Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

inderjeet singh · 02 Jul 2006

fateh sangat ji i just got off from tv now where i saw badal and mann groups clashing with each other in the manji sahib in prescence of guruji....................... well just happened sum 30 mins back................... its the occasion of 400 years of prakash....and all the singhs were there..............badal as he unofficially heads sgpc got the chance to speak started playing his sick politics and spoke about some akali congress stuff................this offended the mann group and all d guru ki fauj"the nihangs" there as it wasnt the occassion for politics.................. mic was snatched.........and a chaos happened all in the prescence of guruji and guruji was quickly taken away from the scene.................... the last i saw was the nihangs with their swords out.................. now basic conflict is that badal we all know is a pro-bjp,rss fellow and very much a nationlist and so against khalistan....................but the rest all akcnowledge wot the indians did......badal doesnt bother. man its on national tv here in india (thank god only one channel was there to cover it)..............and they going like "talwarein nikli and pagdiyaaan uchhali".............. this is sick but one good thing though badal wont dare speak politics again he's gotta be scared ..........the spat is still on ..........the nihangs were al over the place with their kirpans........and i think righlty so no what i stay in delhi and about 2 years back during dsgpc elections on front page of a leading newspaper there was this big photo of a sikh pulling another sikhs kesh with his tuban off just because he belonged to sum other group.................. the damn non-sikhs sum of them in collg thought it was funny but i couldnt say anything......wot could i............... waheguru ji...........wot a shame??????

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

JEEVAN SINGH · 02 Jul 2006

WE ALL NEED TO STAND BY S S MANN AND PROF DARSHAN SINGH VERY STRONGLY WRIGHT NOW THEY NEED US!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Prabhjoyt Singh · 02 Jul 2006

a truly shameful disgraceful and disgusting incident

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

P.S.Sandhu · 02 Jul 2006

Veer ji. They are not Sikhs..they are maligning Sikhism...they will get punished...n matter, either its chandu or badal..or barnala ...they will weigh their pan..

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

kaur · 02 Jul 2006

Tempers flare up at Akal Takht Mann, Badal men clash at Manji Sahib Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, July 2 The quadricentennial celebrations of the foundation of Akal Takht would go down in the history of the Sikh panth as the “blackest day” as turbans of SGPC chief, Mr Avtar Singh Makkar, president, Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar), Mr Simranjit Singh Mann, and some other Sikh leaders fell off in the presence of Guru Granth Sahib and Sikh high priests, at Manji Sahib inside Golden Temple Complex here today. Jathedars of the five Takhts had a tough time as chaos prevailed even before the “ardas” and they had to carry Guru Granth Sahib away hastily, hurting the sentiments of the Sikh sangat present on the occasion. Shockingly, the Task Force of the SGPC, Akali MLAs and some senior leaders fled from the scene and failed to safeguard Guru Granth Sahib, leaving the stage open for the angry SAD (A) supporters. In the no-holds-barred clash, members of Badal and Mann factions of SAD used swords, lathis and attacked one another with fists and blows — something unprecedented in the history of SGPC. It was for the first time that even the “ardas” of the religious function could not be completed as tempers flared up. Consequently, the Sikh high priests postponed the bhog of “akhand path” to July 21. The trouble started when the SGPC did not give time to Mr Mann to address the Sikh sangat after Mr Parkash Singh Badal and Jathedar Makkar had spoken. Within no time, SAD (A) men captured the stage and its president Mr Mann made his followers raise the demand for ‘‘azadi’’ (freedom) amid slogans of “Bole So Nihal…”. SAD (A) activists also raised slogans like ‘‘Badal murdabad’’ and ‘‘Mann zindabad’’. The incident occurred even as a number of banners like “Akal Takht mahan hai, Sikh panth di shan hai’ adorned the walls of Harmandar Sahib . While SAD (A) supporters captured the stage, SAD (B) and SGPC men escorted Mr Badal and the SGPC chief to a safer place. The SGPC chief said it was not his but the ‘‘turban of the Sikh panth’’ that had fallen off. Mr Mann, however, said a fitting reply would be given to pro-Badal activists who had removed his turban. He claimed that it was the Sikh sangat which had raised the demand that he should be given time to speak on this historic occasion. However, Mr Badal and SGPC chief said it was the sole right of the SGPC to decide who would be allowed to speak or not. Mr Mann claimed that he had participated in the function on the appeal of Jathedars who had said Akal Takht’s ‘‘Sirjana Divas’’ should be celebrated jointly. He said it was not the function of SAD (B) only. Mr Badal alleged that Mr Mann had repeated the acts of his ‘‘nana’’ (maternal grandfather Aroor Singh who had honoured General O’Dyer at Akal Takht after the Jallianwala Bagh massacre. Mr Mann said he had already sought unconditional apology from the Sikh panth for the acts of his grandfather and maintained that, ‘‘Mr Badal had not tendered any apology on behalf of his grandfather, Fateh Singh, who had allegedly added poison in water during Jaiton Morcha’’. Meanwhile, the unfortunate developments have caused concern among the well-meaning people in general and shocked the devout Sikhs in particular. Earlier, the clash on February 22, 2003 involving activists of the Shiromani Khalsa Panchayat, members of the Sikh Students Federation (Mehta group) and employees of the SGPC inside the SGPC complex in which 19 persons had been injured had hit the headlines. Today’s incident evoked strong reaction from the Sikh masses who described it as highly regrettable and avoidable. The latest developments show that the SGPC has not learnt any lessons. The clash, points to the failure of the SGPC’s crisis management system, they maintained. Earlier, in his address, Mr Badal had sought the help of Sikh sangat to bring SAD back to power in the state. Bhai Mohkam Singh, spokesman of the Damdami Taksal, Bhai Baldev Singh, President, Akhand Kirtani Jatha, Mr Onkar Singh Thapur and U.K-based Dal Khalsa leader Manmohan Singh Khalsa, while expressing concern over today’s incident blamed Mr Mann for it. However, Mr Jaswant Singh Mann, President of the All-India Shiromani Akali Dal said SAD (A) should have been given time to address the Sikh sangat. He said infighting among Sikh groups was an unfortunate development.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

