Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

.... · 18 Jun 2006

wanted to ask do only akj bibyaan wear dastaars..i mean is it a MUST for bibyaan to wear dastaar... ..as i am aware there are different jathas...however do all of them agree on bibyaan wearing dastaars???

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

Kaur · 19 Jun 2006

Sat Sri Akal Ji, Thats precisely what i would like to ask aswell. I go to the Gurdwara and i see bibiyaan with kirpans, but just chunni on their heads, then again i see bibiyaan who have also chukked amrit who have dastaars. What is the sangats view on this please? Is it wrong not to wear a dastaar?

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

singh · 19 Jun 2006

nope...as of now there is no consensus that all bibian must wear a dastar... however, akj is one of the most vocal proponents of dastar for all - they dont even let you do kirtan if you dont have a dastar. do i agree--dont know...but there are the facts

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

anon · 19 Jun 2006

well daas believes keski (small dastar) is kakkar. it is the lost kakkar as it has been turned in to kesh over time. this is against maharajs hukam. (consult the literature section of this site). it is really only akj that views keski as kakkar, but bibia all over the panth wear dastar or keski. alot of nihang bibia wear dastar. sant gurbachan singh ji bhindranwale's whole family wore keski and he was a taksali. keski at the least is hukam for bibia, its just that sikhi has been influenced by other dharams and has lost its distinctiveness. you have got to ask yourself, who would benefit from changing keski to kesh? it is most likely to have occured during the british raaj, when the british were looking to weaken the sikhs, so they targeted our rehit, and slowly influenced akal takht to change the kakkars. so who benefits? do sikhs benefit from not wearing keski? no they do not, its just a lax in rehit, guru maharaj loves his rehit and we are changing it! obviously the british and other dharams would benefit, as sikh women would lose their distinctiveness and look more like hindu women. it will confuse the sikhs, slowly one change in rehit is followed by another and on the whole the whole rehit maryada is made less strict and now we have soo mny amritdharis walking around who are not fully rehitvaan. changes in rehit effect our spiritual jeevan, and changes in rehit weaken the panth overall. the goreh back then must have been laughing seeing bibia walking aorund with just a chunni. compare a amritdhari bibi with a chunni with a singhni with a dastar? who looks more like a khalsa to you? after all: "khalsa is my roop" says guru gobind singh ji

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

KS · 19 Jun 2006

Guru Fateh I am astonished and angered at the comments made by 'anon'. ''Who looks more like a Khalsa to you''?. This is a pathetic comment, always made by those that advocate the dastaar for women. Firstly, if we are of the view that we are one under the Akal Takhyt then we should respect the fact that there are many women who take amrit and do not wear dastaar.......it is not rehiit to do so. Akj need to come to terms with this.....i sometimes feel that the AKJ would like to set up in competition with the Akal Takht as it appears to me that they seem to criticise everything that comes out of the akal takht and are of the view that what they do is the only way forward. Secondly, anon's view would seem to suggest that it does not matter about naam kamai etc so long as the woman wears a dastaar. I do not like AKJ taking a dim view of those women that choose not to wear a dastaar. I have been involved with teh AKj for many years, more so in the late 90's than now. Although, i respect their ethos of naam kamai, i do not warm to their arrogance. I know of many females who will wear a dastaar at home and gurudwra etc but once out are happy to remove it...i have seen this happen several times over. There are some that do not have naam kamai. There are others who go out regularly and eat out at places such as Mcdonalds etc....not too bothered about the egg content of certain products.....but because they wear a dastaar they are wonderful.....this is a complete nonsense and i have spoken to many people about this (all non akj and some quite religious) and they say that the AKJ, especially the youth are too concerned about how they look rather than what really matters and that is naam kamai. If we are to realise our dream of khalistan we need to become one. A Hardline and arrogant approach by organisations such as the AKJ will mean that this will never happen. Bhul Chuk Maaf Guru Fateh KS

