Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

Agreed · 31 May 2006

Punjab is now a defunct and meaningless name: It no longer exists Time to recognize & rename the Sikh homeland as Khalistan Punjab, as everyone who is familiar with some history of the region should know, is a combination of two Persian words (Panj & Aab) and gives the meaning of "Land of 5 Rivers" in reference to the five tributary rivers of the Indus which flow through the region. However, what is not so well known is that it wasn’t actually the Persians who gave the Punjab its name, nor was it the Punjab's indigenous people. It was the Mughals. The Mughals were the first rulers to officially use the term Punjab (or Panjab) as the name for the region that lay between the Indus and the Yamuna. Specifically, it was during the reign of Akbar that the word Punjab was most likely popularized and Akbar's court is also credited with having given the Punjab's various 'Do-Aabs' (Also words of Persian origin) their present names. The Punjab therefore, its definition and identity, is a product and relic of the Mughal empire. This is a fact which surprisingly is not known by many "Punjabis". Or perhaps, these facts are well known but are deliberately overlooked and kept quiet on as they crush the very foundations upon which the chauvinism of "Punjabi pride" and flawed concept of the so-called "Punjabi nation" are built upon. In any case, they are simple facts which cannot be denied by any serious person. So, Punjab is not the name of a nation or of a people but is a name coined by foreign Persian-speaking invaders in reference to the major geographical features of the region, i.e. the rivers Jhelum, Chenab, Ravi, Beas and Sutlej. Now, fast-forward to the 21st century and this land of five rivers no longer exists as a politically united entity. What’s more, the people who defined and gave this region its name no longer exist either. Actually, they disappeared from the scene hundreds of years back. What then, is the logic behind the continued use of this name "Punjab" as a name for the Sikh homeland? A territory which is not a land of five rivers, does not have a native Persian-speaking population, and in which it’s indigenous and majority Sikh people are not descended from people of Turko-Mongol (Mughal) or Persian stock. The absurdity of continuing to identify the Sikh homeland as "Punjab" presents an interesting contradiction in Sikh collective thought. For the Sikhs, it is clear that they cannot ever depict the Mughals in a positive light as the Mughals had committed heinous crimes and atrocities against them. So why then champion a foreign name given to the Sikhs native homeland by these very same rulers who had not only occupied by force the land which had belonged to the ancestors of the Sikhs but who had also waged war against the Sikhs very own Gurus? There is then the fact that the Sikh majority Punjab state in India is not a land of five rivers. Only three rivers pass through it. So once again what is the purpose of having the territory named as Punjab? Isn’t this not a complete joke? To have a land in which only three rivers pass through it known as a "land of five rivers" by using a word of Persian origin? A phone conversation with a Naga had sparked off this questioning behind the logic of continuing to identify the Sikh homeland as Punjab. Getting confused over references to the "Sikh nation of Punjab" the Naga gentlemen quite rightly asked isn’t the Sikh nation known as Khalistan, and if we could use the word Khalistan so that everyone could be clear on what was actually being discussed. He gave the example of confusions over the name of his own homeland. To the Nagas, their homeland of "Nagalim" is the word used to describe all of the Naga dominated and inhabited areas of their region; or what they call, "the traditional Naga homeland". Then there is the Indian state of "Nagaland" which is nothing but an Indian creation and only a tiny fraction of Nagalim. Not surprisingly, the Nagas reject both the boundaries and the name of Nagaland as these are artificial and have been enforced upon them by the Indians. His insistence that the correct terminology of “Nagalim” and “Khalistan” be used in reference to the Naga and Sikh nations was wholly correct on his part, and for which he is owed a word of thanks. The names of nations and territories should reflect either the identity of its people or of its defining geographical characteristics. But this is not the case with the Sikh homeland. The name Punjab neither reflects the identity of the people nor does it reflect the geographical features of the territory. Some years back after his return to India the long time advocate of Sikh independence, Dr Jagjit Singh Chauhan, suggested that the Punjab state be renamed to Khalistan. Although the word Khalistan has become tainted over the years and made almost synonymous with “terrorism” due the propaganda machinery of the Indian government and media, the name Khalistan is in fact a true representation and definition of the Sikh homeland. Much more so than the Mughal name Punjab is as ever since the collapse of the Mughal empire and later with the partition of the Punjab between two new countries, the name Punjab, in relation to the Sikh homeland, is now completely meaningless and defunct. Since the creation of modern India in 1947 there have been numerous examples in which foreign imposed names have been reverted back to their indigenous names or given new identities in the language of the local people. The United Provinces became Uttar Pradesh, Madras became Chennai, Bombay became Mumbai, Calcutta became Kolkata and most recently Assam has been reverted back to Asom. Taking all of these and the many more examples into account isn’t it then high time that the Sikhs also got rid of the now defunct and meaningless name Punjab which was given to the region by foreigners and rename their territory to Khalistan? When Assam can be renamed back to its historical name of Asom after its indigenous Ahom dynasty which had ruled Asom as an independent kingdom for hundreds of years it is then a perfectly legitimate demand for Sikhs to push for the renaming of Punjab to Khalistan; a name and identity which reflects the demographics and aspirations of the Sikh nation and does not continue on an outdated relic left behind by the Sikhs one time nemesis, the Mughal emperors. A. Soni London, UK http://www.panthic.org/news/129/ARTICLE/2497/2006-05-28.html [%sig%]

