Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

Sikhi · 12 Jun 2006

I know that bani has many subject about the followers of Islam, but what did Guru Maharaj said about the last prophet of the Abrahamic faith? What was their view on the message he brought into the world?

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

Mehtab Singh · 14 Jun 2006

This Shabad is by Guru Nanak Dev Ji in Raag Maajh on Pannaa 141 sloku mÚ 1 ] salok ma 1 || Salok, First Mehla: muslmwxu khwvxu musklu jw hoie qw muslmwxu khwvY ] musalamaan kehaavan musakal jaa hoe thaa musalamaan kehaavai || It is difficult to be called a Muslim; if one is truly a Muslim, then he may be called one. Avil Aauil dInu kir imTw mskl mwnw mwlu muswvY ] aval aoul dheen kar mit(h)aa masakal maanaa maal musaavai || First, let him savor the religion of the Prophet as sweet; then, let his pride of his possessions be scraped away. hoie musilmu dIn muhwxY mrx jIvx kw Brmu cukwvY ] hoe musalim dheen muhaanai maran jeevan kaa bharam chukaavai || Becoming a true Muslim, a disciple of the faith of Mohammed, let him put aside the delusion of death and life. rb kI rjwie mMny isr aupir krqw mMny Awpu gvwvY ] rab kee rajaae ma(n)nae sir oupar karathaa ma(n)nae aap gavaavai || As he submits to God's Will, and surrenders to the Creator, he is rid of selfishness and conceit. qau nwnk srb jIAw imhrMmiq hoie q muslmwxu khwvY ]1] tho naanak sarab jeeaa mihara(n)math hoe th musalamaan kehaavai ||1|| And when, O Nanak, he is merciful to all beings, only then shall he be called a Muslim. ||1|| Other places: http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=90&english=t&id=3759 http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=99&english=t&id=4116 http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=1214&english=t&id=50970 http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=1236&english=t&id=51876 http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=1288&english=t&id=54054 [%sig%]

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

Singh · 14 Jun 2006

Raam Raheem Puraan Quran, anayk kehay mat, ayk na maanyo

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

some1 · 14 Jun 2006

and this proves that non sikhs can goto sachkhand.

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

... · 14 Jun 2006

This shabad doesn't use the word "Mohammed" even once. Once again, the translator has taken the very generous liberty of reading it in. Just as Sukhmani Sahib re-defines Pandit and Bhagauti and whoever fits this definition is in fact a Sikh, Guru Sahib has once again re-defined 'Muslim'. Guru Sahib in the same vaar, before the salok Mehtab Singh posted re-defines Muslim in the following way, [gurbani]sloku mÚ 1 ] imhr msIiq isdku muslw hku hlwlu kurwxu ] srm suMniq sIlu rojw hohu muslmwxu ] krxI kwbw scu pIru klmw krm invwj ] qsbI sw iqsu BwvsI nwnk rKY lwj ]1][/gurbani] So, if someone follows this description, they are in fact a Sikh. A Muslim would find this definition to be blasphemy. I'd also like to ask the above author to think for a moment and ask himself if he really thinks Mohammed, who married a 9 year old at the age of 50 and sanctioned the rape of women prisoners, would really find a place in Sachkhand with Guru Sahib and all the Gursikhs. Rather than being politically correct and having an inferiority complex about Sikhi, just use your common sense.

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

A.S.Khalsa · 14 Jun 2006

VJKK VJKF, Guru Nanak Dev Ji used to respond by say ''there is no musalmaan, there is no hindu'' when people asked him to what faith he belonged to. This statement that Guru said used to cause much anger amongst folk...and complaints...untill they actually listened. Guru Ji said that in the here after world, there is no caste, no creed, no status, and no religion, everyone is looked upon as equal, therefore God does not take into consideration of what faith or rituals etc you follow...He only looks into the Heart to see the love and devotions a person has for Him, and the Good Deeds they performed. This is what gains a soul salvation Guru Nanak Explained. This delighted many folk who listened on... Puhl Chuk Maaf Karna (forgive me for any foolish mistakes please) VJKK VJKF

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

Sikhi · 14 Jun 2006

The Shabad by Guru Nanak Dev Ji in Raag Maajh on Pannaa 141 cleary says that if a true muslims lives according these rules he actually is a pure Sikh. Does this mean that Guru Maharaaj doubts the preaching of the last prophet? If a prophet can't make his followers into a being that Guru Maharaaj is saying what is the use of calling such a person a "prophet" ?? Am I wrong?

