Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Question about Bhagats

Question about Bhagats

kps · 23 Mar 2004

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAAVAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!! Many times on this forum and others, people have said that the idea that Bhagat Kabir Jee, Baba Sheikh Farid Jee, Bhagat NaamDev jee, and others were contemporaries and Sikhs of Guru Nanak, not from earlier or later times. I would like to humbly request the proof. People have said this so many times but whenever I ask, "can you please provide some evidence" the discussion stops right there and a new topic starts. Can somebody please post the proof, that in fact Bhagat Kabir Jee was a Sikh of Guru Nanak, as well as Bhagat Farid Jee and all the other Bhagats in Gurbani - Sikhs of Guru Nanak or one of the Mahalas of Guru Nanak jyot. Thank you, bhul chuk maaf karna jee, VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAAVAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!

Re: Question about Bhagats

lang · 23 Mar 2004

ya i aksed too before and no response

Re: Question about Bhagats

Kulbir Singh · 24 Mar 2004

I will try to translate parts of Giani Gurdit Singh jee's book in response to your question, KPS jeeo. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Question about Bhagats

kps · 30 Mar 2004

any updates pyareo? chardee kalaa jeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee, -daas

Re: Question about Bhagats

. · 30 Mar 2004

kulbir singh ji what time period is gianni gurdit singh ji from? and did he use any praahtan sources?

Re: Question about Bhagats

Kulbir Singh · 30 Mar 2004

Giani Gurdit Singh jee is still alive, and lives in Chandigarh. He is quite old and I pray before Vaheguru to allow him to write more. Giani jee wrote many great books and my favourites are on Bhagat Baani and on Raagmala. Another interesting book by him is "Mera Pind". In this book he has preserved the rural life of Malwa region of Punjab. Very interesting book that is. He travelled to the birthplaces of the bhagats and has researched numerous old manuscripts to arrive at the conclusion that all bhagats physically met Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and adopted him their Guru. Bhagat Kabir jee met him at Ayodhya along with other bhagats like Bhagat Ramanand jee. After this meeting he became a Sikh of Guru Sahib and accepted Naam from Siri Guru jee. I will try to translate some of the work of Giani jee soon. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Question about Bhagats

gk · 30 Mar 2004

excerpts taken from the book - "The Way To Establish Permanent Peace" Raj Jogi Sant Attar Singh Ji page 67 " IV Sheikh Farid - was a mohammedan searcher after Truth. He followed the rites and rituals of his religion and was very strict in saying his Namaz five times a day. He meditated every morning on Allah." page 68 "Bhaikan was also a mohammedan saint."

Re: Question about Bhagats

sewak · 31 Mar 2004

Gurfateh bhai Kulbir Singh where could I get buy this book mera pind and how did you get it I have been looking for it for a "long" time and couldn't get it from anywhere

Re: Question about Bhagats

benti · 12 May 2004

Bhai Kulbir Singh, any progress on that translation?

Re: Question about Bhagat Kabir

Rawindar Singh · 20 May 2004

Waheegurujikakhalsawahegurujeekifateh. My dear fellow sikhs, for the past 2 weeks I have been listening to a cassette of hymns by Bhagat Kabir. The more I listen, the more I understand his message to mankind. I went on the internet and looked into the history of the saint. One person wrote that Kabir ji did not think highly of women and actualy said in one of his verses that women stood between man and god. I find that hard to beleive. No saint would say that and if he did then why are his verses in the holy granth. Can some one please enlighten me. Thank you. Wahegurujeekakhalsawahegururjeekifateh.

Re: Question about Bhagats

Singh · 21 May 2004

There seems to be very little proof that all the Bhagats met Guru Nanak and took Amrit or Naam from him as expressed by Kulbir Singh. This whole concept appears only to occure because people can't understand how the Bhagats got to God without physicaly having Guru Nanak. Hence we get people latching onto a book while at the same time condeming other books such as by Max Macalith. A well known account for example exists of Guru Nanak meeting Sheik Ibrahim who was the successor of Bhagat Farid Ji (to make things clearer Farid Ji was not 'alive' to meet Guru Nanak). Bhagat Dhena and many other Bhagats mentioned in Guru Granth Sahib Ji such as Bhagat Prehlard clearly existed before Guru Nanaks time. Kulbir Singh you mention that according to Giani Gurdit Singh book the bhagats met Guru Nanak and were his followers yet you only mention Bhagat Kabir Ji. What does Giani Gurdit Singh book say about Bhagat Farid, Namdev, Tralochan, Bhaikan etc.

