Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

India Up To It Again!

India Up To It Again!

Dalvir Singh · 22 Jun 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Pyare Sangat ji, daas had received an email message showing that India is up to its old tricks again, as they have now published more books distorting Sikh History. In the books, it says Guru Tegh Bahadur was a criminal and a rapist, Guru Gobind Singh ji was a weak-hearted individual who worshipped Durga, etc etc. http://www.panthic.org/news/126/ARTICLE/2532/2006-06-11.html Distortion of Sikh History continues in Indian Books Sunday 11th of June 2006 Panthic Weekly News Bureau "The first step in liquidating a people is to erase its memory. Destroy its books, its culture, its history, Then have somebody write new books, manufacture a new culture, invent a new history. Before long the nation will begin to forget what it is and what it was. The world around it will forget even faster……The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting.” -Milan Kundera Amritsar Sahib, Punjab (KP) - Sikh organizations worldwide stand united and resolute in protest against the blatant and systematic distortion of Sikh history in elementary and high school history textbooks by the RSS and other Hindu extremist groups. Sikhs along with other minority communities including Christians, Muslims and Jains have become victims of a massive government organized campaign to spread false and distorted information about these minority communities in an attempt to homogenize them into the construct of one religion, one language, one land of Hindus: Hindu, Hindi, Hindustan. Despite the protests and peaceful pleas from the Sikh community and various other minority groups, the government continues to allow and in fact supports the publishing of this false information about these religious groups. Just recently the National Council for Educational Research and Training (NCERT) published a history on ‘Medieval India’ to be used in the high school curriculum. In this, Professor Satish Chandra of Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU), New Delhi wrote that Guru Tegh Bahadar Ji was a ‘looter and a rapist’ and that Guru Sahib became a martyr not in the name of the freedom to practice religion but because Chandra claims Guru Sahib ‘was a criminal.’ When the Sikh minority expressed their grievances with this gross historical fallacy, Chandra defended his work by saying that he used a ‘credible Persian source’ albeit that this source was written over a century after Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji’s Shaheedi. When questioned about the erroneous points that he presented in the text he said that he wanted to provide a ‘constructive interpretation of tradition.’ Congress Party leader Sonia Gandhi expressed support for Chandra’s work despite protests from the Sikh minority. The book is full of numerous other historical fallacies about the Sikh Guru Sahibans with false information saying that Guru Nanak Sahib ‘renounced the world’, that Guru Gobind Singh Ji was a ‘worshipper of Hindu Goddess Chandi’ and that Sikhi is ‘a part of the Hindu movement.’ Another history textbook titled ‘History of Punjab Part II’ which is full of historical fallacies and objectionable material about the Sikh Guru Sahibans is now in wide distribution and being implemented in Punjab school curricula. The book makes multiple flagrant distortions of Sikh history calling Baba Budha Ji ‘a thief,’ and portraying Guru Hargobind Sahib as a person of immoral character. Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji is termed as an ‘oppressor’ while Guru Gobind Singh Ji is presented as a weak hearted person and a worshipper of the Hindu Goddess Durga. Numerous other perversions of history are presented in this book which is being used in the syllabi throughout Punjab and in several other states. The Sarbat Khalsa Mission issued a referendum calling for a committee to be established to ensure that such historical distortions are not permitted in the future. They also stated that only accurate and approved books with proper scholastic research should be implented into the curricula. They also called for action against Lahore Book Shop, Lajput Rai Market, Ludhiana, the book publishers and made a call to all Sikhs worldwide to boycott their company and to take strict actions against the owners of the publishing firm. A glimpse of material contained in the books: In Original Gurmukhi Format : View Page A View Page B English Translations: Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji And Bhai Bidhi Chand A Sikh of the Guru was bringing a Turkish horse to Amritsar as a gift for the guru. The officials of the king in Lahore intercepted the Sikh and took the horse into their possession. The officials then presented the horse to the king. Upon seeing the beauty of the horse, the king ordered that the horse be sent to his stables and a fair price be given to the owner of the horse. When the guru came to hear of this incident, he became extremely angered, as he was not able to do anything else. Due to some unknown circumstances, this horse became crippled. The king then proceeded to gift this horse to the kazi of Lahore. The kazi sought treatment of the horse, after which the horse became well once again. Guru decided that he would attempt to purchase this horse from the kazi for 10 thousand rupees. He took possession of the horse from the kazi in Lahore to Amritsar without paying the price. In the meantime, a Sikh of the guru captured a falcon of the king. Also, a woman by the name of Kaulan who was staying in the haveli of the kazi fled with the same Sikh who had captured the falcon of the King. The woman Kaulan was in love with the guru therefore the Sikh helped her flee from the kazi. Another Quarrel Between The Guru And The King While living in the jungles, Guru Hargobind Ji brought many people into the Sikh fold. Of the individuals who had become Sikhs there was one who was a famous thief known as Buddha. This thief later on became known as Baba Buddha. The title of Baba was bestowed upon Buddha by the Sikhs of that time. This person by the name of Buddha stole two of the kings most prized horses from the king’s stables and presented them to the guru. This incident led the king to become even more angered as he was already quite angered by the deeds of the guru. The king sent a large force of soldiers from Lahore under the command of Kamar Begh and Lal Begh to Amritsar. The army while advancing rapidly crossed the Satluj River. The Gurus Return To Punjab Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji returned to Anandpur from Patna. Upon returning, he purchased some land for 500 rupees from Devi Madho the king of Kehloor. On this land, he founded the city of Makhowal, which even to this day exists near the bank of the river Satluj near Kartarpur. The city of Kartarpur was one resting place of Guru Hargobind Ji, which the Sikhs consider as a holy place. After living as an Udhasi in Bengal and then returning to Punjab, it seems as if the Guru (Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji) began a criminal life of killing and looting. He had once again resumed his criminal activities, which he had suspended whilst living as an Udhasi in Bengal. The land between the Satluj River and Jhansi had been completely plundered by Guru Tegh Bahadur. The Gurus Rebellious Activities The guru had also joined with Adam Haffaz and when this Muslim began looting and killing fellow Muslims the Guru also followed his lead and began killing his fellow Hindus. Places of worship had become the prime target of the Guru and Haffaz. From the villages they had recruited many armed followers who were paid handsome salaries for their assistance in the lootings and killings. Those that were rebelling against the Mughal Empire were also inducted into the criminal gang of the guru. The Order Of The Guru The Sikhs who Guru Gobind Singh had, given the name Khalsa, were ordered to arm themselves, keep their weapons with them at all times, keep knotted and long hairs*, wear blue clothing, never wear red clothes, and never used tobacco. All the restrictions, which had been placed on eating and drinking, were abolished. *The guru was the follower of the goddess Durga who was the goddess of power. The devi had permitted the guru to open his hair and unsheathe his sword. The guru had vowed to keep his hair uncut in the remembrance of the goddess Durga, he then also gave this command to his Sikhs. Teachings For His Son Gobind Guru Tegh Bahadur said to his son Gobind “now I am going to become a martyr, son make sure my body is not left to be eaten by crows and dogs.” Afterwards he instructed his son to take revenge for his soon to come death and appointed him as his successor. He picked his son up in his arms, kissed him on the forehead, and proceeded to leave for Delhi. These were times when the King had jailed hundreds of Brahmins and had hoped that if Guru Tegh Bahadur would become Muslim, then the rest of the Hindus in jails and otherwise would follow his lead. The King Asks For A Miracle To Be Performed The king had a religious debate with Guru Tegh Bahadur numerous times and said that if you are the real Guru then show some miracle otherwise adopt the Islamic faith. When the Guru said no to both options given by the king he was sent to prison. The guru has asked numerous times to become a Muslim but he declined their request every time. For this disobedience, they began to torture the guru. Not being able to take this torture any longer, the Guru declared that he will show a miracle and will provide proof that his path is true. A Unique Scheme He was presented before the King, on this occasion all the Kings employees were present to witness the miracle. Addressing the gathering the Guru Ji said that a man’s religion is to remember God but since the King has ordered him to show some miracle he shall obey these orders. Then Guru Ji proceeded to write some words on a piece of paper thaveeth which he then tied around his neck. He then exclaimed that no sword could cut his neck due to what he had written on that paper. Now the executioner was called so that this miracle may be tested. When the executioner swung his sword and hit the Gurus neck, the guru’s head separated from his body and landed on the ground. Seeing this onlookers were surprised. Then the papers was taken from the guru neck and read, the paper had the following written on it, “ਸਿਰ ਦੀਆ ਸਰ ਨ ਦੀਆ” ** meaning that he had given his head but not revealed his secret. The guru did not longer physically exist but his holy deed stayed forever. All were surprised to see this incident take place; the king himself became saddened and in anger ordered all to leave. Even though, this is the tale that the lovers of miracles have narrated; it is most likely that the guru was declared a rebel and executed. (** Eds. Note: The above is a serious distortion of Gurbani, the actual verse is : ਸੀਸ ਦੀਆ ਪਰ ਸਿਰਰੁ ਨ ਦੀਆ ॥) These blasphemous extracts provide further evidence that the RSS in collaboration with the Government of India is on a wide scale misinformation campaign to distort, misrepresent, discredit and swallow all minority communities into the Hindutva mold in order to make their motto of 'Hindu, Hindi, Hindustan Bakee Ka Nahee Rahey Nishan' a reality. It is crucial for the Sikh Nation to understand the seriousness of this issue, and the need to take appropriate actions so further denigration and alteration of Sikh history is thwarted immediately. Panthic Weekly appreciates the efforts taken by organizations such as Sarbat Khalsa Mission, Shahbaaz Khalsa, GURSIKH, Khalsa Alliance, and others so our Nation can be kept aware of the surreptitious attacks on our faith and history by Hinduvta forces and agencies. Reference Information : Letters from Organizations in regards the above books : Original Letter by Sarbat Khalsa Mission : Click to View Page 1 English Translation : Our children will lose faith after reading such books with distorted facts about Sikh Guru Sahibans and the roots of Sikh values will be destroyed. This is the reason that this matter needs immediate action. Should we accept that history writers and teachers are enemies of Sikh values? Before writing such false information, writers should think and collect only true matter so that it matches the historical facts written by Bhai Veer Singh and Bhai Sahib Singh and only those books should be taught in schools and colleges. History of Punjab Part II, History of the Punjab by Mohamad Lateef, and other such books, interpreted by Gurmukh Singh ‘Gurmukh’ and published by Tajinderbir Singh, should be taken back from schools and colleges and should be banned instantaneously. 1. A committee should be established to read again all the history books published, so that publishing of such degrading books can be recognized and then banned. 2. Only, accurate and approved books should then be allowed in schools and colleges. 3. Above mentioned books are being sold at “Layalpur Depot” outside the Akal Garh Market, for the purpose of disturbing the environment and to defame Sikhs. 4. Above-mentioned book has been published by Lahore Book Shop, Lajpat Rai Market, Ludhiana. Strict actions should be taken towards the owner of this shop so that the situation can be brought to normal again. Please cooperate, with grief, Sarbat Khalsa Mission (Reg:) President: Jarnail Singh Vice President: Gurdeep Singh General Secretary: Harmeet Singh Press Secretary: Prabhjeet Singh Secretary: Jagjeet Singh Treasurer: Kamaldeep Singh Gurmukhi Original of Collective Letter : Click to View English Translation of Collective Letter by: Kalghidhar Youth Seva Society, Sarbat Khalsa Mission, Guru Granth Sahib Satkar Committee, Sarab Rog Ka Aukadh Naam, Guru Angad Dev Seva Society (Reg), Nitnem Seva Society, Gurmat Chetna Front, Bhai Ghanaiya Ji Seva Society Khalsa Ji Wake Up...............Khalsa Ji Wake Up………….Wake Up Now!!!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Sadh Sangat Ji in the stores a book by the name of History of Punjab Part II has been published. In this book, a great deal of objectionable material has been written regarding Sikh Guru Sahibs. Also in this book disrespectful words have been used for Baba Budha Ji, which have pierced the hearts of every Sikh. In this book, Mard Agamra Kalghidhar Pathshah Guru Gobind Singh Ji is described as a weak hearted person. In this book, the 6th Guru Sahib, who uttered the words “ਦੋਲਤ ਗੁਜਰਾਨ, ਔਰਤ ਇਮਾਨ, ਪੁੱਤਰ ਨਿਸ਼ਾਨ” is portrayed as a person of bad character. In this book, Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib who uttered the words “ਭੈਅ ਕਾਹੂ ਕੋ ਦੇਤ ਨਹਿ, ਨਹਿ ਭੈਅ ਮਾਨਤ ਆਨ” is termed as an oppressor. In this book, Bhram Giani Baba Budha Ji is said to be a thief. Most shameful is the fact that this book, which pierced the heart of all Sikhs, was printed by in Punjabi by Lahore Book Shop, Ludhiana: Prof. Tejinderbir Singh and in English and Hindi by Kalyani Publisher Lyallpur Book Center Choura Bazaar Ludhiana. The main point to take notice of is that this book has been included in the history syllabus and it presents a much distorted version of Sikh history, which will lead to the weakening of Sikh credibility throughout the world. Sadh Sangat Ji, this has now become intolerable. What worse can we hear than this?? They have directly attacked us by presenting our Guru Sahibs in such a false and degrading manner. Wake Up Now!!! Our self-respect is being threatened!!!!! Wake Up Now!!! They are killing you in your own home!!!! Wake Up Now!!! The Guru who you bow your head to, the guru from whom you ask for your wants, over who you wave the whisk, over whom you hang a canopy, that Gurus glory and grandness is being tarnished!!!!!!!!!! If you do not wake up now then do not be proud of the saroop that you see in the mirror, which was gifted to you by Guru Gobind Singh Ji….instead you should feel ashamed. Our Guru Sahib has taught us to protect the religion of others but we are not even protecting our own religion. If we do not give these people a strong/powerful response today then any Tom, Dick, and Harry will get up and speak wrong of our Guru Sahibs. If we have love towards our Guru…if we truly accept Guru Granth Sahib Ji as our father, then those brothers who are fighting this battle, lets stand with them and prove that we are the sons of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. This is not a request but this is a message as we all have the same father Come, let us work collectively……. Kalghidhar Youth Seva Society * Sarbat Khalsa Mission * Guru Granth Sahib Satkar Committee * Sarab Rog Ka Aukadh Naam * Guru Angad Dev Seva Society (Reg) * Nitnem Seva Society * Gurmat Chetna Front * Bhai Ghanaiya Ji Seva Society * the entire Sadh Sangat. Mobile: 98882-46276, 92179-40965, 98150-40945, 98762-08665, 5145249, 98154-02525, 98158-00113. [%sig%]

