NO smioke without Fire-the sinking Sikh Phoenix of Malaysia
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 01 Jul 2006
Some three weeks ago, while on visit to my homeland, I realised the true state of the Sikh identity prevalent in present day Malaysia and wrote about it and warned the kaum to come up with some strategy to check this erosion of the identity.It was a simple observation, no rocket science needed for this.
While many of the more active writers remained silent -knowing full well the truth in what was written ,some small time individuals ignorantly tried to defend it, one finding faults with the expressions used and other finding faults with typo errors and the meaning of phoenix etc.and another claiming the words mone was dergatory- while ignoring that these same monnes have have been derogatory towards their own Guru given roop and dastaar !Mind you, with such people in todays world, the Guru is just used upon their lips to pass their own views and time! It means nothing otherwise.They forget that degradation of the Guru given roop.
Some clever on even argued about the minimum identity- that will make a Sikh recognisable.I did not say that was acceptable, I said even that minimum is not present among most!
Another interesting item was these same people did NOT clarify themselves if they are condonong the erosion of the identity-patitpoona or making excuses for those who were patit or monne!But from their objections it was CLEAR they accepted that patitpoona was justifiable- at least that was the thrust of their argument!My complain was ..there is an increased number of Sikhs who have 'lost' their identity- a mild term when in actual fact these people have not lost their identity but DISCARDED it!
But no one came with or took issues about the concrete numbers that I had laid down about the identity of the majority present day Sikhs in Malaysia.It looks like a very fair amount of parbandhaks are patitis or mone or more still, shall we say rodde!No one said , we will take a survey among the Skh parbandhaks and see how many do don the dastaar or Sikh roop, even at its minimum in todays Malaysia.
What an individual does with his saroop is his problem, but the affairs of the panth are our concern-the collective concern of the panth.There can never be any compromise on that.
Interestingly shortly after my expossure of the truth of Sikh identity in Malaysia today, the only Punjabi newspaper of Sout East Asia-Malaya samachar published an interesting article again questioning the present day state of Sikh identity in Malaysia!So who is telling porky tales or being ecnomical with truth ? ?These individuals like........... or Malaya Samachar and me?May be their so called understanding of the language is not really what they portray they know!!They can be forgiven for that.
The Malaya samachar says "..aaj kal kaum wich patittpoona bahot waddh giya hai.Eh ek bahot nazuk masla hai kaum layee atte agge aun wali paniri layi......Jithe dekho dastaar lahi ja rahi hai ...aaj kal kaafi gurduare de parbandhak vi ese halat wich han"
Similarly, many poets and kavis too have written over the last few days about this issue,however I will share one more kavita that was published in the samachaar of 29th of June, which actually says EXACTLY what I wrote about the present day Sikh identity in Malaysia.
SIKH JAGAT NU HALUNA ( a cry for the Sikh world)
Sikha wekh zara gaur oye (Sikh-please take note )
pisshe lagyaan foki taur oye (you are after the material wordly show)
tun ghar Sikh de janamiya (you were born in the home of a Sikh)
dharra mush te kithe kes oye (where is your beard , moustache and hair ?)
tun bhol giyaan virsa apna (you have forgotten your own heritage )
bhol gya gur updesh oye (you have forgotten the Guru given message)
Dhan dhan gur da khalsa (blessed be the Gurus' Khalsa )
bina sis vekhaye jaur oye (who despite loss of head showed his skills)
jehrri deh nu lochan devte (the body which goddesses yearn for )
tun wich vishayaan de haarti ( you have lost for worldly matters)
tun pub kelabi rul gya'n (you are lost in the pubs and clubs)
teri mat nashiyaan ne maarti ( your intelligence has been retarded by alcohol)
jadon pag ser to'n lath gayi (where your turban is lost by you )
chuni lah deti wekh kaur oye (even the dupatta is being lost by the kaurs
Sikh wekh zara kar gaur oye (sikh pay attention and take note )
The kaivita written by Malaysian based Giani Balwinder Singh Dhaliwal,Gurduara sahib Port Dickson, goes on to speak about the kurbani of the younger sahibzade and then calls upon the Sikh youth to recalim back their lost heritage and identity !
This cannot be any further from the truth that is in Malaysia today.
There is no doubt there are small groups of Sikhs who are very dedicated and concerned enough to try and do something for the kaum.The Sikh Naujawan Sabha,the Punjabi clasess and the meetings like for the Sikh Agenda are powerful thrusts into that direction where the eroding identity of the community can be checked.But I believe these efforts need more support and enlightening in the community for the community to take note and check what is happening.There is simply an attitude of could not care less about the dastaar.
The start has also to be made in gurduaras where parbandhaks MUST revert back to Sikh roop to start with, if they genuinely want to do sewa and have the desire to see the Sikhi that should be.Having books and guide booklets to the dictum in a gurduara is of no use if the parbandhaks themselves do not start with themselves as an example.Full stop.There are already many guides, how are these folowed?
