Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Daas needs sangat's help!

Daas needs sangat's help!

daas Dalvir Singh · 29 Jun 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Pyare Sangat jio, daas needs your help. Recently, daas has made many mistakes including eating from non-amritdhari hands. On top of this, my worldly parents are 'taksali' and put a lot of pressure of me saying that what the Akhand Kirtani Jatha believes in is against the Akal Takht Maryada. Such things they really oppose is the eating of only food made by amritdhari's, swaas swaas simran, sarbloh bibek and some more. Just recently, daas was working at a house my pua ji and my worldly father bought. After a few hours of work, daas along with his worldly father, sister and cousin went to my nana ji's house to eat food. Daas knew it is wrong to eat food made by non-amritdhari's but in the event of going there, daas was extremely hungry (daas knows this is no excuse as one who takes amrit gives one head to Guru ji and should follow rehit) and so daas ate the roti made. Today, after realizing my mistake, told my sister (who is not amritdhari and is the only one who knows how to make roti in our household except for my mom, but she works basically day and night) not to make me roti as daas understood his mistake (which had been repeated a couple of times before.) She didn't make me roti but told my worldly father of what daas said and he got upset at this (as he has before, saying this is Brahamvaad) and gave my a lecture saying that this is wrong eating from anyone's hands is ok, as long as I get food in my stomach. He went on to say that if I keep this up, I don't have darshan of Waheguru ji (this really hurt.) Daas told him that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh had darshan of Waheguru Ji and he kept this rehit of eating out of amritdhari hands only. My worldly father said well how do we know he had darshan of Waheguru Ji, he could be faking it. That the panth is weak because of these things and this manmat. Daas didn't know what to say to this, as Daas does not know any rehit's to refer too or any bani to refer too which state that eating of Amritdhari cooked food is only allowed for Amritdhari's. There is more to this problem but daas will leave it at this. Pyare sangat jio, please help daas with this problem. Please provide any relevant quotes, etc for this situation at hand. Daas needs all the help daas can get. Daas knows he needs to get peshed, but how does daas know if this problem will not occur again. Please help! Kirpa karo saadh sangat jio, daas nu bahit muddhat chaidee ya. Bhul Chuk Maaf Kardo jio. daas Dalvir Singh Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

Jagvinder Singh · 30 Jun 2006

I was just wondering... our Dashmesh Pitaah loved everyone regardless of race and religion. The sakhi about hom as a baby placing hands on both pitchers, one of a muslim and another of a hindu, meant that he loved all, and he would stand for all. Lets say, you were a devout hindu or muslim, but you also loved the guru and longed for his darshan. he had stood up for the weak regardless of caste or creed. And you hoped for the guru to come to your humble house and partake in dinner there. vegetarian of course. Do you think, the guru, judging by your immense love and devotion towards him as a man of god, would reject your appeal, to come and eat, just because youre not amritdhari?Surely you'd be saddened, as that means, you are not free to practise your own faith freely, of you want the darshan of a man whose mission was to keep up righteousness. Im sure guruji would have agreed to the request, as long as the food was vegetarian and made with love and devotion.He wouldnt want to sadden anybody or break anyone's heart. He himself sacrificed so much for everyone's happiness. Guruji wouldve been more that happy to have eaten at your house. Now, look at ourselves.We are so deeply caught up in this narrowmindedness. That food must be eaten by amritdharis, this and that. Have we forgotten our love and tolerance towards people of other faiths? Would we break someone's heart, just because theyre not amritdhari?

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

sanjo · 30 Jun 2006

bhai sahib ji das cannot help you with quotes, but if they your wordly parents are taksali then i am sure there have bene many great taksali gursikhs who kept sarbloh bibek. das thinks he has seen people mention that perhaps sant gurbachan singh ji khalsa bhindranwale was bibeki and also sant jarnail singh ji bhindranwale. i think they are caught up in the jatha arguement, its shameful. many great shaheeds and gursikhs have been bibeki, tell them this and they cannot say anything to it. otherwise keep japping naam and keep up the rehit, das doesnt think u need to pesh but thats your choice paji, forgive das as das couldnt help too much

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

lion king · 30 Jun 2006

i am amritdhari my family are all non amritdharis but i have to still eat from them otherwise i would starve to death