kaur · 02 Jul 2006

Sikh clergy’s edict on boycotting Mann, 5 others Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, July 2 In an unprecedented directive, pronounced shortly after a clash on the concluding function of quadricentennial celebration of the foundation of Akal Takht, the five Sikh high priests have urged the Sikh sangat not to allow SAD (Amritsar) president Simranjit Singh Mann, an SGPC member, Youth Akali Dal president and three other leaders of his party from speaking at any Panthic platform. Interestingly, SAD (A) senior vice-president Daljit Singh Bittu, has been spared despite him being present at the time of the clash. The others who have been indicted for “insulting Guru Granth Sahib” and indulging in the clash as part of a “deep-rooted conspiracy” were SAD (A) general secretaries Bhai Ram Singh and Gurjatinder Singh Bhikhiwind, Youth Akali Dal president Barinder Singh Mann, Baldev Singh Sirsa and SGPC member Harcharn Singh Burj. The Sikh clergy also directed not to extend any support to those indicted. It is perhaps for the first time in the 400-year-old history of Akal Takht that such harsh suo motu action has been taken after convention of an emergency meeting. The action has apparently been taken in the light of statements made by Parkash Singh Badal and Avtar Singh, presidents of the SAD and the SGPC, respectively, shortly before the meeting of jathedars. The directive is viewed as a “step short of excommunication” without adopting complete procedure. Both Mr Badal and Avtar Singh had already announced that Mr Mann won’t be allowed to participate in such functions in future. However, SAD (Longowal) president Prem Singh Chandumajra described the directive of jathedars “hasty” and urged them not to play “partisan role”. He said Akal Takht belonged to entire Sikh Panth. Meanwhile, Mr Mann has decided to convene a meeting of all Panthic organisations shortly to take stock of the situation arising out of the pronouncement of the directive.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Singh · 02 Jul 2006

Bhai Mohkam Singh, spokesman of the Damdami Taksal, Bhai Baldev Singh, President, Akhand Kirtani Jatha, Mr Onkar Singh Thapur and U.K-based Dal Khalsa leader Manmohan Singh Khalsa, while expressing concern over today’s incident blamed Mr Mann for it.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

righton · 02 Jul 2006

Bhai Mokham Singh of DDT...Interesting

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Jul 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh. I can only repeat the call..... "O POLITICIANS...QUIT OUR GURDWARAS !!" as posted on the Front Page of the Saptahak / Rozana Spokesman. Our Gurdwaras have become the POLITICAL STAGE for these RASCALS to fignt thier petty battles. How FORTUNATE that we have SO MANY 300/400/500 SHATABDEES to Celebrate in our LIFE TIME....and how UNFORTUNATE that we have WASTED all of them on "petty political maneouvering by the GOLAK CHORS entrneched in our Gurdwaras..EACH "Shatabdee" has just been a means of wasting Golak Money on "Emphasising the POLITICIANS..and for their Personal GLORY...at the Recent 400 th Sri guru Arjun Ji Sahib Ji's Shatabdee in Taran taran..I saw More POSTERS of Badal and FAMILY ( son and wife) than posters on Guru Arjun Ji. IN fact More posters of GURU ARJUN JI were "TORN DOWN" by these people simply because they carried the words DGMC at the bottom !!!.. With Photos of NIHUNGS ( belongng to the Baba Harian Welan Wala among others) brandishing NAKED SWORDS INSIDE the Manji Sahib hall and in the PRESENCE of Sri guru garanth Sahib jee....how can we then turn around and tell the World that the SIKH SWORD/KIRPAN is NOT a WEAPON ?? That we be allowed to carry such on airplanes and all over ?? Isnt this a SAJASH to SABOTAGE the "campaign to allow Kirpans everyhwere " ?? It is..definitely it is. No one in his right mind will beleive us anymore....the evidence of "Sikh Violence" is too graphic !!! The Goras and others will just say..Come on Singh.you must be joking..you mean the Singhs slashing their swords in front of Guru Ji are just "playing" ?? and KNOCKING OFF another Singh's DASTAAR in front of Gur Ji is also a joke only ?? Then WHY you people get so angry if a Customs officer asks you to just remove your dastaar for small check up ?? And how quickly the Five " High Priests".... found fault with one party and sacntioned them....the sad episode of the SGPC NOT INVITING Prof Darshan Singh to its shatabdee stages and then crying "foul" when he attended the Govt Stage purely as Kirtaniya...and the calls to the FIVE to "excommunicate" the Ex'Jathedar for attending that Stage as Ragi is being heard all over...NO one in his right mind will beleive that the Five are Neutral and Panthic..they also have their own Dharra... Dharam Pankh kar udriya..Guru nanank Ji in Asa Dee Vaar.....how TRUE. Guru Ji Please come and save us from ourselves.... SIKHI nu SIKHAAN KOLON BACHAO...SAVE SIKHI from the SIKHS....especially those sitting on its highest THRONES.... Sri Guru Hargobind Ji was on the Gurgadee of Satguru Nanak Ji for 38 years... the LONGEST of any Guru except the Founding aad Guru - Nanak ji Sahib. Guru Hargobind Ji's Father was Shaheed, His Son Guru Teg bahadur was Shaheed....and His Grand-son Guru Gobind Singh Ji was Sarbans Daani. ..entire family shaheed !! After the Shahedee of Guru Arjun Ji, Guur hargobind Ji put on the Twin Swords of Miri and PIRI and put the Sikh kaum on a New Footing and ESTABLISHED the Akal takhat right in front of Darbaar Sahib Established by His father Guru Arjun Ji and and Grandfather Guru Ramdass Ji Sahib. This event of the Formation of the Akal Takhat is of such monumental proportions in Sikh history that it is often called the Turning Point or Corner stone or Milestone. How then did the SIKH KAUM celebrate the 400th Shatabdee of this Turning Point in Sikh history....by a relatively LOW KEY simple Akahnd Paath over just three days...in a place where hundreds of such Akhand Paaths go on all the time. In 1984 some POLITICIANS conspired to smash down the "physical Building" of the Akal Takhat....and this time it seems these same politicians conspired to Smash Down the Very PRINCIPLES of Akal Takhat...by staging the exact same drama as in 1984. The Building of AKal Takhat could be rebuilt..in fact it was twice over..BUT this Latest ATTACK on the Basic Principles, the Dignity and Maryada and SUPREMACY of Akal takhat will be very difficult to rebuild. 1984 pictures of the Army attack on Akal takhat splashed around the world to prove Sikhs are terrorists..and violent...this time around similar pictures flashed around the World...SIKHS with DRAWN SWORDS hacking at each other, throwing each others dastaars on the Ground with complete DISREGARD to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee's Prescence !! IS this any way to show the world the 400th Shatabdee of Akal Takhat ?? The 400th Shatabdee of Akal Takhat should have been such a huge affair...celebrated for at least ONE FULL YEAR...concurrently with the 400th Shatabdee of Sri guru Arjun Ji....a Truly UNIQUE opportunity to Show in a Practical manner the TWIN PRINCIPLES of MIRI and PIRI that showcase Sikhi and Gurmatt. With deepest of anguish.... JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI"

