Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

5vikaari,no-amritvela manmukh · 09 Jul 2006

Isn't this a good idea? Why doesn't SGPC talk to the Punjab government about it?

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

some1 · 09 Jul 2006

Agreed, its horse, u goto Hindu holy cities, u can't even find a liqour store, but in Amritsar, the GOI endorses them.

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

singh · 09 Jul 2006

well that would be a bit taliban style wouldnt it? The point is the people want to drink and cut their hair

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

gigi · 09 Jul 2006

Although I wish that there were no liquor stores and barber shops in Amritsar, but I don’t think a ban should be enforced. Even our Gurus who founded the city did not enforce this. We should do Parchar to people to not cut there hairs and drink liquor. Although I do believe that meat shops should be closed for force. During the movement, Baba Manochahal closed down many meat shops. I believe animals should be protected from abuse and torturous deaths at the hands of butchers.

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

5vikaari,no-amritvela manmukh · 09 Jul 2006

Well if they have no place to goto to get the latest hair style many wouldn't, only a few would cut their own hair. Well I never really thought of the muslims/hindus/christians that live there ;)

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

Khalsa Jatha · 10 Jul 2006

Ofcourse the barbers and liquor strores should be banned. I don't think the Gurus would have allocated any sites for the barbers or the pub when they built kartarpur, amritdar etc.

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

Singh · 10 Jul 2006

it is common practice not to allow cigaretee booths/liquor stores in cities deemed to be holy. All hindu cities have this ban. There were no barber shop and liquor stores or cigs stores in Amritsar until the British. Bhai Ram singh fought against this. So why can hindus have these rulkes for their cities and it is not applied to Amritsar? This is one of the issues the jujarhoos fought for.

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

kals · 10 Jul 2006

barbers? r u on crack? what about the non-sikhs?

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

PTE SINGH · 11 Jul 2006

You can't ban stuff from the city as a whole but an exclusion area from these things including billlboards could be set up around the complex

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

Khalsa Jatha · 11 Jul 2006

Ban it all. Why we pretending to be Politically correct! I can't imagine Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj allowing the booze shop in settlements set up by our Gurus. Even Maharaj's horse refused to go down the tabacco field!

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

singh · 12 Jul 2006

" Even Maharaj's horse refused to go down the tabacco field!" yeah but he didnt forcibly stop the soldiers and horses from going there. I pray to God sikhi doesnt turn into fundamentalist islam. We are supposed to do parchaar, not FORCE people to behave like our beliefs say. Do that and it wont be long till everyone hates us - like whats happening with muslims

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 12 Jul 2006

"gigi" thinks meat shops should be banned, yet liquor and barber shops are ok??? gigi- you DO realise that alcohol and cutting hair are more serious offences, i.e. there is still the debate on Jhatka meat - yet there are CLEAR rules on cutting hair and drinking.

Re: Shutting down barber/liquor shops in Amritsar

some1 · 12 Jul 2006

i feel the same as u Singh, i really hope it does'nt take that turn.