Re: 1 Wife or 3
Mandeep Singh · 30 Mar 2004
Firstly since our history diasgrees and so does gurbani on having many wifes we can conclude that this is false.
Secondly you should ask for the source of the information where hes making this claim. If you look at india's hisorical documents going back centuries they are not all that credible i.e. scrolls that no longer exist, and half the time you cannot be sure who has written them, they could be scriblings of a mad man, including puratan janamsaki, even Radhaswamis admit this!
So basically looking at the majority of india's historical documents, they most likely are false as there so many conflicting points of view, so the only common thing they have is that they are old. E.g. consider the 84 ghulughara, GOI deny acts of genocide however sikhs say it did happen and have lots of evidence to prove this, this is only 20yrs since this happened so looking at the evidence you have two sides of the story each as old as each other yet completly different claims.
Dont even let those blokes quote from ppl like Mcleoyd or mcaullif as i think you will find that the prints of their books have vastly changed since the first edition so you cant even be sure what his real findings were/are. and should they be contradictory to bani, well look as his sources, the above anonamous scrolls.
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Kulbir Singh · 30 Mar 2004
Despite what the historians write, our Guru Sahibaan had only one wife at a given time. It is possible that Siri Guru jee had more than one wife but not at a given time.
Historians who liked to view our Guru Sahibaan as true Kings, felt the need to depict them as kings having many wives. This is why only Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee and Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj are shown as having more than one wives.
The reality is that Siri Guru jee had only one wife at a given time. After the demise of their wife, they may had gotten remarried.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Kulbir Singh · 31 Mar 2004
--------
I don’t know about the idea that historians have tried to make the Guru Ji like all other kings which is why this issue only surrounds 6th and 10 patsha’s because Guru Har Rai was also a King and lived like 6th and 10th patsha’s but no controversy exists there.
---------
Who says that Siri Guru Har Rai jee is not accused of having more than one wife? Many misguided and ill-informed historians have written that Siri Guru Har Rai jee had 7 wives. They have written a story that Siri Guru jee married the 7 daughters of a king and the oldest one of these wives was Mata Kishan Kaur, who was only 13-14 years old at that time. Siri Guru jee was also young and in his early teens at the time of his marriage.
This story of 7 wives is ridiculous and false and now it has been proven beyond doubt that he had only one wife - Mata Kishan Kaur jee.
As for Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee, Mata Sundri and Mata Jeeto jee were not two women but one woman with two names. It is a common tradition in Khatris and many others too to change bibi's name when she gets married. Jeeto was Mata jee's name before marriage and Sundri was the name that Mata Gujri jee gave her because of her natural beauty and noble temperament. Many of Mata jee acquaintances from before marriage continued to call her Jeeto jee, while her in-laws called her Sundri jee. This is how this misunderstanding was created. After amrit chhak, Mata Sundri was named Mata Sahib Kaur.
As for Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee, historians write that he had 3 wives but this cannot be true. It is quite possible that there too, the name of his wife was changed after marriage and he got married again when his first wife passed away. Our Guru Sahib could not have kept 3 wives at one time. Historians have misunderstood.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: 1 Wife or 3
princess of power · 31 Mar 2004
oh my god, this is so pathetic.
Do any of you people actually listen to katha of Suraj Parkash when they do it at the Gurdwara?
If you did, you would realize exactly how and why Guru Hargobind Ji had 3 wives.
Its really quite beautiful. Why are we trying to make our Gurus fit into our own ideals? We should accept that those times are vastly different to todays times and we were not gore in those days where Indian Culture mattered. Not some western Culture where only 1 wife is acceptable.
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Kulbir Singh · 31 Mar 2004
Bhain jee Princess of Power jee,
Kindly post the story behind Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee's marriage, as you state is written in Suraj Parkash Granth.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: 1 Wife or 3
princess of power · 31 Mar 2004
Nope. Its all there for you.
"minat naal fal mildha"
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Kulbir Singh · 31 Mar 2004
--------
Nope. Its all there for you.
"minat naal fal mildha"
---------
Tussi vee thori mehnat kar lavo, Bhain jee.
Please post the story as you heard it.
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Kulbir Singh · 01 Apr 2004
Khalistani Veer jeeo,
Please refer to Gurbani Paath Darshan by Sant Gurbachan Singh jee for details on 7 wives of Siri Guru Har Rai jee. I will see if I can provide you with the page number.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Answer in Naam · 02 Apr 2004
if you want the answer spend your time doing Naam Simran and Paath and become one with Waheguru and you will get all the answer to life.