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

PTE SINGH · 01 Jun 2006

More holes in that argument than a tea bag... [%sig%]

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

massra di dal · 01 Jun 2006

panjab in future all 5 rivers will become part of khalsastan. if #jagjit chauhan wants to help the panth, then before we even touch on names of states we must look closely at the situation of the panth, panjabis and sikhs

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

J.A.T.T · 01 Jun 2006

Jagjit Chauhan? LOL I don't like that dude for some odd reason. Sirdar Simranjit Singh Mann is a good man though. I believe he make Khalistan a reality instead of Jagjit Chauhan.

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

some1 · 01 Jun 2006

change my name and i'm still me. punjab needs 2 be liberated not renamed.

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

gh · 01 Jun 2006

the khalistan will have only few khalsa in it, i dont see the name fit. call it Dusht-a-stan or Manmatastanbecasue the majority of people tehre are either dushts or practice manmat

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

singh · 01 Jun 2006

manmatastan sounds good to me

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

some1 · 01 Jun 2006

u can have 1 khalsa, but the need for khalistan is too great to ignore. In order for the Dharam to grow Sikhs need a good home base... a good HEAD QUARTERS. that is the biggest problem. Sikhism due to its current state can't do its core purpose, uphold human rights...as sikhs human righs are violted day in day out...the need for KHALISTAN IS NEEDED.

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

some1 · 01 Jun 2006

thodi avastha tha bohath uchi hauni ah.

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

KS · 01 Jun 2006

Currently all Gurdwara Committees and other Sikh Institutions are full of people who take their orders from Delhi either directly or Indirectly thats why we are in a mess. You need a independent state so that the institutions can make an effort on Sikhi.

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

trigger · 01 Jun 2006

Calling it khalistan means persian / arabic words being used -no way - terrible !! It can't be called land of 5 rivers, coz there's only 3 ??? . . . but it can be called land of the PURE??? hum??? yes- coz everyone there is pure... oh and do we then change the name to bhaya-stan when bhayai become the majority - like in a few years ??? what a crap article

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

... · 01 Jun 2006

i guess you could name pujab khalistan...but then my impression of khalistan wouls be only the true gursiikhs living peacefully with one another. sounds lie a dream huh.lol. that would be great though :)

