Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

WHY? · 01 Jul 2006

As all Gursikhs are fully aware that the Khanda is affiliated as a philosophy and nishan for the Khalsa and the Khalsa Panth. However, why have the punjabis, who believe in consuming alcohol, meat, intoxicants, bhangra, etc etc (list goes on)... why have they hijacked an emblem which so moral and honour to wear have robbed it and associated it towards their own immoral and dishonourable deeds and worst of all have tatooed their body by making it a designer label. An example is here: http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/4-PURE-PUNJABI-T-SHIRTS-Sikh-Khanda-Panjabi-Sikhism_W0QQitemZ140003012900QQihZ004QQcategoryZ53043QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

actually · 02 Jul 2006

the khanda originates from the ad chand which is donned by nihangs. Nihangs dont have a problem in consuming alcohol, meat, intoxicants, bhangra etc. . . . . so, the truth is that people who do have a problem with the nihang practices, have hijacked the nihang symobol. why??

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Jagvinder Singh · 02 Jul 2006

no, thats rubbish. what do you mean by the nihangs dont have a problem with consuming alcohol, meat, intoxicants n bhangra..... cut the sarcasm dude. i guess everyone is entitled to their own views regarding chatka and drinking sukha. but look at baba nihal singh harianvela wale. he dont do sukha, eat chatka, and hes a bibeki. trust me, there are still nihang singhs left who dont fit your stereotype and are really chardikala. i dont know abt the uk nihangs tho. so, please,please, just because of a few of them, dont stereotype all the nihangsinghs into one negative category.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Why? · 03 Jul 2006

Actually, I went to Harianvela and all the perform is seva, simran and sacrifice... and as Jagvinder Singh says "dont do sukha, eat chatka, and hes a bibeki" whcih is totally correct... I bumped into loads of these wannabe nangs and they have come from rajistan which is flooded by poverty and dope, to escape it they have robbed guru sahibs roop and deluded individuals like yourself... My question is not about these nangs... its about funjabis embezzling the panths nishan What do we recite everytime we do our nitnem within japjee sahib asa(n)kh moorakh a(n)dhh ghor|| asa(n)kh chor haraamakhor|| Countless fools blinded by ignorance|| Countless thieves and embezzlers|| [%sig%]

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

some1 · 03 Jul 2006

so r u saying ur not punjabi (sorry if your a non punjabi sikh).? Cause even Sant ji takled about his Punjbi heritage.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

guruji's_student · 03 Jul 2006

you cnt judge all "nihangs" ... on some ppl .. who consume bhang!! .. there not sikhs nor nihangs!! i know a lot of nihang singhs who are ck!!! ... so dnt judge some ppl on all iof them ... waheguru

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Why? · 04 Jul 2006

I am not takled about Sant ji (who ever that maybe as theres so many)? Nor about Jalibi heritage

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

chingahri · 04 Jul 2006

whats wrong with jalebi heritage? let the punjabis carry on. They know its sikhism that made punjab the name. Dont worry mate time changs things. As punjabis loose their real heritage they will also one day have to wake up to what they lost and then come scattering back from the waves of deceptive maya.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

anonymous · 04 Jul 2006

anyone notcied that the iran flag has a khanda like object in the middle too. maybe they stole it aswel. but yh everywhere u look u see khandeh, its stupid. its like the christian cross, people just wear it around their necks for fashion.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

sidhu proud bhatti · 04 Jul 2006

these punjabis need to become sikhs first

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Because · 04 Jul 2006

Because without Sikhism these "Punjabis" would not have an identity. They would be little to no different from the Bhaiyas, Beharis and the rest of the Indian peoples. It is Sikhism that gives Punjab somewhat of a distinct identity from the rest of India and nothing else.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

yeah · 04 Jul 2006

in the same way you cant judge all nihangs from bibeki vegetarian nihangs - there are many who have sukha, eat meat and have alcohol

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

some1 · 04 Jul 2006

so are most of you claiming to not be punjabi? if so how can PUNJAB BE KHALISTAN.?

