Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Tapoban Amritvela Simran

SG · 02 Jul 2006

Are non amritdharis and people without kesh allowed to join in the Saas Giras Simran? how about people who are amrit dhari but do not know how to do the technique used in doing simran?

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

. · 03 Jul 2006

people who are not amridhari ... havent got nam dridh. so stick to normal simran ( or am i wrong ) if ur amrithari then eather learn of some one or .. breath sayin waheguru .. wahe in gur out

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

singh · 03 Jul 2006

. you shouldnt have said so .. i though it was only upto the punj to do that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

niyarakhalsa · 03 Jul 2006

Request is that , dont get into this jhamela of " bal ki khal nikalna" guru sahibs hukam is " aap japo avreh naam japavo ". so just do it. leave all the doubts with the guru , it is guru sahibs duty to handel them ! not ours . so , just do GUrrrr , gur ... gur gurrr, Gurr... why waste time in anything else.

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Anon · 04 Jul 2006

How can you stop non-amrtidharis from coming to the Saas Giras Simran????? They should be allowed. All should be allowed! Please do not stereotype

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006

---------- Are non amritdharis and people without kesh allowed to join in the Saas Giras Simran? how about people who are amrit dhari but do not know how to do the technique used in doing simran? ----------- Swaas Swaas Naam Abhyaas is done in the main diwan hall of Gurdwara Sahib and as thus no one can be stopped from coming there. Every now and then a non-amritdhari person or a non-akj person comes to abhyaas but no one is stopped. There are no pehredaars standing outside to stop anyone from coming. Whoever wants to come comes. The bottomline is that no one can imitate anyone and learn the correct way of doing Naam Abhyaas. One has to learn it directly from the Punj Pyare. Kulbir Singh

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Charanjit singh · 04 Jul 2006

that is a big dhill of tapoban singhs , you don't do simran in keeertan yet you teach peopel how to do saas graas ????

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

gupt!! · 04 Jul 2006

kulbir singh..u say no1 is stopd..ther is a 2-4 amritvela in (UK) ot really syaing where..and you have to be AKJ and AKJ only to be able to enter..that is wrong!if it was just amritdharis fair enuff hunna but u have to have taken amrit from AKJ panj piayre only! if an amritdhari singh or singhnee wlked into the amrit vela they would do the simran and after b4 leaving to go home or whatever a singh or singhnee would approach them and say not to come back..that is stoppin someone frm doing simran! even if the singh or singhnee is naam dhridh knws saas graas they have to have got it frm AKJ. vaheguroo

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

singh · 04 Jul 2006

Bhai Kulbir Singh Jis message should be told to the Cross Roads youth at Coventry and the other AKJ youth from the midlands, you cannot stop people from doing Simran with you...... for the love of God open your eyes.....

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006

--------- that is a big dhill of tapoban singhs , you don't do simran in keeertan yet you teach peopel how to do saas graas ???? -------- Charanjit Singh, how is it a dhil and how are we teaching people saas giraas abhyaas? Singhs do their abhyaas and if someone happens to hear them, so be it. The bottomline is that you can't stop people from coming to Guru Sahib's darbar. That would be manmatt. In the story of Doctor Bhai Basant Singh jee we learn that Singhs used to do abhyaas and so loud was the abhyaas that the whole pind (village) used to hear it, including manmukhs. One manmukh by the name of Ganga Singh used to come to the place where Singhs did abhyaas and make fun of them. One day he went over the board and starting imitating them and mocking them. All of sudden he felt a severe pain in his stomach and he starting wailing and crying out to Singhs to pardon his mistake. What we are not supposed to do is not teach abhyaas to anyone but if we are doing abhyaas and someone happens to hear the abhyaas, that does not violate any Gurmat principle. Kulbir Singh

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

???? · 04 Jul 2006

veerji vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji veerji i also agree where you say that if anyone else hears one do naam abhyass it is not putting any naam abhyassi at fault. As naam can only be attained through guru saroop panj piyare. Veerji on one of your other posts you mentioned about Dhunni should not be done infront of none amrithdharis, here it is. 'The Kirtaniya knows that sangat is singing behind him. He also knows that sitting in sangat are individuals who have not yet taken amrit. By doing dhuni in open program, the kirtaniya is japping Naam to individuals who have not yet received Naam from Guru Sahib i.e. are not amritdhari yet. This seems to be a wrong practice.' veerji here you have mentioned kind of the opposite, to the post in this thread. Or am i mistaking that simran in kirtan dhunni should not be done infront of non-amrithdharis. Still i don't see the difference.

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Confused Khalsa · 04 Jul 2006

Thank you for the clarification, this should end the madness in the UK.

