Forum
The Cowardly Radhasoamis
The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Kulbir Singh · 30 Mar 2004
The Pusillanimous Radhasoami
This very interesting incident, Bhai Tajinder Singh jee narrated to me as follows:
************BEGINNING OF THE NARRATION********************
I used to work in Indian Air Force and kept my beard open all my life. They tried to put pressure on me to tie my beard but they failed. During my service, I met with many different people who had different beliefs.
There was a Radhasoami in our unit, and he had a very bad habit of targeting Sikhs for conversion. He used to openly preach against Shabad Guru – Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. He was quite adept in debating and defeated many Sikhs when debating about the supremacy of his religion – Radhasoami.
He was known to be a very tough guy and often bullied others. I used to ignore him but he used to try to engage me into debating whether Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee can be Guru. I knew that if I engaged myself in debating with him, something of extreme nature would happen. For this reason I used to ignore him.
One day, I was sitting under the tree with other Sikh officers, that this Radhasoami person accosted me and tried to engage me in a debate over Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee.
“How can a book be the true Guru”, he asked me.
“Why can’t it be”, I replied hastily.
“Because it can’t talk and can’t guide anyone”.
“Who says Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee does not talk or guide anyone? You are totally unaware of the power of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee”.
“I have heard many false stories about your Granth. I don’t believe any one of them”.
When he said this, it got upset at what he was saying. I sternly asked him, “Do you want to see the power of Siri Granth Sahib jee?”
“Sure. Show it to me”.
“Then come with me to my quarter. I have parkash of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee in my house. I will show you today, the power of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee”.
Saying this, I got up and started walking towards my quarter. He followed me to my house. I got to my house, took a quick shower and came out wearing Gurmukhi attire.
We both went to the room of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. I stood there and did an ardaas from the bottom of my heart. I pleaded to my Guru to help me prove to this manmukh about the power of my Guru.
As soon as I completed the ardaas, I felt a special power inside me. I addressed the Radhasoami as follows:
“I will not harm you or get upset at you in any manner. So don’t get alarmed at anything. I am going to show you the power of my Guru. You just stay calm”.
Something happened to the Radhasoami guy and he started feeling a bit scared. I was sitting by the entrance, while he was sitting towards the wall facing the entrance. We both were sitting in front of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee.
I got divine inspiration to take out my big kirpan (sword). I took out my kirpan. The raw Sarblohi power got out and I saw the diving jyot (light) of Vaheguru coming out of the Siri Sahib. I could not believe my eyes. My swaas swaas naam, within me, started with full fervour. My eyes closed and I sat there enjoying the divine colours of Naam. I don’t know how long I stayed like this. Then I opened my eyes and saw that Radhasoami guy in front of me, with a perplexed countenance.
I looked up towards the Radhasoami guy, with kirpan in my hand and said, “So do you want to see the power of my Guru?”
The sight of the Sarblohi kirpan, my countenance expressing diving colours of Naam and Bir Rass, did something unthinkable to this bully. This bully, who was known to be a lion became a pussycat in front of me. He had drops of sweat on his forehead that displayed trepidation at the sight of a Singh in Bir Rass.
He replied in a trembling voice, “No Sardar jee, I don’t need to see anything, Just let me go”.
“I told you before that I won’t harm you. Be calm and answer my question. Do you want to see the power of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee?”
“No, I just want to go home”, cried the Radhasoami. I was amused to see him breakdown like this but I did not want to let him off the hook so easily.
I asked him in pure Khalsa spirit, “Do you now agree that Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is the true Guru”.
“Yes I do. I have seen the power with my own eyes.”
“Are you ever going to debate about the authenticity of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee again?”
“Meri Tauba, Mere vadiyaan dee tauba. I will never debate about Granth Sahib again”.
“Watch your language. How dare you say “Granth Sahib? Don’t you know that you are supposed to say, Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee?”
Hearing this, he almost broke down. He was getting increasingly scared. I decided to go for the final blow.
I said, “I will let you go only if you say that your Guru is false. Now follow me and say – Mera Guru jhootha (my Guru is false)”.
He hesitated a bit but looking at my stern and Bir Rass face he quickly said, “Mera Guru Jhootha”.
“now say - Radhasoami Matt jhootha”.
He followed me, “Radhasoami Matt jhootha”.
Now say, “Mera Guru Kutta” (My Guru is a dog).
He said, “Mera Guru kutta”.