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

shawanawa · 04 Jul 2006

if you think that is bad then check out the "Iced out SIKH KHANDA Hiphop bling Pendant & chain" http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Iced-out-SIKH-KHANDA-Hiphop-bling-Pendant-chain_W0QQitemZ200003770322QQihZ010QQcategoryZ49744QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Because · 05 Jul 2006

All of this "Punjabi" stuff is the product of overseas Indians. It has nothing to do with the actual people or culture of Punjab. People from Punjab who have migrated to the West now have their own subculture/identity which should not be labelled as "Punjabi". It should be labelled as Indo-Candian, British Asian, Punjabi American or whatever else along those lines.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

some1 · 05 Jul 2006

all these ppl u lable punjabi over here are as much punjabi as they are sikh... so cut it..

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

No1 · 06 Jul 2006

some1 you are a no1 lol

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Sardar · 08 Jul 2006

Sikhism and punjabi culture seriously doesn't go together. These punjabi songs have to stop including Sikhism in it.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

some1 · 09 Jul 2006

Why? WHo r u to tell a Sikh who sings in punjabi not to sing about sikhi? Sikhisim and punjabi go hand in hand.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

No · 09 Jul 2006

No. punjabi culture is dirt. Sikhism and Sikh culture should be kept free from filthy punjabi "culture"

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Sardar · 09 Jul 2006

>>>>Why? WHo r u to tell a Sikh who sings in punjabi not to sing about sikhi? Sikhisim and punjabi go hand in hand.<<< Dear Sister/Brother "some1": Punjabis existed long, long, long before Sikhism came into form. Punjabi culture is all about drinking and diong other stupid sins on purpose and calling that "enjoying life". I'm not saying oh it's wrong that these singers sing about Sikhism because it does somewhat contribute to Sikhism even though they're Non-Sikh. But what I don't like is when they have those jatts with smiley faces, flower-style paagh(lol!), doing bhangra and girls doing gidhaa and theres all this other stupid stuff in there but at the same time it also includes Sikhism, like that stupid song about jatts which goes like"oh jatt punjabi dosto sanu maan punjabi haun da", and at the same time they show some lady "doing Paat" and then she hands out "parshaad" to her son who was haircut and didn't even cover his head when he took the "parshaad". And his father who was standing beside him also takes the "parshaad"and hes wearing that jatt-flower thing paagh. And the father covers his son's head with hankerchief after his son takes the "parshaad" with a bare head. And oh ya they also have Sardar Bhagat's photo at the back too. See this type of stupid stuff I'm talking about. If they wanna sing about Sikhism, then they better make separate songs, not include jat shrabi stuff in there. But even if those singers make separate songs about Sikhism, on the other hand they make those stupid songs where they would have girls dancing and jatt stupid stuff in there. Hans Raj Hans does Kirtan and still he makes those songs which have girls and all this stupid stuff in there. These people think they're Sikhs, even if they know nothing about Sikh Religion. But most importantly, even though they're not even AmritChak and don't even do Paat, they think that they're Sikh. They think they're automatically Sikhs. And "some1", as for your Punjabi Culture and Sikh Religion going hand-on-hand.......NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NEVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Sikhi forbids so many things that the Punjabi Culture includes, Punjabi Culture came from HIndus and Muslims, not Sikhs. Punjabi Culture has the stupid caste system, and Sikhi doesn't believe in it. Punjabis think Khanda is some jatt sign or a punjabi sign, while they don't even know why the Khanda has 2 Kirpans, 1 Khanda in the middle, and the Chakar around the Khanda. They don't even what the means, and who does it really represent.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

some1 · 09 Jul 2006

Do u not dare call my culture dirt. Ur an idiot if u deny ur punjabi heritage. This neo-punjabi agreed is grossely wrong, but PUNJABI culture what it was, went hand in hand iwth sikhi. MIND UR SELF .

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

some1 · 10 Jul 2006

k mangaye pravoh u r all much better then punjabis who are sikhs. u must be the off spring of some very qualitatious non-punjabi punjabi families.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Dalbir · 10 Jul 2006

You guys do know that the Khanda is a relatively new symbol (from the 1930's). I saw this old picture of Harmandir Sahib once and it had a different flag, with a single kirpan, katar and I think a degh on it.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

No · 10 Jul 2006

Look i dont give a crap about some man-made Hindu origin "punjabi culture". Aside from the name "punjab" which was given by the Mughals the rest of "punjabi culture" is more-or-less hindu with a dash of Islamic Sufi influence. Sikhism and Sikh culture is a separate entity from pooooojabi culture. It is wretched poojabi culture than needs Sikhism to survive. Sikhism does not need 'punjabi culture'.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Dalbir · 10 Jul 2006

"It is wretched poojabi culture than needs Sikhism to survive. Sikhism does not need 'punjabi culture'." Very true....but Panjabi bravery and recklessness has come in handy! What we could do with now is great scientific minds!

