Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gursikhs having false Heroes

Gursikhs having false Heroes

Kulbir Singh · 02 Jun 2006

I have been thinking for some time whether it is appropriate for Gursikhs to have false heroes. A Singh who follows the Sarblohi, Kharagdhaari, Rehit of Siri Guru Dasmesh jee cannot be a fan of a manmukh sansaari person like Tendulkar, Amitabh Bachan, Beckham etc. The real soora or hero is that person who has subdued his or her mind and realised his or her real self. A person who can act very well i.e. can do fake crying or fake laughing very well can never be a hero. Same way a person who can kick a ball very well or a person who can hit the ball with his bat very well cannot be called a hero for this one quality. Why then people go crazy after these fake stars? Gurbani explains it very beautiful: [gurbani]ijh krxI hovih srimMdw iehw kmwnI rIiq ][/gurbani] jih karanee hovehi sarami(n)dhaa eihaa kamaanee reeth || You have made it your habit to practice those deeds which will bring you shame. [gurbani]sMq kI inMdw swkq kI pUjw AYsI idRV@I ibprIiq ]1][/gurbani] sa(n)th kee ni(n)dhaa saakath kee poojaa aisee dhrirrhee bipareeth ||1|| You slander the Saints, and you worship the faithless cynics; such are the corrupt ways you have adopted. ||1|| This is the sign of Kalyug that Gursikhs or the Bhagats of Vaheguru are slandered but thugs, rascals and scoundrels are worshipped. In another shabad Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee beautifully states the symptoms of manmukhs in Kalyug: [gurbani]Koty kau Krw khY Kry swr n jwxY ][/gurbani] khottae ko kharaa kehai kharae saar n jaanai || He calls the counterfeit genuine, and does not know the value of the genuine. [gurbani]AMDy kw nwau pwrKU klI kwl ivfwxY ]3][/gurbani] a(n)dhhae kaa naao paarakhoo kalee kaal viddaanai ||3|| The blind man is known as an appraiser; this Dark Age of Kali Yuga is so strange! ||3|| [gurbani]sUqy kau jwgqu khY jwgq kau sUqw ][/gurbani] soothae ko jaagath kehai jaagath ko soothaa || The sleeper is said to be awake, and those who are awake are like sleepers. [gurbani]jIvq kau mUAw khY mUey nhI roqw ]4][/gurbani] jeevath ko mooaa kehai mooeae nehee rothaa ||4|| The living are said to be dead, and no one mourns for those who have died. ||4|| [gurbani]Awvq kau jwqw khY jwqy kau AwieAw ][/gurbani] aavath ko jaathaa kehai jaathae ko aaeiaa || One who is coming is said to be going, and one who is gone is said to have come. [gurbani]pr kI kau ApunI khY Apuno nhI BwieAw ]5][/gurbani] par kee ko apunee kehai apuno nehee bhaaeiaa ||5|| That which belongs to others, he calls his own, but he has no liking for that which is his. ||5|| [gurbani]mITy kau kauVw khY kVUey kau mITw ][/gurbani] meet(h)ae ko kourraa kehai karrooeae ko meet(h)aa || That which is sweet is said to be bitter, and the bitter is said to be sweet. [gurbani]rwqy kI inMdw krih AYsw kil mih fITw ]6][/gurbani] raathae kee ni(n)dhaa karehi aisaa kal mehi ddeet(h)aa ||6|| One who is imbued with the Lord's Love is slandered - his is what I have seen in this Dark Age of Kali Yuga. ||6|| [gurbani]cyrI kI syvw krih Twkuru nhI dIsY ][/gurbani] chaeree kee saevaa karehi t(h)aakur nehee dheesai || He serves the maid, and does not see his Lord and Master. [gurbani]poKru nIru ivrolIAY mwKnu nhI rIsY ]7[/gurbani] pokhar neer viroleeai maakhan nehee reesai ||7|| Churning the water in the pond, no butter is produced. ||7|| Young boys and girls get crush over these fake heroes and they don’t realise that just because a person is very good at faking a cry or can do a good acting of being in anger, does not mean that the fake hero will also be good for them if they had a relationship with them. Most of these fake heroes are very unsuccessful at their home front. So why make them heroes. These heroes and sports persons may be good at acting (and kanjarpuna) or kicking the ball or batting but they are all destined to go to Jammdoots for they have no bhagti. What is their status in the eyes of Guru Sahib? Imagine, what will be their fate in the next world? I can remember the famous pankiti of Gurbani to express this: “Vadda hoya dunidaar, gal sangal ghat chalaiya”|| (Person who is considered to be great in this world by worldly standards is taken to the court of Dharam Rai with chains around his neck). Such persons who are destined to be dragged to the court of Dharam Rai with chains around their necks, should never the heroes of Gursikhs. We will get only thus far as our heroes are. If our heroes are kanjars like Shahrukh Khan, Amitabh Bachan, cricket players or soccer players, then it seems logical that we will suffer the same fate as our heroes. If our heroes are Baba Deep Singh, Bhai Gurdas jee, Baba Budda jee, we can expect some kind of kindness from Guru Sahib. Kulbir Singh