I knew that the bully had been tamed. I let him out. As soon as he was out of the room, he started running away. I had a good laugh. All the Singhs in the unit were relieved that in the future they would not have to endure the sarcasm of this bully.
**************** END OF THE TRANSLATION*******************
The above is based on what Bhai Tajinder Singh jee narrated to me a couple of years ago.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
DKaur · 30 Mar 2004
haha... good story.
This reminds me of the time that i had a argument with a Radhusoami girl at school. By the end of our conversation she totally lost it.
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Mandeep Singh · 30 Mar 2004
Excellent story! more more!
I was wondering one of the radhaswami basis of not accepting sri guru granth sahib as guru is that gurbani refers to purakh, being body and for this reason they will not accept guru sahibs saroop. instead some dude who lives in spain soaking the sun. Could somone elaborate on this misguided belief?
also when did they come about i.e. when did GOI create this latest anti sikh group?
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Singh · 31 Mar 2004
It appears that rather than beat the Radhasoami in an argument the Singh just sacared him. Who would not be scared with someone with a kirpan in his hand looking in bir ras. So what if the Radhasoami said he now beleived in Guru Granth Sahib Ji in such a situation where he must have felt threatened. The truth is that it would have been much better for the Singh to debate with him and through this really make him beleive in Guru Granth Sahib Ji from the inside. This would have been a victory from the roots, rather than scaring the guy with the kirpan and making him say he beleives in Guru Granth Sahib Ji on the face of it to get out of the situation. If we are gonna behave like that with all people who don't agree with us or our philosophy we will be known as people who have no solid faith to debate with but people who just use force rather than religouse discussion to get our point across.
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Kulbir Singh · 31 Mar 2004
Singh,
You wrote:
---------
It appears that rather than beat the Radhasoami in an argument the Singh just sacared him. Who would not be scared with someone with a kirpan in his hand looking in bir ras.
--------
This story is not about winning a debate from Radhasoamis but shows how cowardly they are. This Radhasoami used to bully Sikhs all the time and used to insult them and hurt their feelings by calling Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee a book.
Bhai Tajinder Singh who narrated this story to me and who tamed this bully, used to avoid him because he did not want to debate with a fool (moorakh). Gurbani says it very clearly that a moorakh (fool) cannot avoid getting beaten up:
MOORAKH GANDH PAVAE MOOH MAAR||
This person wanted to see the power of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and he saw it. I don’t see anything wrong with what Bhai Tajinder Singh jee did. If this Radhasoami had some spiritual power, he would have never disowned his Guru.
By the way, Bhai Tajinder Singh became a member of Akhand Kirtani Jatha in mid 1950s. Bhai Tajinder Singh is the one who got privilege of slapping Mahatma Gandhi in Birla Mandir Delhi, when Gandhi insulted Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee by calling Siri Guru jee a misguided patriot of India.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
kaur · 31 Mar 2004
"Bhai Tajinder Singh is the one who got privilege of slapping Mahatma Gandhi in Birla Mandir Delhi"
So fortunate was mahatma gandhi to have been blessed (slapped) by the pavitr hands of a Gursikh. He should have been blessed with a few dunday and sotiaan too for that terrible comment.
Awesome story by the way Bhai Sahib. Radhasoamis are cowards indeed. Ask them the historical background of their "religion" and you will hear a different story every time. They are a bunch of confused individuals.
[%sig%]
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
ns · 31 Mar 2004
The story was excellent , the pangtees ringing in mind after reading are "birthi kade na hoveee jan ki ardaass" excuse if I have misspelt. "Satgur bajoo gur nahee koyee niguraa ka haa naho borra"
Regards
Narinder
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
S Singh · 31 Mar 2004
That was an amazing story. We all should follow the example of Bhai Tajinder Singh Jee, and not tolerate the insult of our guru by misguided moorakhs, who question whether or not Sri Guru Granth Sahib is Satguru.
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 31 Mar 2004
Woah!! That was truly awesome. I felt some beer raas when reading it. Thanks for sharing it Bhai Sahib.
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
me · 01 Apr 2004
Kulbir Singh,
Why dont you post the incident that happened on Sunday @ dixie gurdwara. That is an excellent example of radhaswami cowards. After all, you led the debate;)
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Yes please · 02 Apr 2004
Yes please tell us.