Re: Question about Bhagat Kabir

daas · 21 May 2004

could you please quote the shabads that Bhagat ji states this

Re: Question about Bhagats

S Singh · 21 May 2004

Well, I wrote the following a while back on another site concearning Bhagat Naamdev Jee. ----------------------------------------- "This is a very big misconception that many people have now a days. Not just Hindus but even some Sikhs believe in the misconception that the Bhagats were not the contemporaries of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee. This misconception was first started by the British scholar and historian Max Arthur Macauliffe a hundred years ago. Since then almost all scholars have just followed suit. Sri Bharadwaj says based on facts, ancient Marathi Granths such as “Bhaghat Rasaimat Sindhu”, “Naamdev Jeevan Charitar”, says “Guru Nanak Mahaprabhu bhagat Nanak Swami and Naam Dev met at Kumar Teerath”. That is why Bharadwaj says “Bhagat Naamdev’s time period could not have been before Guru Nanak Jee”. This opinion of Bharadwaj is based on research on old granths Naam Dev Charitar. In fact Bharadwaj has even written a book “Gyanashwar v Gyan Dev” in which he sites many sources and comes to the conclusion that “Naamdev and Guru Nanak were contemporaries. The Bhagat were honoured with the fact that they were contemporaries of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee. They were influenced by Gurmati Shabadavli, Gurmat principals, Gurmat words, and even by the Gurmantar Satnaam. Some of the Bhagats had met Sri Guru Guru Nanak Dev Jee at Ayodhya. I encourage you to please read Giani Gurdit Singh’s “Ithihas, Sri Guru Granth Sahib (Bhagat Bani Bhag)” second edition." ------------------------------ Other Bhagats whose bani is in SGGSJ were all Sikhs of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. [%sig%]

Re: Question about Bhagats

Gurvinder Singh · 21 May 2004

All the Bhagats were 100% Gurmukhs. If anyone has any doubt about this, then please consider the following facts: 1. They all write about Amrit & Naam. Amrit & Naam can only be received from Satguru - this is a fact in Gurbani. 2. They all write about Guru Sahib - which Guru do they write about, if not our very own Satguru? 3. They all had Darshan of Vaheguru - this can only ever happen by going through Satguru, as per Gurbani. 4. The Bhagats most definately met Guru Sahib. This is obvious from their Bani in Guru Granth Sahib Ji. However, Guru Sahib is eternal, always present, always has been present, so they could easily have had Darshan of Guru Sahib before 1469. Trust in the eternal truth of Gurbani, not some human's perception of history. Gurbani makes it so obvious that these Bhagats were Sikhs of Satguru Ji.

Re: Question about Bhagats

curious · 21 May 2004

was the concept of naam and amrit in asian society before sikhi?

Re: Question about Bhagats

sikh · 22 May 2004

in maculiffes book he says when Kabir was already dead when Guru Nanak Dev Ji visited that place

