Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

jesus film in usa

jesus film in usa

endlaind singh · 28 Mar 2004

Gurfateh. Has any of our usa sangat seen the jesus film? any good? - in terms of faith/ God etc? films regarding faith in the Immortal One are rare and far between.

Re: jesus film in usa

Rashpal Singh · 29 Mar 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh My friend over here in UK has seen it and he says that it is all blood and gore...and about how Jesus sacrificed his life to save us all....(yh right)

Re: jesus film in usa

JS · 29 Mar 2004

Dear Rashpal Singh what's the sarcasm for??????

Re: jesus film in usa

Singh · 30 Mar 2004

Rashpal Singh is right. Jesus could not have taken sins of the whole world. He was a good man but again he could not have done the impossible.

Re: jesus film in usa

Rashpal Singh · 30 Mar 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh Which sarcasm? Please, point it out to me where I was being sarcastic. Thank You :)

Re: jesus film in usa

... · 30 Mar 2004

I have seen the film. I went in expecting something inspirational, but all I saw was 2 hours of Jesus getting beaten down. you learn nothing about the religion you learn nothing about the man the only bright point in the movie is the relationship between jesus and his mother.

Re: jesus film in usa

gabroo khalistan dah · 30 Mar 2004

and that he folds 2 gods will

Re: jesus film in usa

endlaind singh · 30 Mar 2004

phew. finally seen the fil;m and i agree with "..."! i too was expecting something inspirational but found lots of gore. nothing else learnt except, i suppose, sacrifice. so not an inspiring film at all, even though it supposed to be about "God's son". i preferred even Green Mile, which showed the humble black guy blessed with God's power of healing. Are there any other inspirationjal films that anyone can think of which remind the viewer of God?

Re: jesus film in usa

Not Khalsa · 30 Mar 2004

I have heard someone say that guru gobind singh jee said in bani that he would take the sins of sikhs upon himself to absolve them of this. I have been looking for such a reference but have not seen anything. One example was that guru sahib said plants are also life, but he will take this paap upon himself as we need to be able to eat. There was 14 in all. I am not sure if this is true or not, has anyone else heard of this?

Re: jesus film in usa

JP · 30 Mar 2004

This movie WOULD be good under the circumstance that the viewer had a deep love for Jesus to BEGIN with. This movie does no character build up for Jesus, so non-Christians really can't be expected to feel much sympathy based solely on the movie. Earlier impressions of Jesus being a saviour, messiah, etc. are neccesary for this movie to be a moving experience.

Re: jesus film in usa

??? · 01 Apr 2004

Rashpal Singh and "..." and co, ever thought about the impact of Shaheedi, given the central importance of this to us as Sikhs. Imagine casting a similar film about the likes of Baba Banda Singh Bahadur, say... I'm looking forward to seeing this film, but the responses above echo those of Christians who have been revolted by the level of blood and suffering depicted..."it's not the message of Christ" many say. To me, from the reviews I've read and the responses aired to date from those who have seen, the movie is seems as if it is more a 'visual meditation' if you will, hence the message of Christ that many commonly hear with doves flying in the air, clearly isn't the theme being sought... ...for instance, returning to our personal examples of Baba Banda Singh Bahadur, or even others say Guru Arjan Dev Ji, the 4 Sahibzade etc one could depict each of these with a more 'shaant' flavour, focusing on the values to be learnt, the humility, gyan, compassion to be fostered...alternatively, these are equally (if not more so than that possibly depicted in recent movie) available for depiction from a more, as what Islam would describe "Jalaalee" aspects of the Divine -in Sikhi this also features, predominantly in Dasam Bani such as the Chandi Paath, particularly Ugardanti, Bhagautee Astother and even references in Jaap Sahib (see Rual Chand, verses concerning Akaal in the 'horrible form' of the destroyer)... Just some thoughts... [p.s. Rashpal Singh, you're sarcasm is evident in the "yeah right" comment following the Shaheedi of Jesus, you are in effective ridiculing his shaheedi in doing so and I humbly request that you reconsider you stance on the matter]

Re: jesus film in usa

Singh · 01 Apr 2004

Dear ???, Rashpal Singh is right in saying that Jesus did not die for all our sins. If you believe he did then why bother even being a Sikh? Why not become a Christian if you want to rid yourself of sin? Further, dying for somebody's sins is meaningless. Jesus was brutally murdered, but how does that relate to my sins? Christians continually state that Jesus died for us, but his death cannot atone for the sins of billions of humans before, during and after his death.

Re: jesus film in usa

gaiani · 01 Apr 2004

first all if jesus was alive today he wud be in a synagogue not church, second he was a rabbi. He never started christianity, it was after his time. And ??? what is crusifiction compared to being cut joint by joint? or cooked alive?

