Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

chauppee???

chauppee???

guptt · 17 Jun 2006

as our daily nitnem we read chaupee sahib (kabyo bach benti) but in most gotkeh it doesnt have the "Arhil" in it. then also there is more chaupee after the "arhil" towards the end before we get to swaiyaa and dohra (sagal duaar ko chhad kai). do we have to read these bits of bani that are not present in my gotka? also do we read the other chaupee (sri mukvak patshahi 10,pranved ad ekankara) also daas reads one swaiyaa (sravag sudh samuh sadan kai). i have heard that it is hukam to read 10 swaiyaas, what is the meaning of the 10, what are the 10 swaiyaas? is daas reading less bani than he should? thank you for any replies. bhull chukk maaf

Re: chauppee???

anon · 22 Jun 2006

???

Re: chauppee???

Kulbir Singh · 22 Jun 2006

------------- as our daily nitnem we read chaupee sahib (kabyo bach benti) but in most gotkeh it doesnt have the "Arhil" in it. then also there is more chaupee after the "arhil" towards the end before we get to swaiyaa and dohra (sagal duaar ko chhad kai). do we have to read these bits of bani that are not present in my gotka? ------------ This is a controversial issue and different Gursikhs have different take on this. I can only talk about what I personally do or believe in. “Arhil” is a form of poetic chhand with defined number of maatras (poetic metre). Most Panth reads 25 pauris (up to “Dusht Dokh te leho bachaayee||”) but Taksalis read more pauris that are not related to Benti Chaupai. The first pauris are totally independent Rachna (composition). I personally do only 25 pauris. --------- also do we read the other chaupee (sri mukvak patshahi 10,pranved ad ekankara) --------- This Chaupai is different from Benti Chaupai and is not mandatory for Khalsa Panth. It is found in Siri Akal Ustat. -------- also daas reads one swaiyaa (sravag sudh samuh sadan kai). i have heard that it is hukam to read 10 swaiyaas, what is the meaning of the 10, what are the 10 swaiyaas? is daas reading less bani than he should? -------- 10 swaiyaas mean the ten pauris of these swaiyaas. Each pauri is one swaiyaa. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: chauppee???

satnam · 22 Jun 2006

I have a personal experience, i know a kid who could not talk until 8 years, some body told their parents to read chopayee sahib with ahrill to the kid. earlier they used to read chopayee until Dusht Dokh te leho bachaayee. so they started reading until sagal doar to chadke. After few months of listening ahrill, he started talking. Ahril part written by 10th Guru also makes mind sharper. The meaning of ahril is that it can make a mute person (gunga person) normal and a dum person smarter.

Re: chauppee???

A Singh · 22 Jun 2006

re: CHOPAI SAHIB The reality is quite simple: The stanzas 26 and 27 (starting Kirpa Kari Hum Par Jagmata...) and the Arrill and the subsequent Chopai (Sambat Satr..) are all REFERENCES to the Benti Chopai Paath and the Granth itself, hence why the Sikh Rehit Maryada doesn't make their reading mandatory. Now some people like the DDT, Nihangs and even 3HO have used this to attack the Panthic Rehit Maryada, but insisting that the Akal Thakt have "CUT THE BANI" and "REJECTED" the Bani - a good example of this can be found on the "Shortened Banis thread" and also on the "Chardikala Jatha Live on Saturday Night" video on Mrsikhnet or Google video. The truth couldn't be farther from this - the Akal Thakt haven't cut short any banis - if this is the case, then surely it would mean the recitation of only 5 pauris of the Anand Sahib during the Rehras or when making Degh etc is also 'CUTTING SHORT' or 'Rejection' of the last 34-35 pauris? Clearly not - if we use our brains. The issue is clearly nothing to do with rejection or cutting short any bani, it is simply referring to the bani and asking us to recite the bani and allowing us to leave aside the 'references', funnily enough Nihangs don't seem to quibble about the Dohra that follows the "Brahm Kavich" or "Bhagauti Astoter" Banis in their Gutkas, which they happily accept as a just a reference. Bottom line: Akal Thakt have set the minimum requirements - this is the least we should do - I personally recite the longer version (in fact often recite the Nanaksar or Buddha Dal Rehras Versions which are some of the longest versions available), however equally will recite the standardised version when in public or if pressed for time.

Re: chauppee???

daas · 22 Jun 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh There is a Gurdwara Sahib in India (i forgot the name) that is the place where Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj composed Sri Chaupai Sahib. It shows there that Sri Chaupai Sahib is full (not 25 Pauris). It has written proof of Puraatan writings. Daas will try to find out the name of the Gurdwara Sahib. It's not only Damdami Taksal that believes in full version, Takhat Sri Hazur Sahib, Takhat Sri Patna Sahib, and several other GurSikh Jathas believe in it. go to kathaa.net and listen to ucharan of Bhai Sahib Jeevan Singh Ji Khalsa, they also read full Sri Chaupai Sahib. It's just SGPC and Missionary college that have doubted the entire Sri Chaupai Sahib. Most other Jathas in the Panth believe the full version. forgive me for my mistakes

Re: chauppee???

