Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Camps!

Camps!

Akal Akal · 05 Jul 2006

I have just recently read the hundreds of mails on camps and feel that they have overall done some service to the community. Camps are an old idea, Bhai Sahib Randir Singh (AKJ), Sant Bindrawale and many other prominent sikhs held gatherings to do parchar. The sort of culture and type of camps done by singhs of old can not be repeated in England, simply because most campers lack basic language skills and knowledge of sikhi. However, I have noticed BOSS and Sikhi camp seem elitist where as the sikh student camp seems for the average punjabi-sikh on the street, but this is not true sikhi - but we are not all true sikhs! Each is doing an important job, especially sikh student as they seem to bring in the worst of the worst! but still manage to make something of them from the testimonials. It seems that most posts about camps are targetted at individuals who have 'bad histories' or 'presents' for that matter. The individuals should be dealt with instead of labelling the camps as 'bad'. If we continue to label whole camps as 'bad' it will have a very detrimental effect on the community at large. The cyber sangat must approach camps to highlight the problems instead of just labelling the whole camp as manmat. I think we must look at the Khalsas whos names we all remeber, as mentioned above and increase our levels of tolerance. We should keep in mind our 5th and 9th Guru, "I may not agree with you, but i will die for your right to disagree with me" ps - I listen to punjabi songs

Re: Camps!

amarjeet singh · 06 Jul 2006

listenin to punjabi songs is pure manmat

Re: Camps!

_lowest_ · 07 Jul 2006

hmm labelling a camp as bad or manmat isnt gonna help improve it, of course not. but some camps need to be shut down, and reorganised with some more experienced and rehitvaan gursikhs, in order to sort out the problems. i do feel sorry for the organisers who obviously want the camp to be a success, but we need to sharpen up our act and make sure that no one is going away from the camp misinformed, or with bad experiences. hopefully the camps this year will be a success, and people will go away from them inspired by what they have seen and taken part in.

Re: Camps!

nobody · 08 Jul 2006

absolutely. sikhstudent camp needs to be shut down as it is just PURE manmukhi activities and does not further one's Gursikhi Jeevn but rather hinders it. This is coming from a person who has attended the camp and knows many other people who share this view.

Re: Camps!

khalistan_zindabaad · 08 Jul 2006

yeh boss camp is excellent few places left so give ur forms in ( istill have to )

Re: Camps!

Singh · 09 Jul 2006

If you want to learn and experience sikhi, and meet top Gursikhs, then there is no better place than khalsa camp.

Re: Camps!

run · 09 Jul 2006

for more information on sikh student camp visit www.sikhproblems.blogspot.com

Re: Camps!

some singh · 09 Jul 2006

I felt a lot of pyaar at sikh student camp even though I thought some of the security are idiots. oh yeah and I didn't like the way that the nangs think they are beyond rules which everyone else has to follow

Re: Camps!

Gursevakh Singh · 11 Jul 2006

sikh student camp changed my life I've been goin for the past 2 years. I used to smoke drink and cut my hair. whilst being there i didnt feel as though i was being discriminated against and the amount of pyar i gained for our Guru, is beyond describing. It is true some wrong goings went on with some nangs provoking it. I am happy to hear that these nangs are banned and a new security team is in place. The organisers need credit because they been through alot of hassle and yet are determined to carry on with camp. I am grateful to have attended this camp and am now on the path of a Gursikh. Instead of waking up to shave i now do 5 Bani Nitnem, instead of going to the bar after lectures i am now doing Rehrass Sahib Ji and instead of goin clubbing I am doin Kirtan Sohila. I am tired of hearing that this camp is complete manmat and is very hurtful to think that the camp that has helped me is being labelled this. If it is really bad why not try helping it out? Is that not the sikh way? The organisers are open to new people and suggestions. Pull Chuck Maaf Karni Gursevakh Singh

Re: Camps!

Harcharan Singh · 12 Jul 2006

For anyone who wants to experience and learn about Guru Sahibaans puratan kirtan using Guru Ji's created instruments and raags, there are still some places left on the UK Sikh Music Camp, which takes place at the end of this week, applications should be submitted on-line. US and CA sikh Music Camps take place over teh next month, please have a look, it is an eye-opening and life changing experience: http://rajacademy.com/page.php?page=sikhmusiccamps There are over 630 Gurmat Sangeet students around the world to date and growing, the structure is highly organised and resources are excellent and highly researched. Vahe-Guru

Re: Camps!

Singh · 12 Jul 2006

Gursevak singh, try attending other camps like khalsa camp. Then you will see why sikh student camp is not popular!

Re: Camps!

Gursevakh Singh · 12 Jul 2006

No thank you Singh im happy with Sikh Student. Maybe some other year...

Re: Camps!

Bhudysut · 13 Jul 2006

Wahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Wahiguru Ji Ki Fateh I have been quiet in regards to the camp issue, but if the Sangat does not mind, I would like to add my 2 cents worth. As someone who attended the first three BOSS (I stopped attending the BOSS camp because it was full of angry little boys who loved pointing fingers) camps and one of the Khalsa camps, I am not one who adheres to the fact that one camp is inherently better than the other. Whilst I do agree that the actions of some individuals are questionable, misbehaviour is not exclusive to the Sikh Student Camp. I have seen instances of un-Sikh like behaviour at various camps (which I may add was dealt with). But why bad behaviour was seen as a exclusive Sikh Student Camp problem is interesting. Those individuals who partook in bizarre activities have since been barred (according to Gursevakh Singh Veer Ji), yet there are still those who continue to criticise. I honestly feel the most Sikh-like way to deal with a situation such as this, was to have approached the organisers and asked if they could be helped in any way. In this way, any suggestions and concerns could have been raised whilst organisation was being carried out (this may of happened, but I have not heard anything to the contrary). However, good old-fashioned Punjabi mentality has seemed to have crept in here. Some people will never lose the mindset of ‘mine being better than yours’. I want to add, I have never attended Sikh Student Camp and no real intention of doing so. But that is not because of what has been said on this and other forums. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Ji Dass Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: Camps!

_lowest_ · 14 Jul 2006

waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh please forgive me if i offended anyone, i did not mean to single out sikh student camp, and nowhere in my post did i mention it. i have been to sikh student camp myself, and i mostly experienced the positive aspects. i hope that sikh student camp is a success and that everyone goes away from the camp feeling chardikala and having learnt more about sikhi. waheguru jee ka khalsa, waheguru jee kee fateh!!