Re: jesus film in usa

??? · 01 Apr 2004

I do not dispute your comments regarding present day Christian propaganda, nonetheless, Rashpal's comments were unnecessarily sarcastic, we would not tolerate such comments regarding the Shaheedi of Guru Arjan Dev Ji or Guru Tegh Bahadur from others -it is not your point that I took issue with, its Rashpal's manner of expressing something in a disrespectful way.

Re: jesus film in usa

singh · 01 Apr 2004

what was wrong with what rashpal said? he obviously disagrees with teh notion that jesus died for rashpal's or any of our sins. If you find this offensive, well, you should consider that maybe rashpal finds it offensive to be told that jesus died for his sins. jesus' crusifiction can't really be compared to the shaheedi of baba banda singh bahadur or others. accounts from their time tell of how htey met death, without flinching, without screaming or showing any signs of pain. while the jesus movie apparently shows him howling in pain. also, the sikhs accepted bhana as mithaa and didn't complain to god about it. it's well known that jesus told god that you've forsaken me during his crusifiction. i guess if they made a movie about singh shaheeds it would be a little different. it would be like one of those old silent films. they torture, but no reaction except naam and banee. no screams or any of those things that make for good drama.

Re: jesus film in usa

Rashpal Singh · 01 Apr 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh 1st of all, Jesus did not die for us, he was a Jew or christian....we are not jews or christians. I am not saying Jesus was a bad man....To be honest, frankly I don't care if he was a good man or bad, he did nothing for me or sikhi. Sikhi was nourished with the blood of SIKH shaheeds, not the khoon of Jesus. I didn't mean to 'disrespect' him anyhow.....I was just telling you, he did'nt die for us........Shaheeds of the Panth died for us. If you think he died for us then you can become a Christian. VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: jesus film in usa

Not Khalsa · 01 Apr 2004

Author: Not Khalsa Date: 03-30-04 18:50 I have heard someone say that guru gobind singh jee said in bani that he would take the sins of sikhs upon himself to absolve them of this. I have been looking for such a reference but have not seen anything. One example was that guru sahib said plants are also life, but he will take this paap upon himself as we need to be able to eat. There was 14 in all. I am not sure if this is true or not, has anyone else heard of this?

Re: jesus film in usa

... · 01 Apr 2004

??? To be honest i did go in thinking about how such a movie would apply to sikh shaheeds...and how such a movie would depict Mughals/Hindus/Muslims and i admit i do know a fair deal about christianity...and was expecting this knowledge to help inspire me in my own religion... but you know what? i walked out of the movie feeling cheated out of $30...i did not get one extra thing out of the movie...i felt empty walking out of the movie...Mel Gibson did nothing to develop characters and did very little to show how Jesus felt that God had abandoned him, but then later Jesus proves his faith in god...I didnt see this at all... All I saw was Jesus getting the crap kicked out of him... i know that if this movie had been about Guru Arjan Dev Ji, I would have been inspired. I guess I would have to be Christian to get the full effect....but I know many christians who feel the same as I do...

Re: jesus film in usa

??? · 02 Apr 2004

VJKK VJKF! "..." thanks for your comments, which are valid as they comment on the content of the film and how you personally found it, without any need for sarcastic remarks. "Singh", for the record, I am not indicating anywhere that Jesus died for us as Sikhs at all, I have no objection to someone making mention of this, Rashpal Singh's manner of raising this could have been done in a manner more befitting when talking about a Saint, sarcastic language like "yeah right" is hardly befitting, especially when coming from a the mouth of a Khalsa. For the record, for any paranoid folk, I am not referring to him as a Sikh Sant or otherwise, but he was regardless of his time period or otherwise, a man of God and a Saint, which Rashpal Singh fails to recognise again, in his reply stating "frankly I don't care if he was a good man or bad, he did nothing for me or sikhi". Rashpal Singh, Jesus existing a long time before Sikhi as we know it today existed as I'm sure you're aware, but I trust you'll agree that Gurmat has always existed and whatever the state of Christianity today, Jesus like any other Bhagat, Prophet, Avtar or Guru came here to guide people to God, now that is the big picture that you seem to be missing, the issue that many Christians may have twisted or lost his message is another matter altogether. Again, I repeatedly state, I am not comparing him to Sikhi, he is from another tradition, however his status as a Saint warrants some respect which appears to be gravely missing. Regarding Jesus on the cross talking of being forsaken, this is something that needs to be viewed with a little more care, let's not forget Guru Nanak too approached Akal Purakh with a similar notion upon seeing the suffering of people at the hands of Babbar and also think of Guru Gobind Singh in his Shabd (Mittr Pyare Noo) following the Shaheedi of the younger Sahibzade...I'm not prepared to accept our Guru Sahibs as being weak in the slightest, we're all intelligent people here, so I'll allow everyone to draw their own conclusions from these episodes as to why a Saint, Prophet, Avtar or Guru would see fit to express such notions. Concerning, Sikh Shaheeds, I agree with have a history proud and written by the very blood of our ancestors, this is something that I will not ever doubt -interestingly, on this point, I saw the thread on White Sikhs and 3HO. Whilst I admire the rehit kept by these Singhs and Singhnees, I find do find it hilirious to see 3HO Sikhs with their "holier than thou" attitude towards Sikhs of Indian origin, the fact remains that Punjabi Sikhs have written their history in blood, 3HO Sikhs have written theirs with money and business. Sorry for any harsh or foolish comments on my part. Gur Fateh!