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

Hargurmit Singh · 02 Jun 2006

Vahiguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Jee Kee Fateh Yet another classic from the pen of Bhai Sahib Bhai Kulbir Singh jee. This forum was indeed missing posts like these for a long time. Hopefully you will spend some time sharing and starting posts like this.. Humbly [%sig%]

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

some1 · 02 Jun 2006

veer ji, i agree with ur post whole heartedly, but i have to say one thing, theres many different types of heroes. my self for example... MY HEROE IN LIFE IN GENERAL..EVERYDAY HEROE...HEROE HOW ONE SHOULD LIVE AND ACT IS SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JI.... MY HEROE WHEN IT COMES TO MAKING A LIVING...BECOMING SUCCESSFULL FINANCIALLY IN LIFE IS ARNOLD SCHW. MY HEROE WHEN IT COMES TO BODY BUILDING IS AGAIN ARNIE... MANY HEROES..MY HEROES WHEN IT COMES TO ACADEMICS ARE ANY PHDS... MY HEROES WHEN IT COMES TO FIGHTING FOR FAITH AND NATION..ALL SHAHEEDS...AND CHE GUEAVERA

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

NS · 02 Jun 2006

With all due respect, who are you to judge everyone by your own standard? No offense intended.

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

Singh · 02 Jun 2006

I totally agree that we shouldn't follow these bhanders and make the heroes of our heart real people, all round people, saint soldier people who sacrificed for the good of others and also kept there faith attaining to such high levels of purity of consciouness. They are the real heores. Baba Deep Singh jee and the likes were not in this game of truth for praise or to make money off it. They believed and lived there belief. That is the measure of a real man. When the going got tough they faced it and showed us the way of the pure. Thats so great,!!! What a great post you have put up, it is really motivating and reminds me of there great sacrifices as I write I can't help but feel my eyes wet with tears in there remembrance. Alas!!! When will be the day that the lord will accept me and take me from this wreched hell of duality??? "Mittar Piarai Noo, Hal Muree daa da Kahainaa, Tidh bin Rog Rajaieeaann da Odan, Nagh Nivasaan de Raihnaa" How much longer do I need to wait? I feel as if I am going to burst without HIM? O lord here my plea and show me yourself within the soul. I can't wait any longer and I can't hold on. Why don't you remember me??????????