Re: India Up To It Again!

confused · 22 Jun 2006

we should start a fund to buy as many copies of this book as we can and then publically burn them in a rally...i would suggest each major city in each country start this up...in the mean time im gonna try looking for where we could purchase this book....it would be wicked to show how much we oppose this!!!!!!!

Re: India Up To It Again!

KS · 22 Jun 2006

The insults to Guru Ji's are unforgiveable, especially after the Guru Sahibs sacrificed so much for Hindus. The worst thing is that Badal is in a alliance with the BJP/RSS.

Re: India Up To It Again!

singh · 22 Jun 2006

"we should start a fund to buy as many copies of this book as we can" - what? and make them richer? - make it a best seller? I hope we don't end up looking like muslim lunatics burning flags. - sikhs are not supposed to get angry. full stop. esp over nindia there are better things you can do for the panth- try to excell and be brilliant in everything you do - like study, sports, business so that people can see that you have been given the best teachings We need parchar in places like india to stop the majority of youth wrecking their lives being hooked on drugs - not more silly rallies making us look like idiots

Re: India Up To It Again!

Sidharth · 22 Jun 2006

please, please, please. it is not india or hindus which are "up to it again". it is the communists and their cohorts in jnu which are doing this. satish chandra, romila thapar etc. are big time communists who have no religion and remember the communists are back in power in india. please read this and you will understand what i mean http://organiser.org/dynamic/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=88&page=2 and this book review by a sikh: http://www.indiastar.com/wallia19.html

Re: India Up To It Again!

PTE SINGH · 23 Jun 2006

Again a nation and a religion is blamed because one author writes a book. No wonder Sikhs won't get togther, because sensible people will not follow such silly propaganda and the anti-Hindu brigade won't accept reality. [%sig%]

Re: India Up To It Again!

some1 · 23 Jun 2006

Sorry PTE Singh, if you have not learnt from history it is not my fault. This is a clear cut attempt by the Hindu RSS and government of India to dissolove Sikhism and assimilate it. Crystal Clear.