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Non-Sikh by Choice · 10 Jul 2006

<<>> Can you explain your comment with more depth? I like to know why Punjabi culture needs Sikhi even though the Punjabi culture itself is anti-Sikhi to begin with. <<>> LOL Interesting...It’s funny how you criticize a song/music video, but yet, you know every little detail of the music video you were describing in your post. Why are you watching these music videos if you hate Bhangra/Punjabi culture to begin with? I am sure watching these music videos are helping your “Sikhi”. *rolls eyes* [%sig%]

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

amarjeet singh · 10 Jul 2006

some1 stop speakin so much rubbish its giving me a headache if you have nothing sensible or true to say just keep quiet.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

some1 · 10 Jul 2006

congrats every1 cussing ur visra ur ma boli ur aan like this.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Sardar · 10 Jul 2006

hey you non-sikh by choice, i don't watch music videos. i think it was my sister who put on this music video on the computer once, and i was just watching the stupidity in the song. lol! they have proud over being farmers!!! [%sig%]

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

PTE SINGH · 11 Jul 2006

I think you will find that Sikhi has survived and thrived very well in Punjabi Culture. Remember there is a good reason that Punjab was where Sikhi was born and that all the 10 Guru’s were themselves Punjabi. They never lost sight of their background, remember the gurus chose and maintained Punjab as their base and the centre of Sikhi. Those that think that Punjabi culture is limited to Drinking and dancing are idiotic. Punjabi culture throughout the world stands for Honour, integrity, Humanity, fairness and tolerance. Punjabis have always shown bravery and fortitude and a never say die attitude against adversary, and it is these very values that are ingrained in Sikhi. [%sig%]

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

. · 11 Jul 2006

"Those that think that Punjabi culture is limited to Drinking and dancing are idiotic. Punjabi culture throughout the world stands for Honour, integrity, Humanity, fairness and tolerance. Punjabis have always shown bravery and fortitude and a never say die attitude against adversary, and it is these very values that are ingrained in Sikhi." Sorry but in my trips to Punjab so far I saw none of this.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

. · 11 Jul 2006

"Author: guruji's_student Date: 07-03-06 08:02 you cnt judge all "nihangs" ... on some ppl .. who consume bhang!! .. there not sikhs nor nihangs!! i know a lot of nihang singhs who are ck!!! ... so dnt judge some ppl on all iof them ... waheguru" This is very silly. The vast majority of Nihangs DO consume meat and drugs. There may be small sections who do not but the majority do - only Sikhs living in a "bubble world" Western countries who have never had real experience with Nihangs in Punjab, would say other wise. Bhang and Jhatka are not minority practises in the Dals but are mainstream and accepted. Even those who do not consume it still acknowledge it and do not criticise it.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

some1 · 11 Jul 2006

haha **** PTE Singh u said what i could'nt say in so many posts. Of course people are proud of being farmers u idiot.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Anti-Crap · 11 Jul 2006

Im sorry but the Sikh Guru's were not "punjabis". Please do not apply this label to Guru Sahiben when they did not use it themselves! In fact, the words "punjab" and "punjabi" were not even in use or existence during the life-time of Baba Guru Nanak. No where do the words "punjab" or "punjabis" appear in the compositions of Guru Nanak. Call them Sikhs, call them Humanists, but dont insult and degrade Guru Sahiben by applying the "punjabi" stamp on them. Now whoever said that punjabi culture values integrity, honour, fairness, tolerance etc must be bloody joking! The typical punjabi is among the most dishonest, two-faced, cowardly, jealous and selfish excuse for a human being you could ever come across. Ever seen a punjabi defend themselves one-on-one? Never, and they never will. I am embarrassed about the number of incidents i have seen and heard about punjabis getting bullied, beaten up or robbed and how they can only win a confrontation when the odds are like 3 or 4 to 1 by jumping someone after a night out or something (usually another indian/punjabi). Honour, integrity etc are values promoted by Sikhism, not by crappy culture of punjab and rest of india. Without Sikhism, punjab does not have any distinct identity from the rest of the subcontinent. The people of eastern pakistan (sindh, punjab) and northern india are all apart of the same racial stock, have overlapping linguistic and caste identities, share common heritage, history and culture etc If its is "bhangra" that makes punjab "distinct" then all that can be said to that is people all over india and parts of west asia use a dhol in their own fashion so that hardly amounts to a great and unique culture... But to each their own. If you identify with "punjabi" culture, that is entirely your choice and thats fine. But dont confuse it with Sikhism and Sikh culture, and dont get mad when the Sikhs dont allow highjacking of Sikhism and Khalsa by "punjabis".

