Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

I stand by what I said: Sushma

I stand by what I said: Sushma

Mehtab Singh · 24 Jun 2006

http://www.samachar.com/showurl.htm?rurl=http://www.expressindia.com/fullstory.php?newsid=69910&headline=Sikh~Remarks:~I~stand~by~what~I~said:~Sushma [u]I stand by what I said: Sushma[/u] Press Trust of India New Delhi, June 24: Under attack from pro-Congress Sikh religious leaders here for her comments on the martyrdom of Guru Arjan Dev, senior BJP leader Sushma Swaraj said she stood by her remarks that a Hindu courtier had little role in the execution of the fifth Guru ordered by Emperor Jehangir. She also received support from Sikh scholars who described Jehangir's courtier Chandu as a "small fry" behind the Guru's execution. "I did not concoct a story. I quoted excerpts from a book, 'Pancham Guru, Jeevani Guru Arjan Dev', by Satbir Singh. It clearly states that Jehangir was primarily responsible for the execution of Guru Arjan Dev as Sikhism was becoming popular fast because of its principles and teachings," Swaraj said. Her comments came in the wake of Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee (DSGMC) Chief Harvinder Singh Sarna accusing her of distorting historical facts related to the martyrdom. "Is Sarna trying to belittle such a great sacrifice by linking it to a tiny courtier like Chandu who had some grudge against the Guru because he turned down a matrimonial proposal from him for the Guru's son," Swaraj said. Sikh scholars also endorsed Swaraj's views, which she had expressed at Tarn Taran during a martyrdom anniversary event that Jehangir had his own reasons for ordering the execution. "In a way she is right. There was a war of succession and Jehangir had to take a hardline to remain in power," Bhai Veer Singh Sahitya Sadan Director Mohinder Singh said. In his comments, columnist Mahip Singh quoted excerpts from Jehangir's autobiography in which the Mughal emperor mentioned why he ordered the execution. "In Tuzuk-i-Jehangiri, the emperor himself has used highly disparaging remarks against Sikhism and pledged to wipe it out," Singh said. Akali parties also threw their weight behind Swaraj as they criticised the DSGMC Chief for what they called "politicising" the Guru's sacrifice. "The martyrdom was not an ordinary event. It should be seen in its right perspective. There's no denying that it was the Mughal emperor who put the Guru to death," Akali Dal (Panthak) leader Manjit Singh, also a DSGMC member, said. The Shiromani Akali Dal also accused the DSGMC of attempts to create a controversy out of Swaraj's remarks. "Political differences are one thing, but history is another. It's sacrosanct. The DSGMC has tried to politicise a great sacrifice," SAD general secretary Onkar Singh Thapar said. [%sig%]

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

L Singh · 24 Jun 2006

I agree, Guru Jee was martyred because of Jahangir's Islamic views. Sikhi was spreading at a high rate and Jahangir along with Sheikh Sarhindi did not like it's growth.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

Sad Sikh · 24 Jun 2006

It is amazing how Sikhs themselve are now trying to distort history!Chandu's role seems to have increased since 1984!Chandu played a small fry role.To please the evil mughal chandu would have even killed his own father , just like jehangir who killed his own brother and father ! Guru ji's role should not be belittled by associating with a small fry like Chandu.There were also good muslims and hindus, while there were aslo bad hindus and muslims! But for Sikhs today to distort history shows how bad these Siksh have become using Sikhs history to take political pot shots at an opposition leader!

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Jun 2006

chandu had the same role as the evil and harami JHOOTHANAND in Suba Sarhand's Darbaar....they provided the "ammunition"...but had no actual power to do anything... Shushma is backed by no other than Principal Satbir Singh. Jarnail Singh

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

S Singh · 26 Jun 2006

The Chandu story is just that a made up story. Chandu is not mentioned in Tuzuk-i-Jehangiri. Other court officials are mentioned so why not this chandu charachter. He probably never existed.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

fresno sikh · 26 Jun 2006

SSAKAL All you Chandu supporters should join the BJP and RSS just like some the spineless leader of the sikh community. According to Kavi Santokh Singh when Jhangir left for kashmir from Lahore he told Chandu to keep them with him and show him respect and he will clarify all the matters with Guruji when he comes back. But before Jhangir came back from Kashmir Guruji was already tortured and executed by Chandu orders. Few years later Jhangir handed Chandu over to Guru Hargobind ji and was taken around with his face balckened around town and recieved a blow on his head from the same person Chandu got hot sand poured over Guruji by which he died. Chandu was the main cause of Gurujis death. I would recommend fellow sikhs to read tikka of Kavi santokh singh jis Gur Partap Suraj by Sodhi Teja singh which is in very simple punjabi.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

