Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

specifications for sikh wife

specifications for sikh wife

lookerer · 13 Jul 2006

im looking to get married. my parents have some girls in mind from the 'west' but i prefer one from india, just for my own reasons. one is that girls from here are (for the most part) are conditioned by western society to have a more western approach to life. not their fault, as males here fall in the same trap as well. i feel they dont respect certain things which i think make a good sikh woman. these things might be classified as part of 'punjabi' culture, but i think they are neccesary for being a good sikh woman and raising good sikh children. as a sikh, i feel girls from india who have been raised in good gursikh homes and taught decency and respect, will make a more suitable wife and mother from a sikhi standpoint. girls from here definition of decency and respect is more along the lines of what western society says, and they are more inclined to having more 'affectionate' expectations rather then 'functional' needs. This in turn becomes more of a relationship based on maintaining the persons affection and emotions, rather then doing sikhi. however, the situation is this. i feel uncomfortable going into other persons home and looking at their daughter and possibly saying no. I dont want to make a wife search into a charade. my parents have narrowed it to two girls and said i have to choose one. when i go see them....what, on a personal level, do i look for in making a decision and speaking to them? is it proper to ask personal questions? what are possible 'red-flags' to watch out for? how important of a factor is it to how the mother is? can i ask her about her past? also, ive heard that punjabi parents tend to match body types, ie tall with tall, big with big and so on. how much looking lik a 'jori' come into play, ie not being totally opposite in look...?

Re: specifications for sikh wife

singh · 13 Jul 2006

this is YOUR LIFE...ask the questions you need to ask. make sure you take this ONE opportunity, and i know you know that you will only get one chance to say "yes" or "no" and use it to get as much info as you possibly can. fateh

Re: specifications for sikh wife

kirtan lover · 14 Jul 2006

Looks... don't count... disregard that... Just make sure you don't look really odd together.. Don't ask direct yes no type questions as you will get answers you want to hear... think of it as if you are interviewing for a candidate in a job... harsh I know but this is what you have to do to ensure there is some match between you. Ask open ended question based on scenarios. In my opinion girls that have too much of a bond with family will find it difficult to settle in a new home. So try and find how she will get over this. Ask how she will settle in a new environment, not will you be able to settle in a new environment. Good luck and remember .. this is all in his hands and we really are just a part of his whole mechanism.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

singh · 14 Jul 2006

Your assumptions about Sikh Women from the West is so off, it is funny. There are many Sikh women who are great people and who don't have a Western slant to them from the West. It all depends on the up bringing within the families. You can't assume the Girls in Punjab are goody two shoes, everything has changed over the last while. You have to look at the good qualities of the person, not the country or birth place. I am in a similar position as you and will most likely be travelling to the homeland sime time soon to get married. I think you should ask the questions you feel are important. Prepare before you meet them. Think of what you want to ask them. What values are important to you, what you want to do in life - do you both have smiliar goals and natures. Can you picture this person as the mother of your children? Does she want to live within the family or seperate. What is her nature like? Someone above mentioned that looks don't matter. Who are we kidding here, you have to be comfortable with the person on all levels, otherwise your mind will start running afterwards. Remember if you don't feel its right - then keep looking and remeber to do ardaas before you have started, and take guidance it always helps.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

some1 · 14 Jul 2006

and remember the girls are at liberty to say no also.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

lookerer · 14 Jul 2006

singh, i didnt make an assumption. i made a generalized statement, which is obviously not true for every girl. there are indeed always exceptions, but im looking at the broader picture of the west, and the realities that come with living here. what i was saying is that the odds are more likely to get a good gursikh girl from india. we should not judge, but rather use good judgement. we have to open eyes and not ignore issues. ok, so there are some girls that are good, but that does not mean we close our eyes to the rest of them. take a look at 'hi5' which is more accesible here. its not an exact indicator, but a good eye opener. see how many distar-walian girls are posting their pics for world to see. these pics are in not-so-decent clothing, and they are promoting their interests ie in music, tv shows, movies etc. essentially, they are advertising themselves but justify it by saying its a way to keep up with friends. meanwhile, they are also telling everyone in their profile that they absolutely love kirtan and sikhi and saadh sangat. if you notice in my post, i made mention to males being in the same boat. when i mean say the word 'west' i am not criticising anyone, i am simply implying that there are certain distractions to living in this society which prevent furthering sikhi, or atleast make it harder. many people are blind to it, because they have assimilated, and certain things are now second nature to their lifestyle. again, do not take this as labelling every person. as well, i didnt say girls in punjab are the best either, but rather that the chances of getting a good gursikh girl from there are more. why do you think tapoban sahib is trying to preserve our sikhi so much while living here. so we dont forget and lose it. anyhow, back to the topic. i myself am not the most knowledgeable in these matters, which is why i asked. the points given do make sense, they are greatly appreciated but one want answered. how much should i look into the family and their history? as well, what should she be able to do for [i]me[/i] ie my expectations of her.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

one · 14 Jul 2006

Thats all an individual opinion and your asking the saad sangat is like saying "what should I eat for breakfast"; everyone has different tastes and expectations, do some soul searching and find urs. Even the judgements u make on "western" women are just urs, other ppl might think the opposite towards "eastern" women and feel that they are not as much into sikhi.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

Singh · 14 Jul 2006

I totally agree with 'lookerer' I know many singhs that agree with veer jee. There maybe a handful to distar vaali girls in the west which are not like that. but i have been told by many that this hi5 has many sikh girls and boys showing themselves off in a way which we can not even imagine to think that puratan singhs and singhnis would have done. I think this puts off a lot of people and thats why many go back to india to find there partner. which would inculde that they have that connection with panjab. ps one jeeo I dont think nothing is wrong to ask sangats view on something like this... lookerer jee turned to sangat, I dont really the similarity in the example you gave about breakfast at all.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

