Re: Bhai Saheb's Baani???
Kulbir Singh · 22 Jun 2006
"Dhur kee Baani" is only one i.e. "Baaniyaa sirr baani" i.e. "Amrit baani" of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. This baani is the Akath Kahaani of Akal Purakh that our Sarbagh Satguru Sahibaan brought on Earth from Sach Khand. All other baanis besides this baani lack the Paaras Kala of Gurbani.
Bhai Sahib's Maha-kaav (great poem) called Jyot Vigaas is by no means equalling baani. It's true that Bhai Sahib was divinely inspired to write this and he did not have control over himself when he wrote it but still it cannot be called Amrit Baani. Amrit baani is only Gurbani. Nonetheless, Jyot Vigaas is a great Gurmat poem.
Jyot Vigaas is unique out of all other poems written by Sikh writers like Bhai Vir Singh etc. It is different. You know as soon as you start reading it. It's very concentrated as opposed to very shallow and dilluted poems you see out there. Many mystical secrets have been revealed in this poetic work. Many mystical incidents that occurred in Bhai Sahib's life are written in here.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Bhai Saheb's Baani???
Kulbir Singh · 23 Jun 2006
---------
Are you honestly implying that Bhai Vir SIngh's poems are "shallow adn diluted"???
----------
Bhai Vir Singh jee's poems are dilluted because they contain non-Gurmat stuff in them but Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee's poems are Tatt Gurmat and they contain no traces of non-Gurmat stuff in them. Read both authors and find out yourself.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Bhai Saheb's Baani???
kirtan lover · 23 Jun 2006
I too read this in the profs keski book. However I was deeply disturbed by this.
Re: Bhai Saheb's Baani???
Kulbir Singh · 23 Jun 2006
A Singh jeeo,
By non Gurmat I don't mean anti-Gurmat but what I meant was that many poems of Bhai Vir Singh are of general nature e.g. on beauty of nature, general stuff etc whereas Jyot Vigaas is strictly on Gurmat related issues or mystical experiences. The fact of the matter is that Bhai Vir Singh and Bhai Randhir Singh jee were poets of different genre. At this time I don't have any example since I don't have access to Bhai Vir Singh jee's books. At a later date, I will try to post something to prove my point.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Bhai Saheb's Baani???
Dalvir Singh · 23 Jun 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Kulbir Singh jio, could you, for the benefit of the (cyber) sangat put up Jot Vigas so we all can read it and gain some knowledge. Thank you Khalsa ji.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh