Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Egg and Fish???

Egg and Fish???

KHALSA UK · 07 Jun 2006

A muslim asked me why Sikhs cant eat Fish as it is not meat as it has no organs or something and an egg is not suppose to be a chicken??? I sort of talked back, but without a solid argument and I next time I get asked, I dont wish to be in the position of the other day I was in. Please Sangat Ji, if you can put the argument up of why Fish and Egg is banned in Sikhi??? Thanks a lot! WJKK WJKF

Re: Egg and Fish???

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 07 Jun 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeekeeFateh Firstly, Muslims say anything, which means anything ridiculous - one is allowed to eat fish because it doesn't have organs, come on, they themselves have halal meat, which just means without having blood inside the animal and praying while cooking it - how does this make it fine to eat. A fish is just a different type of animal, but it is still a living creature like us. Within the Egg is what would have been called a chick if the chicken wasn't injected, thus making it virtually a dead liquid form of an animal. So, it is still an animal, but just one that is dead but could have had life. Plus, Guru Sahib Jee states to only have simple foods, as egg, fish etc, is characterised as a food for pleasure just as a chicken and beef is. We don't live to eat, we eat to live. Any type of pleasureable food shouldn't be on a Sikhs mind, but simple food is fine i.e. roti, dhaal, sabjee etc. A Sikh wasn't created to serve ones self, but to serve Vaheguru Jee, Guru Jee, his saints, sikhs and the rest of humanity. Muslims always find ways of allowing themselves to have any sort of worldly pleasure. Hope that helped. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Egg and Fish???

Sanjo · 07 Jun 2006

fishes are animals and a egg is like a embryo. the egg is like the human egg that grows in a womans womb it will slowly turn in to a human being. the chicken eggs will turn in to a chicken with the correct care n by tkaing these eggs away eating them is preventing life which is going against waheguru jis hukam. also i think chickens are given some kind of chemicals which stimulate egg production beyond normal. alot of people always say fish isnt a animal, ive never heard the internal organs thing before, but as far as im aware fishes do have some organs i.e a liver where cod liver oil comes from. they have a stomach aswel. end of the day they act like any other animal on land i.e move around seek shelter reproduce and eat. its a stupid arguement fishes have eyes they have a face, how can they say it aint a animal. people that say fish isnt meat are ignorant, alot of muslims say its ok to kill n eat a animal if you look after n raise its young, they say its like replacing the dead one. afraid not that soul that was in the animal has gne n waheguru jis hukam has been contested. also meat eaters wnt eat certain meats, like muslims wont eat pork or horse or dog meat. because its against "etiquette", but that is a flawed arguement because etiquette is governed by your social surroundings and the culture you live in. for westerners we would never thing of eating dog meat but go to places in asia like china and it may be seen as a delicasy. if your going to eat meat then eat all meat, at the end of the day its meat! i think its clearly evident sometimes that religions like christianity n islam fail to grasp that every single living being has a soul and is a sublime creation of waheguru. muslims certainly believe that everything on this earth was made for mans pleasure as man is waheguru jis supreme creation. therefore we have a right to everything. but basically egg n fish are meat!

Re: Egg and Fish???

Singhstah · 07 Jun 2006

VahegurooJiKaKhalsaVahegurooJiKiFateh The argument is that fish has no organs so its veg is complete bull**** its still alive and you still kill it. These people are so dumb How thick are these idiots, egg is not supposed to be a chicken??? wtf??? the whole point that chickens lay eggs is to reproduce, it because a hen for Gods sake. VahegurooJiKaKhalsaVahegurooJiKiFateh

Re: Egg and Fish???

some1 · 07 Jun 2006

but ppl are stoopid and ignorant saying fishes don't have organs, they have all the organs humans. That is the stoopidest justification. EGGS are more of a moral issue. Eggs that are farmed these days are not created by a hen and rooster doing the deed, but rather something added to the hens feed. So that egg CANNOT grow into a chicken. (unless its a freerun egg). Either way if you r going to eat eggs make sure its freerun...not because u kill, but those factory farmed chicken laying eggs are horribly treated. kept in pens 1inch smaller then them...notmoving for its entire life..its horrible.

Re: Egg and Fish???

Huh! · 07 Jun 2006

What's wrong with eating fish/meat or eggs?