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Harcharan Singh · 12 Jul 2006

When Guru Nanak Dev Ji graced this world, Punjab and Punjabis were nothing more than a land of humiliated, downtrodden, lost, faithless and courageless slaves. It was Sat-Guru who awoke them, gave them sight, focus, courage, strength, honour, meaning, happiness, peace and a chance at achieving mukti. The location, culture and land is of no significance in it's own right, God recognises no land, culture or faith, only truth - and it was that which Guru Sahiban brought to the world. It is certainly true that there it is no coincidence Punjab was chosen i.e. there was injustice and large scale evil occuring, but it is also true that Punjab and Punjabi's hold no special significance, if it they did, Sikhi would not be a universal faith, created for all man from all corners of the planet, it would be gift to punjabis only. although there are historical Gurdwaras etc, the gift that Guru Ji gave us was written, and can be experienced and relaised without one ever having to visit Punjab or know Punjabi culture. It is this exact Punjabi loving and fusing (with Sikhi) attitude that many non-punjabi people who are interested in sikhi loose interest, because they are made to believe that caste, bhangra, drinking, meat, pride, wealth, big flash weddings, dowry, people who descend from Punjabi but who are not baptised claiming to be Sikhs etc ... are part of the Sikh culture. It is important to always seperate Punjabi and Sikhi. The only area that is common to some extent is the language and poetic/singing styles seen in bani. That aside the 2 are distinct, one is Manmukh the other Gurmukh. Vahe-Guru.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

erm · 12 Jul 2006

listen, why dont all you wasters get on with your school work- go to the gym- get a job - basically, do something useful.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

PTE SINGH · 12 Jul 2006

To author . , I'm sorry that you have only had the misfortune of bad experiences when visiting Punjab, however for you to make such generalised and offensive statements without provocation on simply your own experience shows that you have a very narrow outlook on life. To anti crap, I and any other true Punjabi will quite happily show you the fine attributes we posses, just have the class to call us cowardly, dishonest and from a crappy culture to our face. Unlike yourself I am not hiding my e-mail or my name and would be happy to enlighten you on Punjabi culture whenever it would suit you. Infact why don't you also share your name and Town on this forum as boldly as you share your views and i am sure that one of my fellow Punjabi's who is local to you will quite happily pop round to educate you. Regards Pte M Singh Sodhi Gravesend (UK) [%sig%]

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

lols · 12 Jul 2006

Dear erm, School work - yea I study loads life long learning Work - Yea I do from 7.45am till 6pm x 4 days a week gym - I do three times a week Kung Fu - Yea I do, 4 times a week What do you ? sharpen your pencils all day?

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Canadian (Non-Sikh by Choice) · 12 Jul 2006

You know what I find funny about this......Is that Khalsa Sikhs are supposed to be brave and strong compare to Punjabis, but here in Canada, it us Punjabis (Jatts to be exact) are more bigger, stronger, faster and braver than these so called "Singhs". If wasn't for us Jatts, a lot of these "Singhs" would get beat up by everybody easily here in Canada. People don't mess with Sikhs because us Jatts, not because these "Singhs" LOL Truth hurts, eh?

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Dalbir · 12 Jul 2006

I guess the Khanda has become a symbol for a lot of people. Once though I met a "Sikh" girl from Northern England (Midlands), she used to go out every weekend to raves, take all sorts of drugs and generally tart about........and she wanted to get a Khanda tatooed on her arm...... I nearly cried.........