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

Kulbir Singh · 19 Jun 2006

--------------- wanted to ask do only akj bibyaan wear dastaars..i mean is it a MUST for bibyaan to wear dastaar... ..as i am aware there are different jathas...however do all of them agree on bibyaan wearing dastaars??? ------------ All puratan Jathas had their bibiyaan wear dastaar. All bibiyaan with Sant Attar Singh Mastuanawalay used to wear dastaar and still do. The ladies in the family of Sant Gurbachan Singh jee Bhindranwalay and Sant Kartar Singh jee Bhindranwalay used to wear dastaar. Central Majha Khalsa Diwan had all bibiyaan wear Dastaars. The Sikhs characters of novels of Bhai Vir Singh were dastaardhari. Dastaar is not an AKJ thing. Dastaar is a rehit of Guru Sahib. AKJ believes it to be a kakaar where as many other jathas who support the wearing of a dastaar for women and men consider it to be a rehit but not a kakaar. It does not matter what you call Dastaar – a kakaar or a mandatory rehit. The bottomline is that a Bibi cannot join the Khalsa Panth if they don’t wear a dastaar. Kulbir Singh

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

KS · 19 Jun 2006

Khalsa jee....there you go again......''a bibi cannot join the khalsa panth if they dont wear dastaar''. Where is this written????. Panj piare at Akal Takht, Sri Kesgarh Sahib, Nanaksar and dam dami taksal to name but a few don't impress this upon you at amrit sanchar stage. So are you trying to say all those bibian who have taken amrit from these jathas are not part of the panth????. Come on...get a grip of yourself....My wife is an amrit dhari, but dooes not wear dastaar but she has more nimrata and does more paath than many Keski dar bibian. Your statements that such people are not part of the panth are an absolute nonsense. Such statements just go to illustrate my earlier points made above. You are just isolating yourself in making these comments. Guru sahib has not given organistaions such as the AKJ the authority to make statemnts such as made in this thread. Accept it or not, ''the bottom line is that dastaar for bibian is not mandatory''. There are clearly more important issues for the panth to deal with.....lets move on... . Bhul Chuk Maaf Guru Fateh KS

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

. · 19 Jun 2006

Wahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikifateh "The bottomline is that a Bibi cannot join the Khalsa Panth if they don’t wear a dastaar." Extremely disappointed to read these comments by bhai kulbir singh ji.... Wahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikifateh

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

anon · 19 Jun 2006

"KS" ji u are right forgive daas, i shouldnt have sounded so harsh like that. frogive daas's hoamai. you are correct that naam kamayi is important, it the most important rehit for a gursikh. but daas was jsut trying to identify the importance of the keski and how the panth can be affected if this rehit is completely lost. as for other jathebandis n akal takht maryada, just cos they say somehting doesnt mean its correct. the majority may say keski isnt kakkar but it doesnt mean that it isnt. like kulbir singh said they still recognise the importance of dastar tho. like i said jeo, guru ji says khalsa is his roop, forgive me if the comments i made were offensive but a bibi with dastar stands out of the crowd u cannot deny that. daas has met many bibia who are amritdhari and das thought they were hindu, guru sahib has given singhs this saroop to ensure a khalsa can be seen wherever he goes, so doesnt this apply to bibia aswel. i admit that some keskidhari bibia myt do pakhandi things but that doesnt mean we shouldnt do parchar of how important the dastar is in the panth. again who would benefit from the khalsa loosing its distinctiveness? certainly not the khalsa panth. agn sorry for any stupid comments das wasnt thinking before das typed up the last post

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

??? · 19 Jun 2006

"My wife is an amrit dhari, but dooes not wear dastaar but she has more nimrata and does more paath than many Keski dar bibian." i know mone that do more paath and have more nimrata than many amritdhari singhs, going by your logic is it acceptable to cut your hair?

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

gupt singhnee! · 19 Jun 2006

really a bibi shud wear a keski whether they beleive it is keski or not...it is our sign..if u see sum1 wearing a keski u wil knw theres a sikh..jus like wen u see a muslim wearing their kurte and their hat on their head (sorry i dnt knw wt its called) and u see d muslim women wearing their bburkaas u knw it is a muslim stright aaway...all puraatan singhnees wore keski..it luks amazing man!! just hw guru gobind singh jees khalsa raaj shud luk like! bt wearing a keski dsnt mean ds it ur doin it all.u hv 2 live like khalsa..no kurehts like doin eyebrows or wearing make up or anything! bul chuk maaf! vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguru jee ke fateh

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

???? · 19 Jun 2006

'The bottomline is that a Bibi cannot join the Khalsa Panth if they don’t wear a dastaar.' Definitely agreed. sangat ji, how do some of you deny this fact after knowing Guru Gobind Singh ji tied a dastar of Mai Bhago ji himself. For other various reasons we are quick to say that both men/women are given equal status to do things according to sikhi, then why back away when it comes to wearing dastar. If you call a singh a khalsa who wears his crown. Then how can one call a bibi a khalsa when she is a moni?

