Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Singh · 05 Jun 2006

The below does not seem to be doen with proper maryada: or may be I am being to hardcore? http://www.mrsikhnet.com/

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Satnam · 05 Jun 2006

American sikhs are still learning path of sikhism I appreciate their dedication to sikhism. ***admin cut for not sticking to the subject.***

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

. · 05 Jun 2006

That isnt right is it .. .to show what happens in a amrit sanchaar..

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

some1 · 05 Jun 2006

omg

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

... · 05 Jun 2006

im pretty sure the khanda they are using is made of steel an shouldnt panj piare know there panj bania off by heart:S?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

explain · 05 Jun 2006

will somone care to explain what is wrong with these pictures for those who don't know much about the amrit sanchar maryada?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Harmeet Singh · 05 Jun 2006

vaheguru jee ka khalsa || vaheguru jee kee fateh || don't be shocked... you will see a lot of amrit sanchar photos out there on the internet these days. vaheguru jee ka khalsa || vaheguru jee kee fateh ||

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Sacha Banda · 05 Jun 2006

American Sikhs are still learning so they are unknowingly making some mistakes in the Vidhi. But what excuse to Punjabi or Indian Sikhs have for not even using Laridar Sroops at Amrit Sanchars? Padched Sroops are a recent innovation that started 50-60 years ago. But at Amrit Sanchaars Padched Sroops have only been widely used for the last 30 or so years. One dhil leads to other dhils. We need to come back to the puritanical ways of the Khalsa and leave all of these innovations and deviations.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

babajee · 05 Jun 2006

panj pyara is wearing a ring!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Singh · 06 Jun 2006

Nishkam sevak jatha take pic and videos of amrit sanchars please don't put american sikhs down we need to get the panth as 1 the pic look amazing even tho i agree it is wrong

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

E · 06 Jun 2006

nope it is not proper maryada, you are right, but this is not unusual, very few amrit sanchars are done in correct maryada as was done originally when dasm patsah started the khalsa, to start with anyone who knows a bit of history knows roop of panj pyare is 5 singhs. Those who have faith in bhai randhir singh, and trust that he reminded us of what dasm patsah initially instructed are very lucky.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Gandalf · 06 Jun 2006

Wasn't the first amrit sanchar done publicly?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

some1 · 06 Jun 2006

not a ring, what is this world comming to?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Jasdeep Singh · 06 Jun 2006

If they are doing amrit wrong, then we should provide support and help them learn the correct way of doing it, but we must do it in a way that shows respect to them. They are at least trying to do it, and from what I can tell on their website they do really love Sikhi.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

. · 06 Jun 2006

Im kinda left speechless.. not in a bad way im suppose but not really in a good way either.. i mean yeah its amazing to see the love they have for waheguru ji.. but whats going wrong with us apnai 'punjabi's' its like we're getting more and more weaker.. oh i dont know?!!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

. · 06 Jun 2006

is it me or are they using a steel khanda ... isnt it ment to be sarbloh .. it is good that american sikhs are learning the sikhi way of life and are living the khalsa's life. But , they shouldnt make the mistakes they are making .. they should ask like erm how should i put it .. ' punjabi sikhs that already do it too maryada and do amrit sanchars right ' ( i hope i put it in right tense ) . And things like wearing rinds is just wrong and to be a punj piara you should no the punj bania of by heart .... or am i cleary of my nut and lost the plot ?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

nmop · 06 Jun 2006

vaheguroo ji ka khalsa vaheguroo ji ki fateh I dnt undastnd isnt it that the panj pyaare are 5 singhs since when are singhnias allowed 2 b in the panj pyaare? correct me if i am wrong. Also i noticed the ring and the steel khanda! vaheguroo ji ka khalsa vaheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

lai · 06 Jun 2006

extremism is not an aspect to sikhi. jewlery is NOT banned nor a paap. Shamsher pita wore a ruby jewel in the front of his dumala. Where do you get this "concept" that it is banned. relax. Lets have someone explain in their opinion what THEY think is wrong with the amrit sanchar other than women as the panj piareh.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

. · 06 Jun 2006

"Those who have faith in bhai randhir singh, and trust that he reminded us of what dasm patsah initially instructed are very lucky. " E you are so up yourself

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 06 Jun 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib 'nmop' Jeeo, a Singhni is allowed to take part in the panj pyarai, as gender or caste doesn't affect our religion in anyway. Sikhi is higher. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

nmop · 06 Jun 2006

bhupinder singh daas no ur rong roop has everything to do with panj pyare the roop is 5 gurmukh SINGHS

