Is this acceptable to display shri guru granth sahib ji on internet
sandeep singh · 15 Jun 2006
I found one side http://www.granthsahib.com. This site display shri guru granth sahib ji. is this acceptable.
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
sandeep singh · 15 Jun 2006
I found one side http://www.granthsahib.com. This site display shri guru granth sahib ji. is this acceptable._lowest_ · 16 Jun 2006
rather than you asking 'is this acceptable' let me ask you, why isnt this acceptable?Jagvinder Singh · 16 Jun 2006
it does have its good and bad points i suppose. the bad point is, by making it commercially available, we are allowing it to fall into the hands of people who would want to distort it, maybe like the rss or stuff, who are hell bent on distorting our history and faith anyways.they can take passages from it and claim them as their own. the siri guru granth sahib should only be available in the "book"(im uneducated on other respectable terms for it) form, and that too, to amritdhari gursikhs only. this ensures that it recieves the upmost respect a guru would deserve. it should also not be sold for personal profits. well, the good point is, it would serve useful to sikhs who are not amritdhari yet, but would still want to turn to guru ji for advice and love. for those who cannot keep the physical form in their homes, its good that they could read from it in the internet instead of disrespecting it. also, for those who cannot read or understand gurmukhi, like our gora sikh brothers. what else could they ask for anyway.also, for non sikhs who would like to know what is written in the SGGS, they could use the internet. these are just examples, bhul chuk maaf.A Singh · 16 Jun 2006
What is unacceptable about it?ss · 16 Jun 2006
Why not that is not the physical saroop. Its the Hukam of Akal Purakh and is being communicated to you via internet. Will you say its not okay to talk a Gurbani Tuk on the phone or discuss gurbani via other communication medium. We will need to ban all the magazines if that was the case as magazine go through a lot of handling through various hands and I am not sure if it is all according to Gurmat?satvinder · 17 Jun 2006
A feeble two cents. Supposedly one concern here is how Guru Granth Sahib ji is viewed. For example a person not versed in Sikhi may come across the site and read while consuming food or worse still, substances which are prohibited in Sikhism. So concerns about disrespect seem pertinent but then it’s doubtable such a person would come across the site so readily and it’s doubtable that they would be interested in reading anyway. The benefits of access to Gurbani over the internet are enormous in that it then becomes accessible to those who may not otherwise have access but who wish to inform themselves. It provides an opportunity for people to learn and acquaint themselves with Guru ji. Erm, this can't be such a bad thing?