V. D. Savarkar's claims
Kulbir Singh · 11 Jul 2006
“Till the appearance of Shivaji on the political scene, it could be roughly stated that from the Himalayas to the seas – wherever the Hindu arms met those of the Muhammadans, before 1627, the Hindus were sure to lose,……….”
“From the Himalayas to the seas, wherever the Hindu arms met those of the Muhammadans after 1627, the Hindus were sure to win and the Muhammadans were sure to lick the dust, whatever be their strength or however tumultuous be their war-cries of “Allah-ho-Akbar” ! – God be victorious – God doubtless proved victorious, but it was the Hindu God.”
After this the author Veer Savarkar goes on to write that after the birth of Shivaji, non-Muslims always beat Muhammadans. He goes on the give examples of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaj, Baba Banda Singh Bahadur and other Sikh generals along with some Rajput generals.
I see that there are many exceptions to this claim by Savarkar e.g. - The battle of Panipat was fought 140 years after 1627. The Marathas fought valiantly and had one of the best generals of world – Bhau Sahib – but still lost.
The claim of Veer Savarkar is a spiritual one. He claims that something special happened after the birth of Shivaji Maratha in 1627. The tide changed in the favour of Hindus and against Muslims. Muslims always lost after that.
Since we are talking about the spiritual claims, the zavaal or the downfall of the Muslim empire began in 1675 when they ordered the martyrdom of Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee. Aurangzeb left Delhi and never returned back. He died in South India trying to suppress the Shia Muslim kingdoms and the Marathas. As the matter of fact, The first nail to their coffin was nailed after the shahidi of Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee Maharaj, in the early 1600s (I believe in 1606).
Then long before the battles of Shivaji, Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee Maharaj the sixth Guru of the Sikhs, won and fought 4 battles with Shah Jahan in Punjab. These battles I think are the first battles won against the Muhammadons in India. After that it was all downhill for the Mughals.
My intention is not to take away any credit from the Marathas who indeed played their great role in finishing off the Muslim rule from India but the statement that everything changed after 1627 the birth year of Shivaji does not seem to be correct.
It would be interesting to hear from Chandra Singh and other knowledgeable Hindu brothers. The above quotes are from Savarkar's book - Hindu Pad Padashahi.
Kulbir Singh
Re: V. D. Savarkar's claims
Kulbir Singh · 11 Jul 2006
Chandra Singh
-------------
What Savarkar meant (IMO) was the populairty of the Shivaji's approach to tackle the Islamists. Otherwise Shivaji couldn't arrived on the political scence in the year he was born.
------------
What you are writing is fine but this is not what he is saying. He is clearly saying that with the auspicious birth of Shivaji, the tide turned against Muslims. The Sikhi view on this is that anyone who gets to the position of power, is because of that person, or persons, previous good karma. When these people fail to do Dharmi Raj, their good karma burn and they lose their kingdom. We believe that the reason Muslims went down is because of their bad karma of killing Dharmi people, especially Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib's shahidi. Many people don't understand how Guru Sahib's shahidi burned the good karma of Mughals and how they went downwards from that time.
When the Kashmiri Pundits came to Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib at Siri Anandpur Sahib, and implored Guru Sahib to save their Dharma, Guru Sahib went into deep meditation. Siri Guru jee's Sahibzada - Baba Gobind Rai asked the reason for Guru Sahib's meditation. Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib explained the situation to Siri Dasmesh jee. Siri Dasmesh jee (tenth guru) asked the remedy of this problem. Siri Guru jee said that a sacrifice of a saintly person is required to destroy the evil rule of Mughals. At this Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj who was only a boy of 9-10 years old, said that who is a greater saint than Satguru jee himself. Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee was greatly pleased by this response of his son and declared that he would sacrifice his life to save Tilak and Janju.
From this saakhi we learn that Aurangzeb's evil regime was destroyed because he had committed the great sin of shahidi of Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee. From that day, until his death about 35-40 years later, he never slept properly and forever stayed tense. He had to stay forever engaged in battles and wars. The erosion of his kingdom happened from 1675 onwards. So much so that there was an open rebellion of people of Delhi after the shahidi of Guru Sahib. He never was able to come back to Delhi again. He stayed and died in South India.
