Re: Women and honour!
Jagvinder Singh · 26 May 2006
dear ? , i dont know where you dreamt tt from, but no she did not. mata gujri ji gave birth to sahib sri guru gobind singh ji, the king of kings. she wouldnt even dream of doing something like that. jumping off a building... you out of your mind bro?, you're talking about our grandmother here. her spirit left her physical body for sachkhand upon knowing that she had served her purpose on earth by teaching the younger sahibzadas how to takraa with death.
please dont ever post anything like that, its very upsetting.
[%sig%]
Re: Women and honour!
Harcharan Singh · 27 May 2006
Vahe-Guru ji ka Khalsa Vahe-Guru ji ki Fat-heh
Just to correct a point above, Mata Gujri did not commit suicide, she breathed her last during meditation and hearing of the shaheedi of her beloved ones - Akaal Purkh called her back and preserved her honour, she had completed her objective of supporting her divine grandsons through their testing time.
Although it is a horrible scenario, probably the worst for Sikhs, I personally believe we should look at our Guru Sahiban and all the shaheed for answers.
They all went through their tortures, tortures which are incomparable in cruelty terms, but accepted them and Akaal Purkhs hukum with Vahe-Guru on their breath.
This single point I feel provides the answers.
There are people who will talk of the partition and and 1984.. which were very dark periods in our history, and ones where some Sikh women did commit suicide. Obviously we cannot relate to their pain and situation in any way, and it is not for us to judge their actions, they made their decisions under the worst conditions and only Vahe-Guru can judge them.
But again, I will mention Sikh women of the old who chose to fight, these are the blessed and enlightened souls we should look to as role models.
Bibi Baag Kaur (Mai Bhago), Bibi Gur-Sharan Kaur (who cremated the elder sahibzadey), Bibi Ranjit Kaur (who fought and killed 2 Mughal soldiers), Shaheed Bibi Prem Kaur (of Nowshera battle), Bibi Deep Kaur to name but a few...
Please see the following for more examples:
http://allaboutsikhs.com/women/
As per Guru Gobind Singhs instructions, all Sikhs, including women, should be shasterdhari, and have some Shaster Vidya.
All should carry a kirpan and know how to use it.
If God ever put's you in the worst case scenario, then we listen to our father Guru Gobind Singh to learn how to die:
Dayh Shiva bar mohe ehai, subh karman tay kabhoon na taro. Na daro ar so jab jaa-e laro, nischai kar apanee jeet karo. Ar sikh ho aapnay hee man hau, eh lalach hao gun tao ucharo. Jab aav kee a-odh nidhaan banai, at hee ran mai tab joojh maro. 231. (Guru Gobind Singh)
Give me this boon Lord, that I never refrain from righteous deeds. That I have no fear when fighting the enemy, That I attain victory with faith and fortitude, That I keep your teachings close to my mind. Lord, my desire is that I sing your praises and when the end of this life draws near, may I die fighting, with limitless courage in the battlefield.
Re: Women and honour!
Jasdeep Singh · 27 May 2006
I don't believe suicide is the answer. Some times even Strict Amrithdhari women can be in this situation at no fault of thier own ie comming home from work etc. Rap is not the victims fault, that is why they are called victims. I truley beleive that you should learn ways to defend your self, carry a kirpan, and learn self defence tactics so that you can protect yourself. When that Bibi was saying that her "husband told her to kill herself to protect her honur", the husband really was protecting his honur not hers, and he is telling his wife that her life is not valuable and that he can't live with the shame. No one would ever tell a Singh to kill himself to protect his hounor if it were revresed somehow. This is a double standard, so NO do not commint suicide and do defend your self fully non stop, and if that thing should ever happen then one must look to Guru ji and find inner strength to carry on. I beleive all things happen for a reason, and I hope that more women read this post and understand taht suicide is not the answer it is thier families answer to rap so they can tell people that she was "strong" and not be shamed by others. When really they should understand and provide support. Strengh is not giving up, it is when a person carrys on and puts all their love and devotion to Guru ji. Just my view, I strongly beleive in equal rights and such and beside suicide is sin.
Re: Women and honour!
waste of time · 27 May 2006
wateva ppl....just because u have a conversation with someone of the opposite sex...does notr make you a flirt or slapper...an certainly does not justify saying you have no honour to protect..