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

singheee laad. · 03 Jul 2006

This ia badals way of getting back at Mann for his speach at Taran Taran, Manns speech was inspiring he talked about how nothing has changed in 400 years how Sri guru Arjan Dev jee was persecuted for being a sikh and giving langar to wanted people, he said today singhs arer tortured and thrown into jail for feeding hawara jee and his companian's. He said the the sikh nation is not free. You could see badal was very angered by it... he has now got his own back.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

sarbloh · 03 Jul 2006

Bhai Baldev singh will be next akal takht jathedar as he has decided to lick the shoes of Badal.Sad even the AKJ has got polluted.I hope the admin allows it. Wahegurujeekakhalsa Wahegurujeekeefateh

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Jagjit Singh · 03 Jul 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, below is quoted from the above article by varinder Walia, who has a pro-badal bias. "Bhai Mohkam Singh, spokesman of the Damdami Taksal, Bhai Baldev Singh, President, Akhand Kirtani Jatha, Mr Onkar Singh Thapur and U.K-based Dal Khalsa leader Manmohan Singh Khalsa, while expressing concern over today’s incident blamed Mr Mann for it." As far as Mokham singh, most people wonder how much he believes in the principles of the past jathedars of the Taksal. Baldev singh was ex-communicated by AKJ on a worldwide basis, and has nothing to do with AKJ. The only person who recognises him is Badal, and that seems only for these press releases. As for Manmohan singh, lets not even go there, as most youth from Southall/Slough know his links with Chaudary in Southall, the very person who was funding muslim gangs against sikh youth. Although what happened in manji hall was not right, one thing is clear, a movement is gaining momentum against Badal and his years of betrayal. He is desparately clutching to power, and he is rattled by SAD Amritsar continual remindings to him on stage about what betrayals he has done. I think you will find throughout the Panth, very few people will be against Maan, but alot with be against badal. Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

M Singh · 03 Jul 2006

Bhai Baldev Singh, so called AKJ chief, wants Badal to honor him by some good post; he will stand by him till he gets something from Badal.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Kulbir Singh · 03 Jul 2006

Its true that Baldev Singh does not represent the majority AKJ sangat in India but then where is presence of the real jathedar of AKJ in press? This is a question that we must address. It was important for AKJ to have voiced opinion in this matter but unfortunately the Jatha leadership is totally aloof of the political developments in Panth. The current AKJ leadership in India is not active, nor committed to the Panthac causes. AKJ needs a functioning jathedar. Admit it or not, Harnaam Singh is a very proactive jathedar of Taksal. By comparison, Jatha is performing really poor. Kulbir Singh

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

S Singh · 03 Jul 2006

Mokham Singh is a buddy of the RSS and also has links with the GOI. He is a very dirty individual. I wonder why the Taksal do not boot him out for good as to date he has never done or said anything panthic.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

some1 · 03 Jul 2006

excommunicate Mann? obviously GOI has a control of the "jathedars" of the takhts. its a shame when there are talks about banning the most panthic man in the panth.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

humkire · 03 Jul 2006

arshi ji, thank you so much fer that lovely post that is so expressive ,articulate and details and summarises this whole situation which really angers us all beyond belief . as you have tried to say ,i so agree with you that sgpc and akal takht need to rise above party politics and be freed from the clutches of any political masters who have hijacked them . i would have been such a happy person to see both the shaheedi and akal takht celebrations to be all inclusive affairs involving everyone from the various socio-political-religous strands within our panth both national and international. we dont have a problem if this people want to destroy themselves ,dats their own fate ,but meddling in the affairs of the panth manipulatively to cause it harm and tarnish its image is a very very serious matter for which they need to be severely punished and eradicated .this is my firm view in total agreement with you .i can only vaguely imagine the retribution and punishment that lies ahead for them in the court of dharamraj wen the day of reckoning comes . sarbat khalsa has to decide who the jathedars of sgpc ,and the 5 takhts are ,independently ,not goi,badal or amarinder or anybody else .and these people need to have a futuristic ,progressive ,all inclusive ,revolutionary,vision of khalsa panth which rips off old outdated paralytic structures,and is modelled along present and future needs and developments within the panth .they need to take advantage of new technologies ,they need to be ambassadors of the panth ,they need to be unifiers ,and people with intellectual brilliance ,spiritual stature ,futuristic vision,charisma ,appeal ,humility and dynamism .we need the wonder-boys of sikhism to be in charge ,not this pack of idiots .sorry for my language . thanks again for yer very inspirinational post which highlights in dazzling brilliance the eternal marriage between the sheedi and the akal takht formation and their absolutely important significance.keep it coming please .we need more from you . [%sig%]

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

singh · 03 Jul 2006

js arshi.... if u didnt know.. i got a news flash for you.. THE KIRPAN IS A WEAPON, AND IS MEANT TO BE ONE, WHETERH U TRY TO MASK IT TO GORAI OR NOT, ITS STILL A PRACTICAL WEAPON

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

humkire · 03 Jul 2006

singh, u need catch the drift of wat arshi is tryng to say.its a weapon ,yes ,but its gurujis beloved gift to us ,and it is not to be abused .wat arshi is trying to say is that its wrongful use gives people the impression that we too are are a violent people like islamic terrorists and that we are not cultured enough to be able to celebrate an important festival in a peaceful ,spiritual ,and dignified way . u need to go easy with arshi .he has in his post expressed in a succint manner the emotions we are all going thru fer wat hapened .as a sikh you are obliged to give credit to a fellow sikh brother wen it is due and not swoop down on a couple of words he has typed like a vulture after a little scrap of meat on the african savannah .i think this overtly critical western mentality which is nothing much ,but too much intense mind stuff is beginning to dry up our hearts and minds which are supposed to be naam soaked with wet wet wet gursikhi luv fer each other as the first chhant of asa divar says .