After all there is no smoke without the fire and the smoke and fire cannot be hidden for long !!!
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
Re: NO smoke without Fire-the sinking Sikh Phoenix of Malaysia
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 02 Jul 2006
Dear Veer ji, I dont doubt your expressions.If you were around last year this jathebandi was taken to task.but silence prevailed and no accountability was dispensed from them.
But if you see the situation that the kaum is in and the loss of the identity --one qwill wonder what the word SIKH means any more to these people from Malaysia.
I have just found out how the so called ex jathedaar of the SNSM has been entrtaining the RODDA MODERATOR of Sikh Diapsora dduring the rmona moderators visit to Mlayaisa so as to get a glowing report to say sabh accha hai- when in reallity sabh accha NAHI!
Rab Hi Rakha kaum da.
Re: NO smioke without Fire-the sinking Sikh Phoenix of Malaysia
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 02 Jul 2006
Humkire, I have no doubt about what you have said.I agree that this small organisation has done a lot that cannot be matched by any.But of late some cracks have appeared where either because it has diverted its attention to international affairs and lost track or just that it's recent leadership is taking Sikhi far more easy - it is a genuine concern about the state of Sikh identity in the country today.
Unfortunately someone took the opportunity to take pot shots at SNSM, but on the whole I think they have done a great job, and from now onwards need to looks the issues closley so that they can be more effective.
There is no doubt irrespective of what positive or negative critisism the SNSM takes,NO Malaysian SIkh who is concerned about the present state of affairs will still rally under the flag of the SNSM to do their sewa.
The issue here is NOT the SNSM, but the declining sight of the Sikh turban in the malaysian peninsular.However hurtful it sounds, we must look for ways to combat this patitpoona in our youth.
The kaum has been shaken, if from this hurtful article some good comes out and we are able to check the patitpoona, then I feel humbly that I have been proven wrong and will accept any penance from the panth.But the fact many more have become dastaar dhari and proved me wrong, then I feel humbled but that we have achieved the objective in increasing the dastaar dhari is good enough for me.
Re: NO smioke without Fire-the sinking Sikh Phoenix of Malaysia
have heard it all before! · 03 Jul 2006
very nice dream -the trouble then and now is... then we were being suppresed and had to live to fight and now we willingly are shedding sikhi as we see beautiful girls and as another faith offers us the money or just for fashion or politics....that is the difference.....live in a real world, and not beautiful diarhheao of words. humkire ji, every body tells us all is accha , but really is it ?!
Re: NO smioke without Fire-the sinking Sikh Phoenix of Malaysia
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Jul 2006
Dear Veer Humkire jio,
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh.
Thanks for bringing in a fresh new perspective on things taking place especially in malaysia. I like the way you see things..please dont lose heart..Malaysia needs people like your good self to push forward.
Your LOVE for Guru Gobind Singh Ji..and Sikhi outshines everything else..way to go bro..same over here..if we all beleive faithfully that we all have the same Father Pita ji Guru Gobind Singh ji..then its half the battle won..and onward..march..Guru ji truly EMPOWERS His OWN !!
Re: NO smioke without Fire-the sinking Sikh Phoenix of Malaysia
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Jul 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh.
Gall hagee PRINCIPLES dhee !! WE all have MONA friends...some even have MONA relatives..sons..daughters ( YES DAUGHTERS TOO !!)..BUT we should NEVER sacrifice our Principles to satisfy anyone. Thats the crux of the "problem"..Just like Baba deep Singh Ji drew a line and declared..cross over or stay behind...its the SAME here..either you stand for GURU and SRM (Gurmatt) or you are for your monaism (Manmatt).
I know GURU is far away..and our MONAS are nearby...so it becomes awfully difficult to choose between the two..irs so easy to "disown" the GURU..but hey its impossible to disown your own flesh and blood..life long friends..etc etc. I understand....but then be brave enough to state it so..dont be two faced..among Gurmatt people declare Haan Ji Gurmatt..GURU..SRM..is very important....and then wehn among monas..tell them..its ok yaar..this is the real world..after all you also contribute daswandh for the Gurdawra..you cna be Pardhaan..why not yaar..soem are too conservative/pichankhichoo/kattar maryada blah blah blah..i am liberal yaar..its ok with me i see the real person not his prhrava..blah blah. THESE TWO FACED ones are the real culprits..NOT the MONAS !!
They have NO PRINCIPLES..Ganga gayeh taan Ganga Raam..Jamuna gayeh taan jamuna Dass..Radhasoami mil piya taan Dhan guru Gurinder Singh Ji..ate je Nirankari mil piya..Dhan Satguru Hardev Ji..ate je Jathedar Vedanti takkar piya taan Zor de ke..Akal takhat Kee Jai ho..AAseen AKAL TAKHAT de naal haan...
