badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
inderjeet singh · 02 Jul 2006
fateh sangat ji
i just got off from tv now where i saw badal and mann groups clashing with each other in the manji sahib in prescence of guruji.......................
well just happened sum 30 mins back...................
its the occasion of 400 years of prakash....and all the singhs were there..............badal as he unofficially heads sgpc got the chance to speak started playing his sick politics and spoke about some akali congress stuff................this offended the mann group and all d guru ki fauj"the nihangs" there as it wasnt the occassion for politics..................
mic was snatched.........and a chaos happened all in the prescence of guruji and guruji was quickly taken away from the scene....................
the last i saw was the nihangs with their swords out..................
now basic conflict is that badal we all know is a pro-bjp,rss fellow and very much a nationlist and so against khalistan....................but the rest all akcnowledge wot the indians did......badal doesnt bother.
man its on national tv here in india (thank god only one channel was there to cover it)..............and they going like "talwarein nikli and pagdiyaaan uchhali"..............
this is sick but one good thing though badal wont dare speak politics again he's gotta be scared ..........the spat is still on ..........the nihangs were al over the place with their kirpans........and i think righlty so
no what i stay in delhi and about 2 years back during dsgpc elections on front page of a leading newspaper there was this big photo of a sikh pulling another sikhs kesh with his tuban off just because he belonged to sum other group..................
the damn non-sikhs sum of them in collg thought it was funny but i couldnt say anything......wot could i...............
waheguru ji...........wot a shame??????
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
JEEVAN SINGH · 02 Jul 2006
WE ALL NEED TO STAND BY S S MANN AND PROF DARSHAN SINGH VERY STRONGLY WRIGHT NOW THEY NEED US!!!!!!!
[%sig%]
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Prabhjoyt Singh · 02 Jul 2006
a truly shameful disgraceful and disgusting incident
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Jul 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh.
I can only repeat the call..... "O POLITICIANS...QUIT OUR GURDWARAS !!" as posted on the Front Page of the Saptahak / Rozana Spokesman.
Our Gurdwaras have become the POLITICAL STAGE for these RASCALS to fignt thier petty battles. How FORTUNATE that we have SO MANY 300/400/500 SHATABDEES to Celebrate in our LIFE TIME....and how UNFORTUNATE that we have WASTED all of them on "petty political maneouvering by the GOLAK CHORS entrneched in our Gurdwaras..EACH "Shatabdee" has just been a means of wasting Golak Money on "Emphasising the POLITICIANS..and for their Personal GLORY...at the Recent 400 th Sri guru Arjun Ji Sahib Ji's Shatabdee in Taran taran..I saw More POSTERS of Badal and FAMILY ( son and wife) than posters on Guru Arjun Ji. IN fact More posters of GURU ARJUN JI were "TORN DOWN" by these people simply because they carried the words DGMC at the bottom !!!..
With Photos of NIHUNGS ( belongng to the Baba Harian Welan Wala among others) brandishing NAKED SWORDS INSIDE the Manji Sahib hall and in the PRESENCE of Sri guru garanth Sahib jee....how can we then turn around and tell the World that the SIKH SWORD/KIRPAN is NOT a WEAPON ?? That we be allowed to carry such on airplanes and all over ?? Isnt this a SAJASH to SABOTAGE the "campaign to allow Kirpans everyhwere " ?? It is..definitely it is. No one in his right mind will beleive us anymore....the evidence of "Sikh Violence" is too graphic !!! The Goras and others will just say..Come on Singh.you must be joking..you mean the Singhs slashing their swords in front of Guru Ji are just "playing" ?? and KNOCKING OFF another Singh's DASTAAR in front of Gur Ji is also a joke only ?? Then WHY you people get so angry if a Customs officer asks you to just remove your dastaar for small check up ??
And how quickly the Five " High Priests".... found fault with one party and sacntioned them....the sad episode of the SGPC NOT INVITING Prof Darshan Singh to its shatabdee stages and then crying "foul" when he attended the Govt Stage purely as Kirtaniya...and the calls to the FIVE to "excommunicate" the Ex'Jathedar for attending that Stage as Ragi is being heard all over...NO one in his right mind will beleive that the Five are Neutral and Panthic..they also have their own Dharra...