S Singh · 27 Jun 2006

fresno, What makes you think Kavi Santokh Singh was not making up stories ? He was born in the 18th century, a long time after our Guru Ji. It is people like you who like to distort and twist history who should join the Congress. Why is there no mention of Chandu in Tuzuk-i-Jehangiri ? or any other Mughal Court records from that time period ? Probably because Chandu never existed and the story was made up.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

satnam · 28 Jun 2006

Now it is Chandu and you will see BJP Telling later that Gangu Bhaman had no role in shaheedi of younger sahebzade's. BJP is trying to change sikh history with help of Badals.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

S Singh · 28 Jun 2006

satnam Why cant you guys get it in your heads that there is no Chandu. Historical texts and court diaries have no mention of him. If he was a bigshot diwan then why would he get NO mention in any official gazettes of the time ? I guess Kavi Santokh Singh tried to change Sikh history by telling half truths.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

Satnam · 29 Jun 2006

All Kathawachaks, Sant Singh Maskin, Bhai Pinderpal singh, Sant Hardev Singh, Damdami Taksal, Nanaksar, say Chandu was the main Culprit.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

AB · 29 Jun 2006

Satnam, I don't care what Sushma says but what is wrong is S Singh asking about Chandu? The following is a google search titles Chandu Shah and Guru Arjun Dev ji, which serves to illustrate the nature of the references to Chandu in current Sikh accounts: http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=Chandu+Shah+and+Guru+Arjun+Dev However, there is not a single contemporary source to indicate that the Hindu banker Chandu Shah was in any way personally vindictive towards the captive Guru ji. So why the ever increasing emphasis on his inclusion in the accounts? Now, I don't know whether he was a real person but would sure like to find out. However, logically, don't you think Jahangir's memoirs or some other court text would've mentioned Chandu if he had a part to play in Guru ji's martyrdom? Kavi Santokh Singh was not a historian and in any case, why did it take a century for Chandu's name to appear? Now, the problem is, as soon as I write this, people like Fresno will be jumping around in California calling me a Bahman or a Missionary or whatever the latest insult is thrown at the person who tries to question. Bhai Kulbir Singh, Bhai A Singh and Bhai Amandeep Singh Madra - You three seem to have the best historical point of view and neutral points of view. Could you please comment on this thread and share your thoughts with us.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

S Singh · 29 Jun 2006

>>Author: Satnam >>Date: 06-29-06 13:39 >>All Kathawachaks, Sant Singh Maskin, Bhai Pinderpal singh, Sant Hardev >>Singh, Damdami Taksal, Nanaksar, say Chandu was the main Culprit. Must all be true then if they say it......NOT ! Ask them to provide sources. They will cite Kavi Santokh Singh. Some say Chandu was a rich banker from Delhi others that he was a Minister (Deewan). That itself helps to show flaws in the story. The clever kathawachaks will make use of certain parts of Tuzuk-i-Jehangiri (the parts that suit their stories where Jehangir mentions his act of barbarity). BUT they will conveniently forget to mention that no person going by the name of Dewan Chandu Shah is mentioned anywhere in the Tuzuk-i-Jehangiri or in any other Mughal court records.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

S Singh · 02 Jul 2006

Vijadeep Singh Ji, Where is your proof ? Why is there no mention of Chandu in Mughal Court records and Jehangirs Tuzuk-i-Jehangiri ? Jahangir holds his hands up and accepts full responsibility for the Shaheedi of Guru Arjan Dev Ji in his Tuzuk. He is an invention of Kavi Santokh Singh.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