Re: Question about Bhagats

Singh · 24 May 2004

S.Singh The question is not if one or two of the Bhagats were contempories of Guru Nanak but all the Bhagats in SGGS. I can't believe that they were all contemporary's as this does not add up with the times they lived. If Bhagat Namdev was a contemporary of Guru Nanak surely this would be mentioned in the Jenam Sakhi’s or Bhai Gurdas Vars, considering Guru Nanaks meetings with other holy men no where on the same level as Namdev are mentioned in the Jenam Sakhi’s etc. As for Gurvinder Singh questions 1. They all write about Amrit & Naam. Amrit & Naam can only be received from Satguru - this is a fact in Gurbani. Bhagat Prehlard existed in completely a different Jug than Guru Nanak yet he is recognised in Gurbani as a Bhagat, are you suggesting he was both a high Bhagat and yet ignorant of the basic tenant of Naam? Where did Bhagat Prehlard get naam and amrit from as he obviously existed pre 1469. BTW naam has always been used, even Guru Granth Sahib Ji shows how naam was even used in the very first Jug, Satjug. 2. They all write about Guru Sahib - which Guru do they write about, if not our very own Satguru? The tenants of Gurmat have existed pre Guru Nanak as Sikhi is eternal. Guru Granth Sahib Ji makes it clear that even Gurmucks existed in Satjug, jugs before 1469. They may not have physically had Guru Nanak but still have been following the Guru as the Guru is not a physical body but the teachings and upesh. 3. They all had Darshan of Vaheguru - this can only ever happen by going through Satguru, as per Gurbani. Once again Bhagat Prehlard was on a link with God as per Gurbani, yet he existed before Guru Nanak’s time, so your question is some what conflicting. In fact Bhagats have been existing through out the ages and not just since Guru Nanak’s time “Har Jug Jug Bhagat Apaya Phaij Rakhda Aiya Ram Rajai.”

Re: Question about Bhagats

S Singh · 24 May 2004

“Singh” Jee, Actually various Janamsakhis do mention the Bhagats meeting Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Ramanand and the Bhagats time period is actually between 1500-1600 Bikrami. This is the time when Guru Nanak Dev Jee was here in bodily form i.e. 1526-1596-97 Bikrami. Bhagat Ravidas Jee was a contemporary of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Mira Bhai who lived during the reign of Mughal Emperor Akbar was a disciple of Bhagat Ravidas Jee. This in itself proves that Bhagat Ravidas Jee was a contemporary of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Mira Bhai’s time period was at the earliest 1555 BC, while some say she was born even later than 1555 BC. Bhagat Kabir Jee was also a contemporary of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. There meeting are mentioned in Granths of the Kabir Panthis. This is confirmed by the writings of the first Kabir Panthi Dharam Daas. Puraatan Granths “Kabir Mansoor” mention meetings of Guru Nanak Dev Jee and Bhagat Kabir Jee several times. Bhagat Pipa Jee was also a contemporary of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Bhagat Pipa Jee like most of the Bhagats was in the “Ramanandi Shaka”. Bhagat Pipa Jee’s nephew Anant Das Jee’s commentaries (which were written in 1645 BC) mention an important meeting between Guru Nanak Dev Jee and Bhagat Pipa Jee. Besides these, Meherwaans Janamsakhi mentions many of the Bhagats meeting Guru Nanak Dev Jee at Ayodhya. Infact there was even a Gurdwara built in the memory of this meeting hundreds of years ago which still exists today. The Bhagat who were present in this meeting were Nama (Naamdev), Jai Dev, Trilochan, Ravidas, Sadhana, Dhana, Banee. [%sig%]

Re: Question about Bhagats

Singh · 25 May 2004

S Singh, Thanks for your reply, “Actually various Janamsakhis do mention the Bhagats meeting Guru Nanak Dev Jee” Please can you give real references as I have never seen Jenam Sakhi’s which show all the Bhagats meeting Guru Nanak. Whilst we know Guru Nanak visited Ayodha and a Gurdwara exists there now we do not have any proof that he met all the Bhagats mentioned in Guru Granth Sahib Ji there. I have never read any Jenam Sakhi in which Bhagats Trilochan, Dhana, Ravidas etc held discourses with Guru Nanak, surely such a thing occurring would be recorded at least by Bhai Gurdas. What discussions are recorded of Bhagat Ravidas for example having with Guru Nanak, what updesh was given to them? If Guru Nanaks discussions with the Sidhs are recorded why aren’t his discussions and teachings to the Bhagats recorded (perhaps they never occured). Just because Guru Nanak visited Ayodha where he debated with many holy men we cannot assume that every Bhagat mentioned in Guru Granth Sahib Ji was there, and that they all became Sikhs. Just think about it, if every single Bhagat in Guru Granth Sahib Ji met Guru Nanak and became his Sikhs at Ayodha would they have not visited their Guru again for instance at Kartarpur where Guru Nanak settled. Or did they all just meet Guru Nanak once and then didn't bother to visit their Guru ever again??? This contradicts their own Bani's in Guru Granth Sahib Ji While you mention meetings with Kabir Ji and Bhagat Pipa you fail to account for the rest of the Bhagats in Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Concerning Bhagat Ravidas you have given some dates concerning his life period but no evidence for him meeting Guru Nanak. Are we to assume he was in the crowd at Ayodha; then again we can always say the Bhagats were there in the crowd in Medina, Mecca and any where else Guru Nanak went as well...