Re: India Up To It Again!

sarbloh · 23 Jun 2006

<> Dear Pie singh, May be u r right.But I havent not been able to understand: 1.Why Rajiv Gandhi led Congress completely swept elections after his mother indira gandhi was killed? 2.Isnt KPS Gill roaming freely in indian and earms tremendous respect and is often called as super cop.Why is that? I do understand that a poor indian like rikshaw pullers or labourers are not involved in this anti sikh propaganda but there is a significant population of the majority religion of India who love the sikh beating,infact they love muslim beating as well,hence parties of majority like congress or bjp perform this beating and gain power. Bhul Chukk Maaf RAAJ KAREGA KHALSA WAhegurujeekakhalsa Wahegurujeekeefateh

Re: India Up To It Again!

JS · 23 Jun 2006

PTE Singh who do you define as sensible? If the education department of India is using these books in Schools most children will follow this, Do you expect children to stand up in class and denounce these books? Do you think they will write something else when it comes to exam time and fail? Of course not. When a serious matter is being discussed do not act as appologist for anti Sikh propaganda or call it anti Hindu. A lot of the anti Sikh hysteria in the late 70's and onwards was caused by these kind of books and media reporting. Thousands died, this is not a small matter.

Re: India Up To It Again!

LS · 23 Jun 2006

Some people will support India no matter what they have done to Sikhs. Often they have a relative who is in the Army or the Police and they have brain washed them.

Re: India Up To It Again!

Bruce Lee · 23 Jun 2006

India is still far to get worst yet. Its kaljug, the whole world is becoming corrupt and this is when the khalsa will rise. Thats why it is so important to jaap naam, keep as much rehit and have pyaar for Guru Jee. It's like the lotus flower, which sets in dirty water. India and the rest of the world is the dirty mud and water and the Khalsa will be that beautiful shining flower. Its so IMPORTANT to jaap as much naam, this is will help us for the big day!

Re: India Up To It Again!

Dalvir Singh · 23 Jun 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Bruce Lee ji is right. The time will come Khalsa ji when we will need to rise again to make Khalsa Raj. Jap an immense amount of naam now! Don't delay, do amritvela do Sukhmani Sahib da paath and do IMMENSE IMMENSE amount of Naam Simran, Day and Night! This way we will go to the battlefield filled with Divine Powers from Akal Purakh to fight the manmukhs! SAT SRI AKAL - WAHEGURU JI IS THE TRUTH Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: India Up To It Again!

sarbloh · 23 Jun 2006

http://www.zeenews.com/articles.asp?aid=304477&sid=NAT Swaraj under Sikh fire for "distorting" history New Delhi, June 23: Senior BJP leader Sushma Swaraj today came under fire of the Delhi Sikh Gurudwara Management Committee that accused her of distorting historical facts related to the martyrdom of fifth Sikh Guru Arjan Dev. DSGMC chief Harvinder Singh Sarna told a news conference here that the BJP MP wrongfully described Chandu, Mughal emperor Jehangir's courtier who carried out the Guru's execution under royal orders 400 years ago, as innocent. At a women seminar organised by the SGPC at Taran Taran on June 14 to commemorate the martyrdom anniversary, Swaraj had allegedly described Chandu as a mere Mughal employee who she said was only carrying out the royal orders. "Her comments came after SGPC member Kiranjot Kaur said in her lecture that both Jehangir and Chandu were to be blamed for the Guru's execution. But Swaraj immediately got up and gave Chandu a clean chit," Sarna said. "It's a historial fact that Chandu was the man who influenced Jehangir against the Sikhs and the Guru. Chandu was very much part and parcel of the entire execution episode. He was the man who tortured the Guru savagely. Swaraj has blatantly twisted Sikh history which we strongly oppose," Sarna, who also accused Shiromani Akali Dal chief Parkash Singh Badal of allowing RSS interference in Sikh religious affairs, said. The DSGMC leader alleged that Badal and his supporters were present at the event where Swaraj spoke but issued no reaction to her comments.

Re: India Up To It Again!

GuptSoulja · 23 Jun 2006

'Chandra Singh' Jeeo: 'Does Akal Purukh ask any where in Granth Sahib to fight MAnmukhs?.' Lets not argue with anyone: We do not know though Dalvir Singh Jeeo could be on a spiritual level where he knows such things - we shouldn't always jump to conclusions and start judging others. It has occurred in the past where manmukhs have attacked God's devotees many times, and this has mentioned in Gurbani through Bhagat Pralaad's story, and this can happen again. If a manmukh follows the demons inside of the body wherein internal destruction is their aim, it can easily turn into external destruction. If this is impossible then why have men become murderers, rapists, burglars etc, then? This time of kalyug is unpredictable and so anything is possible. In addition, God's devotees produce justice, first from their internal world, and then manage this justice into the external world, earth. Guru Gobind Singh Jee will provide this justice to the world in the near future through his Khalsa, thus his devotees. A Khalsa isn’t any old Sikh, but one who has reached Saachkhand. Only a Khalsa will be allowed in the Khalsa Raj of Punjab.

Re: India Up To It Again!

Sardar · 23 Jun 2006

"Does Akal Purukh ask any where in Granth Sahib to fight MAnmukhs?." Firstly, I would like to say "Chandra Singh" that you don't call it "Granth Saheb" It is Guru Granth Saheb Ji Mahaaraaj Ji, the only living Guru in this world and will always be. Secondly, Khalsa was created to fight injustice. Now is the time to fight these manmukhs, maybe not physically right now, but verbally and have enough evidence to support it so the world won't tink wrongly of the Sikhs. If these people still won't stop and there is no other option left, then it is right to raise the sword. Shiri Guru Gobind Singh Saheb Ji Mahaaraaj Ji said so. There's the proof!!! [%sig%]

Re: India Up To It Again!

Dogra · 23 Jun 2006

Staggers the imagination. PTE Singh is right. If the subjugation of history and people are right then how on earth can the Prime Minister Manmohan Singh be allowed???? Tell me do you think Pakistan would ever have a nonmuslim leader?? How on Earth can the Chief of the Army General Joginder Singh attain such a position???? Hate is a easy manipulator, the bare facts are ignored, just the asy ride Hate provides. Majority of people are not militants or distorters of history, most people, regardless of faith, know full well that any person who sacrifices his life like Guru Arjandevji, Guru Tegh Bahadhurji and the sons of Guru Gobind Singhji are indeed Gods Angels, sent personally by the lord during those dark times.

Re: India Up To It Again!

Dogra · 23 Jun 2006

"Senior BJP leader Sushma Swaraj on Friday came under fire of the Delhi Sikh Gurudwara Management Committee that accused her of distorting historical facts related to the martyrdom of fifth Sikh Guru Arjan Dev. " This person's foolish statements are pathetic and outrageous. History has been noted, she is condemnmed for these comments and emails will besent to BJP for a retraction. : email:[address removed]

Re: India Up To It Again!

KS · 25 Jun 2006

Pioneer News Service | New Delhi At a press conference on Friday, Sarna had accused Swaraj of distorting history by defending Mughul emperor Jehangir's Hindu courtier Chandu who had carried out Guru Arjun Singh's execution at a seminar in Taran Tarun. The Hindu Hill Rajas attacked Guru Gobind Singh Ji at Anandpur Sahib and requested Moghul troops to do the same. Gangu Brahmin was behind the betrayal of Guru Gobind Singh ji's family. Gulab Singh, Lal Singh and Tej Singh Brahmins conspired with the British to bring down the Sikh Raj. Arya Samaj and the post 1947 events. Seems to be a link with Brahmins and misfortune of Sikhs.

Re: India Up To It Again!

jason · 25 Jun 2006

Dogra baji you have to understand that the prime minister monahman singh and these other so called sikh leaders are not real sikhs but coward athiests. How can you call Prime minister Manmohan Singh a sikh when he puts a guy like tytler in his cabinet who had thousands of sikhs murdered. How can you call any of these guys sikhs who work with men who murdered thousands of sikhs, india cannot survive and go anywere if it continues to attack its minority's.

Re: India Up To It Again!

jason · 25 Jun 2006

listen chandra singh, you bin given evidence that sikhs are not hindus so don't make claims that they are, secondly the hindus did attack are guru's and payed for it when the sikhs destroyed them, thirdly you may be a BJP supporter but the party's like congress bjp and the little weak RSS are trying to destroy sikhism because you guy's feel ashamed having to be inferior to sikhs.

