Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 08 Dec 2007

Is it just me, or are there others who are sick and tired of so called "Sikhs" who are totally against Sant Bhindranwale? I find that the typical 40-somethings who grew up in Punjab and were in their youth during 1984 are the worst, as all they saw/heard at the time was anti-Sikh government propaganda- and it seems to have worked! These people have not done any research whatsoever and just spew whatever they've been told - now these kinds of people are moaning about the portrait of Sant-ji at Amritsar, along with Shiv Sena, BJP etc - whom one would expect this from, but our "own" are not even on one side! Sant-ji never approved the killing of innocents, yet is being made out to be some kind of "hindu-murderer" - makes me think sometimes, what is/was the point of exclusively targeting specific guilty people to gun down (as was the majority case throughout the 80's by the Singhs), as the Singhs are demonised anyway? - Why not just go round blowing up mandirs across India - it does the trick for Al-Qaeda and the Hindus certainly got away with it in the case of the Babri masjid! Bhul chuk maaf

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 09 Dec 2007

bhindranwale did great things when speaking for equal rights for sikhs, i don't believe he killed inocent ppl. But bhindranwale shouldn't of endangered the lives of inocent ppl or damage for the harmandar sahib, i blame operation blue star or the congress party and bhindranwale, i blame the congress for attacking the harmandar sahib and for planning the attack, and i blame bhindranwale because when he knew the govt wanted him he should of gone under ground rather then start preparing the harmandar sahib as a battle field, he shouldn't of brought weapions into harmandar sahib. If bhindranwale went underground the congress party would of bin forced to boycot their plans for operation bluestar and forget about it. But congress party isn't a hindutva party remember indira gandhi married a parsi her son married a cathlic who is the current leader of congress and the rss and all hindu militant organisations have wanted to destroy congress from the day india got independence, it were hindutva supporters who killed gandhi and it was hindutva supporters who wanted to kill rajiv gandhi more then the sikhs did after he sent in the indian army to kill tamil hindus in sri lanka supporting the non hindu govt of sri lanka, the congress were smart and were power hungry and corrupt ppl that explains them they were no hindu militant group they are just like the british they know how to pin groups against other groups and how to make ppl their puppets, jagdesh tytler who was the biggest player in anti sikh riots was raised by a christian missionary. Now some ppl are going to say bhindranwale went into harmandar sahib to protect it but i would like them to provide me evidence of this. Because i have never seeen evidence just heard story's and when i ask these ppl were they heard these story's well they heard it from someone else.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Harinder Singh · 09 Dec 2007

So true. But then this is ghor kaliyug in which saintly person is slandered and sakats are worshipped. Its not just Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Bhindrawale, people in Punjab slander jhujarru singhs too, and u have same people worshipping Navjot Sidhu who is a sell-out. But no need to worry. Waheguru Jee knows everything. He is true and His Justice is true as well. People of Punjab will pay a HEAVY price for betraying SAtguru Jee and His pyare sikhs.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 09 Dec 2007

Harinder Singh ji, you say that you blame Sant Bhindranwale, as well as the Congress party for operation blue star. Do you really think, that to arrest 1 man, there was a need for tanks, helicopters and thousands of military men to completely destroy Akal Takhat sahib and kill innocent pilgrims too? Sant ji used to hold open speeches - most of the time there were undercover police & intelligence officials in the sangat- why not use a sniper to kill him? Sant ji said on many occasions, that he was not "hiding" in the complex of Darbar Sahib, if the government wanted to arrest him, they could have - yes, there may have been a backlash, but surely the congress knew that sending in the army would create a much greater resentment towards Delhi. The reason for operation blue star was to "teach a lesson" to the Sikhs.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Mehtab Singh · 09 Dec 2007

Mr. mandeep, I gave you link to a book on Discover Sikhi forum where Mark Tully of BBC has clearly stated that the army had planned the attack 7-8 months before it took place, therefore you cannot blame Sant Ji. You still haven't checked the book. Please hold your comments until you have checked.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 09 Dec 2007

Sorry - my last post was meant in response to mandeep, NOT Harinder Singh ji...

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Bakaree · 09 Dec 2007

I am so sick and tired, of ignorant people who do not know the full facts. The "why didn't he let them arrest him" is the same thing I have heard hundreds of times. What people don't realise is that sant ji, had been arrested previously and let go without any charges. Many other gurduawara sahibs were attacked (I believe 70 something, but don't quote me) was their intended target, one man, at the everywhere at the same time? If they had not been for the gursikhs many more would have died, as the government chose such a special day knowing full well that Sikhs from all across India including the world would be there. also, it was unconstitutional, the Punjab police have stated that if they were ordered to arrest sant ji, they were more than capable of doing so, indeed they were not told to do so, as there were no charges. The army was brought in over the Punjab government head, bypassing them. it was malicious and meticulously planned don't believe the hype

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 10 Dec 2007

I suggest you read 'The Gallant Defender' written by AR Darshi. Mr Darshi was CM of punjab at one time. He lets people in on a lot of what was happening in background during those days. In his book, he writes that dozens and dozens of sikh places of worship were simultaneously attacked. If the army only wanted Sant ji, than why would they also attack those places? The attack was in the planning for a long time before it actually happened. The government had a model of Darbar Sahib built many months before the attack and commandos practiced attacking it. Sant ji knew this, and like a good son decided to accept shaheedi defending his father's house.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 10 Dec 2007

Mehtab Singh could you tell me were that author heard that story, did he get that fact from an ex indian spy, were their pictures taken, how did that author know that the indian government planned an attack before sant jarnail bhindranwale was in their, their books that say sant jarnail bhindranwale killed inocent hindus but these books don't tell us were they got their facts from does that make it true. I don't think so, if you know the book so well could you tell me were the author got his information from. Their books all over the place their books that claim sikhism is part of hinduism without evidence does it make it true because its in a book, NO. Bakaree you said 70 gurdwaras were attacked could you name me some of the gurdwaras and tell me what happened to them.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Harinder Singh · 10 Dec 2007

Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Bhindrawale fought one of the greatest wars ever. The singhs had pretty mediocre weapons(It was government who placed sophisticated weapons after the attack) and the singhs who actually fought werent many. I think they were about 50 odd singhs who got ready for shaheedi. Many singhs ran too as they dint have the kamayee who give shaheedi. The army had thought that this operation would last only for few hours but were completely shocked at the response they got from guru ke soorme. THe army was killed in large numbers(which obviously they wont admitt). The army got so insulted and angered at singhs that after they entered Darbar SAhib complex, they started killed innocent pilgrims. THe army committed terrible sins and the whole of indian nation will suffer from those sins in the future. Khalsa is going to come back and teach New Delhi a lesson.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Mehtab Singh · 10 Dec 2007

http://www.experiencefestival.com/a/Operation_Blue_Star_-_Beginnings/id/1819377 [i]In October 1983, 600 top soldiers of the Indian army began rehearsing an assault on the Akal Takhat at a secret location in the Chakrata Hills about 150 miles north of Delhi. They constructed a replica of the Darbar Sahib complex for the training.[/i] (Ref: Mark Tully's "Amritsar: Mrs. Gandhi's Last Battle" Page 118). [i]Reports of these plans reached the Sikh Leadership. Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale along with Major General Shabeg Singh and other militants moved their quarters to Akal Takhat.[/i] This was the info I gave you on Discover Sikhi forum. You said you had the book and will check, but you never did.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 10 Dec 2007

mehtab singh were did the author get his information from is what im asking you, and yes im going to get my hands on that book, but once again tell me were did the author get his information from, did he get it from a khalistani who could of made that story up or did he get it from an indian soilder who saw the plans or an ex indian spy. Tell me were did the author get his information from or did he get it from one of his buddies. I heard this story a million times and like i said no one has ever given reference to were this story came from. government and books have bin written saying sant jarnail bhindranwale killed inocent hindus does this mean its true.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 11 Dec 2007

Mehtab Singh i have a very important question to ask before i move on why did the congress party attack sikhs and why were they against sikhs??

