Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

can an amritdhari remarry

can an amritdhari remarry

Sanjo · 01 Jun 2006

from another thread regarding homosexual amritdharis i noticed people telling bhai sahib not to get married again as his first marriage wasnt a success due to certain reasons. just got me thinking, can a amritdhari remarry if their spouse passes away? n what if the marriage fails completely n the two amritdharis involved are completely incompatible, is divorce allowed? and can the two people involved marry other amritdharis afterwards? lets just pretend there are no children involved, children make things complicated n we should always try to do whats best for them i suppose, so whats maryada regarding the above questions. thanks

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

singh · 01 Jun 2006

I think (NOT ENTIRELY SURE) that Guru Amardas Ji said that you can get married again if your spouse passes away.

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

some1 · 01 Jun 2006

Honestly veerji, I just can't see a marriage between to "sane" ppl breaking down compeletly. WORK THROUGH IT.

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

h · 01 Jun 2006

you can get married if your wife/husband paases away. divorce was unheard of literally during guru jis times, literally. i think divorce is a recent trend, but a more and more popular one.

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

Gurpreet Singh · 01 Jun 2006

I think its all western society....In the old times there was something called compromise but people are so busy with everything else so they don't want to spend time compromising...if guru sahib is the center of a marriage...i don't see it breaking down....what else is there to life..other than japping naaam ...

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

Tired Veerji · 02 Jun 2006

Only re-marry if your spouse dies. No other reason!

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 02 Jun 2006

well said bhai sahib'Gurpreet Singh' Jeeo.

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

Kulbir Singh · 02 Jun 2006

It takes two to compromise. In case the spouse of a Gursikh leaves Sikhi or otherwise just leaves the gursikh, and all means to bring back the spouse fail, it is a viable option to get married again, if need be. If possible, the Gursikh should stay single but if he or she can’t help it for whatever reason, then there is nothing wrong in getting married again. This issue has been discussed at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib at Panthak level, and it is generally accepted that a second marriage in extreme cases is allowed. Having said the above, we can get Guru Sahib’s khushiyaan only if we obey the hukams of Guru Sahib. If both husband and wife follow Gurmat, then there can be no problem. It is pretty disappointing to see the rate of failing marriages in Sikhs today. Something must be done at panthak level Schools should have mandatory classes on how to live in a relationship. Today we see that no relationship is working. Children don’t get along with their parents and parents don’t get with their children. Husbands and wives don’t get along with each other. The relationship problem now has became very grave. Before marriage, Singh and Bibi along with their parents should be required to take a Gurmat course on relationships by the Gurdwaras. I know this sounds kind of funny but there are just too many cases of mismanagement of relationships. Kulbir Singh

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

Chinese Singh · 03 Jun 2006

Yes i agree with you Kulbir Singh Ji. More help needs to be carried out by Gurdwaras. I learnt that mosques and churches have marriage councelling services to help marriage and family life. Gurdwaras should do something along these lines. Also, i think that many sikhs arent educated in this particular field in terms of sikhi and relationships. relationships are seldom discussed i think with the elders and the young. in my opinion, if people were educated in gurmat from a young age, including in relationships, i think that there would be far less divorces

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

PTE SINGH · 05 Jun 2006

I think people are being naive to say that a person should only remarry if their spouse passes away. There are many reason why a person could break up a marriage and have a divorce. Surely people who have unfaithful or abusive partners should be allowed to divorce and remarry. [%sig%]

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

satvinder · 05 Jun 2006

Fully appreciate that education concerning relationships [of all nature] is vital. On a separate note... Kulbir Singh Veer ji you wrote: "In case the spouse of a Gursikh leaves Sikhi or otherwise just leaves the gursikh, and all means to bring back the spouse fail, it is a viable option to get married again, if need be." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Veer ji, I was just interested in what happens to the commitment made to the almighty during laavaa(n) in the event of the break up of a marriage. As I understand it we are not just committing ourselves to our spouse during laava(n) but a deeper bond is being tied in this process. My personal stance would be that this commitment [both to spouse and the almighty] is unbreakable unless one partner deceases… but this is just my opinion and although it seems ideological it is not grounded in any knowledge of Sikhi.

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

satvinder · 05 Jun 2006

ps. would be interested to hear other's thoughts on this.

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

2006 · 05 Jun 2006

Im sorry to say Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Ji but Satvinder is right about that.. I mean we are not 'JUST' Sikhs (Manmukhs) we are Guru's Sikhs ie. Gursikhs so when we marry we are making not only one commitment to just our partner but also to guru ji too infront of the Guru Granth Sahib Ji, I believe you should try and work at a marriage come good or bad.. i believe karam can play a big part in marriage and you just have to take everything as Guru Ji's Hukum. I have always been one think that you marry once.. and once only if worst comes to worst in whatever scenario im left single then dedicate the rest of my life to Vaheguru Ji. Also I strongly believe in Sanjog.. so forgive me if im wrong but I think most problems lie in so called Love marriages.. If you are a true gursikh then just leave everything is Vaheguru Ji's hands.. surely then you will have nothing to worry about! That's just my opinion though n im not even married yet so I just hope im not wrong in the way i think!