Re: India Up To It Again!

jason · 27 Jun 2006

chandra singh the remark i made that we are not hindus is response from the other thread and your hindu site. Secondly if you do the research you will see guru gobind singh ji was betrayed by hindus and attacked only forr the hindus to be destroyed, thirdly khalistan is a real cause and is needed to stop hindus from attacking sikhs in the most cowardly ways example having riots in hindu dominated areas against sikhs.

Re: India Up To It Again!

some1 · 27 Jun 2006

India is going to destroy the Sikhs by the books, by making our gorgeous history dissapear... its time we get a leader... Some1 with the charisma and character of Sant ji. man o man........ppl like me sit at home and are netwarriors...we need 2 unite and combat india...creat the raj of khalsa...

Re: India Up To It Again!

GuptSoulja · 28 Jun 2006

'some1' Jeeo: if you want to make a change and be chosen for such a seva then start japping so much more of Naam. Only Naam will save us and this world. First we have to save ourselves through Naam; essentially conquer and have khalsa raj over our internal world and then can we save the external. A true warrior is one who has raj over his/her body, and only that being shall be supported and helped by God.

Re: India Up To It Again!

someothergirl · 28 Jun 2006

i think if i read books by the likes of ernesto guevera i'd gain alottt..... please every1 read books about countries that have formed in similar situations as punjab, it is a dire need we educate our selves on our situation and our enemy, and the action that we are going to need to take........politically.

Re: India Up To It Again!

Dogra · 28 Jun 2006

Jason, sorry but your claims of Guru Gobind Singhji being betrayed by Hindus is just hate stirring and untrue. How can you enmasse say people of whatever religious persuasion can all think the same? The Hill rajas did betray Guruji, but how many were at Anand pur sahib 1699, how many converted, how many made their first sons Sikh? Jason lose the hate, it will only eat at you. http://www.punjabilok.com/faith/sikh/gurugobind.htm "As he grew up he was also taught the history of India, and was made aware of the socia1, religious and political situation. Right from the beginning he was also given training in music, prayers and use of weapons in accordance with the Guru traditions. Research shows that the Guru’s family had close relations with Hindus, Muslims and people of other creeds. The families of Nawab Rahim Bakhsh and Karim Bakhsh and of Raja Fateh Chand find mention in this context. All the Hindu, Muslim and Sikh children used to play and study together. They favoured the banks of Ganga for their games. After returning from Assam, Guru Tegh Bahadur ji called the whole family from Patna to Anandpur. In Phalgun month of Vikrami year 1728, Mama Kirpal started out with the whole family on a journey to Punjab. It took them through Baksar, Kashi, Prayag, Ayodhya, Lucknow, Mathura, Saharanpur and Ambala. Leading Sikhs also accompanied them. In Lakhnaur, Bhikhan Shah and Peer Arifdeen met the Guru. They reached Anandpur in the Magha month of 1729 as per Vikrami calendar."

Re: India Up To It Again!

jason · 29 Jun 2006

listen we know what the muslims did to us, but the amount of cowardly attacks done to sikhs by hindus are just as many as muslims.

Re: India Up To It Again!

jason · 01 Jul 2006

what are the rss doing right now and the bjp.

Re: India Up To It Again!

komal · 01 Jul 2006

dear chandra singh >>Can you point to any Hindu religious leader inciting HIndus against Sikhs? i think u need to read history books about sikhism that werent written by hindu's. m.a. macaullife found many letters showing hindu pandits and rajputs complaing to mughal authorities about the Guru's. do u know why? because as you said sikhi is the religous path for kalyug, and if every hindu converts to sikhi the brahmin will have no control over india ever again. but u still havent answered my question from before. if u think sikhi is the proper dharam for kalyug why havent u become an amritdhari khalsa? ur mission is take hatred u think sikhs have for the hindu and transfer it to islam and muslims. i know u think ur smart but not quite. if u want to prove that ur sincere, become a khalsa, and stop this charade. p.s. i see u have as much hate for a khalistani as u do for a muslim. u should stop this because all of hindustan will be khalistan in the future, so u might as well jump on the bandwagon.

Re: India Up To It Again!

komal · 04 Jul 2006

dear chandra singh ji >>My only concern is the maligning and blackening of Hinduism by anyone. i support u on this endeavour, but that is not what u r trying to do. ur clearly trying to show that sikhi is no different than hindu dharma. a muslim can easily take passages from the koran that are almost the same as the bani in the guru granth sahib. if ur mission is to teach people about hinduism, then u should only do that. dont give us lessons about sikhi. >>You call it hatred, i call it their true nature and identity. Both are born out of same evil i.e. Abrahmism. chandra ji, thank u for showing ur true face. ur calling all muslims evil - baba farid, pir bikhim shah, mian mir. then u call all khalistani evil. what is wrong with a khalistani? Baba Banda Singh Bahadur, Navab Kapoor Singh, and Ranjit Singh were all khalistani. they all fought for sikh raj. Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj was sent to earth to spread sikhi to the whole world. does that make him a evil prodcut of Abrahmism? in case u dont know there were a lot of Hindu brothers that fought in the khalistan movement. when i went to india two years ago i met quite a few hindu's who knew khalistani's, even fed and housed them. >>>I am afraid you're confusing me with somebody who gives a damn for your fantasies. once again chandra ji thank you for showing that u are a hateful person with no care about the future of sikhi, and only wish to bring sikhs in to the hindu dharam. werent u saying many times that sikhi is the dharam for kalyug? if so why dont u want it to be succesfull and restore dharma to india and the world? the answer is u dont want sikhi to grow, u want it to die off. >>What an idiotic Manmukhi way of thinking, typical trait of Abramic mind. im being called a manmukh by a manmukh. i guess it takes one to know one :). no this isnt a trait of a abrahamic mind. when Guru Gobind Singh ji started the khalsa some political minded brahmin leaders provoked rajput raja's and the Muslims to kill the Guru and his Sikhs because they claimed the guru was out to convert every hindu in to becoming sikhs and then taking over all of india. maybe those hindu's were the one with an idiotic manmukhi Abrahamic mind. im afraid u are the one with the fantasy if you think khalsa raj isnt going to happen. Guru Gobind Singh himself said it will be established. >>HAve you read anything other than Khalistani propaganda?. have u read anything other than RSS propoganda? since when did m.a macauliffe become a khalistani? unlike you he had true love for sikhi, and on his death bed he was reciting japji sahib. how many times have u recited japji sahib? CHandra Singh, im going to ask you a question which we all know the answer to, but i think we should read directly from u. if u think sikhi is the true dharam for kalyug, then why havent u become an amritdhari khalsa yet? maybe after this u will take some time off the tapoban web site, and come back with a new i.d. see u then.

Re: India Up To It Again!

jason · 04 Jul 2006

thanks komal i don't think chandra singh is going to be able to reply and if he does could chandra singh please answer my question rather then saying go see a docter why are the rss and bjp trying to destroy sikhism and didn't he ask which hindus are trying to destroy sikhism well here's the answer the rss and bjp.

Re: India Up To It Again!