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Karimul Fateh · 11 Dec 2007

Veer Mandeep ji, We would like you to go through this link "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Frontier_Force".Here is what it says "Since the SFF consisted largely of Tibetans, they were seen as an ideal counter-terrorist force as they were not directly related to Indian demographic profile. Thus, the Director General (DG) Security, Research & Analysis Wing (R&AW) dispatched 500 SFF operatives along with over 500 Indian Army special forces to Sarasawa for Counter Terrorist training, it is also thought that the selected troopers thereafter was sent to Israel for highly specialized training. These men formed the nucleus of an ultra elite and highly classified new detachment, known as the Special Group, which fell under the command of the SFF Inspector General (IG). Surprisingly, most Tibetans no longer serve in the Special Group. By early 1984, the SFF's elite Special Group became the primary counter-terrorist outfit in India. They participated in the assault on Golden Temple, but the mission was to prove faulty due to a lack of intelligence on the militants whereabouts in the temple locality. The SFF Special Group is very similarly structured like the Special Air Service (SAS) Regiment, its Headquarters supported by a Intelligence and Planning wing, a Training wing and a specialist Signals Troop which is solely responsible for support operations. Having four Squadrons each made up of around 100 troopers, which are further divided into four Troops. Each Troop has a specialized role. "

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 11 Dec 2007

As I've stated in my post, read THE GALLANT DEFENDER by AR Darshi, a Hindu, and the former chief minister of Punjab. It is a worthwhile read, and a lot of your questions regarding authenticity should be answered.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 12 Dec 2007

i know operation bluestar was planned and soilders needed training thats not my question my question was evidence on that bhindranwale went into harmandar sahib to protect it because he got word the indian government would attack it for no reasion.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Karimul Fateh · 13 Dec 2007

<< i know operation bluestar was planned and soliders needed training thats not my question >> You don't need to give training to already trained soldiers , you only tell them the details about the plan like which company of which battalion will make the move. Who'll be at egress point and who will secure which area and who will throw the cordon.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Karimul Fateh · 13 Dec 2007

here is one more link "http://www.rediff.com/news/2004/sep/14pca.htm" Operation Bluestar: 'Right decision, wrong implementation' New Delhi | September 14, 2004 15:22 IST Last Updated: September 15, 2004 15:11 IST The decision for a quick commando action instead of a siege of the Golden Temple in Amritsar to flush out terrorists was taken by army generals at the 'eleventh hour' taking then prime minister Indira Gandhi by surprise.P C Alexander, who was principal secretary to Gandhi and later to her son and successor Rajiv Gandhi, says this in his just released autobiography. <> The initial plan, as spelt out by then army chief General A S Vaidya, was an 'effective siege' involving cutting off telephone lines, electricity, water, food and inflow of men and weapons, says Alexander in Through the corridors of power published by Harper Collins, India. However, four days after briefing Gandhi, Gen Vaidya got back to her and said that it was the 'considered opinion' of the generals commanding the operations that while the siege could work for the smaller gurudwaras (where extremists had stocked arms and ammunition) it could not work in the case of the Golden Temple. Gandhi, writes Alexander, was 'taken aback', but she 'respected their professional judgement' and did not interfere with those in command of field operations. << So the government was not only after Sant Jarnail Singh ji Bhindranwale, it has somme other motives also>> Stating that the Golden Temple was easily accessible to intelligence teams for several weeks before the operations, Alexander writes, "If correct information about their (militants') numbers and weapons was available, it is doubtful whether they (army) would have gone ahead with the changed plan of operations in the manner they did, which necessitated the entry of tanks." << This only shows it Operation Bluestar was planned many weeks before hand>>

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 13 Dec 2007

Gandhi herself ordered the attack so she wouldn't appear weak , as there was an election near. the former CHIEF MINISTER OF PUNJAB himself confirmed that the army had been practicing the assault on a model. As for how sant ji knew, he had spies and informants, how else would he know?

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Khalsaspirit · 14 Dec 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Xylitol jio, Quote "read THE GALLANT DEFENDER by AR Darshi, a Hindu, and the former chief minister of Punjab" Could you verify when this AR Darshi was chief miniter of Punjab? and what is full name of AR? Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 15 Dec 2007

nope, sorry ji, can't verify any better than you can. and I don't know what the name stands for.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Khalsaspirit · 16 Dec 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, In that case let's see the history of prevoius chief ministers of PANJAB since the independence of HINDUSTAN and occupation of PANJAB. 1947 August Gopi Chand Bhargava (Congress) 1949 April Bhim Sen Sachar (Congress) 1949 October Gopi Chand Bhargana (Congress) 1951 June President’s rule 1952 April Bhim Sem Sachar (Congress) 1956 January Partap S. Kairon (Congress) 1964 June Gopi Chand Bhargava (Congress) 1964 July Ram Krishen (Congress) 1966 July President‘s rule 1966 November Giani Gurmukh Singh (Congress) 1967 March Gurnam Singh (Akali Dal) 1967 November Lachman S. Gill(Akali Dal) 1968 August President’s rule 1969 February Gurnam Singh (Akali Dal) 1970 March P. S. Badal(Akali Dal) 1972 March Giani Zail Singh (Congress) 1977 June P. S. Badal(Akali Dal) 1980 February President’s rule 1980 July Darbara Singh (Congress) 1983 October President’s rule 1985 September Surjit S. Barnala (Akali Dal) 1987 May President’s rule 1992 February Beant Singh (Congress) 1995 August H. S. Brar (Congress) 1996 October R. K. Bhattal(Congress) 1997 February P. S. Badal (Badal Akali Dal) 2002 February Amarinder Singh (Congress) 2007 February This one every one knows (Badal Akali Dal) khima for going bit off the topic, we asked this because not juct once three times mentioned AR Darshi as chief minister of Panjab. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 17 Dec 2007

Xylitol Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > Gandhi herself ordered the attack so she wouldn't > appear weak , as there was an election near. > > the former CHIEF MINISTER OF PUNJAB himself > confirmed that the army had been practicing the > assault on a model. As for how sant ji knew, he > had spies and informants, how else would he know? what was the cheif ministers name.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 17 Dec 2007

Karimul Fateh actually every army trains before a major operation, for example freeing hostages they'll do drills to make sure they get it right if they have few day's to train, or major operations overseas they will train to best of their ability with the time they our given. us army british army canadian army But my question was were is the proof and evidence that sant jarnail bhindranwale went into harmandar sahib to protect it, I don't want to hear stories i want to hear evidence behind these story's, kids say santa clause is real does it make him real because kids say he's real nope, the reasion we know he's not real is because their is no evidence. So if sant jarnail bhindranwale really went into harmandar sahib to protect it were did this story come from and were is the evidence to back it up. Because if indian govt planned to attack harmandar sahib just for no reasion the world would of called the indian govt a terrorist govt, and in the 80's india's economy was doing horrible so not to many country's would of cared trading with india especially when it almost collapsed in 91. and why were 20-25% of the soilders used to attack harmandar sahib sikhs?