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

E · 06 Jun 2006

panj pyare were, still and will always be 5 singhs - from the day dasm patsah started the khalsa this cannot be changed, roop of panj is 5 singhs, dont ask me why, ask god, as this was preordained, just as all 10 guru's had male form - to call this discriminatory is to call god discriminatory - god write the script this is his play. bhupider singh - "gender or caste doesn't affect our religion in anyway" if this is so can a singh marry a singh? in anand karaj does the singhni walk infront of the singh? also i have asked several singhs and bibia from bhai sahibs time who knew bhai sahib personally also i have spoken to many who attended rensvais in bhai sahibs time none of the singhs or bibia ever witnessed or heard of singhnia in panj pyare - i ask those jatha singhs now who believe bibia should be allowed in panj why they think this is so do you think there werent any bibia chardi kala enough? this is rubbish because there were many gurmukh singhnees, including those mentioned in ranggle sajjan. it is a new practice which did not happen in akj of old, it is more common among new jathebandhe like the one in the pics the pics are evidence which show how the way amrit sanchars are done change over time, poeple use their own 'mat' - hence method of instilling amrit changes.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

anon · 07 Jun 2006

exscuse me "E" "in anand karaj does the singhni walk infront of the singh?" this has nothing to do with gurmat.its to do with culture totally and the previous and still prevelant stereotype that men are higher than women. this is not prevalent in gurmat, however, and so the man walking infront of the women serves no significance whatsoever.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 07 Jun 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Well said bhai/bibi 'anon' Jeeo!! I still stand by my word, and also bhai/bibi sahib 'anon' Jee is correct in what he/she stated. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bruce Lee · 07 Jun 2006

Of course women can serve in the punj. Does it mean gora can't be in the punj because the original punj were brown. Does it mean tharkhans can't be in the punj becauise 3 jatt Sikhs and 2 khatris stood up. In sikhi we don't have caste, gender or discrimiation.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

... · 07 Jun 2006

like now we're complaining about how their not doing the amrit sanchaar right........but even in england or something .....the next generation will end up like that aswellll cuz to be honest if you look around there are alottt of sikhs who are out of touch with sikhi......so really i dnt even think they are sikhs... ...we really should keep that maryada going somehow...i mean as generatiion is moving on they are bringing new light ....however.......some of the maryada is slipping away!!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

E · 07 Jun 2006

well anon look at the pictures of the wedding posted by admin anon - "this has nothing to do with gurmat.its to do with culture totally " http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=80499&t=39843#reply_80499 the singh is walking infront, is this not in accordance with gurmat? anyway you are going off topic, the point is there is a fundamental difference betweeen a singh and a singhni, and gender does play a role in sikhi. hence one is named singh, the other kaur. panj are 5 singhs fullstop. skin colour doesnt fudamentally change form of a singh. a singh is fundamentally different from a singhni. you havent responded to any of my other points, lets remain calm and keep this civilised minds should be kept open to the truth bruce lee, if women can be in panj why isit that all singhs and bibia from bhai sahibs time tell me they have never seen or heard of this occuring. do you think it was a coincidence that 5 singhs gave their head in 1699. 5 ....not 1 or 2 or 3, but ALL 5 - this was meant to be, script was written by god. this is not discrimination, it is just carrying out amrit sanchars with correct maryada -as was done and has always been done - we cannot change how they are done. putting women in panj changes maryada.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bruce Lee · 07 Jun 2006

There was a man from Bhai Sahibs times who told a gursikh that women were in the punj pyare. Balpreet Singh knows!!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

sikhsister · 07 Jun 2006

In 1699 Guru Gobind Singh ji gave Amrit Di Daat to only five 'Singhs'(males), can you show me some reference that Bibian also took Amrit that day? If so then Bibian was given equal place as far as taking Amrit as well as being part of 'Panj'. If not so, then leave the bibian alone, do not expect them to take Amrit either, let them be barbie dolls of hollywood & roam around the world to look for a Singhnee to marry. Excuse me for using harsh words, but the reality is that Sikhi has had enough 'Kamai vaale Singh' before who could represent Panj Piyare of Guru; so there was no need to include Singhniyaan for that purpose; BUT these days; the ratio has reversed and it is hard to find 'real sikhs' of Guru. They may be wearing Bana; but talk like many of you who put down their counterparts and have no respect for women. Singhniyaan on the other side are beginning to realize that 'sewa' alone in the kitchen is not enough, they need to devote same time and effort to enrich their souls with Bani and Simran. Contempary Sikh women are coming to the forefront in all areas of life; be it professional, religious or social. Sikh women are more involved in community projects (sewa) as compared to their male counterparts. As far as 'oontaayiaan' like 'reciting baanies by heart'; taking off jewellary; using only sarab-loh khanda; I suggest someone be polite enough to post the comments on that site, so it can be taken care of next time. http://www.mrsikhnet.com/index.php/2006/06/04/love/ Bhul chuk maaf karni ji Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Harcharan Singh · 07 Jun 2006

1 - In my personal opinion.... Some, people forget who the Khalsa was, they were an army, of Akaal Purkh, with Guru Gobind Singh Ji as the Commander. The Panj Pyare were the 1st soldiers and a specialist unit thereafter. This is proven by there importance in the years that followed, both spiritually, martially and politically. Even in Sikhi, on the large part, women have a high status, they were needed to look after and raise the children, and when necessary, then fight alongside their brithers shoulder to shoulder, but not as a first choice. As a 1st choice, the men will fight and die, therefore as long as there are able bodied and rehitvaan Gursikh Singhs, there is no need for a female panj. If the day ever came when there were not 5 capable Singhs, then it would be a different matter. The panj pyare are not simply dressed up for the day, they serve the same martial, spiritual and political purpose they did in the old days. It comes down to the fact that the panj pyare are frontline soldiers, the 1st to give their heads, therefore as per good culture, nature, survival, the men go to war 1st. 2 - The reason the Sikhni follows the Singh is that she is leaving her home and entering her spouses home, the Singh is leading her to his home and to her new life. Their is no big mystery, no cultural misunderstanding and no confusion. I think people get obsessed/carried away with political correctness. In Gods eyes man and woman are equal, and have equal opportunity to praise God, to sing to God, to pray to God, to spread his word, to defend his word....but in the last case, man will put his life at risk 1st, this is nature.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

babajee · 07 Jun 2006

Harcharan singh, do you know anything about lions? lionesses go out and do the hunting and even the fighting. The male lions defend the home, but the lionesses give the actual muscle. so what are you talking about nature? The first human civilizations were also like this.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

anon · 08 Jun 2006

yeh bhai sahib "E" so what about the picture put up by admin? wel lets ask the tapoban singhs if they think a man infront a woman serves any significance in terms of gurmat? why what significance do you think it shows?that men are of a higer status than women?? thats a slightly chauvanistic point of view....for a gursikh you beleive that there is some significance yet you dont actualy seem to know what the significance is.well thats very good isnt it. when bhai sahib bhupinder singh said "gender or caste doesn't affect our religion in anyway" i think bhai sahib meant that gender or caste SHOULDNT affect our FAITH. i think bhai sahib is trying to say that sikhi isnt culture bound. evidently gender naturally will mean that some sevas are ideal for women and other for men, thats just a result of our sociobiology.i agree both men and women have different roles, but when it comes to being in the panj...i dotn beleive there is no role division. also you say you have spoken to those in bhai sahibs times who have vouched for the fact that bibiyaan werent in the panj,well i can tell you there are others from bhai sahibs times who have said that on a few occasions bibiyaan were in the panj...so what do you say to that?? anyway instead of looking backwards lets look now at GURMAT. yes its true that the 5 who gave their heads that day were singhs...i bet there wernt even any singhnaa present there, they were proabbly at home cooking, cleaning etc. that was the culture of the time. and bhai sahib "harchaarn singh" "man will put his life at risk 1st, this is nature." his life is not at risk, if it is for guruji that he is giving his head.infact "true life" is guaranteed for those who give their head.so your theory doesnt really work. anywyas just because they diednt come forward doesnt mean they were less willing.let me ask you this, do you think that mata sahib kaur who stired the amrit was any less willing to give her head than the panj???? she wasnt even officially "amritdhari" then and was given the amazing seva of, in essence, putting naam into the amrit.isnt this the BIGGEST SEVA???? so your saying, she would not have given her head?? if mata sahib kaur was given the seva to stir the amrit which was subsequently given to the panj pyaare, why would you think that gurugobind singh ji would be against bibyaan being in the panj now??? think about it.her role seems to be the highest really...dont you think?? forgive any mistakes.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

??? · 08 Jun 2006

very good post from harcharan singh!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

singh · 08 Jun 2006

in my eyes i think women should do the sme as men as in sikhi me are the same sorry if i sed anything wrong

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 08 Jun 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib 'Harcharan Singh' Jeeo, Singhs can go to war first as well, while the Singhs stay at home and look after the children. Now, do you know why I used Singh for the two priorities mentioned above, because a Singh is a female as well as a male Sikh. There'e no difference. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Jasdeep Singh · 08 Jun 2006

When a women takes amrit she gives her head to Guru ji, jsut like if a man takes Amrit. She is one of gods children jsut like men. We have to remember back in that time our Guru's told us they were the same as men, but the people (man) and punjabi culture was not ready for such a change, and thus womens roles were limited not by Guru ji, but by men. We now live in a time that this is all changed, women are recognised as our equals in culture finally, thus the culture has changed. Most of the arguments agaisnt women are cultural and not Sikhi, so if you want to talk on culture issues then look at our culture now, If people want to look at it from a Sihki side then women can be one of the Panj. Culture has no effect on sikhi, Sikhi is the greatest faith to ever emerge, and sikhi teaches us to be equals so we must get all this biased and gender and caste stuff out of our faith. Guru Gohbind gee was a great Great Great soul, Guru, writer, he had a pure soul, do you really think he would have denied a women for the panj pyare of course not. Man rejests it cuase it does not conform to mans ideas, man has problems with it becuase man has a hard time accepting women as equals thus having to treat and respect women as equals scares many men; for fear of power loss. We have to take our old ideas that we were raised withthat are not sikhi and flush them down the toliet. [%sig%]

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

E · 08 Jun 2006

anon - "yeh bhai sahib "E" so what about the picture put up by admin? wel lets ask the tapoban singhs if they think a man infront a woman serves any significance in terms of gurmat?" you should read my posts before you post, ive alredy answered your question quote "point is there is a fundamental difference betweeen a singh and a singhni, and gender does play a role in sikhi. hence one is named singh, the other kaur." you are trying to argue that there is no difference between a singh and a singhni, but the truth is there is, one is male the other female. panj pyare are made up of 5 males, why? because thats how god ordained it to be so. panj pyare are 5,why? because thats how god ordained it to be so. anon -"also you say you have spoken to those in bhai sahibs times who have vouched for the fact that bibiyaan werent in the panj,well i can tell you there are others from bhai sahibs times who have said that on a few occasions bibiyaan were in the panj...so what do you say to that??" there is a rumour that on ONE OCCASION, ONE BIBI was included in panj. now i ask you, do you not find this strange, that out of all the amritsanchars done in the period there was only ONE OCCASION when a singhni was in panj, and even then it was only ONE bibi. if its NORMAL PRACTICE to include singhnia in panj, would you not expect at least 2 0r 3 singhnia in EVERY amritsanchar????? i have spoken directly to several who new bhai sahib personally, have you?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

E · 08 Jun 2006

babajee sed - "do you know anything about lions? lionesses go out and do the hunting and even the fighting. The male lions defend the home, but the lionesses give the actual muscle. so what are you talking about nature?" lionesses hunt and provide food for family, males fight for territory and look after females when attacked by other lions, females definatley do not mess with the males - watch some nature programmes. nature harcharan singh is talkin about is that fact that god made males stronger than females 99% of dasm patsahs fauj were singhs, this is the role males play in nature when burglars set off the alarm in my house, my dad goes downstairs with the kirpan, not my mom. i think this is what harcharan singh was trying to say harcharan singh is saying males and females have different strenghs he's not saying one is superior over the other.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

sanjo · 08 Jun 2006

das would rather take amrit from a chardi kala bibi who jaaps an immense amount of naam rather than a singh who is just getting his place in the panj due to his gender. what does everyone else think? if the amrit sanchar is about giving the abhlakee naam n planting it within them then the focus should be on naam. akj emhpasises that the panj must be chardi kala rehitvan gursikhs. if the emphasis is on naam then the most suitable rehitvan gursikhs should be chosen to plant the naam within the abklakee. irrespective of gender. just because gursikhs from bhai sahib randhir singhs times used to do certain things doesnt mean that it ends there n we must accept it without asking questions. guru ji has giving u the capability of cognition and has given women equal chance to jaap naam. so the question is whats more important during amrit sanchar. the physical saroop of the panj or the spiritual level of the panj? can a singh who has never woken up for amrit vela or never jaaped naam give naam to another??? in this case wouldnt you prefer a rehitvan singhni to do this seva??? [%sig%]

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 08 Jun 2006

well said bhai sahib 'sanjo' jeeo!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Jasdeep Singh · 08 Jun 2006

Yes Well said in deed.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Harjas Kaur · 08 Jun 2006

"Even in Sikhi, on the large part, women have a high status, they were needed to look after and raise the children, and when necessary, then fight alongside their brithers shoulder to shoulder, but not as a first choice." Women are never a secomd choice, because there are no choices in war, only necessity. An army is twice as fierce with strong women fighting with it. An army is twice as weak with women trailing behind it. In the next war, it may well be a bibi who saves your life. Either with a kirpan, a gun, bandages or langar. But your survival, our survival is dependant on our unity. There is no room for second class soldiers, citizens. There is only one Khalsa panth. And as far as I know, Gurbani says that women are in it. What does the world know about women that Sikhs themselves have forgotten? When you need them, women aren't second place, they are front and center, proud, strong and free. [%sig%]

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

. · 09 Jun 2006

yep totally agree with "sanjo"

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

E · 12 Jun 2006

das would rather take amrit from a chardi kala bibi who jaaps an immense amount of naam rather than a singh who is just getting his place in the panj due to his gender. what does everyone else think? how about a gurmukh whos gender is ambiguos?, thus form is changed, like if part of ones body is not complete (ang heen) "so the question is whats more important during amrit sanchar. the physical saroop of the panj or the spiritual level of the panj?" answer = physical saroop reason = a bram gyaini who has merged with god cannot be in panj if he is angheen

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 12 Jun 2006

Vaheguroo!! Jee Kaa KHalsa!! Vaheguru Jee Kee FATEH!! Bhai SAhib 'E' Jeeo: Wrong! The physical saroop doesn't matter and it doesn't effect the ones who they give amrit to. However, the spiritual level does because if the Singh hasn't japped a lot of Naam or doesn't follow most of the rehit then this will certainly effect the one taking amrit. Haumai will effect that person taking amrit. So, the Panj have to be a Khalsa and a 'bram gyaini'!! Vaheguroo!! Jee Kaa KHalsa!! Vaheguru Jee Kee FATEH!!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

a(o) · 12 Jun 2006

bhupinder singh if physical saroop dnt mata ansa the question of y an ang heen singh cannot do seva in the panj of course it matters. the panj pyareh represent bhai daya singh, bhai dharam singh, bhai himat singh, bhai sahib singh and bhai mokam singh/ how can a singhni represent them?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 12 Jun 2006