komal · 05 Jul 2006

chandra singh >>>Do you think observing certain rituals matter to Akal Purukh?. If it doesn't matter to him why it matters to you?. Why you think i should submit to collective ommunal ego of Sikhs like you?. What i am supposed to gain out of it? Of course it matters. Akal sent out Guru's here for a reason. if you think our guru sahiban have given the proper spiritual path for kalyug attempt to follow it? instead u give a typical hankari, manmukh repsonse which is it doesnt matter. u dont need to give in to my ego, but at least u should shed ur own. >>>Dr. E. Trumpp, who had found Guru Nanak a “thorough Hindu” and his religion “a Pantheism derived directly from Hindu sources chandra ji thank u for exposing urself as another RSS wala. Dr Trumpp made this assesment with the assistance of HINDU PANDITS. sikhs refused to help him after he was smoked tobacco smoke in to the sri guru granth sahib. at first u claimed that ur not trying to prove sikhi is part of hinduism, and the guru's werent hindu but now u present an article that says Guru Nanak was indeed a hindu. its arrogant hindu's like u that make sikhs dislike other hindu's in the first place. >>>“a Pantheism derived directly from Hindu sources” Sikhi is faith with too many Indian, and Semitic strains, so its impossible to lump it in to one category. do urself a favor and read the the guru granth sahib with an open mind and open heart. for heavens sake dont scan through trying to prove that its just another hindu text. >>So, other scholars were put to work to rewrite Sikh history in the sense desired by the British. Max Arthur Macauliffe, a highly placed British administrator told the Sikhs that Hinduism was like a ‘boa constrictor of the Indian forest’ which ‘winds its opponent and finally causes it to disappear in its capacious interior’ yes, he was right. if you bother to read sikh history, especially after 1947, you will understand why they call hinduism the boa contrictor. also macauliffe was not appointed by the british, the singh sabha got him interested in Sikhi, and they helped him put together the sikh history in english. not only that but macaullife was shunned by his fellow british for his interest in Sikhi. he died all alone, and on his death bed he recited japji sahib. i said it in my previous post he had true love for sikhi. >>>he “boa constrictor” account is repeated by Khushwant Singh, who is very attached to “Sikh separate identity which we are trying to, and perhaps will go on trying to maintain” Chandra ji, i must thank u for giving everyone in tapoban forum a big laugh. Khuswant Singh attached the "Sikh seperate identity'? LOL! Khushwant has been claiming sikhs are Hindu's for years! >>>He is worried by Hindu open-mindedness: the description that follows claiming Hinduism as a religion, doesnt even make sense. ur supporting the claims that hinduism is even a religion, since it has no set practices, no rehit, just make things up as u go along. >>> It is this power of absorption of Hinduism, that it is even willing to recognize Prophet Mohammed as an Avatar of Vishnu, u may recognize the prophet as an avatar of Vishnu, but that would be a foolish move, because the prophet only believed in one God, and he certainly didnt claim to be an avatar of vishnu. once again ur article is a typical RSS work riddled with mistakes, inaccuraccies, lies, and slander (against macauliffe this time). >>>Sikhism has sprung from Hinduism, no it hasnt. its sprung from Guru's and their wish to follow the hukum of Waheguru which is to bring dharma back to the world in this kalyug. >>>Did they believe in Shahada? i.e. There is no God but Allah and Mohammad is his prophet. If no then they were not Muslims. They just had muslim names. r u trying to tell that baba farid and pir bikham shah were not Muslim, but Hindu? >>>If so then why Ranjit singh took the oath of protecting cows?. out of his tolerance and love for all people. that is why. he also made very generous donations to mosques, and encouraged muslims in their professions as musicians, artists, and physicians. that still doesnt matter because Ranjit Singh still established Sikh Raj, so that would make a Khalistani, because any Sikh that want Sikh raj is a Khalistani by ur definition. >>>Khalsa was created by Guru Govind Singh Ji but Khalistanis were seeded by Brits and plant became full blown tree with fertilizer of Missionaries & petro dollar. Once again, dear chandra, u r incorrect. the brits did not "plant' any khalistani, because it is in the very make up of a khalsa to wish that sikhi would spread around the world. which missionary are u referring to? macauliffe? he was not a missionary, but a civil servant. I think the genius RSS has confused macauliffe with w.h. mcleod who is not very popular among most Sikhs. >>You are talking politics and it has its own dimensions. thats ENTIRELY what u are talking about. u dont have an ounce of spirituality in u. ur motives are know to all of us now.... u are trying to prove(very unsuccesfully) that sikhs are hindu, and that sikhi is part of Hinduism. ur next motive is to spread hate and venom against Muslims, which is quite cheap and vulgar of u. i think u lead a very unfulfilling life, which why ur on an internet board spreading ur vile politics. i think u should take ur free time reading the ved and being a proper hindu. Fateh.

Re: India Up To It Again!

komal · 05 Jul 2006

chandra, one thing i want to add. since u clearly have no care and love for the sikh religion, and only wish to distort it and demean its followers, i think u should stop posting here, because ur intentions dont come close to matching ours. there must be many forums with people of ur character. u should join them.

Re: India Up To It Again!

jason · 06 Jul 2006

what do you mean the british set up the game plan to make sikhs think that hindus are trying to destroy the sikh religion the rss and bjp are clearly trying to destroy the sikh religion and have every sikh become a hindu read the article on top of the thread which shows evidence of what the rss is trying to do, it's because of hindus like these that drive sikhs to become khalistani's. Chandra singh do you personally believe sikhs are a branch of hinduism or a seperate religion. Chandra singh what is your opinion on the sikh religion. I doubt now he'll come back to answer any questions

Re: India Up To It Again!

komal · 06 Jul 2006

chandra singh >>>Here is a reminder for the people like you who are possesed by their communal ego and use Sikhi to dominate and controll others. ur missing the point. i do not care if u want to become a sikh or not, nor sikhs wish to dominate others. but u keep harping about being a gurmukh and claiming to love sikhism, if that is the case why not follow the sikh path? u still wont give an answer. >>>Regarding Akal Purukh sending (pretty much like Abrahamic god sending prophets) Guruji, did they ever claimed that they have been sent by Akal Purukh?. yes, dear friend. the guru's made several comments about relaying the word of waheguru. for ex. http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=Page&Param=722&english=t&id=31081#l31081 jaisee mai aavai khasam kee banee taisrhaa karee gi-aan vay laalo. As the Word of the Forgiving Lord comes to me, so do I express it, O Lalo. if that isnt good enough for u, let me refer to Guru Gobind Singh ji, and what he wrote in Bachitar Natak. its starts here, and goes on for several pages http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=132 When the Lord ordered me, I was born in this Iron age. I had no desire to come, because I was totally absorbed in devotion for the Holy feet of the Lord. But the Lord made me understand His Will and sent me in this world with the following words.................. I have adopted you as my son and hath created you for the propagation of the path "You go therefore for the spread of Dharma (righteousness) and cause people to retrace their steps from evil actions". guru ji goes on to say .... For this reason the Lord sent me and I was born in this world....Whatever the Lord said, I am repeating the same unto you, I do not bear enmity with anyone....Whatever the Lord of the world said, I say the same unto you, I cannot remain silent in this abode of death. >>>You mean indulging in rituals amount to following it?. Don't you know that actions are performed at two levels i.e. mental, physical. And one at mental level is always suprior to the one at physical level the path the guru has given us arent useless rituals, u arrogant windbag. that is just awful disrepect! yes actions are performed at mental and physical levels, yes the mental is superior, and u are nowhere near reaching the mental level, otherwise u wouldnt be wasting time with ur distortion of sikhi, and spreading hatred. i said it before, uve exposed ur true self to us. >>First understand what Manmukh & Gurumukh stand for?. You have no idea about these words. yes i do. dont come to a sikh site, and pretend to know more about our religion that we do. uve been shown to be incorrect so many times, yet u continue to show what great saint u are. i must commend u for ur persistence. >> You think that just by dressing yourself in a particular style one becomes Gurumukh. Being Gurumukh is a state of conciousness achived after the destruction of mind. the dress is very importan part. if it wasnt important to keep our kes then our guru's wouldnt have told us to do so. all the spiritual masters whether in middle east, india, or the orient kept their kes intact, yet u regard it as useless. shame. >>>So your problem remains same i.e. you can't withstand anyone who refuses to submit to your collective ego?. my only problem is that u trying to lecture and deceive us when ur knowledge of sikhi is superficial at best. how many times have u been proven wrong? its hard to keep count. >>>Do you remember one couplet from Guru Nanak Devji Singh na chale lehade, Sant na Chale Jamat Lions never seen in pack and Self realized Saints never found in groups. chandra, do not flatter urself. ur not a saint, nor a lion. more like a hyena, with deception and hate on ur mind. >>I only object to Hindu bashing and villification. If you can live without it you won't see my face. i also object. i also object to what uve been doing on this website, so give that a rest. >>>Where is semetic strain? i showed u that in the earlier part of this post. i noticed any time something about sikhism doesnt jibe with hindu philosophy, u lose it and call it an abrahmic/british influence. >>>So his attachment to seperate sikh identity is not born out of love for Sikhismn but his loyality to modern west so that he can weaken united native resposne to west by creating wedge among Hindus & Sikhs. u jsut dont know what u are going on about. if u read any interview of khushwant singh, he clearly states sikhi is based on vedantic principles, and that japji is a commentary on the vedas and upanisads. ur know-it-all attitude is laughable because u dont know much, which has been and will continue to be proven over and over. >>>Again i just quoted KS, its not my opinion. if its not ur opinion then why post it?!!!! acutally most of these opinions arent even urs but theyre just an unoriginal copy and paste. some of ur opinions ive read in articles elsewhere online. >>>Why don't you answer my question i.e. did they believe in Sahada?. most probably they did. >>> So called modern Khalsitnis are agents of Abrahamism. blah, blah. lol, u will never tire with this abrahamism stuff will u? >>>The Ek OMkãr should not be converted into Allah. its not ek omkar. it is EK OANKAR, or even more proper EK OANGKAR. in case u dont Allah simply means "the God". just one God, Ek. Allah, Raam, Brahma its the same. dont take my word for it, Guru Arjan wrote - The Muslim God Allah and the Hindu God Paarbrahm are one and the same. it seems our beloved Guru also was a victim of the Abrhamic influence. Too Chandra Singh wasnt around to show him the way. >>>>The categories provided by a British civil servant still remains the thought equipment of modern sikh scholars ultimately degenrating into Khalistan movement those werent just his thoughts, but also of contemporary Sikhs. i think on this site u will find some discussions about the confrontation sikhs of that time had with the Arya Samaj, who made claims quite similar to u. >>Sikhism is an Indic spiritual system rooted in Dharma without any amount of overlap with cults of devil worship ie. Chrsitianity & Islam. sorry to burst ur bubbble, but ive provided the bani of the Guru's which shows that their path did share things in common with the semitic faiths. >>The path shown by great Gurus if followed judicioulsy leads to the self-realization in the form of merger with Wahe guru i.e. Brahmn. yes Waheguru, ie Brahm, ie Allah, as stated but Guru Arjan. once again i must ask u if you think the path of the Guru's is the proper one, why dont u follow it? why do u call it a bunch of useless rituals?? >>>in this interview, Bhindranwale had said that Sikhism “was a revealed religion; and the Sikhs were people of the Book.” Yes sikhi is a revealed faith, and i provided numerous proofs. Sant Bhindranwale had a masterful knowledge of gurbani. not just that but he was at a spiritual level that would amaze. if you are ever lucky to come in contact with spiritually enlightened person, ask them and ull find out for urself.