Thats all. Sikhi is about Sarbatt Da Bhalla...BUT it is NOT about Sarbatt Maryada THEEK Hai.. we dont seek bad about anyone..BUT a SIKH is one who follows SRM/Gurmatt. Period. Sikhs can be of various shades and standards...but only those who continue to "progress"....towards GURMATT.
Re: NO smioke without Fire-the sinking Sikh Phoenix of Malaysia
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 05 Jul 2006
veer humkire jio,
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
i have no words to describe the happinss i felt reading your post..but one thing i can share with you..our pita ji dhan dhan dhan guru gobind singh ji works in very mysterious ways to keep a watch over his piyaare..i am very very happy - beyond words to read about the parchaar you are doing..and will do...and offer my humble ardass at the lotus feet of our beloved Guru Ji that He keep you ever more showered by his blessings. Bless you. this message not only made the proverbial day..it has made my proverbial month ( at the very least)..i was very very sad after the events of july 2nd..but you lifted up my spirits. thank you. stay in chardeekalla veer and carry on your parchaar...
JsGyani.
Re: NO smioke without Fire-the sinking Sikh Phoenix of Malaysia
JSGyani "arshi" · 11 Jul 2006
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh.
At the 19th AGM of the SNSM - Sikh naujawan Sabha malaysia the 19th Jathedar elected unanimously by the greatest number of Sabha Members present ever is a unthaak sewadaar of 30 YEARS..Sardar Malkith Singh - Amrtidharee and full sikhi sroop. With over 3o years of Solid Kaar sewa - the Honest to goodness Dasan Nauhaan naal ketee sewa type under his Kamarkassa..he is definitely the new wave of Sikh Leadership. The SNSM and the Sikh Sangats have a lot riding on thsi new Leadership..to stem the tide of monaism that is spreading all over and even in Sikh Organsiations. The SNSM stands solidly for SRM and Keshadharee sewadaars in its Committees and Management...somethign which should be emulated by the Sikh gurdawras and the Gurdawras Council.
Recently a MONA Moderator came all the way from UK and while admitting shamelessly to the Keshadhree Sroop as being MAJESTIC, REGAL Sabat soorat Dastaasira..still went on to say he is insulted by being called MONA as he is also just as sikhs as the dastaardharee and that he too can look majestic regal ?? People who FLUSH down a little bit of Sikhi Principles down the Bathroom Sink daily..claim they are Sikhs ?? who is fooling whom ?? Character Assasination and underrmining of the SRM through their self set up forums and groups seems to be the only weapons in their arsenals..although they also drop hints of..( i have high ranking police officials as relatives ??) who are these trying to scare ?? Nobody is scared of such antics. at home they grow chick peas in their garden and on the forums they claim they are high class sikhs...Only a KHALSA is Caste Free..anybody else remains with his BORN CASTE - even if he tries to fool himslef that he is a sikh and so no longer the low caste he was born as. A "Puthha Tava" Tamil is better than such a sikh as he is true to his beleifs even though he amy be black skinned...but a black skinned mona is nothing.
FULL SROOP SIKHI is spreading like wildfire through out the world..these monas are living in a fools paradise as they dream of one day controlling the Gurdawras and being Jathedars at Akal Takhat..wherever Sikhi si in "decline" it si DUE mainly to the established "leaders and aape banneh Jathedars and commanders in chief" who paid more attention to getting larger numbers to be their forum members and akal purakh ki copy cat fauj soldiers..instead of gettign on teh ground as foot soldiers.
Re: NO smioke without Fire-the sinking Sikh Phoenix of Malaysia
Gurcharan Singh kulim · 11 Jul 2006
Congragulations to the Sikh sewadaars and HONEST SIKH Roopis members of the SNSM, who have voted a Khalsa sikh to the jatheraari- sr Malkith Singh ji.We pray and hope the SNSM will SOMETHING to chnage the flow of tide that has been around for sometime in malaysia - that is the abandoning of Sikh SAROOP.
Much hue cry went up from pro monapoona and monas and also those who dont have any understanding of the Punjabi language or even English lnaguage wo were shouting foul when their antics an dthe real state of affairs of Sikh saroop in Malaysia was exposed by me.
I hope Malkith Singfh ji will return the SNSM to proper parchar and reverse what leaders or commanders of a certain man made fauj have done to the Sikh saroop in the last twenty years they have been manipulating the scene in malaysia.
ironically, these poeple were os blined that when the state of affairs was exposed by me on a visit..one of their colonel's was ASKING ME for solutions!Is it not ironic they did the mess and after I made an observational report they wanted anspwers from ME!! is this areflection of their bankrupt mentality ?
But anyway we hope the new jathedar Ji,will take the Sikh saroop to great and new heights and damage the aspirations of those are trying to bring about the acceptance of monism into the panth!
Congragulations to Sikhs of malaysia who care for the Sikh saroop and dastaar and to Malkith Singh JI!