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

lol · 13 Jul 2006

Canadian, >>are more bigger, stronger, faster and braver Dont make me laugh, have you ever heard of the saying "It aint the size of the dog in a fight, it is the size of the fight in the dog" and another well known sayin "The bigger they are the harder they fall" It is well known that Bhai Bhachitur Singhjee was short in height, but had a fearless heart, when a intoxicated elephant was about to attack anandpur sahib.. bhai bhachhiatar singhjee went at the elephant with a long spear and pearced through its armour and went into the elephants head making it go crazy and reverted and attacked its very owners [This particular spear is perserved on the premises of Kesgarh sahib, anandpur sahib]. Okay you may not know about that but you may heard of a reknowned chinese kung fu master named Bruce Lee, it is well know that he was 5 foot 7" and he was able to knock out easily a heavyweght boxer. So, what does the above explain that people like you think that you are lions however in reality your just a poodle that go round roaring like lions. [%sig%]

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Dalbir · 13 Jul 2006

Sometimes it seems like caste is a major issue with Sikhs in Canada. What is typical however is that once Sikhs have no external threat to themselves they always fall into infighting. Look at the misls for example, once the Moguls and Afghans were no longer a threat they started fighting each other. It's dumb moves like that which cost Sikhs their empire! Although put really distastefully, I can understand the point made by Canadian (Non-Sikh by Choice). Even when I was growing up in London, Kesh dhari Sikhs used to get bullied alot. When trouble reared its ugly head it was mostly monay who dealt with it and made most sacrifices, even if many of them were sharabi kebabi types. Yeh, Im proud of my history, roots too, but we can't keep pulling out the Bhai Bachittar Singh's story.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Jagvinder Singh · 13 Jul 2006

my cousin, a typical punjabi proud jatt from punjab, was watching punjabi virsa... and in that, a guy was singing a song... "hath vich kara payaa hovay pehchaan punjabi di" which means, a punjabi is recognised by the kara on his hand. they even hijacked our kakaar now. lol. somebody ask him, if a tamil wears a kara, is he a punjabi then? heh. im sick of these guys man... and he was like... kara bakshish hai guruaan di. yes, thats true, its a guru's gift. but shouldnt you also listen to the guru's hukam for you to be a khalsa, if you really want his blessings? its like double standards man. AND oh yeah, CANADIAN, you talk the talk huh, why dont you walk the walk too. Khalsay chup kar kay baithey hundey haan es da eh matlab nahi ke sanu talwaar chalauni nahi aundi. why dont you come down to singapore sometime and look me up.And yeah, i'll also try teaching you a thing or two about equality of man regardless of castes. gotta change your 13th century mindset to year 2006. 138 race course rd my mobile no. is 94520671. Look me up when you're down in singapore. I might have to show you the might of guru gobind singh ji's ladla, if the need arises.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

some1 · 13 Jul 2006

Honestly veeroh, when was the last time you heard of a Singh doing a brave act in Canada? Or even fending off would be attackers? All i hear is Sikh is beaten up on temple property, Sikh youth attacked blah blah. Never Youth fends of assailgents. Not saying that Jatts do own, but I've def heard those stories.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Bhudysut · 13 Jul 2006

Wahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Wahiguru Ji Ki Fateh I think that the Khanda has been hijacked by certain idiotic factions wanting to be a part of something they have no clue about! I think the perfect example of this are the morons of Jattworld (who regularly try and post their delirious nonsense on this respectable forum see 'Canadian non-Sikh by choice' post!). When I was shown their site they openly talked about putting pornographic images onto their pages, yet with a big Khanda on one corner of their screen! Canadian non-Sikh by choice Ji, your comments raised are somewhat short-sighted. If the Jatts were bigger, stronger and smarter (as you stated), why were they continuously pillaged, murdered and raped by Babur and his desendants up until the time of the Guru's. There is a vast difference between Sikh's and Jatt's (read Major Barstow's memoirs for reference). I think you have to look at these so-called Punjabi performers also. I recently saw a music video with Jazzy Bains and he and all his entourage were wearing these very shiny large Khandey, so the Khanda has almost become a fashion accessory to all and sundry. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Ji Dass Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Dalbir · 13 Jul 2006

If you read Bachitar Natak in the Dasam Granth, it says their that after his first few battles, Guru Gobind Singh Ji expelled all the people from Anandpur sahib who didn't fight. Also like I said before the Khanda in its present form is only 70/80 years old. Some people over emphasise the piri side of Sikhi in their lives and the result is sometimes high spirituality but with cowardice. On the other hand some over emphasise the miri, or worldly power and you people in Canada, esp. Vancouver can see the result of that, with greed and corruption talking over the mind leading to all that drug dealing and death (johal etc.) pursuing worldly power. A balance is needed either in an individual (i.e. sant-sipahi) or at a higher corporate level, where the community balances itself out because it contains a mixture of the two.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Sardar · 13 Jul 2006

Punjab. This word meaning Land of the Five Rivers. Is it the land of the five rivers anymore? NO! Before Shiri Guru Angad Dev Ji Mahaaraaj Ji, was there any way you could write in Punjabi? NO! Well you shouldn't really call it "punjabi alphabets" really they are GuruSahibanJi came up with GurMukhi Alphabets, GurMukhi is different from punjabi. Just because a Sikh farms, does not mean she/he belongs to "punjabi virsa".

