Sarbloh Granth
Gurooo · 29 Jun 2006
vjkk vjkf can anyone give me some info on sarbloh granth??????? wot is tapoban's view do they see it as siri guru gobind singh ji bani
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Gurooo · 29 Jun 2006
vjkk vjkf can anyone give me some info on sarbloh granth??????? wot is tapoban's view do they see it as siri guru gobind singh ji banianswer · 29 Jun 2006
]"The authorship is however questioned by researchers and Scholars of Sikhism on several counts. First, the work is marked by extraordinary effusiveness and discursiveness of style over against the compactness characteristic of Guru Gobind Singh's composition as collected in the Dasam Granth. Qualitatively too, the poety of Sarbloh Granth does not match that of Guru Gobind Singh's Chandi Charitras and aar Durga Kee dealing with the same topic of wars between the gods and the demons. Profusion of metaphor and superb imagery of the latter compositions are missing here. Second, the author of Sarbloh Granth often uses his name, "Das Gobind" or the phrase "Das Gobind Fatah satigur ki" which is generally contrary to the style of Guru Gobind Singh. Third, the Sarbloh Granth contains, quite out of context, an account of the Sikh religion, which also includes a reference to the devolution of guruship on Guru Granth and Guru Panth (stanzas 3159-66). This would be out of place in a work of Guru Gobind Singh's own composition. Lastly, there is also a reference in it to Rup Dip Bhasha Pingal (stanza 2938/8) a work on prosody written by one Jaya Krishna in 1719, i.e. eleven years after the death of the Guru. According to Pandit Tara Singh Narotam, a nineteenth century Sikh scholar and researcher, Sarbloh Granth is the work of Bhai Sukha Singh, a granthi or priest at Takht Harimandar Sahib at Patna Sahib, who however claimed that he acquired its manuscript from an Udasi recluse living in a forest near Jagannath (Orissa)." The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism ed. Harbans Singh Punjabi University Patiala, Vol 4, pg. 57Khalsa · 29 Jun 2006
i heard that nihangs say it's bani so do taksal and akj, the nihangs kept the granth a secret for 100 of yrs saying that it gave them bir ras (the warrior essence) and ppl only know about it due to budha dal printing it out in 2000 wot do ppl think of nihangs do parakash of Guru Ji with dasam granth and sarbloh granth in the same presence?? i neva seen or heard sarbloh granth do gurdwara in the uk have it???ns · 29 Jun 2006
How funny indeed,it could take a lifetime for one to understand the deep meanings of Japji, and we all know for a fact Guru Granth Sahib Ji is our Guru Ji.If the nihangs ketp it secret for 100 years to give them bir raas then what happened to this bir ras in 84, where were they did all this bir ras become nothing, how absurd?????Jagvinder Singh · 29 Jun 2006
dear ns. the nihangs did not get involved in the politics of 84, because there was no point in it. We could die fighting when we knew we were going to lose. that was stupid. Guru ji has also taught us to use our brains and not waste our numbers just like that. Do you have any idea of the might of the indian government? Do you think its an overnight thing fo you to get khalistan? you think they gonna give it up so easily?. The time is not here, we all have to connect spiritually, thats more important for us. The nihangs felt it was better for them to carry on with their seva of the panth at that time.Khalsa · 30 Jun 2006
i disagree the nihangs could of have played a big part in the movement after operation bluestar. there just all in love with santa "singh" who's got no jeevan at all. all they do is make sukha eat sukha make sukha eat sukha on and on and on!!!!!! So called warriors of guru sahib wud have cum to the frontline to defend the KHALSA PANTH!!!!! with all there naamand bir ras lolllllll cut sum goats insteadabout · 30 Jun 2006
>>>>>>>>>>>dear ns. the nihangs did not get involved in the politics of 84, because there was no point in it. We could die fighting when we knew we were going to lose. that was stupid. Guru ji has also taught us to use our brains and not waste our numbers just like that. Do you have any idea of the might of the indian government? Do you think its an overnight thing fo you to get khalistan? you think they gonna give it up so easily?. The time is not here, we all have to connect spiritually, thats more important for us. The nihangs felt it was better for them to carry on with their seva of the panth at that time.<<<<< Wat kind of thing is dat 2 say!when we know we are going to lose?? evry single battle singhs have ever fout they where out numbered by thousands, that doesnt mean they wouldnt fite!!! no 1 sed its a overnite fing to get khalistan, its about the fact that your holiest place of worship is being attacked, you dont stand and do jack ****, if your house is being attackd by many people would you stand outside and say forget it becuz its gona get destroyed with or with out me in there? the fact is mahraaj was in harmander sahib, the nihangs should have been there to protect there guru and fite with the panth. n dont even start on sant was a terrorist crap. You have to connect spiritually, but you dont sit back and watch akaal takht sahib being destroyed, even if you know you going to get slaughtered! evry single battle Gursikhs have fout no matter what numbers the have, they have fout until their last breath!sanjo · 30 Jun 2006
