Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

WHY did the guru....

WHY did the guru....

P walla!! · 28 May 2006

Wjkk WJkf Piyari sadh sangat ji....daas was reading a book on the gurus and had come across some interesting paragraphs. ..Some years after his release Guru Hargobind Sahib ji was wedded to Mata Damodari, but then she had passed away, mahraj ji then got married to Mata Devi the daughter of Bhai Davara and Mata Bhagan but then mahraj had a third wife, Bibi Nanaki, (do not mistake this for the Bibi Nanaki in Guru Nanak dev jis times). Gurrrroo Also maharaj passed away and became one with akhal purakh on the 3rd of march 1644, was this natural death, mahraj was 49 years old when becoming one with waheguroo! Guru Har Rai ji was then given the Gaddi…Mahraj ji was wedded to Kishan Kaur in 1647 and then a second marriage took place with Kot Kliani and became the mother of Ram Rai. Finally Guru Gobind Singh ji was engaged with Mata Jito ji and later on wedded to Mata Sundari and Mata Sahib Dewan. Why was this??? Why did the Great Gurus have more then one wives..!!! Sangat ji daas would like to comment here that…we should have full faith in our gurus and not question what they do as they were complete!! BUT also saying that it is important we know about our Gurus History…daas is only asking this question because of some ‘Sikhs that have more then one wife’ use the above comments an excuse and reply…If the Gurus can have three wives then why cant I?? We need a strong answer to this and not just say we can not do what the gurus did!! There must be a stronger answer…!! Forgive any mistakes as you are the humble sangat! Gurrrrrrrrroooooooooo Wjkk WJkf

Re: WHY did the guru....

no. · 28 May 2006

the gurus didnt have more than one wife its important to make sure you dont believe everything you read the majority of the accounts about our gurus are innacurate and have no supporting evidence, and have been passed down by word of mouth... so not accurate our gurus did not have more than 1 wife

Re: WHY did the guru....

no. · 28 May 2006

btw mata sundari and mata jito are the same she was called jito by her parents, but mata gujri changed her name to sundari coz she was so beautiful people say guru gobind singh ji "married" mata sahib kaur, but she was not a wife really, she was a sevadar of the khalsa.so she "Married" guruji to do seva for the khalsa

Re: WHY did the guru....

Sardar · 28 May 2006

Guru Gobind Singh Ji Mahaaraaj's Wife's(Our Mother) Original Name is Maataa Saheb Kaur Ji. People called her other names in signs of respect. And our Gurus never ever had more than one wife(unless if there was a reason).

Re: WHY did the guru....

..... · 28 May 2006

guru gobind singh jee had 3 wifes i think...after the 1st one had past away

Re: WHY did the guru....

unsure · 28 May 2006

i'm also confused on this issue. baba gurbachan singh bhindrawale (i think in khalsa rehat maryada) and bhai kahn singh nabha in mahan kosh both say guru hargobind ji, guru har rai & guru gobind singh ji had more than one wife & name all the wives & their families. i remember looking into this a couple of years ago, but i could not find any real historical evidence to say that these gurus had just one wife. i don't think that it's right for a sikh today to have more than one wife, but if the gurus did it they must have had a good reason for it. & i'm nowhere near the same level as baba gurbachan singh or bhai kahn singh ji so i can't say they're wrong. that's why i'm confused!

Re: WHY did the guru....

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 29 May 2006

VaheguruJeeKaakhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Don't believe anything you hear or see from whoever it is, a baba or anyone else. Why do you even need to have doubts about our Guru Jee? Clear it and do more Naam Bhagti - this subject is a waste of breath, as it just involves horrible doubts, which is something we shouldn't be having (in which Gurbani states), especially about our GURU. They all had one wife, but Indians, Muslims, anyone else will try and do whatever they can to give themselves a better advantage, or a satisfication of their needs. They will do whatever they can to prove it through lies. Having more then one wife is WRONG and AGAINST GURMAT. DON'T QUESTION YOUR GURU; TRUST THEM. DO NAAM BHAGTI TO CLEAR YOUR DOUBTS. Vaheguroooo!!!!!!!!!!!!! Sat Sri Akaal

Re: WHY did the guru....

singh · 29 May 2006

1 wife end of story!

Re: WHY did the guru....

. · 29 May 2006

okk then...i went ot one of this camp and they told us themselves that guru gobind singh jee did have more than one wife...as the 1st one past away he married another 1, and after that she went to sachkhand aswell so he married another 1.......does that mean half of the sikh nation are confuzed about their history and do not know the truth .....as ppl are fighting over what story is right??? maybe i could be wrong duno...but ive just stated what ive been told?

Re: WHY did the guru....