Singh · 14 Jul 2006

I agree with Lookerer. Many guys also tell me that girls from India are better. But it's all a matter of perspective because many guys also like to get married to a westernized girl. Some prefer westernized while some prefer eastern. I am also getting married soon, and I think that I will choose someone in India. Hi5 is also one of the reasons because of which I choose not to marry in the west. But it is all a matter of preference. There are plenty of Chardi Kala Kaurs in the west. [%sig%]

Re: specifications for sikh wife

singh · 14 Jul 2006

bibia from india are way better than bibia from the west, half the ones in the west chit chat with boys all the time, wear revealing,tight clothes and post their pictures up on the interenet eg. hi5 etc.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

do you really need our opinion · 14 Jul 2006

If you are here asking these questions - you need to ask yourself if you are actually ready to take on the responsibility of marriage. Answer no. 2 was perfect - it's YOUR life - YOU will have to live it - YOU figure out the questions. Marriage is not just about bringing a girl into your family and expecting her to settle in. You and your family [if you both live at your parents home after marriage] will also have to make adjustments to your personalities and your lifestyles to accommodate her. Marriage is not a one way thing - you BOTH take laavaan and you BOTH make a comitment to each other and to God. I would urge you to think about what marriage means to you before you take this step. Please don't take this as criticism. Think about it with a cool mind and take it as friendly advice. All the best. One final thing and this is just a personal opinion - looks aren't all that important - you will not be spending your days gazing into each others eyes forever beacuse at some point "real life" will take over but yes obviously [by the very nature of this relationship] you will need to feel attracted to the person and that can happen through liking their personality. Good luck.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

do you really need our opinion · 14 Jul 2006

by the way - the title of this post is really funny - "specification for a sikh wife"... hmnn don't forget that she is a person - she will have thoughts and feelings in the same way as you - don't forget the human aspect during the "interview" :-)

Re: specifications for sikh wife

lookerer · 14 Jul 2006

'do you really need our opinion', point taken. im not learned in many things which is why i asked, but gave some background info to myself as well, as well as my personal opinion. i dont believe i said anything wrong. if i did, i apologize. i have noticed too many people thinking this subject is an attack, and therefore hiding the fact of what is true.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

ck singhnee · 14 Jul 2006

WOW. lookerer is absolutely right. couldnt have said it better myself. nice post. its good to see we have some morals left.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

. · 14 Jul 2006

be careful though..these days girls and guys get marrages and come to canada and then leave their partner..all to come into a country..it's called a fake marrage so watch out for people in india...there have been tonnss of cases so far especially in British Columbia/Vancouver area. no attack intended..just keep your eyes open. :D

Re: specifications for sikh wife

kaur · 17 Jul 2006

fatehjee, you know how some of you are saying that most of us girls here are westernised and wear revealing clothes and put pictures up on hi5, im sorry but i have seen many men doing the same thing, its not just women and not every woman or girl does so ! i mean i dont do this, i wouldn't think of putting my picture up or wearing "revealing clothes" i think , i know many girls who arent what you call "westernised". you need to be careful with how we say things jee, because come one you have to admit that there are so many men/boys doing the same thing, chatting to girls putting there pics up on hi5 e.t.c but again not all men/boys do ! yes, there are women BUT men ALSO. marriage is a hard thing, yes and we all want to find the perfect partner for life, you should know what questions you want to ask, you need to ask her what you want to know. anyway i jus thought ill bring forward my point, bhul chuk maaf karne, fatehjee

Re: specifications for sikh wife

amarjeet singh · 17 Jul 2006

yes true westernised applies to both men and women

Re: specifications for sikh wife

ranks · 17 Jul 2006

i think if you read the message he specifically states that it applies for both males and females, as hes made reference to it. if you also read it, he does say alot don't wear revealing clothes but he says theres alot that do. i dont think hes blaming anyone in particular, hes blaming the society they live in and stating the 'odds' are better for india. for an example, in india, though some girls might talk to guys, its still frowned upon while in the west it isnt. girls are generally more susceptable to the western lifestyle, why do you think there are very few situations in which a girl born here goes specfically back to india to get a guy? because girls from here want a guy who is from here and has 'western' tendencies because thats what they have been conditioned to want, and that type of person would match their lifestyle. people are too sensitive to certain issues and i think thats the case with this one, especially when anyone has the slightest inkling of someone being 'sexist'. the post isnt as harsh it comes off sounding, and it is worth taking note of. i think many people are sub-conciously focusing on the points they want to read, and not the entire point as a whole. our sikh community should stop being so defensive in issues like this. the amritdhari community has a tendancy to separate 'punjabi' and 'sikh' as two separate identities, which might be true, but there are definitely things that overlap and might not always be strictly [i]punjabi[/i] even though some punjabis may share that belief. this is a situation where someone like this will post about it, a couple of people will read it, then it will be forgotten entirely but the truth will still remain. the key word people need to read is GENERALLY. it does not mean exactly, always, or literally.

Re: specifications for sikh wife

... · 18 Jul 2006

talking to guys is still frowned upon in the west aswell

Re: specifications for sikh wife

??? · 18 Jul 2006

you know when you say women from india are better, if you could find a wife from the west who wasn't so "westernised" e.t.c wouldn't that be better as you have both been bought up in similar ways...and could i just say one more thing, forgive me if i offend any one in any way, well you know how some men prefer a wife from india is that because most women from india are seen as hardworking, you know like more of a housewife type or like to work more and dont believe in conjugal roles (shared work). because most women here are most probably working women and therefore believe that everything , all the roles should be shared equally? any way i was just wndring! ...fateh