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Karimul Fateh · 17 Dec 2007

<< and why were 20-25% of the soilders used to attack harmandar sahib sikhs? >> This statement of your really tells your ignorance about operation bluestar, the 10 Guards Battalion of indian army battalions which took part in operation bluestar had few Sikh soldiers in its rank and no other battalion had Sikhs under their ranks. The battalion which took part in operation bluestar were 1 Para 10 Guards 11 Garhwal 14 Kumaon 3 Garhwal 15 Kumaon 26 Madras 9 Garhwal SFF (which specialises in guerrilla warfare & composed of Tibetan refugees) BSF CRPF Except 10 Guards which was commanded by Lt Col Israr Khan , all other battalion were and are raised on etnic basis and 10 Guards had few Sikh soldiers listed in its rank. So your say that 20-25% Sikh soldiers took part in operation bluestar is absolutely wrong. << actually every army trains before a major operation, for example freeing hostages they'll do drills to make sure they get it right if they have few day's to train, or major operations overseas they will train to best of their ability with the time they our given. us army british army canadian army >> It is true, that army trains its soldiers, but not before any major operation as you have suggested, that training is part of their routine, every indian soldiers goes for BPET (12- 15 kms) run and other training in their battalion premises. Besides that Indian Army has Counterinsurgency and Jungle Warfare School setup in which almost every Indian Infantry battalion has been trained. So Indian army already had soldiers in its file which were adequately trained.(1 Para, SFF which are special forces ). Now let us get look into Operation bluestar and answer these question , 1. Why operation bluestar was carried out on the day when there were so many people had been there for pilgrimage.(Operation bluestar was carried out on the day of Martyrdom of Guru Arjun Dev ji). 2. We know that Punjab was cut off from outside world (there were none , telephone services, train, bus services to Punjab). If the Indian Government wanted they could have imposed Curfew in all of Punjab before start of Operation Bluestar, so that none of the pilgrims would have reached Harmandir Sahib. So the people caught in cross fire would have been minimum or there would have been none. But the Indian government capable of doing it didn't exercised this option Why? Was it deliberately not done. So that there could be maximum casualties of Sikhs . 3. If the Indian Government says that when talks between Akalis and them failed , then the operation bluestar was carried out. Then can Indian government justify that why it didn't let pilgrims go out of Harmadir Sahib before starting its operation. a) If the Indian government is saying that they feared Santji would have slipped in this manner, then it is clearly established that Indian government cared little for the sanctity of Harmandir Sahib, they wanted Santji dead in Harmandir Sahib only. b) If they are saying that pilgrims had been taken hostage then it is the biggest lie of all, you can check the eye witnesses account for that. 4. How can Indian Army justify that it had tanks in its file when it entered into Harmandir Sahib? Tanks are not meant for Counterinsurgency operations as far we all know. 5. How come when talks between Indian army and Akalis failed then just after that operation bluestar was started full blown? These things show that Indian Government cared less for the sanctity of Harmandir Sahib all they wanted was Santji dead, no matter if whole of amritsar burned.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Karimul Fateh · 17 Dec 2007

AR Darshi is an ex PCS officer not chief minister of Punjab as claimed by some members of this message board. A R DARSHI, Ex PCS Officer has retired as Joint Secretary Punjab Govt, during his long service in Punjab in the capacity of Indicial Magistrate, Sub Divisional Magistrate, Additional Deputy commissioner and Joint Secretary to Government of Punjab.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 17 Dec 2007

sorry about the mistake above regarding Darshi ji's job. he was privy to a lot of backroom meetings and behind the scene political stuff, this lead to confusion in my memory . About the Author A R DARSHI, Ex PCS Officer has retired as Joint Secretary Punjab Govt, during his long service in Punjab in the capacity of Indicial Magistrate, Sub Divisional Magistrate, Additional Deputy commissioner and Joint Secretary to Government of Punjab. He has carefully watched and monitored all politico-religious agitations and consequent developments. He has been able to recall and commemorate the outstanding contribution made by Sant Jarnail Singh Bhandranwale, who had raised the emaciated spirit of the Khalsa and had made an unparalleled and unique sacrifice in defence of the faith and the philosophy of the Khalsa so fondly created and nourished by Guru Govind Singh. here's the scoop. Indiaclub.com Description This book has been written for some compulsive reasons and meaningful purpose. The first reason is that during my long service in Punjab in the capacity of Judicial Magistrate, Sub divisional Magistrate, Additional Deputy Commissioner and Joint Secretary to Government of Punjab, I have carefully watched and monitored all politico-religious agitations and consequent developments right from the reign of late Partap Singh Kairon to the present day government of Parkash Singh Badal which is still crumblingly lurking on till this last day of 1998. The Second reason is that during the long stint of service in Punjab, very close and cordial relations with the top leaders of all political parties especially with the leaders of the Shiromani Akali Dal. This book is either based on author’s personal conversations held with the political leaders or his knowledge derived from political and other events. These events includes intra-contradictions prevailing among the Akali leaders; their confrontation with the discriminatory Congress governments; their conflicts with Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale; and last but not the least, Sant Bhindranwale’s struggle against the offensive launched by the Nirankaris headed by Gurbachan Singh, to subvert the Sikh religion. Although this book was written in 1985, after assassination of Longowal, yet it could not be published then. Now it is being published so that it may precede or coincide with the tercentenary celebrations of birth of the Khalsa. They have conveniently forgotten the outstanding services rendered by Sant Bhindranwale who has resuscitated the dead spirit of the Khalsa with his blood. Hence this book is being published on this auspicious occasion to refresh and revive the forgotten memory of the gallant defender.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 18 Dec 2007

i got ks brar's book and its in chapter 8 that he claims that quarter of sikhs were used to plan and work operation bluestar, and he is a sikh who helped plan operation bluestar Karimul Fateh i know why the govt attacked harmandar sahib to teach sikhs a lesson its indian politics, but can i ask you something whats the difference between bjp and congress, is the congress party anything like hinduatva??? secondly i hold indian govt and bhindranwale accountable, govt wanted to teach sikhs a lesson and they used bhindranwale as an excuse to attack harmandar sahib, why did he start turnign the harmandar sahib into a battle field by preparing it for battle and bringing guns in, why didn't he go underground, by challenging the indian govt back he ended up endangering the lives of thousands of inocent sikhs and damage to the harmandar sahib, why didn't he go underground and attack the govt and pick a battle ground were inocent sikhs wouldn't be killed.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Karimul Fateh · 18 Dec 2007

<< i got ks brar's book and its in chapter 8 that he claims that quarter of sikhs were used to plan and work operation bluestar, and he is a sikh who helped plan operation bluestar >> KS Brar a b***ard , his book is nothing but Indian government White paper which was released after Operation bluestar you can believe that basta** at your own peril. Regarding Santji, He himself had surrendered before the Indian government but was acquitted as no charge could be proved against him as there were none. Sikhs have defended Harmandir Sahib throughout their history whether it was Zakriya Khan or Ahmed Shah Abdali or Indira Gandhi and we Sikh will continue to do so.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 19 Dec 2007

read a book that actually tells the true story about what happened, rather than govt. propaganda. Gallant Defender book is now online: http://www.bhindranwale.net/sikhismbooks/the-gallant-defender.html