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

---- · 02 Jun 2006

yesterday i went to the gurdwara and there was a katha going on and in between the bhai sahib ji said "if we get up at amritvela, do seva, do naam, sangath...never feel that we are superior than others since it creates huamai. He also says theres two types of huamai as mentioned in the shabad below: "tofI mhlw 5 Gru 5 dupdy (716-1) todee mehlaa 5 ghar 5 dupday Todee, Fifth Mehl, Fifth House, Du-Padas: <> siqgur pRswid ] (716-2) ik-oNkaar satgur parsaad. One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: AYso gunu myro pRB jI kIn ] (716-2, tofI, mÚ 5) aiso gun mayro parabh jee keen. Such is the blessing my God has bestowed upon me. pMc doK Aru AhM rog ieh qn qy sgl dUir kIn ] rhwau ] (716-2, tofI, mÚ 5) panch dokh ar ahaN rog ih tan tay sagal door keen. rahaa-o. He has totally banished the five evils and the illness of egotism from my body. ||Pause||" he said the panch dokh are the punj chors as well as guru ji says 'ar ahan rog', thats the second type of huami rog that we get....when we start feeling superior than others since were amritdhari and others arent, so we start despising them and hoping for suchkund well others are left to rot....he said we should always thank Guru ji that hes saved us from this kuljug otherwise we would be rotting like the rest in the fires of kuljug...jus thank him thats it nothing more...this will save us from this very bad and deadly huamai rog......these are only my little penny words I dont mean to lecture anyone in any way....upon hearing that yesterday it made me think where I stood I jus felt like sharing it with the sangath...we all may say we know wuts gonna happen to these worldy heros afterlife but when declaring this were actaully saying it in sheer ego........ "nanak naam chardi kala, there pane sarbath da pala"

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

unreal · 02 Jun 2006

With respect, I believe you may be overgeneralizing the issue. Also, I think you may be narrowly interpreting the term "hero". Shaheed Baba Deep Singh ji was a "hero" but Mario Lemieux was also a "hero" (at times). This does not mean the two are equivalent or the term "hero" applies to each equivalently - simply that the term "hero" applies to both, but applies differently. Baba ji was a hero for more reasons than I care to mention, and Lemieux was a HOCKEY hero because, at times, he single-handedly seemed to take games over and acieve victory. People respect Baba ji for a myriad reasons and respect Lemiux for his tenacity and skill in the game of hockey. There is a difference between worshipping someone as a hero and admiring someone, and even looking up to someone with regards to their athleticism in sport - there is nothing wrong with the latter position. There is nothing wrong with a Sikh athlete admiring the skill, tenacity, strategy etc of a top athlete in his/her chosen sport; in many cases, this often translates to that Sikh athlete trying to improve his/her game in an attempt to get to the same level as the athlete in question. For example, a Sikh soccer player may love the way Ronaldhino plays, may watch clip after clip of Ronaldhino's highlights, and spend hours every day practicing to get to a similar level - there is nothing in wrong with that. The Sikh athlete is admiring the specific skill set of Ronaldhino, not worshipping Ronaldhino as a god. Moreover, the Gurbani you have referenced does not say that a Sikh doing the above is "wrong". For that matter, even if someone isn't an athlete, there is nothing wrong with admiring or respecting a professional for the skill they possess in their chosen field. I may not be a heavyweight wrestler but I can admire Alexander Karelin for his HEROIC feats in the realm of olympic wrestling. I may not be a boxer but I can admire the heart, courage, strategy and skill of Muhammed Ali when he went toe to toe with, and beat, the insanely powerful George Foreman. This is not worship of someone as a role model, or even as a great or good human being - it is respect and admiration for a specific skill set, be it athletics or arts or whathaveyou, that another person possesses. And heck, if that admiration shifts to supporting one's home team (sorry, the Maple Leafs suck :) ) than as long as such support is not fanatical or overbearing, I don't see the harm. I apologize but either I am misunderstanding the gist of your message or I am in disagreement with your interpretation.

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

some1 · 02 Jun 2006

unreal u said what i wuz tryna say.

