Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sevatothemax santhiya?

Sevatothemax santhiya?

stupid · 29 Jun 2006

gurfateh!i urgently needed the ful japji sahib santhiya,along with the complete nitnem santhiya. sevatothemax on has part of japji sahib, n e 1 knw wer full 1 can be obtained?thanks

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Gurpreet Singh · 02 Jul 2006

the santhiya on www.sevatothemax.com is HORRIBLY done, it shouldnt even be called santhiya. You should find another srouce to do santhiya

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Here we go again!! · 03 Jul 2006

Gurpreet Singh - why is it 'Horribly done'? Please can you do some Santhiya and upload it, or are you that type of CyberSingh who can't do anything for the Sangat but just likes to diss any seva done!!!!

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Jagjit Singh · 03 Jul 2006

Gurprret singh, if that is your real name. Your comments are out of order. Either help towards improving something, or quit complaining.

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Kirandeep Kaur · 03 Jul 2006

Gurpreet singh how cna you say its "horribly worng " are you a scholar a giani if so as stated above plese record on mp3 your own santhyia and forward to that webste, bet you can't even read grubani

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Dal · 03 Jul 2006

Vahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Vahe Guru Ji ke Fateh The Santhiya given in these classes has been excellent and has been a real eye opener to Sikhi and Guru Nanak Dev Ji's message, And also the life styles of GurSikhs like Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Jee, I have personally learnt a lot from these classes, not just about JapJi Sahib but all 7 Nitnem banis, And I have always had answers to any Sikhi questions raised, with honesty ref to Gurus Bani, and with the up-most humility, the actual site has also been a great inspiration with many great un-seen pictures including Bhai Rama Singh Jee, The seva of the class and the site is much appreciated by many, and i hope both continue to grow. Why cant the sangaat look at the positives, instead of whinging, a lot of message boards are turning to this trend of back biting and gossiping, may be they should be moderated more strictly? Phul Chuk Maaf Vahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Vahe Guru Ji Ke Fateh

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

:O · 03 Jul 2006

ye your all right, gurpreet singh how can u say it is horibbly done, as mentioned above why dont you do some seva towards it if you think it is sooo "horibbly done"!!!!!

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

! · 03 Jul 2006

i wouldnt be suprised if gurpreet singh doesnt like the santhiya because he is one of those people who doesnt pronounce gurbani with bindia, overpronounces lagamantra etc. satinamu

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

member · 03 Jul 2006

WaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa WaheguruJeeKeeFateh!! Dear 'stupid' We don't think your stupid if you are trying to learn Paath. But thank you soo much for pointing out that we accidently deleted the file off the site. The file is now back on the site. Please forgive us for this serious error and thanks for using the MP3 files to learn Paath. We think it was during th upload of the Bhai Raam Singh Jee and Gianni Amolak Singh Jee Videos, we will insure that this does not happen again. Their was a disclaimer by Bhai Sahib Jee who teaches in the class to advise that he might make mistakes in the Santhiya and humbly begs the Sangat to forgive him for any mistakes. Bhai Sahib has studied Gurbani for over 30 years and is just trying to help the youth, as he has done many times before, that's all. We also take on the criticism against the site and beg those to do Ardas for us Moorakhs to learn from our mistakes. All we ask is to carry on doing Seva and to have Sangat of Gursikhs to inspire us. If anyone is interested we have started to upload a series of New articles on Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh Jee. For more info on the 1978 Shaheedee Sakha please select the 1978 Lecture catergory on the blog page. For more update information please visit the site at www.sevatothemax.com or www.akj.org. Thank you for taking interest in the site positive or negative. WaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa WaheguruJeeKeeFateh!! [%sig%]

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Gurpreet Singh · 03 Jul 2006