Re: Egg and Fish???

.. · 07 Jun 2006

arent plants alive - like veg etc they require water to live the Sun essentially they are living ??? Why do we eat them ?? We are still kiiling them by eating them

Re: Egg and Fish???

KHALSA UK · 07 Jun 2006

Thanks every1 for replying in a serious manner. I understand that the fish argument is stupid now as it is still living and they still kill it. The egg they say is two types, one is the one that is suppose to grow into a chicken and the other one is that was never going to grow into a chicken anyway - its that part which is very confusing at the moment. WJKK WJKF

Re: Egg and Fish???

Disciple · 07 Jun 2006

WJKK WJKF. i am a vegetarian, but get asked by others that eating vegetarian food is also killing life as the plants and beg are/were alive (breath, reproduce, produce waste products). can anyone explain that to me so i cant answer any futre queries i may recieve.

Re: Egg and Fish???

singh · 07 Jun 2006

it is up to you whether you eat meat, fish or eggs, we don't have foolish arguements over this as we beleive our time is better spent on thanking God for the gifts he gives to us. Some points -plants are living too -the eggs for sale for eating are the unfertilised ones ( ie the would never have been chickens or hens) -are muslims more successfully in anyway due to the diet they eat??

Re: Egg and Fish???

Disciple · 07 Jun 2006

WJKK WJKF. I am a vegetarian, but people ask me that if i dont eat meat because its killing a life form then why do us Sikhs eat plants and vegetables which according to science are also living (breath, reproduce, produce waste products)? i hope someone can answer this because it would help me greatly in future questions. [%sig%]

Re: Egg and Fish???

Sardar · 07 Jun 2006

Well, people we got to eat something to survive.

Re: Egg and Fish???

Daas · 08 Jun 2006

Vaheguru First of all the fact that we are here in human form and here to meet our beloved means that in order to sustain this life we must eat. However at the same time, Guru Ji tells us not to stuff ourselves but to eat little and only what is needed. Regarding Vegetarians; Plants have life, they have a 'soul' and technically there is no difference between plant and animal...however.... a khatakaar once said that 'whatever we eat we then take on its lekha' (by my understanding lekhaa means the deeds the animal has committed in its life and refers to its account of good and bad deeds) so an animal would have larger lekha which will take more naam simran to correct... however, a plant would have very little lekha and thus is better spiritually since in order to repay for taking that life less is 'owed' to put it bluntly... I can't remember the book I read in... it may have been Say Kineyiaa but....we shud be doing like 2hours of simran just to repay for all the ants and insects we accidently kill during the day!!!.... so we can see through logic that as you go up the chain of plants - animals - humans.... the 'value' increases, the 'lekha' increases and thus is a greater sin...... Anyway, dispite my above argument for vegism, there is no point arguing with ignorant fools... just say straight that we pray we may get giaan of what is right and wrong....we just rather not take the risk of eating meat.... This is what I understood from the Katha... forgive me for my mistakes

Re: Egg and Fish???

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 08 Jun 2006

VahegurujeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib 'KHALSA UK' Jeeo, Don't listen to people like bhai sahib 'singh' Jee. Also, the answer to your question is that we Sikhs don't indulge in pleasureable foods, as Guru Sahib Jee says that one is punishable if the person indulges in pleasureable foods. The type of food people eat are characterised from good to bad, and egg is in between along with chocolates and others, which clearly determines them to be wrong. I don't understand why Sikhs find it so difficult to tell these Muslims that we don't live to give ourselves pleasures, similar to the way Kings live, but we are instead meant to be beggars that only beg for things of importance, i.e. Naam, and everything else Sikhi stands for. We Serve Vaheguru Jee not ourselves. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Egg and Fish???

KHALSA UK · 08 Jun 2006

Bhupinder Singh Daas Ji, Your point has been noted. Thanks for helping and everyone else. WJKK WJKF

Re: Egg and Fish???

santa singh · 09 Jun 2006

so, Bhupinder Singh "daas" , do you delibrately make your food horrible tasting?? are we supposed to eat food that doesn't taste nice?? please don't say this especially to any non-sikhs, as you will wrongly make our religion look stupid.

Re: Egg and Fish???

funny · 09 Jun 2006

please don't say this especially to any non-sikhs, as you will wrongly make our religion look stupid. Excellent point santa singh!