Vaheguru Jee KAa Khalsa Vaheguroo Jee Kee FAteh!! 'how can a singhni represent them?' Whenever I say Singh in my text i'm refering to a female as well. So if the Singh has a high spiritual level how can she/he not represent those mentioned in your post? For instance, every Singh is meant to be like Guru Gobind Singh Jee in which means possessing all qualities of the names of these Singhs, so again how can one with a high spiritual level of such a possesson of qualities not be apart of the Panj. On the journey to Vaheguru Jee every Singh achieves such qualities, as these are not restriced only to males. But, both females and males can obtain such qualities and will, regardless of gender, be allowed in Saachkhand. Also, you're saying only a male can enter Saachkhand but not a female because only they can possess such qualities! Incorrect, as there are so many females in Saachkhand, even as we speak, who were only allowed in this realm due to their virtues. Whoever enters Saachkhand would have attained the virtues of the original Panj Piarey. Now, if gender mattered so much then why did Guru Gobind Singh Jee wed Mata Sahib Kaur and then initiate her as the MOTHER OF KHALSA, ALONGSIDE GURU GOBIND SINGH JEE BEING THE FATHER!! Guru Jee wouldn't choose a female who has sinned so much to be the mother of the purist of pure, the Khalsa, but someone being worthy of such a position - hence possessing virtues of honour to put someone there on that high position. Gender doesn't play a role in Sikhi, and for those who would ask why then cannot a male marry a female is due to the type of union Vaheguru Jee has created in which Guru Sahib Jee states many times; the union of a husband and wife where Vaheguru Jee is the husband and we the bride. This union of husband and wife has been played from time ago to now. In addition, if a male did get married to another male then how can they produce children, and so in this way Vaheguru Jee has only given a significance and meaning to the marriage of a man and woman. Now ponder over the Gurbani line provided below. Nothing can be seen except for Vaheguru Jee. There is no Bhupinder Singh but just Vaheguru Jee existing within and throughout every substance in this world and the next. sabh eaek dhrisatt samath kar dhaekhai sabh aatham raam pashhaan jeeo || They look upon all with equality, and recognize the Supreme Soul, the Lord, pervading among all. If the physical body did matter so much why do we have a Guru in the form of a book? Why did Guru Nanak Dev Jee tell Lehna Jee (Guru Angad Dev Jee’s former name) to eat his body and why was then Lehna Jee about to eat it? Well the answer is because Lehna Jee was in love with Guru Sahib Jee not the body. We have to learn that this body is temporal and that a soul is and can be reborn in a body of a female. Anyone of us could have been a female or male in our past lives, it doesn’t necessarily mean we were in the physical body we are in now then as well. Again, this materialistic body is only temporal and can turn to dust anytime, as only the soul is eternal. Bhai Lehna Jee saw the truth and that is why he became Guru, and so in this way if we learn to see the truth so can we be allowed in Saachkhand to reunite with our beloved husband. Vaheguroo Jee KaaKhalsa Vaheguru Jee kee FAteh!!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

mr o and mr mow · 13 Jun 2006

bhupinder singh, "Whenever I say Singh in my text i'm refering to a female as well." right........., thts quite silly, female a singh..... "So if the Singh has a high spiritual level how can she/he not represent those mentioned in your post? " bcos like i sed b4, physical saroop DOES matter. duh, a angheen brahmgyani cannot partake seva in the panj. full stop. stop tryin 2 speak rubbish to get out of it "Also, you're saying only a male can enter Saachkhand but not a female because only they can possess such qualities!" where did ny1 say tht singhnis cant enter sach khand? doin seva in the panj pyare requires a physical saroop as well as certain spirtual level. dnt twist words, if u have nything intillegent 2 say, please reply, if u gona twist words and make up ur own rehit, then please get out

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 13 Jun 2006

Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguroo Jee Kee FATEH!! Listen bhai sahib jeeo, the argument was on gender not disability; if a female is allowed to partake in the panj pyiara, not if someone disabled is. So, is a female somewhat disabled is that what you're declaring? Also, if you don't have a proper argument to go against what I've said then don't post, especially if you're going act so childish by bringing up such ridiculous points to amuse yourself. Read the whole of my post which I bet you haven't done. You cannot change what gurmat is and gurmat has nothing to do with gender. This gender has turned into a status for Sikhs. Just because the original panj were males this doesn’t affect Sikhi to the extent of believing in the physical form to have a significance or role. Only Muslims believe males and females to have their own roles in which the males have a higher authority and role to play whereas females with lower roles which are not of any value. Is this in the teachings of Gurmat? I thought we don’t believe in the caste system, because you’re trying to state that females are lower then males so only they can partake in the panj. When five chardi kala Bhramgyanis unite as five then nothing can be see except for Guru Gobind Singh Jee, not a Singh with smaller dhaari then another singh or a singh without dhaari (hence a female), but just Guru Gobind Singh Jee. Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguroo Jee Kee FATEH!!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

mr e and mr mow · 15 Jun 2006

bhupinder singh, this is not rocket science a man missing a single toe, is not 'disabled' but is still not conforming to the form that the panj must be in. it is really quite silly to equate being female to being disabled, and shows that your argument doesn't have any substance the point trying to be made is that gender itself is irrelevant, but the gender of a man gives the individual a specific form which qualifies them to be acceptable for panj seva. if there is a deviation from this form - whether it is a missing toe, disability, or different gender - means that individual is no longer able to do this seva, please refrain from trotting around you have written "When five chardi kala Bhramgyanis unite as five then nothing can be see except for Guru Gobind Singh Jee" no, if these brahmgyanis are missing a finger, toe, eye etc, then they are not acceptable for panj seva. this is nothing to do with females being lower than males, you are trying to make it sound that way as you have no argument.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 15 Jun 2006

Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee kee FAteh! 'but the gender of a man gives the individual a specific form which qualifies them to be acceptable for panj seva.' You're talking complete rubbish. You have nothing to base your argument on and stop bringing angheen Bhramgyanis into this. You're still going off topic, look forget it. This argument is a waste of time so you believe what you want to and I'll believe what Gurmat promotes. You will one day see equality, if not today. Both genders have the same light, both genders have the same parents, both genders can reach saachkhand and both genders have a soul. That's what matters, not the materialistic body. This is what makes the goraa Sikhs much more better, besides the jewelrey part, as they can see this equality so clearly though for people like you find so much difficulity and are stuck in perhaps tradition or ego of a male's physical body being higher then a females. Females are exactly the same but with just a different physical body - that is it, nothing else. It's not 'rocket science'. Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee kee FAteh!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

singh · 15 Jun 2006

Panj piare can never be exactly the same roop as the Original Panj. For example, a white Singh cannot do seva in Panj because he is white and the Original Singhs were Asian, the Bana they wear should be exactly the same, every single thing should be EXACT (like the Dastar should be tied the same way also)...Obviously physical does not matter so your arguement is baseless. The food that you eat everyday should be Amrit, prepared in Sarab Loh, so then don't let your Singhnia cook for you. This type of attitude is the Muslim/Hindu-mat that Guru Nanak Dev Ji was trying to take out of us. What you are saying is more cultural rather than Spiritual or religious. [%sig%]

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

E · 15 Jun 2006

singh you havent understood what has been said fact - a singh who's form is incomplete / has been altered (eg losing part of body) cannot be in panj, no matter how chardi kala he is. fact - gender fundamentally changes form, not to go into details, but having a gender change is completely different from your skin changing colour (eg tanning) fact - gender gives both males and females separate and different forms. fact - if ones gender was ambiguous, he would be considered angheen, eg a genetic male who doesnt have a complete male phenotype (outward structure) thus gender plays a role in saroop of the panj.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

babajee · 15 Jun 2006

WHY ARENT ANGHEEN PEOPLE ALLOWED? USE YOUR COMMON SENSE!! if one cannot kneel or stir the khanda, then they cannot be panj pyare, it doesnt mean that if one cut their finger and has a scar, they lose the seva.. use your common sense, how can a panj do the duty of being a panj if they cannot stand, hold a kirpan or stir the khanda, or administer the amrit?? Thats why that rehat is there.. now heres a question... WHAT DOES THAT HAVE TO DO WITH BIBIAN? are you saying just because they are female they are disabled and therefore cant do the seva? Wow, this really shows your level of intelligence.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 15 Jun 2006

Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee FATEH!! Bhai Sahib 'E' Jeeo: 'fact - a singh who's form is incomplete / has been altered (eg losing part of body) cannot be in panj, no matter how chardi kala he is.' Nothing to do with gender unless if you're stating that females are all incomplete, which would be completely ridiculous. You have no argument here. 'fact - gender fundamentally changes form, not to go into details, but having a gender change is completely different from your skin changing colour (eg tanning)' This sounds more like a joke, so again there's no argument here. 'fact - gender gives both males and females separate and different forms.' And whats your point? There spritiuallity counts not their physical body. Thats only temporal for the world; its not needed for the next. 'fact - if ones gender was ambiguous, he would be considered angheen, eg a genetic male who doesn’t have a complete male phenotype (outward structure)' Oh come on, that doesn't consider the person to be angheen - so that means you are referring to females being angheen every time you or anyone else says that. Equality goes above religion, as it is seen through the soul which is Vaheguru Jee and Vaheguru Jee is above religion and thus sees one light everywhere. We also have to see this. This equality will come from Naam. Jap Naam aat pehar and we will only feel love and compassion, and the divine knowledge of truth. The truth is Vaheguru Jee and only he will be seen. Furthermore, Vaheguru Jee has no form, as we all know, and so Vaheguru Jee has done this so that no one sees a female or male to be higher but just an equal entity of a materialistic form to be the only difference. Though, the spiritual form always to be the same, light. Even though one may see Bhramgyanis in Saachkhand with dhaari and others not with dhaari this is all just the formless light of Vaheguru Jee. They don’t see a difference, but when we do reach Saachkhand we will not see a difference between them as well. This thinking is manmat. Gurmat is what one would see in Saachkhand, complete equality. Guru Gobind Singh Jee didn’t change the name Khalsa to khalsee for a female, but left it to be the same Khalsa for both males and females, as Khalsa is above everything in this world including religion as it sees complete truth. The Khalsa has equality and so in this way the kakaar keski was given so that both females and males can be seen equally. Finally, the Khalsa is made out of naam which evolves around humbleness in which not to see one to be inferior, disadvantaged, or worse then another from their physical form or spiritual form. The physical form is nothing, its dust and its worth nothing if it doesn’t have a high spirituality of naam. Now, the Khalsa is capable of having this high spirituality of naam. A female is able to wear all the kakaars given by Guru Jee just as males are, females… There isn’t any point of carrying on, as the truth is that females can partake in the seva of the panj and there’s no doubt about it. [gurbani]gurmuiK eyk idRsit kir dyKhu Git Git joiq smoeI jIau ]2][/gurbani] As Gurmukh, look upon all with the single eye of equality; in each and every heart, the Divine Light is contained. ||2 Vaheguru Jee KAa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee FAteh!!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