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

Mehtab Singh · 14 Jun 2006

Just yesterday morning daas was listening to Maskeen jee's katha. Maskeen jee stated that the only true panth is prem panth, and even a non-Sikh. like a Jew or a Christian or a Muslim who has prem can achieve the supreme spiritual goal. Guru Gobind Singh Jee's words "jinn prem kiyo tinn hi prabh paayo" ([i]whoever loves achieves God[/i]) were also discussed. Chandra veerji, I have talked to a few GurSikhs about the difference between the semitic belief that their faith is the passport to heaven, and how GurSikhi sees it. The main difference is that in Sikhi, a person is not condemned just because he/she is a non-Sikh. The Gurus didn't condemn any religion. Guru Nanak Dev Jee was asked about the end result of Hindus and Muslims, as in who will be saved. Gurujee said "shubh amlaa baajo dono roi", "both will cry if they haven't done good deeds", so we need to understand that Gurujee was not prejudiced against any religion at all. Please don't mistake this as the semitic idea that all non-Muslims or non-Christians are doomed for hell for eternity. Now the other question "What happens to non-Sikhs". From what I have been told, a good devout Hindu, a good devout Muslim, a good devout Christian doesn't go to hell just because he/she is not Sikh. Thats a semitic belief, not a Sikh one. The "my way or the highway" theory if you will. But the thing is that the Hindu gets what he/she aimed for, which could be the deity he/she worshipped. And so he/she goes there, enjoys the fruits of his/her good deeds, but eventually has to come back into the cycle of reincarnation as liberation comes only through Naam from the SatGuru. The Muslims and Christians aim for heaven, and they may achieve it too, but they too don't get liberated. The GurSikh on the other hand has Gurjee to free him. This is what I have come across. Its not my opinion, just what I have grasped. If I made any mistake please forgive me. daas ~ Mehtab Singh

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

Baldeep Singh · 16 Jun 2006

Bhai Mehtab Singhjee You are absolutely correct, Sikhi does not condemn anyone or any faith. What you sow is what you are gonna reap sooner or later. I dont have no pity for the ignorant fool (chandra Sinh), he is attempting to convince Gursikhs that the Gurmat dharm is a Hindu Dharm, moreso, he is frustatingly attempting to convince himself and every turn he is hitting a wall (Grinning) ;-)) [%sig%]

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

dr sharma · 16 Jun 2006

abrahmic? who wants to have pandit influence? id rather think for myself with guru granth sahib as our logic base

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

london singh · 16 Jun 2006

Vijaydeep Singh you're argument is very inconsistant. On the one hand you say that Guruji did not put praise Mohammed in the Guru Granth Sahib because this is against Islam as it is shirk but then you state that there are verses already in praise of Mohammed in the Koran. So does this mean that the Koran is guilty of shirk? As for a 'nirmala' stating that Mahdeen means fundamentalist Islam and Mohammed that is a new idea brought forward recently and along with his other claims has been easily refuted. The verses clearly refer to a PERSON and not a BELIEF. All translations of Bachittar Natak state that Mahdeen is used for Mohammed. Considering that Mohammed has been accused of peadophilia, genocide and basically every known war crime there is, it is not surprising that the Bachittar Natak refers to him in a negative manner.