KS · 02 Jul 2006

HindustanTimes.com » Columnists » Pankaj Vohra In the eye of a storm between us | Pankaj Vohra July 2, 2006 Former Prime Minister Vishwanath Pratap Singh and senior BJP leader Sushma Swaraj have come in for a lot of flak on what is being termed as ‘their attempts at rewriting history’. Another former PM Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Indira Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi’s political advisor Makhan Lal Fotedar have trained their guns on Singh. They have described his reference to them in the controversial book released last week as “total falsehood”. On his part, Singh has stuck to his position though he has been unable to defend his views on Vajpayee and Fotedar convincingly. Sushma Swaraj’s plight is no better since her views on Diwan Chandu Shah, who every Sikh believes to be, besides Emperor Jahangir, the man responsible for the martyrdom of the fifth Sikh Guru Arjan Dev, have kicked up a controversy that may cost the BJP and its electoral partner, the Shiromani Akali Dal, very dearly in the forthcoming Punjab assembly polls. Swaraj is reported to have stated that Jahangir alone was to be blamed for Guru Arjan Dev’s martyrdom and not Chandu Shah, a courtier. Perhaps she was guided by the BJP’s old policy of attacking Muslims in order to consolidate the others (Hindus and Sikhs). But this seems to have backfired. The views were expressed in Tarn Taran at an Akali platform in the course of a meeting of the Istree Dal organised by Surinder Kaur Badal, convened to commemorate 400 years of the martyrdom of Guru Arjan Dev. Among others, even Rajasthan CM Vasundhara Raje attended. Matters took a turn for the worse when Darshan Singh Raagi, former chief of the Akal Takht, speaking at a Punjab government function two days later, made repeated digs at both the BJP leader and the Akalis for distorting history. Raagi, who now lives in Canada, criticised Swaraj and said that Chandu was both the instigator and, later, also the executor of Guru Arjan Dev. He had instigated the emperor to order the guru’s execution on the plea that he was working against the interests of the Hindus and Muslims. Subsequently, he carried out the execution. According to Sikh scholars, the real reason was that the guru had been pressurised by a Sikh gathering to break the marriage of his son, Guru Hargobind (who later became the sixth guru) to Chandu’s close relative after the latter made unsavoury remarks. Chandu had then taken his revenge and had used all kinds of torturous methods that led to Guru Arjan Dev’s martyrdom. While identifying the line between the instigator and the executor, Raagi did not end the BJP’s criticism. He said that the BJP had also instigated Indira Gandhi to act against the Sikhs. When Operation Blue Star was ordered, some of its leaders praised the late Prime Minister. But subsequently, they distanced themselves from the Congress stance and were critical of the party’s actions against the Sikhs. Now Sushma Swaraj is being accused of trying to distort Sikh history in order to absolve Chandu. It’s being argued that if Sushma is right, which she stoutly maintains, then was the sixth Sikh guru, Guru Hargobind, who took custody of Chandu, leading to the latter’s punishment (being clobbered to death by the same implements that Chandu had used to pour hot sand over the head of his father, Guru Arjan Dev) wrong? How could she be allowed to get away with this distortion of facts? The controversy raging at the gurdwara level may force the BJP to issue a clarification to assuage the hurt feelings of the Sikhs. The Congress, on its part, has been ignorant of the Sikhs’ anger with the BJP. It is yet to exploit the issue to its advantage in Punjab where a battle royale is waiting to be fought early next year. The Akalis who had criticised Raagi for speaking from the Punjab government’s stage had no answer when the former Akal Takht chief said that he could go anywhere where the holy book (Guru Granth Saheb) could go. In fact, the 400th year of the martyrdom has also thrown up some other issues which do not seem to be flattering for the Congress party either. The Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Committee management had wanted Manmohan Singh to preside over a function which was to be held at the Vigyan Bhawan to mark the event. He did not agree and is yet to send a message for the occasion, knowing fully well that it would help his party. Congressmen often wonder whether Singh has at any time had the interests of his party in mind or is he too image-conscious to get identified with one community. The second point which could embarrass the government and the BJP is that the Pakistan government has already gone ahead and issued a commemorative stamp on Guru Arjan Dev. Nothing of the sort has been done here. As for rewriting history, VP Singh may end up having a lot to explain on what has been written in the book, whose author Ram Bahadur Rai is known for his well-researched articles. Rai must’ve been privy to a lot of goings-on within the BJP, because of his proximity to the Sangh parivar at that point in time. Although Vajpayee has denied the references to his quitting, the matter can be corroborated, or denied, by those in the know. A similar story about Vajpayee’s quitting had done the rounds in the early Nineties, when LK Advani was made the leader of the Opposition. Two prominent Delhi leaders had persuaded the then RSS chief to resolve the matter. On Fotedar, Singh may have erred badly. Fotedar doesn’t engage in loose talk. Thus the remarks attributed to him appear unbelievable. He had met VP Singh along with Natwar Singh who must be knowing what transpired. He has neither endorsed nor denied entries in the book. But in the backdrop of all this is the story that during his tenure with Rajiv Gandhi, Fotedar had been asked to secure the resignations of two persons. One was VP Singh and the other Amitabh Bachchan. Could it be Singh’s revenge on Fotedar when he is perceived to be down? The saga of rewriting of history has not ended. In the coming weeks, many more things may come to light which would shed light on what is the truth. Between us.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

Mehtab Singh · 03 Jul 2006

I just have a question in mind. Who do we trust more? A Sikh like Kavi Santokh Singh or a tyrant like Jahangir?