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

Kulbir Singh · 02 Jun 2006

Unreal, ------------- Baba ji was a hero for more reasons than I care to mention, and Lemieux was a HOCKEY hero because, at times, he single-handedly seemed to take games over and acieve victory. People respect Baba ji for a myriad reasons and respect Lemiux for his tenacity and skill in the game of hockey. ------------ This is quite upsetting. To put Baba Deep Singh jee and Lemieux in the same line shows serious disregard to Baba jee. Anyway, perhaps it’s okay for hockey players to have Lemieux as the benchmark of hockey skill but for a Gursikh to get obsessed by such false hero is wrong. They are false heroes because their skills or their expertise lie in futile worldly things. It’s like saying that so and so person is my hero because he makes tasty daal. While you can appreciate the skill this person has but to elevate this person to a level of worshipping, as the youngsters today do is wrong. Many youngsters who have actors and sports people as their heroes would probably faint if approached by their heroes. This is how much they are into this illusion of false heroes. Fine, Tendulkar can bat very well. So does this quality make him a good human being? No. Fine, Beckham can play soccer very well but does this quality make him a good person also? The answer again is No. So if a person is not a good person in his real life and if a person is not serving the humanity nor serving God, how does such person deserve to be a hero? How many youngsters do we see going crazy or getting filled with awe on the mention of Bhagat Puran Singh jee? Not many. When Bhagat jee was in his physical body, he used to walk around Siri Amritsar like an ordinary person but recently when Salman Khan of Kanjarwood came to Siri Darbar Sahib for darshan, whole of Harmandir Sahib and adjoining areas were packed with people wanting “darshan” of Salman Khan. In the house of Siri Guru Raam daas jee, where the only one who deserves any attention is Siri Guru Raam daas jee himself, people were doing shameless acts to get a glimpse of Salman Khan. This is what I am targeting at. Is this fair by any standards of Gurmat? -------------- There is a difference between worshipping someone as a hero and admiring someone, and even looking up to someone with regards to their athleticism in sport - there is nothing wrong with the latter position. ---------- Okay you can appreciate an athlete for his physical skill but how correct is it to get obsessed with this athlete and to hang his pictures in your home, to dream about this athlete, to have feelings of infatuation for this athlete etc. Okay, lets forget about sportspersons for a moment and focus on the actors of Bollywood; what quality of these actors should a Gursikh appreciate? Is there anything in these actors that a Gursikh can appreciate? None that I can think of. In the end, I want to clarify that it’s not appreciating a skill that I am against. What I am against is to consider the owner of this worldly skill to be next to God and to worship and get awed by him or her as if you would for God himself. Increasingly, I am getting amazed at the results this age of Kalyug is producing. A saakat is worshipped while a Gurmukh is slandered; amrit is considered to be sour and thus ignored but liquor and other poisons are considered to be sweet; we go after things we cannot attain and don’t belong to us but have no idea what belongs to us. All this is really a sign that Kalyug has come around in full swing. May Guru Sahib enable us, his humble Sikhs to not get tempted by the temptations of this world and to focus on our aim to meet Vaheguru. Kulbir Singh

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

chi chi · 02 Jun 2006

yeh i agree

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

a singh · 02 Jun 2006

well said kulbir veer ji, yet another beautiful post :)

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 02 Jun 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa vaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Jee has made a pretty good point, and one that shouldn't be ignored. You are incredibly right in the case of manmukhs being much appreciated over Gurmukhs, and this relates to all the people that think the ones that are "too" religious are extremists or terrorists whilst those who drink, smoke, commit adultery, cut hair are praised, which is another form of worship. If this age was satyug such a person wouldn’t be praised but perhaps killed whereas in this age of kalyug the religious are hated, so Vaheguru Jee in a way turned everything upside down where instead the religious are punished, in a sort of way. Thus, showing there to be no difference between a Gurmukh and Manmukh, just that a Gurmukh loves Vaheguru Jee but a Manmukh does not, even though Vaheguru Jee loves both the same amount. Vaheguru Jee has essentially taught us to live and get along in this world where demon and angel live together, so that only Vaheguru Jee is seen within everyone. This is why Vaheguru Jee created the Khalsa, as the Khalsa are the only ones that are able to see this love within all whereas others such as a Hindu, Muslim etc, would hate those who are different then them. So, Bhai sahib Kulbir Singh Jeeo what others like bhai sahib ‘some1’ Jeeo are doing is looking at the good points of another, but not bad, which is what a Gursikh should do in order to remain humble. But at least the being should know to always remember who they are, which is a Sikh. But you’re right as well, because if a sikh praises a celebrity for instance, then the sikh would want to be more like the celebrity, and thus forgetting who they are. My personal opinion is that one should not praise a Gurmukh or Manmukh, but instead, profoundly focus on ones self and ask yourself if you really love Vaheguru Jee. But then if yes, that person should do as much as Naam bhagti, jap naam Aat pehar, follow all rehits, and seva, as much as they can, and become that Gurmukh themselves. Even though becoming a gurmukh isn’t the aim. Sorry if that didn’t make any sense. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