That conversation could be sikhi orrientated....and the joking around is fine ...were not saints we have our lows those jokes with sangat could be what helps us stay strong in sikhi wen we down.....to call someone bhaj is such huge respect and pyar...dont cus peoples love and respect just cause u dont understand it...
no affence but the person that sed "girls justify it by calling guys there brothers"....obviously dont now what a brother means....no affence mr singh but id hate to be your sister
if you dont want to chat to your sisters then dont...but dont look down on your sisters for chattin to there brothers
i have many brothers and sisters who help me through my highs and lows...i would call my best friend my brother....maharaj nows he has helped me throuh the worst of times, iv never seen him as anything other than my bro....never needed to...i get so much pyar from him being my big bro....y wud he ever need to be anything else....beleve everything with a true heart ...maharaj nows....
i no some ppl badnaam the relatuionship of brother and sister....doesnt mean we kill that relationship...we should sort the ppl that badnaam it....WHICH IS NOT EVERY1...mite be hard...but thats wat needs to be done....
u never now wat chardi kalla gursikh maharaj will send you as sangat...guy or gal...id rather have a wicked ck bro as my sangat than a not so ck sister or mayb even no gud sangat at all...
vaheguru....sori 4 mistakes....
vaheguru
[%sig%]
Re: Women and honour!
Kulbir Singh · 31 May 2006
This is a very complex topic. Only women can really answer this question. Here is what I can say based on my lowly intelligence:
1) Guru jee’s daughter, who has taken amrit, should be fit enough to defend herself. She should die fighting than lose her honour. This is the ideal option. Die fighting, rather then letting anyone violate you. Bhai Sahib writes in one of his books that a Chardi Kala waali Bibi, who is full in rehit and Gurmat, cannot lose her honour. Dropadi’s honour was saved. She was about to be stripped off her clothes when Akal Purakh saved her. She was saved because she called out to Akal Purakh. If a chardi kala waali Gurmukh Bibi calls out to Siri Guru Dasmesh jee, wouldn’t her honour be saved? Rehitdhaari, Dastaardhaari Gurmukh Bibi is million times more dear to Guru Sahib than Panchaali (Drupadi). How would her honour not get protected by Guru Sahib, provided she calls out to her father - Siri Guru Kalgidhar Paatshaah?
2) In case a Bibi is not in position to fight back, my personal inclination is that it is better to give your life than letting a filthy Manmukh violated your body. In the past brave Rajput bibiyaan like Rani Padmini of Chittor along with hundreds of other Rajput women, did Jauhar (sacrificing life than losing honour). In 1947, thousands of Sikh Bibiyaan repeated this Jauhar in Rawalpindi area. Their argument was that if they are caught alive, they will be severely violated by many Pakistani beasts and will be sold to brothels afterwards. To avoid this dishonour, they committed Jauhar.
3) Some Gursikhs claim that Bibiyaan should accept bhaana and get violated instead of doing Jauhar. I know suicide is against Gurmat but letting a manmukh touch your body is not Gurmat either.
In the end, its up to Bibiyaan to decide what they want to do. The first option seems best to me.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Women and honour!
Tarrandeep Kaur · 31 May 2006
oh dear me, i cant believe bhai kulbir singh has jus said that. i have always respected his views and his rehit. but to say its ok for a bibi to take their life..........................tut tut that cant be rite....
tera keea meeTHa laagai har naam padaarath naamak maangai.
i say fight till your last breath, always remeber vahiguru, but never kill yourself.
Re: Women and honour!
Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 31 May 2006
VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurujeeKeeFateh
FIGHT BACK! And don’t ever think of committing SUICIDE protect your honour by doing what GURU JEE would want you to do, not what your mind wishes. KHALSA was created to protect the honour of religion, others and your own.
There is no difference between a man and female, and in this way a brother isn't always there to protect their sister, so the sister shouldn't rely on another to protect her.
Let me tell you one thing, Naam, Vaheguru, will be there to protect you if you're there for him.
The religion Sikhi was created out of Naam, and so if everything Guru Jee has commanded us to do through his rehitnamas, Hukamnanas, and teachings, essentially Naam, Amritvela, nitnem, Kakaars, and other gurbania, then no one in this world can touch you and destroy your honour.
You may think everything I’ve said sounds like a joke, and perhaps unrealistic, but other females that have been saved (Dropadi, as stated by Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Jee) by Vaheguru Jee, wouldn’t see this as a joke.
In this Dark Age Vaheguru Jee has made evil strong and an age where there’s less happenings of miracles or gods saving you, but an age where nothing of the sort seems possible and if someone does come into such a situation where a man holds a knife at you and has something disgusting lurking in his plans, then nothing at that time probably would seem possible.
Due to this reason of killing, suffering, raping, INJUSTICE, Guru Gobind Singh Jee created you, YES YOU, a Gursikh that does not fear such things, and is ready to put up a fight even if there’s countless beasts before your very eyes.
I know what I’ve said sounds as if it’s easier said then done, but you yourself ARE THE KIRPAN, the kirpan represents honour, courage, dignity and power, and that is you. If you think you’re not strong enough and you’re not this KIRPAN then you should do a LOT MORE NAAM BHAGTI. Until you become this KIRPAN.
What I’m saying isn’t a joke, but something that every Gursikh has to do right NOW!!
This age is going to become even worse then it was, and is now.
This KIRPAN will only be attained by JAPPING SO MUCH OF NAAM. USE MOST OF YOUR TIME BIBI SAHIB JEEO TO JAP NAAM, AND READ A LOT OF GURBANIA. DO BEBEK TO HELP YOU GET CLOSER TO VAHEGURU JEE.
VAHEGURU, VAHEGURU, VAHEGURU VAHEGURU VAHEGURU VAHEGURU
Sat Sri Akaal
Re: Women and honour!
Harcharan Singh · 01 Jun 2006
Veer Kulbir ji has given his thoughts and set out a list of options.
These options may hold true for women in general, but not for sikh women.
As per the examples given in my previous post of "Gursikh" bibiyaan, suicide is not an option.
If a women lives as per Guru Gobind singh Ji's instructions, she is under his protection and "guidance", thus is shasterdaari, hence need only refer to option 1.
If a woman does, she is not a Sikh, and then other options are open to her.
We need to differentiate between who this advice is being given to.
If a women is fighting with a sword, capturing her alive is not going to be on the attackers mind, trying to save his own life and finish her off will be at the forefront of his thought.
Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj clearly asnwers this question - and it applies to all his sons and daughters:
Jab aav kee a-odh nidhaan banai, at hee ran mai tab joojh maro
Vahe-Guru
Vahe-Guru
Re: Women and honour!
Amarjeet singh · 01 Jun 2006
kulbir singh jio
to suggest that suicide is ever acceptable is not gurmat.
not gurmat at all
Re: Women and honour!
Kulbir Singh · 01 Jun 2006
Dear Gursikhs Veers and Bhains who corrected me,
I probably have given the wrong advice by suggesting that women who cannot fight back should commit Jauhar rather than letting filthy manmukhs violate their bodies. I stated my personal inclination and not necessarily Gurmat advice. Therefore, I take back my comments made in option 2 in my previous post.
Saadh Sangat jeeo maaf karna. Bhul chuk dee maafi jee.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Women and honour!
Khalsa Fauj · 01 Jun 2006
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
being a singhnee myself i'd never be able to live with myself after losing my honor. guru sahib says...sachahu oraay sabh ko uppar sach aachaar.
first of all, a girl should never put herself in position like that. it will be highly unlikely if we just be careful and avoid putting ourselves in a situation where a rape is likely to happen. for a sikh amritdhari bibi it is nearly impossible. i can picture someone in a nightclub, out on the street at night, is probably inviting a rape, although that is not all the possiblities, a singhnee will never be in a place like that, or atleast she shouldn't...neways...you asked if it is worth killing yourself . I think it is. singhnees are a foundation of any nation and dishonoring a singhnee is a dishonor of the whole nation. if one's going to die once, die with integrity and honor.
I agree with whoever above said that you should kill the person trying to rape you. yes, i'd rather die saving myself from a shameful dishonor like that. dont get me wrong, i really feel sorry for those bibias who have to go through that, honor might not be as valuable to a non-sikh (or an atheist) person and yah they claim that they have come out stronger, but for a sikh bibi or rather the whole sikh nation honor is everything. and we should do everything possible to save it.
just my two cents.
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
[%sig%]
Re: Women and honour!
Agreed with Maninder · 02 Jun 2006
Maninder have the answere.....
Courage and Inspiration for Sikh Women
Harcharan Singh · 04 Jun 2006
Some inspiring stories of brave Sikh women of the old...
http://www.gurunanakdarbar.net/NobleandBravesikhwomen.pdf
http://allaboutsikhs.com/women/
This is an excellent blog for bibbiyan...
http://dedicatedkaurs.blogspot.com/2006_01_01_dedicatedkaurs_archive.html