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Tejwant Singh · 02 Apr 2004
Nice fairy tale that lacks GURMAT. It is a shame that some of us get impressed by these stories where the character becomes more important than ONE TRUE GOD that he is trying to seek. One can not express GURMAT in anger as the writer said he did. The Miracle of SGGS is not in any light coming from a kirpan, but by obeying and following the teachings of our GURUS. Sikhi doesnot lie in any 'miracle' like the sheen of a kirpan but by practicing the following as mentioned by Guru Nanak:-
1. Naam Japnah
2. Kirat karni.
3. Vand kei chaknah
Rest is all parrot talk.
Tejwant Singh
Tejwant Ji, how much naam simran do you do? have you ever experienced
the power of Naam? Have you ever tried to see the Jot of 10 Gurus in
Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji? if your answer to all these questions is
no, then how do you know what is gurmat and what is not? Sikhi is all
about love, devotion, and faith. If a Sikh has faith, his/her Guru
can do anything. Please read Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and try to
understand the true aspect of Sikhi. Akaali Phoola Singh did ardas
and he went to war, even when maharaja ranjit singh refused, and when
maharaja saw akaali phoola singh's fighting spirit, he put his step
ans asked his ary to join akali phoola singh. Ardas can do anything.
The story that we just read is the result of true ardas. Have you
ever did ardas to Guru Sahib? If not, rest is "parrot talk". One can
argue as much as he/she wants and get nothing out of it. Please try
to FEEL and LIVE Sikhi and please have a little bit of faith. It
would help you in long run.
Thanks,
Jaswant Singh
Jaswant Singh ji,
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki Fateh.
First of all I want to apologise if I offended you or anyone else.I am also sorry if my remarks made you angry as your post shows.
As we read in Anand Sahib everyday, NON DAVAREI PARGAT KEEYEII, DASVAN GUPT RAKHAEIAH.In other words ONE'S RELATIONSHIP WITH ONE TRUE GOD IS ON ONE & ONE BASIS. It is unique. Only Vaheguru knows how much paath each of one does and who & how one follows the path which has been carved for us by ONE TRUE GOD. Only Vaheguru knows which milestone each of us is at on this GURMAT journey. You and I will never find out no matter how much we try. Playing GOD is not my duty as a sikh.Hence it is not my duty to ask any gursikh how and how much he/she loves ONE TRUE GOD.
My only duty as a sikh is to point out any ANTI GURMAT aspects I encounter. Gurbani is a tool box which has to be opened and used all the times. It is not to be used as a stool during lunch, or while sitting on it waiting for a kirpan, an object to act like THE FORMLESS. JOT of 10 GURUS lies in the 'GAVEEIE, SUNHEEI, MUN RAKHEEIE BHAO, DUKH BHUR HAR SUKH GHAR KEI JAEI'.in other words ONLY LIVING BY GURMAT IDEALS WE CAN ATTAIN VAHEGURU'S GRACE, not by any other means.
My only request to you is to please give the verses from SGGS where an anger in front of SGGS can make a Kirpan shine or any other of your view points.Without Gurbani everything becomes idol worship.
Tejwant Singh
[%sig%]
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
S.S. Singh · 03 Apr 2004
Tejwant Singh Jee, the reason I think this story is great is because it inspires the rest of us to not tolerate disrespect of Guru Jee, especially by heretic Radhaswamis. Furthermore, I have met Bhai Tajinder Singh Jee. His life is truly inspirational to all. When he served in the military, he kept Sarbloh Bibek, which I think is extraordinary. Furthermore, he refused to tie his beard for all the years he was in the military, despite pressure from his commanding officers.
I have heard that his son is a Shaheed.
Anyway, I think that you have confused “Bir Rass” with “anger”(krodh). When Bhai Tejinder Singh Singh Jee did Ardas infront of Guru Jee, and took out his Kirpaan, he was in Bir Rass not anger. There is no sin in Bir Rass.
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Tejwant Singh · 03 Apr 2004
S.S. Singh writes:-
Dear Singh Ji,
FYI...noone can disrespect Guru jee no matter how much one tries. How can one disrespect teh CREATOR? Thats so silly. Can you please give me a verse from SGGS where it says that a sikh can say that the other's God is Kutta as Tejinder Singh did?? I will appreciate it. I would like to point out Guru Teg Bahadur Ji did not tell kashmiri hindus that their god was kutta but gave his life instead even though he did not believe thier way of seeking ONE TRUE GOD- IK ONG KAAR. A sikh can only follow Guru's path, not his own.