Re: India Up To It Again!

komal · 08 Jul 2006

chandra singh >>But this is not about prophetism & revealation. Guru Nanak is clearly stating that the words that he speaks are coming straight from Waheguru. as usual u return to ur typical tactic when u are cornered which is to resort to an extravagant vocabulary contest. once again u are showing ur disrespect to the guru by trying to distort his bani. >>>For all that you have quoted i can claim Guru Govind Singh ji to be an Avatari Purush. no u cant claim this! u r not Guru Gobind Singh!! guru ji clearly stated that waheguru, brahma, allah, god, etc. claimed the guru as his son and wanted him to spread the dharam God deemed appropriate for this kalyug. once again in desperation u resort ur vocabulary contest. the words of the guru make it quite clear who sent him to the world, and why. >>If that is so why you guys mock hindus for follwoing rituals?. How come your rituals are useful while that of Hindus are useless?. what is this you guys business? yes some sikhs will mock hindus for their beliefs and that is atrocious. these sikhs and people like u should learn to respect and tolerate the beliefs of others. but still doing naam simran, and reciting nitnem daily is going to do a lot more to cleanse ur soul than making offerings to idols, or paying a brahmin priest to pray for them, and also for sikhs doing nitnem and naam simran is a lot better than going to gurdwara every sunday without even immersing themselves in bani just because its part of their weekly schedule. >>You have done nothing other then indulge in ad-hominem attack and shouting wolf. Your whole logic has been that since i have not converted to Sikh sect so i don't know anything. now look who is talking. u are the chap who has called people manmukhs, idiots, evil abrahamics, and requested people go see a head shrink. u deem urself worthy of respect yet dont give any. the reason u dont know anything about sikhi RELIGION, not sect, is because u have not made an honest effort to learn about it. the things u claim have already been posted elsewhere on the internet. >>I am talking about Allah of Quran as revealed to Mohammad. If you have cared to study Quran you will know that he is distictivly different from the God of Guru Granth Sahibji. i have a feeling u have studied the quran as closely as the guru granth sahib and that says it all. u said the God in the guru granth sahib is the same as brahma, but not allah. Guru Arjan made a fool out of u, when he said allah and Paarbrahm are one and the same!! ur only answer is that allah is only mentioned x number of times ram, gobind etc are mentioned x number of times (i read this in an RSS manual too), but fact remains allah and parbrahm are the same according to the guru. as usual u resort to sidetracking and playing word games, and offer nothing of substance. besides the God described in Guru granth sahib isnt completely as mentioned in previous Indian texts. the guru's were above copy and pasting. it is a fact that sikhi is revealed, and it has aspects of it that are related to to traditional indian beliefs, and semitic beliefs. >>As i have said truth of Sikhism is the truth of Upnishads so why i would detest Sikhi and distort it?. sikhi is the truth of the upanisad, vedas, and quran. a hindu and muslim will find sikhi compatible with their own faith. just so u know guru nanak dev never bothered to learn sanskrit, so to say his bani is simply a commentary of or inspired by the vedas and upanisads would be wholly incorrect. >>He was mere a Abrahmic fanatic with garb of Sikhism. if u read more the guru granth sahib more closely u will begin to accuse the guru's of being abrahamic fanatics, and traitors to bharat mata, because their philosophy is not completely in line with older indian traditions. the only fanatic here is u, who is unwilling to accept that the bani of the guru as it is, and trying to twist to comfort his petty ego. Now chandra singh, let me get to the crux of the matter. as they say its time to put ur money where ur mouth is. u said on many occasions sikhi is the path for kalyug. if that is the case u should FOLLOW the path of dharma,otherwise ur words are not worth trusting. u talked the talk now walk the walk. in order to be a sikh one must follow the hukum of our 10 guru sahib, which means u take amrit from panj piare which is a blessing of the guru to us manmukhs. keep ur kes uncut, and carry ur kirpan ( be a shastardhari and kesadhari as our guru wanted, and as Krishna and Ram Chander were in previous yugs, and yes even Prophet Muhammad), naam jaap waheguru, recite ur nitnem daily. these acts cleanse ur soul and make u a real gurmukh, not studying sikh scriptures to show it is no different than hindu scriptures and has nothing in common with the quran. this is nothing more than an act of a politician who uses spirituality to further his own cause. thus far uve only been a politician, now we will see if u are ready to back ur claim of wanting to be a gurmukh. do not resort to typical answer "oh ur an idiot manmukh. why should i follow useless rituals like keeping kes, reciting bani, etc." this is nothing more than a cowardly answer, insulting to the hukum of our guru, and shows that u find true sikhi to be repellant to ur instincts. u seem unwilling to be a good sikh, unable to be a good hindu, why dont u first try to be a good human being first? since uve come here i noticed there hasnt been an ounce of spirituality, love, or respect in posts. just hate, distortion, and intolerance (u say even the RSS is too tolerant for u!!) so now here is the question. since u regard the sikh religion to be the dharma of the kalyug, will u follow the USEFULL path the guru has given to us? yes or no? if not, give us a straight answer why. NOTE to the admin: until chandra gives an honest answer to this question, i dont think any of his messages should be allowed to be posted on this message board. it should be a privilege to post here, not a place for hateful low self esteem individuals to act out their issues online.

Re: India Up To It Again!

jason · 09 Jul 2006

chandra singh do you believe sikhs are hindus, another question is the rss trying to get sikhs to believe they are hindus because they themselves are to scared to fight islam and pakistan, and can you show me hinduism is not a made up myth.

Re: India Up To It Again!

komal · 15 Jul 2006

hello chandra singh it is completely futile to have any discussion with u. u didnt give one reasonable answer to any of my questions just resorting to another game of vocabulary gymnastics, attacking islam, concept of khalsa raj, and making very weak and unsuccesful attempts to distort guru bani to ur suit ur fanatical needs. u are a complete fraud, as shown by ur refusal to once again answer whether u will become a sikh since u said urself that the path of guru is the proper spiritual path for kalyug. u just add more and more substance to our belief about ur intentions.

Re: India Up To It Again!

jason · 21 Jul 2006

why did hindu gods have castes and fight war's witheachother if their all one god, and why did hindu gods have war's at all if their their all belong to ram.