Heera Singh · 29 May 2006

Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh!! from what I've heard Guru Gobind Singh Jee only had one wife ..as said above, mata sundri and mata jeeto were the same person... Mata Sahib Kaur is the mother of the Khalsa, she was directly wedded to Guru Jee.. She said she would not marry anybody and wanted to be with Guru Jee, but Guru Jee said he was already married... he said you can't be my wife, but you can be the mother of the Khalsa... it was at the first Amrit Sanchar where Mata Sahib Kaur Jee putt the pattasay in ... that is why she is called mother of tha Khalsa... therefore she was not Guru Jee's "wife"... Mata Sundri/Jeeto was the only wife of Guru Gobind Singh Jee..!! Chardi Kalaa! Vaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!

Re: WHY did the guru....

Makhan · 29 May 2006

All Sikh gurus have had only one wife. How could they go against Gurubani? All these stories were started by moorakh Hindu to discredit our great gurus. 99.9% Hindu avatars had more than one wives and that is why they invented these stories. 99% of Sikh sakhis or history is written by non-Sikhs. Present day Sikh writers follow the same old stories and even exaggerate them to show that Sikh guru could do the same and any one who tries to oppose this is considered against sikhi and jathedars pass judgement or hukmnama against them. Please do not believe every thing you read. Test it against Gurubani because it is our litmus test.

Re: WHY did the guru....

Kaur · 29 May 2006

Fateh ji I recently heard a fascinating theory that makes sense. This is writtten by a historian - I cant remember the name unfortunately. Basically, Mata Jeeto became Mata sundri because Mata Gujri found her to be so beautiful. AND then when she took amrit, she was renamed Sahib kaur. This makes so much more sense to me personally as in those days many gursikhs changed thier names once they had taken amrit. So, all these three bibia were infact one. For those who think guruji had more than one wife ... where did they get married ? Guru jis anand karaaj took place at Guru ka lahore in Anandpur sahib. If in fact he had three wives - where are those gurdware ? No where :) because they don't exist.

Re: WHY did the guru....

NS · 29 May 2006

Im not sure, but I heard there are different ashes for Mata Sundari Kaur Ji and Mata Jeeto Kaur Ji, as well as different gurdwaras....Not sure tho..

Re: WHY did the guru....

Sardar · 29 May 2006

Original Name Mata Saheb Kaur, Nick Names: Mata Jeeto, Mata Sundri(probably more i dont know). Heera Singh, personally i tihnk you're influenced bt wrong literature. If we're not even sure of who our parents are after taking Amrit, then it is just sad. GurJi gor married to Mata Saheb Kaur and it was the Panj Pyare who put the patasay in:Bhai Daya Singh JI, Bhai Dharam Singh Ji, Bhai Mohkam Singh Ji, Bhai Himmat Singh Ji, and Bhai Saheb SIngh Ji. According to my personal opinion, it was not Mata Saheb Kaur who put the patasay in the Baataa. I don't know people messed up the history so much. And the british took the old testaments to England. they are still they're which originally belong to the Khalsa. Now that has the real history and everything.

Re: WHY did the guru....

D · 30 May 2006

why don't you guys look at gurmat? would gurmat allow having more than one wife at a time? no. so why would you think that our Guru sahibs who taught us gurmat would have more than one wife?! THINK ABOUT IT!

Re: WHY did the guru....

Bundha · 30 May 2006

Sadh Sangat Ji, the Guru’s were PERFECT and their actions were PERFECT, it is we who are not. Whatever the Guru’s did was the absolute truth, but we cannot take it, we look at our glorious Gurus from our level and judge them from our level. You want the truth, you can’t handle the truth! When we do not understand anything we try to rationalise it and basically blame everyone except handle the truth. We blame the Brahmin, we blame the writers the scholars but we cannot handle the truth. Guru Gobind Singh Ji had three Mahals, Mata Jeeto Ji, Mata Sundari Ji and Mata Sahib Kaur Ji, DEAL WITH IT ! It is a great insult to our glorious Mata Ji’s to deny their existence. This notion that there was just one and at different times she was called differing names seems an appealing idea but is wrong. The notion that when one ascended the heavens Guru Sahib Ji married another is also appealing but wrong. For whatever reason, who are we to question? Guru Sahib Ji had three Mahals and that is all there is to it. There are Gurdwaras dedicated to all three Mahals. Just as the Guru Sahib Ji was vegetarian but hunted, accept and move on. Just as kesh is fifth kakaar, accept and move on. Marriage with Mata Jeeto Ji July, 1677 Marriage to Mata Sundri Ji May, 1685 Birth of S. Ajit Singh Ji to Mata Sundri Ji November, 1686 Birth of S. Jujhar Singh Ji to Mata Jeeto ji March,1690 Birth of S. Zorawar Singh Ji to mata Jeeto Ji 1697 Birth of S. Fateh Singh Ji to Mata Jeeto Ji 1699

Re: WHY did the guru....