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jul 2006

---------- 'The Kirtaniya knows that sangat is singing behind him. He also knows that sitting in sangat are individuals who have not yet taken amrit. By doing dhuni in open program, the kirtaniya is japping Naam to individuals who have not yet received Naam from Guru Sahib i.e. are not amritdhari yet. This seems to be a wrong practice.' veerji here you have mentioned kind of the opposite, to the post in this thread. Or am i mistaking that simran in kirtan dhunni should not be done infront of non-amrithdharis. Still i don't see the difference. --------------- About dhuni in Kirtan, the above is just one point and in kirtan, a Gursikh leads the sangat in singing praises of Akal Purakh. In abhyaas, no one leads anyone. All Singhs japp Naam together. Singhs are not inviting any non-amritdhari or non-akj. If someone just happens to come, once in blue moon, you can't kick that person out of Guru Sahib's darbar. That we feel is wrong. In our case, this abhyaas is done in the main hall of the Gurdwara Sahib with parkash of Guru Sahib. For this reason you can't stop anyone. First of all, non-amritdharis just don't come to abhyaas. Over the last so many years, we can count on our finger tips occasions when a non-amritdhari showed up there. Besides, a person who has not learned the technique from Guru Sahib can never figure out what Singhs are doing. Last thing I want to say is that we never claim that Tapoban Singhs are perfect or anything like this. It's quite possible that we may be at mistake in this case. Kulbir Singh

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Singh · 04 Jul 2006

kulbir singh..u say no1 is stopd..ther is a 2-4 amritvela in (UK) ot really syaing where..and you have to be AKJ and AKJ only to be able to enter..that is wrong!if it was just amritdharis fair enuff hunna but u have to have taken amrit from AKJ panj piayre only! if an amritdhari singh or singhnee wlked into the amrit vela they would do the simran and after b4 leaving to go home or whatever a singh or singhnee would approach them and say not to come back..that is stoppin someone frm doing simran! even if the singh or singhnee is naam dhridh knws saas graas they have to have got it frm AKJ. vaheguroo Bhai Kulbir Singh Jis message should be told to the Cross Roads youth at Coventry and the other AKJ youth from the midlands, you cannot stop people from doing Simran with you...... for the love of God open your eyes..... Gursikhoo, benti from daas is please watch what you say, DON'T DO NINDIYA OR CHUGLIYA of this AMRIT VELA. This amrit vela is very Chardi kala!! Please watch what you say!! You have to understand!! The gursikhs tell you to do pesh, if you don't have naam dhrih and a keski rehit! I REALLY DON'T WANT TO ARGUE, ITS A PURE WASTE OF TIME!! PLEASE FORGIVE WJKKWJKF

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

(*) singh · 05 Jul 2006

Coventry amritvela rocks , the Gursiksh who attend that amritvela do so in a gupt room and all follow the same rehat , that is why they ask people to go pesh with panj singh and keep keski rehat and have naam dhrrir , that is there choice as then they know that all who are present keep to similar rehat.

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

. · 05 Jul 2006

I am going to ask that Admin allow this one final message to clarify the situation in UK. The difference between the UK and Canada is that in the UK many people WANT to learn Swas Swas Simran but because of their affiliations to other Jathebandia, they refuse to Pesh at a Amrit Sanchar to receive Naam DriRh (in UK the only Jathebandi which gives Naam DriRh correctly is AKJ. At others some very strange things are done). Therefore they attempt to enter the Amritvelas to learn how to Jap Naam. To learn to Jap Naam can only be taught by the Panj. This is the difference between situation in UK and Canada.

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Singh · 05 Jul 2006

well said Author: (*) singh

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

.. · 05 Jul 2006

The reason there are more jeevan they wale gursikhs in the jatha at uk, is because they do what they Panj Piyare tell them to! They have jewel and they dont want to share it with any one....lets say Guru Gobind Singh ji gave you ridh sidh or a gift would you go around sharing and telling people about it...no way! So why do we keep things like ridh sidhs and other experience gupt?? The people that dont have it will always complain so I would like to do a benti to all the singhs that have naam drir is to stay away from topics such as this one..as it wil surely damage your jeevan! Just carry on japping naam and the ones that wont to argue then carry on!!

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

kirtan lover · 05 Jul 2006

For the first time I must agree with the Tapoban policy.... excellent as for "Coventry amritvela rocks , the Gursiksh who attend that amritvela do so in a gupt room and all follow the same rehat , that is why they ask people to go pesh with panj singh and keep keski rehat and have naam dhrrir , that is there choice as then they know that all who are present keep to similar rehat." hhhmm that doesn't justify any sort of exclusion...just shows that singhs need to be educated. Puran Ji never excluded anyone from attending amrit vela and amrit vela led by him could be heard all around the houses. And as for .. The difference between the UK and Canada is that in the UK many people WANT to learn Swas Swas Simran but because of their affiliations to other Jathebandia, they refuse to Pesh at a Amrit Sanchar to receive Naam DriRh (in UK the only Jathebandi which gives Naam DriRh correctly is AKJ. At others some very strange things are done). Therefore they attempt to enter the Amritvelas to learn how to Jap Naam. To learn to Jap Naam can only be taught by the Panj. This is the difference between situation in UK and Canada. What a nonsense.... so what if they want to learn... ultimately it is their loss. Typical biggotted opinions of oneself... so prevalent in todays singhs!!! Get to grips... Guru Nanak Dev Ji exclude anyone in this fashion??