Dharam Pankh kar udriya..Guru nanank Ji in Asa Dee Vaar.....how TRUE. Guru Ji Please come and save us from ourselves.... SIKHI nu SIKHAAN KOLON BACHAO...SAVE SIKHI from the SIKHS....especially those sitting on its highest THRONES....
Sri Guru Hargobind Ji was on the Gurgadee of Satguru Nanak Ji for 38 years... the LONGEST of any Guru except the Founding aad Guru - Nanak ji Sahib. Guru Hargobind Ji's Father was Shaheed, His Son Guru Teg bahadur was Shaheed....and His Grand-son Guru Gobind Singh Ji was Sarbans Daani. ..entire family shaheed !!
After the Shahedee of Guru Arjun Ji, Guur hargobind Ji put on the Twin Swords of Miri and PIRI and put the Sikh kaum on a New Footing and ESTABLISHED the Akal takhat right in front of Darbaar Sahib Established by His father Guru Arjun Ji and and Grandfather Guru Ramdass Ji Sahib. This event of the Formation of the Akal Takhat is of such monumental proportions in Sikh history that it is often called the Turning Point or Corner stone or Milestone.
How then did the SIKH KAUM celebrate the 400th Shatabdee of this Turning Point in Sikh history....by a relatively LOW KEY simple Akahnd Paath over just three days...in a place where hundreds of such Akhand Paaths go on all the time.
In 1984 some POLITICIANS conspired to smash down the "physical Building" of the Akal Takhat....and this time it seems these same politicians conspired to Smash Down the Very PRINCIPLES of Akal Takhat...by staging the exact same drama as in 1984. The Building of AKal Takhat could be rebuilt..in fact it was twice over..BUT this Latest ATTACK on the Basic Principles, the Dignity and Maryada and SUPREMACY of Akal takhat will be very difficult to rebuild. 1984 pictures of the Army attack on Akal takhat splashed around the world to prove Sikhs are terrorists..and violent...this time around similar pictures flashed around the World...SIKHS with DRAWN SWORDS hacking at each other, throwing each others dastaars on the Ground with complete DISREGARD to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee's Prescence !! IS this any way to show the world the 400th Shatabdee of Akal Takhat ??
The 400th Shatabdee of Akal Takhat should have been such a huge affair...celebrated for at least ONE FULL YEAR...concurrently with the 400th Shatabdee of Sri guru Arjun Ji....a Truly UNIQUE opportunity to Show in a Practical manner the TWIN PRINCIPLES of MIRI and PIRI that showcase Sikhi and Gurmatt.
With deepest of anguish....
JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI"
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
singheee laad. · 03 Jul 2006
This ia badals way of getting back at Mann for his speach at Taran Taran, Manns speech was inspiring he talked about how nothing has changed in 400 years how Sri guru Arjan Dev jee was persecuted for being a sikh and giving langar to wanted people, he said today singhs arer tortured and thrown into jail for feeding hawara jee and his companian's.
He said the the sikh nation is not free.
You could see badal was very angered by it...
he has now got his own back.
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Jagjit Singh · 03 Jul 2006
Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, below is quoted from the above article by varinder Walia, who has a pro-badal bias.
"Bhai Mohkam Singh, spokesman of the Damdami Taksal, Bhai Baldev Singh, President, Akhand Kirtani Jatha, Mr Onkar Singh Thapur and U.K-based Dal Khalsa leader Manmohan Singh Khalsa, while expressing concern over today’s incident blamed Mr Mann for it."
As far as Mokham singh, most people wonder how much he believes in the principles of the past jathedars of the Taksal. Baldev singh was ex-communicated by AKJ on a worldwide basis, and has nothing to do with AKJ. The only person who recognises him is Badal, and that seems only for these press releases. As for Manmohan singh, lets not even go there, as most youth from Southall/Slough know his links with Chaudary in Southall, the very person who was funding muslim gangs against sikh youth.
Although what happened in manji hall was not right, one thing is clear, a movement is gaining momentum against Badal and his years of betrayal. He is desparately clutching to power, and he is rattled by SAD Amritsar continual remindings to him on stage about what betrayals he has done.