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Kulbir Singh · 02 Apr 2004
--------
Doesn't this just back up the idea that Guru Ji's had more than 1 Wife. It appears that most of the evidence support this, perhaps?
----------
No it does not.
Taksal's information on Siri Guru Har Rai jee's 7 marriages is probably based on Sooraj Parkash Granth.
There are many saakhiyaan that have been altered by Brahmins who wanted to confuse the Sikhs. The wise Sikhs of Guru Sahib, discern correct saakhis from incorrect ones, just as the bird Hans, separates milk from water.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: 1 Wife or 3
disneyland Sikhi · 03 Apr 2004
Kulbir
Having single handedly doubted the veracity of most Sikh scholars, you must have some very strong evidence for this statement!
I think you have done a diservice to both Guru and sangat, since the Khalsa itself built the Gurdwara at the samadh of one of Guru Gobind Singh ji's wives at Sri Anandpur Sahib, and another in Delhi. Both of these will have existed before Kavi Santokh Singh had even sat down to write Sooraj Prakash Granth.
Isn't this akin to doubting the Guru? If all historical texts state they had more than one wife (not just one, but three Gurus), and in the 21st century, raised on western notions, Sikhs begin to state that this 'cannot' or rather 'ought' not to have happened, then we are morally judging the Guru on culturally different criteria. The problem here is that people are reacting on an emotional level and not questionning where these moral judgements that are causing these emotions have come from.
Also I fail to see why a brahmin would state that the Guru had more than one wife, get hold of Sooraj Prakash and edit the text to include it! Surely that reinforces the status of the Guru as a shah-i-shah! I can see a brahmin trying to paint the Guru as defender of brahmins and brahminism, but what purpose would adding 3 wives have for the brahmins? None at all!
Another Sikh might feel it morally dubious to hunt. Will they accuse brahmins of adding hunting stories to the lives of the Gurus?
Re: 1 Wife or 3
jagroop singh · 03 Apr 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Hope all are well....
Disneyland Sikhi - it's absolutely fine if you wish to replace your Guru-given name with sarcastic statements (e.g. disneyland sikhi) which before readers even get onto your comment points to your 'anonymous/arrogant approach', but please refer to other Singhs and Singhnian as Kulbir 'Singh' etc. especially when they give their names as such.
i have been taught by the Sangat that Singhs and Singhnian should always be referred to by their full name - this is a basic point.
The Sangat has also taught me that we should always use Gurfateh when addressing one another.
Hope this helps...
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Re: 1 Wife or 3
NO EVIDENCE · 04 Apr 2004
Can somone actually give reference to any SPECIFIC EVIDENCE to support the claim of any of the Gurus having more than one wife?
Plz dont quote mcauliff as considering the fact that his books have 'changed' over the years through the various editions i dont accept them. i want to hear real sources and real evidence.
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Guldeep Singh · 04 Apr 2004
Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Ji
>>...based on Sooraj Parkash Granth.
There are many saakhiyaan that have been altered by Brahmins who wanted to confuse the Sikhs. The wise Sikhs of Guru Sahib, discern correct saakhis from incorrect ones, just as the bird Hans, separates milk from water. <<
Virji are we doubting the Sooraj Prakash Granth because certain sakhian don't fit with our beliefs? What evidence is there that Brahmin's altered this Granth?
Tomorrow if one doesn't like a passage of any Rehat Nama one can also say..."Lets not follow this. It seems some Brahmin has added this line"
I am no scholar but as far as I know, brother Khalistani is right there are two Gurudwaras of the departure of our Mata Sundri Ji and Mata Jito Ji.
As for Guru Hargobind Sahib's Marriages, when Chandu scolded the brahimin for arranging the alliance of young Hargobind Maharaj to his daughter the Sangat felt insulted and requested Guru Arjan Dev Ji to refuse the rishta... Three Gursikhs at that time did ardas from three different places that they would give their daughters to young Hargobind Ji. This ardas had to be accepted...therefore three wives."
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Mohan Singh · 05 Apr 2004
Guldeep Singh said:
"Tomorrow if one doesn't like a passage of any Rehat Nama one can also say..."Lets not follow this. It seems some Brahmin has added this line""
Bhai Sahib perhaps you have not read all the Rehat Namas. They are the most perfect example of corruption. Comparing old and new manuscripts huge differences pop up, Rehat Namas appear from no where (eg Prahilad Rai Rehat Nama on kesh as a kakkar for example), and Chaupa Singh Rehat Nama tells us that Brahmins are the best and women are inferior.
You must be aware of the social context, the history of, language features and content, author, and possibilities of corruption, of the Rehat Namas and any historical source.
