Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

Kulbir Singh · 25 May 2006

Even Raagis don't keep pothis on Vaaja when doing kirtan. Jatha that is supposed to be the jewel among Jathas of Panth has adopted this very wrong practice of not memorizing baani and doing kirtan from Pothi. Bhai Sahib Atma Singh jee Panjokhra was very much against Pothi kirtan. Singhs who have done his sangat even today do only Kanth kirtan. They can do kirtan for hours without referring to pothi. Here are some points to ponder upon: 1) By placing pothi on the vaaja, don't we disrespect the pothi? Shouldn't the pothi be parkash on a rael as opposed to the vaaja? 2) While doing kirtan, saliva from the kirtaniyaa's mouth ends up on the pothi. Is this according to Gurmat? 3) Ones who depend on the pothi have to keep referring to pothi for the next pankiti. How can they concentrate on shabad if they have to keep referring to the pothi? 4) The way they turn panna (pages) of pothi, without washing their hands is totally contrary to Gurmat Maryada of washing your hand before handling pothis. 5) What kind of pyaar is this that to do even the most basic shabad they have to refer to the pothi. Singhs in olden days used to remember so many shabads. What does sangat think about this issue? I personally think that the Jatha in Western countries needs to ponder upon this be-adbi of Gurbani. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

Harmeet Singh · 25 May 2006

vjkk, vjkf Pyare Kulbir Singh Jee, you have brought up some very good points for having the Pothi Sahib nearby while doing keertan. But a few comments on not having the Pothi Sahib on harmonium or near the harmonium: 1) Even some of the most experienced and best keertania have made mistakes which the Sangat didn't correct the keertaniya while singing until for example 2 minutes after singing the line many times wrong...then the keertaniya corrects his/her mistake by reffering to the Pothi Sahib infront of them (Amrit Keertan) and then everyone sings the correct line. (the Guru Ka Keertani is like the director (sorry I couldn't find a better word) in this Jatha while doing keertan as they are directing the Sangat on what to say). 2) MOST of the time the Pothi Sahib is put on a wooden stand that is way higher than the harmonium and is slanted so the keertani can see. The height of the stand compares to probably the height or almost the height of the stage where Ragi Jees do keertan on. Also on this stand is a clean cloth/rumala is put over it and then the Pothi Sahib is put on the stand and cloth...so there is actually a lot of respect for the Pothi Sahib (Amrit Keertan). *side note: you should be able to memorize a shabad by the time you can play it on the harmonium very flowingly and have completed learning all the notations and are ready to sing at a smagam or Akhand Path Sahib or even just at home. It's really not that hard. (sorry to sound rude..I have no intention on being rude but it's a good point that by the time you have practised so much that you can flowingly play the tunes and play somewhere, that the shabad practically gets memorized by itself..I'm talking from experience..not from an opinion)* I am just Guru Ka DasnDas..the lowest of the low...please forgive me if I said anything wrong and also I hope because of my post it doesn't become an arguement..just an improvement/awarement issue. Sorry if i put some words in capital letters as I am not even close to saying anything in a mad voice..all is said in a gentle voice... This Shabad is by Bhai Gurdaas Ji in Vaars Bhai Gurdaas on Pannaa 10 drSx vyKx nwmdyv Blky au~T iqRlocn AwvY] dharashan vaekhan naamadhaev bhalakae out(h) thrilochan aavai|| Trilochan awoke early daily just to have sight of Namdev, Bgiq krn iml duie jxy nwmdyau hir clq suxwvY] bhagath karan mil dhue janae naamadhaeo har chalath sunaavai|| Together they would concentrate on the Lord and Namdev would tell him the grand stories of God. myrI BI kr bynqI drSn dyKW jy iqs BwvY] maeree bhee kar baenathee dharashan dhaekhaa(n) jae this bhaavai|| (Trilochan asked Namdev) “kindly pray for me so that if the Lord accepts, I may also have a glimpse of His blessed vision.” Twkur jI noN puiCEs drSn ikvYN iqRlocn pwvY] t(h)aakur jee no(n) pushhious dharashan kivai(n) thrilochan paavai|| Namdev asked Thakur, the Lord, as to how Trilochan could have sight of the Lord ? hskY Twkur boilAw nwmdyau noN kih smJwvY] hasakai t(h)aakur boliaa naamadhaeo no(n) kehi samajhaavai|| The Lord God smiled and explained to Naamdev; hQ n AwvY Byt so qus iqRlocn mYN muih lwvY] hathh n aavai bhaett so thus thrilochan mai(n) muhi laavai|| “No offerings are needed by me. Out of my delight only, I would make Trilochan to have sight of me. " hauN ADIn hW Bgq dy phuMc n hMGW BgqI dwvY] hou(n) adhheen haa(n) bhagath dhae pahu(n)ch n ha(n)ghaa(n) bhagathee dhaavai|| I am under the total control of the devotees and their loving claims I can never reject; rather I myself also cannot understand them. hoie ivcolw Awx imlwvY ]ñò] hoe vicholaa aan milaavai ||aa|| Their loving devotion, in fact, becomes mediator and makes them meet me.” *I didn't post the Shabad in a sense to have a reference to this topic just posted it because it was such a pyara Shabad :) (like all shabads) :D * bhul chuk maph karnee jee vjkk, vjkf :)