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

Heart · 19 Jun 2006

Vahegurujeekakhalsa Vahegurujeekeefateh "The bottomline is that a Bibi cannot join the Khalsa Panth if they don’t wear a dastaar." Pyaara Kulbir Veerjee, i dont think this statment is right at all. Before i start i dont want you to take offence to anything i say. How is it your right to say that any bibi who doesnt wear dastaar/keski cannot join the khalsa family? Is that Guru Sahib's choice? Where does it say in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj that you cannot join the khalsa paanth if you dont wear a dastaar? You should support your answers with quotations from Gurbani. Guru sahib will accept anyone who decides to take on the paath of sikhi. I personally believe that its not what the outside loooks like but the inside. " Dontt judge a book by its cover. You could go to the gurdwara and see plenty of bibia wearing dastaars.. just because they were dastaars does not mean they are all spirtually enlightened. Yes, smoe of them will be but its not about the phsycial appearance. One can look like they have so much sikhi from the outside but its about the pyaar and sharda within you for guru sahib that matters in the long run. Also, there are girls out there who cannot wear dastaar/keski due to family problems, or maybe they are not ready but then again by saying these comments were are shutting them away and saying " you arent allowed to be part of the khalsa family" ? That is no encouragemnet whatsoeveer. There are people who read this forum taht are just being introduced to sikhi, lets not discourage them by saying these comments. If you dont have anything nice to say dont say it at all. hor galaa(n) sabh koorreeaa thudhh bhaavai paravaan ||4||5|| Everything else is false. Whatever pleases Your Will is acceptable. ||4||5|| jin guramukh hiradhaa sudhh hai saev pee thin thhaae || Those Gurmukhs who are pure of heart-their service is accepted. It is about pure love in essence.. Please pyaara kulbir veerje, do not take this personally this is a general comment Bull chaak maaph karnee jee Vahegurujeekakhalsa Vahegurujeekeefateh [%sig%]

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

Lost Soul · 19 Jun 2006

It's VERY rare to find bibyan wearing turban these dayz. I usually see them wearing a Rumāl instead of turban.

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

Harjas Kaur · 19 Jun 2006

I understand what people are saying about chardi kala amritdharee bibian who don't wear dastaar, who do lots of sewa, paat and bless the whole Panth. And I have seen young AKJ amritdaree's who wear bad clothing under those dastaars. So this is a point well taken. Any divisions in the Panth must come to an end before unifying under Khalistan. But I for one happen to believe keski is a kakkar. A khalsa is like a soldier fit for combat at all times. If a soldier has no helmet, he will suffer the greatest field casulties. Also, keski is no guarantee of protection, but it is a commitment not to expose the kesas to harm, and yogically not pollute those kesas with bad energies of the environment. The head is the highest center of the body, and all spiritual warfare starts in the mind, in the thoughts. It's critical to protect the dasam duar from bad influence. Spiritual bana of the Khalsa is about spiritual warfare against evils both within you and around you at all times. Both women and men have hairs, have heads, have energy centers and openings. Both have the tenth gate opening. Both are under subtle and unseen spiritual energy influences which affect the thoughts and the mind. Even temptations to do evil. So both men and women need to protect this gate, this entryway, or exit opening. One must respect, that dastaar-wale bibian have to live the part of Khalsa roop, and not just dress up and pretend while continuing to do bad things. We need to always be ready to fight the evil impulses. Kes alone wrapped over the dasam duar can protect the mind with Naam vibration. But the kes too must be protected, or it can lose this vibration. Just as kanga protects it from being in knots and unable to deliver Naam current, so keski insulates the kes and shields that current. I do not say amritdharee bibi without keski is not a khalsa. But, I do say it she is out of proper uniform. For one thing, a soldier needs his head protected in spiritual/physical combat. Everything about kakkars is about always being ready...even when you are asleep. I believe the original rehit has been corrupted, and in time, the Akal Takht will restore this kakkar. Fingertips under kirlian photography shows unseen electrical energy. In the photo, the young woman and her friends were severly injured by lightning just a few seconds after this picture was taken. http://www.crh.noaa.gov/grb/safety.php Electrical-magnetic properties of hair are subtle and seldom seen, but very powerful. Every thought you think, consciously or unconsciously takes form as an electrical impulse and travels along the neurons of the brain and spine to communicate between mind and body. It is a subtle energy vibration which biophysics proves can alter the very chemistry of the brain. This influences mood and perceptions. Thoughts, although seemingly invisible have a very powerful effect on the body. Hair is a conductor and receiver of electrical current. That is it's spiritual purpose. Especially hair on the head is in close connection to brain and spine. It receives and transmits spiritual energies and thought-waves, both positive and negative. Even as a single thought directs the entire body. So your mind, and your thinking is what you want to protect the most when you wrap the dasam duar with joora, and insulate with keski. Your protection is to surround your mind always with Naam vibration. And shut out the evil influences of the world. Keski and kanga and kirpan and kacherra and kara all serve the function to protect the body-mind from evil influence. These are the 5 kakkars. The 5 weapons against the 5 inner evils kam, krodh, lobh, moh, ahankar. Kes is not something you wear on the body. It is the body. Just as you wear a kara, but you do not wear your hand. All kakkars are put on the body to protect the body spiritually. [%sig%]