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

jogendra · 05 Jun 2006

i read this in history books and have heard these stories from older people telling oral history. if i am wrong please inform me. when the muslims came and took away the women from the hindu's the sikh warriors would rescue this ladies. then the singhs would try to reunite them with their families. alot of women were not accepted back and the singhs would take care of them and even marry them. these women were indeed divorced because their husbands, fathers, and families would not accept them back.

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

SIKH · 05 Jun 2006

Can we all just stop for a moment and think. Let us remember that the concept of divorce and the term is a modern western phenomenon. THEIR IS NO SUCH THING AS DIVORCE IN GURU SAHIB'S SIKHI. So maybe its best to bear this in mind when talking about such matters. Even acknowledging it i think is wrong. You can live apart if your husband or wife are beyond any means of help, when all efforts have failed. But those who seek this 'divorce' thing for manmat reasons, such as not loving the partner, wanting different things in life etc. These people are deluded if they think that Guru Ji will forgive them. This is manmat and there is only one home for this, narak.

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

some1 · 05 Jun 2006

those are moral issues and obligations. if one does a divorce on their own will...there is no point in marrying again.

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

satvinder · 05 Jun 2006

I'm sorry, I wasn 't questioning Veer Kulbir Singh Ji's perspective. I think veer ji has made it clear that marriages should be worked through. His comment about remarriage was in the event of all attempts to reconcile having failed. My personal ideology on remarriage is based on observations and is not necessarily grounded in Sikhi. I was just wondering what Sikhi's stance would be on the issue of the commitment made to the divine during the act of marriage in the event of separation and in the event of remarriage. I apologise if my question sounded controversial, this wasn't the intention... it was a genuine query.

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

YO · 07 Jun 2006

IF U MARRY IN HUKAM THEN U DIVORCE DONT IT MEAN WEN U REMARRY.. IT IS IN HUKAM? OR NO?

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

sikh · 08 Jun 2006

Yo ji we get married in hukam, and we should stay in the marriage regardless of whatever happens. did the sikhs who were being hunted duirng guru ji's times give up their sikhi? they could have easily given it up thinking there was a easier way to meet god? the persecution was obviously affecting their sikhi! but no they stayed true to guru ji. so it makes me laugh when some people say that its ok for the person to get out even if the marriage is effecting there sikhi. this is also hukam and we must brave it out. but no we run at the first instance of trouble. with our weak minded spitirually corrput western man matt thoughts! and then we say we are still obeying guru ji's hukam, pls get a life and stop kidding urself. guru ji isn't that complicated nor is his sikhi! something to ponder on!

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

singhni · 09 Jun 2006

A amritdhari true singh can'nt remarry,even if he have hard life.It is Guru ji hukam.If amritdhari singh devorce an amritdhari singhni what we should call him.I think he is not amritdhari any more,because he broke his promise,what he made in Guru Sahib presence.Read rehitnama.thank you very much

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

Harjas Kaur · 09 Jun 2006

I think with people, it's not a perfect world. Things happen they have no control over. We shouldn't encourage abandoning of families. But when partner has already been abandoned, we shouldn't be too judgemental. But I will leave those decisions about remarriage to the Panj Piare. I have never been married. In fact, I think I'm growing old unmarried, in forties now. I never look for a partner. It would be nice I guess in some ways to have a husband. But I lived my whole life alone and it's easier just the way it is. Fortunately for me, It is easy to live this way. But I wouldn't try to force anyone else to stay unmarried. As I get old I will have no family except the sangat. So I can appreciate people who want to get remarried and need a family life. Strictness is one thing, but I do think sometimes people have extenuating circumstances. Anyways Guruji speaks through the decision of the Panj Piare. [%sig%]

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

kuri · 12 Jun 2006

yeh i agree ppl r too judgemental if a woman has an arranged marriage and then her husband starts battering her and then they divorce u shudn judge the woman to want to get married again and not live alone and have no kids yes theres karma and she made an oath with her wife beater husband but no one reali knows what they wud reali do until they are in the situation themselves!

Re: can an amritdhari remarry

jss · 13 Jun 2006

No way, can an amritdhari rehatwan Sikhremarry if the spouse is alive irrespective of living together or in separation. Haan kache pilye can do whatever they want but a true sikh will keep the promise he made to Guru till death.