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Mehtab Singh · 19 Dec 2007

Lets keep in mind that this book was written by a well-educated and eminent officer who was a non-Sikh, infact a Hindu. The reader will thus have to accept a lot of what he says about Sant Ji. Those who think Sant Ji was responsible for Operation Bluestar, I have made some efforts to skim portions from the book for them to read and then decide who was responsible. [i]http://www.bhindranwale.net/sikhismbooks/thegallantdefender-chapter4.html It was not for nothing that Sant Bhindranwale, while addressing the concluding session of the Gurmat Training Camp organised by the A1SSF at the Guru Ram Das Langar Building on 31st December 1983. had pre­dicted that a conspiracy had been hatched (by Longowal and his clique) to level malicious charges against him and then set a stage for the Indian government to send para military forces to enter the Golden Temple Complex. He therefore cautioned the AISSF and other Akali workers to beware of these enemies of the Khalsa Panth. Earlier he used to say that he was neither in favour nor against the demand for Khalistan but on this occasion he spelt out (hat now it was up to the Indian government to decide whether they wanted to keep the Sikhs with them or out of them. If Khalistan was offered to them they will not refuse. It was a clear warning to the traitors headed by Longowal as well as the Indian government that the day Para Military F'orces were sent to Golden Temple Complex the foundation of Khalistan would be laid. When. in collusion with the Indian government. Longowal accused Sant Bhindranwale as the Congress Agent in second half of 1983 and simultaneously made an announcement that the Sant would not be permitted to address the audience from Manji Sahib, the Sant shifted his stage to the roof of Guru Ram Dass Langar building not for fear of Longowal but in the interest of unity he had so fondly brought about in the Akali Dal. Ho therefore voluntarily refrained from going to (he Manji Sahib and instead started addressing his audience from the Guru Ram Das Langar building. As a result flow au­dience at Manji Sahib gradually withered away consider­ably whereas the Langar building thronged with the en­thusiastic Sikh volunteers especially the youths. Thus Longowal. who had made a futile attempt to isolate Sant Bhindranwale. stood himself isolated from the Sikh masses. This situation totally demoralised Longowal. http://www.bhindranwale.net/sikhismbooks/thegallantdefender-chapter5.html Seeing the agony being suffered by the Sikhs In-dira Gandhi again pretended to assuage their injured feel­ings by inviting the Akali leaders for further negotia­tions. Strangely enough this time Rajiv Gandhi took ac­tive part in negotiations. The talks were held at Delhi on 17th & 24th January 1983 but as usual the result was yet another zero. Except these two secret meetings Rajiv Gandhi never participated in any other negotiations. This was very intriguing. Perhaps he had made up his mind that further negotiations with the Akalis would be a fu­tile exercise. He appeared to have opted for military ac­tion against the Sikhs led by Bhindranwale. Colonel B. Longer also played a hideous role in Pun­jab crisis. He was the man who analysed the overall po­litical fallout if a military attack was launched on the Golden Temple Complex. His conclusion was that mili­tary operation would create a political climate in the coun­try in favour of the Congress (I) to win the elections. It was, therefore, he who had turned the military action in favour of the Congress just six months before the elec­tions were due in January 1985. http://www.bhindranwale.net/sikhismbooks/thegallantdefender-chapter6.html The Sikhs were projected as communal, extremists, terrorists, separatists and anti national. To disseminate this vicious propaganda against the Sikhs, the Press, All India Radio and TV. were pressed into service. This ca­nard was carried to every nook and corner of the coun­try. The cry of the Sikhs was drowned in the vast sea of this vicious propaganda. Political atmosphere was sur­charged to such an extent that the Hindu Opposition Parties vied with one another to denigrate the Sikhs and advocated for taking military action against Sant Bhin-dranw ale and his followers. Atal Bihari Bajpai, President of'BJP. Charan Singh. President of the Lok Dal. leaders of both the Communist Parties, which style themselves as secular but basically they too are communal, and oth­ers were strong votaries of taking military action against the militant Sikhs. So much so Harchand Singh Longowal, Balwant Sin.gh Ex-Minister, Surjit Singh Barnala. and some other Akali leaders covertly supported the military action simply to please the Centre and then gain politi­cal power, So all Hindu Parties and the Akali traitors among the Sikhs cried with one voice "attack the Golden Temple Complex and teach a lesson to the militant Sikhs http://www.bhindranwale.net/sikhismbooks/thegallantdefender-chapter7.html The day of attack, 3rd June 1984, which was being observed as martyrdom day of Guru Arjan, was inten­tionally chosen by Indira Gandhi and her Hindu govern­ment mainly for two reasons. Firstly, she wanted to show indignity to the religious heritage of the Sikhs and chal­lenge their faith. Secondly, she wanted to entrap and massacre as many Sikhs as possible, because they had assembled there in large numbers to have a holy dip in the Sarovar and pay obeisance on that memorable day. O.n 3rd June the Sikhs pilgrims gathered in thousands and thronged the Golden Temple Complex. They came to observe Ihe martyrdom day from every nook and corner of India and even from abroad. As such, choosing of this auspicious day by Indira Gandhi to take military action was a monstrous crime against humanity which no civi­lised nation could have thought of much less to carry it out. However, the government in the White (Lie) Paper published in July 1984 naively tried tojustify the timing of military action-under the protect that Sant Bhindran-wale had instructed his followers to massacre the Hin­dus on 5th June, To give credence to this white lie Indira Gandhi alleged to have intercepted such a message hav­ing been sent by Sant Bhindranwale to the Sikh peas­antry. On what date the alleged message was sent by Bhindranwale and when it was intercepted by the gov­ernment is liil a mystery. If for sake of arguments it is admitted that such an absurd lie was true Indira Gandhi could.have advanced the timing of the savage attack by a few days although even then such an attack could not have been considered justified b\ any reason. This dis­information and lie was spread only to camouflage the monstrous plan of Indira Gandhi and her government. It is non-the-less crystal clear from the actual fact that Indira Gandhi and her government had intention­ally chosen the martyrdom day of Guru Arjun for launch­ing savage military altack on the Golden Temple Com­plex simply to challenge the Sikhs and their religion and force them-to surrender (hemselves before the Hindus. Whether or not she succeeded in her sinister design to subdue the Sikhs is yet to be evaluated.[/i] It is clear that the attack was pre-planned well in advance.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 19 Dec 2007

Karimul Fateh i agree with you about ks brar, but when ever you want the truth you have to read both sides the story and a third party to find out what really happened, im always curious about what happened in the 80's and have an interest in india politics and how it effects sikhs, i use to consider sant jarnail bhindranwale a hero, but for him staying in the harmandar sahib and risking the lives of thousands of inocent ppl doesn't make a good leader. He should of gone underground then the indian government would of bin forced to call of operation blue star or try explaining to the world why they would attack a minority for no reasion. If you read about indira gandhi by western authors she really wanted to put this image out their she was this strong feminest leader who loved her ppl, and she loved her reputation and wouldn't want to risk hurting it, so it wouldn't make sence for her party to attack harmandar sahib for no reasion and they did want to hurt the sikhs. This is why i consider the congress party smart they wanted to send sikhs a message and bhindranwale wouldn't leave harmandar sahib, this was the oppurtunity they were waiting for, they attacked the sikhs and had an excuse to tell the world so the world would sypathise with india and nothing would happen to indira gandhi's reputation. But tell me do you believe that congress is anything close to a hindutva party.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Mehtab Singh · 20 Dec 2007

mandeep, whether Sant Ji was inside the Sri Darbar Sahib complex or anywhere else, they were going to attack Sri Darbar Sahib anyways. If you are so adamant on blaming Sant Ji, why were 42 other Gurdwaras all over Punjab attacked as well? How would that be answered? Was Sant Ji in 42 Gurdwaras at one time?

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 20 Dec 2007

mehtab singh name me each one of the 42 gurdwaras as well as what happened in them what type of attack took place?

