Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

A Singh · 19 Jun 2006

Sikh lore indicates that Sian Mian Mir, a Muslim saint and close associate of Guru Arjun Dev and Guru Har Gobind Sahib, who witnessed the torture of Guru Arjan Patshah at the hand of Mughal rulers of the time, laid the foundation stone of Sri Harmandir Sahib. I believe that this is also mentioned in Mahan Kosh (if a learned member of the Sangat could verify that would be appreciated). However according to Jathedar Kirpal Singh in his book "Sri Harmandir Sahib Da Sunehiri Itihas" that the foundaiton stone of the Golden Temple was NOT laid down by Sayyad Mian Mir. He bases this on Rattan Singh Bhangoo's Panth Parkash in which the latter writes: "Heh to haal likhaige aise | Hui nuksan singhan no jaise | Mat kit aisee likh dikhravai | Jis te raj hamaro javai | "Hindu Turk mail kash nah(i) | Muslman kad sach kahai | (Panth Parkash page 40) What is the Sangat's view on this matter?

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

london singh · 19 Jun 2006

If i'm not mistaken the first mention of Mian Mir placing the foundation stone of Harmandir Sahib is mentioned in the Amritsar District gazetteer in the 1880's. Before this there is no mention. The gazetteer is a document published by the British who include some local history. The author of the gazetteer makes no mention of where the information was from. Until the 1920's there is no Sikh literature that mentions this. After the Gazetteer the Arya Samajis used to criticise the Sikhs saying that how could the Harmandir Sahib be holy when the foundation was laid by the meat eating Muslim. The foundation story gained credence amongst Sikhs in recent years.

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

Kulbir Singh · 19 Jun 2006

I personally believe that it was Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee Maharaaj himself who laid the foundation stone of Siri Harmandir Sahib. If we really think about it, why would Siri Guru jee have Hazrat Mian Mir to lay the foundation stone of the greatest and holiest centres of Sikhs? Guru Sahib was not politically correct. Guru Sahib always did what was according to Gurmat i.e. the hukam of Vaheguru. If we believe this story of Hazrat jee laying the foundation stone of Siri Darbar Sahib then we will have to accept all this political show that takes place at the opening ceremonies of our Gurdwaras. According to Gurmat, people are either Manmukhs or Gurmukhs. Gurmukhs are those individuals who's Mukhs (faces) are towards Guru Sahib i.e. who are Sikhs of Guru Sahib. Manmukhs are those individuals who's mukhs are towards their mann. I do believe that Hazrat jee had become an admirer of Guru Sahib and used to listen to Siri Sukhmani Sahib without fail but I am not sure if he was a Gursikh of Guru Sahib. Simply saying, in my humble opinion, Hazrat jee, though he was a player of high spiritual states, was still not at the level where he would have been accorded the honour of laying the foundation stone of Siri Harmandir Sahib. Great Brahmgiyanis like Baba Budda jee, Bhai Manjh jee, Bhai Gurdas jee, Bhai Moosan jee etc. were in their physical bodies and not to mention Siri Guru jee himself. How could anyone else had qualified to lay the foundation stone of Darbar Sahib? No, this story is a fabrication of writers like Giani Gian Singh. Sikh scholars got attracted to this story because it fits in their "mithiya" (false, distorted) understanding of all equality and unity of all religions. All religions are different and all are at different levels. These pseudo scholars also claim that Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee has baani of Hindus and Muslims. How naive of them. Its true that Bhagats were born in Hindu or Muslim families but they did not stay Hindus or Muslims forever. They became Sikhs after meeting Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and only then they were able to bring Dhur kee Baani in this world. In order to bring Dhur kee Baani from Sach Khand, one must have reached Sach Khand. One can reach Sach Khand only if one is a true Sikh of Siri Guru Nanak-Dasmesh jee. Period. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

Jagvinder Singh · 20 Jun 2006

dear kulbir singh ji, i feel your mindset is no different than that of fanatical muslims, who say that people not muslim are infidels. i feel that is the point you raised that hazrat ji was not a gurmukh, surely then, he mustve been a manmukh. so if that's the case, we should ban every non sikh, better still, non amritdhari from entering sri harimander sahib. and this coming out of the mind of guru nanak's sikh, guru nanak who believed in universal brotherhood, equality of all. na koi hindu, na koi musalmaan. agreed that we all believe in different paths, but eventually it all leads to one goal. besides, what better way was it to build religious harmony and tolerance than what guru arjan dev ji did. not many people would have the love to allow that kinda thing to happen, but our gurus proved it. hazrat ji was a highly respected sufi saint. and if you're to read sufi writings, they preach the same peace,love and equality that our gurbani preaches. im sorry kulbir ji, but i feel this point has to be brought up

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

Kulbir Singh · 20 Jun 2006

Jagvinder Singh jeeo, ------------- i feel that is the point you raised that hazrat ji was not a gurmukh, surely then, he mustve been a manmukh. so if that's the case, we should ban every non sikh, better still, non amritdhari from entering sri harimander sahib. ------------ Where did I say that manmukhs should be banned from coming to Gurdwaras? You are putting words in my mouth. If we go by your logic of equality of mankind, then why not allow Muslims to be in Punj Pyaray? Why not have Hindus doing Granthi sewa? After all, according to your flawed logic, all paths lead to the same goal. Then there should be no difference between a devout Sikh and devout Muslim and a devout Hindu. So why not have Muslims and Hindus do sewa in Punj Pyaray. Why not start doing nimaaz in Gurdwara Sahib and "Om Jai Jagdish Hare" at Gurdwara Sahibaan? It seems like you are a victim and product of the education they teach in India e.g. all religions are same and equal and different paths leading to the same goal; Be Indian first and Sikh later etc etc. ---------------- and this coming out of the mind of guru nanak's sikh, guru nanak who believed in universal brotherhood, equality of all. na koi hindu, na koi musalmaan. ----------- Who says that “na koi Hindu na koi musalmaan” means that all religions are same? This verse means that there are no true Hindus or Muslims. This was the observation of Guru Sahib when he emerged from Veyee Nadi after getting hukam to preach the true path to the world. ---------- agreed that we all believe in different paths, but eventually it all leads to one goal. --------- Who says that all paths lead to the same goal? Where in Gurbani does it say so? Hindus want Mukti, Baikunth or Swarag depending on their sects; Muslims want Jannat and Sikhs want “Mann Preet Charan Kamala Re”. How are these destinations and goals same? Sikhi rejects Swarag and Heaven and even Mukti. How are our goals same then? Jagvinder Singh, I seriously think that you have been brainwashed by the fabricated history you have read in your text books in India. Read some Tatt Gurmat literature e.g. books of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. Kulbir Singh

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

Jagvinder Singh · 20 Jun 2006

dear kulbir singh ji, i didnt put words in your mouth, but it seemed the way you said that only those who believe in the guru's word are gurmukhs, and the rest are manmukhs. im sorry if i offended you. every religion has its own set of laws and its own code of conduct. but isnt god the central theme of all religions? i mean, why cant we just have some tolerance, and respect each other's beliefs. RESPECT. NOT FOLLOW. and no, i didnt study or live in india, and dont worry, i didnt read any of the fabricated rss texts you're talking about. even guru gobind singh ji took the guise of a pir in his lifetime. if a pir or a sufi is a manmukh(non believer of the guru... like what u said), why would our dashmesh pittaah have done such an act. after all, he was anterjami. but, maybe, his reason behind it was to educate that all holy men, after all, are men of god. they spread the same message of love and peace. and he had 2 muslims( nabi khan, and i forgot the other's name... they were brothers)who risked their lives to accompany him while he was disguised as uch da pir. not all muslims are the same. they mustve had an awesome load of respect for our guru ji. then, look at pir budhu shah, who sacrificed his sons for dashmesh pitaah's war of righteousness. think about it, then why not, would guru arjan dev ji have hazrat ji lay the foundation stone of sri harimander sahib? p.s. I am a citizen of the republic of singapore. a place where multi races and religions have lived peacefully for the past 60 odd years.a place where everyone is allowed to practise their religious right. i am not an indian citizen.

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

satvinder · 20 Jun 2006

Some more questions... they are relevent to this thread. Why were FOUR openings constructed in the darbaar sahib? Why was only ONE causeway erected? Who made these decisions and why?

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

satvinder · 20 Jun 2006

waheguru. sorry about the seemingly abrupt post earlier. This is just due to lack of time, no other reason.

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

Kulbir Singh · 20 Jun 2006

Jagvinder Singh ------------ dear kulbir singh ji, i didnt put words in your mouth, but it seemed the way you said that only those who believe in the guru's word are gurmukhs, and the rest are manmukhs. ---------- I still stand by this. Ones who have come to the sharan of the true Guru – Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaj are Gurmukhs and rest are manmukhs. What’s so hard about it? I explained earlier also that unless one obtains Patit-Paavan Naam from the true Guru, one cannot be a Gurmukh. To obtain Naam, one has to offer one’s head to Guru Sahib and then take Amrit. After taking amrit of Khanda Baata, one is blessed with Amrit-Naam. After jaap of this Amrit-Naam, one swims across this terrible ocean called world. ---------- im sorry if i offended you. every religion has its own set of laws and its own code of conduct. but isnt god the central theme of all religions? ---------- No, God is not the central theme of all religions. Some religions like Buddhism and Jainism don’t even believe in God. Lets be thankful to Shankracharya for ridding India of these atheist religions. In any case, the understanding of God that Gurmat offers, no one else offers. Just read Gurbani for details. Only through, Gurmat one can realise God to the fullest possible extent. Don’t even talk about Semitic religions, who have nothing to offer in this case. Some Indian sects do have some knowledge but it falls short of Gurmat. --------- i mean, why cant we just have some tolerance, and respect each other's beliefs. RESPECT. NOT FOLLOW. ---------- We respect all human beings and all good things of all religions. No question of this. But respecting them does not mean considering them equal to Gurmat. Understand the difference. ------------ even guru gobind singh ji took the guise of a pir in his lifetime. if a pir or a sufi is a manmukh(non believer of the guru... like what u said), why would our dashmesh pittaah have done such an act. ---------- I don’t believe that Mard Agambra like Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee who left the fort of Chamkaur after challenging the Mughals would escape Machhiwara in the disguise of a Muslim Pir. This story is a blasphemy. Siri Guru Dasmesh jee would never do such an act nor any other Guru hid like this. This story is totally nonsense and does not befit our Guru Sahib. Kulbir Singh

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

A Singh · 20 Jun 2006

Veer Kulbir Singh, You have provided some interesting comments - I always enjoy reading your posts as you usually are one to have at least have some line of Gurbani supporting your assertions and interpretations together with other historical sources. It would be useful for the forum perhaps to understand some of the following comments you have made above: 1. "Don’t even talk about Semitic religions, who have nothing to offer in this case" You mentioned this in respect of God being a central theme, please could you elaborate for us all to understand how you have concluded this, since on the face of things the Bible, Tohra and Koran all speak of God again and again (you comments on Janism and Buddhism are spot on). 2. "These pseudo scholars also claim that Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee has baani of Hindus and Muslims. How naive of them. Its true that Bhagats were born in Hindu or Muslim families but they did not stay Hindus or Muslims forever. They became Sikhs after meeting Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee" Surely Veer Jee, you don't regard Gyani Gyan Singh to be a pseudo scholar (I have aired my concerns over some of his conclusions and assertions elsewhere, he is nonetheless a Nirmala Gyani?). Moreover, how did all the Bhagats meet Guru Sahib, when many of them existed prior to Guru Sahib's time? Also do not these Bhagats have their own movements? 3. If the Uch da Pir sakhi is 'blasphemous' as you say, why (a) has it circulated for so long unchecked (compare to say Gurbilas P6 or Sooraj Parkash) and also (b) what were the motivations of the original writer behind this assertion (other questionable items such as devi worship can easily be explained by fanciful twists and/or personal background of the author, however here it doesn't seem to be clear). 4. "We respect all human beings and all good things of all religions. No question of this. But respecting them does not mean considering them equal to Gurmat. Understand the difference." You are right there is a clear difference, however for avoidance of doubt please could you clarify how we can respect someone if we regard them as effectively on an inferior path? Also does this not mean we should, like the Muslims and Christians, actively evangelise our faith, since we would only be spreading the truth and helping these individuals out of weaker situations or paths? Is it not necessary for us through compassion to tell them they are on a wrong or weak path and to propagate the message of the Guru through active conversion rather than simply raising awareness - surely Sarbatt da Bhalla would require us to convert people to the Khalsa way? 5. "na koi Hindu na koi musalmaan” means that there are no true Hindus or Muslims. This was the observation of Guru Sahib when he emerged from Veyee Nadi after getting hukam to preach the true path to the world. " Veer Jee, does this by implication mean that if there were true Hindus or Muslims that there would be a chance for them to live and truthful and spiritually fulfilling life? Veer Jee, I ask the above for clarification of your comments rather than any challange - I'm pretty sure others here probably share some of those questions, please could you shed some more light on these and also provide some more of your supporting arguments using the touchstone of Gurbani (as you usually do). Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

Kulbir Singh · 20 Jun 2006

Veer A. Singh jeeo, ------------------ 1. "Don’t even talk about Semitic religions, who have nothing to offer in this case" You mentioned this in respect of God being a central theme, please could you elaborate for us all to understand how you have concluded this, since on the face of things the Bible, Tohra and Koran all speak of God again and again (you comments on Janism and Buddhism are spot on). ------------- My friend, this is a long topic and should be discussed under a different thread. I am worried that a discussion about Semitic religions will turn ugly with some of our posters making severe allegations on their prophets, something I am not interested in. Basically, in my opinion, Semitic religions are far from the reality because they haven’t even discovered who we are and why we are. They have no idea about the complexities of Aatma, Mann and Antashkaran. They don’t believe in Reincarnation that even the atheist religions of India figured out. They are far from the spiritual heights that India religions have reached. Did you ever wonder why Guru Sahib has not given much importance to these religions in Gurbani. Gurbani does not even mention Isaayee and Moosaayee (Christians and Jews). It has references to Islam but much less than those of Yogis as an example. Bhai Gurdas jee has very brief references to Isaayees and Moosaayees. Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee must have met them while travelling in Middle East. Gyan Khand (In Siri Jap jee Sahib) mentions Budh, Krishna, Mahesh etc but does not have a single reference to Muhammad, Jesus, Moosa (Moses), Ibrahim (Abraham), Dawood (David) or any of the other paigambars (prophets) of Semitic religions. They must have existed but it seems like they were not very elevated souls. All this has enabled me to conclude that the Semitic religions are not as sophisticated as the religions founded in India are. ----------------- 2. "These pseudo scholars also claim that Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee has baani of Hindus and Muslims. How naive of them. Its true that Bhagats were born in Hindu or Muslim families but they did not stay Hindus or Muslims forever. They became Sikhs after meeting Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee" Surely Veer Jee, you don't regard Gyani Gyan Singh to be a pseudo scholar (I have aired my concerns over some of his conclusions and assertions elsewhere, he is nonetheless a Nirmala Gyani?). Moreover, how did all the Bhagats meet Guru Sahib, when many of them existed prior to Guru Sahib's time? Also do not these Bhagats have their own movements? ------------ Our Janamsaakhis state that Guru Sahib met all bhagats. Giani Gurdit Singh has proved it beyond doubt that Guru Sahib met all bhagats. Please refer to his Book Itihaas Bhagat Baani. I have written about this topic several times on this forum. Please use the search function to find out. -------------- 3. If the Uch da Pir sakhi is 'blasphemous' as you say, why (a) has it circulated for so long unchecked (compare to say Gurbilas P6 or Sooraj Parkash) and also (b) what were the motivations of the original writer behind this assertion (other questionable items such as devi worship can easily be explained by fanciful twists and/or personal background of the author, however here it doesn't seem to be clear). -------------- Maha Kavi Santokh Singh jee Chooramani has done great service to Panth by writing Gur Partap Suraj Parkash but by the same token, he has included some very naïve saakhis perhaps based on hearsay. It seems like he wrote everything he heard from old people in villages and I am glad he did so but now it’s our turn to use Bibek Budh and pick correct saakhis out of this ocean of saakhis he wrote. ----------- You are right there is a clear difference, however for avoidance of doubt please could you clarify how we can respect someone if we regard them as effectively on an inferior path? -------- Every human being must be respected because Parmatma is sitting in everyone. Now this is a different matter how much these humans have realized God sitting in them. Whether Christian or Muslim or anyone for that matter; we must respect and love all. ------------ Also does this not mean we should, like the Muslims and Christians, actively evangelise our faith, since we would only be spreading the truth and helping these individuals out of weaker situations or paths? ----------- A Sikh should always do parchaar of Sikhi but only to those individuals who seem like potential candidates (Gaahak). Otherwise a Sikh should not bother like missionary religions do. ------------ Veer Jee, does this by implication mean that if there were true Hindus or Muslims that there would be a chance for them to live and truthful and spiritually fulfilling life? ---------- Muslims and Hindus who meditate on Kirtam Naam reach very far spiritually. All the respect to them. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has written that some of the fortunate ones who japp Kirtam Naam can reach as far as Karam Khand but they cannot reach the ultimate spiritual state of Sach Khand. That is only possible through Sikhi. Thanks for raising some very thought provoking questions. It was a delight to read them. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Foundation Stone of Harimandir Sahib

A Singh · 20 Jun 2006

<> This, I believe is the key message that we need to take away from here and not that equal means the SAME, which as we know from many internal discussions is hardly the case. As per the comments concerning the lack of mention concerning Isahi (Christians) or Yehudis (Jews) within Bani, I personally must differ from you in your conclusions, although I concur that the sophistication of spiritual search within the East has been overall more indepth and solid than the West or Middle East, however the influence of time space and circumstances should not be ignored. It is clear when we look at the bani of the first Guru through to the last, that certain aspects reflects their surrounding, particularly in terms of groups with whom discourses are held, the appearence of Muslim or Islamic related discussions increases as we go through the 10 Gurus and discussions with Yogis is more evident in the the Bani of the first and earlier Gurus. But whatever the case and whatever we may personally feel about other traditions, I don't believe we should write off the prophets (be they Jesus, Mohammed, Moses or whoever) as 'not very elevated souls' simply on the basis that we consider the current state of their traditions to lack in spiritual sophistication. Yes, I as any self-respecting Sikh, may well hold regard for Jesus and his matyrdom, however it goes without saying that the sacrifices of the Sikhs and the Gurus remain (and in my humble opinion will alway remain) incomparable against all others, nonetheless, I can't bring myself to use this as a means to belittle others, only to strike at the very root of my soul to inspire myself and hopefully others around me to elevate our own jeevans. Thanks for sharing your thoughts, I have enjoyed this discussion with you Veer Jee. Gur Fateh!