Re: Egg and Fish???

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 09 Jun 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeeKeeFateh Bhai Sahib 'santa singh' Jeeo: I think you're kind of confused and I think this is your problem: going down to the burger shop and ordering burger and chips; stuff your face with this delicious food, or stay at home and spend all your time making somosa, cake etc, basically be like every other human; indulge in this world and its pleasure, enjoy your life here while you can because this dream and its pleasures aren't going to last for long. This dreams beautiful, isn't it, oh sorry to the demons that is, as only they enjoy these pleasures by using your body which then makes the mind think that you're enjoying such pleasures, but truthfully they are. Your body has turned cheap for them, as they're using it for free and you're letting them. Do you know what simple foods are? Simple foods are using the raw materials just to make food that we need, which are dhaal, roti, sabjee etc, and that’s it. Also, other types of foods are fruits, and liquids such as milk, water etc. This is a necessity and it’s healthy. Other then the simple foods, there's only food for pleasure - we don't live to EAT, but we eat to LIVE. The true pleasure is Naam, and everything else in this world is a delusion; its fake. Let Naam be ones only search for pleasure, not worldly things which just leave one astray and confused for what the real pleasure is. All these pleasures in the world bore and indolent the human to jap a lot of naam. Lose the pleasures in this world to realise the true pleasure within it. Sat Sri Akaal

Re: Egg and Fish???

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 09 Jun 2006

[gurbani]syv kIqI sMqoKIeNØI ijn@I sco scu iDAwieAw ][/gurbani] Those who serve are content. They meditate on the Truest of the True. [gurbani]En@I mMdY pYru n riKE kir suik®qu Drmu kmwieAw ][/gurbani] They do not place their feet in sin, but do good deeds and live righteously in Dharma. [gurbani]En@I dunIAw qoVy bMDnw AMnu pwxI QoVw KwieAw ][/gurbani] They burn away the bonds of the world, and eat a simple diet of grain and water.

Re: Egg and Fish???

Sikhi · 10 Jun 2006

Just say the next thing to the muslim: We dont do something which we maybe have to suffer for. When we reach Dharm Raj and someone ask us why didnt you ate meat? We always can say out of love for Akaal Purkh. To keep his creation like it is. What will a muslim say? Well, we liked a chicken with french fried rather then roti with sabjee?

Re: Egg and Fish???

santa singh · 10 Jun 2006

can you not have the true pleasure of naam if you enjoy your food?? have you ever laughed? assuming you might have accidently laughed once in your life, did you feel guilty and repent for having that pleasure because it was not from the true pleasure "naam" can you define what this true pleasure "naam" is ? (in your opinion Bhupinder Singh dass jee)

Re: Egg and Fish???

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 10 Jun 2006

Vaheguroo Jee KAa KHalsa!! VAhegurOOO Jee Kee FATEH!! 'have you ever laughed?' No I find it difficult at times, but when I do I feel like japping so much NAAMM!! VAHEGUROOO!!!!! Anyway, its my turn: HAVE YOU EVER JAPPED A LOT OF NAAAMM???!!!! 'can you define what this true pleasure "naam" is ?' Its out of this WORLD!!; you have to feel it for yourself to believe it. It cannot be described!!!! JAAP NAAM VAHEGURUOOOO!!!!!!!!! VAAAHHHHHEEEEEGGGUUUUURRROOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! SAATT SRRI AAKKAAALL Vaheguroo Jee KAa KHalsa!! VAhegurOOO Jee Kee FATEH!!

Re: Egg and Fish???

Singh · 10 Jun 2006

Guru Hargobind Sahib has specifically written Hukamnama saying not to go near Fish or Eggs. In Gurbani Bhagat Kabir Ji has said one who consumes Fish and Marijuana can never get Mukhti. [%sig%]

Re: Egg and Fish???

fresh vegetarian · 10 Jun 2006

here is my experience. Eating maas gave me more energy for training. But when i tried to do my bhagti i could not get any ras out, i felt like something was blocking me, and then i got frustrated. i gave up meat and started eating raw vegies fruit nuts milk and vitamins recently i found keeping away from meat the energy slowly starts coming back in small trickle signs at first. but if i went back to meat the ras gets blocked out as did before. i am happy as i am for now but would like to do more research and see if i lack anywhere perhaps try some multivitamins. two areas do concern me thinning hair, bigger forehead, and im not married yet but want to make sure i do not lack anything for fatherhood purposes. so if theres any doctors around please advise me.