Re: jesus film in usa

Rashpal Singh · 02 Apr 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh Jesus was a sort of 'saint', just like Mohammed, Moses and the hindoo gods. But, like Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji has mentioned in his Bachittar Natak, all these 'avatars' or leaders ALL strayed from there path that akal purakh had given them, and started up their own religion. Anyway, you can read Bachittar Natak for all the details. Now im pretty sure if Jesus listened to Vaheguru and followed the way Vaheguru taught, then that path would have been the true path. This is why Dhan Guru Nanak came down in Kaljug, to teach the true path. Dhan Guru Nanak Dhan Gurmat. If I have said anything wrong, please, forgive me! VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: jesus film in usa

... · 02 Apr 2004

Rashpal Singh... you obviously do not know much about Christianity. Jesus did not start Christianity. He preached a way of life (much like our Gurus did) that would bring one closer to god. he did not push his way of life in an institutional form. He should be respected for what he did and what he taught... Jesus was always a jew. he was never a christian! (much like 9 of our gurus did not shak amrit...but are still considered great Sikhs) Christianity arose long after his death... what happened after his death was that his 12 apostles got together 40 years or so after his death and wrote teh gospels. people started to follow this new religion at their own risk ... they were killed for saying they were Christian.. (much as Sikhs did ...and still do today in Punjab). 400 years after his death, teh bible was written adn the christian church started to flourish.

Re: jesus film in usa

Rashpal Singh · 04 Apr 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh '...', Why are you telling me Jesus' life story? How can you say that the Gurus never partook amrit??? Of course they did!!! If they didn't, it would make them hypocrites, which they CERTAINLY, NEVER WERE!!!. Gurbani, stresses on amrit from the satguru....so ofcourse they took amrit, they were overflowing with it, and handed it out free to egveryone and still never occured a loss. When Guru Nanak was bathing in the river for 3 days and got taken to sachkhand, there he was given amrit!!! Also, you can never compare the greatness of the Sikh faith and Christianity, not that I say you are. VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh :D

Re: jesus film in usa

Mohan Singh · 09 Apr 2004

I agree completely with Rashpal Singh. Vaheguru

Re: jesus film in usa

simba · 09 Apr 2004

I agree with "???". All he/she is saying is that as Sikhs we should respect other religions, especially monotheist religions. To do otherwise is against Gurmat.

Re: jesus film in usa

~l~ · 10 Apr 2004

vaheguru i think rashpal singh ji's right aswell.... ~l~

Re: jesus film in usa

singh · 10 Apr 2004

>>"Regarding Jesus on the cross talking of being forsaken, this is something that needs to be viewed with a little more care, let's not forget Guru Nanak too approached Akal Purakh with a similar notion upon seeing the suffering of people at the hands of Babbar and also think of Guru Gobind Singh in his Shabd (Mittr Pyare Noo) following the Shaheedi of the younger Sahibzade...I'm not prepared to accept our Guru Sahibs as being weak in the slightest, we're all intelligent people here, so I'll allow everyone to draw their own conclusions from these episodes as to why a Saint, Prophet, Avtar or Guru would see fit to express such notions."<< What are you talking about??? You're comparing Jesus screaming and crying and blaming god to our guru's??!?!? Show me anywhere where our guru's ever said that god has forsaken them. Guru Jee said, 'Tera Keeaa Meetaa Lagaii.' Also, Guru Tegh Bahadur Jee headed off for Delhi himself to get shaheedi. Didn't have to be dragged, kicking and screaming. If you want to respect Jesus and Christianity, that's fine. Go ahead. But trying to compare him to our guru's? What are you on?? Open your eyes.. Christianity as a religion and Jesus as a prophet, can't and don't offer even an iota of what sikhee does. This may not be politically correct and may not fit some people's hippie-ish, flower power, praise everyone blindly viewpoint, but it is the truth.

