Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

"Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

"Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

moorukh · 26 May 2006

Gurfateh Veero & Bheno, I am a 24 year old male Amritdharee in the UK and work as a teaching instructor (supply teacher for ages 11-16 - when permanent teachers call in sick I go in to cover). I have been in this profession for less than a year now. Everyday (or every few days), I have the same job of going in to a new school and trying to get to know the students very quickly, trying to build a rapport or some kind of mutual respect; its no easy job. I feel really drained by the end of the day and cant wait to get home. Being a 6ft5 singh with a dumalla and flowing beard, I stand out and I always hear "Bin Laden" or people shocked to see me or trying to hide their laughter when they see me. The way I've been tackling this is to just ignore it "Moorakhe Naal Na Loojeeai" but yesterday it really got to me when someone said "Oh, we've got Bin Laden today" and I retaleated verbally by asking "which ignorant fool said that?". Anyway, the whole situation blew out of proportion and another teacher had to intervene to calm the situation down. My question to the rest of Sangat is how do they deal with this kind of attitude...??? Yesterday, I totally felt that I should have just kept quiet and beared it because my anand went really low; and the reason that I retaliated was my lack of Sehn-Shaktee which is in turn due to the lack of kamaiyee. I'm not going to stay in this profession (not due to the above reasons), but feel that I will always have to face this kind of ignorance. Can other Sangat members please share their experiences and/or how they feel is best to tackle these type of situations. Thank you. Gurfateh Parvaan

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

PTE SINGH · 26 May 2006

You should not have to put up with that, and have every right to feel angry. Ignoring it is not the way to go, the situation should always be reported and taken all the way.so that others do not have to suffer it. At the end of the day the remarks of a few sad individuals should not bother a Sikh, but make sure that you always challange such things in the correct calm manner.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

some1 · 26 May 2006

BIG THING, YOU HAVE TO REALISE IS THAT THEY ARE KIDS. second thing be calm explain to them, kids are not meant to know everything. u became a teacher, now realise ..u have 2 teach.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

I Singh · 26 May 2006

Bhaji I think that what you did was perfectly fine. How would they like it if you were to call them "Hitler", "Paul Barnardo" or some other name just because of the way they look? Name calling should not be tolerated especially when it happens because of your race, ethnicity or faith beleif. Personally if I were in your place I would not be in this profession. Kids from grade 6-12 are the worst. If you want to stay in this profession then you should either teach grade 1-5 or up grade and teach at the college level because students at colleges are much more mature minded. Just my opinion, forgive me for any offence.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

fresno sikh · 26 May 2006

SSAKAL I used to work in Emergency room at hospitals as a Xray tech also had the same issues even before 9/11. Change careers, it can be draining. When you will look back at this I think these things make us a better person. Stay in Chardi Kala. I used to think there was no end but Whaeguru has plans for each one of us. Now I have a desk Job making twice as before and work with about 10 people. I also feel bad about our sikh children who have to face these things on a daily basis and our people are giving this issue a deaf ear. [%sig%]

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

. · 26 May 2006

i feel lucky compared to your situation, but i do get called names n bullied n stuff, jus 4 wearing a dastaar. it is hard, n i used 2 try n laugh it off but i realised that if i dont sort it then theyre gonna keep saying it n next time its gonna b someone else. i suppose we jus gotta explain it to them, without coming across aggressive. n they want u to get pissed off so ur kind of giving into them if u show it. if it happens again then report the kid, coz thats all they are kids.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

Knowing M.E. Knowing You · 26 May 2006

don't get angry as suggested by PTE Singh. only small difference in age between you and kids, see?? keep cool. if they know they can genuinely wind you up by calling you such things, they will start doing it much more. i used to give teachers much hell when i was a kid. always challenge racist remarks - interrupt everything and go all the way BY THE BOOK. keep adrenaline under control.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

..... · 26 May 2006

i dont know if its a good idea to start an argument with these kids, but this behaviour cannot be tolerated nor ignored, something has to be done a teacher must be respected and these comments are no way acceptable, the fact that your not a teacher at one schoold does make it that much harder, it maybe better to stick to 1 school, so kids get used to you if that is not possible, inform the headteacher of any abuse, make sure these kids are dealt with harshly i know of a teacher in my local area who is in his 30's and wears a dumalla and open beard and teaches in secondary school, iv been informed by kids its very inspirational to see a Rehitvaan Gursikh as a teacher everyday, he's like a role model

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

jogendra · 26 May 2006

as an adult - and when dealing with children - we have to remain in control and by getting on their level - we loose what we are trying achieve as a child i loved it when i could get my teacher in a situation that would totally confuse them and they would act out but then i would not respect them again the teachers that i truly remember and respected were the ones that delt with my attitude and were able to change my negative thinking into positive thinking - teachers - teach - (respect - love - tolleration) if they don't then first levels of intolerance can happen and children can grow up to become raicist adults and pass it on