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

. · 05 Jul 2006

the only Jathebandi which gives Naam DriRh correctly is AKJ _________________________________________ wow, look how united our panth is.

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

. · 05 Jul 2006

to all who think they have naam.they dont.we dont. in my opinion, there is no wrong way of doing simran, as in i mean there is no wrong way of repeating Vaheguru...if that is what is ebing repeated and meditated on and of course no one should be restricted acsess to darbar sahib, as this would be totally going agaisnt the whole point of the four doors to allow everyoen in and the fact that darbar was built on the lowest ground, so the lowest of the low could enter. following this philosophy stated by gurusahib, i woudl like to state that no one should be restricted from doing simran. on the other hand, i never uynderstand why poeple who ahve not learnt to do simran in that certain way(the "akj" way- sorry i had to say that, as i know the no jathebandi has any right over claiming ismran as their own but its easier to say the "akj" way) but those who havnt learnt this particular way, should not be trying to imitate others. simran is one, Vaheguru is one.and Vaheguru is simran, naam is simran, seva is simran.there are lots of methods, but each one of us is taught differently, depending on the situation at the time, or jathebandi or whatever, not saying one is better than another. instead of worrying about the fact that soem people arent "allowed" in amritvelas and instead of making rules such as these, everyone should cocnentrate on themselves.if oen does sirman themselves, they will gain the phal.doesnt matter what anyoen else is doing.im sure even in these coventry amritevlas people may lose track and start getting other thoughts.everyone just tries their best to remain focused and cocnentrate on Vaheguur alone..and not checking whos coming in and whether theyve had a certain naam dridh technique or not. mahraj says, this is the greatness of kaljug(i know that sounds weird) but gurusahib says sqjugu qRyqw duAwpru BxIAY kiljugu aUqmo jugw mwih ] sathajug thraethaa dhuaapar bhaneeai kalijug oothamo jugaa maahi || The Golden Age of Sat Yuga, the Silver Age of Trayta Yuga, and the Brass Age of Dwaapar Yuga are good; but the best is the Dark Age, the Iron Age, of Kali Yuga. Aih kru kry su Aih kru pwey koeI n pkVIAY iksY Qwie ]3] ahi kar karae s ahi kar paaeae koee n pakarreeai kisai thhaae ||3|| As we act, so are the rewards we receive; no one can take the place of another. ||3|| as we act.as we do simran, we reciieve the phall. none of us have really had naam dridh please remember this. we have not got naam, naam comes from within as does amrit.so no poin t in arguing, we are all in the saem boat.leats just all try and jap naam and read, do vichar on teachings of guursahib so we dont remain trapped in these silly and pointless arguments. Eie purK pRwxI DMin jn hih aupdysu krih praupkwirAw ] oue purakh praanee dhha(n)n jan hehi oupadhaes karehi paroupakaariaa || Blessed is that mortal being, who shares the Teachings for the good of others. please eveyone take note of the following beuatiful tuk swJ krIjY guxh kyrI Coif Avgx clIAY ] saajh kareejai guneh kaeree shhodd avagan chaleeai || Let us form a partnership, and share our virtues; let us abandon our faults, and walk on the Path. SHARE OUR VIRTUES instead of focusing on each others avguns.this goes for me too.

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Singh · 05 Jul 2006

It seem some people are writing silly comments just to have a go..... because you do saas girrass, it does not make you anti-panthic or anti-unity! Only a really pathetic person can suggest such a thing. By doing saas girass to get the greatest unity! You get united with Waheguru!!!

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Singh · 05 Jul 2006

Your wasting your time argueing! Author: .. well said!!

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

www.abhiyaas.co.uk · 05 Jul 2006

Admin jeeo please lock this topic and if possible remove it from the phorum as it is just hindering people from their Naam Abhiyaas. Some silly comments get made in such topics and mainly AKJ is called bad names along with Gursikhs from that Keertan Jatha. Sangat jeeo please take the following into account. 1. Khalsa should do Naam Japna instead of questioning what the panj piyare have told us. 2. Topics as these just cause more friction. 3. If we want panthic unity then we must actually wake up Amritvela and ATLEAST do two hours Naam Japna. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh says 'Khalsa Raaj will come, deffnitely come, and can but not come." This can only happen if the Khalsa accepts all of humanity as one. This can only come through Naam Japna. Please accept this humble benti Admin Jeeo. Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Tapoban Amritvela Simran

Admin · 05 Jul 2006

Topic locked. No more messages will be approved for this thread as per request from sangat. Admin.