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

Mehtab Singh · 16 Jun 2006

Chandra jee, Guru Nanak Dev Jee is Aad Guru. He was born a Guru. http://members.dancris.com/~sikh/chap03.html Without the Guru, there can be no Gurbani. Guru is a channel through whom Gurbani is delivered. Therefore, when at the age of seven, Guru Nanak delivered the first Divine message to his teacher (Rag Asa Mohalla 1, Patti Likhi, p-432), he had to be and he was the Guru. Before disappearing in the river, a lot of Gurbani was already delivered by the Guru. He was, thus, born as Guru and his Guruship started from the very birth. Bhai Gurdas, a Sikh apostle writes that first the Almighty bestowed His blessings on Baba (Guru Nanak) and then He sent him to this world to spread the Divine Word: "Pehlan babei paya bakhash dar, pichhon dei phir ghal kamaee." (Bhai Gurdas- Var 1, pauri 24) [u]Who was Guru Nanak's Guru? When he was asked, who his Guru was, Guru Nanak replied that God Himself was his Guru[/u]: "[u]Unfathomable and Infinite is God Who acted as Guru of Nanak." (Sorath Mohalla 1, p-599)[/u] Definition of Guru according to Sikhi: http://members.dancris.com/~sikh/chap01.html India before Guru Nanak: http://members.dancris.com/~sikh/chap02.html [%sig%]

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

komal · 17 Jun 2006

chandra singh. u obviously have a great phobia and hatred of Muslims and Islam. I think u should keep this disease to yourself. ur clearly a hindu fanatic trying to twist sikhi in something that will make you feel comfortable. unfortunately for u, sikhi DOES have things in common with Islam. Sikhi is the bridge between the Indian and Semitic faith, and one day all Muslims and Hindu's will be brothers when Sikhi becomes strong again. To answer ur question, the Guru of Guru Nanak is Waheguru. God is the guru of Guru Nanak. This may not fit in with Hindu philosophy, that is ur problem. if you have as much love for Guru Nanak Dev Maharaj as you pretend to have, you would already be a Sikh instead of a troll!

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

london singh · 17 Jun 2006

>>Then cmoing to Dear Brother London Singh Ji, Vachitar Natak needs newer understadning as Mahdeen can come after Ramananda and Gorakh may not be historicall true but Semtioc faiths after Gorakh Panth and Vaishnav panth can be true.Das will put some links about it on new thread some other day.<< Vijaydeep Singh, I think that disputing that Mahdeen is Mohammed solely because his name is not listed chronologically is a weak argument. If Mahdeen is just an allegory for fundamentalist Islam then the verse makes no sense -; Tin bhi ek panth upaja He also created his own sect Sabh te apna naam japayo He caused all to contemplate his own name So has fundamentalist Islam created a sect and has it caused it's own name to be contemplated? This doesn't make sense only Mohammed created his own sect and he caused his name to be contemplated which is a part of the Islam creed. Earlier within Bachittar Natak the following verse appears Mahdeen ketay prithi maanjh hooey sammay aapni aapni ant mooaye Jitay Aulaya ambiya hoei beetay titiyo kaal jeeta na teh kaal jeetay Jitay Raam se Krisan huie bisaan aay titiyo kaal khaapiyo na teh kaal jeetay Many Mohammeds have been created and each dies according to his time All the Prophets and saints of the past were conquered by Death, but none could conquer it All the incarnations of Vishnu like Rama and Krishan were destroyed by death, but they could not destroy him. So according to you if Bachittar Natak has to be chronological then Mahdeen here cannot refer to fundamentalist Islam as it did not appear before Raam and Krishna. So how many fundamentalist Islams have there been?