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

m? · 26 May 2006

i went to nyc one time to site see and we came to ground zero, and some black guys made a joke that first we want to blow it up now we are taking pics of it.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

Sanjo · 27 May 2006

i think that religious studies at schools these days should be improved to try n tackle these issues. im not sure what secondary education is like nw but i think alot of people are confused between gursikhs n "bin laden". bhai sahib i think perhaps u could suggest this to the headmaster or religious studies teachers in the staff room during breaks or something this could mke a small but significant difference. as for the kids well they are only kids so forget about them, its harder when a older seemingly mre educated person judges you as a "terrorist". eveeryone always looks at you differently nowadays they do get suspicious. however i find it comforting that there are some educated kind people out there that actually like seeing a amritdhari. like some old english bibia say hello sometimes and its like they are only saying hello to me cos i have got guru jis saroop. its amazing, for some reason tho alot of people find the image odd, alot of others respect and feel joy in seeing guru jis saroop.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

guruji's_student · 27 May 2006

waheguru .. id end up beating the kids.... well ive jst took amrit in august and wear dastar onli person in ma town and that and i go 2 school as im 16!! .. and got some bad comments but been good.. cus ppl klnwo who i am and that so tekk ah uve jst gotta educate them !! ... its hard.. cus has been tymes where ive kiked off but all maharajs kirpa i wish u the best of look paaaji :) AKAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL HE AKAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

Singh · 27 May 2006

If another teacher said it a formal complaint should be made.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

*-*-* · 27 May 2006

you have to also remember to see mahraj in every1-everything is a test!...ur job is to educate so bhaji please this is a benti now-EDUCATE!!!...also rem tht the only way we gt through kaljug is to jap naam so keep mahraj on ur mind in the good and the BAD TIMES!!

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

Benji · 28 May 2006

Yes bhaji, I understand your problem fully as i work with students of year 7-11 aged 11years to 16years. VERY HARD IN SUCH SITUATIONS but If it would had been me in place of you , i would have talked to the head of the dept and the headteacher together thereby requesting to talk to the kids in their year assemblies by creating a power point to show the differences between BIN LADEN and Guru Gobing Singh's KHALSA. Have the guts to go for it. Make them that its a part ofDEMANDING EDUCATION OF PRESENT TIME. I had to support two girls of year 10 and 11 as one of them arrived from Afghanistan( a Sikh Family) and the other one came from Pakistan ( muslim FAmily) they both made good friends as they had little English on them but what they experienced in school (students always calling them Bin Laden) that they were always in tears. No senior authority took any solid steps to sort out the problem and being a teaching assistan, I was always ignored or not taken seriously. Any way, if you think you liked my idea of power point then I would say its a GR...R...Reat step you can take to flourish SIKHI. WJKK WJKF

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

domalla premee · 28 May 2006

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh 1) As a teacher whether you are also an authority figure.You are in the driver's seat. These kids will test your authority, especially if you are a temp. This age group also wants to assert its individuality yet is not mature yet and despite their defiance actually crave limits. Calmly but firmly assert your authority then and there as a teacher by questioning the disruptive behavior in question. Adjust your body language to show you mean business. You take the focus off yourselfby shifting the focus to the task of running an orderly classroom. 2) If that does not work then treat this kid as a repeat offender. Be creative. Respect of others is a key lesson these kids are learning at this age. Be creative. You can use this situation as an opportunity. Give the kid an assignment to research about the Sikh faith and report about it in class. Expect it to be complete in return for amnesty for the repeat offense. The alternative is what happens by the book and be sure to follow up on it. A presentation may be helpful as another reader suggested. I also know of a girl who wore dastar who started learning gatka.This girl was treated rather cruelly at school. A multicultural fair occured and her Ustad suggested they do a Gatka presentation for their contribution. They spoke about Sikhi then did the demonstration. What happened was amazing. The abuse stopped and kids her age had a new found respect for her.Just goes to show you that lemons make great lemonade. 3)Smile! Focus on the positive. Remember whose son you are! Don't second guess yourself. Think clearly do a quick Ardas. Then do the best you can. That is all that is expected of you. Walk tall and confident knowing whose son you are. You know who you are and you don't need to justify yourself everytime you walk in public. Never make what people in general think of you as your problem. Their negative attitude is not your problem nor can you always correct it. Some people just don't know others are plain cruel to fill a void within themselves. I feel sorry for them. They are not happy to start out with. Believe in what you are doing. Don't just bear what you do to pass the time. Be passionate about it. The lessons you learn from what you do now will serve you the rest of your life. dass

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

Makhan · 29 May 2006

I am an Amritdhari Sikh Teacher and teach in England. I don't go to my school with flowing beard but nicely tied. Every one in school knows that I carry my siri-sahib with me all the time. I am in the same school for the last 16 years. I had few problems when I started in this school, as the catchments area is mostly council estate and have very few Asian kids. But now parents and kids show me more respect than to white teachers. They may be making remarks behind my back, which I don't know. What I know is that majority of them don't want to leave and move to next form at the end of class year. You have to teach them about yourself not only the subject you teach. Those who say to change your profession are not right. Take it easy. I know it is very difficult job especially supply teaching.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

Moorakh Mugad Eean · 30 May 2006

I too work for an educational institution, but not as a teacher. I have faced quite overt racism from students. one particular young lady thought it appropriate to shout out "Kray Twins" everytime i walked past (The Kray Twins are two sardar music producers who have recently been on MTV). It got to the point where i would dread going to work because there is little to nothing that could be done about it, and i'd hear people call out "kray twins" in the hallways while going about my business. Eventually i had had enough and the next time she did it, i introduced myself as a member of staff and took down her details. i took these to her tutors, had them deal with her and had an apology letter handwritten by her as well as having staff warn her that she could be thrown out. Now i walk past her as if nothing has happened and she says nothing to me. occasionally her friends will try to pass more sublte comments (such as humming the Kray Twins tune) but not as overtly as her as they know what they're in for if i were to pull any one of them up. Most of the time it can be ignored but when it gets to that point ,the only way to deal with it is to stamp your authority and show them what a fine line they are walking. let them know that you COULD have them thrown out if you were to push your case, but give a strong warning instead. show them that they cant get away with this, because as human beings nobody should have to put up with abuse because of their ethnicity or beleif. whatever you do, dont show these kids that you are losing your cool. thats what they're looking for. engage one of them in a debate and show him and his friends how small he really is. Tell him how our forefathers fought terrorists and invaders, fought in both world wars with the allies, and of the Sant Sipahi concept. frankly, put them in their place to the point where they cant say anymore. and go ahead and make personal comments. their clothes, hairstyle, handwriting, lack of intelligence, its all fair game. The most effective teachers i know can verbally rip any of their students to shreds in a second should the occasion call for it..

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

a singh · 30 May 2006

sorry makhan veer ji, tieing your beard is against gurmat.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

Makhan · 30 May 2006

Moorakh Mugad Eean "and go ahead and make personal comments. their clothes, hairstyle, handwriting, lack of intelligence, its all fair game. The most effective teachers i know can verbally rip any of their students to shreds in a second should the occasion call for it." It is easy said than done. As a teacher you cannot make comments about your pupils. You are not teaching in India and carry a cane. If a child complains about you making comments about them you will be done for this and this is true. You are a teacher you are not at their level. You have to show the difference between right and wrong. If you bring yourself to kid's level you are in no position to teach them.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

Makhan · 30 May 2006

A Singh That is what you think. Cutting or trimming is against gurmat. You are not going against Sikhi but adjusting yourself according to the environment. As when Guru Nanak Dev Ji went to Mecca even he dressed accordingly and if you do not believe read Bhai Gurdass Ji's Varran.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

a singh · 31 May 2006

Author: Makhan Date: 05-30-06 17:19 A Singh That is what you think. Cutting or trimming is against gurmat. You are not going against Sikhi but adjusting yourself according to the environment. As when Guru Nanak Dev Ji went to Mecca even he dressed accordingly and if you do not believe read Bhai Gurdass Ji's Varran ^^ your kidding me right. What difference is it to tie your beard up and leave it open, aside from the fact it is guru jis haukam. I am a tad younger then u and i never tie my beard; doesnt matter where i am going or what environment i am in.

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

singhanee · 31 May 2006

A SINGH.. who are you to say what is and what isnt according to gurmat! thats so ignorant...even if it is against gurmat.. is that a really good way of putting it.. do u think that comment.. would make anyone change ther mind?? ur not helping. i think this is the biggest problem in youth today! THAT LACK OF MANNERS!!

Re: "Oh look, its Bin Laden!"

I Singh · 31 May 2006

Ok guys, lets not start a new topic about beard tying. That is a different issue. We need to discuss the original topic because it is a very serious issue. My opinion is that Bhaji should teach grade 1-5 kids because those kids don’t act as Mr. Know-it-alls because of their innocence. They are still young can be handled much easier then the older kids in grade 6-12. If not that then college would be my suggestion. The college students are very mature minded and don’t act as childish as the highschoolers. Besides, colleges have a zero tolerance policy towards name calling.