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Dalbir · 13 Jul 2006

Bhudysut wrote There is a vast difference between Sikh's and Jatt's (read Major Barstow's memoirs for reference). ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Barstow, from what I've read seems to equate Sikhs with jatts. Can you back your above statements with quotes Bhudysut?

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Canadian (Non-Sikh by Choice) · 13 Jul 2006

“lol”, Why didn’t you quote my FULL sentence instead of just quoting few words only? Here’s what I said: “Is that Khalsa Sikhs are supposed to be brave and strong compare to Punjabis, but here in Canada, it us Punjabis (Jatts to be exact) are more bigger, stronger, faster and braver than these so called "Singhs".” Notice how I ONLY mention about Sikhs IN CANADA? As for the rest of your comments, well I will take it as a joke. Lol <<>> Umm actually, this should only apply to you Singhs out there that keep using history to make yourselves look like lions, but the REATILY is, it’s Punjabis are doing all “seva” in our community. Please, stop talking about the past. No one is scare of you. In fact, some of the “Singhs” here on this thread are agreeing with me. I hope you notice that as well. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Dalbir, First of all, I like to apologize to you and rest of the people who found my last post to be offensive. I made that comment because your fellow “Singhs” were saying nasty things about Punjabis and I wanted give them a reality check. <<>> Actually, caste isn’t such a big problem here in Canada. The only time “caste” might become a problem here is when comes to marriage. But besides that, caste isn’t an issue here in Canada compare to the UK or Asia. You wouldn’t find too many caste based Gurdwaras here in Canada unlike the U.K. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Jagvinder Singh, <<>> LOL! Deal! When I feel like spending couple thousands of dollars to travel some 3rd world country like Singapore, I will give you a call then. Anyway, I think you need do some research before labeling Jatt as a caste. Just for the record, I am very westernized person. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Bhudysut, <<>> Funny you said because it seems like the Admin/Mod don’t find my post to be disrespectful. If you are going to call me a moron, then does make the Admin/Mod a bigger moron for letting my post go through in the first place? You need to be very careful of what you are saying. <<>> Once again, just like “lol”, you take my post out of context. Here’s what I said: “Is that Khalsa Sikhs are supposed to be brave and strong compare to Punjabis, but here in Canada, it us Punjabis (Jatts to be exact) are more bigger, stronger, faster and braver than these so called "Singhs".” Notice how I ONLY mention about Sikhs IN CANADA? <<>> Here’s what Major Barstow said about Jatt Sikhs: "They (Jat Sikhs) are manly without false pride, ---. No one could be associated with them for any time without conceiving both respect and liking for them". He went on to say, "the Jat Sikhs sent a very high percentage of their eligible men to the army". In fact the Jat Sikhs attach extremely high regard to the military and police services. The people who give their lives in battles or otherwise for a good cause in their eyes are regarded as the most honourable heroes. The modern Jats have up held the tradition of their forefathers.” [%sig%]

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Jagvinder Singh · 13 Jul 2006

Canadian, singapore a 3rd world country? go check, the exchange rate of a singapore dollar with a canadian dollar.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Canadian (Non-Sikh by Choice) · 13 Jul 2006

1.00 CAD Canada Dollars = 1.40137 SGD Singapore Dollars http://www.xe.com/ucc/convert.cgi [%sig%]

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Dalbir · 13 Jul 2006

I guess a lot of us are wondering what direction Sikhi will take next, seems to have a life of its own. Bigger than any component parts in my view. WJKK WJKF

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Jagvinder Singh · 14 Jul 2006

exactly, Canadian, so never call singapore 3rd world. its just a difference of 40 or so cents. you get a kick out of looking down on people from asian countries dont you? dont forget where you came from man, dont forget your background.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Bhudysut · 14 Jul 2006

Wahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Wahiguru Ji Ki Fateh Dear Canadian non-Sikh by choice Ji, I just wanted to comment on your remarks. Whether the admin on this forum find your post disrespectful or not is NOT in question. I imagine the reason the respected admin of this forum allowed your post up was more to do with objectivity than reverence. My disagreement is with you and your post and not with this forum and the people it represents. So your logic is totally flawed! I think it is you who should be extremely careful of what they are purporting to. I think Dalbir Singh Veer Ji reinforced my point regarding your whole Canadian Sikh/Jatt position. Situations in Vancouver and Toronto are nothing to be proud of! Without trying to sound like an egoist, I would rather be respected than feared. Respect is gained and fear never gains respect. I imagine the right-wing factions of Canada are just sitting back and laughing, whilst the Punjabi youth go around murdering each other over drug money and making general fools of themselves. Here is where my indictment of short-sightedness is evidenced again. As I have noticed with many of your Jattworld comrades, you are not very partial to reading a whole book. I have some advice when you nit-pick at books, you only gain half a story. To quote Major Barstow (page 155 ‘The Sikhs’ – An Ethnology): “As has already been explained, the virtues of the Jats are identical with those of the Sikhs, but the latter possess in a higher degree, the ardent military spirit which had its origin in the warlike precepts of Govind Singh...................One of the highest qualities of Sikhism is its power to improve the social condition of its adherents by removing the trammels of caste. As a Mazbhi Sikh, the despised Chura or sweeper at once becomes a valiant and valued soldier, and imbued with the spirit of his martial faith loses all memory of his former degraded calling.” (Dalbir Singh Veer Ji, I humbly hope that satisfies your request) As for your comments on Singapore being a third world country! Well, the difference between the Canadian dollar and the Singapore dollar is not that great. Also according to that, what does this say regarding the status of Canada compared to the UK? 1.00 GBP United Kingdom Pounds = 2.08394 CAD Canada Dollars (Please Sangat Ji, I do not believe that Canada is a third world country, I am just trying to make a point!) Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Ji Dass Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Canadian (Non-Sikh by Choice) · 14 Jul 2006

Bhudysut, 1. Don’t try to associate me with Jattworld. I have no connection with them at all. 2. People like McLeod has acknowledge that Jatt were the backbone of Khasla. If you don’t believe me, then read his book on history of Sikhs. 3. U.K. is a joke! I find it funny how brown people live in country that once invaded their motherland and rape their women and kill their brothers in large numbers while stealing all their riches/assets from India. Also I find it funny how U.S.A has U.K. on its knees. It shows how powerful U.K. is today. *rolls eyes* 4. Punjabis in Canada are highly respected especially when comes to politics. Punjabis are not laughing stock in Canada unlike you U.K. Sikhs who usually get beat up by whites, blacks and Muslim youths. Please don’t try to deny this because we all have heard stories about this on Sikh websites including this website. This is just one example! Anyway, people fear, but at the same time respect Jatts/Punjabis here in Canada. [%sig%]

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

kirtan lover · 14 Jul 2006

Canadian (Non-Sikh by Choice) Please stop there.. YOUR becoming a laughing stock.

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

agreed · 14 Jul 2006

canada non sikh sher ahktha "U.K. is a joke! I find it funny how brown people live in country that once invaded their motherland and rape their women and kill their brothers in large numbers while stealing all their riches/assets from India. Also I find it funny how U.S.A has U.K. on its knees. It shows how powerful U.K. is today. *rolls eyes* " n how nice were the canadian sikhs treated by the canadioan establishment when the british empire ruled india? third grade citizens mate! n sikhs themselves willingly were the backbone of the british army too this could include your own forefathers dude. and thats while the assets and riches were stolen as you say. i roll me eyes too. things are just the way they are, why should you i or anyone take any bull for someone elses tamasha? a sikh is a sikh stop using plonker statements. The reality is a few people get busted and then its blown out of proportion, that does not exact to mean 700 000 uk sikhs are sitting on their bundhs getting whacked. The vast majority of punjabis in uk in heavy concentrations in west london, gravesend, and other areas actually do not take crap. How in the flaming world can you take a few stories on this site to tarnish all sikhs living in one country???????????????????????? ok so canadian jatts are feared? lol now what? moucha patla sheeshe samneh shatti khol lah sirch badam rogan malee chal! what else you want a medal and a gold bhaali and a besan bread on the other hand with a canadian maple leaf decorated haar round your neck. why you so uptight? relax the ego, we have cousins all over the joint in canada, there is no them and us silly billy

Re: Punjabis hijacked the Khanda

Admin · 14 Jul 2006

Thread Closed.