Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

doing ishnan in olden days

doing ishnan in olden days

singh · 11 Jul 2006

Since gursikhs hav to keep their kirpans (a kakkar) with them alll the time even wen doing ishnan, i was wondering how did the puratan singhs do ishnan with their big kirpans, as in them days im aware they wore massive kirpans like 3 foot...so how did they do ishnan with them? i.e. it would be hard to tie it to ure keski like we do nowadays with small kirpan. and how did they go to sleep with such a big kirpans plz help.

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

PTE SINGH · 12 Jul 2006

I would imagine that it is easy to sleep with your kirpan on, as I regularly sleep with my rifle however in all probability a warrior would have to keep his sword dry as possible. If it was getting wet on a regular basis it would rust no matter how well it was maintained. I know that this will be controversial and though I am a sardar I am not amritdari. However I have become more mindful of the 5Ks in my last 6 months as a reserve soldier than in the 27 years previous, As we all know the 5ks do have a spiritual purpose, however they do also have a very practical and military purpose. We as Sikhs become more hung up on the brahmistic ritual side of our Ks then the military and practical side. The weapon, the keshara the Kanga and daily bathing all have parallels with life in the army. In the army a soldier like a khalsa is to always have his weapon with him, however this does not mean that it needs to be slung on my shoulder when I bath, sleep or defecate, it means it should not be further than arms reach, so why would a khalsa wear his sword when bathing, when he could keep it dry and still within reach. Though we are taught that we should never be without our rifle we are trained to fight with bayonets and unarmed because during battle any one can become without arms while fighting. Surely a Sikh warrior in the old times would not have to retake his amrit because he sword was knocked from his hand. There are many occasions that a Khalsa would be without arms and die without arms, as many warriors in Sikh history did, it does not mean that there committed a kurhit.

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

Balpreet Singh · 12 Jul 2006

Keeping kakaars at all times is a rehit. If a kakaar falls accidently a Gursikh does ardaas for forgiveness and that is enough. Puratan Singhs had smaller shastar as well as the large 3ft sri sahib. The kirpan we all wear now was also something puratan Singhs had and was their kakaar. Even now we see that Singhs that wear a large 3ft sri sahib also have a smaller one underneath.

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

Harcharan Singh · 12 Jul 2006

Was the small kirpan not introduced by the British post the 2nd Anglo-Sikh war? The British collected all arms from Sikhs after they lost their Punjab, as Sikhs with arms always posed a military threat to the British (hence the numerous battles post the 1st Anglo-Sikh war). This was the reason that Baba Ram Singh insisted all Khalsa carry a laathi (in place of the kirpan - real one), so that Singhs would never be unarmed. The British are said to have allowed the smaller kirpan as a compromise, mainly to intice and recruit the Khalsa Singhs in the high profile Sikh Regiments, in which the British insisted on maintenance of strict rehit. I have never seen a picture or read a reference regarding a small kirpan, prior to the annexation of Punjab. In my view the small kirpan is a a recent addition to the Panth. Prior, a full kirpan would have been kept by Gur-Sikh, this is not to say that a number of other smaller shaster were not kept on the person, but the kirpan we see today is not puratan, if it was it would have a unique name, not one shared by the full sikh sword of defence - Kirpan. Shaster Naam Mala proves the Guru Gobind Singh Ji had no need to share one name for similar weapons. The Kirpan is designed as a minature replica of the kirpan, sheath included.

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

singh · 12 Jul 2006

it makes sense that even purataan sikhs would keep small kirpan with them in addition to the large one. so when bathing they coudl keep small kirpan ang sang and large one could be put asid.e Acutally, purataan sikhs would carry more than one weapon.

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

5vikaari-no amritvela manmukh · 12 Jul 2006

Very much agree with PTE Singh.

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

Mustaana! · 13 Jul 2006

Please PTE SINGH Do not post again on this site if this is what you are going to say about the Kakkars. We were told by our panj piyare to keep our kakkars on us all the time. You are a sardar and have not even taken amrit, please next time dont give such manmat advice. You will only confuse other gursikhs.

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

PTE SINGH · 13 Jul 2006

Mustana, I think you misunderstand, i was in no way shape or form advising anybody to do anything and made it very clear that i am not a authority on the Kakkar rehit, i only gave my opinion that many situations would occur where a Khalsa would be without his arms and that would not make him any less of a Khalsa and would not mean that he would have sinned. After all many thousands of Khalsa from Guru shaibs time to date have been taken as prisoners of war or political prisoners and would be totally unarmed during captivity right up untill they were put to death. Would this in your rehit mean they have sinned or have anything to seek forgivness for? Would a Khalsa fighting in a pitched battle refrain from using his small kirpan as a last resort in fear that it may be struck from his body? The 5 Kakkars are a khalsa's military attire and should be used and treated as such. [%sig%]

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

Balpreet Singh · 13 Jul 2006

Harcharan Singh, If you look at puraatan shastar of Guru Sahib and Gursikhs at Akal Takhat Sahib and other places, you will notice there are small kirpans. Same at Hazoor Sahib. Guru Gobind Singh jee's small kirpan is still displayed every day at Hazoor Sahib. I have seen Baba Deep Singh jee's small kirpan as well. I have also seen a picture of Baba Maharaj Singh and he has many shastar on his person. He has two small kirpans like we see today. One is in his gatra and the other is held in his hand. I haven't scanned this picture but will try to do so on the weekend. Small kirpans are puraatan and Gursikhs kept them as well as the large ones. As for the point PTE Singh brings up about Singhs being deprived of their kirpans after being captured: they did not purposely part from it and so there is no question of fault. The fault exists where a Singh purposely removes the kirpan. Incidental removal that is not intentional is not considered a fault even now. There is no need for anything more than an ardaas.

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

BirRass Singh · 14 Jul 2006

Buggal Deh Shastar - Shastar kept close to body near armpit (Kard, Khanjar, Pesh Kabz, Pistol) Kamarkasa Deh Shastar - Larger shastar kept in Kamarkasa (Kukri, Choor) Jang Deh Shastar - Large shastar which would be used on the battlefield kept in a Gatra (Tulwar, Khanda, Saif etc) Gupt Shastar - Hidden shastar which would never be used unless nothing else is available (nar nakha, bichuwa, small kard, small pesh kabz) Dumala Shastar - Shastar adoring the dastar (Gajga, Chakar, Sher Mukhiya) unlike today, olden singhs were armed to the teeth, they didnt jus carry a blunt butter knife, and they knew how to use everything they carried.

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

singh · 14 Jul 2006

Dear Balpreet Singh, Are these small kirpans or pesh kabz/kards? and can we remove our kirpan during close combat training?

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

Balpreet Singh · 14 Jul 2006

These are not pech kabz, they are small sri sahibs. I don't think that we can remove our sri sahib for training. Try to find a way to secure it so it isn't a danger.

Re: doing ishnan in olden days

Singh · 14 Jul 2006

Can someone post up some pictures of these Puratan kirpans. I have never seen a Puratan kirpan before only Pesh Kabz, Jambiyas, 3 foot tulwars, etc.