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

GuptSoulja · 20 Jun 2006

'Heart' Jeeo And Others: In gurbani it has been said that one should be internally and EXTERNALLY pure. Guru Gobind Singh Jee's image applies to a Khalsa, which means male and female; they have NOT been distinguished, they are the same. So, how can a Khalsa without bana be apart of the Khalsa Panth, be apart of Guru Gobind Singh Jee's children if that person hasn't adopted Guru Sahib Jee's appearance of a Khalsa. khalasa maero roop hai khaas. Secondly, Guru Gobind Singh Jee then says that even the spirit of the Khalsa is where Guru Jee is - Khalsay may hau karo nivaas, which determines that the internal has to be pure as well as the external. A Khalsa is totally pure. All Kakaars were man made but the hair was God made, as it plays much more of a significance role in Sikhi. For instance, Bhai Taru Singh Jee had his scalp removed instead of his hair, if kakaar, and obviously so were all his other kakaars removed, but then why did Bhai Sahib Jee insist of his scalp being removed instead of his hair if he had already been separated from all other kakaars without hesitation. Why was the hair of so much importance? The Hair is apart of the body; it being natural means it is a God given form which cannot be removed whereas the kakaars were given by Guru Gobind Singh Jee, which means these can and have to be worn no matter what even if one has cancer in which the hair loss is the end result, then no matter what a Kakaar is still being worn, hence Keski. In addition, according to the rehitnama of Bhai Chaupa Singh, who was a contemporary of Guru Gobind Singh Jee, the five Kakaars of Sikhi were Kachara, khrha, kirpan, khanga and keski. Below shows this rehit which has comes from the resources of the website panthkhalsa.org: Bhai Chaupa Singh says, "Kachh, karha, kirpan, kangha, keski, Eh panj kakar rehat dhare Sikh soi." Translation: The five Kakars of Sikhism are special undewear, steel bracelet, sword, comb, and small turban. A person who wears all these Sikh symbols should be considered a Sikh. KUbu qyrI pgrI mITy qyry bol ] khoob thaeree pagaree meet(h)ae thaerae bol || How handsome is your turban! And how sweet is your speech. The shabad above refers to God, and the focal point is on the turban and vocal, but not on the bodily appearance as the turban has been given a beautiful image of the formless God – remember God has no gender, so if God wears it why can’t his children show the same approval and wear it too. The turban signifies royalty, beauty, equality and respect and for the ones that don’t wear it, sorry to say this, are in fact the opposite of these qualities in which the turban provides. They have gone against the respect given by God and have instead adopted the demonic way of life. If God whom has no form can wear a turban then why can’t his children? Again forgive this servant and beggar if anyone has been offended in anyway.