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

khalistan · 01 Jun 2006

“Hindu Militants Murdered 38 Sikhs in Cold Blood” Clinton: India Responsible for Chithisinghpora Massacre WASHINGTON, D.C., May 30, 2006 – In the introduction to former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright’s new book, The Mighty and the Almighty, former U.S. President Bill Clinton writes that “Hindu militants” are responsible for the massacre of 38 Sikhs at Chithisinghpora in March 2000. This reflects previous findings by the Punjab Human Rights Organization, the International Human Rights Organization, the Movement Against State Repression, and New York Times reporter Barry Bearak. President Clinton writes, “During my visit to India in 2000, some Hindu militants decided to vent their outrage by murdering 38 Sikhs in cold blood. If I hadn’t made the trip, the victims would probably still be alive. If I hadn’t made the trip because I feared what militants might do, I couldn’t have done my job as president of the United States.” According to Amnesty International, “the attackers wore uniforms of the armed forces and were led by a tall man whom they addressed as Commanding Officer (CO). All Sikh men were rounded up, ostensibly to check their identities, and made to sit on the ground in two groups against the walls of the gurdwaras [Sikh temples] a few hundred metres from each other; they were shot at point blank range. As the attackers withdrew, they reportedly shouted Hindu slogans.” On August 2, 2002, the Washington Times reported that the Indian government admitted that its forces were responsible for the massacre. India finally admitted that the evidence it used to implicate alleged Kashmiri “militants” in the murders was faked. At the time of the Chithisinghpora massacre, Dr. Gurmit Singh Aulakh, President of the Council of Khalistan, strongly condemned the murders. “What motive would Kashmiri freedom fighters have to kill Sikhs? This would be especially stupid when President Clinton is visiting. The freedom movements in Kashmir, Khalistan, Nagaland, and throughout India need the support of the United States,” he said. Khalistan is the Sikh homeland declared independent on October 7, 1987. The massacres continued a pattern of repression and terrorism against minorities by the Indian government, which it attempts to blame on other minorities to divide and rule the minority peoples within its artificial borders. The Indian newspaper Hitavada reported that the Indian government paid the late governor of Punjab, Surendra Nath, $1.5 billion to organize and support covert terrorist activity in Punjab, Khalistan, and in neighboring Kashmir. A report issued by the Movement Against State Repression (MASR) shows that India admitted that it held 52,268 political prisoners under the repressive “Terrorist and Disruptive Activities Act” (TADA) even though it expired in 1995. Many have been in illegal custody since 1984. There has been no list published of those who were acquitted under TADA and those who are still rotting in Indian jails. Additionally, according to Amnesty International, there are tens of thousands of other minorities being held as political prisoners. MASR report quotes the Punjab Civil Magistracy as writing “if we add up the figures of the last few years the number of innocent persons killed would run into lakhs [hundreds of thousands.]” The Indian government has murdered over 250,000 Sikhs since 1984, more than 300,000 Christians in Nagaland, over 90,000 Muslims in Kashmir, tens of thousands of Christians and Muslims throughout the country, and tens of thousands of Tamils, Assamese, Manipuris, , and others. The Indian Supreme Court called the Indian government's murders of Sikhs "worse than a genocide.” The book Soft Target by Canadian journalists Zuhair Kashmeri and Brian McAndrew , shows that the Indian government blew up its own airliner in 1985 to blame Sikhs and justify further repression. It quotes an agent of the Canadian Security Investigation Service (CSIS) as saying, “If you really want to clear up the incidents quickly, take vans down to the Indian High Commission and the consulates in Toronto and Vancouver. We know it and they know it that they are involved.” On January 2, 2002, the Washington Times reported that India sponsors cross-border terrorism in the Pakistani province of Sindh. “Only in a free Khalistan will the Sikh Nation prosper and get justice,” said Dr. Aulakh. “When Khalistan is free, we will have our own Ambassadors, our own representation in the UN and other international bodies, and our own leaders to keep this sort of thing from happening. We won’t be at the mercy of the brutal Indian regime and its Hindu militant allies,” he said. “Democracies don’t commit genocide. India should act like a democracy and allow a plebiscite on independence for Khalistan and all the nations of South Asia,” Dr. Aulakh said. “We must free Khalistan now.”

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

JSS · 02 Jun 2006

It should be called Gurmatstan. That is the only way that international countries will understand that it is a Sikh country. The word Khalis is a muslim word and that adds confusion

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

ghostly punjab · 02 Jun 2006

the entire sikh nation needs preparation only in the tone of naam, gurbani amrit and rehat for now. then the mangh of khalsa will come

Re: Rename Punjab to Khalistan?

J.A.T.T · 02 Jun 2006

umm how about we call it "Sikhstan" or "Sikhistan" instead? Sikhstan/Sikhistan = Land of the Sikhs