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

GuptSoulja · 30 Jun 2006

You do not have to re-take amrit, as you didn't remove a kakaar or commit a sin. Though, apologize to Guru Sahib Jee in ardaas and try harder to maintain this rehit. Also, you don't need to provide anything to your parents, if they say you're not going to have God's darshan is this going come true, no, so you hold your faith and love in this rehit. Jap more naam!! Read Guru Gobind Singh Ji's bania to become fearless!! And finally read more Sukhmani Sahib paath to help your naam. ONLY NAAM WILL SUPPORT YOU AND HELP YOU MAINTAIN YOUR SIKHI!! You don't need anyone elses help, just naam's help. Naam is a friend that can guide you through anything. So jap more of it.

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

Hum phikari tere!! · 30 Jun 2006

Dont argue, there is no need. You dont need to get help from us as you have the guru, daas use to do the same things, like fight and argue with his farther. At the end it got me no where, the best thing to do is to do an ardaas, that mahrajs saves you from kam, krodh, lobh, moh, hankar! Ask mahraj to guide your farther, daas has many times given quotes to his father but there still has been no affect, ardaas is very important and jaap naam, always. Dont eat, simple as. Bhai sahib Randheer singh didnt eat for about 40 days, he got what he wanted becuase he had faith in waheguroo. This is a test do not fail it. A person that says that Bhai Sahib Randhir singh didnt get no where can also be no where in his kamai. Just laeve it to waheguroo, mahraj will surely help you. HAVE FAITH IN HIM!

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

Balpreet Singh · 30 Jun 2006

Jagvinder Singh, Guru Gobind Singh did not eat food prepared by non-Khalsas. The oldest source of Sikh history is the Bhatt Vehis. In Guru Kian Sakhian, sakhi 99 about Guru Gobind Singh and Bhai Dalla of Sabo Ki Talwandi is as follows: " one day, Rai Dalla, requested with folded hands, "Maharaj! My wife Kapuro has asked many a time that you come and auspiciously visit our palaces. Kindly come into the Fort today." Agreeing to his modesty, Guru Jee alon wiht the other Sikhs came forward to visit the fort. The ladies of Rai Dalla bowed their heads to pay obeisance. Guru Jee took his seat on a modish bedstead. Guru Jee said to Rai, "Arrange the kitchen for the Khualse Sikhs on one side and the kithcen for the Bibeki Sikhs should be on the other side." Khulase Sikhs is a term for Sehajdhari Sikhs. So as you can see, Guru Gobind Singh himself, regardless of how much love he was shown kept bibek rehit. For other references, see the article on Bibek in the Gurmat section or search for other threads in the Forum. Bibek is not an optional rehit nor is it just a rehit for Singhs associated with the Akhand Kirtani Jatha. It is Guru Sahib's rehit. Singhs in the past and even now have made big sacrifices to maintain this rehit. Lots of Singhs whose families are not amritdhari or even Sikh make their own food at home.

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

kaur · 30 Jun 2006

dearest veerji, i definitely know how u feel and how much it hurts to not be able to follow what you believe in so strongly. But i think you also need to consider your parents strength in their own beliefs and no matter what you need to remind yourself for all they have sacrificed for you from childhood to now and realize that this is the family guru ji gave you and you must cherish it even for all their faults. it doesn't make you any less sikh jio...tell me...did sahib sri guru nanak dev ji not eat from the house of bhai lalo? he did...why? because bhai lalo made a living from honest labor. as long as you know that nobody cheated another to get that food on your plate then you must not discriminate so harshly. give your family time...give everyone around you time to adjust to the changes that you want to make in your life...otherwise too much change too quickly can result in hurt feelings...and a true sikh of guru ji should try never to hurt another's feelings. bhul chuk maaf karni waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

... · 30 Jun 2006

I think Dalvir Singh needs to do what he feels right doing. There is no doubt that eating from non-amritdharis is not acceptable according to rehit. If he can follow this rehit or not at this time is something he has to decide for himself. Guru Nanak ate from Bhai Lalo because he was a Gursikh. There are no examples of any Guru Sahibs eating food prepared by non-Sikhs that are reliable.