Re: jesus film in usa

Rashpal Singh · 10 Apr 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh Simba, Where on this thread has someone been disrespectfull to any religion? or Jesus? Please point it out, as I am not aware of it. VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: jesus film in usa

simba · 10 Apr 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji ki Fateh >>and about how Jesus sacrificed his life to save us all....(yh right)<< >>You're comparing Jesus screaming and crying and blaming god to our guru's??!?!?<< >>All I saw was Jesus getting the crap kicked out of him...<< If you don't think any of these are disrespectful then just replace the name Jesus with the name of any Shaheed from our history. Tell me how you would feel if someone said this to you? Wouldn't you think of it as being disrespectful? Can you picture any great Sikh from our past talking like this? I can't. No one on this thread is arguing the superiority of Christianity to Sikhi. You are only arguing with yourself. All people are trying to say is that we should respect the views of others. It doesn't look good if we talk down about the death of any religious man. They believe in Jesus as much as we believe in our Guru's. This is an artistic expression. No one knows if he acted like that when he was crucified. Some people think that he didn't even die on a cross, but on just a long pole. He was vocally against the caste system of Judaism. Jewish priests lived like Kings while most other people were dying on the streets. They had their own walkways above the rest of the city so that they wouldn't have to walk with the common folk. Sound familiar? This is probobly why he was killed. I think he was a great man and to talk down about him is in my opinion very disrespectful. How can you expect people to respect your views when you don't show any respect for theirs. We should all be, and especially in this day and age, ambassadors for Sikhi. We should be walking talking examples of the greatness of Sikhi. We don't need to put anyone down so that we can feel superior. This is totally against Gurmat. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: jesus film in usa

Rashpal Singh · 12 Apr 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh Simba, >>and about how Jesus sacrificed his life to save us all....(yh right)<< Why do you find this offensive and disrespectful? I am simply stating facts. Not opinion. >>You're comparing Jesus screaming and crying and blaming god to our guru's??!?!?<< Singh is right. How can you compare that Guru (Jesus), to the SATGURU (Guru Nanak Dev Ji)? >>All I saw was Jesus getting the crap kicked out of him...<< And, how is that being disrespectful to Jesus?, the person is just telling everyone what he saw in the film. Which is why this thread was set up, to discuss the film. >>replace the name Jesus with the name of any Shaheed from our history.<< No. Sorry. I cannot do this, as our shaheeds put harder shaheedia forward than Jesus did. Getting cut limb by limb is harder than get nails in hands and feet. Getting your scalp cut off is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting broken in the wheels is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting sawn from head to toe is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting your nails and eyeballs is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting your muscles ripped out bit by bit is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting your body pierced by burning hot pincers is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting burnt alive is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting boiled in boiling hot water is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting hot sand poured over your body whilst sitting on a burning tavi is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting beaten by over one hundred soldiers is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting blown up by cannons whilst standing in front of them is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting acid bottles, spears, bullets thrown at you is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting cut on your body and then chilli powder poured into them is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting more than 17 fatal wounds in battle and still carrying on is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting your head chopped off and to carry on fighting is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting your skull bashed up and broken is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting cut up into little little pieces is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting your Childs dead body put around your neck is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting bricked alive is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. Getting beheaded at the cost of SOMEONE ELSES religion is much more harder than getting nails put in your hands and feet. The list is endless. A whole book could be written in that format. >>You are only arguing with yourself. All people are trying to say is that we should respect the views of others.<< Yes, of course we should respect the views of others. I do respect the views of others. I respect all your views, I am just expressing my own. >>It doesn't look good if we talk down about the death of any religious man.<< No. It doesn't 'look' good. But I am not saying that I can put the sort of shaheedi he put. I start crying when I get pricked by a small needle. I am just saying, you cannot compare how Jesus got Kurban to how our ENDLESS ENDLESS shaheeds got Kurban. >>He was vocally against the caste system of Judaism. Jewish priests lived like Kings while most other people were dying on the streets. They had their own walkways above the rest of the city so that they wouldn't have to walk with the common folk. Sound familiar? This is probobly why he was killed. I think he was a great man and to talk down about him is in my opinion very disrespectful. How can you expect people to respect your views when you don't show any respect for theirs.<< We are not discussing about his life and his teachings, obviously the teaching were very good, just what every religion teaches. Common Sense. We are discussing his shaheedi. He was a good man, I don't think any religious guru or prophet was 'bad', it is just the people in the religion that give them a bad name. >>We don't need to put anyone down so that we can feel superior. This is totally against Gurmat.<< No one is getting 'put down', like I said Jesus' kurbani was hard to give, but still, even harder were the kurbania of sikh shaheeds. Jesus' shaheedi was 'mahaan' for the Christians, but even more 'Mahaan' were the shaheedia of our gursikhs. jagath maa(n)hi hai pa(n)thh s jaethae karai ni(n)dh nehi kabehoo(n) thaethae || He never slanders any other faith or religion of the world. Rehatnama Bhai Nand Laal Jee VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh