Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

DKaur · 13 Jul 2006

I was recently in India. Myself, my husband and 2 other singhs decided to go to metha to check it out. As we walked down the paath we admired the beautiful lawn. To our left was the main divan and to our right were the stores, we first went to the stores. Before leaving we went to matha-tek. As we went to mata take we noticed that kirtan was going on on the left side and that 10 akhand paath sahibs were going on on the right side and that on tabeya they had not done parkash of guru ji. Can someone please explain why that is? I mean why wasn't parkash of guru ji done? Is there any reasons behind this?

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

uk singh · 13 Jul 2006

let me look into my crystal ball. wouldnt common sense tell u to ask there and then???

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

some1 · 14 Jul 2006

Singh thats very rude. your a UK JACK.

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

Satnam · 14 Jul 2006

Bhenjee this question can be asked on [address removed] http://www.damdamitaksal.com

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

wonderer · 15 Jul 2006

I myself have visited taksal headquarters lately and also seen the same thing happening. I think they are starting to practice some next things...

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

singh · 15 Jul 2006

they were probably too busy doing a havan.

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

S Singh · 16 Jul 2006

singh, please don’t say that. I don’t agree with everything that happens at Taksal, but out of respect lets not do unnecessary sarcasm like talking about Havans etc.

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

..... · 16 Jul 2006

iv heard so many people say that havan's have been done at Mehta, well wheres the proof? show me some pictures

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

Singh · 17 Jul 2006

If it is a taksal tradition then it is brahmanism.

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

!?! · 17 Jul 2006

'Singh' - what a stupid thing to say! What is wrong with doing a Sampat Paath?

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

singh · 17 Jul 2006

what is haavan?

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

Sardar · 17 Jul 2006

whats a havan?

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

Buss Teekia · 17 Jul 2006

wahegurujikakhalsawahegurujikefateh! Here we go on again....anyone wanna join in on the ride!!????......just as always on fourms we dont answer the question that needs to be answered instead we go in to 50 other directions and we leave the sangat and the person who asked the question hanging.....ANYWAY....ive also been to metha...we have to remeber that this is a SCHOOL so at that time the singhs might have been practicing to recite gurbani that is why so many maharaj day saroop were parkash.....other than that Taksal has gone through alot of changes since the split or whatever u wanna call it....this is just my 2 cents if some wants to BASH me that fine...i know! why not drag this topic on with sum more useless crapp and not answer the question...anyone else who knows more PLEASE answer the Question

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

Singh · 17 Jul 2006

I said the havan was brahmanism, not the sampat path. But now we are on the subject, the sampat path is against Panthik maryada aswell! Panthik maryada says only do sehaj paths and akhand paths. !?! wrote: > 'Singh' - what a stupid thing to say! > > What is wrong with doing a Sampat Paath?

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

calisingh · 17 Jul 2006

how many of you have actually done any type of paath which covers all of guru sahib???? if you have not, i dont htink you can say that a sampath paat or any other paat is anti-maryada... does the maryada say that a sampath paat is wrong??? no. its like saying you cant to do japji sahib in the evening b/c the rehit maryada says that it is part of the morning banis... get over yourselves...

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

... · 17 Jul 2006

Any slander against Taksaal is slander to 10th master; for tenth master began institution of taksaal for sikh to gain knowledge on gurbani. The teaching have been pass from generation to generation through 10th master.

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

Singh · 17 Jul 2006

I have respect for Bhindran Taksal but to suggest the Taksal we see today is a direct descendant of the one of Baba Deep Singh is only wishful thinking. There is no historical basis for the lineage Taksal puts forward. Not ONE historical text has been brought forward which supports it. Taksal was started in its present form by Baba Sunder Singh. Morale Vale have their own dera with a separate lineage which also includes Baba Bishan Singh. At any rate, questioning Taksal is not wrong. Gursikhs should be able to question any Sikh body. When Taksal claimed for 20+ years that Baba Jarnail Singh was alive, it was wrong. It was a lie to the entire Panth that both Dhumma and Ram Singh have admitted.

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

gupt · 18 Jul 2006

VJKK VJKF SANT JARNAIL SINGH JI'S SHAHEEDI DEBATE IT DOES NOT HAVE TO COME UP IN THIS TOPIC SO PLZ SHHHHHHH!! INCASE U CAUSE CONFLICT

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

Gurlaal Singh · 18 Jul 2006

How do you know it is a lie? :)

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

singh · 18 Jul 2006

why do people say that the current taksal does not have direct linage to Guru Gobind Singh Ji? and people say that the current taksal was started by sant baba sunder singh ji, these are both blatent lies and then anti-taksals will say wheres the proof? well seeing how sant baba sunder singh stayed with and got sikhiya from sant baba bishan singh ji AND wrote about it, doesn't this mean anything? just because you don't like taksal for what ever reason, do not bring false information into the debate to try and discredit the kurbaniya taksal has given for the panth....at the top of this forum it says personal attacks and flame wars are not premitted, but these people are blatently attacking taksal and trying to discredit it, which should not be allowed