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

S Singh · 03 Jul 2006

Vijaydeep Ji Jehangir does mention the execution but accepts full responsibility in his Tuzuk. There is no proof that Chandu ever existed. No Mughal court record shows his existance. Would court records ignore such an important Dewan ? Read Dr Ganda Singhs book - Guru Arjan's Martydom as he did extensive research and found no evidence of Chandu existing. The story like many others has been made up.

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

S Singh · 03 Jul 2006

Mehtab Singh The question is not about trust but about the truth. If Chandu existed and he held the position of Dewan he would have been mentioned somewhere along the line in the Tuzuk or other court records. Why is it that he suddenly appears in the writing of Kavi Santokh Singh ? Why would such an influential dewan who had the ear of Jehangir not get a mention in any Mughal records ?

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006

1) The reason for shahidi of Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee Maharaaj was much more than merely Chandu. If we believe that Siri Guru jee got shaheed just because of his personal family problem with Chandu, then he cannot be classified as the great shahid he is now. 2) By the same token, it does not mean that Chandu did not exist or that he did not play a role in the shahidi of Guru Sahib. He was a small pawn but the actual reasons for Guru Sahib's shahidi are beyond our understanding. 3) Sheikh Sarhindi the fundamentalist Mujaddid of Naqashbandi order of Islam played a very active role in Guru Sahib's shahidi. He and his chela Murtaza Khan (or whatever his name was) were instrumental in pursuading Jahangir to take this extreme step of doing shahidi of Guru Sahib. 4) Just because Chandu did what he did or Gangu deceived Sahibzade does not mean that the whole of Hindu quom is bad. This kind of thinking is not befitting for a Gursikh. Chandu did not play the negative role he played because he was opposing Guru Sahib as a Hindu but he did so because of his personal problem with Guru Sahib. So to derive that all Hindus are bad because of Chandu or Gangu is anti-Gurmat thinking. 5) Apart from the main reason that Jahangir wrote in his autobiography, there were many spiritual reasons too for Guru Sahib's shahidi. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written that some of these reasons cannot be explained in this physical world. Kulbir Singh

Re: I stand by what I said: Sushma

JK · 29 Jul 2006

Please find extract from SGPC's website regarding Dewan Chandu's torturing of Guru Arjan Sahib. He [the governor of lahore] handed Guru Sahib over to Chandu, a petty businessman and an orthodox Hindu of Lahore city. He tortured Guru Sahib for about three days in a manner unknown in the history of mankind. http://www.sgpc.net/gurus/guruarjandev.asp The orthodox Hindus and the fundamentalist Muslims (Shekh Ahmed Sirhandi, Birbal and Chandu) were some of the most jealous of Sikh community and Guru Arjan Sahib. After the death of Akbar in 1605 both Hindu and Muslim fundamentalists move the new head of state emperor Jahangir against Guru Sahib. Jahangir himself was also jealous about Guru's propagation of Sikhism. He promptly obliged the enemies of Guru Sahib. Many baseless allegations were leveled against Guru Sahib, one of those was helping the rebellious Khusro. Guru Arjan Sahib was arrested and brought to Lahore where he was charge-sheeted and implicated in the false cases. The Governor of Lahore was assigned the task of the execution. He handed Guru Sahib over to Chandu, a petty businessman and an orthodox Hindu of Lahore city. He tortured Guru Sahib for about three days in a manner unknown in the history of mankind. It is said that Mian Mir (a Muslim Sufi Saint and friend of Guru Sahib) tried to intercede on behalf of Guru Sahib but the latter forbade him. During the torturing period, Guru Sahib was made to sit on the hot iron plates and burning sand was poured over his naked body. When his body was blistered, he was chained and thrown into the river Ravi. Thus Guru Sahib embraced martyrdom on Jeth Sudi 4th (1st Harh) Samvat 1663, (May 30, 1606) Jahangir in his autobiography acknowledges that he personally ordered the execution of Guru Arjan Sahib.