Respectfully
Tejwant Singh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 04 Apr 2004
vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh
Tajwant Singh Jio, there is NO way you can compare the Kashmiri Pandits with Radhaswamis.
Kashmiri Pandits took sharan of Guru Ji whereas Radhaswamis are doing the opposite.
Kashmiri Pandits were helpless and hence they came to Guru ji with nimarta, whereas, as we can tell from the story, the Radhaswami officer was full of ego and haume to such a level that he did not care about the beliefs of others.
"He used to openly preach against Shabad Guru – Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. He was quite adept in debating and defeated many Sikhs when debating about the supremacy of his religion – Radhasoami."
"“How can a book be the true Guru”, he asked me."
=> "noone can disrespect Guru jee no matter how much one tries. How can one disrespect teh CREATOR?"
I am not to clear about what you are trying to say here. Yes, it is true that Guru Sahib ji is beyond these things, but there are nidaks and dushts who do nothing but ninda of Guru Ji. If this wasn't possible, like you are saying, then there wouldn't be a need for Guru Arjan Sahib ji to write the 13th pauri of Sukhmani Sahib.
=>"Can you please give me a verse from SGGS where it says that a sikh can say that the other's God is Kutta as Tejinder Singh did??"
Guru Sahib clearly said: "Eh Bhupat Sab Divas Char Ke Chute Karat Divaja"
and "Apay Beej Apay Hi Khaao"
vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
unknown... · 04 Apr 2004
WahegurujikakhalsaWahegurujikifateh
Hey wt is da story of Gandi sayin bad things abt Guru Ji??? I dont kno abt dat incident. Can som1 pls tell me abt it.
Thanks
WahegurujikakhalsaWahegurujikifateh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Amrit-Dharee · 04 Apr 2004
Tejwant Singh, you speak as if the Radhaswami Guru is actually worthy of the title "Guru".
The Kashmiri Hindus were not Ninduks of Guru Sahib. Radhaswamis and their "Guru" most definitely are.
Those who slander the Guru deserve punishment. This is a well-estabilished tradition in Sikh History. Baba Deep Singh Jee rose up because his Guru and Sikh institutions were being DISRESPECTED. Bhai Tajinder Singh Jee, who lost physical control under divine influence was merely following the same Gurmat tradition.
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Jaswinder Singh Sekhon · 10 Apr 2004
you people are the bigest paapi's
rhoada soami's openly say they are not sikhs but are rhoada soamis.
it is you people who twist things.
i am not a rhoada soami but i have been to some of there satsangs. they quote from the sri guru granth sahib ji maharaj and other religious books of other religions.
at there satsangs the rhoada soami baba gives his satsangi's and oppertunity to ask him questions. i witnessed his say "master / maharaj is not part of my name", and he always replies to ay question with: brother / sister. the rhoada soami baba forbids the use of intoxicants such as alchahole, tobacco etc and also meat of any sort.
our ninth Guru, Sri Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji Maharaj was a firm believer that every individual has the right to believe in whatever faith they wish. As Sikhs we should respect that. We should let others get on with their believes, and we should practice our own. Instead of spending time posting incorrect information on the net, you could be doing path or something more usefull with your time.
As the Rhoada Soami baba openly says that the Rhoada Soami faith is not a part of Sikh, you people have no right to iunsult it as much as you do.
i am taking about the rhoada soami satsang beas, not the other rhoada soami faiths. i dont know what they preach.
Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Singh · 13 Jan 2005
does anyone know of details on how gandhi was slapped by bhai tajinder singh?
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
xx · 01 Feb 2005
Can someone please tell me why radhasoamis insist on forcing their beliefs on their children and siblings?
What I mean is, they force their children to attend satsangs with them and ban meat in their homes even though the other members of the house might eat it?
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Kulbir Singh · 01 Feb 2005
----------
What I mean is, they force their children to attend satsangs with them and ban meat in their homes even though the other members of the house might eat it?
------------
What do you want to do "XX"? You would rather have them take their children to Macdonalds and Harvey's? Where Radhasoamis are wrong they are wrong but if they don't expose their children to meat it is a good thing they do.
As long as children are children and not adults, they should be given guidance by their parents. When they grow up, they do what they want to do. If they have been brought up and if they have been instilled with good morals, there is a high probability of them becoming good citizens.
