Re: Guru Granth Sahib Defined
Jagvinder Singh · 29 Jun 2006
Gupt Singh ji, very well said. Im in total agreement with you. Dasam Guru Granth Sahib ji and Sarbloh Guru Granth Sahib Ji are not given the respect that they deserve. Guru Granth Sahib Ji is good on its own. But bir ras can only be obtained by the other 2 Guru Granths. And, bir ras forms a major part of a warrior's diet, eg. nihangs. The first khalsa. Today, we are denominated into so many organizations that we are too confused about ourselves and sikhi.
The British, during their campaign in india, banned the other 2 Guru Granths cos they knew the amount of destruction they could cause to the enemies of the khalsa panth. Before the Brits came in, Dasam Guru Granth Sahib was seated in the Akal Takhat, facing Guru Granth Sahib in the Durbar Sahib. They eliminated any form of shakthi which was available to the khalsa. They banned our Bana. They went on a mass killing of the nihangs. Almost wiped them out because they knew if there was one people who knew the traditions of the khalsa, it was the nihangs. To prove this authenticity, go read up chandi di var, written years before 1699. and theres a line which says, Khet Paiyaan Nihangaan. Dashmesh Pitaah had already foresighted the creation of the Nihangs in the khalsa mould.
They wiped out our history and tradition, and what is left now, is, a singh wearing a starched turban(like a cap), beard tied up, trying to fit into the crowd. Im not saying we cant be like this, my point is, we shouldnt forget our traditions, our roots, our bani and our bana.
Bottomline is, we are to blame for our own mistakes. Had the panth not fallen into the hands of the dogras, and modern day SGPC.
Another reason for the loss of respect for the other 2 granths was, when sikhs, led by SGPC, demanded that they were a separate religion, and wanted out from India's Greater Sphere of Hindusim. It was a good move. It was good we established ourselves as an independent religion. But along with doing that, we discarded all things that were hindu-like. If we look into Dasam Guru Granth Sahib, we will see ram avtar, krishan avtar and chandi charitra, which are banis about hindu mythological characters. The purpose of these banis is to gain inspiration and courage from the examples of brave warriors like ram, krishna and the goddess chandi. besides, these banis are written in the way guru ji saw it. itsnothing pro-hindu. But, sadly, our modern leaders, in their narrow mindedness, rejected this.
our history couldve been different. Dear brothers and sisters, i recommend you go read up Dasam Guru Granth at least, and harness that mahaan shakthi of our Kalgidhar Pitaah. Our war of fighting the 5 evils inside us(and the enemies outside), will become 2fold easier.Its bir rass. Its the mukhvaak of our guru. Therefore, it should be given the same amount of respect as our Adi Guru Granth Sahib.
Re:
Balpreet Singh · 29 Jun 2006
Dasam Granth was not in existence when Guru Gobind Singh left his mortal body and gave the Gurgaddi to Guru Granth Sahib.
Dasam Granth was compiled by Bhai Mani Singh after the passing of Guru Gobind Singh after he went to different places to collect Guru Sahib's bani.
Sarbloh Granth is even more recent than that and all scholars agree it was written not by Guru Gobind Singh jee but by a Granthi of Patna Sahib.
Bhatt Narbadd Singh who was present at Nander when Guru Gobind Singh gave Gurgaddi to Guru Granth Sahib also mentions only the saroop of Guru Granth Sahib being parkaash.
As for the argument that Guru Granth Sahib does not have bir ras or "shakti" power; I will say this is an argument developed by the UK Nangs. I have never heard of any ban on Dasam Bani by the British. If you have some source to support this assertion, I'd be interested. In fact, Sikhs serving in the British army, in addition to Jaap Sahib and Svaiyay used to also read Chandi Di Vaar.
Sri Guru Granth Sahib is a POORA Satguru. A Sikh can read Guru Granth Sahib and get every type of power from it, be it Bir Ras or some other. I find it to be blasphemous and insulting if someone says Bir Ras can only be found from Dasam Bani. I accept that Guru Gobind Singh jee's bani is filled with Bir Ras and should be recited and respected as Gurbani, but the Gurgaddi rests with Satguru Granth Sahib who have no equal and are complete within themselves.
Re: Guru Granth Sahib Defined
sad and shocked singh · 01 Jul 2006
Gupt Singh ji, It looks like you must go back and read the Sikh history again,You are doing nothing but spreading dubious tales that have no foundation.Balpreet singh ji has said all I wanted to say.
You are spreading romours unfounded,Please stop at once .Gurgaddi was given tio Guru Granth sahib by Guru Gobind Singh ji himself at Nanded.Full stop.
Please cleanse your mind and get some real knowledge.