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

sarbloh · 25 May 2006

Guru Fateh Whats the difference between pothi and gutka.Is it wrong if i keep gutka in a bag white I travel?Do gutkas have to be prakashed as well?

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

Gurpreet Singh · 25 May 2006

I am also very apposed to the use of pothis on the vaajaa, its nothing but beadbi, especially when most people dont even wear a hazooria anymore to keep their hands somewhat clean before changes pages in the pothi. Also, I have noticed that their is just soo much less rass in the keertan when the keertanee is using a pothi, u can honestly hear the difference. It's not only a problem in AKJ, the youth of today regardless of jatha have this problem, if u wanna see beadbi of pothis just goto a youth keertan

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 26 May 2006

VaheguruJeekaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh What you have said is very true and should be done, but the reason for why the Jatha hasn't adopted this practice is due to the reason that most do not comprehend and practice the teaching of Gurbani. Some Sikhs are starting to waste their time a lot with nonsense, but Gurbani teaches not to indulge in such, for instance in movies, as doesnt Gurbani teach one not to waste time in clear tricks to the mind, which is watching useless drama. If every SIkh in the world did comprehend and practice Gurbani then they would be left to practice the truth, which would be to jap naam, read gurbani and earn a honest living (work). But, because not that many poeple do practice the teachings of Gurbani they instead waste their time in vain, in nonsense and in a dream. Thus, they don't use their time to read a lot of Gurbani, which would lead them to memorising it automatically. If one does kirtan, and everything else I've said then the love for Gurbani through Naam will help them to know it of by heart, and in this way their body would turn into a store house for Gurbani; the store house of the practice of truth and only the truth. A Sikh should be serving others, so why do we serve ourselves? Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

sarblohi · 26 May 2006

i have to agree it isnt really that hard to memorize one shabad

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

singh · 26 May 2006

with the advent of sikhi tothe max, pothis are now rarely used.

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 May 2006

Already we have THOUSANDS of SHABADS that DONT GET SUNG....at all. Anyone ever sat down and thought about it....out of 1429 aangs of Sggs..just how many Shabads NEVER get sung aby any Raagi ?? Many THOUSANDS ( just as many thousands NEVER get to be read as Hukmanamas as well) Then we have kirtaniyas who dont even memorise the FEW that they sing all the time....sometimes i am amazed..the Jatha will be sitting in snagat waiting for their turn....and then will begin to SING the EXACT SAME Shands that the previosu jatha already sang for one hour...Dont they have any different ones ?? KANTH Gurbani and "look see Gurbani" is million miles different..this is one reason why the Kirtan of SOORMA SINGHS (blind ragis) is so wonderful...its all KANTHs A Jatha that calls itself AKHAND KIRTANI JATHA has no excuse not to KAANTH GURBANI. Period. I beleive Bhai Sahib Bhai randheer Singh ji never used any pothis on vajaas. Please carry on that tradition. I support Kulbir singh on thsi one. Right thing is to kaanth gurbani..even for NITNEM Banis...Sri sukhmani Sahib..Asa Dee Vaar,,Ramkali vaar..Oankaar (Dakhnee).. then you dont need a MP#/POD but do your own paath jabanii

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

nishaan sahib · 26 May 2006

how can one prepare their body to handle the parkash when doing naam bani?