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

Jagvinder Singh · 30 Jun 2006

Dear balpreet singh ji, could you please give me more reference for that source, the author, year it was written, more info on it please. personally i think its fabricated.

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

Balpreet Singh · 30 Jun 2006

Jagvinder Singh, What makes you think it's fabricated ? Guru Kian Sakhian by Sarup Singh Kaushish is acknowledged as one of the oldest sources of Sikh history. It was written in 1790 based on Bhatt Vehis. Bhatt Vehis themselves are considered the most authentic sources of Sikh history and have been used by many historians including Harjinder Singh Dilgeer in his book "Guru Ke Sher". Scholar Piara Singh Padam was the editor of one edition and it has recently been translated into English by Pritpal Singh Bindra.

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

Sardar · 30 Jun 2006

Balpreet Singh Ji, GuruJi created one Khalsa, not two different sects of Sikhs. Anyways, there is enough evidence to support that GuruJi ate from non-AmritDharis' hands. And lets not tirn this into a arguement and help our fellow Sikh brother.

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

Balpreet Singh · 30 Jun 2006

Sardar, I have never said there were two Khalsas created. I'm not sure where you got the impression I did. I think you might be confused by the term "Khulasah" which is a term used for Sehajdhari Sikhs (not initiated) in all the Puratan literature. There is no doubt at all that Bibek of food is a fundamental rehit for Sikhs. There is only ONE Khalsa and that Khalsa has been given bibek as a rehit. If you have some evidence that suggests otherwise, please present it. The best way to help any Sikh brother is to let him know what is rehit. Whether he is able to follow this rehit in his situation is something he himself has to decide, but that doesn't change the fact that a rehit is a rehit.

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

Balpreet Singh · 03 Jul 2006

Bhatt Vehis are not written exclusively by non-Sikhs. Sarup Singh Kaushish was a Sikh. His fore-fathers were Sikhs. Bhatts like Narbad Singh and others were all Sikhs. As for your examples from history, the story of Guru Gobind Singh eating the offerings is a lie. I'm not sure where you read it, but it is an attempt to equate Guru Gobind Singh's childhood with that of Krishna, etc. Handi Sahib is built where a Sikh woman prepared the kichheri. It wasn't a random woman, she was a Sikh bibi and there was a Sikh Sangat at Danapur. You brought up Gangu: do you think Guru Gobind Singh would have a separate cook for himself and that too a Brahmin? Gangu was a cook for the Kashmiri Pandits not Guru Gobind Singh. I'm not familliar with your story from Suraj Parkash.

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

singh · 04 Jul 2006

if its ok to eat langar after kirpan bhayt, then why dont they do bhog to langar at Darbar Sahib? or any of the other major takhts?

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

f · 04 Jul 2006

you are making a HUGE deal out of this. sikhi isnt about crying over eating out of someones hands. it shows you have along way to go in understanding. who CARES man. you need to start unerstanding what gurbani is really telling us. minor thigns like this do not make up sikhi, nor is it waht gurbani preaches.

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

Singh · 04 Jul 2006

"Das Dalvir Singh"...just tell your dad that Sant Kartar Singh Bhinderanwale was a hardcore bibeki...to the extent, whereby if a Singh of the Taksali Jatha went home (for whatever reason) the first question Sant Ji asked on their arrival was...have you eaten from the hands of a non-amritdhari if they said yes...they would straight away have to go pesh before the punj just explain to your dad(whose Taksali) that bibek is not manmat...but Gurmat & that its a Rehit that Taksal accepts too. but AmritVela di Rehit is a must if one is to keep bibek (whether amritdhari or not)

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

shawanawa · 04 Jul 2006

if guru ji says look at everyone as equal, why do we look at them differently when eating from their hands? he says see them in the same light, to look at everyone with an impartial eye and to see ones Self, ie god. if we put this total mistrust and lack of faith in people, what use is our gurbani? essentially what it means is that the 'actions' our rehit is controlling us rather then the gurbani, and the true meaning behind rehit. now, im not saying eat from everyone and anything, you should use common sense. but if its someone you know who is cleanly and trustworthy, why not? for those who say eating from amrtidharis only, can you explain why guru ji says look at everyone impartially??

Re: Daas needs sangat's help!

Admin · 05 Jul 2006

Question is answered, topic closed.