PTE SINGH · 30 May 2006

Hundreds of years ago in the east there were many practical, moral and social reasons why a man would marry more that once, hence it was not seen as immoral or illegal. This is no longer the case and so it is now rightfully seen as wrong and illegal. There are certain things that are right for the times At that time it was essential for the well being of many women that they were under the protection of a husband, women did not have the same rights as they do now and many men would take rejected women under their protection as wifes. times have changed [%sig%]

Re: WHY did the guru....

Jaspaul Singh · 30 May 2006

Bundha ji .. Those can be your views.. but where is the proof ? we can demand proof for everything but the truth we can NEVER know cuz of how india is .. there are key people that are set out to dominate/eliminate/break our sikh religion.. and since we are a minority in india, we are being stepped on everywhere.. its not very hard to change history when your living in a country you had a terrible past with .. Like the hindu/muslim religion .. sikh religion has been changed again and again by people who have nothing else to do but throw in faults.. My guru was perfect.. he still is perfect in dhan guru granth sahib ji .. lets all focus on more important things in our life including naam simran and seva .. believe in your heart that guru ji was the one and only supreme .. ask for darshan .. pray to be shown the truth .. vaheguroo ..

Re: WHY did the guru....

Makhan · 30 May 2006

"Bundha" You have put down every thing very nicely BUT with what authority can you prove what you have written is 100% correct? You are writing the dates, as you were present at that time. Like rest of us you have read either sakhis or some history books and how authentic these sakhis are. You are saying that we cannot question what Guru Ji did, nobody is questioning guru ji but how can guru ji go against Gurubani? You are thinking and talking like Muslims, as they cannot tolerate any body saying any thing against Mohammed even he did so many wrong things.

Re: WHY did the guru....

o · 31 May 2006

halo bundha po im afraid uve made a very big mistake u missee out the "ki" on keski keski is 5th kakaar kes isnt

Re: WHY did the guru....

... · 31 May 2006

but thats what i dont understand theres no evidence....welll not even a true story that people could agree on......and also as Bundha jee said above we shouldnt question guruji.....we're not questioning guruji but if we are questioned by another religion then we also need to reply back to that question??...this is why it is important for us to know these kind of points ...lol it funny how no1 knows the truth of our history???

Re: WHY did the guru....

Bundha · 31 May 2006

.... Ji, I understand your concerns, we must have an explanation for this, but we must start from the correct platform and not try to rationalise this from our own buddhi or how we would like things to be. o Ji, I stated correct when I said Kesh (actually I was going to carry on and say " Just as Raag Mala is Gurbani accept and move on, Mahapursh are Guru dhay piaray accept and move on " LOL) [%sig%]

Re: WHY did the guru....

Makhan · 31 May 2006

These sort of stories give fuel to anti sikh people to propogate wrong things about about our perfect religion. As ...... we must be able to answer the criticism by non sikhs.

Re: WHY did the guru....

ns · 01 Jun 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheuguru Ji Ke Fateh "Gur ke karni kahee dahavoo" This topic has been going around in circles whenever someone new looks for historical evidence or starts reading Sikh history. Then they begin to wonder why did Guru Sahiban did this and that isn't it wrong. While "P walla!! " you ask the question in a sincere mode for further understanding there some who take this the wrong way and discredit our Gurus. There are smadhs of our 6TH Guru Sahib Jee's wives in India, perhaps the ones who think no 6ht Guru Ji only had one wife , can they enlgihten me on how did those smadhs come about, did the Sikhs at that time just made them up??!! ?Come on people Sikhs around the time of Guru Sahiban probabaly miles were different from us today. We look for quick answers from forums such as this one, I doubt if you ever find the right answer. A lot of Sikh history in sakhian is distorted nothing is 100% correct apart from SGGS, hence the Gurvaak above clearly mentions to us on what to think of Guru's actions, apologies couldn't post the complete shabad , I'm sure someone from this forum will.

Re: WHY did the guru....

anotha theory · 01 Jun 2006

I have heard that Mata Ajit Kaur (Mata Jeeto) and Mata Sundari was the same person... also it was Mata Ajit Kaur that put the patasai in the baataa (i have neva heard the punj piaaray having put them in)... At this time Mata Sahib Kaur wasn't even on the scene.... Mata Ji met Guru Gobind Singh Ji a few years down the line after 1699... As in many cases before , (eg Guru Hargobind Singh ji), Mata Sahib Kaur fell in love with guru ji and wanted to get married and be the mother of his children, however, since Guru ji was already married he said no, but said she will be the mother of all his children, i.e. the Khalsa,.... that is why Mata Sahib Kaur is the mother of the Khalsa.... I have heard many kathakaar portray the happenings as above.... Bhul chuk maaf... ps Even though I agree that whateva happened back then whether the guru's had more than one wife or not, we cant deny the fact that guru sahibs were PERFECT. However, we should discuss these things since there should be a consensus over the whole panth in terms of what happened.... it doesnt sound good if one Sikh is saying one thing and the other another... but i suppose we do that on more important things than just the life stories of guru maharaaj... oh well, all we can do is ardaas for better giaan and do more naam simran...