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

taksal · 19 Jul 2006

well seeing how sant baba sunder singh stayed with and got sikhiya from sant baba bishan singh ji AND wrote about it, doesn't this mean anything? that doesnt prove that he was the next jathedar as the next jathedar of morale wale was a different person. and it doesnt prove baba bishan singhs lineage back to guru gobind singh. just because someone is saying something which you disagree with, doesnt mean they are "discrediting the kurbaniya" that taksal has done. i know taksali singhs take alot of pride that they have a lineage back to guru gobind singhs time, whenever you question taksal that is the main argument they use, so obviously when the argument is exposed as untrue, its not suprising that taksalis become very upset. face the facts - no puratan text mentions your lineage. many people make up fake lineages (eg baba mann singh) to give themselves more credibility and taksal is no different. they have done good for the panth but that doesnt make their lineage true.

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

Singh · 19 Jul 2006

This topic has been discussed on many occasions. At no point has any taksali been able to provide any proof of taksal in purataan sikh history. Give it up, just like you had to with Sant ji shaheedi.

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

singh · 19 Jul 2006

well goign by your theory, then we shouldn't beleive a lot of things, how do you know that bhai sahib randeer singh wrote jail cheetiya?? did you see him in jail personally writing it? going by your way of thinking i could start saying that bhai sahib didnt really write it and it was all a conspriacy by the government who really wrote it. There is no proof he wrote it therefore he did not write it! (even though i do not believe this, i am just trying to proove the stupidity in your point)

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

S Singh · 19 Jul 2006

Taksal is not mentioned in any of the puraatan sources such as Suraj Parkash, Panth Parkash (Bhangoo), Mehma Parkash, Gur Kiya Sakhiyaa, Panth Parkash (Giani Gian Singh), Gurbilas Patshahi Dasvi or even the modern works such as Mahan Kosh. Surely if GUru Gobind SIngh Jee had started a 'Damdami Taksal' it would have been given a mention in anyone of those puraatan works. But no! it is not mentioned anywhere whatsoever. In truth Taksal was started by Sant Sundar Singh Jee a 100 years ago. Prior to Sant Sundar Singh Jee, there is no mention of a Damdami Taksal.

Re: My visit to Metha - Damdami Taksal headquarters

Taksali Singh · 19 Jul 2006

I request all Sangat on here to please show respect when addressing the Taksal. We are all brothers and sisters, perhaps from different jathas, but we have the same father and mother, in that that sense, we all have a lineage going back to Guru Gobind Singh ji. The Taksal does not state their lineage point to pump themselves up, but to show that the knowledge that Guru Gobind SIngh ji passed down to the 40 Singhs at Damdama Sahib, from whom only Bhai Mani Singh ji and Baba Deep Singh ji stayed behind (the rest went to Sachkhand immediately after the bhog of the arth katha of Guru Granth sahib done by Guru Maharaj himself), that knowledge has been preserved. After Baba Deep Singh ji became shaheed, Bhai Mani Singh took control of the Taksal until Bhai Mani Singh ji appointed Baba Gurbakhas Singh to lead the Taksal. The knowledge of Gurbani (arth, ucharan...) and Sikh history and rehit was continously passed down. Each Jathedar of the Taksal produced hundreds of students who carried forward this vidyia. Many students themselves bacame teachers, and that is why a precise lineage can become difficult to trace back now. Simlilairly if you look at the Taksal today it has 3-4 main branches (with hundreds of sub-branches in the form of Taksali students who become teachers and teach at a more low-key level).One may argue over the exact order of Jathedars, but that does not mean the vidyia is lost. Even with each of these splits in the taksal today, the vidyia resides with them all. Baba Sundar Singh ji was given hukam by Guru Gobind Singh ji at Hazoor Sahib to re-energize the Taksal as it had become dormant. If anyone want's an even more detailed history with each jathedaar's history, please speak with Gyani Raam Singh ji who heads the Taksal from Sangrawan. They are very knowledgeable in this sense. Please don't buy into Sanatanist propaganda and call mahaan Gursikhs of the Panth liars. Baba Sundar Singh ji, Baba Gurbachan Singh ji, Baba Kartar Singh ji, Baba Jarnail singh ji, Baba Takhur Singh ji would not make up a lineage. and please, please don't divert the topic by taking cheap shots and saying "taksal lied for 20 years". Speak with each jathedar (Gyani Raam Singh, Bhai Harnam Singh, and others) and ask them if they think Baba Takhur Singh ji was wrong. This is a whole other topic and can be disscussed with a Gursikh level of maturity. All I will say is that mahapursh like Baba Takhur Singh whom everyone in the taksal, including Baba Kartar Singh ji and Baba Jarnail Singh ji, respect to the max would not lie to the sangat. They had their reasons for staying true to their bachan right till the end which we not understand yet, perhaps we will learn what they meant in the future. As a bare minimum we can respect this wish and not slander Baba Takhur Singh ji.