uk singh · 15 Jun 2006

I'm afraid that I have to agree with E on this issue. Forget all this PC nonsense for a minute and ask yourselves, how many puraatan amrit sanchaars have there been with women performing seva in the Panj? Its funny how people decide to follow seen baseena tradition when it suits them but not in this case! This seems to be a modern concoction that is affecting the mind of bhaley mans Singhs and Singhnian...

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

a(o) · 15 Jun 2006

baba jee. no ur rong. angheen means jus tht if u were missing a toe u wudnt b able 2 do seva. missing a toe wudnt really effect ur abilty physically to do seva but it changes the roop of panj.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 15 Jun 2006

'Forget all this PC nonsense for a minute and ask yourselves, how many puraatan amrit sanchaars have there been with women performing seva in the Panj?' Maybe because there haven't been so many chardi kala bibis then. 'if u were missing a toe u wudnt b able 2 do seva. missing a toe wudnt really effect ur abilty physically to do seva but it changes the roop of panj.' So would the panj of today have to even have the exact amount of hair the singhs from the original panj did or tie the dastaar the same as the original panj had? Truthfully, the roop of the panj is actually being a true child of Guru Gobind Singh Jee's just as the sahibzada were. Everything that our father practiced should be practiced by the sikh as well. The roop of the panj is a khalsa, not khalsee for females, but khalsa - no gender. That is what the original panj were, khalsa. A Khalsa is the roop of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. So, whoever is a khalsa can partake in the seva of the panj to be him.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bruce Lee · 15 Jun 2006

"Bhupinder Singh "daas" I guess the three punj have to be jaat and two other khatris. Furthermore they have to be brown!!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

A Singh · 16 Jun 2006

Bruce Lee - you point is well made, this anti-Bibia attitude is prevalent in the Taksal and Sant Samaj (FYI, the castes of the original Punj were more diverse than Jat and Khatri - these were only two of the original Punj and also worth noting is that not all of them were Punjabi). The SIKH REHIT MARYADA clearly indicates that Bibia can take part in the Punj. This should be definitive enough for the Panth to accept, since this is the SIKH REHIT MARYADA approved by the PANTH. If people wish to follow off-shoot movements and personalities who they for whatever reasons presented, be they supported by supposed historical analysis or seena-baseena oral traditions, and place them above the Panth, that is their choice, however the view of the PANTH is final. Bibia can take part in the Amrit Sanchar - we need not have nonsense arguments over basics which have been in force now since the 1920s like this topic and others like meat or keski, unless of course you have agendas to create your own new Panth, in which case, it is clear what your intentions are.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

ss · 16 Jun 2006

What test will you put to see who is a jaat and who is a khatri ???

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

sanjo · 16 Jun 2006

whos hukam is it that panj pyareh must be ang heen? if a singh has had his tonsils removed does he qualify for the panj? furthermore how do we know ourselves that the original panj were physically complete? those great gursikhs may themselves have had scars or minor physical injuries/ we cannot be sure. unless there is evidence to suggest otherwise?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

a(o) · 16 Jun 2006

how is the amount of hair anything like missing a toe??? if u cant c the differnce between them,ur jus finished

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

uk singh · 16 Jun 2006

Bhupinder Singh Ji, how can you say 'Maybe because there haven't been so many chardi kala bibis then? In the past I would say there were more spiritually advanced souls than there are now. This applies to both Singhs and Singhnian.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

