Re: So...why do Tapoban Singhs oppose ding Simran during Kirtan?
Kulbir Singh · 03 Jun 2006
"Sardar jee",
You have been misguided with respect to this issue. Tapoban Singhs don't oppose simran in kirtan at all. Kirtan cannot be heard without doing simran. While listening to kirtan and while singing kirtan, Gursikhs continue the khanda of Naam gupto-gupt inside, using the Naam Abhyaas vidhi taught by the Punj Pyaray. What we suggest (not impose) is that dhuni of Vaheguru Vaheguru should not be uttered by the kirtaniya. Kirtaniya should just do Gurbani kirtan as written in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Here are some points to ponder upon:
1) When doing shabad of Gurbani, we must keep the sanctity of the Shabad by maintaining the sequence of it. To sing anything from outside does not seem right. If there was a need to say "Vaheguru Vaheguru" or "Dhan Guru Nanak" in the shabad, Guru Sahib would have indicated this in the shabad. In the absence of this, we have no right to break the sequence of the shabad.
2) The Kirtaniya knows that sangat is singing behind him. He also knows that sitting in sangat are individuals who have not yet taken amrit. By doing dhuni in open program, the kirtaniya is japping Naam to individuals who have not yet received Naam from Guru Sahib i.e. are not amritdhari yet. This seems to be a wrong practice.
3) It has been confirmed by many Singhs of Bhai Sahib's times that at that time, Dhuni was not done. There were instances where the kirtaniya would lose control over himself due to extreme ecstasy coming from Kirtan and at that time sangat would just do Vaheguru Vaheguru. But the way dhuni is done now a days was not to be found in those days.
4) The fortunate Gursikhs who have attained Naam from Punj Pyaray know what the correct way of Naam Abhyaas is. Doing dhuni is certainly not the Gurmat Vidhi of Naam Abhyaas. When we have been blessed with the Gurmat Dhuni, how can we justify doing Naam by any other method but the swaas swaas Gurmat Jugti?
Having said the above, let us please refrain from arguing over this. We have no allergy from Dhuni and if someone wants to do it, they can do so. We don't do dhuni ourselves just like a lot of Jatha Singhs in India. We don't do dhuni and we advise others not to do it but if someone wants to do it, we don't have any issues with that person. Dhuni does not affect our relationship with anyone.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: So...why do Tapoban Singhs oppose ding Simran during Kirtan?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Jun 2006
absolutely correct veer Ji.
GURBANI is "complete"....no need to add or subtract any words...to add to its attraction/raag/dhuns/ etc etc.
The Kirtaiya owes it to himself that he DOES NOT DISTORT the Shabad as written in Gurbani/Sri guru Garanth ji Sahib. That is DISRESPECT..and what is WORSE than this disrespect is those Kitaniyas who take a Tuk or two from as many as Five or ten Different SHABADS and Mix and Match...They DONT complete even ONE SHABAD...just jump from one to the other.. I beleve Prof darsahn Singh Ex Jathedar of Akal takhat is the ORIGINATOR of this type of Mishra Kirtan...and now practically everyone does this...SERIOUS DISRESPECT !! of GURBANI.
And then of course the Sants/Derawadees..who MIX their won self amde tunes and Kachee bani..into Gurbani tuks and make up their own song..interspersed with loud aakho stanam sri waheguru and Bolo ji..sareh Boloh ji..
Kirtan means NIROL GURBANI..
Re: So...why do Tapoban Singhs oppose ding Simran during Kirtan?
Harcharan Singh · 04 Jun 2006
Vahe-Guru ji ka Khalsa Vahe-Guru ji ki Fateh,
I totally agree with Veer Kulbir ji that simran should not be done during shabad kirtan.
We must strictly adhere to Maharajs kirtan maryada.
For the same reason that veer ji has explained that we should not insert simran into shabad kirtan, we should also always use the rahao as the chorus and epi-centre of the the shabad and abide by Guru Ji's hukum of how to render the shabad, in the ordained raag.
I hope my veers at Tapoban Sahib Ji will see the common sense in this also, and have the spirit to challenge and change the status quo and become Gurmat Kirtan role models to the Tapoban inspired sangat.
Daas
Re: So...why do Tapoban Singhs oppose ding Simran during Kirtan?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 05 Jun 2006
Author: Bundha
Date: 06-05-06 05:18
following in on from what I said earlier,.....
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<,
I am sorry i couldnt find any earlier post by bundha ji....
Anyway for once I too agree with bundha Ji...
2. Naam hug....I got a taste of this when a veer really "looked forward" to meeting me after reading all my posts on this Forum and elsewhere....He came all the way from a foreign land..and when we "met"...He HUGGED ME..and I responded in normal Gursikh Style....
Apparently that was NOT a NAAM HUGG ( from my side..as I am NOT an AKJ while he is..) and he was sorely disappointed thats i didnt have the "naam hugg"...i told him i am not akj....He has NOT contacted me again...
From what i gathered subsequently..the Naam hugg is when an AKJ Singh huggs you..he begins Naam Japp WAHEGURU..WAHEGURU..NON STOP until YOUR Naam Japp BEGINS..soemthing akin to KABADDEE...kabadee kabadee until one runs out of breath..
IF i am wrong...please forgive me but this is what i gathered from that meeting...
Re: So...why do Tapoban Singhs oppose ding Simran during Kirtan?
Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 05 Jun 2006
VAheguruJEeKaaKhalsa VahegurujeeKeeFateh
Bhai Sahib 'Sardar' Jeeo, what you've stated is completely wrong. Sorry but the other names of God such as Allah, Raam, Har etc, are not Vaheguru Jee's real name, as his real name is Vaheguru. So, those who jap this name in Kalyug will, get some where.
The other names have no power in this age, as Kalyug has grown much stronger so only Vaheguru will help. Also, why is someone going to jap Allah if they know that God's real name is Vaheguru? Guru Jee has stated this to be a fact that Vaheguru is the unknown and secret name of God, which has been kept gupt throughout Satyug to Dvaapar, but from Guru Jee whom Vaheguru Jee gave the true name to has provided us with this name through the Panj Pyarai, which is Guru Gobind Singh Jee.
Sat Sri Akaal
Re: So...why do Tapoban Singhs oppose ding Simran during Kirtan?
Hargurmit Singh · 06 Jun 2006
Vahiguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Jee Kee Fateh
When abhiyas and academics collide, this is what happens.
Abhiyas gives you all the powers without having to read a book on a subject. It takes you places that no aeroplane or submarine can take you to.
Academic knowledge is restricted to debate based on ones own understanding of content written in a book or heard from some "expert". There is no "realisation or anubhav" of that experience.
That is why there is an argument as to whether Vahiguru is the Gurmantar or some other words for Vahiguru are equally good. A person who has done or does moolmantar and vahiguru mantar paaths focuses on these mantars without any "doubt" that these mantars will help him on his spiritual path. Others debate these mantars.
The Abhiyasee keeps getting the raas out of this so he exits the debate forum. he is so contended that he does not need to argue or articulate. with the exit of the abhiyasees, the field is open to all academicians to fill up the airwaves or the forum waves and create confusion for aspirants.
this is what happens to most debates on this forum and other forums as well - the conclusion is only a restatement of every individuals positions but not a resolution of the matter in hand.
Simran during kirtan is a new practise started by nouveau ragis. it did not exist 100 years ago. Mixing and matching tuks from here and there has a longer history. I just heard the Liaqat Alis do kirtan in Delhi (they claim to be descendants of Bhai Mardana) and they also never completed a shabad - but would bring the central paart of the shabad and reinforce it with about 5 parmands from different shabads at the end of which the message really sank in. Whether Guru Sahib would approve of this way of doing kirtan - i dont know. But if these people who have only been doing kirtan without exposure to the indian ragis for 50 years can do parmanith kirtan then PERHAPS this parmanith kirtan has a longer history than the vahiguru simran in kirtan.
If we would all focus on doing kirtan by ourselves, then we dont need ragis (at least these "Bhadda" seeking ragis - Bhadda is a colloquial expression used in the taxi trade where u determine the "tarriff" before starting the journey - it is different from bhetha where the amount is given on your sharda and ability and at the END of the journey - or the kirtan.) who ask you before they land how much you will pay them and tell you for what duration they will "perform".
None of the ones that i have met (and sorry to say i have met a whole lot of them - all these "prasid kirtanias") have been blessed with what Guru Nanak Sahib tells us in Jup every morning - "Jis nuu bakshee sifat salaah, nanak badshahee badshaa". If they had then they would not ask for bhaddha for singing his sifat (praise) and nor would they restrict it to a duration.
Sorry for going of tangent here - but if we sit through ragis playing around with tuks, doing vahiguru simran in the middle and at the end paying them the prearranged bhaddha then we only encourage them to continue with this practise.
[%sig%]