I stand by what I said: Sushma
Mehtab Singh · 24 Jun 2006
http://www.samachar.com/showurl.htm?rurl=http://www.expressindia.com/fullstory.php?newsid=69910&headline=Sikh~Remarks:~I~stand~by~what~I~said:~Sushma
[u]I stand by what I said: Sushma[/u]
Press Trust of India
New Delhi, June 24: Under attack from pro-Congress Sikh religious leaders here for her comments on the martyrdom of Guru Arjan Dev, senior BJP leader Sushma Swaraj said she stood by her remarks that a Hindu courtier had little role in the execution of the fifth Guru ordered by Emperor Jehangir.
She also received support from Sikh scholars who described Jehangir's courtier Chandu as a "small fry" behind the Guru's execution.
"I did not concoct a story. I quoted excerpts from a book, 'Pancham Guru, Jeevani Guru Arjan Dev', by Satbir Singh. It clearly states that Jehangir was primarily responsible for the execution of Guru Arjan Dev as Sikhism was becoming popular fast because of its principles and teachings," Swaraj said.
Her comments came in the wake of Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee (DSGMC) Chief Harvinder Singh Sarna accusing her of distorting historical facts related to the martyrdom.
"Is Sarna trying to belittle such a great sacrifice by linking it to a tiny courtier like Chandu who had some grudge against the Guru because he turned down a matrimonial proposal from him for the Guru's son," Swaraj said.
Sikh scholars also endorsed Swaraj's views, which she had expressed at Tarn Taran during a martyrdom anniversary event that Jehangir had his own reasons for ordering the execution.
"In a way she is right. There was a war of succession and Jehangir had to take a hardline to remain in power," Bhai Veer Singh Sahitya Sadan Director Mohinder Singh said.
In his comments, columnist Mahip Singh quoted excerpts from Jehangir's autobiography in which the Mughal emperor mentioned why he ordered the execution.
"In Tuzuk-i-Jehangiri, the emperor himself has used highly disparaging remarks against Sikhism and pledged to wipe it out," Singh said.
Akali parties also threw their weight behind Swaraj as they criticised the DSGMC Chief for what they called "politicising" the Guru's sacrifice.
"The martyrdom was not an ordinary event. It should be seen in its right perspective. There's no denying that it was the Mughal emperor who put the Guru to death," Akali Dal (Panthak) leader Manjit Singh, also a DSGMC member, said.
The Shiromani Akali Dal also accused the DSGMC of attempts to create a controversy out of Swaraj's remarks.
"Political differences are one thing, but history is another. It's sacrosanct. The DSGMC has tried to politicise a great sacrifice," SAD general secretary Onkar Singh Thapar said.
[%sig%]
Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Jun 2006
chandu had the same role as the evil and harami JHOOTHANAND in Suba Sarhand's Darbaar....they provided the "ammunition"...but had no actual power to do anything...
Shushma is backed by no other than Principal Satbir Singh.
Jarnail Singh
Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma
fresno sikh · 26 Jun 2006
SSAKAL
All you Chandu supporters should join the BJP and RSS just like some the spineless leader of the sikh community. According to Kavi Santokh Singh when Jhangir left for kashmir from Lahore he told Chandu to keep them with him and show him respect and he will clarify all the matters with Guruji when he comes back. But before Jhangir came back from Kashmir Guruji was already tortured and executed by Chandu orders. Few years later Jhangir handed Chandu over to Guru Hargobind ji and was taken around with his face balckened around town and recieved a blow on his head from the same person Chandu got hot sand poured over Guruji by which he died.
Chandu was the main cause of Gurujis death. I would recommend fellow sikhs to read tikka of Kavi santokh singh jis Gur Partap Suraj by Sodhi Teja singh which is in very simple punjabi.
Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma
Mehtab Singh · 03 Jul 2006
I just have a question in mind. Who do we trust more? A Sikh like Kavi Santokh Singh or a tyrant like Jahangir?
Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma
Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006
1) The reason for shahidi of Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee Maharaaj was much more than merely Chandu. If we believe that Siri Guru jee got shaheed just because of his personal family problem with Chandu, then he cannot be classified as the great shahid he is now.
2) By the same token, it does not mean that Chandu did not exist or that he did not play a role in the shahidi of Guru Sahib. He was a small pawn but the actual reasons for Guru Sahib's shahidi are beyond our understanding.
3) Sheikh Sarhindi the fundamentalist Mujaddid of Naqashbandi order of Islam played a very active role in Guru Sahib's shahidi. He and his chela Murtaza Khan (or whatever his name was) were instrumental in pursuading Jahangir to take this extreme step of doing shahidi of Guru Sahib.
4) Just because Chandu did what he did or Gangu deceived Sahibzade does not mean that the whole of Hindu quom is bad. This kind of thinking is not befitting for a Gursikh. Chandu did not play the negative role he played because he was opposing Guru Sahib as a Hindu but he did so because of his personal problem with Guru Sahib. So to derive that all Hindus are bad because of Chandu or Gangu is anti-Gurmat thinking.
5) Apart from the main reason that Jahangir wrote in his autobiography, there were many spiritual reasons too for Guru Sahib's shahidi. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written that some of these reasons cannot be explained in this physical world.
Kulbir Singh