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

sarbloh · 03 Jul 2006

You have jathedars everywhere in sikh kaum.Why dont we have Punj at the top of the tree.It shud be the punj who shud choose jathedars etc.The punj shud be selected from a bunch of respected candidates among the sangat by picking up slips in presence of Sri Guru Granth Sahib.This shud be the way out of the present mess the punjabi sikhs have put themselves into. Wahegurujeekakhalsa Wahegurujeekeefateh

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

some1 · 03 Jul 2006

I my self have not seen eye to eye with Paji Arshi, and sometimes we get into arguements..but that does not mean i have the utmost respect for him, the age difference and the wisdom he has because of his years cannot be accounted for on a forum.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Prabhjoyt Singh · 03 Jul 2006

who are Baldev Singh and Mohkam Singh to blame anyone, two tru badal chamchay

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Jul 2006

Author: singh Date: 07-03-06 08:21 js arshi.... if u didnt know.. i got a news flash for you.. THE KIRPAN IS A WEAPON, AND IS MEANT TO BE ONE, WHETERH U TRY TO MASK IT TO GORAI OR NOT, ITS STILL A PRACTICAL WEAPON *******************************>????? Veer Ji..of course it is a weapon.....BUT on the BATTLEFIELD...to fight agianst INJUSTICE..on the side of the DOWNTRODDEN..and the weak...to defend the Poor and those who seek our help... But do you really want to "emphahsise" the "WEAPON" part to a Customs/immigration official at the AIRPORT ?? I would rather emphasisie as veer humkire says..as a GIFT FROM MY GURU. As " a GIFT from the GURU JI" we are sometimes allowed to take it along (maybe)..but as a weapon..110% NEVER. so take your pick. In my country Malaysia...we are "allowed" to carry the Kirpan...without too much show off/advertising..its just a understanding ( based on GIFT from GURU JI) as the country law says clearly NO WEAPONS of any kind..not even a switch blade !! So if I was to keep BRANDISHING my KIRPAN....as a weapon..i would soon have it taken away and myself land in trouble ( many Granthis and ragis from Punjab have suffered this ignominy at the hands of the local police). Please forgive any offense i may have caused to you by these remarks..i am too deeply hurt by what happened at Amritsar... Love to all.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

singh · 03 Jul 2006

does anyone have video of the confrontation????

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

UKSingh · 04 Jul 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki Fateh ji Kulbir Singh ji Pls don't take this the wrong way, but if you have 'concerns' about the current leadership arrangements of the Jatha in India. Nows your chance to speak to the Jatherdar Pooran Ji yourself, as I beleiev he is now in Toronto, so pls go and speak to him about these 'concerns' 'issues' etc. Pls let the cybersanagt know how this goes Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki Fateh ji

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Anon · 04 Jul 2006

Vote for Gyani Jarnail Singh Arshi as next Jathadar

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

LS · 04 Jul 2006

From the news item below, 'Bhai Mohkam Singh, spokesman of Damdami Taksal, and UK-based Dal Khalsa leader Manmohan Singh have expressed their concern over yesterday’s incident and blamed Mr Parkash Singh Badal, president, Shiromani Akali Dal, for it. ' This is different to the previous note where they were supposed to have blamed Mann Darbar Sahib manager, two secretaries shifted Panthic bodies oppose Akal Takht directive against Mann Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, July 3 A day after the unprecedented clash in the Golden Temple complex, the SGPC President, Mr Avtar Singh, today ordered the transfers of the Manager of Darbar Sahib and two secretaries along with ‘strict warning’ that would be filed in their service books, squarely blaming for the ‘sordid incident’. With this, the annual increment of these beleaguered high SGPC officials — Mr Roop Singh, Mr Dilmegh Singh and Mr Waryam Singh — would be stopped. The reversion of some employees has also been ordered. Interestingly, Mr Roop Singh who has been indicted for having failed to make proper arrangements for the quadricentennial celebrations had retuned from the USA to a couple of days before the celebrations. He had gone with the SGPC chief on official duty to the USA even though his services were required in Amritsar to make arrangements for the celebrations. Meanwhile, the Sikh Students Federation (Mehta) today burnt the effigy of Mr Mann for allegedly creating a ruckus at the time of the 400th anniversary celebrations of Akal Takht yesterday. Meanwhile, the Akali Dal (Amritsar) has convened an emergency meeting of Panthic organisations here tomorrow against the directive of the Sikh clergy for ‘virtual boycott’ of its president Simranjit Singh Mann and five other senior leaders of the party. The Sikh organisations that have been invited for the meeting include the Shiromani Khalsa Panchayat, SAD and Dal Khalsa. Bhai Mohkam Singh, spokesman of Damdami Taksal, and UK-based Dal Khalsa leader Manmohan Singh have expressed their concern over yesterday’s incident and blamed Mr Parkash Singh Badal, president, Shiromani Akali Dal, for it. They said Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, Jathedar of Akal Takht, had failed to perform his duty. They said it was most unfortunate that the SGPC had played a partisan role by not allowing Mr Mann to address the Sikh Sangat while non-Sikhs were given time. On the other hand, the radical Sikh organisations have already announced that the Jathedars’ directive against Mr Mann and his party leaders was unacceptable. Leaders of the Dal Khalsa H. S. Dhami and secretary Kanwar Pal Singh in a statement said the jathedar of Akal Takht and four others had divided the community by acting in a biased manner. Though senior SGPC officials have been made scapegoats, Mr Dilmeg Singh, secretary, has proceeded on four days’ leave. Former Jathedar Akal Takht, Prof Darshan Singh alleged that the directive against Mr Mann and his leaders was pronounced at the behest of Mr Parkash Singh Badal. He called upon the Sikh masses to liberate the gurdwaras from such mahants. Mr Parmjit Singh Sarna, president, SAD (Delhi), Mr Harwinder Singh Sarna, president, Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee, and Mr Manjit Singh Calcutta, SGPC member, said the Shiromani Committee tried to convert its religious stage into a ‘Badal rally’ . They said that whenever the SGPC organised religious stages at Fatehgarh Sahib, Muktsar or Chamkaur Sahib, leaders of various Akali factions were allowed to address the sangat from the SGPC stages.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

ns · 04 Jul 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Kulbir Singh Ji is 100% correct abouthe the AKJ. i also fail to understand why the AKJ is not so politically active as it's so active religiously.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

PTE SINGH · 04 Jul 2006

so, who won the fight....?

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006

-------------- Kulbir Singh ji Pls don't take this the wrong way, but if you have 'concerns' about the current leadership arrangements of the Jatha in India. Nows your chance to speak to the Jatherdar Pooran Ji yourself, as I beleiev he is now in Toronto, so pls go and speak to him about these 'concerns' 'issues' etc. ---------------- Pokhar neer viroliye, Maakhan nahi reesay|| Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

GurSikh wannabe · 04 Jul 2006

Kulbir Singh - what do you mean by this? "Pokhar neer viroliye, Maakhan nahi reesay||"

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006

--------- Kulbir Singh - what do you mean by this? "Pokhar neer viroliye, Maakhan nahi reesay||" ----------- It means that you cannot get makhan (butter) by churning water. Kulbir Singh

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

ns · 04 Jul 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Kulbir singh , hopefully that's not an insult to Pooran Ji....

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

some1 · 04 Jul 2006

not but Kulbir Singh, u gotta go talk to him if you believe u can help. Otherwise its like o bads happening i'm gonna ignore it.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Charanjit singh · 04 Jul 2006

Kulbir Singh maybe you fancy yourself as a better jathdar rahter than Pooran ji ??? your just a Kid and need to get a grip , if you got thte gaul then speak to Pooran ji directly rahter than making cheeky comments on the internet

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

You · 04 Jul 2006

The Dal Khalsa is backing Sardar Mann. Do not believe what the Tribune is reporting about S. Manmohan Singh. They are trying to distort facts and cause further problems among the Panthic parties.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006

--------- Kulbir Singh maybe you fancy yourself as a better jathdar rahter than Pooran ji ??? ------------ Such Jathedariyaan may be Mubarik to you. I don't need it. --------------- your just a Kid and need to get a grip ------------- Shows that you are really grown up. --------------------- , if you got thte gaul then speak to Pooran ji directly rahter than making cheeky comments on the internet ------------- What's wrong about making a comment about our leadership? What's wrong is wrong and we should not get upset over constructive criticism. Which Singh would contest that the need of this hour is to have strong leadership that can do us proud. Is it a sin to raise such valid questions? Kulbir Singh

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

some1 · 04 Jul 2006

Kulbir veerji, all we are tryna say is if u feel that and u have the OPEn oppertunity to bring it upto him...u should do so.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006

--------- Kulbir veerji, all we are tryna say is if u feel that and u have the OPEn oppertunity to bring it upto him...u should do so. ---------- And I veer jee / Bhain jee, prayed that "pokhar neer viroliye, maakhan nahi reesay". Somethings are better off not said. I prefer to keep this particular one as status quo. Kulbir Singh

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

JEEVAN SINGH · 04 Jul 2006

we should not allow sgpc and badal members to speak on gurdwara stages in foreign countries !! if they stop us in panjab why can't we stop them here ? [%sig%]

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

reghsdfgsdfh · 04 Jul 2006

did neone record this beadbee that happened??

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Singh · 04 Jul 2006

Dharam yudh morcha’ planned against SAD Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, July 4 The Sikh conclave held at Gurdwara Toot Sahib here today decided to launch “dharm yudh morcha” against the Shiromani Akali Dal even as it had tendered unconditional and unilateral apology for the clash held at Gurdwara Manji Sahib to mark quadricentennial celebrations of Akal Takht on July 2. The Sikh conclave, however, sought reviewing of the “unilateral” directive pronounced by the Sikh clergy against Mr Simranjit Singh Mann, president, Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar), and five leaders of his party. It alleged that Mr Parkash Singh Badal had successfully used Akal Takht against rival factions though the SGPC and the Badal faction was “squarely responsible” for the sordid incident. The Sikh conclave was participated by the Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar), Dal Khalsa leaders, Mr Satnam Singh Paunta Sahib and Mr Kanwarpal Singh, and Justice Ajit Singh Bains (retd), president, Human Rights Organisation, Mr Rajinder Singh, convener, Shiromani Khalsa Panchayat, and Bhai Mohkam Singh, a spokesman of Damdami Taksal. The Sikh conclave said the SAD tried to create a wedge between the rival Panthic factions by using the services of Jathedars. They alleged that the partisan role played by the Sikh clergy had evoked strong reaction from all over the Sikh world. They, however, described the clash in the presence of Guru Granth Sahib as the “most unfortunate incident”. The conclave, however, said that giving a “clean chit” to the Badal faction was an unfortunate development. The Sikh conclave decided to approach the Sikh clergy on July 8 to urge them to summon all the parties which were involved in the sordid clash at Gurdwara Manji Sahib. However, Mr Mann and his leaders, who were pronounced guilty for the acrimonious scenes won’t be part of the delegation that would meet the Sikh High Priests on July 8. Meanwhile, a Political Affairs Committee member of the SAD, Mr Manjit Singh Calcutta, said it was unfortunate that the Sikh clergy had given their “final verdict” without giving a chance to the “guilty” to clarify his position. Mr Harinder Pal Singh, a member of the SGPC from Delhi, belonging to the Badal faction said that after the clash in the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, he was feeling ashamed of being member of the Shiromani committee. He asked Mr Badal, Mr Mann and the SGPC chief, Mr Avtar Singh, to tender collective unconditional apology before Akal Takht . On the other hand, many SGPC members held Mr Mann and his party responsible for the clash and sought the cooperation of the Sikh sangat for their “complete boycott”. SGPC blamed for Golden Temple clash Our Correspondent Mohali, July 4 The SGPC is responsible for the clash that took place at a function organised in connection with the quadricentennial celebrations of the foundation of Akal Takht inside the Golden Temple complex on Sunday. This was stated by Mr Prem Singh Chandumajra, president of the SAD (Longowal), at a press conference here today. He said such an unfortunate incident occurred because Sikh priests acted in a partisan manner. When Mr Simranjeet Singh Mann, president, SAD (Amritsar), was invited to the function why was he not allowed to speak from the stage. Mr Chandumajra said Mr Parkash Singh Badal, president, SAD, had given a political colour to a religious function. He appealed to the Jathedar of Akal Takht to rise above factionalism and take a decision suitable to the Panth at large. Efforts should be made to prevent such incidents in the future, he added. He said July 21, when the bhog of akhand path would take places, should be observed as a “paschatap” day. From July 15 to August 15 seminars were being organised at different places in the state where various issues facing the Panth would be discussed.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Singh · 04 Jul 2006

