Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sarabloh Granth

Sarabloh Granth

A Singh · 14 Jun 2006

Gur Fateh! I would like to discuss what the Sangat's views are on the Sarabloh Granth being installed as a third part of the Guru Granth Sahib as it is claimed by some to be the practice amongst the Nihang Dals. As per the Sikh Rehit Maryada, it is clear that no other book should be placed on par with the Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Some people view this as yet another insult to their view on what was the "Puratan" format of Sikh practice (i.e. having both Guru Granth Sahib Adi Bir and Dasam Granth Sahib placed side by side) by the Singh Sabha. Others disagree with this view, since the Dasam Granth was not given Gur Gaddi by Guru Gobind Singh at Nanded (as it was compiled after his passing), but in any event it can be accepted that post compilation by Bhai Mani Singh Shaheed, it was treated on par with the Adi Granth Sahib by the Puratan Singhs - for this, we have ample evidence. This practice is still in vogue today in Hazoor Sahib, Nanded and parts of Patna and within the Damdami Taksal. The question I would like to raise however is not if Dasam Granth or Sri Sarabloh Parkash should be given the Gurgaddi, this has been discussed before many times, but if indeed the prakash of the Sri Sarabloh Granth is a "puratan maryada" as claimed by some today. If it was, then why is the parkash not evident in Hazoor Sahib, which the supporters of the Guru Granth Sahib in three formats saroop view, argue to be the true holder of traditional Khalsa maryada. In fact it seems that not even all Nihang Dals or Deras practice this maryada? In fact it only seems to have come to light recently (i.e. post 1920s) and doesn't seem to be any puratan maryada? Perhaps I am missing something, but what are the Sangat's views? [Hopefully we can have a little more than the "secret text" theory]

Re: Sarabloh Granth

PTE SINGH · 15 Jun 2006

Whats the Sarabloh Granth? Please explain

Re: Sarabloh Granth

Jagjit Matharu · 15 Jun 2006

Nice of you all to refer to Guruji as a book. Well done Singho!

Re: Sarabloh Granth

Jagvinder Singh · 15 Jun 2006

hey jagjit, dont start such a meaningless argument again. ive had enough of this bloody fanaticism. maybe you, since you were a kid, were always told to refer to the guru granth sahib ji as a living breathing guru, not a book. but some unfortunate ones like us, whose parents never were into sikhi, we had to find our own way, and everytime the guru granth sahib ji was referred to as a holy book only. exactly, in its physical form, it is only a book. PHYSICAL FORM. thats logic isnt it. its called guru because all the divine wisdom and knowledge of our gurus plus other saints is in there, therefore whenever we need SPIRITUAL guidance, we refer to it. but yes, we're not meant to worship it as a living guru. because, we're not supposed to do idol worship. our worship should only be naam of akaal. hope you get that right. itstill is referred to as a holy book in non punjabi speaking circles. cut all this fanaticism. if u gonna get down to these nitty gritties, trust me dude, no one's gonna take amrit. and then you'll complain tt oh, our singhs are being misguided, losing their sikhi. of course they will. u guys make sikhi virtually impossible to practise. dude, its year 2006 now. we are the minority. lets get the numbers first, then the strictness will come. [%sig%]

Re: Sarabloh Granth

Charanjit · 15 Jun 2006

Jagvinder Singh, In your terms who or what is a "fanatic"? I suppose giving your head to Guru Ji is a sign of fanaticism? Wearing a kirpan is a sign of fanaticism? Bowing down to a "book" is a sign of fanaticism? Following a strict code of conduct (Rehat Maryada) is a sign of fanaticism? Is short being a GurSikhs is a sign of fanaticism!

Re: Sarabloh Granth

some1 · 15 Jun 2006

who is a fanatic? hmmmm........... Sikh code of conduct? how many people on this board (me inclusive) are out there finding zulum???? theres no such thing as strict code of conduct any more.

Re: Sarabloh Granth

Jagjit Matharu · 15 Jun 2006

Its not fanatism.....its faith. Gursikhs have faith which is often interpretated by Punjabis as Fanatism. Thats the life of a Punjabi justifying why they have turned their backs to Guruji.

Re: Sarabloh Granth

Charanjit · 15 Jun 2006

"Author: some1 Theres no such thing as strict code of conduct any more." So what's the point?