For everyone who is saying that im wrong for writing what i did, here, i will give u examples of what is wrong. Also, notice that these examples have nothing to do with lagamantars or bindis..........although i do not agree with the overuse of bindis, and i do believe laagamantars should be pronounced very shortly notice that all these examples only come from the start of jap jee sahib, as i didnt listen to anything else Eg. 1 in the first pauri of jap jee sahib, bhai sahib says.........CHOOPAI chup n hovaee, when it should be read chupai chup n hovaee, bhai sahib has thus changed the unkar in chupai, to a dulankar, without reason and has thus wrongly pronounced it Eg.2 when saying sahas sianpaa lakh hohi, bhai sahib says "huhai" instead of "hohi". i do not understand why he would take away the hora in hohi and replace it with a unkar, when there is no need to do so. (notice once again, this is not a problem with bindis or laaglamtras as i did not complain about not pronouncing the sihaari in hohi even though most of the panth agrees how it should be prnounced in this case. Also sahas is also mispronounced, but to avoid useless arguement i will not discuss this further) Eg3 in pauri 2 of jap jee sahib, bhai sahib says hukam milae vadiaee. when it should be read hukam milai........bhai sahib has replaced the laavaa in milai with a dulaavaa, once again there is no purpose for this change (notice once again there is no complaint of lagamantars or bindis) I only listened up to here, and i feel this is enough to call this santhiya "horibly done". ATLEAST 3 mistakes in the first 2 pauris, without even talking baout bindis or lagamantars, is way tooo many to say this santhiya is correctly done. For everyone who seems to think i have a personal problem with the bhai thats doing the santhiya, you are incorrect. I dont even know who he is. I am sure he is 100 times a better gursikh than me, but just because he is a gursikh doesnt mean that he ucharan is shudh. To everyone who is writing that I should help fix something instead of complaining about it. Sat Bachan. Its my benti to you that you do ardaas for me that I am able to do anytype of seva for sangat. But until then, i would recomend either downloading nitnem of bhai jarnail singh jee, or buying a cassette of gyanee raam singh and mimicing their ucharan. They each got their own style, but i believe both do a great job of it

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

reality · 04 Jul 2006

hmmm looking at your points above i would say you aren't complaining about the santhiya more the pronounciation of words, now this does come down which school of thought you have learn't from, its obviuos by your end comment you believe in the taksal school of pronouciation, and that is fine each to their own, but everyone is entitled to do their own research and adopt what they feel is correct. All you have done is looked at words which are pronounced differently to the way you have been taught, if you look at sikhito the max, the spelling of milai has dulevaa not laav, also I have seen that certain paathis will read it has they have been taught regardless of what is written in front of them ??? Again I agree with the majority on your statement "horribly done" to be very negative, you could have said their are pronounciation differences etc, though you are entitle to your opinion as others are. The one truth that all Gursikhs must except is that only Guru Ji knows the correct pronounciation when it comes to Gurbani, to even try and claim so and so is correct is a disservice to the individual as they would be the first to claim that "Akhah vadah katae bhul chuk maaf karn ji".

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Gurpreet Singh · 04 Jul 2006

sorry about the typo, i meant to write that bhai has replaced the dulaavaa with a laavaa, just came out the wrong way. Also, "reality", i think you are mistaken that the difference comes from wat school of thought you are from. Regardless of where one gets santhiya from, no body teaches to change dulaavaa to laavaa, or a hora to an unkar.

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Here we go again!! · 04 Jul 2006

Gurpreet, Your choice of words were the main reason so many Gursikhs replied to you. If your too stupid to realise that then carry on with you dissing seva. I dont think even if Sangat did ardass for you, you will be the type of person who would take hours out of your life to help anyone. Im just making assumptions, don't take offence. I dont think the website admin or Bhai Sahib actually visit this forum alot, so if your lucky they might reply to your weak answer. If you read the post written by the admin of the site, Bhai Sahib requested that a disclaimer should be put on the site as any individual can make errors. I have seen people write on Forums critisizing the Paath on this site. But I congratulate anyone who does this seva. Guru jee will bless those who take time and effort in helping others, we also know what he thinks of people who for whatever reason or allegience diss anyones seva. [%sig%]

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

....... · 04 Jul 2006

I have heard tapes of people such as Baba Kartar Singh Bhindranwale where he has made mistakes in reading Paath, sometimes he has corrected himself. Everyone is human and makes mistakes. Although I don't think you would have been so fast to point out "horrible ucharan" on his part.

