Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Why?! · 06 Jun 2006

As the sikhs of the Guru we are to have full respect, love and dedication to our Guru. Our Guru is the most important aspect of our lives. So why is it then that some people believe it is ok to joke about the gurus? Only recently I heard of somebody speaking on a stage and who said that "Why did guru arjan dev ji have to make the sukhmani sahib so long and boring?" How can someone who calls themselves a sikh talk like this? I can understand somebody not appreciating gurbani and the message and hence it may be "boring" to them, but as a sikh speaker how on earth can you make a statement like this?! Yes im sure it was said as a "joke" but I don’t think it is right or respectful to make jokes like this about the gurus or gurbani. Especially as sikhs. Im sure some people will say oh he sounds like a fanatic and he cant take a joke. But yes I can take a joke, but some jokes I don’t make and some things I wouldn’t joke about. One of these is my guru. It is just another example of how little respect people have for gurbani. Im disgusted that people can talk like this, please lets try and shw guru ji FULL respect.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Bundha · 06 Jun 2006

Why?, I am surprised and disgusted that some one should say this, especially if he was a singh and in the gurdwara of all places. I am also surprised that he didn't get a good 'kicking' when he walked out of the Darbar Sahib. Sukhmani Sahib is a jewel , a masterpiece by Guru Arjan Dev Ji, every tuk is like a precious gem, may this person get his just rewards.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Tired Veerji · 06 Jun 2006

Who said this? We can have a word with him, was this in the UK? It looks like something the sikhstudent lot would say! I have heard this comment from one of the naang boys before.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

d · 06 Jun 2006

yes your right tired veerji.its exactly who you think it is

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Tired Veerji · 07 Jun 2006

This sikhstudent jokers are messing about with our maryada. I am getting tired of their boyish attitude to Sikhi. They shouldn't be running camps. This whole boy/girl huggy thing and trying to get in their with the student crowd by having langer eating competitions, water fights, bhangra dancing, insulting Guruji etc. We have heard to all to often now! It's about time the sangat got their act together and kicked their naang backsides out of the UK.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

..... · 07 Jun 2006

name & shame....otherwise whats the point in even mentioning it

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

o · 07 Jun 2006

hai maha maha maha maha maha maha maha maha maha maha maha maha maha MAHA MAHA MAHA MAHA paap

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Bazzer · 07 Jun 2006

I think ......... is right, unless you name names and name camps and who are organising them and who the culprits are then giving just vague descriptions means nothing. Unless we know who is organising langar competitions, and bhungra dancing and who is insulting Guru Ji nothing can be done, criptic clues are no good.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Lad · 07 Jun 2006

Was this the talk at some uni? Someone at the march was saying that one of the sikhstudent organisers said something like this at some talk he did! Naam, gurus ustat, the path to vaheguru, the clensing of the soul etc how are these things which are all in sukhmani sahib boring? whoever said it was prob speaking to some youngsters without much giaan, as if anyone said that in front of older gursikhs who read and had pyar for sukhmani sahib ji would have given this guy a thupar straight away! Guru ji talks about 'sant ki ninda' and what happens to one who does this. now no matter whether we believe this sant to be a human sant or sant as in guru ji, it is still clear what is going to happen to this guy. maybe if he had read it he would have known not to insult gurbani! whoever said this statement aout guru arjan sahib jis sukhmani sahib will be getting something kicked out of him by gurus shaheed singhs one day!!how can you do nindia of gurbani and still be a sikh?

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

d · 07 Jun 2006

tired veerji and others a few singhs are trying to sort the problem out. theyve already had a few meetings with those who are "in charge" of sikh student camp. i cant really give any more details, but i think things are starting to happen now. the person who said the thing about sukhmani sahib also said that gurdas maans songs are more spiritual than gurbani.i personally think the specific people should get beaten up. anyways, theres no point in naming names right now. the truth will come out, all in due time. its VERY difficult to shut down a camp..the only thing that can be done, i reckon is to expose the poeple who are doing wrong parchar at this camp, and to expose the general other wrongdoings that are happening at this camp. because, those people who are attracted to these sorts of places and this distorted type of sikhi will always find a way to get together and have these sorts of camps.and as far as im concerned they cant be called gurmat camps anyway. atleast by exposing this anti sikhi parhcar we can make sure that those who really truly do want to learn about gursikhi and gurmat are aware that this is not the place to go. and for those who wana go to mess about and be dodgy....well lets jus hope mahraj does kirpa and on us aswell....

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Bundha · 08 Jun 2006

Another thing that can be done is if a group of Chardi Kala Singhs attend these Student Camps and then confront any beadbi or wrong doing. Give them a hard time and challenge any wrong parchaar.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Who is this guy · 08 Jun 2006

He said gurdas maan songs are more spiritual than gurbani? What is this guys name? Is he part of some organisation, sounds like he is the organiser of some camp? All groups, societies and camps etc should break all links with people who think some songs by a sufi pir can come even close to the greatness of gurbani! How can anybody ever justify saying that filth?

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

anon · 08 Jun 2006

yh attend these camps on the sly, and whenever anything happens confront them on the spot. why isnt the respect for guru granth sahib campaign involved in this, isnt this disrespect of guru ji? equal to taking guru ji to a club i reckon! these nangs are fakes. they think by wearing bana n big kirpans n big dumaleh they are keeping sikhi alive. i bet they have never bene taught about naam. they can never be true warriors if they have no bir raas from naam japping. its pathetic,whether they think their form of shaster vidya is the correct one or not, without that storage of naam they are wimps, when khalsa raaj comes these fakers will be punished by dharam raj. we just got to make sure we dont turn out like them n we should jaap more naam. jeeahu mailae baaharahu niramal || Inwardly polluted, and outwardly pure. bwhrhu inrml jIAhu q mYly iqnI jnmu jUAY hwirAw ] baaharahu niramal jeeahu th mailae thinee janam jooai haariaa || Those who are outwardly pure and yet polluted within, lose their lives in the gamble. they are shamefull n give a bad name to the few true rehitvaan nihangs out there.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Bhudysut · 08 Jun 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Sangat Ji, I find it amazing that you can make comments such as these! If 'Why'?! Veer/Bhan felt such an issue with someone making a remark like that, questions have to be asked as to WHY a point wasn't raised at that specific time. It seems pretty fruitless to come on here after the event has happened and start doing nindyan of people. All I have seen here is accusation after accusation followed by nindyan! If I was put in an unfortunate position of being present when my Guru is being insulted, I would (with my Guru's blessings) attempt to non-aggressively confront the individual making such remarks and try to clarify their comments. For as we all know, comments can always be misconstrued. All it takes is some hot-head to take a misunderstanding further and create something that was not there! Attempts to forcefully try to resolve situations only lead to more negativity. It seems many of our Singh's are yet to learn this. I repeat, I consider any slanderer of my Guru to be epitome of idiocy. But I also consider my Guru to be all powerful and my Guru will sort the good from the bad themselves. So Sangat Ji, please lets all try and refrain from the nindyan and chuglyan, and try and be more constructive about this (and not destructive). Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Ji Dass Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

intrested to know... · 08 Jun 2006

he did a talk at my uni once before, i wasnt into sikhi then so didnt think to much of it but mocked the images of Guru Nanak Dev Ji

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Bundha · 08 Jun 2006

Bhudysut, if you read the original post it says " Only recently I heard of somebody speaking on a stage .................." 'Why' was not there at the time, he/she is only reporting this. As for chugli, I see no chugli or nindhiay, all I see are concerned Singhs who are voicing there unease at wht they have heard and want more information. From the above posts, it seems people know who the purportators are but are unwilling to name and shame. Unless we know who these people are they will carry on with their misguided comments.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