Re: WHY did the guru....

... · 01 Jun 2006

Kulbir Singh please post your views.

Re: WHY did the guru....

singh · 01 Jun 2006

"Bundha" throwing in Raagmala and Kes as Kakkar will not support your argument. These are completely irrelevent and have nothing to do with the fact that Guru Ji had one/multiple wives. If you think they do, this is Sant Baba logic at its finest!

Re: WHY did the guru....

singh · 01 Jun 2006

In the past, it was very common for wealthy/royal males to have more than one wife as men are naturally polygamus -v. poor guys would be left single often. Its a bit like the dominant alpha male in many animal species having more than one partner, whereas other weaker males end up with none- its natural- kudrat- genetic tendancy developed overtime so that the best genes are passed down. It was not seen as wrong in those days. Today, SOCIETY has started to make it look like one wife is the 'proper' way - and polygamy is wrong. Sad thing is people make up lies that the Gurus did not have more than one wife- they were diferent names for the same person- the hindus made it up - RSS is making up stories etc. etc Every scholar I know who has researched sikh history agrees that some Gurus did have more than 1 wife- people who say it is lies have generally just heard it off someone else and dont want to beleive it and have not read old historical material. Society's rules of what is right and wrong change overtime. In the years to come we will have people saying that the Gurus 'didnt marry at this age or that age' and they couldn't have married a 12 year old girl or a 14 year old girl- that historians must have got the ages wrong. - dont just beleive what you think is right or everything your jatha tells you.

Re: WHY did the guru....

Bundha · 02 Jun 2006

Funny how everything you lot think about has a reference point with 'Sant Babas' shows how insecure in your beliefs you are, everything has to be twisted back to 'sant babas', sad boys.

Re: WHY did the guru....

singh · 02 Jun 2006

"Bundha" the exact same thing could be said of your own post twisting everything back to Kes as Kakkar and Raagmala!

Re: WHY did the guru....

Makhan · 12 Jun 2006

Singh says"In the past, it was very common for wealthy/royal males to have more than one wife as men are naturally polygamus. It was not seen as wrong in those days. Sad thing is people make up lies that the Gurus did not have more than one wife- some Gurus did have more than 1 wife- people who say it is lies have generally just heard it off someone else and dont want to beleive it and have not read old historical material. Society's rules of what is right and wrong change overtime". Sikh gurus did not gave in to what was natural and acceptable in society during their life time. If they they were to go with the society Guru Nanak Dev ji would not have rejected " janeoo" the hindu sacred thread. Each and every guru after Guru Nanak was his "Joat" and they preached and practice what Guru Nanak ji said "one man one wife" and you have to accept this. You have to take the bitter pill. You have to take what SGGS ji says.Who do you believe SGGS ji or some sakhis and historians. "Another theory's " post makes sense. This can be believed.

Re: WHY did the guru....

Sardar · 12 Jun 2006

>>>>>>okk then...i went ot one of this camp and they told us themselves that guru gobind singh jee did have more than one wife...as the 1st one past away he married another 1, and after that she went to sachkhand aswell so he married another 1.......does that mean half of the sikh nation are confuzed about their history and do not know the truth .....as ppl are fighting over what story is right??? maybe i could be wrong duno...but ive just stated what ive been told?<<<<<<<< Are you talking about the Tapoban Camp?

Re: WHY did the guru....

Makhan · 13 Jun 2006

Author: Sardar "okk then...i went ot one of this camp and they told us themselves that guru gobind singh jee did have more than one wife...as the 1st one past away he married another 1, and after that she went to sachkhand aswell so he married another 1.......does that mean half of the sikh nation are confuzed about their history and do not know the truth .....as ppl are fighting over what story is right???" It means that Guru Gobind Singh Ji did not accept Akal Purakh's hukam, but followed "Kam" and married second time and third time. This is first time I have heard this story. Please do not bring our great gurus to hindu avtars level. Accept what SGGS Ji says.

Re: WHY did the guru....

Sardar · 13 Jun 2006

K! ASK GURUJI FOR THE TRUTH! YOU ALL SEEM TO HAVE DIFFERENT VIEWPOINTS!!!!