Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Book on Bhinderanwala banned

Book on Bhinderanwala banned

Tribune News Service · 15 Jul 2006

Book on Bhinderanwala banned Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, July 15 Damdami Taksal chief Baba Harnam Singh Dhumma today banned its own publication, “Rise and Fall of Khalistan Movement”, authored by one Buta Singh, that described his predecessor, Sant Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale and Dal Khalsa as “creations of Congress party”. The book, which is in fact an M.Phil thesis of Buta Singh, who had got degree from Guru Nanak Dev University a couple of years ago, was earlier released by Baba Dhumma himself on June 6 at Akal Takht to mark ‘Ghallukara Divas’ (genocide day). Virtually upset, the Taksal chief said he was “stabbed in the back” by his own men who had misguided him to publish and release the book from Akal Takht. “Since the book was in English, we could not read the contents before its publication”. The person responsible for it would be punished suitably, he said. Baba Dhumma has also constituted a three-member inquiry committee to take strict action against the “guilty”. Interestingly, Taksal and Akal Takht had described Sant Bhinderanwale as “Great martyr of 20th century” and now describing him as “creation of Cong” has come as a great embarrassment. Mr Kanwarpal Singh, a spokesman of Dal Khalsa, said Baba Dhumma had already tendered an unconditional apology for the publication of the controversial book. He, however, urged Baba Dhumma to give “exemplary punishment” to media and publications of the Taksal who got this book printed and released by Baba Dhumma. The publication and the ban of the controversial book have brought infighting in Damdami Taksal to fore. A Taksal faction, opposed to Baba Dhumma, is likely to raise storm on the publication of the controversial book. Bhai Mohkam Singh, a spokesman of Damdami Taksal, and Bhai Jasbir Singh Rode, a former Jathedar Akal Takht, have already taken at independent and parallel stand to support Mr Simranjit Singh Mann, president, Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar), after clash on July at Gurdwara Manji Sahib, Golden Temple. Dal Khalsa, while terming the book as “collection of historical wrongs”, urged Damdami Taksal to award severe punishment to its media manager for keeping Baba Dhuma in the dark. “It is directed at spreading the government’s theory and myths’, said Dal Khalsa. It said that a meagre expenditure of Rs 98 by Giani Zail Singh for a press conference meet of Dal Khalsa at Hotel Aroma, Chandigarh, had been blown out of proportion. Though Bhai Mohkam Singh, spokesman, Damdami Taksal, has refused to comment, it is learnt that he might remove Mr Tarjeet Singh as general manager, Khandedhar, the mouthpiece of the Taksal . The book stated that Indira Gandhi decided to reactivate the dormant Naxalites in Punjab to foment violence. The book stated that Sant Bhinderanwale supported the Congress candidates during the Assembly elections of 1980. However, Dr S.S. Narang, a former professor of GND varsity who was guide of Buta Singh, the author of the controversial book, said that his student had mentioned quotable references in his book. Dr Narang said he himself was an admirer of Sant Bhinderanwale and the book, too, is dedicated to him (Sant Bhinderanwale) and hence it should be read from the angle of a researcher.

Re: Book on Bhinderanwala banned

Tribune News Service · 16 Jul 2006

‘Khandedhar’ manager sacked Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, July 16 Infighting in the Damdami Taksal, once headed by the Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale group, today took a serious turn when Bhai Mohkam Singh, a spokesman of the Sikh seminary, sacked Mr Tardeep Singh, General Manager, ‘Khandedhar’, a monthly magazine of the organisation. Mr Tardeep Singh is confidant of Baba Harnam Singh Dhumma, successor of Sant Bhindranwale, who was made in charge Media and Publications of the Taksal. Indicting Mr Tardeep Singh for publishing controversial book - ‘Rise and Fall of Khalistan Movement’, authored by Buta Singh, Bhai Mohkam Singh, said that the matter was being probed. The book based on M.Phil thesis of Buta Singh, a former student of Guru Nanak Dev University, released on ‘Ghallukara Divas’ (genocide day) was suddenly banned by Baba Dhumma yesterday. Bhai Mohkam Singh alleged the book was published under direct supervision of Mr Tardeep Singh. He (Bhai Mohkam Singh) sought unconditional apology from the Sikh Panth for the publication of the controversial book. Meanwhile, Baba Ram Singh, head of breakaway group of the Damdami Taksal, has urged Sikh clergy to summon Baba Dhumma for publishing the controversial book that had dubbed Sant Bhindranwale and the Dal Khalsa as ‘creation of Congress’. He said it was shocking that while Akal Takht had honoured Sant Bhindranwale as ‘great martyr of 20th century’, the book of Damdami Taksal had portrayed him (Sant Bhindranwale) as ‘Congress agent’. He said the publication of the controversial book was outcome of a ‘deep-rooted conspiracy’. A storm has already been raised against Baba Dhumma who had sided with the SGPC and the Shiromani Akali Dal (Badal) after a clash on July 2 at Manji Sahib Gurdwara (Golden Temple) while Bhai Mohkam Singh and Bhai Jasbir Singh Rode, a former Jathedar Akal Takht had taken side of the SAD (Amritsar) chief, Mr Simranjit Singh Mann, after the clash on July 2. It is learnt that Baba Dhumma stands isolated among radical Sikh organisations following recent developments. They (the radical Sikh outfits) now have started questioning the role of Bhai Rode and Bhai Mohkam Singh, who were instrumental in the installation of Baba Dhumma as successor of Sant Bhindranwale. Baba Dhumma never courted arrest or held any position in the Damdami Taksal before his installation as Chief of the Taksal. It is learnt that Baba Dhumma was specially brought from the USA to take control of the Damdami Taksal.

Re: Book on Bhinderanwala banned

Its me again ! · 18 Jul 2006

We need to know what is written in the book , that it need to be banned....??? All I know from the news is that the book was written as part of PHd. thesis and is a research work.....

Re: Book on Bhinderanwala banned

** · 22 Jul 2006

In the book it is said that Sant Bhindrawale was planted by congress and he was a congress agent. Dhuma released this book.

Re: Book on Bhinderanwala banned

... · 22 Jul 2006

it all seem as some propaganda quiet person who speak the truth ban freedom of speach

Re: Book on Bhinderanwala banned

Nanak Singh Bhatti · 24 Jul 2006

DHUMMA is a MOLE planted by the NAZI INDIAN government. It's our duty to support BHAI RAM SINGH JI, the true sevadar of DAMDAMI TAKSAL. KHAISTAN ZIDABAD. SANT BHINDRANWALE ZINDABAD. [%sig%]

Re: Book on Bhinderanwala banned

some1 · 24 Jul 2006

Nanak Singh Bhatti, you have it wrong. He is a true sevadaar of the Panth, the only Jatehdar besides Bhai Mann that speaks up for the issue of khalistan. If one is a sevadaar of the panth, he is automaticaly a sevadaar of the Taksaal, as well as AKJ and all other Jathabandhis.