Events at Akal Takht draw flak K.S. Chawla Ludhiana, July 4 The events which took place at the Akal Takht on July 2 at the time of celebrations of quadricentenary of the establishment of the Akal Takht have been condemned by cross section of Sikhs. Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi, president, Gurmit Sidhant Pracharak Sant Samaj, said today that it was deplorable that the Akal Takht was being used for political purposes. Baba Bedi said the Sant Samaj was not invited for the celebrations of the foundation of the takht. ''As a matter of fact, we have not accepted the present jathedar of the Akal Takht,'' he said. Baba Bedi said the Sant Samaj never participated in the celebrations as an organisation and if some saints had attended the function, it was in their individual capacity. Baba Bedi said organisers of the function should have allowed Simranjit Singh Mann to address the gathering since he was representing a section of the Sikhs. The SGPC chief and Parkash Singh Badal had adopted the authoritarian attitude and were not allowing the genuine Sikh leaders to express feelings at such religious functions. Badal was out to use the takht for his political benefits which was condemnable. Baba Bedi also criticised both factions for the desecration of Guru Granth Sahib. They should not have quarreled in the presence of the Guru Granth Sahib which was the guru of the Sikhs. Baba Bedi called upon the Sikhs to think how to save the takht from the misuse by the politicians who were bent upon establishing their family rule. Lt. Col Channan Singh Dhillon (retd), president of the ex-services league, Punjab and Chandigarh, also condemned the happenings at the takht and described it as shameful. Col Dhillon said the takht was being used a personal fiefdom by Parkash Singh Badal and no opponent Sikh leader was allowed to raise his voice of dissent. This was against the traditions of the takht. Col Dhillon urged the Sikhs to save it from the clutches of Badal and his coterie. Col Dhillon also supported the assertions of Prof Darshan Singh, former jathedar of the takht, and Paramjit Singh Sarna and Harvinder Singh Sarna of Delhi for political use of the takht by Badal.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

humkire · 04 Jul 2006

veer charanjit singh ji now thats not a very polite gursikhi way of addressing yer sikh brother kulbir singh as a kid who needs to get a grip .and i presume you are a sikh too .i think we all need to watch the worldly bickering totally anti gurmat way we talk to each other on a sikh forum especially if we are close to our guruji and love our panth and our fellow brothers and sisters . i was actually quite proud of him ,even though he may be akj or something to be able to be honest enough to mention stuff that other akj like to keep hidden .this is a refelection of his sincerity in believing in the principle of accountability and fairness and openess.he is right in being able to express his concerns in a democratic manner over an issue he is concerned about .and he has to be respected and given the space for that ,not gagged and being acused of this and that . and in sikhism ,kids and adults are all children of the guru .im my short lifetime ,i ve seen an aged gyani or preacher behaving like an idiot and speaking in an ignorant manner ,and i have seen yung sikh kids doing the most amazing keertan on stage .its about guru's kirpa on someone ,not a matter of age ,in sikhism .so wat if kulbir singh is 16 or 20 or 30 .i have read amazing stuff written by him on this forum .i dont know him ,never met him ,am not his supporter ,but his various posts on aspects of gurbani have many a time ,made my day .he comes here unselfishly and shares his knowledge and time with us .in my lifetime ,i have been blessed to listen to the kathas of every top sikh parcharak i think longer than u have been on this planet and i can well assure you that the knowledhe has has expressed time n time again on certain very complicated aspects of gurbani,gurbani grammar ,gurmat ,itihias ,etc show me that he is a wonderboy of sikhism ,hardly excelled by a few others ,no matter wat his age is . i think yur comments are very very unfair by the democratic standards of the western society we live in and certainly by the standards of gursikhi piar for one another .i hope u can get get a grip of this .my gursikhi luv to u in all my sincerity .may guruji do his apaar kirpa and bakhshish on you ,my dearest veerji .

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

bgt · 05 Jul 2006

And I veer jee / Bhain jee, prayed that "pokhar neer viroliye, maakhan nahi reesay". Somethings are better off not said. I prefer to keep this particular one as status quo. ........... i dnt undrstand veerji, if somethings are better off said, theyre defintely not better off said in public then. because at the very least, it is at least polite to have said it in person. to say it in public but not speaking in person even though the occasion arrises, seems to fall towards chugli, no? i hope i'm mistaken in this. please think about it and explain.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

UKSingh · 05 Jul 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki Fateh ji Veer Kulbir Singh ji pls do not take offence but you say 'And I veer jee / Bhain jee, prayed that "pokhar neer viroliye, maakhan nahi reesay". Somethings are better off not said. I prefer to keep this particular one as status quo. Kulbir Singh' If you intended not saying anything, why say it in the internet!!!!!, now you have aired your thoughts, then surely the correct way of expressing them is direct to Jatherdar Pooran ji himself!!!!!!! rather than over the internet!!!!!! It seems simple sense to me :) Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki Fateh jio