Re: Question about Bhagats

S Singh · 25 May 2004

Singh Jee Just because something is not mentioned in Bhai Gurdas Jee’s Varaa does not mean it did not occur. Bhai Gurdas Jee never accounted for every single story from Guru Jee’s life. The primary focus of Bhai Gurdas Jee’s varaa is not Janamsakhis but to describe Gurmat philosophy from Gurbani. That is why it is called the “key” to understanding Gurbani. I have already given “real” references by mentioning Granths, commemtaries, and Janamsakhis which mention Guru Nanak Dev Jee meeting with various Bhagats. For example, I mentioned Mehervaan’s Janamsakhi telling us about the meeting which occurred at Ayodhya. This Janamsakhi specifically mentions the names of the Bhagats Nama (Naamdev), Jai Dev, Trilochan, Ravidas, Sadhana, Dhana, Banee all meeting Guru Nanak Dev Jee. I told you about the commentaries written by Bhagat Pipa Jee’s nephew which also mention how Guru Nanak met with Bhagat Pipa Jee. Besides this, I have already mentioned to you that the Kabir Panthi Granths mention Guru Nanak Dev Jee meeting with Bhagat Kabir Jee. As I mentioned in my previous post, the first Kabir Panthi Dharam Daas also mentions Guru Nanak Dev Jee meeting with Bhagat Kabir Jee in his writings. Puraatan Granths “Kabir Mansoor” also confirm that this meeting did take place. I don’t understand what “real” references did I not mention to you in the first place. I had already given to you the names of men close to the Bhagats, granths mentioning these meetings. The reason I wanted to prove to you that Bhagat Ravidas Jee was a contemporary of Guru Nanak Dev Jee is because in your previous post you said they were not even contemporaries. So the reason I mentioned Mira Bhai follower of Bhagat Ravidas Jee was to prove that Bhagat Ravidas Jee was in fact a contemporary of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. As I have mentioned before in Mahervaan’s Janamsakhi, Bhagat Ravidas jee is mentioned as amongst the Bhagats who met with Guru Nanak Dev Jee at Ayodhya. Twareek Guru Khalsa (pg 80) also says “Namdev, Ravidas, Trilochan, Parsaa & Haso Rai, Dharam Daas (both followers of Kabir Ji), Nitya Nand (was a follower of Ramanand) all met Guru Jee. A Granth belonging to Ravidas Panthis mentions an interesting story in page 435” “Mardhana was with Guru Nanak Jee when visiting Banaras (Kaashi). The Brahmans and Khatris of Kaashi said to Guru Nanak Jee “You have visited that low caste Chamar Ravidas, when we (the high caste) are not even suppose to get touched by their mere shadow. Hearing this, Guru Nanak said to them: NEECHA UNDAR NEECH JAAT, NEECHI HU AT NEECH|| JITHAY TIN KAY SANG SAAT, VADIYA SIO KIA REES|| JITHAY JEECH SAMALIAN, THITHAY NADIR TERI BAKSHISH|| (siri raag M, 1 -15) All this proves that the Bhagats whose Bani is in Guru Granth Sahib Jee were not only contemporaries of Guru Nanak Dev Jee, but had met Guru Nanak Dev Jee personally. [%sig%]

Re: Question about Bhagats

S Singh · 25 May 2004

Also Singh, I would like to point out to you that the Gurdwara I mentioned at Ayodhya was not constructed because Guru Nanak Dev Jee merely visited that area, but was constructed in the memory of the historic meeting that took place between the Bhagats and Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Similarly, Panja Sahib was not constructed because Guru Nanak Dev Jee merely visited that area, but because of the event that took place there i.e. the story of Guru Nanak Dev Jee stopping a huge bolder with this hand.

