Re: Sarabloh Granth
Jagjit Matharu · 15 Jun 2006
Nice of you all to refer to Guruji as a book. Well done Singho!
Re: Sarabloh Granth
Jagvinder Singh · 15 Jun 2006
hey jagjit, dont start such a meaningless argument again. ive had enough of this bloody fanaticism. maybe you, since you were a kid, were always told to refer to the guru granth sahib ji as a living breathing guru, not a book. but some unfortunate ones like us, whose parents never were into sikhi, we had to find our own way, and everytime the guru granth sahib ji was referred to as a holy book only. exactly, in its physical form, it is only a book. PHYSICAL FORM. thats logic isnt it. its called guru because all the divine wisdom and knowledge of our gurus plus other saints is in there, therefore whenever we need SPIRITUAL guidance, we refer to it. but yes, we're not meant to worship it as a living guru. because, we're not supposed to do idol worship. our worship should only be naam of akaal. hope you get that right. itstill is referred to as a holy book in non punjabi speaking circles. cut all this fanaticism. if u gonna get down to these nitty gritties, trust me dude, no one's gonna take amrit. and then you'll complain tt oh, our singhs are being misguided, losing their sikhi. of course they will. u guys make sikhi virtually impossible to practise. dude, its year 2006 now. we are the minority. lets get the numbers first, then the strictness will come.
[%sig%]
Re: Sarabloh Granth
Jagjit Matharu · 15 Jun 2006
Its not fanatism.....its faith. Gursikhs have faith which is often interpretated by Punjabis as Fanatism. Thats the life of a Punjabi justifying why they have turned their backs to Guruji.
Re: Sarabloh Granth
khalistan_zindabaad · 15 Jun 2006
sri guru granth sahib ji is the eternal guru for the sikhs. . . guru sahib ji also wrote sarbloh granth and sri dasm granth ( being guru jees bani) i beleive they should hold the same respect. listen to katha of sri dasm granth on
http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/audio/index.php?q=f&f=%2FKatha%2FSant_Jarnail_Singh_Ji_Khalsa_Bhinderawale%2FSri+Dasam+Granth
for more information
Re: Sarabloh Granth
Jagvinder Singh · 15 Jun 2006
i didnt say anything about the rehit maryada.... to each one their own. but yes,
slamming somebody each time they make a small grammatical error, such as, using the word book, or holy book to refer to siri guru granth sahib ji, is fanaticism. if we slam each other on these small little details, how are we going to live together. i just didnt like jagjit singh's sarcasm on his first post. THAT WAS FANATICISM.dont judge me.
Re: Sarabloh Granth
Jagjit Matharu · 16 Jun 2006
So an english translation by a SGPC employee becomes gospel?? All my point is that we are discussing Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, lets not refer to our eternal guru as a book.
Re: Sarabloh Granth
Jagvinder Singh · 16 Jun 2006
you should be thankful enough that there are english translations being written, so its reachable to a larger audience..... how do you think the christians got so huge.... it was because of those very translations.... and, yeah, i respect your opinion, and even i have pothis of SGGS at home, in romanised, and with the highest respect, its still titled SGGS.come on man, im sure you have used the term holy book to describe SGGS to your non sikh friends before, dont deny this fact. 90% of us do. its all over in the media, even in documentaries u can hear tt we do take it as our eternal guru, but my point was, in PHYSICAL contex, it is a book. and it will be, to non sikhs who still come to pay respect to it, to bow to it. we cant force em to imagine its our guru, come on. tts what i was tryin to tell ya.
Re: Sarabloh Granth
BirRass Singh · 16 Jun 2006
Jagjit Matharu - can you translate the meaning of "Granth"?