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Kulbir Singh · 05 Jul 2006

UK Singh jeeo, -------------- If you intended not saying anything, why say it in the internet!!!!!, now you have aired your thoughts, then surely the correct way of expressing them is direct to Jatherdar Pooran ji himself!!!!!!! rather than over the internet!!!!!! It seems simple sense to me :) -------------- Why is the correct way of expressing only in person? When we express our opinions about other leaders like Badal, Tohra, Maan, Dhumma, Sant Samaj, do we actually go in person to express our opinions? I don't think so. So why should there be a different stand when talking about AKJ leadership? And all I said was that the role of our leadership should be more proactive and dynamic. I don't see why such a comment cannot be made on a forum. My comment was not geared specifically towards Bhai Surat Singh only but towards whole of AKJ leadership that has been totally absent from the forefront of Panth and the wrong person Bhai Baldev Singh is forcefully representing AKJ at all panthak forums. AKJ jathedar should not only be a person with bhagti but also one who has leadership qualities i.e. can represent jatha at all fronts. Bhagti and Shakti go hand in hand. Miri and Piri go hand in hand. The jathedar needs not only piri but also miri. Bhai Raam Singh in his younger years did a fabulous job of leading Jatha in tough times of post 1978. Now too the AKJ leadership needs to realise that if it does not play an active role in Panth, it will hurt the whole jatha. Along with listening to kirtan, the jathedar should do at least the following: 1) Play an active role in Panth. 2) Actively do parchaar of Sikhi in India and abroad. Look how hard Bhai Harnam Singh Dhuma and Bhai Ram Singh are working. They are going pind to pind doing parchar. What is the jathedar of Jatha doing as compared to other jathedars in Panth? 3) Jathedar of Jatha should keep rehit of Khalsa that Singhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee used to keep. The jatha should do parchar of Tatt Gurmat maryada and bring acceptace in Panth for Dastar, Mundawani, Laridaar Saroop, Sarbloh Bibek etc. The above are my personal thoughts and I repeat these are strictly my personal thoughts. I have nothing personal against anyone. All I want is to see Jatha and Panth Khalsa in chardi kala. Chardi kala will come from above i.e. from leadership. Chardi Kala will not come if we give up rehit. Chardi Kala will not come if we get upset hearing constructive criticism. So again, meri hath jor ke benti hai, lets all keep rehit, japp naam and do parchaar of Sikhi. Kulbir Singh

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

UKSingh · 05 Jul 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki Fateh ji Kulbir Singh ji the 3 points made are valid, thats not the issue, what i am tryign to say is, now Pooran ji is in Toronto, speak to him about these issues, otherwise everythign else said on boards like this is just ego talking :)))) and no action Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki Fateh ji

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Kulbir Singh · 05 Jul 2006

UK Singh jeeo, I am pretty sure that what I have written on this forum will reach him. There is no need for me to go to him for this. Do you think I don’t know he is in Toronto at this time? I do know and still I chose the medium I thought was best to voice my concerns. I have my reasons for doing what I did, and the way I did. Perhaps if you meet me in person, I will explain you the reasons. Certainly not on an open forum. Kulbir Singh

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

some1 · 06 Jul 2006

why is Baba Nihal Singh taking the side of a panth da dokhi? Is Baba Nihal Singh ji not staying true to what he was in the 80s?

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

..... · 06 Jul 2006

i am glad akj india are staying out of petty stupid poltical games between personalities like this.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

JEEVAN SINGH · 06 Jul 2006

Nihaal Singh Nihung is a puppet of badal and always has been !! he was sacred of sant bhindrawale ji thats why he kept himself low key ! his thugs were first to pull their swords out at akal thakt sahib [%sig%]

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

Satnam · 06 Jul 2006

Badal and Mann both are trying to pull legs of each other. Both of them have certain issues. Mann is honest but he is not a good politician . Badal is better politician but he is corrupt and trying to control SGPC and Akal Takht Jathedars. We should reject both of them. we need to give chance to Daljit Singh Bittu as a chief Minister of Panjab.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

JEEVAN SINGH · 06 Jul 2006

every one needs to get together on this issue and stand strong in one voice and start a mass movement against badal and his thugs ! they have done to much damage to the panth, they are pushing us into a panth vs panth war, ddt they've split, akj they've damaged, federations and thakts are under their belts !!!!! so khalsa ji please wake up and support panthic organistions like bhai daljit singh bittu, dal khalsa etc, prof darshan singh ji khalsa. [%sig%]

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

M Singh · 07 Jul 2006

Veer Kulbir Singh Ji Your first mail on AKJ leadership came after my comments on So called Jathedar Badev Singh. I am impressed the way you are airing your view points. No problem . That needs do be said and discussed. Well done. Well said. It is one's choice what he says and how. Your initial comments (and later also) were not even personal. That shows your seriousness and worries about the community. To me, it seems, it is better we are avoiding political stages in India. Situations and issues are so complex that only a talented man can handle those, with Guru Kirpa. It is better we are silent. Our silence means a lot. People respect us for our silence (minus our weak points on Rahet Maryada). No body is worried about Gurmat princilples in the panth, in general. "Sach Kinare Reh Gaya, Kheh Marde Baman Molane". Under such "Ram Rolla" it is better we are away. Those who are serious, will find the answers and their leaders. They ( so called sikh community) are not listening to the Guru. Will they listen to AKJ chief? How many are convinced with "Lari daar" saroop of Guru Sahib. Very very very few. If they are not convinced with this very very logical and serious issue; can an AKJ chief will be able to convince a gathering which is generally only of about 20% of Amritdharies, on issues of relgio-political nature. I think, Bhai Randhir Singh Ji was highly blessed by Guru Ji and the community at that time was also not as non serious as of today. So he played a good role, where needed. Bhai Ram Singh Ji delivered good speeches in Dharam Yudh Morcha, in the presence of stalwarts, Sant Jarnail Singh and Sant Harchand Singh, Longowal. At present we have worse of every thing. Our press is playing with or against few. No rules no Gurmat, is there, to be followed. Our leaders as well as Jatheders are no mountains, only little pebbles or sand particles. ( e.g. Can we compare Harnam Singh with Sant Kartar Singh; no; not at all.) I conclude. Given the situation like today; let the persons like Baldev Singh have the field day. He likes it, let him enjoy it. Guru Ji likes so, may be. Please, do note; I am fifty and persons of this age learn to live with the situation than to try to change it. However, if some one changes that, I love it. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karna Ji.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

