Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

Sardar · 13 Jul 2006

Many of the people today have been trying to find a way to make Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa go together. There is lots stuff in punjabi virsa that Sikhi opposes. Such as the false caste system made by the bahmins. Also, no rights for women in punjabi virsa. Idol worship, etc.

Re: Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

Dalbir · 13 Jul 2006

At this moment in time, for most Sikhs of a Punjabi background, the two are very difficult to separate. Besides you have to remember the vast majority of Sikhs are from a Jatt background, who love this as much as their Sikhi heritage (if not more in some cases). Also look at how the SGPC mob back home are so out of touch with the Sikh diaspora. I guess Sikhi will slowly become separated from Punjabi culture as the diaspora slowly loses touch with Punjab. But then we are in danger of having big differences in practices between Sikhs From the East and those from the West, with large scale westernisation taking place resulting in a further loss of numbers. Yet more division we could do without. What do you think?

Re: Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

some1 · 13 Jul 2006

U r just denying who u r by denying ur Punjabi Visra. I'm sorry. Idol worship??? Ur telling me that all the Sikhs in Punjab where idol worshippers before they moved to Toronto?

Re: Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

Sardar · 13 Jul 2006

Some1, no I'm not saying that.

Re: Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

inderjeet singh · 13 Jul 2006

veer jeeo no better person to ask but me coz i live in delhi and no exactly wot happens in punjsb as i keep interacting wid a lot of ppl from there and lemme tell u the youth there are so proud of speaking punjabi and wearin turbans ........from punjabi perspective thats cool but sorrily enuff...........when it comes to sikhi...............all they do is wear turbans and when they do that, irrespective of whether they keep proper kes or dhaada(which few do.....)they think that this is it when it comes to sikhi....wearing a turban and thats it and even the reason for wearing a turabn is not coz of sikh identity but coz of looking good and coz of punjabi identity.............much lik a lot of ppl wear turbans in songs lemme pour my heart out today even though i myself am in crap ........... ppl in punjab stick to their punjabi virsa pretty well by speaking punjabi but the kind of affinity they show towards songs,punjabi and all that is wot they just dont towards sikhi............................. and wid no offence gurdass mann and jazzyb etc. are more talked about than the guru sahibaans ........and ppl feel so relieved and satiated on listening to some slow songs like they listening to kirtan.......................... see being a punjabi or not being one is inconsequential in the end........wot matters is sikhi......punjabiyat is a culture ,a great one but still a culture.........................and sikhi ppl u know enuff wot trulu sikhi is............................... we can be a true punjabi by being a true sikh coz we read ,write and spea punjabi when doing gurmat veechar but speaking punjabi alone and being proud of some folklores is of no use.............................

Re: Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

some1 · 13 Jul 2006

I am poora khalistani , but if you believe u r not punjabi why do u want a Vakhra Punjab aka Khalitan.

Re: Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

ijs · 14 Jul 2006

its more important to be poora sikh that is a khalsa and then demand for a khalistan coz a khalistan without khalsa is meaningless its more imp. to be a pucca sikh first and maybe later be a staunch khalistaani

Re: Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

some1 · 14 Jul 2006

umm sure can't some1 be a non-sikh and a khalistani [%sig%]

Re: Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

Sardar · 14 Jul 2006

Some1, Khalistani-----now divide this word up-------Khalis+Tani=Khalistani! Khalistani only refers to KHALSA! As indian only refers to indians not Sikhs. And Inderjeet Singh Veer Ji, I totally agree with you, your comments were very positive, but i must say that it is not punjabi that they read and write, it is GURMUKHI! Shiri Guru Angad Dev Ji Mahaaraaj Ji created these alphabets. And really it is supposed to be called GURMUKHI NOT PUNJABI! Here check out this website: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gurmukhi I was not beginning a discussion about Khalistan "ijs" Bhenji/VeerJi(which ever one you are!). I think this topic has been discussed before about Khalistan, do a Tapoban Search and you may or may not find it! WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH!

Re: Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

fresno sikh · 14 Jul 2006

SSAKAL Once I was listening to speech by human rights advocate Jaswant Singh Khalra. He said there are three kind of punjabis. One who are in pakistan (turks), second who when Nadir Shah came to India merciless massacared thousands and later that evening contemplating about the happenings with his wazir. His wazir said these people have no spine and will reward you further. These people presented their wives and daughter to Nadir Shah. Third was the Khalsa who fought him and took back the loot and the women and returned them. I think Mr. Khalra explained it quiet well. "Bole So Nihal Sat Sri Akal" I felt like saying that for the third kind of Punjabis(THE KHALSA)

Re: Confusion Between Sikh Virsa and punjabi virsa

Dalbir · 14 Jul 2006

Independent minded Sikhs who don't grovel to any other quam are true Singhs.