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

Kulbir Singh · 20 Jun 2006

My understanding is that a male cannot join Khalsa Panth without wearing a dastaar. Then how can a female join Khalsa Panth without dastaar? A male head without dastaar is not accepted by Guru Sahib at the time of amrit sinchaar. Then how can he accept the dastaarless head of a female at the time of amrit sinchaar? I don't think a male without dastaar can even enter the Amrit Sinchaar Mandal. Then how can a female do so? I am sorry if some of the readers found my views outrageous but this daas has no intention of being politically correct. Rehit is rehit and is one for both males and females. No distinctions have been made by Guru Sahib. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

KS · 20 Jun 2006

Guru Fateh So what alot of you are doing, especially veer Kulbir Singh, is challenging the authenticity of thousands of amrit sanchaars around the world!!!. This cannot be good for the confidence and morale of thousnads of sikhs around the world. KS

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

???? · 20 Jun 2006

KS ji the confidence and moral of thousands of sikhs around the world has only be limited to what the majority has been educated with. Letting the world be aware of the importance of dastar is a good cause. Then that should boost more confidence unless one wishes to be ignorant and ignore this fact. Just by telling somebody once that dastar is mandatory obviously would not work in first instance. Sikhs should be educated about this through programmes,camps and so on. May be a day will come where SGPC will to realise this fact. Veerji please do not take me wrong whilst saying this but as you mentioned about your wife not wearing a dastar but having alot of nimarata and doing alot of path. According to this you class her to be a tyar-bar-tyar khalsa. Then may be you could say the same about yourself. Why bother wearing your dastar too, just do alot of path, which naturally brings nimarata, then that should not class you any less than a tyar-bar-tyar khalsa. veerji this is not a personal attack at all just an example to realise upon the same can go for the rest of the singhs across the world who are in the same dilusion. The fact that has been mentioned about bibiyan wearing dastar's and yet don't seem to comply or present themselves as a whole khalsa roop may be because of lack of other rehits like not wearing decent clothings. This too is a true, then i would say that they can take examples from bibiyan like your wife and build their nitnem do seva. One cannot go without the other.

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

. · 23 Jun 2006

to me baiscally its just simple...gurji's hukam for every sikh to wear a dastaar....so i dnt understand whats the arguement about?? ..if one does not wear a dastaar then that does not mean they are not a sikh as some said there could be family problems and guruji will take care of them... ...by the way ... as most ppl said that there are bibyaan out there who have taken amrit but do not wear a dastaar...... so does that mean panj pyare agree that dastaar is not mandatory :| ???

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

Balbir Singh · 18 Jul 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! Strange there is no mention of Guru's Vaak in such a long discussion. It seems that values have become important which the Gurus never assigned for Simran, what to talk about becoming pure (Khalsa) with Simran? Quote >>>to me baiscally its just simple...gurji's hukam for every sikh to wear a dastaar....so i dnt understand whats the arguement about?? <<< Please provide the reference of Guru Ji's Hukam in His words. This is the wonderful Guru's Shabad I found in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. [gurbani]mÚ 3 ][/gurbani] "mehlaa 3." [gurbani]lokw vy hau sUhvI sUhw vysu krI ][/gurbani] "lokaa vay ha-o soohvee soohaa vays karee." O People! Ego is reddish, wears red outfits. [gurbani]vysI shu n pweIAY kir kir vys rhI ][/gurbani] "vaysee saho na paa-ee-ai kar kar vays rahee." By wearing garbs, it does not receive him. It remains by wearing different garb. [gurbani]nwnk iqnI shu pwieAw ijnI gur kI isK suxI ][/gurbani] "naanak tinee saho paa-i-aa jinee gur kee sikh sunee." Nanak! Those receive HIM who listens Guru's Lesson. [gurbani]jo iqsu BwvY so QIAY ien ibiD kMq imlI ]2][/gurbani] SGGS Ang 785-18 "jo tis bhaavai so thee-ai in biDh kant milee." As it pleases HIM that takes place. They meet this way husband. Perhaps ego in some people is still trying to tempt God by wearing special garbs. In my view those, who come to know true Simran, contemplate and live Guru's Shabad alone. Balbir Singh

Re: all bibyaan wearing dastaar???

. · 18 Jul 2006

hmmm no1 seems to reply bak :S ???