. · 08 Jun 2006

i was lookin through the old sikh stuent camp thread and it seems many people have been there and found out how totally anti gurmat it is.... those who have been to sikh student camp and experienced this please email to my email add especially someone who posted as "gupt singhni" under that thread

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Bhudysut · 08 Jun 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Dear Bundha Veer Ji Respectfully, if its a case of hearing this from a third party, why was it ever brought up in the first place? If it was not seen nor heard primarily, but Why?! Veer/Bhan, then why bring it up? Since when are we suppose to make comment on conjecture? I would have thought that as Guru loving Sikhs, we would try to distance ourselves from this kind of conduct! Veer Ji, without knowing for certain, comments like "It looks like something the sikhstudent lot would say!" are being said. I may be a bit simple, but that looks like nindyan to me! I have always been taught, that nindyan under any circumstance is still nindyan. So any unease that concerned Singh’s have should be targeted in a much more constructive way. Remember this, there was a lot more disrespect of Guru Ji during the times of when Guru Ji had their physical form. Ask yourself, how did they deal with it? Their actions showed that even in the midst of degenerates, their own beauty shown through. That for me is the perfect example of how to deal with this matter, not to start pointing accusatory fingers straight away. I want to reiterate the fact that I consider any debasement of my Guru to be immoral and downright stupid. But I also have the up most of faith in my Guru too. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Dass Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Concerned Manmukh · 08 Jun 2006

Gurfatheh All. Lets make this productive and not this fade away on the internet. Instead of spreading rumours please can the people who HAVE BEEN please come forward and show your concerns by emailing and phoning the Sikh Student organizers. Rumours dont do anyone any good. So can the people who post messages on this and other forums please be ready to walk the walk rather than just talk the talk. If you are REALLY concerned then do something about it. Its easy to be a "Internet Warrior" in the comfort of your homes but reality is different not many are prepared to actually do anything. So for those of us who want to do something here are a few Ideas. Contact the Camp organisers, info is below The only way to stop this is if the people who are witnesses to beadbi please step forward if you have pyare for Sikhi. Its a simple request, no heads are being asked for :) for those who cant be bothered to click here are the contact details: Here is a link -> http://www.bmagdns.co.uk/sikhstudent/contact.htm email: [address removed] Tel:07742 468895 - 07706 566507 Address:Sikh Student Camp, PO Box 2684, Romford RM6 5YZ. PS Can you also cc in to our email address [address removed] so that we can approach them as well with evidence that people have been trying to contact them. Lets see if the people on these forums are willing to take steps to actually doing something, or just chat on these forums for their own ego. Hopefully our next post will be positive and a step forward. Gurfatheh.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

anon · 08 Jun 2006

daas has sent a email to that email link you gave mr concerned manmukh ji. it is as follows: <<<<<<<< waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh pyareh jio, i have heard disturbing news recently that perhaps some of the activities that are performed at sikh student camp are not according to gurmat. many people have voiced a concern about parcharaks making disrespectful remarks about guru ji and guru ji's great bani, in particular the amazing sukhmani sahib. many are outraged as some claim to have attended your camp and witnessed such manmat. i am just a das of the guru and i am concerned with whether this is all true or not. for your camp's sake i hope it isn't true, i am just a simple gursikh who is not associated with any group or jatha, i am just concerned with such comments being made. alot of people may have attended your camp in the past and if any wrong parchar is going on then this is a major issue. if any beadbi of guru ji is taking place then i think the responsibility lies with the organisers to stop it. if it did occur and it continues then i can guarentee that the whole of the UK sangat will be outraged. most now would expect you to look in to any parchar that occurs at your camp and investigate the parcharaks. this guru ka das strongly believes that only the most chardi kala rehitvan gursikhs should be allowed to perform parchar on such a big scale. the organisers may not be aware of such false parchar if it occured but due to such concern of some people about your camp, it is your responsibility to look in to these claims and investigate parcharaks. if such beadbi did occur and the organisers are fully aware of it and are not doing anything to prevent such disrespect, then i can only do ardas that guru ji does kirpa on you guys and gives you some buddi. any false parchar is a big risk taken by the parcharak, if it occurs waheguru ji will surely punish the culprits. again i reiterate i am just a simple daas of the guru and i am not associated with any group or jatha. bhull chukk maaf waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh <<<<<< i put your email address as the cc thingy. dont know whether this will do any good, if anything if any false parchar is going on it will let them know that people are watching them closely and hopefully they will stop. if everyone sends a email it wont hurt and it could do some good, who knows waheguru kirpa kareh.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Har_Jan_Kaur · 09 Jun 2006