This criticism of Radhasoamis that you brought forward is not valid.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 02 Feb 2005
Great post veer Kulbir Singh ji, I agree- the radhasoamis are total cowards-I have worked with 2 recently and have defeated them in many debates with Guru Sahib's kirpa.
In response to Jaswinder Singh Sekhon- I have come across many RS - and not any one of these has claimed to be a non-sikh. If they are not Sikhs- why do they STEAL lines from Gurbani to quote- haven't they got anyone spiritually high enough to compile their own holy book? How many Christians/Muslims/even Hindus (true Hindus) quote from other holy books?
One RS even said he doesn't drink or eat meat, but smokes because that's allowed because it is not a "mind altering" drug- so it was ok for him to smoke tobacco. The RS are just a cult who have quite a high following from people who are too weak to follow their own religion properly (many so called Sikhs/former Sikhs) The RS are as despicable as other groups like Narkdharis/Namdharis etc, however innocent hey may make themselves to seem.
Raj karega Khalsa!
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
jarnail kaur arshi · 02 Feb 2005
Dear Kulbir singh ji
does saying to someone that he is Kuta a good thing to do?
you say beer raas
so singhs start calling other people kutey when they come in beer raas
i think some of it was anger which made bhai sahib call someone a kuta
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
jarnail kaur arshi · 02 Feb 2005
bhai saab veer kulbir singh ji do you agree?
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
theorist · 02 Feb 2005
I think Bhai Sahib had a right to be angry because this was guru ji that the guy was insulting, not an ordinary person. I think you guys are forgetting this. But this anger is not the krodh anger that is pointless, it is bir ras, which is what propels the warriorness, if that is a word, in Sikhs. Remember we are spposed to be sants first, but that does not mean totally ignoring the sipahi part. And as for kutta, I dont think there is anything wrong with saying it where it is due, even guru ji uses the word: kutta raaj bahaaliyey...
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
jarnail kaur arshi · 03 Feb 2005
guru nanak sahib has not called a person a kutaa
please understand the shabad
it says if u give the dog an empire the dog will still lick the flour from the mill (chakki)
so please donot twist gurbani and apply it anywhere u want
still waiting for veerji to reply!!!!!!!!!
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Kulbir Singh · 03 Feb 2005
Bhain jeeo, yes I don’t mind calling fake gurus “kuttay”. There is nothing wrong in speaking the truth. It is not as if I regularly go out and call them kuttay or other such adjectives. If need be and if they attack you, then there is nothing wrong in speaking the truth.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 04 Feb 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
I agree. A fake "GURU" is a DOG...why ?? because like a DOG he feeds on his chelas offerings...just like a dog feeds on his Master's leftovers...and the "more charrawa" a chela gives this dog-guru...the more he wags his doggy tail. TRUTH is always BITTER...that is why people HATE your GUTS for speaking the TRUTH.
Jarnail Singh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
jarnail kaur arshi · 05 Feb 2005
mith bolra ji har sajan swami mora|| hau samal thaki ji oh kadde na boley kaura||
and guru sahib in the next pangti stress ''Kaura bol na janee''
guru nanak dev ji did not call vali kandhari a kutta when he rolled down a stone to them
guru amardaas sahib ji did not call bhai dattu a kutta when bhai dattu kicked guru amardass sahib instead guru sahib caught bhai dattus feet and asked him if he was hurt
guru arjan dev sahib ji didnot call jehangir a kutta neither he did utter any bad words against bhai prithi chand though guru sahib faced hard times
guru hargobind sahib didnot utter a bad word against pende khan when khan turned againsts guru sahib. when khan got decimated by guru sahib and was flat on battle ground guru sahib sheilded his face from sunlight with HIS own dhaal
i dont know why guru ke sikh should swear at anyone?