Sardar · 22 Jun 2006

When the British invaded India, they found it very very very very hard to rule over Sikhs. Every battle they had with Singhs, the British always lost. So in order to weaken them, the British attacked their main source of Bir Rass, which was GurBaani. They shortened Chaupee Saaheb and also attacked other parts of GurBaani. But they did it in such a way, what it was unnoticable. They were such clever people. They changed Sikhs. They even changed Baanaa. Before it just used to be Chola, but the "Kurta Pajama" really came from the British. They designed Kurta Pajama in such a way, that it looked like Indian clothing. The way Damdami Taksal publishes Gutke is actually the right way. They still have Shiri Guru Gobind Singh Saheb Ji Mahaaraj's Gutka kept somewhere that i dont know. The way Baani is written in that Gutka is the way Damdami Taksal publishes Gutke. That proves my point!

Re: chauppee???

. · 22 Jun 2006

daas wrote: >>There is a Gurdwara Sahib in India (i forgot the name) that is the place where Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj composed Sri Chaupai Sahib. It shows there that Sri Chaupai Sahib is full (not 25 Pauris). It has written proof of Puraatan writings. Daas will try to find out the name of the Gurdwara Sahib.<< A Gurdwara (of which you do not know which) has a handwritten copy of Chaupai Sahib written by Guru Gobind Singh Ji (but you have provided no evidence). Furthermore it has the additional Bania proceeding it (which you have not referenced or proved) and this therefore makes this additional Bani a compulsory part of Chaupai Sahib. What a compelling argument - If only you had not presented this earlier, the Panth would not have been confused for so many years!

Re: chauppee???

. · 22 Jun 2006

"They still have Shiri Guru Gobind Singh Saheb Ji Mahaaraj's Gutka kept somewhere that i dont know. The way Baani is written in that Gutka is the way Damdami Taksal publishes Gutke. That proves my point!" Sardar, this doesn't prove anything as this Gutka does not exist. Making up the existence of a Gutka just makes Taksali claims look even more ridiculous. The original Damdama Sahib Bir scribed by Bhai Mani Singh does not exist any more, never mind Gutke which would solve all the controversy on Bani lengths, etc.

Re: chauppee???

Super Singh · 22 Jun 2006

Sri Chaupai Sahib in morning path has 29 Pauris, and in the Reharaas Sahib it is extended. This is Dhan Sri Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj's maryada. This is what he left to us. And for proof, this is what is in BrahmGiyani Baba Deep Singh's hand written pothi of nitnem. People who say and follow the new rules of reading half the bani are causing a division in the panth. All i can say is is reading the full bani wrong. I thought the more we read the more we reach towards our goal of dasam dawar!!!!

Re: chauppee???

satnam · 22 Jun 2006

I think best way is to read 6 month choti rehras and 6 month waddi, which ever gives your soul more anand, accept and read that chopayee. People who read waddi chopayee already know its anand, so people who read choti rehras should give a try to waddi chopayee for few months. i am very sure that waddi chopayee wont hurt them.

Re: chauppee???

..... · 23 Jun 2006

"And for proof, this is what is in BrahmGiyani Baba Deep Singh's hand written pothi of nitnem." And where is this Pothi and how do you know it is written by Baba Deep Singh? And how do we know it has the extended Chaupai Sahib in it?

Re: chauppee???

A Singh · 23 Jun 2006

Sardar and others, Your stories are very interesting! 1. As clearly stated above, the Chopai has not been shortened or disregarded, I have explained this fully - just because today some fools from the Kala Afghana camp use this as a means to further their propaganda is a different thing altogether. 2. Arguments like x y and z jathas or taksals believe in it are nonsense - the Akal Thakt by mandating the 25 pauris be read is in NO WAY stating that it doesn't believe in the others or the Arill - these are regarded as references to the bani and not the Paath of Chopai Sahib itself. The PANTH made this decision not the British. 3. Stupid arguments about cholas and kurtas are ridiculous - the Kurta Pyjama is hardly a British innovation! Moreover the Chola is hardly unique to the Sikhs - look at a Bengali Kurta and boom, you have yourself a Sant Chola. 4. The Gurdwara where Maharaj uchared the Chopai Sahib is called "Bajhor Sahib". I have been to this Gurdwara - it is beautiful. However, as I have illustrated, it doesn't prove in anyway that the Panth is 'ignoring' or 'changing' bani. In fact others are: - The Buddha Dal Gutka, the Chopai Sahib paath is deemed to start from the beautiful Dohra: "Mahakaal kee Saran Parey so ley bachai..." for both the morning and evening recitals of the Chopai Sahib. The Morning recital sends with the full Arill and full Chopai (sambat satr sahas...) - The Nanaksar Gutka begins the evening rehras from "bohar asar kaa kaataa maatha..." but the morning recital from the "Hamri karo haath..." Hence the rehiras version is shorter than the Budha Dal. - The Taksal Gutka begins the evening rehiras from "pun rahas kaa kaataa seesha", hence even shorter than the above two. Moreover, the DDT even includes the Swayae and Dohras from Ram Avtar after the morning Chopai recital and even cut in half the Chopai (Sambat Satr) in their morning version - SO MUCH FOR X Y Z gutkas!!! If the Panth is incorrect and these so-called 'puratan' jathabandias are correct (I'll leave aside the question of accuracy of their claim to being 'puratan'), then why do they all have differences in their maryada? They all harp on about Guru Sahib creating only 1 maryada, what happened now???