I think you will find throughout the Panth, very few people will be against Maan, but alot with be against badal.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Kulbir Singh · 03 Jul 2006
Its true that Baldev Singh does not represent the majority AKJ sangat in India but then where is presence of the real jathedar of AKJ in press? This is a question that we must address. It was important for AKJ to have voiced opinion in this matter but unfortunately the Jatha leadership is totally aloof of the political developments in Panth. The current AKJ leadership in India is not active, nor committed to the Panthac causes. AKJ needs a functioning jathedar. Admit it or not, Harnaam Singh is a very proactive jathedar of Taksal. By comparison, Jatha is performing really poor.
Kulbir Singh
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Prabhjoyt Singh · 03 Jul 2006
who are Baldev Singh and Mohkam Singh to blame anyone, two tru badal chamchay
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Jul 2006
Author: singh
Date: 07-03-06 08:21
js arshi.... if u didnt know.. i got a news flash for you.. THE KIRPAN IS A WEAPON, AND IS MEANT TO BE ONE, WHETERH U TRY TO MASK IT TO GORAI OR NOT, ITS STILL A PRACTICAL WEAPON
*******************************>?????
Veer Ji..of course it is a weapon.....BUT on the BATTLEFIELD...to fight agianst INJUSTICE..on the side of the DOWNTRODDEN..and the weak...to defend the Poor and those who seek our help...
But do you really want to "emphahsise" the "WEAPON" part to a Customs/immigration official at the AIRPORT ?? I would rather emphasisie as veer humkire says..as a GIFT FROM MY GURU. As " a GIFT from the GURU JI" we are sometimes allowed to take it along (maybe)..but as a weapon..110% NEVER. so take your pick. In my country Malaysia...we are "allowed" to carry the Kirpan...without too much show off/advertising..its just a understanding ( based on GIFT from GURU JI) as the country law says clearly NO WEAPONS of any kind..not even a switch blade !! So if I was to keep BRANDISHING my KIRPAN....as a weapon..i would soon have it taken away and myself land in trouble ( many Granthis and ragis from Punjab have suffered this ignominy at the hands of the local police).
Please forgive any offense i may have caused to you by these remarks..i am too deeply hurt by what happened at Amritsar... Love to all.
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006
--------------
Kulbir Singh ji
Pls don't take this the wrong way, but if you have 'concerns' about the current leadership arrangements of the Jatha in India.
Nows your chance to speak to the Jatherdar Pooran Ji yourself, as I beleiev he is now in Toronto, so pls go and speak to him about these 'concerns' 'issues' etc.
----------------
Pokhar neer viroliye, Maakhan nahi reesay||
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
GurSikh wannabe · 04 Jul 2006
Kulbir Singh - what do you mean by this?
"Pokhar neer viroliye, Maakhan nahi reesay||"
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006
---------
Kulbir Singh - what do you mean by this?
"Pokhar neer viroliye, Maakhan nahi reesay||"
-----------
It means that you cannot get makhan (butter) by churning water.
Kulbir Singh
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Charanjit singh · 04 Jul 2006
Kulbir Singh maybe you fancy yourself as a better jathdar rahter than Pooran ji ???
your just a Kid and need to get a grip , if you got thte gaul then speak to Pooran ji directly rahter than making cheeky comments on the internet
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006
---------
Kulbir Singh maybe you fancy yourself as a better jathdar rahter than Pooran ji ???
------------
Such Jathedariyaan may be Mubarik to you. I don't need it.
---------------
your just a Kid and need to get a grip
-------------
Shows that you are really grown up.
---------------------
, if you got thte gaul then speak to Pooran ji directly rahter than making cheeky comments on the internet
-------------
What's wrong about making a comment about our leadership? What's wrong is wrong and we should not get upset over constructive criticism. Which Singh would contest that the need of this hour is to have strong leadership that can do us proud. Is it a sin to raise such valid questions?
Kulbir Singh
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006
---------
Kulbir veerji, all we are tryna say is if u feel that and u have the OPEn oppertunity to bring it upto him...u should do so.
----------
And I veer jee / Bhain jee, prayed that "pokhar neer viroliye, maakhan nahi reesay". Somethings are better off not said. I prefer to keep this particular one as status quo.
Kulbir Singh
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
JEEVAN SINGH · 04 Jul 2006
we should not allow sgpc and badal members to speak on gurdwara stages in foreign countries !!
if they stop us in panjab why can't we stop them here ?