any justifications based on gurbani are most welcome by veer kulbir singh ji and Jarnail Singh Ji as to if sikhs are allowed to bad mouth any other human
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
. · 05 Feb 2005
Author: me
Date: 04-01-04 15:23
Kulbir Singh,
Why dont you post the incident that happened on Sunday @ dixie gurdwara. That is an excellent example of radhaswami cowards. After all, you led the debate;)
WHERES THE ACCOUNT? PLEASEEEEEEEEEEEE
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
jarnail kaur arshi · 07 Feb 2005
singh sahib ji are we allowed to bad mouth other humans
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
jarnail kaur arshi · 07 Feb 2005
any one please
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
jarnail kaur arshi · 08 Feb 2005
some enlighting responses from our learned veers and bhains
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
jarnail kaur arshi · 09 Feb 2005
mit(h)aa bolan niv chalan hathhahu(n) dhaekai bhalaa manaaeae||
He speaks mildly, behaves humbly and even by giving something to somebody wishes good of others
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
jarnail kaur arshi · 10 Feb 2005
mit(h)aa bolan niv chalan guramukh bhaao bhagath arathhaeou||
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Kulbir Singh · 10 Feb 2005
Bhain jee Jarnail Kaur Arshee jee, I don't know what point you are trying to make. Are you saying that one should not speak the truth?
In Gurbani you can find several pankitis where very harsh words have been used sometimes. These words may seem harsh to some but they are actually nothing but the truth. In one of the pankitis, Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee equates all people without Naam as dogs, pigs, donkeys, crows, snakes and beasts (Gurmantr heenas jo praanee....).
Guru Nanak Dev jee reserved the harshest words for Jainis (adherents of Jain religion of India). Guru Sahib has called them "Sirr khuthai Shatainee" (demonic, satanic jainis, with shaved heads).
The kalyugi gurus are like dogs. They are greedy like dogs and like dogs they keep on barking words like, "A Granth cannot be Guru. You need to have a living person, otherwise you are doomed". If this is not bakwaas, then what is it? What is wrong in calling them dogs when in fact they are acting like dogs? If they want to preach their own faith, there is no problem but they insist on using (actually misusing) Gurbani for their personal gains. I hope SGPC does something to stop them from using Gurbani.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
jarnail kaur arshi · 12 Feb 2005
thanks bhai kulbir singh ji at last i have a response
as to the pankti by guru arjan sahib ji
kookareh sookareh garadhhabheh kaakeh sarapaneh thul khaleh ||33||
its "tul khaley"....which in punjabi goes to in the class of....but guru sahib has not addressed to those as dogs or animals
as for the one by guru nanak sahib
naanak sirakhuthhae saithaanee eaenaa gal n bhaanee ||
shatani here stands for following the mind, being worldly clever, not listening and trying to be clever
about the use of gurbani i think gurbani was and IS for the world. it is not someones personal property so SGPC cannot do anything to stop people reading it or using it for their lives.
gursikha di charoon dhoor
PS I would appreciate a reply
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Amandeep Singh · 24 Feb 2005
Hmmmmm
So a person who has so called beer ras :-) makes us believe that if tomorrow say some radhasoamis catch him with weapons in their hands he will still show his beer ras ....
gallan karniyaan hor gall hai ...
Just contrary to this I have witnessed another incident that inhibits me to speak ill of anybody ....
There were few sikhs in air force posted in a station in assam. There were few radhasoamis and few gursikhs. One of the gursikhs was constantly behind radhasoamis ... bad mouthing in front and at back ... continuosly for days ... and one day that gursikh challenged one radhasoami veer that you have dehdhari guru who is a cheat ... you won't believe in guru granth sahib etc etc ... that chap just said ... look I believe in guru granth sahib ... I do not say anything ill of you ... then why do you make fun of me or say ill of my guru....
That radhasoami chap was really very sad ... (later on told me ... that he went back to his quarters and sat on meditation .... praying why he has to listen such bad things from that sikh when he has not said anything or harmed him)...
That very same night that gursikh's experience in his own words ( ... I was sleeping and then suddenly I got up and saw a buzurg with white attire and white beard with "tej" on his face ... said .. why you keep insulting that chap ... did he ever say anything to you or anything against guru sahibaan ... and then after that ... gursikh found his jaw turned to one side and he couldn't speak properly ....)
The next day he asked somebody to fetch that chap so that he can apologize ... and only after he apologized ... his face was set right ....
What I came to know from that chap is radhasoami is not a religion .. it is just a path .. you can call it yoga - surat-shabd-yoga to be precise.. that allows you to see light within and hear the sound current .. thats what we read in gurbaani ... anhad shabd, naad, naam dhun ... musalman faqeeran nay jisay "bang-e-sulaimani" keha hai ... hindu santa nay "ram shun" keha hai tay bible ch "Word" tay "Logos" keha hai.
gur nanak dev ji has said about "antar pargaas"... "antar soor chandra" ,... and this is what surat shabd yoga says that you will see galactic constellations within which are called saur mandal and chandrama mandal and your sould will break through this ...