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

komal · 17 Jun 2006

chandra singh "As far as Islam is concerned it is an "Aasuric" (demonic) cult rooted in Adharma and it is my duty to oppose it. " some muslims say the same about Hindu dharma. how does that make you feel? simply you think islam is aasuric because of the bad treatment the muslim invaders gave the hindu population "As one can see, the very term "Islamophobia" is stupid because Islam is a belief system and it is not possible to be phobic of a belief." thnk u for giving me an insightful briefing about phobia's and how they cant be used as a feeling for a religous belief. i was saying phobia for muslims as a people, is that hard to understand? "What do you know of Hindu Philosphy?. " irrelevant. YOU are HERE assuming you know the be all and end all about sikhi. yes i know what ur answer is going to be, ur not trying to be a know it all, but when u continue arguements with bhai kulbir singh and bhai mehtab singh who DO know a great more about sikhi then u, then u are being an obnoxious know it all. i think you should spend more time ASKING them instead of LECTURING, no? "I thought (if i go buy my Sikh brothers on this forum) Sikhi is best religion for the age of kaliyuga but you seems to indicate otherway and you stooping sikhi below the two outdated religions i.e. Hinduism & Islam and making it mere bridge between the two." yes sikhi is the best religion for kalyug, you got that right, but u obviously dont believe it until u have become a full kesadhari, amritdhari sikh who follows the sikh rehat, but that wont happen will it? u will remain a hindu who will put the vedas and upanisads over the sri guru granth sahib. i think you are just here to play games. u shouldnt feel too proud of what ur doing, many others have come before and tried ur game. "Hindus have been Chanting above since thousands of years before Khalistanis started claiming it as USP of Sikhi." chandra ji, i can sense ur bitterness towards khalistani's. if you really have love for sikhi then u would be a khalistani urself. in the future hindustan will become khalistan anyway, so u may as well jump on the band wagon ;) "Only thing Guru Nanak devji asked was to become Gurumukh from Manmukh." very, very smart reply chandra ji. the same remarks a mona will make while excusing himself for not keeping kes, for not taking amrit. youll have to do better than that. i will end this message but i want you to prove to us u are sincere. become a full practicing sikh, jaap the beautiful naam of waheguru, keep your kes, then ur claim to trying to become a gurmukh will be taken seriously. dont disappoint us.

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

E · 18 Jun 2006

mihar maseeth sidhak musalaa hak halaal kuraan || Let mercy be your mosque, faith your prayer-mat, and honest living your Koran. saram su(n)nath seel rojaa hohu musalamaan || Make modesty your circumcision, and good conduct your fast. In this way, you shall be a true Muslim. karanee kaabaa sach peer kalamaa karam nivaaj || Let good conduct be your Kaabaa, Truth your spiritual guide, and the karma of good deeds your prayer and chant. thasabee saa this bhaavasee naanak rakhai laaj ||1|| Let your rosary be that which is pleasing to His Will. O Nanak, God shall preserve your honor ---------------------------- a true muslim is one who lives according to what siri guru nanak dev ji taught, hence a true muslim is actually sikh. --------------------------- pa(n)j nivaajaa vakhath pa(n)j pa(n)jaa pa(n)jae naao || There are five prayers and five times of day for prayer; the five have five names. pehilaa sach halaal dhue theejaa khair khudhaae || Let the first be truthfulness, the second honest living, and the third charity in the Name of God. chouthhee neeath raas man pa(n)javee sifath sanaae || Let the fourth be good will to all, and the fifth the praise of the Lord. karanee kalamaa aakh kai thaa musalamaan sadhaae || Repeat the prayer of good deeds, and then, you may call yourself a Muslim. naanak jaethae koorriaar koorrai koorree paae ||3|| O Nanak, the false obtain falsehood, and only falsehood. ||3|| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