[%sig%]
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
reghsdfgsdfh · 04 Jul 2006
did neone record this beadbee that happened??
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Kulbir Singh · 05 Jul 2006
UK Singh jeeo,
--------------
If you intended not saying anything, why say it in the internet!!!!!, now you have aired your thoughts, then surely the correct way of expressing them is direct to Jatherdar Pooran ji himself!!!!!!! rather than over the internet!!!!!!
It seems simple sense to me :)
--------------
Why is the correct way of expressing only in person? When we express our opinions about other leaders like Badal, Tohra, Maan, Dhumma, Sant Samaj, do we actually go in person to express our opinions? I don't think so. So why should there be a different stand when talking about AKJ leadership?
And all I said was that the role of our leadership should be more proactive and dynamic. I don't see why such a comment cannot be made on a forum. My comment was not geared specifically towards Bhai Surat Singh only but towards whole of AKJ leadership that has been totally absent from the forefront of Panth and the wrong person Bhai Baldev Singh is forcefully representing AKJ at all panthak forums.
AKJ jathedar should not only be a person with bhagti but also one who has leadership qualities i.e. can represent jatha at all fronts. Bhagti and Shakti go hand in hand. Miri and Piri go hand in hand. The jathedar needs not only piri but also miri. Bhai Raam Singh in his younger years did a fabulous job of leading Jatha in tough times of post 1978. Now too the AKJ leadership needs to realise that if it does not play an active role in Panth, it will hurt the whole jatha. Along with listening to kirtan, the jathedar should do at least the following:
1) Play an active role in Panth.
2) Actively do parchaar of Sikhi in India and abroad. Look how hard Bhai Harnam Singh Dhuma and Bhai Ram Singh are working. They are going pind to pind doing parchar. What is the jathedar of Jatha doing as compared to other jathedars in Panth?
3) Jathedar of Jatha should keep rehit of Khalsa that Singhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee used to keep. The jatha should do parchar of Tatt Gurmat maryada and bring acceptace in Panth for Dastar, Mundawani, Laridaar Saroop, Sarbloh Bibek etc.
The above are my personal thoughts and I repeat these are strictly my personal thoughts. I have nothing personal against anyone. All I want is to see Jatha and Panth Khalsa in chardi kala. Chardi kala will come from above i.e. from leadership. Chardi Kala will not come if we give up rehit. Chardi Kala will not come if we get upset hearing constructive criticism. So again, meri hath jor ke benti hai, lets all keep rehit, japp naam and do parchaar of Sikhi.
Kulbir Singh
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
Kulbir Singh · 05 Jul 2006
UK Singh jeeo,
I am pretty sure that what I have written on this forum will reach him. There is no need for me to go to him for this. Do you think I don’t know he is in Toronto at this time? I do know and still I chose the medium I thought was best to voice my concerns. I have my reasons for doing what I did, and the way I did. Perhaps if you meet me in person, I will explain you the reasons. Certainly not on an open forum.
Kulbir Singh
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
JEEVAN SINGH · 06 Jul 2006
Nihaal Singh Nihung is a puppet of badal and always has been !!
he was sacred of sant bhindrawale ji thats why he kept himself low key !
his thugs were first to pull their swords out at akal thakt sahib
[%sig%]
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
JEEVAN SINGH · 06 Jul 2006
every one needs to get together on this issue and stand strong in one voice and start a mass movement against badal and his thugs !
they have done to much damage to the panth, they are pushing us into a panth vs panth war, ddt they've split, akj they've damaged, federations and thakts are under their belts !!!!!
so khalsa ji please wake up and support panthic organistions like bhai daljit singh bittu, dal khalsa etc, prof darshan singh ji khalsa.
[%sig%]
Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib
JSGyani "arshi" · 11 Jul 2006
Recently all the Forums have been flooded with mails by MONAS gleefully showing how Dastaardharee Khalsa fight in Gurdwaras... these MONAS fail to see the Second Echelon leaders of these same dastardharees are MONAS and Beard trimmers...
The Truth is these "dastaardharees" are no more Khalsa than their MONA sons..BOTH must be chased out of the Takhats and Gurdawras..