Yes it is easy to say "the Brahmins did it" but historical corruption (most likely by our own "Sikhs") has occured ALOT if you do research. It is something you have to accept. Doesnt Suraj Prakash Granth talk about meat being OK, doesnt Panth Prakash say drugs and alcohol are OK? Doesnt it also say that Guru Ji tried to sacrifice his children to Chandi? Why do later historical texts have an obsession with Hindu Gods, Durga etc whilst the earlier ones appear unfussed?
Apologies if I have offended anyone.
Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
Re: 1 Wife or 3
jagroop singh · 06 Apr 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Bhai/Bhen D Sikhi Ji
You wrote:
"Why have you said it to me? If this is how you feel Jagroop, why didn't you state it earlier to Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh ji when he posted these two posts above?"
> i went on from my first point (i.e. sarcastic alias), which was directed at you entirely, to share someting with everyone - not just you. This is what i have been taught this by the Sangat - that we are to refer to Singhs/Singhnian by their full Guru-given name. i mentioned it once before on this forum as a general point, again before the whole Sangat...the fact that it seemed that i was referring to you directly in this case is simply because it was at this point i joined the thread; i believe everyone, including Bhai Kulbir Singh, should address the Sangat with Gurfateh, regardless of the mode of communication we are using e.g. an internet forum.
You wrote:
"To paint me as an 'arrogant' young Sikh? Double standards?"
> You're arrogance has nothing to do with the fact that you do not address other Sikhs with Gurfateh salutation. i clearly referred to the fact that although you have chosen to adopt an anonymous identity on the forum which happen to, in all fairness, come across as sarcastic (disneyland being suggestive of 'make-belief', 'dreamworld' etc.), you then compound this by not addressing others with their Guru-given/Guru-blessed name, which they have proactively chosen to use. Please do not feel offended dear Singh/Singhni...please help me by doing my Seva when you find me not respecting the Sangat.
You wrote:
"Trying to divert the issue? I don't know which"
> i am not a Gursikh, am unable to read Punjabi, have not even been blessed with Guru's Amrit; nor am i a scholar or anything else. So, i do not even have the means to divert this thread in any meaningful way; that was not my intention.
You wrote:
"I shall drop the disneyland for your benefit..."
That is a nice gesture and i look forward to addressing you by your full Guru-given/Guru-blessed name in future. i humbly feel that all the other Sangat on this forum should follow the example of some of the others, and use their full Guru-given/Guru-blessed name and not an anonymous alias, which has sadly become very common amongst the cyber-Sangat.
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Kulbir Singh · 06 Apr 2004
Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh!
Veer Jagroop Singh has given us hukam to start every post with fateh. From now on, I will TRY to write every post starting with fateh.
In some cases, where I am not sure whether I am debating with a Singh or not, I will not write fateh as I don't intend to say fateh to Radhasoamis, Naamdhaaris etc.
And believe it or not, but our Guru Sahibaan did not have more than one wife at a given time. I believe that all saakhis with respect to this are wrong. Rest Guru knows.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: 1 Wife or 3
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 30 May 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
1. FATEH is s HUKM of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI......and ALL SINGHS MUST use this SALUTATION...... now at the other end, why should we worry whether a radhasaomi/narakdhari/namdhari/whatever is READING our message or a SINGH JI is reading it. We just OBEY our GURU JI and write the FATEH.
2. I MUST agree in full with Veer Ji Kulbir Singh that Each of OUR GURU JI's Had ONLY ONE WIFE and this assertion is backed up in that ALL the GURBANI teaches us......this is NOT a Western Culture/Punjabi Culture etc. and we are not rying to ape the West and trying to fit our Gurus into our ideals.....far from it.....OUR GURU JI were PERFECT and it is their ideals that we should fit into.
3. The "corruption" of our History begins with GURU HARGOBIND Ji with Books like Gurbilas Patshahi Chheveein.....whereby the "brahmin" ( this is not an super individual but the collective"society that GURU NANAK CHALLENGED in ASA DI WAAR and that felt threatened its position in Indian Society would go if GURU NANAK succeeded...and this corruption of our History is still going on ( through the abduction of our Entire Historical HERITAGE from Darbar Sahib in 1984 by the Indian Army and giving a false image to the world that a FIRE destroyed the entire Sikh reference Library)..and the reapperance of doctored texts, etc all over the world...)...
a lot of people have already written about the vastly different accounts of 1984 Holocaust..and this is just 20 years ago..so what about Guru nanak nearly 500 years ago...???
Jarnail singh