Re: chauppee???

Gurpreet Singh · 23 Jun 2006

A Singh, I think you are a little confused on this topic. All the jatheybandis you mentioned in your post agree where KABIO BAACH BENTI CHAUPAI starts and ends. However, Chaupee starts from before Kabio baach benti chaupee and some jathaybandian choose to also do part of the chaupee as well. For rehiraas sahib, nanaksar, buddha dal, takhat sri hajoor sahib all do the same rehiraas. Taksals is a little smaller. But both versions are found in purataan pothian. I believe, but could be wrong, that taksaals rehiraas is the shortest one found in purataan pothis, but some also contain the rehiraas found in buddha dal/nanaksar gutka. Therefore both versions are acceptable

Re: chauppee???

Sardar · 23 Jun 2006

Here answere my question: What did Bhai Saheb Bhai Randhir Singh Ji say about Shiri Chopai Saheb? What version did he do?

Re: chauppee???

G · 24 Jun 2006

Dear A Singh ji, ------------------------------------ 4. The Gurdwara where Maharaj uchared the Chopai Sahib is called "Bajhor Sahib". I have been to this Gurdwara - it is beautiful. However, as I have illustrated, it doesn't prove in anyway that the Panth is 'ignoring' or 'changing' bani. In fact others are: ------------------------------------ Perhaps it was a typo, but just a slight correction - the Chaupayee Sahib gurdwara is called "Bibhaur Sahib". A lot of bandars there! Solid post otherwise. Gurfateh!

Re: chauppee???

kirtan lover · 27 Jun 2006

Yes it was Gurdwara Bharbhaur Sahib

Re: chauppee???

A Singh · 29 Jun 2006

G - thanks for the correction. Yes, there are loads of Monkeys in the surrounding forests, but a very serene setting nonetheless. Gurpreet Singh - perhaps my post is unclear - the Akal Thakt has not disagreed or disowned the closing Chaupai stanzas, but these are references. Simple as that, if others wish to make non-issues out of these, that is their choice (and possibly agenda).

Re: chauppee???

Satnam · 29 Jun 2006

Bottom line is reading more Bani wont Hurt anybody. More Bani means giving more time to God, which is good.

Re: chauppee???

Singh · 30 Jun 2006

Chaupai Sahib paath clearly goes beyond the 25th pauri as can be seen by the numbering in Sri Dasam Granth. Those who do not read the full version are not following Guru ji's Hukam. All Amrit Sanchars should read the full Paath. Only Guru ji knows why mortal people in the early 20th century thought they knew better than Guru ji and changed the Maryada...

Re: chauppee???

A Singh · 30 Jun 2006

Reading more bani will not hurt anyone - agreed, no one is suggesting this. But those who argue that somehow in the 20th century someone 'changed' the maryada for the first time, should answer the below: 1. Why do the so-called 'puratan' sampradhas shorten the Anand Sahib in the Rehiras and elsewhere (see Punj Granthi)? 2. Why does the Budha Dal Gutka begin their Chopai Sahib with the Dohra? (Those who disagree - look at the page stating 'amrit tyar karn vali bania' and 'saverr da nitnem' within the Budha Dal Gutka) and the Taksal choose to add the additional Savayae and Dohra to "complete the bani" (see their rehit maryada - these are the words used - i.e. complete the paath). 3. The reading of the Chopai to the 25th stanza was not the decision of a sole individual, but a selection of scholars, gyanis, nihangs, nirmalas, udasis, sants etc etc. I see no problem with their decisions as being those of the Sarbatt Khalsa Panth - those who wish to push their own agendas can do so - there is nothing in this decision which indicates that one cannot read more than the 25th (as indicated above I often read the BUdha Dal version myself, since it is Maha-AnanD!!!)

Re: chauppee???

Sardar · 30 Jun 2006

How is Chopai published in "Singh Brothers'" Gutkes?

Re: chauppee???

Singh · 04 Jul 2006

A singh - your logic does not hold. Rehrass Sahib is one whole paath with shabads taken from different sources. Amritvela Chaupai Sahib is one whole bani up to the 27th pauri at the very least. Nobody can change what bani's are required for Nitnem regardless of who was on what committee. Guru Panth cannot change Guru ji's direct Hukam.