.. naam dharay khand brahmand ... how can a name that could be written be the source of khand brahmand...
In Bible Jesus says ... "If thy eye be single you shall be full of light" ...
One more thing he said ... when you sit on meditation your soul starts moving towards eye centre and when it reaches there you whole body from there down is numb and you are as good as dead and then you see light within and start hearing sound ...
"nanak jeevtya mar rahiyay aisa jog kamayiyay"
This tuk exactly matches the condition he described...
People who follow this path do not have to change religion or change their rehat they can continue the way that they are living just that they have to shun non veg, even eggs and intoxicants even tobacco. no sex out of wedlock.
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Kulbir Singh · 24 Feb 2005
Amandeep Singh jeeo,
The story that I wrote is based on truth and nothing but the truth. The gursikh who narrated me this story is still alive and living in New Zealand at this time. His name is Bhai Tajinder Singh. If need be, he can vouch for the veracity of this story. Regarding the story that you narrated, I don’t see an iota of truth in it. No Radhasoami Guru has the power to reach a Gursikh. A true Gursikh, who follows Guru Sahib’s rehit is above 33 Crore Devtaas and 125,000 Paighambars (prophets). What to say about some Radhasoami Guru.
I ask you to do me a favour. Ask your Radhasoami Guru to come to a Gursikh who keeps rehit and then he will find out what spiritual power means. If you claim this story to be true, then let us know the names of the gursikh who was involved in this story and allow us to confirm this story.
I agree that it is wrong to harass or tease any Radhasoami or any other person because of his faith. This is not the work of a Gursikh. A Gursikh has love for everyone and does not hate anyone including Radhasoamis. I personally enjoy debating with them and have done so many times in my life. There are some really good people and genuine seekers in this faith but I feel sorry for them because as per the will of Vaheguru, they are misled and are living a life based on lies and wrong notions. If they had tried the Khalsa Dharam and had done even half of the hard work they do in Radhasoami meditation, they would be much more elevated than they are now.
If Radhasoamis use their own baani - Saar Bachan – we would have no qualms with them but the fact that they misuse Gurbani for their selfish needs is really appalling. They misinterpret Gurbani and misinterpret the words Dasam Duaar, Charan Kamal, Trikuti in their favour.
------------
What I came to know from that chap is radhasoami is not a religion .. it is just a path .. you can call it yoga - surat-shabd-yoga to be precise.. that allows you to see light within and hear the sound current .. thats what we read in gurbaani ... anhad shabd, naad, naam dhun ... musalman faqeeran nay jisay "bang-e-sulaimani" keha hai ... hindu santa nay "ram shun" keha hai tay bible ch "Word" tay "Logos" keha hai.
-------------
Depending on one’s spiritual state, one experiences many kind of sounds and sights inside. By the way Bang-e-Sulaimaani and “Raam Shun” are not the same thing. Shun means complete silence whereas “Bang-e-Sulaimani” means mystical baang or music. There are many kinds of Anhad Shabads and the ones that Gursikhs believe in are unreachable to others. Only Gursikhs can reach there.
----------
.. naam dharay khand brahmand ... how can a name that could be written be the source of khand brahmand...
-------------
Just as Vaheguru who is sookham and Ashtool too. On one hand Siri Guru jee in Gurbani states that this whole world is a roop of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and on the other hand we all know that Nirgun Raam or unseen Vaheguru is beyond five elements. Same way, the Naam Gurmantra or the true Naam that Khalsa gets from the True Guru can be read and written and recited and also this Naam is Jyot Saroop. The Jyot Saroop of this Naam is discovered when one reaches a high spiritual state. This Naam Gurmanter is such that it connects the seeker to the real form of Naam; that form that is sustaining and holding the whole universe.
------------
One more thing he said ... when you sit on meditation your soul starts moving towards eye centre and when it reaches there you whole body from there down is numb and you are as good as dead and then you see light within and start hearing sound ...
--------------
This is where Radhasomis totally fail me. It is not the soul that reaches anywhere. It is the mann that reaches Vaheguru. Soul is always pure and stainless. Soul is Vaheguru’s own roop. It is our real self that is made up of Soul and Mann. Some scholars further divide Mann into four parts – Chit, Budhi, Mann and one more thing that I can’t remember now. It is also called Antashkaran. When our Mann realises that it is Jyot Roop (mann tu jyot saroop hain, apna mool pachhaan) and starts working towards salvation, it first discovers its Aatma. After being one with Aatma and getting fully cleaned it gets one with Vaheguru.