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

ns · 26 May 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Apologies I disagree, this debate started by Kulbir Jee is of no use at all and a waste of time all caught on bharm and nothing else. When there are plenty of challanges for the Sikh world out there we keep coming up with these types of debates by some of the most learned on Gurbani on this phorum.Does it matter if you have it memorised or not, even if you have memorised and then to have the pothi there you're only ensuring you don't make mistakes. About Saliva my god talk about attention to detail is the kirtania so low down and not bothered about his/her saliva hitting the pothi Sahib. I take that as disrespectful comment to some of the beautiful kirtains out there.Come on Kulbir Jee you can better much posting than this one. Sorry to be critical but where is this post going , it will only end up going aroundin circles.

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

gabroo · 27 May 2006

ns i doubt think anyone who has posted so far, not anyone else with an ounce of respect for guru's baani would consider ths topic as a waste of time. its the pennies that make pounds (if u dont mind me using an analogy from maya). to discuss this matter does not mean that all other challenges have been put on hold. view the multitude of other posts present!!! the post is very relevant, especially as a reminder to us youth that we ought to put more effort into enshrining baani enough inside us to have it memorised. then we can simmar on it anywhere anytime. respect to baani was emphasised by Guru sahib who slept on the floor whilst Baani was layed on his manja. so theres attention to detail ns sahib. sory to everyone else for reading negativity on behalf on mine and ns's post. continue the discussion.

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 27 May 2006

and thats why the "Youth" then descend to the next level....Kirtan Pothis in ROMANISED GURBANI....even Gurmukhi script is then thought unnecessary...only the tutta futta weird pronounciation based on romanised language and the catchy tune...thats kirtaniya for you. Initially it may be ok..but after years and years..the attitude still holds for soem jathedars... Study GURMUKHI..PUNJABI..GURBANI..KANTH..and then kirtan..the rass is out of this world... Some thing s are necessary and soem are absolutley indespensable..

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

ns · 28 May 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Thanks for your comments gabroo sahib jeeo. I understand the need in this hour to memorise as much Gurbani as possible, I have no issues with that at all.But even after memorising so much one can still make a mistake. So do we think now that when people use pothi sahib just to ensure correctness by all means have they gone so low and are showing disrespect and are so lost they don't relaize where there saliva is going when doing kirtan. I'm fully aware of the fact we need respect for Gurbani but I don't understand how comes people who show the utmost respect by ensuring they read the bani right use the pothi sahib. I suppose one solution could be not to use the pothi sahib as in many rehansbahyes projectors are there showing the sangat the Shabad online, surely the kirtania and this thread has the solution starring us in the face. And there is no way that saliva is going all the way up to that projector!! However pothi sahib will still be used by youth who are learning, but the question remains , are our upcoming youth who do kirtan , educated in the western world so daft as to not show respect??? Disrespect to Guru Granth Sahib Jee has been going on in the UK for the past 40-50 years where Guru Jee has been taken to hallls only now we have upcoming Gursikhs who are challanging it head on and ensuring respect.We have a long way to go yet if think it's beadbi to use pothi sahib for doing kirtan!

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

Harpartap Singh · 29 May 2006

Bhai Sahib, Should we not also be worried about Guru ji saroop being kept in Mandirs (in cupboards)? in western libraries? being taken to clubs and restaurants? Why are so few willing to raise their voices against this? And more importantly do something? What would Guru Gobind Singh ji Maharaj have done? What would Baba Deep Singh ji have done? What would Bhai Mani Singh ji have done? What would Bhai Randhir Singh ji have done? What would Bhai Fauja Singh ji have done? Too much talk about the actions of our glorious Shaheeds from the past and NO action.... At least it seems that way in the UK