Re: Sarabloh Granth

khalistan_zindabaad · 15 Jun 2006

sri guru granth sahib ji is the eternal guru for the sikhs. . . guru sahib ji also wrote sarbloh granth and sri dasm granth ( being guru jees bani) i beleive they should hold the same respect. listen to katha of sri dasm granth on http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/audio/index.php?q=f&f=%2FKatha%2FSant_Jarnail_Singh_Ji_Khalsa_Bhinderawale%2FSri+Dasam+Granth for more information

Re: Sarabloh Granth

A Singh · 15 Jun 2006

Bhai Vijaydeep Singh, Thanks for your comments. Jagjit Matharu, good to hear from you again, please note the following: No book should he installed like and at par with the Guru Granth Sahib . [Taken from http://www.sgpc.net/sikhism/gurdwara.html] All anyone is saying is the above, lets not starting deviating from every topic with nitpicking remarks. PTE Singh Veer, the Sarabloh Granth is a scripture attributed to Guru Gobind Singh and particularly respected by the Nihangs. You can read about it here [note, I am not promoting the material on this website, it simply contains an article on the Sri Sarabloh Granth]: http://www.sikh-heritage.co.uk/Scriptures/sarbloh%20granth/sarbloh.htm

Re: Sarabloh Granth

Jagvinder Singh · 15 Jun 2006

i didnt say anything about the rehit maryada.... to each one their own. but yes, slamming somebody each time they make a small grammatical error, such as, using the word book, or holy book to refer to siri guru granth sahib ji, is fanaticism. if we slam each other on these small little details, how are we going to live together. i just didnt like jagjit singh's sarcasm on his first post. THAT WAS FANATICISM.dont judge me.

Re: Sarabloh Granth

ns · 16 Jun 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh A Singh Jeeo you raise a very important topic. One thing is for certain and that is in the ardas at Hazoor Sahib I believe only Guru Granth Sahib Jee is menitoned. However some nihung dals especially some young nihung types with huge egos in the UK mention all three Granths in the ardaas. We really are loosing it amongst our selves and in our upcoming youth. May Guru Ji guide us somehow.

Re: Sarabloh Granth

Jagjit Matharu · 16 Jun 2006

So an english translation by a SGPC employee becomes gospel?? All my point is that we are discussing Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, lets not refer to our eternal guru as a book.

Re: Sarabloh Granth

A Singh · 16 Jun 2006

Jagjit Matharu - perhaps you will kindly note that the term book was used not for Sri Guru Granth Sahib, but for "another book" and moreover the english translation is exactly the point - limitation of language, please could you tell me how you would translate "granth", scriptures, text, books, magnus opus - none of these are acceptable for us, but for purposes of making their point clearly the Rehit Maryada needed to use one, in any event, we digress from the main theme. ns - the three Granths mentioned by the UK Nihangs on their Ardas is not something made up by them - this is how the Ardas exists in the official Budha Dal Gutka. In reality, it is no different to the fact that the Taksal, Nanaksar, Nirmalas and others all have variations, be they small or large from the standardised text of the Ardas.

Re: Sarabloh Granth

Jagvinder Singh · 16 Jun 2006

you should be thankful enough that there are english translations being written, so its reachable to a larger audience..... how do you think the christians got so huge.... it was because of those very translations.... and, yeah, i respect your opinion, and even i have pothis of SGGS at home, in romanised, and with the highest respect, its still titled SGGS.come on man, im sure you have used the term holy book to describe SGGS to your non sikh friends before, dont deny this fact. 90% of us do. its all over in the media, even in documentaries u can hear tt we do take it as our eternal guru, but my point was, in PHYSICAL contex, it is a book. and it will be, to non sikhs who still come to pay respect to it, to bow to it. we cant force em to imagine its our guru, come on. tts what i was tryin to tell ya.

Re: Sarabloh Granth

BirRass Singh · 16 Jun 2006

Jagjit Matharu - can you translate the meaning of "Granth"?

Re: Sarabloh Granth

.. · 16 Jun 2006

too many people do idol woship of the SGGS and forget God which is the whole damn point of Sikhi

Re: Sarabloh Granth

some1 · 16 Jun 2006

charanjit that is the point. for petes sake..this extreemisim is takign the panth down.

Re: Sarabloh Granth

A Singh · 16 Jun 2006

Sarabloh Granth anyone?