there were some but only some nihungs fighting in those days. bhai avtar singh brahma was a true nihung. brilliant gursikh, feared all over punjab by police. if we dont jaap naam ourselves what right have we got to judge other panthic groups. look after your own jeevan first!A Singh · 30 Jun 2006
The Sarabloh Granth, even within the Budha Dal "Printed" version (in fact the teeka is written by an Udasi and not the Nihangs let alone Baba Santa Singh), acknowledges that this Granth came into their possession in the 1800s from an Udasi. So here are two questions: 1. Why, if indeed as the internet Sikhs like to believe, the Nihangs are the original Khalsa and preserve the true traditions of Guru Gobind Singh and have his blessing as the original form of the Khalsa etc etc, then why would this text come into their possession from an Udasi? 2. If indeed this text was only discovered during the 1800s, clearly it was not with the Dal Khalsa or even Banda Singh Bahadur - when the "Bir Ras" or "Chandi charni" would have been required?WHat · 30 Jun 2006
Considering the power of the indian army still took em time 2 get in 2 harminder sahib!!! even young children were throwing grenades and stuff, yet these nihangs could do nufink :s! wastemansss!!!Jagvinder Singh · 30 Jun 2006
look. sant jarnail singh bhindranwale didnt want everyone to be in the complex fighting. he had plans for the future, and as such, had told some singhs to leave the complex and retreat back to punjab. if everyone of us wouldve in there, there wouldntve been no khalsa panth here today.sant ji had tactics, he knew we were going to lose, but yes, die fighting. but he didnt want everyone to die fighting, cos if everyone did, it'd take a second for the indian govt to start the hinduization of the sikhs. by the way, you all talk so much, where were you all when the 84 attack happened, why din u take a ticket to india and join in the struggle, and yes, even before that, when the nihangs were being massacarred by the british after the downfall of khalsa durbar, where were u all to stop those atrocities, nihangs were being wiped out, so as to finish off the khalsa traditions and remove the warriors. akali phoola singh was a nihang, and he was a great general.he fought well against the british.baba gurbux singh, the second jathedar of the damdami taksal, was a nihang, and he fought bravely to save harimander sahib from the invaders. time and time again, the nihangs have proved their forte in history. think its time for u guys to cut em some slack.Sardar · 02 Aug 2006
Seriously, who wrote Sri Sarbloh Granth Sahib Ji? Why? If Dasmesh Pita Sahib Ji wrote it, why? He already wrote Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Ji, why another one? Why not just put the Baani that's in Sri Sarbloh Granth Sahib Ji in Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Ji and make it Big Granth? What were the reasons behind this??????????Dalbir · 02 Aug 2006
Jagvinder - akali phoola singh was a nihang, and he was a great general.he fought well against the british. --------------------------------------------------------------------- I think you might be mistaken, Akali Phoola Singh actually died fighting Afghans long before the Anglo-Sikh Wars. Which is a shame for the Sikhs really, apparently he wanted to attack the British camps in Ludhiana at one stage but Maharaja Ranjit Singh stopped him. I think if he was around when the Anglo-Sikh wars happened, it would have been a different story.S Singh · 03 Aug 2006
I agree with Dalbir Jee. If Sikhs generals like Akali Phoola Singh and Hari Singh Nalwa were alive during the Anglo Sikh wars, we would never have lost the war. In fact, I would say that even without those two generals, if only the Dogras had not treacherously betrayed the Khalsa, we would have won during the battle of Sabrao. The Khalsa army was not like any ordinary Asiatic army. Thanks to Europeans military training, the Khalsa army was a modernized army which equaled the British army in training and discipline. The only exceptions were the Akalis and Gorcharas.gupt · 03 Aug 2006
we on about sarbloh granth! not war wot is the tapoban view on sarbloh granth!! nihangs do parkash of this granth nxt to guru ji wot r views people!livingforwaheguru · 06 Aug 2006
HOW DARE ANYONE SAY ANYTHING AGAINSTS THE NIHUNGS OF 84. The Nihung Singhs were sharpening their kirpans in 84 and getting prepared as they have always done. But it was for another little known threat to people. You see the goat situation had gotten out of control. They were too many goats around and they were bothering people. You know by eating up all the grass (minding there own business) and giving milk to anyone without discrimination. Soooooooooooooooo you see the nihungs were to busy killing off this threat while the regular gursikhs were too busy with the pesky threat of fighting for the respect of the opressed sikhs and for the honour of our sisters. So don't anyone say the nihungs didn't do anything in 84 ok. They are still controling that pesky goat population. GIVE ME A BREAK. Nihungs didn't do anything and thats a fact. You say sant ji didn't want everyone there fighting thats why they