Re: Egg and Fish???

fresh vegetarian · 10 Jun 2006

here is my experience. Eating maas gave me more energy for training. But when i tried to do my bhagti i could not get any ras out, i felt like something was blocking me, and then i got frustrated. i gave up meat and started eating raw vegies fruit nuts milk and vitamins recently i found keeping away from meat the energy slowly starts coming back in small trickle signs at first. but if i went back to meat the ras gets blocked out as did before. i am happy as i am for now but would like to do more research and see if i lack anywhere perhaps try some multivitamins. two areas do concern me thinning hair, bigger forehead, and im not married yet but want to make sure i do not lack anything for fatherhood purposes. so if theres any doctors around please advise me. [%sig%]

Re: Egg and Fish???

santa singh · 12 Jun 2006

Gurfateh ji you havent answered me:- Only if you tell me ( in your opinion) what is the meaning of "japping naam" , what does jap naam mean ?? . . . only then can I answer your question on your terms- because I think we obviously have a different understanding of the term.

Re: Egg and Fish???

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 13 Jun 2006

Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee FATEH!! Firstly, whats naam? Vaheguru. Now, what does japping mean? to recite something and if we say japping naam then that means to recite Vaheguru. So, this is something that should be done continuously, aat pehar and seated bhagti as well. Both forms of meditation have been mentioned in gurbani. dhar ghar dtoee naa lehai shhoottee dhoojai saadh ||5|| At the Door of His Home, she finds no shelter; she is discarded for seeking other pleasures. ||5|| The above gurbani line clearly determines by searching, craving and desiring pleasures in this world, then one has no place in saachkhand. Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee FATEH!!

Re: Egg and Fish???

santa singh · 13 Jun 2006

why do you think that we can't recite Vaheguroo if we are enjoying something? I find that eating nice food makes me often remember or say (ie recite) Vaheguroo. Its a shame that you can't do both. saag, maki di roti . . . yum yum . . . Satnaam Vaheguroo

Re: Egg and Fish???

Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 14 Jun 2006

'santa singh': You're not living in this world for long, maybe you might die tomarrow - stop wasting your time fool! This world is a dream, so carry on living in it and die with it too. But if you ever try and change someone elses view on Naam and enjoying worldly pleasures just as you've tried with me I'll make sure you go straight to hell. Fear Vaheguru Jee.

Re: Egg and Fish???

Ranjit · 14 Jun 2006

You got a major ego problem mate- how can you make sure someone goes to hell? are you God or something?

Re: Egg and Fish???

loool · 14 Jun 2006

ranjit...bhupinder singh = so far ahead than us he can infact give siraf as he is vaheguru da pyaara. its not ego idiot.

Re: Egg and Fish???

santa singh · 14 Jun 2006

I thought Vaheguru dey pyaaray wish for 'sarbat da bhala' not give sirafay for people to go to hell ??

Re: Egg and Fish???

sanjo · 16 Jun 2006

why is everyone argueing calling names if ur going to debate do it with pyaar. people on this forum think they are clever catching others out waiting for a mistake then they jump on it saying oh ur egotistical etc etc. all of u are doing ur own paap. you are waiting for others to make mistakes so you can condemn and feed your own haumai. just debate sensibly with pyaar, if not then all of you are plotting your own downfall. bhupinder singh knows the cure for ego, so if paaji thinks he is doing something wrong then he knows to jaap more naam. alot of us should do the same. we are not perfect, none of us are perfect only guru ji is perfect!

Re: Egg and Fish???

a singh · 16 Jun 2006

Author: santa singh Date: 06-14-06 19:18 I thought Vaheguru dey pyaaray wish for 'sarbat da bhala' not give sirafay for people to go to hell ?? ^^ baba gurbachan singh gave sirpha to a singh when he said 'i have just barked for 2 hours and u want me to do 2 more' and baba ji gave him the sirpha of barking at that same time everyday for 2 hours..why did baba gurbachan singh hand this out, simple he took the mickey out of gurbani and said he was 'barking' not 'reciting.'