E · 16 Jun 2006

'fact - a singh who's form is incomplete / has been altered (eg losing part of body) cannot be in panj, no matter how chardi kala he is.' Nothing to do with gender unless if you're stating that females are all incomplete, which would be completely ridiculous. You have no argument here. ------------------- no im stating gender gives females a completely different saroop ------------------ 'fact - gender fundamentally changes form, not to go into details, but having a gender change is completely different from your skin changing colour (eg tanning)' This sounds more like a joke, so again there's no argument here. ----------------- this is no joke, you just have no answer, so you just keep saying theres no argument here. "What test will you put to see who is a jaat and who is a khatri ???" caste doesnt change saroop, caste system was abolished, sikhism recognises that there are 2 genders ie husband and wife, singh and kaur, it doesnt recognise caste. you are all writing the same thing again and again, you have been unable to make any responses to my points which make sense you are just arguing for the sake of arguing, you cannot admitt that you are wrong. im wasting my time, so im going to stop, if you want carry on talking rubbish feel free "So would the panj of today have to even have the exact amount of hair the singhs from the original panj did or tie the dastaar the same as the original panj had?" no you have to have 5 gurmukh singhs who are not angheen, gender gives singhs a certain saroop, which is completely different from that of a singhni. ----------------- 'fact - gender gives both males and females separate and different forms.' And whats your point? There spritiuallity counts not their physical body. Thats only temporal for the world; its not needed for the next. ---------------- the point is panj have a certain saroop, gender plays a part in saroop. ----------------- 'fact - if ones gender was ambiguous, he would be considered angheen, eg a genetic male who doesn’t have a complete male phenotype (outward structure)' Oh come on, that doesn't consider the person to be angheen - so that means you are referring to females being angheen every time you or anyone else says that. ------------------ if a genetic male has not developed a males phenotype - this means parts of his body are missing- hence he cant be in panj. ----------------- "Maybe because there haven't been so many chardi kala bibis then." - well if you read ranglle sajjan and speak to puratan singhs and bibia as i have done you will know that there definatly was no shortage of gurmukh bibia. "Equality goes above religion" - you are bringing a very political view of equality into sikhi, and sikhi is above politics, according to the west anand karaj is un-just because the singh walks infront of the singhni.......do you think this is inequality? do you think its inequality that all 10 guru's were male?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 16 Jun 2006

Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh!! 'the singh walks infront of the singhni.......do you think this is inequality? do you think its inequality that all 10 guru's were male?' The singhni can walk in front of the singh; it means the same thing. Now, to form a panj the individuals have to have the roop of Guru Gobind Singh Jee spiritually not physically, and not the five original singhs. They were chosen and came forth because they had the roop of guru gobind singh jee spiritually. A Khalsa does have the roop of Guru Gobind Singh Jee, so a khalsa can partake in the seva of the panj to form the image of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. Repeat Khalsa, not khalsee for females but Khalsa for both genders. Spirituality counts not the physical body. The sikhs of today have the wrong concept of the original panj, as everyone thinks the panj now have to be in the exact roop as the original panj but thats false as the original panj represented Guru Gobind Singh Jee, which means only a khalsa can represent Guru Gobind Singh in the form of the panj piarey. When Guru Gobind Singh Jee asked for the heads of five people, five singhs stepped up with courage and this was due to their high spirituallity, as even a singhni could have stepped up if she had this courage but none did and so those singhs that came forth to Guru Sahib Jee were very high in their spirituallity. Thus giving them the courage of overcoming the fear of death. Courage and all other qualities come from Naam and Gurbani. Nothing else. I don't mean to be rude, but you should just quit indulging in this manmat, as the future holds the answer and you will feel ashamed once you see the panj that will establish khalsa raj - the panj that will establish another form of Saachkhand within punjab. Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

a(o) · 17 Jun 2006

bhupinder singh, please quit with ur visions about khalsa raaj. vahiguru will establish khalsa raaj, no1 else. and if u have these visions keep em 2 urself, it wont help ur ego 2 speak about em all ova tapoban. panj payreh consist of 5 singhs, full stop. stop arguing. u still havent answered such a basic point. if fisical saroop doesnt matta y cant a brahmgyani singh do panj payreh seva if he has a missing toe?

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

cybersingh · 17 Jun 2006

According to Akaal Takhat Maryada, no angheen person can be apart of the Punj Pyarai.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 18 Jun 2006

'if fisical saroop doesnt matta y cant a brahmgyani singh do panj payreh seva if he has a missing toe?' He/she can do seva. If he/she can use their tongue to recite gurbani then why can't they partake in the seva? It's just a missing toe. OK listen, lets stop wasting time on this argument. I think that Singhnis and singhs can partake in the seva of the panj - you believe what you want. This topic isn't of importance in gurmat-wise. 'vahiguru will establish khalsa raaj' Of course Vaheguru Jee does everything, but khalsa raj won't be for anyone to live in. Only for those who have reached high levels and are strict in rehit. So, lets fear Vaheguru Jee and become a Khalsa.

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

uk singh · 19 Jun 2006

E - My stance has had to change after reading A Singh's post. Having checked the rehat maryada on the SGPC site, we all have to agree with what is written. We cannot quibble once a law has been passed. This is what it says. No matter what I believed in the past, it has been superseded by Article XXIV of the SRM: At the place where ambrosial baptism is to be administered, the holy Guru Granth Sahib should be installed and ceremonially opened. Also present should be six committed baptised Sikhs, one of whom should sit in attendance of the Guru Granth Sahib and the other five should be there to administer the ambrosial baptism. These six may even include Sikh women. All of them must have taken bath and washed their hair

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

E · 26 Jul 2006

uk singh sgpc also states eating meat is ok, and kesh is the 5th kakkar if you eat meat and believe 5th kakkar to be kesh thats fine otherwise you cant pick and choose parts of their maryada. everyone knows eating meat is a kurehit, and keski is the 5th kakkar

Re: Amrit Sanchaar Photos

ronald mcdonald · 26 Jul 2006

according to sgpc maryada a supersize mcdonalds burger with large fries and mayo is perfectly within the realms of gurmat so uk singh your point doesnt hold