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 20 Dec 2007

as well do you believe congress is anything hindutva like.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Karimul Fateh · 20 Dec 2007

Veer Mandeep Ji, You are very much correct in saying that we have to read sides of the story. As you are taking reference to the KS Brar book "Operation Bluestar: A True Story". But Brar’s version has been severely criticized by several political analysts. One such challenger is Brig. Manmohan Singh Virk (Retd.) who in his review ("Black Spots in the General’s Bluestar") of Brar’s book, wonders why the General failed to address compelling counter evidence such as "the linkages involved in the rise of Sant Bhindranwale, allowing weapons into the Golden temple even when it had been sealed and surrounded by CRPF Units for over a year, and the build up of a situation where the use of the Army could be legitimized, the Constitutional Akali demands, tortuous course of negotiations between the Akalis and Indira Gandhi, and how, on two occasions, these were aborted after an agreement had been reached; of disinformation on Punjab which twisted the content of the problem from Constitutional to communal - including the stage-managed discovery of a cow’s tail and ears in Durgiana Temple and the cigarette butts in the Golden Temple in 1983." Brig. Manmohan Singh Virk believes that the Bluestar was a "devious" plot since it ignored other more appropriate, and less lethal, measures. He feels that, " Given the quantum of Army deployed in Punjab, the terrain, easy observation, and prevention of movement, and the narrow and congested city lanes, there could be no serious interference with the Operation, were it to be a siege." His accounting of the July 1984 meeting presided over by COAS, attended by top Army brass, is indeed illuminating. When, at one juncture, General Sundarji, Chief of Army, is quoting the casualty figures of the terrorists and the civilians killed and wounded, Lt. General Bhupinder Singh, then GOC-in-C of Central Command, were to ask "how many of those killed were terrorists" to which Gen. Sundarji were to reply "practically all of them." Unsatisfied with the answer, attendee Brig. Manmohan Singh Virk were to ask follow-up questions, which Q & A tells a story of its own: Brig. Virk: Sir, how did you determine who is a terrorist and who is not? Gen. Sundarji (losing his cool) : What the hell do you want to find out? Brig. Virk: Just the answer to the question I have asked. Gen. Sundarji: They were there, they got killed. Brig. Virk: I am afraid that does not answer my question. Gen. Sundarji: The number of weapons recovered and the number of persons killed were about the same Brig. Virk: I am afraid this still does not answer my question Gen. Sundarji: What the hell could we have done? The bodies had petrified. Brig. Virk: Sir, it may be in the Army’s long-term interest to say we do not honestly know how many of them were terrorists. According to Brig. Manmohan Singh Virk, "the Army had no idea of how many militants were inside the Golden Temple", a statement when measured against the report of a journalist that weapons were added to the arms cache recovered, reveals that Army brass not only exaggerated the number of terrorists killed but that the Operation itself was ill-conceived and poorly executed. General Sundarji’s prevarication is understandable. In what god’s name could he justify killing thousands of innocent pilgrims, looting of valuable Sikh relics and torching original historical documents? That he was an instrument to do Mrs. Gandhi’s evil bidding is crystal clear. He should have known better and taken the high ground even if it meant his disobeying the immoral summons - as called for by the judgement at Nuremberg.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Mehtab Singh · 20 Dec 2007

mandeep Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > mehtab singh name me each one of the 42 gurdwaras > as well as what happened in them what type of > attack took place? Actually I don't have the names of all 42 Gurdwaras, but since you seem to doubt and question everything, here is something more for you. Once again, this is by a non-Punjabi Hindu human rights activist. http://www.sikhreview.org/june2000/chronicle.htm [u]The Ghalughara: Operation Blue Star - A Retrospect[/u] [i]Ram Narayan Kumar[/i]* [i]* Eminent writer and analyst, author of The Sikh Struggle and The Sikh Unrest & The Indian State, Ajanta Books International, Delhi, 1997. He lives mostly in Vienna and London. Excerpted from the author’s monopraph submitted to Green College, Oxford, UK (Reuter Foundation Paper 128)[/i] On May 25, the government used the announcement to deploy 100,000 army troops throughout Punjab, also encircling 42 important Gurdwaras in the State, including the Golden Temple of Amritsar. Punjab should have been placed under a curfew if the government wanted to prevent innocent pilgrims from gathering at the Darbar Sahib in Amritsar and 42 other Gurdwaras throughout Punjab, which the army planned to attack, to celebrate Guru Arjun’s martyrdom day. A team of Union Ministers deputed by Indira Gandhi met the top Akali leaders secretly on May 26, two days after the announcement of their new program of agitation. The Akali leaders could at least have been asked to take steps to ward off the pilgrims in view of the impending military operation. This was not done. On May 30, President Zail Singh, the Supreme Commander of the Defence Forces, and himself a Sikh, assured a delegation from Punjab that the army had no intention to assault the temple. The President himself was ignorant about the impending operation. The army had isolated and stormed 42 other main Gurdwaras throughout Punjab. In the absence of a thorough investigation, it is difficult to estimate the casualties, but it is known that the operation against many Gurdwaras became bloody. The White Paper says that "terrorists at Moga and Muktsar offered a fair amount of resistance." Tiwana Commission of Inquiry, appointed by the Akali State government elected two years later to investigate some complaints of torture in army custody, said that 257 persons were shot down during the storming of the Dukhniwaran Gurdwara at Patiala. In the absence of an independent and comprehensive inquiry, the total figures of casualties and arrests during the army operation in Punjab shall never be known. The storming of the Temple was followed up with a mopping up operation in Punjab’s countryside, code named Operation Woodrose, which resulted in thousands of young Sikhs getting picked up. The government’s White Paper claims that a total of 4,712 were apprehended. Hopefully this clarifies your querry. If it doesn't, then I am sorry you are arguing just for the sake or arguing. Tomorrow you might ask me for the names of all the 5000 Sikhs who were massacred in Delhi. Well I am sorry I won't have them tomorrow nor do I have them today.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 21 Dec 2007

Karimul Fateh i told you ks brar's book isn't all truth but i still want to hear his side of the story, when ever you want to see the big picture you have to look at it from every angle, think about it why havn't sikhs gotton justice after 23 years, i believe its because our lack of understanding of the situation and india politics, right now congress is attacking bjp for 2002 riots and bjp is attacking congress for 84 riots, were are the sikhs why arn't they raising their voices and getting involved and attacking congress and starting campains, and the 84 anti sikh riots is making congress look hypocritical in front of india why arn't sikhs out their help push this matter.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 21 Dec 2007

Mehtab Singh i tried finding info about the storming of the gurdwara in patiala and couldn't find anything, like i said i need evidence to back info up and i couldn't find anything. I was critizising someone about panthic weekly on the other website and showing their conterdictions and providing evidence of how they got their facts wrong and my comment got deleted for some reasion, but i need evidence hardcore evidence, their's ppl who claim bhindranwale killed inocent ppl and personally i don't believe this because their is no evidence to back it up yet so many ppl and hindu websites and books claim this. Mehtab singh please name all 40 gurdwaras that were attacked. From 1-40 every name. Think about it if their is evidence out their that india was going to attack harmandar sahib for no reasion think about what it would do to india's reputation and how fast the world would turn on them, especially in the 80's india was struggling big time and 1991 the weak economy almost had a huge collapse so for india to start wars with minority's in front of the world without profiding reasion would of bin suicide to india and its govt and economy. Its common sence.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Mehtab Singh · 21 Dec 2007

