Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

uk singh · 23 May 2006

a bhenji told me that she took amrit in an amrit sanchaar (few years back) and the panj piyare told her not to wear dastar. she said why? and the panj replied that "how will we put amrit in your kesh?" this singhni is very strong singhni and she said, "how u going to put amrit in singh's kesh?" she stood her ground and the panj had to allow her in amrit sanchar though they werent happy with her wearing dastaar. now according to "gurmat" (gurbani and mukhvaakhs of guru sahib) it is clear that woman and man should wear dastaar. however someone who likes to justify their own "dhill" in rehit could say "panj pyare's hukam is final - if panj tell you hukam in guru's hazoori then you must obey" or they could say "dastar is not compulsary for women according to the panth". so what's senior gurmukhs views?

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

heallow · 24 May 2006

like ive said panj pyare are panj pyare they either are or theyre not in this case you can make your own judgment would dasm patsah ever say take off your dastar?

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

uk singh · 24 May 2006

i was very saddened when the bhenji told me. i hope this has never happened with anyone and that this is a "one off" isolated case.

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

singh · 25 May 2006

Many years ago at a Soho road Amrit sanchaar, they told 2 bibis to remove their dastaars. They told them these are not essential. The bibian walked out of the Amrit Sanchaar. When Giani Amolak Singh found out, he rounded up the Singhs who did the seva in the panj and gave them a really bad telling off.

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

Singh · 25 May 2006

Any old random group of 5 Singhs who do their basic 5 kakkar, 5 bania, is not panj pyare. Panj Pyare is the most Gurmukh,Abhiyaasi and strict Rehtdharis available and chosen by Saadh Sangat through a strict process. The panj pyare in question, is quite obviously not a panj at all. I wonder how those who claim "all amrit sanchars are equal" will tackle this one...

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

singh · 26 May 2006

I totally agree. There are too many dodgy amritsanchaars going on.

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

uk singh · 26 May 2006

omg. i was telling someone that a bibi took amrit last year but she doesnt cover hair, keeps hair down (in curls), wears earrings, make-up but is apparently amritdhari. the singh who knows her well said that she took amrit at soho road gurdwara and they told her she is allowed to wear earrings, no mention of keeping head covered (let alone wear a keski!!!!), and i was shocked to hear that they said "you can wax your face". does anyone have any info to back this up? if this is true then i wouldn't send anyone there to take amrit because in a way the panj are breaking people away from Gurmat Rehit. someone wants to take amrit in london area. does anyone know when the next amrit sanchar is (preferably one which advocates gurmat rehit of wearing keski)? can an amrit sanchar be organized in london - there are no amrit sanchaars happening in london which give tat gurmat rehit. akj uk - can you do more amrit sanchaar seva in london pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! thanks.

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

?! · 26 May 2006

whats wrong with women waxing their face?! isnt that like every womens dream come true to be able to take amrit yet carry on as normal.. so your like a gurmukh but yet still look and appear to look like a manmukh.. amzing huh?! When is there next amrit sanchaar?

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

singh · 26 May 2006

"isnt that like every womens dream " No i dont think it is every woman's dream to have a manmat amrit sanchar where bujjar kurehats are allowed. I think soho rd amrit sanchars distribute the amrit from a stainless steel bowl too

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

ummm.. · 26 May 2006

the question the rings to my mind, is that when do panj pyare become panj pyare and when are they relieved of their duties, cus some think they are panj pyare all the time ???? it is a seva and nothing more and if you are no where near yooaag you shouldn't offer to do it, the pre requesites nowadays overlook some of the most complex issues, jevvan, truth, kirath, etc, people just pick those who do amritvela with them and know one of the panj baniya off by heart, there is soo much sooadh sadahai being missed out even in AKJ, really people lets get back to the basics !!

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

Moorakh · 26 May 2006

Excuse me do you even know how AKJ pick their punj, if you don't you shouldn't makle these stupid remarks. The AKJ are always picked, the ones who are the MOST spirtually chardi kala in the sangat! Unlike other amrit sanchar, they just pick any dick and harry.

Re: What is Panj in Amrit Sanchaar tell Bibi to TAKE OFF her dastaar.

heallow · 27 May 2006

this singh i know went to soho road once and saw ppl matha teking to some babba after that i dont go to soho road gurdwara, some ppl say its peaceful there i say quite the opposite, if theres manmat going on, atmosphere wont be graet