 23 May 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Frank Decostco Ji! The Sikh Gurus sing about the free Will (Command) of God. Merging in God one realizes this Truth. You asked "Then why does it say to make and effort to recite the Naam?" Please provide a reference. I will be thankful. Balbir Singh

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

df · 23 May 2006

go to gurbani.org and read the article on HUKUM. it will answer your question.

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Vikram Singh · 23 May 2006

Please read the last salok of Jap ji Sahib Jee. Source of all the things is God but God has given the human beings the ability to do efforts. So its by their own efforts someone can get closer and someone get away. For example: In the court, the Judge announce the verdict but the verdict is taken depending on the actions of the suspect. Salok: Air is the Guru, Water is the Father, and Earth is the Great Mother of all. Day and night are the two nurses, in whose lap all the world is at play. Good deeds and bad deeds-the record is read out in the Presence of the Lord of Dharma. According to their own actions, some are drawn closer, and some are driven farther away. Those who have meditated on the Naam, the Name of the Lord, and departed after having worked by the sweat of their brows -O Nanak, their faces are radiant in the Court of the Lord, and many are saved along with them! ||1|| [%sig%]

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Sardar · 23 May 2006

That's the same thought I think I've been having.

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

PTE SINGH · 24 May 2006

Frank, It is the same for all religions is it not? In Christianity there is free will, but you would accept that free will exists because the Lord allows it too. Surely the Lord if he wished can end anything and everything when he so wishes, but chooses to allow us to make decisions under his guidance. Ultimately everyone is under the Lords command. [%sig%]

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Balbir Singh · 24 May 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Frank Ji! Free will of an individual ego is illusion. I have not found one instance in Gurbani explaining free will, the game of an individual. Some may have misinterpreted it like that. We cannot extend the Guru's statement "All is Hukam" with "other than the free will of an individual." Balbir Singh

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Sardar · 24 May 2006

But doesn't it say in the Aasaa Ki Vaar or Aasaa Di Vaar, whichever one it is, that: "Aape Hee Karam Karaanedhaa(n)" He Himselfs Causes Everything To Happen. Then how do we commit sins? How am i writing on this messsage board? How am i having such a thought? So God causes everything single little thing to happen? So God caused the Indian Army or Government to attack SachKhand Shiri Takht Takht Saahib and SachKhand Shiri Harminder Saahib? God caused Hindus to attack Sikhs for no reason and claim them as terrorists? God causes all these bad things and then people are accounted for it?

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

.... · 24 May 2006

basically..if everything happens in god's will...and as someone said god makes some do good deeds and some bad deeds.....then how are the people who do bad deeds reach sachkhand......i mean they will only able to make the attempt when guruji will let them??......basically i dnt understand how this thing works then???

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 24 May 2006

Yes Its All Gods Play, it's his story. This life is a story where both bad and good happen, but at the end only good shall prevail. You'll all find out for yourself sooner or later.

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Balbir Singh · 24 May 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Sardar Ji! Quote >>>Then how do we commit sins? <<< This may be our point of view. Gurbani says God is Same for all. ************** Let us try to understand it this way. We are the owner and master of our body and mind. Does our heart beat as we want it to? Do our blood cells move with our permission? Do our kidneys work according to our instructions? Do thoughts come and go as we dictate? I have not found one thing that is working in my existence as ego wants it. The same is found in the outer world. Who is the cause of all these movements? I wish all great Satsangs. I am away for few days. Balbir Singh

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

singh · 24 May 2006

To those who say "Everything is under Gods hukam, he does not will it so that is why I do not stop drinking..smoking..cuting hair etc." Ask these people why do they make the effort to eat, if it is under God's will won't he pick up the spoon and feed you as well. I don't think i said that properly but it was said in a katha I heard once.

Re: Free Will in the Sikh Religion

Frank Decostco · 26 May 2006

Thanks for your replies, From what I understand - our percieved "free will" is then only an illusion of our ego, but it is really the play of the lord? Then in Banee it says "Karmee Apoe Apnee, Kai NARAI KAI Door" Then accordingly this would mean that really the karam is the lords play and we are played either closer or far away by his will, but this is written as our own karam. It also says "Udam Karat, Anand Baiaa, Simrat Sukh Saar" Through putting in an effort in Simran one gets hapiness. Then again it is only if he wills that you can put the effort in.