Instead of asking us, how about for a change you try asking those Hindus what proofs they have to malign Sant Ji's name? Lets play the game from the other side now.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 06 Jan 2008

they got nothing except for accusations and extremely circumstantial evidence, ie. coincidence.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 07 Jan 2008

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs" Posted by: Xylitol (IP Logged) Date: December 09, 2007 05:05PM I suggest you read 'The Gallant Defender' written by AR Darshi. Mr Darshi was CM of punjab at one time. He lets people in on a lot of what was happening in background during those days. In his book, he writes that dozens and dozens of sikh places of worship were simultaneously attacked. If the army only wanted Sant ji, than why would they also attack those places? The attack was in the planning for a long time before it actually happened. The government had a model of Darbar Sahib built many months before the attack and commandos practiced attacking it. Sant ji knew this, and like a good son decided to accept shaheedi defending his father's house. Do you mind telling me those sikh places of woreship that were attacked, could you name all the gurdwaras that were attacked for me since you claim to have evidence.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 08 Jan 2008

If the word of the Hindu Joint Secretary of Punjab isn't enough to constitute evidence for you, than it's clear that you have a closed mind and have already decided to not change your position no matter what. I don't have the names. find out.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 12 Jan 2008

Xylitol you know what ill order this book tell me which page to look on and the name and author so i can find it on amazon.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 12 Jan 2008

xylitol reason i ask for book name and author is cause ive heard many claims that ppl couldn't prove were correct and couldn't tell me the orgin of the claim which implies in many ppl's heads that its made up, im not saying the book or author is made up but if you could give me a link of were i can find the book and give me the page number that talks about this ill appretiate it.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 13 Jan 2008

No need to order it, it's all online: http://www.bhindranwale.net/sikhismbooks/the-gallant-defender.html

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 13 Jan 2008

Sorry, I don't know the exact page number, just something comeing from memory. I've done all the research on whether or not Sant ji was a terrorist a long time ago. I became very convinced that he was in fact a defender of the community and that the government was trying to tarnish his image. So all this stuff regarding 84 is from memory.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

dilpuri · 15 Jan 2008

Fateh Ji, I do not know here in the forum,why people think that they are only right and they want every one should think there way only. This is not possible. Muslims feel every one is kafir, including we all and they are the only believer of god. Practically this is not the way. Try to think about the world in other's perspective. Otherwise if we remain narrow minded like muslims. This world will like hell. Fateh

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 16 Jan 2008

Xylitol i skimmed through that site and book real quick, their is no evidence for what you claimed, please back up your opinions with fact, cause to the person who made this thred, some sikhs think outside the box with free minds and ask why was jarnail bhindranwale in the harmandar sahib and risk the lives of thousands of inocent sikhs, why did he bring weapions into the harmandar sahib, that to me doesn't make him a sant. For me jarnail singh bhindranwale is just as responsible for operation bluestar as indira gandhi. For ppl who think indira gandhi wanted to kill off the sikhs hence why she attacked harmandar sahib i ask why she keep two sikh body guards, the fact they killed her they should of showed signs they were devout sikhs and were disturbed by operation bluestar, with out a doubt indira gandhi was corrupt and a criminal but she didn't attack sikhs cause she held a prejidice against sikhs.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 16 Jan 2008

Hmmm....search on the net than for the source of the attack on dozens of Gurdwaras. i don't have time to find it. I know this book mentions it but it may not satisfy you b/c it's written by a Sikh www.sikhcoalition.org/SantJarnailSingh.pdf. Also, the book I mentioned does clearly state that the attack was preplanned many months in advance. As a son, he wanted to defend his fathers home. Can you refute this? no. In fact, sangat singh, a former advisor to an Indian gov. defence planning group, also mentions this. You can see his book if you'd like, I think it's called History of the Sikhs. Also, I've seen the gurdwara in patiala, it has so many holes in the walls it looks like swiss cheese (no disrespect meant). I don't know when it was attacked, maybe you can start your search from there. But if you are serious about searching, you're probably going to have to go off the internet as not all info is online.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 16 Jan 2008

tell me were in the book it say's operation bluestar was pre planned and were did they get this information from. I researched sant jarnail bhindranwale and the events of 84. I actually use to support bhindranwale till the point i opened up my mind and started looking at important questions. If what happened in patiala is true you sure could give me references of their being an attack their, im pretty sure their would be information written by someone with evidence that this attack took place. Dude i use real sources not khalistani sources, because real sources back their claims with evidence, IN THE BOOK NO WERE DOES IT SHOW EVIDENCE FOR ANY PRE PLANNING Why are all the khalistanis hiding in the west screaming khalistan if they want khalistan why don't they go to india and get it or are they to scared. Xylitol ive read many books and still continue to, their has yet to be any evidence provided, just like the indian government hasn't provided rock solid evidence that bhindranwale was responsible for the murder of inocent hindus, but at the end of the day till someone gives me rock solid evidince and not urban myth's then ill believe it, but till then cause some khalistanis claim 40 gurdwaras were attacked while they hide in the west all scared of india's government doesn't mean it is true.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 16 Jan 2008

Xylitol tell me what it says in sangat singh's book, tell me what page i can look at, have you even read any of these books or do you read on something on a khalistani website and instantly believe what they tell you, cause give me any website even khalistan.net and i can show you their errors, for example khalistan.net talks about how rss and congress teamed up to destroy sikhs even panthic weekly, but in reality in the 80's rss were even celeberating indira gandhi's murder and the congress were attacking hindutva supporters and pissed off groups like rss by teaming up with a non hindu government of sri lanka and attacking tamil hindus. But tamils made it up by blowing up rajiv gandhi which many militant hindus celeberated. Also the man responsible for anti sikh riots was raised by a christian and that man is jagdesh tytler.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 16 Jan 2008

you can tell when a person has given into khalistani myth's when he thinks congress party is a pure bramin party trying to destroy sikhism because they find sikhism as a threat, oh hell no, reason they attacked bhindranwale was cause their a corrup power hungry party it had nothing to do with sikhism, punjab had alot of money so congress wanted to break the akalis by using bhindranwale thats why indira gandhi backed bhindranwale at one point and brought him into politics to break akalis in half and let congress take over.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 16 Jan 2008

Xylitol give me names of three gurdwaras and tell me what happened at them, just tell me then please if you going to give a book or anything then give me page numbers. Give me evidence, kids say santa clause exsists but their is no evidence thats why its called an urban myth, now ppl say 40 gurdwaras were attacked about 90% of bhindranwale followers say this but can't even name 3 gurdwaras so hence another urban myth. Tell me what type of buisness did indira gandhi want to do in punjab and why punjab's wealth was so important even though they controlled punjab's water and why she bring in bhindranwale and why she had so much interest in punjab's wealth, tell me the relationship she had with bhindranwale, tell me what her and bhindranwale talk about.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Bakaree · 16 Jan 2008

Mandeep singh, please read the politics of genocide by Inderjit Singh Jaijee, He is a human right activist, and has written in my opinion the best, objective, well researched/referenced book on the subject of bluestar (before and after) This book is written academically and backs up everything it alleges with hard facts, if you are really interested go and read this book properly- not just a quick read.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 17 Jan 2008

Bakaree i assume you read this book, tell me what evidence does inderjit singh jaijee provide about the government making plans to attack harmandar sahib for no reason and just killing sikhs cause it felt like it.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 17 Jan 2008

Mandeep, it's been a long time since I've read that book. I'm busy with school and so don't have time to look for specific page numbers. Why do you believe what the gov. says despite their lack of evidence when you don't believe in Sant ji? Seems like you've come in with a negative position. As for me, I initially thought that he was a terorrist, I did my own research, and came to believe that he is a hero and that the info agianst him was false. I also do not waste my time with most khalistani websites as you are correct, they are somewhat paranoid and make up SOME theories which don't make sense. RSS was probably not involved in the whole situation. They didn't want communal tension with sikhs. It was congress, a nastik party that wanted power by any means possible which painted itself as a strong leader of the Hindus. I don't think indira attacked Punjab for its wealth. They were already looting some of punjab's natural wealth (river waters beign a prime example). She wouldn't need to attack to steal this wealth. Remember, lawmakers can pass discrimanotry laws. She attacked b/c she had spread propaganda creating communal tension, she had made sant ji out to be an enemy, and an election was coming up. She attacked so she would look like a decisive strong leader who was not soft on terror - all so she could win an election. She had brought sant ji into politics to try to use him as a puppet against the akalis. But sant ji was too smart for her and began to fight for human rights and appropriate respect for sikh dharm, which is all he cared about. The truth is that the indian media was also against sant ji, an editor for an indian newspaper, 'times of india' I think, actually said they were asked to make khalistanis look bad. This is stated in an old edition of the newspaper. If you don't believe any of this, than you should do some in depth research. *As I've stated above, I have school and don't have time to search for citations for things I've researched for myself a long time ago.* Remember that indian media is bias and cannot be trusted. so why default on the side of believing negative things against sant ji??? If that's not good enough for you, I can't help you. But at the very least you should hold off on negative criticism of sant ji until you've done some in depth research of your own, without relying on gov. sources. Or the indian media.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 18 Jan 2008

Xylitol first you can't name 3 gurdwaras and can't even give me evidence and gave me a book that doesn't explain what you claimed. Secondly now your telling me i listen to the india media, ok xylitol tell me what part of the india's media do i listen to, what is it that i said that makes you think i listen to them.???? Please Answer like i said theirs always 3 sides to the story and when it comes to the 80's their three sides, their the side of the khalistanis and bhindranwale followers side and the india's govt side and then theirs the truth. Guess what Xylitol i look for the truth and thats what i get, tell me wouldn't it hurt indira gandhi to attack the harmandar sahib for no reason since you just told me that indira gandhi wanted to show that she's a strong leader with elections comming up, wouldn't the whole world bad mouthed indira gandhi, and if you read any of her biography's or even listen to what of the worlds leaders of the time said about her, she really cared about her image and showing the world she's a strong leader for the ppl, and ive said this before and thats what you seem to be saying, now if she attacked the harmandar sahib for no reason wouldn't that destroyed her image in front of the world and made her look like the bad guy in india and in front of the world, for attacking sikhs for no reason, then wouldn't she have to worry about what she was going to tell 15% of the army which consisted of the sikhs, wouldn't she worry what to tell the sikhs living across india who would rebel, wouldn't she worry about the punjab rebelling, guess why operation bluestar happened and why majority of the sikhs remained in the army and even went and died for rajiv gandhi in sri lanka, because the congress is to smart and not dumb enough to attack harmandar sahib for no reason. Bhindranwale got used as a puppet by indira gandhi and her party and they used him to attack harmandar sahib, thats why guys like me are against bhindranwale, thats not what a leader does and he clearly in my eyes failed as leader. Xylitol you just conterdicted yourself, now you sound like a hypocrite. Tell me three gurdwaras that were attacked or are you going to sit here and lie to me claiming to have evidence when you dont and tell me why would congress risk having so many sikhs rebel in teh army actually most of the army would of rebelled by attacking the harmandar sahib for no reason.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Xylitol · 18 Jan 2008

I suggest you reread my post as you clearly do not understand what I had written. I get the feeling that you wrote what you did in an emotional state. As for the names, I don't have them nor have I ever claimed to have them, if I did I would have told you a long time ago. I've read from more than one source that dozens of other gurdwaras were also attacked which is why I believe it. I see no point in continuing this back and forth b/c it seems that you are not interested in responding to many of my points. Gur Fateh.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 18 Jan 2008

i have re read your post, and you still havn't answered my questions, so you can't name the gurdwaras but because some guy tells you an urban myth you all of a sudden assume its true with out knowing which holy shrines were attacked, wow you'll believe anything, did you believe in santa clause till you were 10. You don't see a point of debating because you know and i know that you can't answer my questions, i think you now relise this urban myth that the india govt was going to attack harmandar sahib for no reason is an urban myth. So you don't have the names of the gurdwaras attacked yet you still claim gurdwaras were attacked why? answer my two questions 1. why would indira gandhi attack harmandar sahib for no reason and how would she explained to the world why she attacked harmandar sahib for no reason and how would she explained it to the military which consisted 10-15% sikh 2. what have i said that makes you think i listen to india media. I know for a fact you listen to khalistani urban myth's by your conterdictions.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

dashmesh_regiment · 19 Jan 2008

mandeep - At the same time that the Golden Temple was being attacked, some seventy other gurdwaras (Sikhs temples) were also being attacked. As stated in Politics of Genocides: "While the Darbar Sahib was under attack, other Army units were battling their way into 74 other gurdwaras in Punjab." -- http://library.thinkquest.org/C005706/sikh...n_blue_star.php The army had isolated and stormed 42 other main Gurdwaras throughout Punjab. In the absence of a thorough investigation, it is difficult to estimate the casualties, but it is known that the operation against many Gurdwaras became bloody. The White Paper says that "terrorists at Moga and Muktsar offered a fair amount of resistance." Tiwana Commission of Inquiry, appointed by the Akali State government elected two years later to investigate some complaints of torture in army custody, said that 257 persons were shot down during the storming of the Dukhniwaran Gurdwara at Patiala. In the absence of an independent and comprehensive inquiry, the total figures of casualties and arrests during the army operation in Punjab shall never be known. The storming of the Temple was followed up with a mopping up operation in Punjab’s countryside, code named Operation Woodrose, which resulted in thousands of young Sikhs getting picked up. The government’s White Paper claims that a total of 4,712 were apprehended -- http://allaboutsikhs.com/bluestar/ob21.htm the white paper referred to is the GOVERNMENT's own white paper on bluestar - you can read it online. Elsewhere across Punjab hundreds of Sikhs were killed in the army operation at the same time which saw 42 Gurdwaras raided at the same time as the Golden Temple, including high casualties at Moga, Mukatsar, Faridkot, Patiala, Ropar and Chowk Mehta. -- http://www.sikhs.org/1984b.htm i suggest you do a bit more reading - if you want a comprehensive english reading list, please ask. i do however understand your points about there being many inaccurate descriptions of what happened but i think it is fair to say that during bluestar other gurdwaras across punjab were also attacked. the government's own white paper admits this. indira gandhi attacked amritsar because she wanted to unify the majority hindu vote in states such as UP and Bihar - there was an upcoming election. there was also a serious risk that the sikhs would rally behind sant ji and start a full scale rebellion. many sikhs were in the army or ex army. punjab had the makings of a strong rebel army. guns were accessible from pakistan. dangerous situation. you need to ask yourself this question and provide a response - when the singhs killed indira, 3000 sikhs in delhi alone were killed by hindu/congress mob; but when rajiv was killed by a hindu tamil tiger, how many hindu/tamils were killed?