some1 · 02 Jun 2006

Kulbir veerji, please, we have to live a worldly life as well as a spirtual life. but i agree down with kanjarwood...boycott allt hings indian.

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

hsdsms · 02 Jun 2006

personally i don't care about bollywood actors, but I must say that I do respect certain sports personalities. And Kulbir Singh, not ALL sports professionals are bad people. Alot of them are ppl of high moral character.

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

Singh · 02 Jun 2006

Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh jee who are you to judge wheather someone is manmukh or not. Your meant to be the dust of their feet, not saying negative things about them. This will affect your spirtuality if you think like this Bhai Sahib Jee!!

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

unreal · 03 Jun 2006

Kulbir Singh ji, I don't think there is anything upsetting about putting Baba Deep Singh ji and Lemieux in the same sentence, in the manner that I did - I clearly stated that the term 'hero' applied to each of them in a different fashion and context - I took great efforts to point out I was not equating the two. I agree with you that worshipping any such athletes is wrong but, honestly, I haven't seen Sikh youth doing this; however, I haven't spent much time with Sikh youth this past year due to work so you may be speaking from a better position than me. I think the worship or ridiculous admiration of a person themself, be it an athlete or a singer or a 'baba' is detrimental to a Sikh - I agree with you in this - such worship is solely reserved for Guru and the principles espoused by the Guru's Sikhs. It is for a reason our Guru said, "It is the principles (of Sikhi) I love, not the Sikh himself." Actors don't really impress me and I don't find myself admiring them for what they do - they are cheap entertainment for me at best. However, there have been times I have been impressed and/or moved by an actor's skill. For example, there is a movie called Whale Rider which takes place in New Zealand and has to do with a young (10 year old?) girl's relationship with her grandfather, all in the context of the Maori culture. Most of the actors had never acted before and I was very impressed with the young girl's acting. (I highly recommend this movie - it's slow, but I think it's a good family movie and enjoyable.) I was also quite impressed with the actor who did the voice for Gollum in Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy - almost exactly as I imagined when I read the books! Everything said, I think we agree that the worship of anything outside of our Guru and the principles our Guru ji has laid out is not justified, only that our definition of hero may be different. thank you, unreal

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

2006 · 03 Jun 2006

Singh please dont have a go at a Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh jeo.. as he is only stating a point.. he is not judging no one he with reference to gurbani is only stating the truth. Thank you Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh!

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

aho gul sunnoh · 03 Jun 2006

guru gobind singh is the proper don hero

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 03 Jun 2006

VaheguruJeekaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKEeFateh Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Jee hasn't said anything wrong, he has just stated the truth and the obvious, because some people praise people that they want to be like. But one should try and be like Guru Gobind Singh Jee, and that should be the only thing on ones mind, as everything else besides Guru jee is a road to Maya. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