didn't come. YEAH SURE BUDDY. You say if everyone was fighting who would have been left to survive to carry on the faith..MAAAN are you blind.. If all the gursikhs were there fighting there would be no indian nation today. We would have a land of purity and raaj of the pure. So don't give this B.S about they were ensuring our future by not fighting when we needed them. Where were they when all the fake singh encounters happened. When our women were being raped indiscriminatly afterwards. Look the nihungs of the old were rehitvaan naam abiyaasi Guru kay ladlay. Not like most of the drug addicted, meat addicted so called pakhandi nihungs of today. Were was i when 84 happened. I was 3...So i don't remember... Where was santa singhs common sense when he rebuilt the akaal takhat on the orders of the indian government? Don't give me that B.S that nihungs are noble now and we shouldn't say anything against them. Look around you brother. They are a joke in india and aren't respected BY ANYONE.Dalbir · 06 Aug 2006
I do apologise for digressing, I mainly wanting to correct the mistake regarding Akali Phula Singh. I think I may have translation of a small part of the Sarbloh Granth, will try and dig it out and post it when i have time.Dalbir · 06 Aug 2006
Translated from Piare Padams Rahit-name in Khari Boli by Mcleod (yeh, I know, I don't trust him either but what can we do until the panth can produce some decent scholars that can work in English!) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Khalsa is my special embodiment; I dwell within the Khalsa The Khalsa is my mouth and limbs; always I live within the Khalsa The Khalsa is the object of my devotion; The Khalsa proclaims my reputation The Khalsa isis my wings and my feet; The Khalsa is the offspring in who I delight The Khalsa is my encouraging friend; The Khalsa is my parents who give me joy The Khalsa is my virtuous delight, ever tied in friendship with me The Khalsa is my virtue and honour, from the Khalsa I took birth The Khalsa is the source of my supply, through the Khalsa I have performed every deed The Khalsa is my family and friend, the Khalsa works my redemption The Khalsa is the breath of my body, the Khalsa is my very life The Khalsa is my duty (dharam) and my destiny (karam); the Khalsa is my deepest secret The Khalsa is my perfect Satguru, The Khalsa is my family of the noble brave The Khalsa is is my learning and intelligence; on the Khalsa I constantly reflect Nobody is there that can be compared with the Khalsa, none that may reach its furtherest limits. ------------------------------------------------------------ I don't think it is by Guru Gobind though, it seems that the language used is not that used in the Guru's time. (there is much more but I'm tired of typing!)gupt · 07 Aug 2006
plz type more stuff from sarbloh granth nangs r loser'sDalbir · 07 Aug 2006
Continued from previous post: ------------------------------------- If I had the tongues of Sheshnag and the knowledge of Devi, yet would I fail to praise it adequately No falsehood I have uttered as God and Guru Nanak are my witnesses If one had as many tongues as hairs on ones body, yet they still would be insufficient to sing the praises of the Khalsa I am the Khalsa and the Khalsa is mine, the relationship is as the ocean and its individual drops of water The Khalsa is the army of Akal Purakh The Khalsa emerged as the joy of God All my wealth, stowed in a storehouse and treasury, is due to the grace of the Khalsa Like a kingdom with its wealth and mansions, its men and their wives each perform their appointed tasks Though I be an armies chief leader I am the lowliest servant of all Friends, family, riches, mansions and mercy- all come by the grace [of the Khalsa] Leading the household, command over all, body and soul, my physique and my breath- Gifts, greatness, and honour, all I receive, are due to the grace of the Khalsa The whole of the Khalsa, to which grace has been given, makes me worthy of honour and glory Penniless and without leaders are people without number, who [without the Khalsa] like me are astray in this world ------------------------------------------------- A few things that indicate this is not a work of Guru Gobind, assuming the translation is correct. Though I be an armies chief leader I am the lowliest servant of all - hard to imagine Guru Gobind refering to himself as simply an army leader, but perhaps this does give us an idea of the background of the real writer? Penniless and without leaders are people without number, who [without the Khalsa] like me are astray in this world - Guruji wasn't astray he came to put the astray on the right path. BTW I think this portion of the SG is called Khalsa. Regarding the background of the granth: "Kahn singh Nabha describes it as a work in five parts which narrates the descent of God (Ishavar) as the Sarab Loh avatar, to assist an army of gods who were being worsted by demons. It is said to be the work of Guru Gobind Singh and the text is preceded by Sri mukh vakh patshahi 10, but this not a possible attribution. It is, writes Kahn Singh, plainly a latter composition that originated within the devi cult. On linguistic grounds it must come after the time of Guru Gobind." In Mahan Kosh it is also recorded that the granth is also known as Mangalcharan.