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

Kulbir Singh · 02 Jun 2006

Veer Harmeet Singh jeeo, -------------------- 1) Even some of the most experienced and best keertania have made mistakes which the Sangat didn't correct the keertaniya while singing until for example 2 minutes after singing the line many times wrong...then the keertaniya corrects his/her mistake by reffering to the Pothi Sahib infront of them (Amrit Keertan) and then everyone sings the correct line. (the Guru Ka Keertani is like the director (sorry I couldn't find a better word) in this Jatha while doing keertan as they are directing the Sangat on what to say). --------------- If regular raagis can memorize shabads and hundreds of them too, then why can’t nishkaam kirtaniyaas of Jatha memorize shabads? Bhai Atma Singh jee of Panjokhra Sahib used to say that Gurbani naturally comes to Gursikhs during kirtan. Bhai Sahib Atma Singh jee was called Pothi since he had so much baani memorized. Once your mind knows that you cannot use the pothi, it naturally and automatically adjusts to the new reality and starts memorizing baani. Recently during my visit to India, I heard Gursikhs doing kirtan for long long time without use pothi. Bhai Daljinder Singh of Patiala did about 15-20 shabads, all from memory and there was no pothi present at that time. ------------- 2) MOST of the time the Pothi Sahib is put on a wooden stand that is way higher than the harmonium and is slanted so the keertani can see. The height of the stand compares to probably the height or almost the height of the stage where Ragi Jees do keertan on. Also on this stand is a clean cloth/rumala is put over it and then the Pothi Sahib is put on the stand and cloth...so there is actually a lot of respect for the Pothi Sahib (Amrit Keertan). ------------ Pothi on the stand is a rare thing. In most cases, pothi is placed on the vaaja. Even on the stand, pothi sends out a very wrong message. While non-Jatha ragis do kirtan without pothi why do Jatha kirtaniyas not memorize baani and do kanth kirtan. The whole panth does Kanth kirtan. At Harmandir Sahib only Kanth kirtan is allowed. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

Harmeet Singh · 02 Jun 2006

vahiguru jee ka khalsa|| vahiguru jee kee fateh|| Veer Kulbir Singh Jee, yes you are right that Kanth kirtan is the right way to go when doing keertan and you are also right about Bhai Daljinder Singh Jee 'Patiala', he also memorizes his shabads and does keertan from memorization and that's why he does keertan with so much pyar...without having to look at the pothi sahib, he can focus on the ras of the shabad. Yes jathey singhs and singhniya should also do kanth keertan and in most cases (if any exceptions) they should be able to memorize a shabad. That's the glorious thing...you can memorize even 1 shabad and sing it with fullll pyar and concentration (with eyes closed too...not looking around) and it would be much more effective than reading and doing keertan at the same time. Yes, I have to admit that at YOUTH keertans there is rare use of the stand but at raensabhais most of the time it's there (if a family can bring it) and even at akhand path sahib's (keertan part). When I'm saying stand, I'm reffering to the one that goes over the harmonium a bit not the one used for steeks and pothis (the small stand that goes infront of you when you're just doing path). *Regular ragis, that's their way of living so while making tunes up and everything..they have the same amount of time if not more to memorize..no question about it (and yes they do other things too..but a lot of time is spent on preparing to go on keertan duty). *Keertania in the jatha have other jobs in other categories but that CANNOT be used as an excuse to not memorize shabads. EVEN SINGING 1 SHABAD FROM MEMORY AT A PROGRAM OR WHERE EVER IS BETTER THAN SINGING 4 SHABADS (or however many) FROM READING. *By the time you have memorized the keys for the notations of the tune and can play them with your eyes closed, you should have your shabad memorized by then too. Don't get me wrong, I'm all for kanth keertan. the points in my first post were just small points that I pointed out but the points in this post should've showd my views on kanth keertan. vahiguru jee ka khalsa|| vahiguru jee kee fateh||

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

..... · 02 Jun 2006

I recall reading a story about the time of Bhai Sahib how the keertani would come prepared with 16-20 shabads memorized and could play whatever ones they pleased. These day is an entirely different matter. There are still those gursikh that exist that cannot pass a day without having the holy glimpse of the guru (and in human form at that).

Re: Kanth Kirtan Vs Pothi Kirtan

..... · 02 Jun 2006

Talking on having glimpse of guru, what use is it to glimpse with these worldly eyes; the real glimpse is the the divine eyes that enable the person to view the divine light.