reality · 03 Jun 2006

Actually on this occassion i agree with Bhai Kulbir singh ji, the reason I have been a fanatic football fan (soccer for canadians) for years, I played it at high level but due to colour etc really never made it, looking back though and looking where I am now, I wish to god I had focused on my sikhi more, so many years wasted on pursuing something which would have led me away from sikhi in the first place, yes sport is good for exercise, admiring anothers skill is okay but what happens is the obession of trying to become that good, spend soo many hours wasting them when in reality our youth is most precious is sikhis, a time for learning gurbani paath, gurmat vidhiya, history of sikhi etc, yet we can spend hours on sports and TV, really we can justify what we want but when we look at in depth we as parents should help our children lay down solid foundations for their sikhi, so that if they are tested in the future of Kalyug memories of heroes like Baba Deep singh, Bhai mani Singh, Bhai Sati Das, Bhai Mati das, Baba Zorwar singh, Baba fatheh singh, to name a few should come to the mind and help them overcome, not some sportsman !!! what good will that do. Plesae don't take this the wrong way but we have moved to the west and become like the gorea as well, we really need to get back to our sikhi faster than we are. Vaheguru ji ka khalsaa Vaheguru ji ki fateh...

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

sarbloh · 04 Jun 2006

WAHEGURUJIKAAKHALSA WAHEGURUJIKEEFATEH Everyday in our nitnem,we read tav prasad svayiye.In that Guru Ji tells us that even if one is the best warrior(equivalent to say best soccer player in the world),that person is just a BEGGAR who has got this gift from Waheguru.I think the gurvaak says "jachak anek su ekk davviyaa". Basically whole creaton is of beggars and the supreme beggar is one who has got the gift of SIFT SALAT.In japji sahib we read "jisno bakhse sifti salah,nanak patshahi patshah". So what i think is 1.Admiring a KANJARR is wrong. 2.Admiring a sports person is wrong.Instead just admire waheguru ji for creating such a skill and giving it to this sportsman(beggar). 3.Admiring a saint is correct as he has merged in waheguru and hence admiring him means admiring waheguru ji only. Basically make sure that you dont admire anyone apart from Waheguru ji as everyone else is just a beggar.

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

A Singh · 28 Jun 2006

Nothing in this world is bad, after all it is God's creation. It is basically our mind set and our outlook with which we make things good and bad. I see a lot of films, I see Amitabh Bachchan, I have a lot to learn after observing him. I think if as a film maker I have to use or promote a Sikh character how can it be done. How will it enhance the Sikh youth today to feel proud of being a Sikh. The Good and Bad are part of nature, it is upto us what to accept and what to reject. But we certainly have no right to criticize any one. There are some very well make Punjabi films in the 1960s and 70s "Nanak Naam Jahaj" and "Guru Maneo Granth" which were heavily criticized by the Nihags and and many Sikh Organisations. I did not see any thing wrong or offensive as such in these films. But in persent times the Sikh image potrayl is horrible. Why? We don't have a media of our own. I have seen many Amritdhari Sikhs brought up in isolation. When such people go in the outside world many turn out to be failures. Our Gurus have interacted with saints and fakir from all cultures and derived the Guru Granth Sahib. Unfortunately today our so called scholars of Sikh faith are isolating our own people by saying this is good and this bad. Some time ago I read the book "You can Win" by Shiv Khera. It is indeed a very well written book. It gives examples of many personalities world wide who great failures intially before they became successfull. His teachings are very much in line with Bani. But since it is written by some Non Sikh we may say it is bad.

Re: Gursikhs having false Heroes

freaks · 28 Jun 2006

You people are all wack!! For once i totally agree with kulbir singh!!! Admiring a sports person is only ok as long as you admire them for that skill... ie if your an aspiring soccer play and u admire bekham for his soccer skills. But the problem is when sikhs start to admire the person itself!! I think kulbir singh is only talking about amridhari sikhs here as well... no one realy cares if a non amridhari worships a bolleywood star. Amridharis path is different, and its the same for all of us! and as part of that if we worships people who have no love for god we will slow down our own progression. Good job to ANTI-MANMUKH-WORSHIPPING CREW!!