Re: India Up To It Again!

komal · 22 Jul 2006

hi chandra ur question was >>>>>Your above invitation/surmon makes sense only if the 10 Guru Sahib were the only one who realized the Akal. Are you saying that Tukaram, Mirabai, Tulsidas, Surdas, RamKrishna Paramhans etc did not merge into the Akal/Brahmn?. If no then you are a Abrahamic and need to see the light and if yes then following the path shown by them too will lead to Akal/Brahmn. So why should i listen to your surmon/invitation?. i believe mirabai, tukaram, surdas were great saints, and had amazing devotion, but by sikh standards in order to merge with waheguru u need to be in complete devotion with waheguru. there are five spiritual regions (or khands), and to reach the highest spiritual region, sach kand, then a person must devote themselves to waheguru only. there was a discussion about this a few months ago, about who goes to which khand. mirabai was a devotee of krishna and was at a spiritual level most of us would be extrememly lucky to reach, but i couldnt say she reached the state of sach kand, because 1) its impossible for either one of us to know, and 2) as i mentioned before, the guru said in order to merge in waheguru in sach kand, one must be devoted to waheguru. now dont interpret me saying that she wasnt up to par of a sikh, since most sikhs wont be blessed enough to reach sach kand. many sikhs believe that in order to reach sach khand one must be a gursikh, because ive heard of non sikhs who werebrahm giani's and they must surely be in sach kand. for example, even though he never formally became a sikh, but still kept his kes and recited japji sahib daily, Rabindranath Tagore was a brahm giani. from what ive been told the people who were at the spiritual level of the guru's were ram chander, krishna, and a pir from punjab who's name i cant remember at the moment.

Re: India Up To It Again!

sarbloh · 22 Jul 2006

<> In japji sahib,guru ji says that just by listening to Gurmat Naam,one can reach the levels of shiv brahma etc. Moreover,gurbani states that all these avatars drowned in this world ocean,so how can there devotess be carried across. No one has reached sachkhand without Guru Nanak and no one will ever reach sachkhand without Guru Nanak.So dont waste ur time debating with Mr Chandra and japp Naam instead. Mr Chandra doesnt possess the Gurmat Naam and hence spends his breaths on these debates,but we sikhs shud be smart enough. KHALSA RAAJ is coming and all the debaters like chandra singh or the RSS brothers will see it in the near future. RAAJ KAREGA KHALSA KHALISTAN ZINDABAD

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 24 Jul 2006

chandra here is just one shabad from our guru sahib describing the hindus [gurbani] Awju nwmy bITlu dyiKAw mUrK ko smJwaU ry ] rhwau ] [/gurbani] aaj naamae beet(h)al dhaekhiaa moorakh ko samajhaaoo rae || rehaao || Today, Naam Dayv saw the Lord, and so I will instruct the ignorant. ||Pause|| [gurbani]pWfy qumrI gwieqRI loDy kw Kyqu KwqI QI ][/gurbani] paa(n)ddae thumaree gaaeithree lodhhae kaa khaeth khaathee thhee || O Pandit, O religious scholar, your Gayatri was grazing in the fields. [gurbani]lY kir Tygw tgrI qorI lWgq lWgq jwqI QI ]1][/gurbani] lai kar t(h)aegaa ttagaree thoree laa(n)gath laa(n)gath jaathee thhee ||1|| Taking a stick, the farmer broke its leg, and now it walks with a limp. ||1|| [gurbani]pWfy qumrw mhwdyau Dauly bld ciVAw Awvqu dyiKAw Qw ][/gurbani] paa(n)ddae thumaraa mehaadhaeo dhhoulae baladh charriaa aavath dhaekhiaa thhaa || O Pandit, I saw your great god Shiva, riding along on a white bull. [gurbani]modI ky Gr Kwxw pwkw vw kw lVkw mwirAw Qw ]2][/gurbani] modhee kae ghar khaanaa paakaa vaa kaa larrakaa maariaa thhaa ||2|| In the merchant's house, a banquet was prepared for him - he killed the merchant's son. ||2|| [gurbani]pWfy qumrw rwmcMdu so BI Awvqu dyiKAw Qw ][/gurbani] paa(n)ddae thumaraa raamacha(n)dh so bhee aavath dhaekhiaa thhaa || O Pandit, I saw your Raam Chand coming too [gurbani]rwvn syqI srbr hoeI Gr kI joie gvweI QI ]3][/gurbani] raavan saethee sarabar hoee ghar kee joe gavaaee thhee ||3|| ; he lost his wife, fighting a war against Raawan. ||3||

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 25 Jul 2006

Chandra you have a inflated ego and you are opinionated calling peoples thinking filth. Maybe you know what filth is as you may already possess it. Tell me one thing are you a Hindu? or do you consider yourself a Hindu? Donot beat around the bush give an answer in black and white / yes or no?

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 25 Jul 2006

"In japji sahib,guru ji says that just by listening to Gurmat Naam,one can reach the levels of shiv brahma etc. Moreover,gurbani states that all these avatars drowned in this world ocean,so how can there devotess be carried across." Same way, as you reach Sachkhand by worshipping the "roopa (form)" of Guru Nanak Devji. Chandra Sikhs worship Akalpurakh. Is that news to you? Guru Nanak SAHIB was our Guru and not an object of worship. Now dont ask me what a guru is? So HINDOO Avtaars did drown as gurbani tells us? Do you agree? And also find the meaning of word CHANDRA in punjabi. Describes you in entirety.

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 25 Jul 2006

The Indians call us terrorists, but our fight is for our own nation. We have taken to the path of violence to free our motherland from India. War is not our hobby. It is our compulsion. We call the land between the Ghaghar River and the Chenab our own and fight for it. Before 1849, the Khalsa owned all this land so how are we terrorists? We are fighting for the land that the Brahmins took from us by cheating, after the British left. Brahmins = Hindu priests class

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 25 Jul 2006

You have been using negative words against people and labelling their thinking filthy now you cry about abuse? Why do you want me do define a hindu do you not understand? Or maybe hindu word does not have any meaning??? If you want to be a specific hindu like hindu following krishna or hindu of shiv or hindu of ram, or hindu following kali mata then plainly say so. Do not play word games So what are you eh!!! ?!?!?!?

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 26 Jul 2006

Now we are clear that you are Hindu can you tell me the origin of the word Hindu?

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 26 Jul 2006

Did you not read the question??? I repeat it again Can you tell me the origin of the word Hindu?

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 26 Jul 2006

In essence the religion you propose has its name given to it by Arabs?

Re: India Up To It Again!

**_ · 26 Jul 2006

anjaan He said Iranians not Arabs. They followed the same religion as Indians... You better check yourself before you wreck yourself

Re: India Up To It Again!

PTE SINGH · 27 Jul 2006

'In essence the religion you propose has its name given to it by Arabs?' I think Anjaan should be given the award for most sophisticated argument. In case you missed it Anjaan, thats me being sarcastic.

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 27 Jul 2006

****** the absence of the term Hindu does not prove the non-existence of a concept later enunciated as “Hindu Dharma”. Hinduism can flourish without bothering about where it got the name form or who gave that name?. ****** That is where sikhi is different from hinduism. As is clear from chandras response hindu system of today is a mish mash of everything from pathar(stone) puja, to planet puja to animal puja to human puja to river puja and pittar puja and a name for that system which hindus adopted from foreigners. Is it not? PTE Singh thanks for compliments [gurbani] nh pMifqu nh cquru isAwnw ] [/gurbani]

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 27 Jul 2006

SO now its a waste of time when asked a question if hinudism is not a mish mash of beliefs and practices? I am here to listen my friend. That is the reason you dont see any assumptions from my side whereas its you who is labeling people and their responses. ******* "That is where sikhi is different from hinduism." As far as final goal is concerned there is no difference. ******** The way is different. So is it a mish mash?

Re: India Up To It Again!

wpojk · 27 Jul 2006

_______________________________________________ "As is clear from chandras response hindu system of today is a mish mash of everything from pathar(stone) puja, to planet puja to animal puja to human puja to river puja and pittar puja and a name for that system which hindus adopted from foreigners." _______________________________________________ I should really take offense of this statement but I won't. In fact I feel sorry for you anjaan - is this how much respect you have for one of the oldest spiritual systems in the world? You have not done any favours for yourself or the Sikh community. By making such a statement you look like a narrow minded bigot. It is not your fault though, this is the type of stuff they preach in Gurudwaras in the west these days i.e. to humiliate Hinduism and 'big-up' Sikhi....but don't worry we are strong enough to bear it.. We have been able to bear it from the Christians, the Muslims, secularists, communists, scientists and now you guys and the funny thing is we don't have to make death threats about this. [%sig%]

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 27 Jul 2006

I am not from the west so get that out of your head. I have not made any death threats either so what are you talking about? Tell me which statement of mine bigs up sikhi? If you think the following statement humiliates the Hindus then let me know if it is untrue? ''pathar(stone) puja, to planet puja to animal puja to human puja to river puja and pittar puja and a name for that system which hindus adopted from foreigners."

