Re: WHY did the guru....
Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 29 May 2006
VaheguruJeeKaakhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh
Don't believe anything you hear or see from whoever it is, a baba or anyone else.
Why do you even need to have doubts about our Guru Jee? Clear it and do more Naam Bhagti - this subject is a waste of breath, as it just involves horrible doubts, which is something we shouldn't be having (in which Gurbani states), especially about our GURU. They all had one wife, but Indians, Muslims, anyone else will try and do whatever they can to give themselves a better advantage, or a satisfication of their needs. They will do whatever they can to prove it through lies.
Having more then one wife is WRONG and AGAINST GURMAT.
DON'T QUESTION YOUR GURU; TRUST THEM. DO NAAM BHAGTI TO CLEAR YOUR DOUBTS. Vaheguroooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Sat Sri Akaal
Re: WHY did the guru....
Heera Singh · 29 May 2006
Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!
from what I've heard Guru Gobind Singh Jee only had one wife ..as said above, mata sundri and mata jeeto were the same person... Mata Sahib Kaur is the mother of the Khalsa, she was directly wedded to Guru Jee.. She said she would not marry anybody and wanted to be with Guru Jee, but Guru Jee said he was already married... he said you can't be my wife, but you can be the mother of the Khalsa... it was at the first Amrit Sanchar where Mata Sahib Kaur Jee putt the pattasay in ... that is why she is called mother of tha Khalsa... therefore she was not Guru Jee's "wife"... Mata Sundri/Jeeto was the only wife of Guru Gobind Singh Jee..!!
Chardi Kalaa!
Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!
Re: WHY did the guru....
Jaspaul Singh · 30 May 2006
Bundha ji ..
Those can be your views.. but where is the proof ? we can demand proof for everything but the truth we can NEVER know cuz of how india is .. there are key people that are set out to dominate/eliminate/break our sikh religion.. and since we are a minority in india, we are being stepped on everywhere.. its not very hard to change history when your living in a country you had a terrible past with ..
Like the hindu/muslim religion .. sikh religion has been changed again and again by people who have nothing else to do but throw in faults..
My guru was perfect.. he still is perfect in dhan guru granth sahib ji .. lets all focus on more important things in our life including naam simran and seva .. believe in your heart that guru ji was the one and only supreme .. ask for darshan .. pray to be shown the truth ..
vaheguroo ..
Re: WHY did the guru....
anotha theory · 01 Jun 2006
I have heard that Mata Ajit Kaur (Mata Jeeto) and Mata Sundari was the same person... also it was Mata Ajit Kaur that put the patasai in the baataa (i have neva heard the punj piaaray having put them in)...
At this time Mata Sahib Kaur wasn't even on the scene.... Mata Ji met Guru Gobind Singh Ji a few years down the line after 1699... As in many cases before , (eg Guru Hargobind Singh ji), Mata Sahib Kaur fell in love with guru ji and wanted to get married and be the mother of his children, however, since Guru ji was already married he said no, but said she will be the mother of all his children, i.e. the Khalsa,.... that is why Mata Sahib Kaur is the mother of the Khalsa....
I have heard many kathakaar portray the happenings as above....
Bhul chuk maaf...
ps Even though I agree that whateva happened back then whether the guru's had more than one wife or not, we cant deny the fact that guru sahibs were PERFECT. However, we should discuss these things since there should be a consensus over the whole panth in terms of what happened.... it doesnt sound good if one Sikh is saying one thing and the other another... but i suppose we do that on more important things than just the life stories of guru maharaaj... oh well, all we can do is ardaas for better giaan and do more naam simran...