E · 18 Jun 2006

prathhamae garabh vaas thae ttariaa || First, they come forth from the womb. puthr kalathr kutta(n)b sa(n)g juriaa || They become attached to their children, spouses and families. bhojan anik prakaar bahu kaparae || sarapar gavan karehigae bapurae ||1|| The foods of various sorts and appearances will surely pass away, O wretched mortal! ||1|| kavan asathhaan jo kabahu n ttarai || What is that place which never perishes? kavan sabadh jith dhuramath harai ||1|| rehaao || What is that Word by which the dirt of the mind is removed? ||1||Pause|| ei(n)dhr puree mehi sarapar maranaa || In the Realm of Indra, death is sure and certain. breham puree nihachal nehee rehanaa || The Realm of Brahma shall not remain permanent. siv puree kaa hoeigaa kaalaa || The Realm of Shiva shall also perish. thrai gun maaeiaa binas bithaalaa ||2|| The three dispositions, Maya and the demons shall vanish. ||2|| gir thar dhharan gagan ar thaarae || The mountains, the trees, the earth, the sky and the stars; rav sas pavan paavak neeraarae || the sun, the moon, the wind, water and fire; dhinas rain barath ar bhaedhaa || day and night, fasting days and their determination; saasath si(n)mrith binasehigae baedhaa ||3|| the Shaastras, the Simritees and the Vedas shall pass away. ||3|| theerathh dhaev dhaehuraa pothhee || The sacred shrines of pilgrimage, gods, temples and holy books; maalaa thilak soch paak hothee || rosaries, ceremonial tilak marks on the forehead, meditative people, the pure, and the performers of burnt offerings; dhhothee dda(n)ddouth parasaadhan bhogaa || wearing loin cloths, bowing in reverence and the enjoyment of sacred foods gavan karaigo sagalo logaa ||4|| - all these, and all people, shall pass away. ||4|| jaath varan thurak ar hi(n)dhoo || Social classes, races, MUSLIMS and HINDUS; pas pa(n)khee anik jon ji(n)dhoo || beasts, birds and the many varieties of beings and creatures; sagal paasaar dheesai paasaaraa || the entire world and the visible universe binas jaaeigo sagal aakaaraa ||5|| - all forms of existence SHALL PASS AWAY. ||5|| sehaj sifath bhagath thath giaanaa || Through the Praises of the Lord, devotional worship, spiritual wisdom and the essence of reality, sadhaa ana(n)dh nihachal sach thhaanaa || eternal bliss and the imperishable true place are obtained. thehaa sa(n)gath saadhh gun rasai || There, in the SAADH SANGHAT, the Company of the Holy, the Lord's Glorious Praises are sung with love. anabho nagar thehaa sadh vasai ||6|| There, in the city of fearlessness, He dwells FOREVER. ||6|| theh bho bharamaa sog n chi(n)thaa || There is no fear, doubt, suffering or anxiety there; aavan jaavan mirath n hothaa || there is NO COMING or GOING, and NO DEATH there. theh sadhaa ana(n)dh anehath aakhaarae || There is eternal bliss, and the unstruck celestial music there. bhagath vasehi keerathan aadhhaarae ||7|| The devotees dwell there, with the KIRTAN of the Lord's Praises as their support. ||7|| paarabreham kaa a(n)th n paar || There is no end or limitation to the Supreme Lord God. koun karai thaa kaa beechaar || Who can embrace His contemplation? kahu naanak jis kirapaa karai || Says Nanak, when the Lord showers His Mercy, nihachal thhaan saadhhasa(n)g tharai ||8||4|| the imperishable home is obtained; in the Saadh Sangat, you shall be saved. ||8||4||

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

Kulwant Singh · 18 Jun 2006

Singh wrote: > Raam Raheem Puraan Quran, anayk kehay mat, ayk na maanyo> WAJK WJKF I have not read the whole string of this subject but the dass understands the meaning of this tuk in a different way: Raam Raheem Puraan Quran, anayak kehay, mat ayk na maanyo The comma is after "kehay" Meaning: All religious book above say lot of thing but I do not follow them Paahay gahey jab tey tumray... ankh teray ... ** I do not consider them ** Again, this this dass's interpretation.

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

london singh · 19 Jun 2006

Vijaydeep Singh, your answers get more and more ridiculous. You are clutching at straws trying to give the word Mahdeen a meaning which does not fit into grammaritical structure of the verse. As from your response to the wife battering sura of the Koran, that is frankly laughable. One can understand the Muslims attempt to make Islam appear to be a modern faith and one that belongs to the modern world and not to 7th century Arabia but for a Sikh to be taken in by such attempts is a matter of regret. I understand that you belonged to the RSS previously and now you are a Sikh. It is natural to go from one extreme ie RSS and hating Muslims to the other extreme of taking everything that Muslims say as gospel. All the moreso since Muslims are allowed to LIE in order to promote them faith.

Re: What Did Guru Maharaj said about Prophet Muhamed?

Admin · 19 Jun 2006

Topic now closed. Admin.