Re: Question about Bhagats

Singh · 26 May 2004

S Singh You have repeated your previous message, but still the questions I raised hasnot been answered. Surely if they met Guru Nanak once they would have endeavoured to meet him again and again, if indeed they were his Sikhs. Perhaps they did not want or need to get more updesh. If they were Sikhs why would they only meet the Guru once. BTW Twareek Guru Khalsa can hardly be taken as a source from the time of the Bhagats. It's also interesting is how Mahervaan’s Janamsakhi appears to be the only Jenam Sakhi which mentions this meeting, surely such an important meeting have been mentioned in other Jenam Sakhi’s? The Gurdwara at Ayodhya is certainly in memory of Guru Ji visiting the place and holding discussions with a gathering of holy men, if all the Bhagats were actually there is another question. “All this proves that the Bhagats whose Bani is in Guru Granth Sahib Jee were not only contemporaries of Guru Nanak Dev Jee, but had met Guru Nanak Dev Jee personally.” You haven’t mentioned Bhagat Farid for instance, as I have said before there’s an account of Guru Nanak meeting Shiek Ibrahim, the successor to Bhagat Farid Ji.

Re: Question about Bhagats

S Singh · 26 May 2004

Singh, the reason I had to remind you of what I wrote in my previous post is because you just repeated the same questions which were answered in my previous post. As for why did the Bhagats just meet the Guru once, they could have met more then once, the point is “they met”. I only pointed out to you that they met because you claimed they did not even meet. I provided references from puraatan Janamsakhis and commentaries mentioning the Bhagats who met with Guru Nanak Dev Jee because you said there are no Janamsakhis saying they even met with each other. Singh wrote: >“BTW Twareek Guru Khalsa can hardly be taken as a source from the time of the Bhagats. It's also interesting is how Mahervaan’s Janamsakhi appears to be the only Jenam Sakhi which mentions this meeting, surely such an important meeting have been mentioned in other Jenam Sakhi’s?”< -Singh, did you even read my previous post? Because it seems you have either not read it, or are choosing to ignore my points. Twareek Guru Khalsa is an old source, and shows that puraatan Singhs did view the Bhagats as Sikhs of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Anyway, If you want other puraatan sources fine. In a Puraatan Granth “Guru Ravidas” written by Prithi Azaad mentions on PG 42 another meeting between Guru Nanak Dev Jee and Bhagat Ravidas Jee, this meeting took place at 1555 according to the Granth. So now, I have provided three separate puraatan sources other than Twareek Guru Khalsa all saying that Guru Nanak Dev Jee met with Bhagat Ravidas Jee (Meherwaan’s Janamsakhi, Ravidas Panthi Granth Pg 435, “guru Ravidas” Pg 42). Singh wrote: >“The Gurdwara at Ayodhya is certainly in memory of Guru Ji visiting the place and holding discussions with a gathering of holy men, if all the Bhagats were actually there is another question.”< -The fact that a story about Guru Nanak Dev Jee meeting with Bhagat Ravidas Jee is linked to that Gurdwara is sufficient proof that the Gurdwara was built in the memory of the meeting. It is not another question as I have already provided a puraatan source backed up by a scholar who also confirms my point that the Bhagats met with Guru Nanak Dev Jee at Ayodhya, unless you could provide any puraatan sources like I have which might convince me other wise. >“You haven’t mentioned Bhagat Farid for instance, as I have said before there’s an account of Guru Nanak meeting Shiek Ibrahim, the successor to Bhagat Farid Ji.”< -Baba Farid Jee whose bani is in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is that of Farid Sani, and not the Baba Farid the Afghan who lived during the 12th century. Bhagat Farid Jee’s bani is the biggest proof of him being a contemporary of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Even the present head of Baba Farid Jee’s spiritual order Prof. Khalil Nizami says the bani in Guru Granth Sahib Jee is that of Farid Sani. Bhai Vir Singh Jee, Prof. Teja Singh Jee, and Budh Singh all agree to this opinion that the Bani written in Guru Granth Sahib jee is that of Farid Sani the contemporary of Guru Nanak Dev Jee, and not Baba Farid the Afghan who lived during the 12th century. The proof of Baba Farid Jee meeting Guru Nanak Dev Jee is his Bani. Fareed Jee writes: JO GUR DASAY WAATH MUREEDA JOLEA|| (Asa sheikh farid 477) KAR KIRPA PRAB SAADHSANG MELEE|| (Farid soohi 794) Muslim sufis never use words such as “Gur”, “Saadh” or "Prabh". According to a book written by Prof. Khalil Nizami spiritual head of Baba Farid Jee’s spiritual order these words were written by Farid Sani because he was heavily influenced by Guru Nanak Dev jee, this is confirmed by the writer of "Swanay Farid". [%sig%]

Re: Question about Bhagats

Sparkler · 26 May 2004

small point, bhagats could have only met guru sahib once physically on this plane, but many many times in other places I know many gursikhs who know each other intimately and have never met physically due to distance. perhaps guru sahib sent them out to do parchar in places guru sahib did not have the time to travel as he was busy travelling the world.

Re: Question about Bhagats

Good Point · 26 May 2004

Good point Sparkler. But as S SIngh is proven, it seems the Bhagats have also met Guru Nanak Dev Jee atleast once in their lifetime.

Re: Question about Bhagats

Singh · 27 May 2004

I understand that Farid Ji uses words such as Gur or Saadh but these are not limited to any group, sufi or not. Farid Ji also uses words which other Bhagats never use, so what. Is there any proof of Farid Ji in your own words “had met Guru Nanak Dev Jee personally.” . “I provided references from puraatan Janamsakhis” Actually you have only referred to one Jenam Sakhi, and other Jenam Sakhi’s don’t support it. Concerning Bhagat Ravidas Ji you have produced also Ravidas Panthi Granth Pg 435, “guru Ravidas” Pg 42 which are not Jenam Sakhi’s but support the idea of Bhagat Ravidas meeting Guru Nanak. Please would you provide Jenam Sakhi’s to prove a meeting between Farid Sani (Bhagat Farid Ji) and other references as like with Bhagat Ravidas Ji.

Re: Question about Bhagats

S Singh · 27 May 2004

Singh, I don’t understand what logic of argument you are trying to use. The sources I have mentioned are ancient Granths that contain the stories of the respective Saints. Please define the word “Janamsakhi” because it seems you are confused as to what this word really means. As for Bhagat Farid Jee, in Pakistan the present spiritual head of Baba Farid Jee’s dera or spiritual order Prof, Khalil Nizami says Farid Sani was heavily influenced by Guru Nanak Dev Jee (or as they say “Baba Nanak”), and according him that is why he uses non-islamic terms like “Gur”, Saadh, and “Prabh”. I believe Prof. Khalil Nizami unless you could provide someone of the same caliber who says otherwise. [%sig%]

Re: Question about Bhagats

kaur · 27 May 2004

I think that S. Singh has provided ample proof of the bhagats having met guru ji, while all Singh has done is to say he needs more proof. He has not given any proof that the bhagats did not meet guru ji. So I think if he wants to refute the points made by S. Singh, than that makes sense, but to keep asking for more proof when so much is already given does not really seem all that beneficial.

Re: Question about Bhagats

Lakhbir Singh · 27 May 2004

Good points S. Singh. I never knew the Bhagat were Sikhs of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. "SIngh" you have not provided any satisfactory argument to refute S Singh. All you are using is “I need more proof, I need more proof”. Perhaps you should also provide some “proof” like S Singh has to support your argument.

Re: Question about Bhagats

Samrath Singh · 28 May 2004

S.Singh Concerning Farid Ji you really have not provided any proof of him meeting Guru Nanak. I mean for Bhagat Ravi Das Ji meeting Guru Nanak you've quoted Ravidas Panthi Granth Pg 435, “guru Ravidas” Pg 42, but have provided no such references for Bhagat Farid Ji meeting Guru Nanak. Are the words of Prof, Khalil Nizami saying Farid Sani was heavily influenced (which is not the same as meeting) by Guru Nanak Dev Jee and the fact that Farid Ji used words like Gur the whole bases of your argument that Bhagat Farid Ji met Guru Nanak? Can't you provide proof like the ones mentioned for Bhagat Ravidas Ji, as if thats all you have we cannot realistically say Farid Ji met Guru Nanak. Also do you know why none of the Bhagats bani's in Guru Granth Sahib Ji are in any of the granths kept by the bhagats followers? The Bhagats granths don't contain the Bhagats bani in Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

Re: Question about Bhagats

S Singh · 28 May 2004

Samrath Singh or Singh, To begin with, out of all the Bhagat, Baba Farid Jee who not only lived during the times of Guru Nanak Dev Jee, but also lived the shortest distance to Nankana Sahib. Geographically, he was the closest Bhagat to Guru Nanak Dev Jee. It’s difficult to believe that they could not have met especially since that is also what the present day followers of Baba Farid Jee say as well in Pakistan. -Since you want proof from Janamsakhis, then ponder on the following Janamsakhi which mentions Guru Jee meeting with Farid Jee: SRI GURU BABA AUTHOU CHALIA| RAAVI CHANOU DEKH KAR AUJARH PAI CHALIA| PATTAN DESH AIE NIKALIA| PATTAN TO KOS TIN AUJARH THI, AUTHAY AIE BAITHAA| MARDANA NAAL AAHA, PATTAN DHA PIR SHEIKH FARID THA TISKAY TAKHT SHEIKH BRAM (IBRAHIM) THA| (Puraatan Janam Sakhi) -Besides this Janamsakhi, another Janamsakhi by the name of “Meherban Vali Janamsakhi” tells of a story of when Baba Farid jee once went to collect wood and there he also ran into Guru Nanak Dev Jee reciting the following Gurbani Tukhs: APAY PATTEE KALAM AAP, UPAR LEKH BHI THU|| EKO KAHIAE NANAKAA, DOOJA KAHAY KOO|| (Malar dhi vaar M: 1 -1291) -Another Janamsakhi which is now safely at Guru Nanak Dev University taken from the UK also mentions a meeting between Guru Nanak Dev Jee and Baba Farid jee. -Another Janamasakhi, Bhai Mani Singh Jee vali Janamsakhi mentions a meeting between Guru Nanak Dev Jee and Baba Farid Jee. I have given names of four different Janamsakhis all mentioning Baba Farid jee meeting with Guru Nanak Dev Jee.

Re: Question about Bhagats

Gupt Singh · 28 May 2004

>>>>>>>Also do you know why none of the Bhagats bani's in Guru Granth Sahib Ji are in any of the granths kept by the bhagats followers? The Bhagats granths don't contain the Bhagats bani in Guru Granth Sahib Ji.<<<<<<<< Perhaps they got Gyan From Guru NAnak Dev ji, and the Bani written AFTER the meeting, was written in Guru Granth Sahib ji`? bhull chukk maaf VAHEGUROO JEE KA KHALSA VAHEGUROO JEE KI FATEH!!!