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 28 Jul 2006

******** But again your Abrahamic mind will think he was mere a Prophet and Akal is a bloot thirsty tyrant, extra cosmic God. There is nothing in Akal’s creation which can partake of God’s divinity. The elements and forces of Nature are devoid of any divinity whatsoever. The sky is empty space, and the Sun and the Moon and the Stars are only bright spots in that sky. Matter is absolutely material, and animals and birds are mere brutes unless they are domesticated when they show some improvement. Trees are timber, and the flowers embody no more than colour and fragrance. Air and water and fire and earth are what they are, and point to nothing beyond. It is an unpardonable folly and a cardinal sin for man to fancy that he shares even an iota of God’s divinity. So Banis like: kirpaa kar kai aapnee aapay la-ay samaa-ay jee-o. ||21|| Showering His Mercy, He has blended me into Himself. ||21|| would be considered blasphemy punishble by death. ************ Those are all your assumptions / imaginations and reading those one begins realize that you are opinionated. ********** "let me know if it is untrue? ''pathar(stone) puja, to planet puja to animal puja to human puja to river puja and pittar puja and a name for that system which hindus adopted from foreigners."" It is true but the menaing is not what you have learnt from father John. Hindus practice symbolicaly what was taught by Sri Guru Nanak DevJi. ************* So now I have the oppurtunity to hear from Chandra Pandit how river puja and pittar puja help you spiritually as i see its an integral part of mish mash which you promote as Indic Spirtual system. Coming to teachings of Guru Nanak Sahib Guru Nanak never taught stone puja did he? How about the your sacred thread of the BAMANS eh??!!! Now you will say that Guru Nanak used to wear the janeu??? Did he teach you pittar puja and offer water to the sun. Or was he more interested in watering his fields in the west? In contrast to your assumptions about my beliefs my Guru says as follows [gurbani] pwqI qorY mwilnI pwqI pwqI jIau ] ijsu pwhn kau pwqI qorY so pwhn inrjIau ]1] BUlI mwlnI hY eyau ] siqguru jwgqw hY dyau ]1] rhwau ] bRhmu pwqI ibsnu fwrI PUl sMkrdyau ] qIin dyv pRqiK qorih krih iks kI syau ]2] pwKwn giF kY mUriq kIn@I dy kY CwqI pwau ] jy eyh mUriq swcI hY qau gVHxhwry Kwau ]3] Bwqu pihiq Aru lwpsI krkrw kwswru ] Bognhwry BoigAw iesu mUriq ky muK Cwru ]4] mwilin BUlI jgu Bulwnw hm Bulwny nwih ] khu kbIr hm rwm rwKy ik®pw kir hir rwie ]5]1]14] [/gurbani] The names used herein are not your ram who lost his wife or the shiva who rode the white bull or the vishnu depicted as the dark skinned man with four arms

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 28 Jul 2006

I have qouted from gurbani and you cannot read it. Kindly install gurbani font.

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 28 Jul 2006

Instead of coming out with verbal diarohea you should concentrate on the issues. ******** So worshipping them is not wrong as long as you are concious of reality behind them. ******** Sikh Gurus have made the Sikhs aware that this is not the reality and there is no use worshipping the sun the rivers the stones the animals so that people break free from the rituals and get in touch with reality rather than get lost in rituals. you still have not answered the following ''how river puja, pathar puja and pittar puja help you spiritually as its an integral part of the mish mash'' You say that hindu BAMANS were wrong in offering water. Did hindus stop offering water to the sun when guru sahib told them that this will not reach NO one?? Do you personally think you have gained any spiritual benefits out of river puja, pathar puja, pittar puja and gau mata (cow) puja??? ****** Boy!, I am not believer. ****** the following pangti tells about non-believers who think they are right and if THEY find substance ONLY then it is right otherwise it is rubbish. [gurbani]swkq nr siqguru nhI kIAw qy bymuK hir BrmwvYgo ][/gurbani]

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 28 Jul 2006

Another request to Chandra Can you kindly refrain from refering to christianity time and again. More over you commented on my foot note to the Shabad (which you were not even able to read) how immature is that. It shows you have one track closed mind and you call other people narrow minded and having communal ego. Try to deal with issues rather than ranting out. Donot worry I will answer all issues raised by you based on gurbani. I have opened a new thread on Idol worship kindly explain in their how idol worship helps one spiritually and what is the status of idol worship in Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 29 Jul 2006

******** "More over you commented on my foot note to the Shabad (which you were not even able to read) how immature is that." Can you read it as it appears in bold in your post?. ******** Its upto you to read. You have not read it as you said yourself. It is childish to comment on something which referes to a source which you havenot read.

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 30 Jul 2006

non believer = sakat the gurbani pangti you are using to justify tree worship does not point to tree worship it is there to say that there is life and akal purakh in the trees where as the stone is lifeless. by pulling out the living flowers from the trees and putting them on the stone whose puja are you trying to do its upto hindus to decide what to worship but sikh teachings tell us that the worship which the hindus do is not of much benefit. why dont you worship your own excreta as it is also a part of your environment and going by your logic you should be worshiping it. may be some years down the line hindu system would evolve and include excreat worship in the temples. but its not ok for sikhs to worship the objects (as hindus do) because sikhs worship the creator of the objects see the difference?!?!?!?!?!?

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 31 Jul 2006

List your questions

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 31 Jul 2006

chandra wrote ****** Could you reply to my question on Nam Dayv in black and white? NAm Dayv accepts the authority of Gita: paranvai naamaa i-o kahai geetaa. ||5||2||6|| Thus prays Naam Dayv, and so says the Gita as well. ||5||2||6|| *********** It is not one above the other. Namdev ji says that the Gita says it aswell. If I agree with you on one point that doesnot mean that I have accepted your AUTHORITY (true in vice versa aswell) Namdev Ji is not qouting from Gita and has not taken Gita as his guru. Has He? chandra wrote ******* an-din naachai sakat nivaarai siv ghar need na ho-ee. One who dances night and day, and banishes Shakti's Maya, enters the House of the Lord Shiva, where there is no sleep. ******* [gurbani]Avil Alh nUru aupwieAw kudriq ky sB bMdy ][/gurbani] Going by your logic then Allah is a part of Indic Spiritual System aswell? If you say that Shiv and Ram and vishnu are as mentioned in Hindu texts then Allah must the one as mentioned in Islam?

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 31 Jul 2006

******* "the gurbani pangti you are using to justify tree worship does not point to tree worship it is there to say that there is life and akal purakh in the trees where as the stone is lifeless." Your explanation is not consistent with the teachings of Guruji that Lord is all pervasive. If I accept your explanation then what do i do to ****** [gurbani]ijsu pwhn kau pwqI qorY so pwhn inrjIau [/gurbani] You are taking it in wrong context Read the pangti and then read what i said. I did NOT say there is NO akal purakh in the stone. **** "why dont you worship your own excreta as it is also a part of your environment and going by your logic you should be worshiping it. may be some years down the line hindu system would evolve and include excreat worship in the temples." **** You say that the formless is everywhere. and the idols are mere symbols. Why are idols preferable symbols and not your excreta a symbol of the formless as formless is everywhere? Note: Gurbani declares that the formless is all prevasive ***** "but its not ok for sikhs to worship the objects (as hindus do) because sikhs worship the creator of the objects see the difference?!?!?!?!?!? ****** It is your problem that you dont fully agree to what gurbani says and try just take portions which suit you. See ਮੂਲੁ here? moolay comes from ਮੂਲੁ

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 01 Aug 2006

****** "See ਮੂਲੁ here? moolay comes from ਮੂਲੁ" I know that . Originally it comes sanskrit. ***** Earlier it was primal lord for you wasnt it?

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 01 Aug 2006

******* DO YOU AGREE THAT CREATOR & CREATION ARE ONE AND SAME? ANY SEPERATION IS DUE TO MAYA (DUALITY) IN THE MIND OF ONE WHO IS SEEING? ***** [gurbani]ilv CuVkI lgI iqRsnw mwieAw Amru vrqwieAw ] eyh mwieAw ijqu hir ivsrY mohu aupjY Bwau dUjw lwieAw ] khY nwnku gur prswdI ijnw ilv lwgI iqnI ivcy mwieAw pwieAw ]29] [/gurbani]

Re: India Up To It Again!

anjaan · 02 Aug 2006

now answer my question why is stone preferable as to moorti over your own excreta?