Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

an Islamic country allows Kirpan

an Islamic country allows Kirpan

Mehtab Singh · 16 Jun 2006

Just yesterday on my visit to a Gurdwara in Dubai, I found out that the Government of the United Arab Emirates has made a provision for Sikhs to carry the kirpan. I am attaching a scanned version of an identity card a Singh gave me yesterday. Now I am not really sure how much authority such a card has here, but it has the authorization from the Consulate General of India in Dubai, and this ID card is given free to all who take Amrit over here. The date says October 27, 1986. The matter is written out in Arabic as well for Arab policemen to read it, in case they pull over a Singh wearing the kirpan. However, the kirpan is worn under the clothes and kept concealed. Nonetheless, there is a law that allows it. I was wondering, if Islamic countries like this one can make such provisions, why don’t western countries take such a step like issuing ID cards?

Re: an Islamic country allows Kirpan

... · 17 Jun 2006

i find arabs are generally nice with sikhs.

Re: an Islamic country allows Kirpan

middle eastern · 17 Jun 2006

Vahiguru Jee Ka Khalsa Vahiguru Jee Kee Fateh The content and title are very MISLEADIng - even though i am sure the author did not intend to mislead. This identification was issued by the indian embassy in dubai to help sikhs who would get into trouble with the law due to carrying a siri sahib. However, such a card by the embassy does not help in getting into high security areas with their siri sahibs... thank you [%sig%]

Re: an Islamic country allows Kirpan

Sad Sikh · 17 Jun 2006

There is similar provison for Sikhs in Malaysia , Singapore and Thailand.But read the sad story of the situation of the Sikh identity elsewhere.The Sikhs today bar, for a small group of dedicated sewadaars, the identity of the Sikh roop is eroding slowly in Malaysia.The Sikhs there tioday are not living up to the proud traditions sat out by the fore fathers .

Re: an Islamic country allows Kirpan

Mehtab Singh · 17 Jun 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh "middle eastern" jee, you are right in a way. Entering embassies or government offices where they have detectors can make it close to impossible to wear your kirpan and get in there. But the purpose was just to raise a point that why can't western countries have such authorized ID cards as well. Thanks

Re: an Islamic country allows Kirpan

singh · 18 Jun 2006

quote "i find arabs are generally nice with sikhs." I have heard 1st hand account of gutkay being ripped up at the airport in Saudi Arabia and being stamped upon. And little worship place/ mini gurdwara being bulldozed to the ground

Re: an Islamic country allows Kirpan

PTE SINGH · 19 Jun 2006

Amritari Sikhs in the UK are already allowed to wear small Kirpans and as far as i was aware this is the case in Canada???? Which 'western' countries were you refering too?

Re: an Islamic country allows Kirpan

Mehtab Singh · 19 Jun 2006

singh ji, Saudi Arabia is terribly intolerant towards non-Muslims. Agreed there are non-Muslims there but the country is too strict about religion. Not only Sikhs but Hindus also go through the same trouble. I personally know of a Hindu gentleman who had a picture of goddess Durga in his suitcase, and in front of him it was crushed by an airport official, under his shoes. This does happen there. But in places like the United Arab Emirates, usually Arabs and Pakistanis are very friendly towards Sikhs, and I am speaking from personal experience. I wrote an article on Sikhs in the Middle East, and talked about the scenario here: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=77854&t=77512#reply_77854