humkire · 07 Jul 2006

veer m singh jee, my taking of this situation is that guruji has allowed this to happen in his grander design and scheme of things for the present and future chardi kela of khalsa panth and eventual khalsa raaj that is unstopably on the way.gurujee is alowing a lot of dirt to surface ,in order to wash it away. we live in xciting and challenging times .old paralysing structures are beginning to be identified .a voice of dissent is slowly beginning to take strenth and like a fiery tornado ,it will sweep out this structures sooner or later. even sikhi is starting to be distributed to much more than punjabee sikhs .it is guru jee's true parshad to the cosmos.little seeds of sikhi are being allowed to be blown all over this planet so they can germinate ,and sprout into seedlings and massive towering trees in the future.guru jee is sikhi's own personal surgeon and as He has done it all b4 ,He is slowly cutting out the cancerous parts .badal and his unruly pack live on borrowed time .that is absolutely certain . PARGATEO KHALSA PERMATAM KI MAUJ,KHALSA AKAL PURUKH KI FAUJ.This two verses which ring uncontrollably in my ears ,tell the secret of the future of sikhi we can expect without a shade of doubt.because khalsa is gods army ,because he made it for his own pleasure,no way can any idiot destroy it .in fact badal and gang are like an ant in the footpath of a roaring elephant just about to crush the juices out of them.would anyone have ever guessed that bhai sahib randheer would be born and become the surgeon's lethal injection to strengthen the panth .would sikhs living in india 300 years ago and suffering persecution and facing annihilation ever have guessed that one day darbar sahib would be guided in gold ,that they would florish and be found in all corners of the globe within a couple of centuries .but they lived in the hope of a promise .and gurujee is not in the business of breaking promises and dismantling his rose garden . and ,in the face of wat is visible ,i live excitedly and passionately ,like a puppy, begging guru ji to daily make us a part of that which is yet not visible,but slowly shaping and sprouting in GURUJEE'S garden of khalsa panth.i suppose we need to think the unthinkable and humbly love and serve guru jee ,letting gurujee birth, in our souls, khalsa revolution,affecting whoever,is around us in the time and space worlds we live in .guru jee is timeless and spaceless ,so is sikhi,so is the physical manifestation of sikhi.i too am around 50 like you ,but these exciting thoughts make my heart flutter like a 15 year old teenager .

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

someone · 08 Jul 2006

Who says Dal Khalsa is siding with badal ? It is openly siding with Mann and wants to liberate the Gurdwaras from the masands . The organisations siding with badal are : 1)Nihangs of Harianbailaan 2)Members of SSF (Mehta Chawla) who have derived some benefit from badal as their leaders were given high posts in boards during his rule 3)Jathedars of Takhts 4)Some members of SGPC.We cant say all. 5-6 members of Sikh Students Federation have even gone to the extent of burning an effigy of mann which was repeatedly shown by Zee TV. Amongst the SSF members one could see 3-4 monas also. This was repeatedly shown to prove that Sikhs are against Mann whereas everyone knows the opposite is true. [%sig%]

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

KS · 10 Jul 2006

The Badal BJP/RSS hooligans must be stopped. A lot of the Akali workers in the photos were actually monas, that just shows that Badal cares nothing for Sikhs. 10 Akali workers hurt in clash Protest against Jaitley’s statement Vimal Sumbly Tribune News Service Ludhiana, July 9 Workers of the Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar) (SAD-A), including district president Anup Singh Sandhu and vice-president Harjab Singh Daad were roughed up by activists of the Shiromani Akali Dal-Badal (SAD-B) outside the Circuit House here today. SAD-B workers were out to ransack the nearby office of the SAD(A). The SAD(A) claimed that 10 of its activists were injured in the scuffle. Incident took place outside the Circuit House where senior Akali and Bharatiya Janata Party leaders, including Mr Arun Jaitley and Mr Parkash Singh Badal, held a meeting on seat-sharing for the Assembly elections. The SAD(A) workers led by district president Sandhu, carrying black flags wanted to protest against Mr Jaitley, who they alleged was trying to interfere in the functioning of Akal Takht Sahib. The SAD(A) general secretary said the protest was organised against Mr Jaitley’s reported demand that Akal Takht withdraw the hukamnama of boycott pronounced in 2004 against the Rashtriya Sikh Sangat, an outfit of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. The SAD(B) workers, who had information of the protest, had gathered outside the venue since morning. Hundreds of Akali workers appeared to be waiting in and outside the Circuit House complex for SAD(A) protesters. As they (SAD(A) workers) started approaching the Circuit House from their party’s office, which is nearby, carrying black flags and shouting slogans, SAD-B workers attacked them with lathis. The SAD(A) workers were outnumbered by the Badal supporters. Most of them fled, some tried to put up resistance also. In the scuffle turbans of some of the SAD(A) were blown off. Some Badal supporters carried these turbans displaying these to photographers as symbol of victory. District vice-president of the SAD(A) Harjab Singh Daad snatched his turban from SAD-B workers. He was beaten up. However, he was saved by Deputy Superintendent of Police R.K. Bakshi and his men. Secretary and spokesman of the SAD-B, Dr Daljeet Singh Cheema condemned the SAD(A) for its “attack” on his party workers. He pointed out, everybody had the right in a democracy to organise programme of his party. “Why did they (SAD-A) activists try to attack and disturb our programme?”, he asked, adding that they were doing it at the behest of the Congress. SAD(A) general secretary Prof Jagmohan Singh was furious at the incident. He said, the SAD(B) would get a prompt reply. “They have sparked a civil war among the Sikhs and they (the SAD-B) should be squarely responsible for it”, he warned. He claimed the SAD(A) activists were only trying to lodge symbolic and peaceful protest against Mr Jaitley. “However, our workers were attacked and beaten up by SAD-B activists”, he alleged. The SAD(A) has called a Sikh congregation on July 21 at Amritsar.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

JS · 11 Jul 2006

The Gurdwaras and SGPC must be freed from these modern day mahants and Dogras. The Mann group were correct to protest against a group that calls Sikhs Hindus and supported Bluestar.

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

JSGyani "arshi" · 11 Jul 2006

Recently all the Forums have been flooded with mails by MONAS gleefully showing how Dastaardharee Khalsa fight in Gurdwaras... these MONAS fail to see the Second Echelon leaders of these same dastardharees are MONAS and Beard trimmers... The Truth is these "dastaardharees" are no more Khalsa than their MONA sons..BOTH must be chased out of the Takhats and Gurdawras..

Re: badal n mann brawl in manji sahib

some1 · 11 Jul 2006

Arashi ji, i have not seen this, but yes mona's have no place in Sikh politics.