The soul need not move towards any third eye or Trikuti. Show us one Gurbani pankiti to prove that the soul moves towards Trikuti. It is always the mann or our surtee that does it.
---------------
"nanak jeevtya mar rahiyay aisa jog kamayiyay"
This tuk exactly matches the condition he described...
------------
Jeevtayiyaan Marna means to eliminate one’s ego and not getting your body numb. Your description of “Jevtiyaan Marna” is very shallow. What happens when you come out of your meditation? You are not dead then? A Gursikh lives in the state of “jeevtiyaan marna” 24 hours a day and not for 1 or 2 hours while in meditation.
------------
People who follow this path do not have to change religion or change their rehat they can continue the way that they are living just that they have to shun non veg, even eggs and intoxicants even tobacco. no sex out of wedlock.
------------
Of course they do have to change their faith. A Sikh who starts believing in a Dehdhaari Guru can never continue to be a Sikh. You can be either a Sikh or a Radhasoami but not both at the same time. This is the biggest pakhand and a lie that you guys speak to trap innocent people of different faiths. Please prove that one does not have to change one’s faith when becoming a Radhasoami.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Amandeep Singh · 24 Feb 2005
If you do not know about spiritual progress within then its better not to put lame comments on the forum
I have read some books on this and in one of the threads somebody has suggested a book that describes about this ... I will try to get hold of that ....
but till then before putting up comments try to gather information rather than discussing shallowly ...
I am trying you can too ....
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Kulbir Singh · 24 Feb 2005
---------
If you do not know about spiritual progress within then its better not to put lame comments on the forum
---------------
I would like to give the same advice to you. If you don't know the progress inside, you should not post your comments on a public forum.
------------
I have read some books on this and in one of the threads somebody has suggested a book that describes about this ... I will try to get hold of that ....
-------------
Try reading Anhad Shabad Dasam Duaar and Charan Kamal kee Mauj by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. Your Guru - Baba Savan Singh the grandfather of uncle of your present Guru - Gurinder Singh - was from the village of Gujjarwaal near Ludhiana. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee was from Narangwal which is very close to Gujjarwal. They knew each other and Bhai Sahib many times tried to advise Baba Savan Singh to not become a guru but all in vain.
I have read many books on Radhasoami matt and as I said before, this matt is based mostly on Yogic notions. In any case, your dharam is mubarik to you and mine to me.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Singh · 24 Feb 2005
why don't you respond amandeep singh? stop misleading yourself and others about radhaswami mat.
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
gill · 25 Feb 2005
It seems that he is busy reading gurbani. kulbir singh has given him a task
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
parkash · 08 Nov 2005
radhasoami mera naam parkash hain main pakistan ke hyderbad sindh main rahtah hoon .mujhe aap se unorodh hain ke mujhe kuchh adeo caste chaiye shabed vani aur satsang ke kitpya aap mujhe by post ke zariye bajhne kashet karen mian eik midle class nse taluk rakhtah hoon aur main eik karkhane per kaam kertah hoon maine jissko bhi shabed bani yah satsang ke baRE MAIN LANE KO KAHA SAB NE HAAN KIYA HAIN MAGER NAHE LAYE ABHI TAK MAIN AAP SE UPEKSHA KER TAH HOON MUJHE PLEASE AAAP MERE POST ADRESS PER BHEJHE(C839 KHAIROAD POLICE CHOKI KURESHI PARA HYDERBAD SINDH PAKISTAN) MUJHE AAAP JULD SE JULD BHEJHE SATSHRE AKAAL RADHASOAMI
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
singh · 10 Nov 2005
i got one thing to say, i also believe in the sri guru grant sahib, but i am sure it does not teach us to call other faiths/religions kutheh(dogs), if u was a true believer, u would not say such thing, and by the way the radha soami faith teaches from the shri granth, do ur research, u are still an ametuer, just because u are are a singh does not give u the right to do such things, i think u are the pussycat
Re: The Cowardly Radhasoamis
Singh · 10 Nov 2005
singh,
maybe you need to do the research.
Guru Sahib calls the nindaks dogs. Guru Sahib calls people like Narakdharis and Radha Swamis dogs.
"kookar kooR kamaieeay gur ninda pachai pachaan" is just one example