Re: Question about Bhagats

Kulbir Singh · 28 May 2004

Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh! I just want to add to what S. Singh has written about Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj meeting Baba Farid jee. The original Baba Farid lived about 300 years prior to Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Here are some of the points to be noted with respect to him: 1) All Pakistani scholars agree that this Baba Farid jee did not write any baani at all. He was not a poet. 2) He was not a native of Punjab and as such could not have written such purely native countryside Punjabi. It is like asserting that Shakespeare was not English but a German writer. A non-English person could not have written what Shakespeare wrote. Same way, a non-Punjabi could not have written the kind of Punjabi that is in Gurbani under Baba Farid jee name. 3) The Punjabi used in Baba Farid jee’s baani in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is of the same time as Guru Nanak Sahib jee. All linguistics agree to this. If this baani had been written 300 years before Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee, it would have been drastically different. Just compare the Punjabi written today to Punjabi of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee’s times. 4) Farid Shakarganj i.e. the Senior Farid, was a staunch Muslim who converted thousands of Hindus to Islam. He was very strict in Sharia and he would have never used non-Islamic words like “Saadh” in his baani. Now the question arises that if the baani in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee was not written by Baba Farid Shakarganj then who is the writer of this baani? The answer is very simple. As written in the Janamsaakhis, the writer of this baani was Farid Saani, who was sitting on the gaddi of the original Farid. His name was Sheikh Ibrahim but he was also known as Farid Saani and it was he who met Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. It is this Sheikh Ibrahim, whose spiritual thirst was quenched by Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. He wrote the following shabad to Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee: soohee lalith || baerraa ba(n)dhh n sakiou ba(n)dhhan kee vaelaa || . bhar saravar jab ooshhalai thab tharan dhuhaelaa ||1|| hathh n laae kasu(n)bharrai jal jaasee dtolaa ||1|| rehaao || eik aapeenhai pathalee seh kaerae bolaa || dhudhhaa thhanee n aavee fir hoe n maelaa ||2|| kehai fareedh sehaeleeho sahu alaaeaesee || ha(n)s chalasee ddu(n)manaa ahi than dtaeree thheesee ||3||2|| This shabad of Baba Farid jee portrays the thirst of Baba jee very clearly. He is literally begging for spirituality. In response to this shabad, Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee wrote the following shabad: soohee mehalaa 1 || jap thap kaa ba(n)dhh baerrulaa jith la(n)ghehi vehaelaa || naa saravar naa ooshhalai aisaa pa(n)thh suhaelaa ||1|| thaeraa eaeko naam ma(n)jeet(h)arraa rathaa maeraa cholaa sadh ra(n)g dtolaa ||1|| rehaao || saajan chalae piaariaa kio maelaa hoee || jae gun hovehi ga(n)t(h)arreeai maelaegaa soee ||2|| miliaa hoe n veeshhurrai jae miliaa hoee || aavaa goun nivaariaa hai saachaa soee ||3|| houmai maar nivaariaa seethaa hai cholaa || gur bachanee fal paaeiaa seh kae a(n)mrith bolaa ||4|| naanak kehai sehaeleeho sahu kharaa piaaraa || ham seh kaereeaa dhaaseeaa saachaa khasam hamaaraa ||5||2||4|| He cries that “bhar Sarvar jabb uchhalai, tabb taran dulela” but Guru Baba jee says “Na sarvar na uchhalai, aisa panth suhela”. He says that his spiritual path is very hard but Siri Guru jee says that the Gurmat path is very easy and full of bliss. He says "BeRa bandh na sakhiyo" Siri Guru jee says, "Jap tap ka bandh beRla". He says that he has not been able to build his ship to swim across this ocean of world. Siri Guru jee says that if he has not build it yet, then he can now build the ship of Jap-Tap. What a great shabad Siri Guru jee's is! Just amazing. This shabad is most beautiful. I wish some gursikh sing this shabad and I may just listen to it till eternity. Just compare the two shabads and no one can deny that one was written in response to the other one. After hearing Siri Guru jee’s shabad, Farid Saani jee became disciple of Guru Nanak Paatshaah. There is no doubt about it. Sirii Guru jee and he met 3 times in total. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Question about Bhagats

sikh · 29 May 2004

can i just say something....... the more we question and the more we want to know..... leads only further from the truth of Guru Granth Sahib Ji......... we get caught up in all these questions and answers........ just read bani do simran and sewa and the answers will be revealed....... this path of knowledge is in my opinion dangerous

Re: Question about Bhagats

Gianiji’s web sewak · 18 Jun 2004

Sat Sri Akal ji I happened to come across this discussion. There is a Website dedicated to Giani Gurdit Singh ji, which has information about him and his books, which can even be ordered online. The book "Mera Pind" is being reprinted and will be available within a month. It has been typeset, and has two additional chapters, which were in the first edition (that dates back to 1961), and have been added again, after 5 editions. More information on this and other books available from http://www.gianigurditsingh.com Giani ji is busy working on his series on "Ithias Sri Guru Granth Sahib", of which two have been published. They are "Itihaas Sri Guru Granth Sahib: Mundavani" and "Itihaas Sri Guru Granth Sahib: Bhagat Bani Bhag" Because of his delicate health and preoccupations with the books he is writing, he is not available to answer individual inquiries, though they would help to shape the website and will be shared with him. Information on the site is available for all. Gianiji’s web sewak [%sig%]

Re: Question about Bhagats

Mkhalsa · 18 Jun 2004

Singho, will "Itihaas Sri Guru Granth Sahib: Mundavani" be translated into english anytime soon? Please put this request in for it to be translated.