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

ermmmm........ · 04 Jul 2006

Gurpreet singh ji I think ur comments regarding the santhiya are out of order and as some people have said above I would appreciate listening to paath from those who think they are perfect like urself. you should not go round criticising those who give up their own valuable time to teach those who want to learn. its obvious you are Mr no it all and have the ability to teach all those attending the class who are learning a lot from Bhai Sahib. The word 'horribly done' just sums up what you have started on this thread. Bhull Chukh Maff Karna

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

amarjeet singh · 04 Jul 2006

gurpreet singh even if mistakes have been made, who are you to say its been horribly done. that was too harsh, you couldve suggested where he might make improvements, by saying what you did and how you did will not help anyone and just cause friction use your head stupid

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

babajee · 04 Jul 2006

gurpreet singh may have been wrong in the way he attacked the site and the seva, but if he pronounced gurbani wrong, esp that which is agreed upon by mostly everyone, then isnt it still wrong to mispronounce and then promote that mispronunciation, regardless of how gurpreet singh attacked it?

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

babajee chela · 04 Jul 2006

depends on whose pronounciation you agree with, you say mostly everyone ?? i beg to differ, I have heard loads of different pathis prounce the same lines differently, from taksal, akj, nanaksar, etc, i checked out some of the ones gurpreet mentioned and to me they sound very different, i accepted that this is the way they have learn't and do paath, what do i know other than we must continously strive to learn and ask for forgiveness after we do paath... the word that really puzzles me is dehnda dai lehna tak payea, i have heard it prounced as deda, dehda, dehnda etc... I remember this board was so good for learning about stuff like this but lately it has become a board without input from learned people.... i think we should start a section on the board only in connection with gurbani paath santhiya and everyone should input, okay i agree we would probably go over a 1000 post on each line but at least it would show that there is a real interest in learning paath...

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Gurpreet Singh · 04 Jul 2006

Yes, everyone does make mistakes, but if you look at Sant Kartaar Singh Jee's nitnem and look at how many mistakes he makes, you'll notice they are few and far between. Now if you look at the bhai from sevatothemax you'll notice that he makes 3 mistakes in the first 2 pauris. Now this not an attack on watever class the bhai might be teaching, or an attack on him personally. I also make many mistakes when i do paath, but thats why I dont teach a santhiya class. Any SANTHIYA class that makes THREE mistakes in the first TWO Pauris of jap jee sahib, is a santhiya class that is being horibly taught. You may think these words are harsh, but they are the truth. The mistakes i pointed out have nothing whatsoever to do with school of thaught (I think if Kulbir SIngh is reading this, he can confirm this). Just imagine someone teaching a raag keertan class even though they did not know the tune for a raag. Would you not agree that it is being horibly taught? The fact of the matter is that whoever is that whoever is teaching the santhiya class, is himself making mistakes while he reads it. Hence the santhiya is horibly done. Tomorrow, if I got up and taught a class on how to build a house, even though I dont know how to properly build it myself, would you not say its horribly done. Just cuz u know the bhai that is teaching santhiya, or just cuz the rest of his class is good, does not change the fact that the santhiya part of his class is not goood. Lastly, I dont understand why people think i got something against the site, or the people who run it. I dont even know the people who run it, im not even from UK. Also, i think the site is pretty good, I read the bhai fauja singh posts, and downloaded some of the keertan and thought it was prettty goood. It's easy to sidetrack a problem by claiming I am some sort of hater of sevatothemax.com or the bhai that runs the santhiya class. BUt i guess its a lot harder to adress the issue and deal with it.

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

singh · 05 Jul 2006

the mistakes you point or indeed if there are any others according to you are all to do with school of thought, baba kartar singh tapes also have mistakes, no human is perfect the words in baba kartar singhs nitnem that dont seem wrong to you might seem wrong to others, there are many steeks of guru granth sahib out there and the one you have learnt from is the one you will generally follow, but if like some you have studied them all your experience and pronunciations will be better than gursikhs who subscribe to one school of thought, it does not matter if bhai kulbir singh agrees with you or not as he will be the first to admit that only guru sahib knows the true pronunciations, bhai sahib who has done this seva has alot of gurbanee abhyaas over the last 35 years and to criticize in the words you use proves that you have along way to go as you have yet to realize guru jees message to be the lowest of the low, have humility, nimrata, gareebee etc. and make requests in the most respectful manner and on this you have failed...whatever your reasoning....we all beg to do shudh gurbaneee paath and do nitnem ik mann ik chit, but when we sit down tomorrow we need to look inside ourselves that is our mind really here are we reallyt listening obeying guru jee....the path is long and hard and by making such comments we will only go backwards......

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

reality · 05 Jul 2006

Gurpreet Singh, you only seem to quote taksaali Gursikhs paath, do you consider everyone else to be inadequate ??? you have just admitted everyone make mistakes but then go on about 3 that you believe are definitive mistakes ??? have you listened to anyone other than taksaali paath/santhiya, Bhai joginder singh talwara maybe ??? or any Gursikhs within AKJ ?? or any other jatha outside taksaal ??? fair enough if you are a believer in taksaal santhiya, that is your choice. I have found that the paath I hear from taksali pathis to be to rigid in the whole bindi and laagmaatra issue, thus i have never really agreed with there way, I had the opportunity to listen to Talwara jis and found his to be very concise and a good one to listen to and copy. Your analogy of the house build is silly though, you are almost saying that the gursikh teaching the santhiya has no knowledge of paath, as I'm pretty sure you have no knowledge of house building, again maybe another typo error on your part though. Again I would say whoever does paath, santhiya or anything should always remember they are bhullan haar and only Guru ji is samarth and knows the correct pronounciation of Gurbani. I'm sure you have fully addressed the issue and those involved have taken note and may ignore your comments or may not.

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

....... · 05 Jul 2006

"Yes, everyone does make mistakes, but if you look at Sant Kartaar Singh Jee's nitnem and look at how many mistakes he makes, you'll notice they are few and far between." Taking your overtly critical logic further - your issue is that as a Santhiya teacher the Bhai in question should not be making the amount of mistakes he is and so his Santhiya is "horrible". As the Jathedar of a organisation set up primarily for the pronounciation of Gurbani, is it acceptable for Baba Kartar Singh to make any mistakes at all? By your overtly critical logic most likely not - does this make Baba Kartar Singh a "horrible Jathedar"?

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Here we go again!! · 05 Jul 2006

Gurpreet, I dont think your a hater to the sevatothemax sites, and I dont think the Singhs who run it really worry about forums as they probably doing something or other to upload to the sites!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Singh · 05 Jul 2006

Gurpreet singh, have your ever considered it may be you that is wrong? Maybe where you learned they are the ones who have made the mistakes....

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Gurpreet Singh · 05 Jul 2006

i have considered that I am wrong, and then i decided to listen to people of other schools of thought and noticed that the mistakes i pointed out are only made by this bhai. Granted that no body is perfect, maybe i should not have said it was horribly done. It seems to have offended a lot of people, so i apoloigize for that. shota praa samjkay maaf karlo. However, I still stand by saying that the santhiya is not done correctly according to any school of thought. And it is my benti that sevatothemax admins atleast rename these files so people are not mistaken into believing that the bani is being read shudh. It is detremental too all people who listen to this recording thinking that the ucharan is shudh. The website is called sevatothemax, but my keeping up files like this, wiuth the title it has been given, it is not seva at all, but instead if anything it is quite the opposite of serving sangat.

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

singh · 05 Jul 2006

I don't know anything about sevatothemax santhiya. But i found Giani Takhur Singh ji's Sudh Santhiya cd to be very helpful. You can probably find it in various stores around Gurdwaras, like around Dasmesh Darbar in surrey, BC. You may be able to order it online as well.

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Rashminder Singh oz · 06 Jul 2006

in anand sahib he said vadhaiyaaan rather than vaaadhaaiyaaan and he say saran rather than sharan, sastar rather than shaster and much much more

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

..... · 06 Jul 2006

"it is not seva at all, but instead if anything it is quite the opposite of serving sangat" you apologise for saying one stupid thing and then you come out with something even more stupid? either you are intentionally trying to cause controversy or you are completely unaware of your actions. why dont you listen to the entire santhiya and record your own mp3 files of all the mistakes and corrections. i am sure sevatothemax will happily upload it - perhaps this can be your "seva."

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

stupid · 06 Jul 2006

thank you evryone for arguments totally off what iv asked!lol, can some one answer the first post and tell me where i can get santhiya from for japji sahib? tank ju [%sig%]

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

Admin · 07 Jul 2006

Topic Locked. Admin.

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

........... · 07 Jul 2006

could i just ask this question...........wel havent left u with a choice lol! anyways....ppl say that only guruji knows which pronouncation is right yh......so then does that mean half of the khalsa panth will not achieve salvation as they have not pronounced gurbani right?????

Re: Sevatothemax santhiya?

amarjeet singh · 07 Jul 2006

no we can only try our best as long as we try our best and in our minds beleive tht we are pronouncing gurbani as shudh as possible, then thts gr8