Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

amazing monas

amazing monas

... · 30 May 2006

i came back from a asamagam recently and their was a mona that got connected with God . i mea he was leterally moaning and crawiling on the floor. He was flipping side by side accendidntly knocking over children. His hands were in the air. It happend to him twice. Later there was a aunty that started making noises and shaking. What were they seeing? and what made this happend? It just happened to my dad while he was lying down listening to kirtan. He felt he was not in his body and he couldnt move. He had no control. Someone said there is a good thing and a bad thing about this stage. A aunty died in India once since she never got out of that stage. my question is what are they seeing?What makes them flip over side by side. What makes them moan? and is this safe? waheguru ji ka kalsa waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: amazing monas

some12 · 30 May 2006

Honestly, it sounds more like a siesure then ne thing..think about it..do u think mahapurhs like bhai randhir isngh, sant jarnail singh baba nand singh flipped and moaned?

Re: amazing monas

ummm.. · 31 May 2006

u weren't at a kooka smagam were you, they all go nuts there man...

Re: amazing monas

City Slicker · 31 May 2006

"Dear Author"..... This almost sounds "too good to be true"...... doesnt it, does this therefore raise a new question, that us non amritdharis CAN reach salvation, and jaap naam, and open out dasam duar too?? Hey look, what ever they had/ have seen it is meant to be kept "gupt", this means that just like you would not share your bank balance with any1, you must not share your "naam dhari" account with any1 either. If you do, then you may never get it again!!!!- Trust me the amount of times I have "opened" my mouth and told others of "sikhi related experiences", I have had, I have lost it, and who knows when I may get it back!? who knows they could have been jaaping naam, immensly, all all their energies were raised causing them to sway from side to side.... I have too, heard of people swaying like this whilst at simran, keertan programmes, but never have I heard that some1 has dies from it.... anyway, dont you worry too much about what you saw, you just concentrate on what you need to do in your life to get across the ocean!!!! Fateh Ji

Re: amazing monas

singh · 31 May 2006

what is so amazing about that? how do you know they are connected to god? sounds more like wierd black magic thing....

Re: amazing monas

... · 31 May 2006

hmmm i wna nkow aswell..anyone??

Re: amazing monas

some1 · 31 May 2006

honestly if it wuz a connection 2 god they would take amrit.

Re: amazing monas

some1 · 31 May 2006

THAT IS COMMING FROM A MONAH

Re: amazing monas

seva singh · 01 Jun 2006

monah or no monah, if a person is atru believer why cant he reach to god, i know so many sikh guys with turbans and patkas, always acting as if they are tru sikhs in gudwaras and in front of family, then all of a sudden ive seen these same guys and not to forget singhnia to smoking ciggys, weed aand drinking openely in bars and clubs. if you a monah does not mean u cant believe and do simran and get to sach kand

Re: amazing monas

some1 · 01 Jun 2006

Wait a minute....no1` said u cannot reach god, cause i gaurantee you, non-sikhs are reaching god all the time. But i'm saying once a sikh monah or not is touched by god would'nt it be default to take amrit?

Re: amazing monas

singh · 01 Jun 2006

If someone smokes or drinks, then they are no longer a sikh b/c they have committed a bujjer kurhait. what's on the outside matters, but the inside is supposed to match. as it says in Anand Sahib 'Jio nirmal, barho nirmal'. -pure on the inside and pure on the outside is needed. Note that the Bani condemns those who are pure on the outside only and impure on the inside, it also condemns those who are impure on both outside and inside. But also note that the Bani DOES NOT EVEN MENTION purity on the inside without purity on the outside. it only specifically talks about purity on the outside alongside purity on the inside.

Re: amazing monas

J.A.T.T · 01 Jun 2006

Umm I thought Sikhs believe that non-Sikhs can achieve salvation as well, no?

Re: amazing monas

some1 · 01 Jun 2006

not in this new aged neo sikhi.

Re: amazing monas

skaur · 02 Jun 2006

I know some guys and girls who get into naam simran and kirtan and they go crazzy with love, or whatever you want to call it. But either way, Guruji's already said it, without taking amrit and becomming a true sikh... no one can achieve oneness with VAHEGURU! I mean come on, we've all heard/read stories of people who can do such great things, but cannot achieve oneness with Vaheguru untill they give themselves up the GURU! I think its great that even moneh can sit in sangat and feel love for guruji, but thats when they should think of making GURUJI a bigger part of their lives. And, even if they still dont, I hope they still come to kirtan and do naam simran in sagat as much as they can, cuz you never know when GURU JI will do kirpaa on them! So they shouldn't get discouraged by other sikhs telling them that they cant feel love while doing simran and kirtan just because they're not amritdhari! Hope I havn't said anything to hurt anyone. vaheguruuuu help me!

Re: amazing monas

... · 03 Jun 2006

......yhh sometimes when i go to kirtans n that...normally im sitting there with my eyes closed as i could concentrate more.... ...and when i open my eyes...i look around i see all the sangat with dastaars on and that....and i feel out of place.. .....i mean like im sitting there rite in the middle of singhneeyaan.. ..lol get this funny feeling..in a way i feel happy im sittin in sangat of gursikhs....but still feel odd....is it just mee or other people aswell lol...?

Re: amazing monas

J.A.T.T · 03 Jun 2006

So I guess this means that 99.99% people in this world will NOT achieve salvation because they didn't take amrit. Also this means that people like Baba Sheikh Farid Ji didn't achieve salvation as well since they didn't take amrit. Now I understand why a lot of Sikhs are leaving Sikhi and converting to other religions.

Re: amazing monas

* · 03 Jun 2006

im sure bhagat sheikh fareed jee,would have been blessed with charan pahul lets not worry abt wt other people will or wnt acheive,lets just man hukam of our Beloved,our Guru,Guru Gobind Sing jee seeing sikhi is our religion and hes our Guru VaheGuroo :)

Re: amazing monas

Jasmin · 03 Jun 2006

Sure you could leave or you could take Amrit...I mean just because it's unpopular doesn't mean it's wrong, maybe it's right.

Re: amazing monas

J.A.T.T · 03 Jun 2006

Yes, let's be a Sikh of Guru Granth Sahib Ji...........

Re: amazing monas

some12 · 03 Jun 2006

give gurbani quote where non sikhs explicity cannot attain salvation

Re: amazing monas

skaur · 03 Jun 2006

This is to "..." You might feel out of place, but honestly, dont let that discourage you, because before I took amrit, I felt the same way also. And sometimes I felt like I didnt even belong, but sangat shouldn't judge another person sitting in sangat on things like whether they're wearing a distaar/bana/ or anything else for that matter. If you enjoy kirtan, KEEP AT IT!.... Its an amazing feeling if you can get attached, and not many people are fortunate to feel that much love for guru ji, (yes, even some amritdhari people dont feel it) SO ENJOYY!!! vaheguruuuu

Re: amazing monas

. · 04 Jun 2006

haha lol ppl chill! :P

Re: amazing monas

Satnam · 04 Jun 2006

Bad Monas go to Hell but if Mona is very religious and has good karams in his life he or she can go maximum to Heaven or get recarniated. Only Amrit Dhari Gursikhs with a Gursikhi jeevan can go to Sachkhand. You can read a sakhi about Bhai Dalla Brar and Guru Gobind Singh jee regarding this matter. I think this Mona should take Amrit and become Gursikh if he wants to be connected to God.

Re: amazing monas

sim singh · 04 Jun 2006

they can attain salvation through nam etc. but not saachkhaand. to reach saakhanda u need to b amridhari and have the true naam