Could all people who have experienced/witnessed any sort of beadbhi of sikhi at the sikh student camp or by any of the sevadaars who organise the camp, please take a step forward. your help is needed to do something about it. contact the organisers and copy in to concerned 'manmukh' (sorry) jee, its nice to see people trying to do something about this issue - an issue which has been complained about since 2002. the sikh sangat in UK can collectively do something about this. i myself have experienced this camp first hand and know how it is pulling the next generation of sikhs (sikh youth) away from gurmat. please come forward to do something - like i did. I need my brothers and sisters to join me.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Read · 12 Jun 2006

Budshut why dont you try reading the posts? People have said that they have already started to have meetings with people from that camp to discuss these issues! so it is not nindiya and it is being tackled in a constructive way. What more do you want? the fact that people have not smeared the guys name on the internet does not mean that it is ninidya. nor is this something which can be ignored. it is not the speakers personal rehat or sikhi that we are discussin that is between him and guru ji, but it is the comments he is making in his parchar, i.e. that gurbani is boring and gurdas maan is better. if a hindu or muslim was to say that there would be uproar. but if a guy with a dhari says it people dont want to discuss it. people like this should not be invited to talk at any functions and anybody callim them should take a look at what they want to portray to the young sikhs. if he is a speaker/organiser at that camp then as i said its not his persoal issues that are the problem but its what he says on stage. so this aint a persoanl attack or issue, its an issue of parchar. yes and as above for those people who have seen any dodgy parchar please take action as requested.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Concerned Manmukh · 14 Jun 2006

Gurfatheh, Information update to all. Although we put the post up a week ago... we have only recieved 1 reply and that was from "anon" above who has also pasted the email here. This really shows that as "Sikhs" all we do is talk and can not even do what we're doing best at this moment... ie.... be "Internet Warriors". I personally dont understand what people are so scared of... I can appreciate that this may be traumatic as the experiences from this camp have been much more than this... but please think about about our sisters & daughters who will be attending this camp only to get harrassed. YES this is what has happened in the past by individuals who are "sevadars" in the camp. IF NOTHING ELSE SEND AN EMAIL TO THE SIKH STUDENT CAMP SAYING THAT YOU DO NOT SUPPORT MANMATH AT A SIKHI BASED CAMP. Please dont come crying later if its you or your friends/relatives who end up traumatised by this camp's "sevadars". Gurfatheh.

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

sikhissues.blogspot.com · 23 Jun 2006

there is also stuff on www.sikhissues.blogspot.com

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

lovethecamera · 30 Jun 2006

yeah that site been updated now www.sikhproblems.blogspot.com i think [%sig%]

Re: 'Sikhs' disrespecting Gurbani

Jagvinder Singh · 01 Jul 2006

im ashamed they call themselves nihangs. nihangs dont go around doin tt kinda *********. im a learning nihang from singapore, and , it irks me they could make these comments about our guru sahibs and their banis. i hope the sangat realises tt not all nihangsinghs are like tt, tt not all of them sit around, drinking sukha, cutting goats and doing beadbi of gurmat. there are very few of them. the real nihangs are still out there, theyre still chardikala, and theyre still dashmesh pitaah's ladli fauj. hope it clears your doubts on nihang singhs.