The reason Marathas did not rise as high as they should have is that after Shivaji most of their leaders lacked the devotional fervour that Shivaji had. Shivaji was a deeply religious person and his personal character was quite solid. He was not after women as other kings of his times were. Baji Rao, though an excellent military strategist, was a person of lose character. He had a Muslim mistress. I mean, this man who as per Savarkar, was striving to bring Hindu Rashter in India, was a slave to the lust of a Muslim woman. How could we have expected anything better from him.
The reason of downfall of Sikhs in mid 1800s was also this very thing. Some of the leaders, including Raja Ranjit Singh did not keep their character high. When they saw women, they lost their control. It was a dark episode in Ranjit Singh's life to have been associated with Moraan Bai, a dancer of Amritsar city.
Savarkar has written very grudgingly that the Rajputs of Rajputana, mainly the kingdoms of Jaipur and Jodhpur, always sided with Mughals and later with English. What he fails to realise is that the people of Rajputana (Rajasthan) were oppressed by Marathas a number of times. Even in Punjab, when they came to Lahore, they appointed Adina Begh as the governor as opposed to giving this opportunity to Sikhs.
This book by Savarkar is quite well written but it very much ignores the faults of Marathas. It is very one-sided. Unless you look at the faults, how can you fix them for future time?
Kulbir Singh
Re: V. D. Savarkar's claims
Balwant Rao · 13 Jul 2006
after the fall of the unequal compromist that was the Mughal Empire the extremism of Aurangseb took hold
Thus Guru Tegh Bahadur was martyred in 1680
Shivaji died the same year after liberating Maharashtra and his son was martryed in 1689 hacked limb by limb by the Mughals
The Rajput Rajahs Jai Singh and Jaswant SIngh died in that same year and the Mughal attempts to convert the Rathore clan lead to the Rajput rebellion and their defeat of the Mughals in 1707
The Bundelas of central India under Chattrasal led a fifty year struggle to destory the Muslim power in that part of India
And there was the rebellion of the Satmamis and Jaats near the Delhi and UP area
By the time Guru Govind SIngh liberated much of Punjab it was seen as a death knell to the Muslim power - the beginning of the end
within 30 years Baji Rao was at the gates of Delhi
another twenty five years later and the Marathas were at the doors of Afganisthan
If it were not from the British then not a Muslim kingdom would have survived in India
Re: V. D. Savarkar's claims
Kulbir Singh · 16 Jul 2006
----------
Sambha Jee, the son of ShivaJee was also a very brave Maratha. When Aurangzeb gave him the ultimatum to convert to Islam, Sambajee was so angered at the mere suggestion of converting to Islam that he began swearing and shouting at Aurangzeb right at his face! Because of which Sambhajee had his tongue cut out and after torture was executed. He was truly a brave warrior.
----------
Sambha jee no doubt stayed defiant till the end. His refusal to convert to Islam was also very impertinent and insulting to his converters. He died saying obsenities to their prophet and other religious figures. This is why they had to cut his tongue. He continued to say obceneties to them through gestures.
As for the overall book by Savarkar, it is a book written in a very high spirit. It was good to read a Maratha history book by a nationalist Maratha. At times he seems to have got carried away when he declares that the Maratha movement or kingdom was the greatest after Yudhishter. He compares Maratha movement to that of Harshvardhan, Chandergupt, and other great kings of post Yudhishter era. He justifies the attacks on Rajputs and other kingdoms very skillfully.
Where ever he talks about Sikhs, he talks with respect. I give him points for that. Being a Maratha, no doubt, he believed in the greatness of Maratha movement but he was okay with Sikhs. While he laments the lack of effort on part of Rajputana and Jats, he does not utter a word against Sikhs. Rather, he acknowledges that Sikhs gave Abdali a good run after Panipat.
His account about Panipat was just amazing. I always had great deal of admiration for Bhausaheb who was truly the hero of Panipat along with his nephew Vishawrao. Savarkar has written about Vishawrao very emotionally. He compares his death to that of Abhimanyo.
There are a number of points where I disagree with the author but overall, it is a well written book.
Kulbir Singh