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

dashmesh_regiment · 19 Jan 2008

why did the indian army not do a operation blackthunder (1988) to the militants in 1984? surely there were other ways to get them out? why chose shaheedi day of guru arjan dev ji to attack? ask yourself these questions mandeep. it is arguable that sant ji was used by the government in their dirty politics game but sant ji did nothing wrong by fortifying the golden temple. how many times has the golden temple and akal takht been destroyed in the past? several times. amritsar being used as a battleground is nothing new. ever heard of baba deep singh? baba gurbaksh singh? where did they die and fight? who were they fighting? if you know about our history you wouldnt be asking silly questions.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

dashmesh_regiment · 19 Jan 2008

i would refer you to operation woodrose

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 19 Jan 2008

i said it already dashmesh regiment that india's government wanted to teach the sikhs a lesson and they used bhindranwale to do so. But once again could you name me 3 gurdwaras cause you said 70 were attacked could you name 3 other gurdwaras that were attacked during operation bluestar. Reason operation bluestar wasn't conducted like operation blackthunder were they cut the food and water and all that stuff and made the militants surrender without using a bullet was cause india wanted to teach sikhs a lesson, and fact that bhindranwale was inside india's govt used bhindranwale as an excuse to attack by calling him a terrorist, now if he wasn't inside harmandar sahib their would be NO OPERATION BLUESTAR, if so tell me what would indira gandhi say to explain her govt attacking for no reason, remember congress was smart thats why all of today's khalistanis hide in canada america england pakistan, the same pakistan that killed over half a million sikhs in 47. I give credit to the khalistanis who died fighting for the rights of the sikhs and to get justice for inocent sikhs who suffered. But not the khalistanis who killed inocent like talwinder parmar who cried like a baby in front of kps gill according to canadian intillegence reports and media, or bhindranwale nephew who created sikh youth federation and worked for india's government at same time. Did india's government plan on attacking harmandar sahib for no reason even if their were no militants inside the harmandar sahib, were they going to go in their and just start killing inocent ppl? if your answer is yes how would indira gandhi explain the attack to 10-15% of the indian army that consisted of sikhs and sikhs across the country and how would she explained herself in front of the world when she would look like hitler. If bhindranwale went underground harmandar sahib wouldn't of bin attacked so he was wrong in fortifying the golden temple. Dude don't twist history around to justify bhindranwale, when the harmandar sahib was destroyed in the past by afghans and so on and amritsar was turned into a battle field was when the muslims would attack amritsar and harmandar sahib for no reason, the sikhs who fought and died in harmandar sahib back in the 18th and 17th century died protecting the harmandar sahib when it was being attacked for no reason accept for trying to destroy sikhs. If they didn't go to defend the harmandar sahib from muslims attacking the muslims would of attacked it anyways,READ YOUR HISTORY HONESTLY dashmesh_regiment. tell me dashmesh regiment would india's government attacked harmandar sahib for no reason if bhindranwale had left? yes or no just answer the question if you don't it just shows me your just like any other supporter of bhindranwale believing in urban myth. Dashmesh regiement you just said 70 gurdwaras were attacked for no reason could you name me 3 or 5 or even 10 of the gurdwaras that were attacked??? cause i believe its an urban myth but if it were true and you wouldn't believe in an urban myth would you, you should be able to name 3-5-10 or even all 70 gurdwaras that were attacked. Operation blue star the govt used bhindranwale as an excuse to attack harmandar sahib, so why do sikhs look up to bhindranwale as a leader what he did doesn't show leadership quality's in my eyes, if bhindranwale and his followers were not in the harmandar sahib then their would of bin NO OPERATION BLUESTAR. So ppl believe in urban myth now can i ask something i personally don't believe bhindranwale had anything to do with inocent hindus being killed and i give him credit for speaking on sikh rights i said this before. But do any of you ppl believe bhindranwale ever ordered any of his followers to kill inocent hindus yes or no?? My answer is no cause their is no evidence, same reason i believe india's govt wouldn't attack harmandar sahib if bhindranwale followers were inside cause their is no evidence. If youc an believe in urban myth's then why not believe bhindranwal followers killed inocent hindus.?? One reason im against khalistan is i don't understand whats the point of running away from india and getting your own country rather then winning your rights in india and fighting for justice for the inocent sikhs killed in the anti sikh riots and all the other crimes commited.??

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

dashmesh_regiment · 20 Jan 2008

firstly you havent answered any of my questions. secondly, where did i say 70 gurdwaras were attacked? i merely quoted from some sources i found. the governments own white paper on bluestar says other gurdwaras were attacked. the sources have named the gurdwara in patiala. it is a very famous gurdwara. its also says the one at chowk metha was attacked. that is 2. im sorry i cant name any others but the governments own white paper says others were "raided"/attacked. i cant understand why you cant accept this. in any case even if there was no evidence, surely it would be logical for the government to raid other suspected militant gurdwaras? thirdly where did i say operation blusestar happened for no reason? blusestar MAY or MAY not have happened where it not for sant ji fortifying amritsar. you or i do not know this. i personally think it the army would have entered the complex as long as some sikh militants were there. the fact that sant ji was there gave them excuse enough. if he wasnt there, but others were, i personally think the army would have still gone in but not to the extent that it did with sant ji there. this is a difficult qns to answer since you or i do not know the governments plan at the time. we EACH have our PERSONAL thoughts. how do you know the afghans attacked amritsar for no reason? what is your source for this information? you are very confused. on one hand you say some people on this forum are saying bluestar was for no reason (which you think is wrong) yet you say above that the afghans attacked amritsar for no reason and would have done it anyway? what is the reasoning and logic behind this? both attacked for MANY REASONS. some of these reasons may have been similar some different. but surely an anti-sikh ideology came into play into BOTH of the attackers. this you cannot deny. again you do not know the story of baba gurbaskh singh properly. abdali attacked amritsar more than once. one of the times he did was to get rid of the nihangs led by baba ji. why? these nihangs would raid his caravans at night and take his loot. he did not like this. gurdwaras are known as places of worhsip and politics. what is anandpur sahib? a fort and gurdwara. think about this. it is clear that some of sant ji's followed killed innocent sikhs and hindus. whoever says they didnt i think is blind. sant ji himself stated in public that this was wrong. but "innonence" is subjective. whilst you or i may say they were innocent, the people who killed these innocents may claim that they were not. you were not there nor was i. fighting for justice you say!? 24 years on and ask the riot victims families how much justice the indian government has given them? the killers are MP's whilst the victims live in slums given 2 lakh rupees each as compensation. what about the thousands of sikhs killed in fake encounters? where is there justice? mr khalra was killed for seeking justice. you need to read up a bit more and think before you shout.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 20 Jan 2008

dashmesh_regiment you also conterdicted yourself, you claimed during operation bluestar that 74 gurdwaras were attacked then said 42 were attacked "At the same time that the Golden Temple was being attacked, some seventy other gurdwaras (Sikhs temples) were also being attacked. As stated in Politics of Genocides: "While the Darbar Sahib was under attack, other Army units were battling their way into 74 other gurdwaras in Punjab." "Elsewhere across Punjab hundreds of Sikhs were killed in the army operation at the same time which saw 42 Gurdwaras raided at the same time as the Golden Temple, including high casualties at Moga, Mukatsar, Faridkot, Patiala, Ropar and Chowk Mehta." you sound just like xyliton your telling me to believe in fairy tailes yet won't provide me evidence, you sound like those ppl who claim jews did 9/11 yet ppl can't provide evidence and constantly making up fairy tailes. As well what does 84 anti sikh riots have to do with what im saying about bhindranwale.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

dashmesh_regiment · 20 Jan 2008

I have not contradicted myself - AGAIN, where did I PERSONALLY say that 74 or 42 (or any specific number of gurdwaras) were attacked? I merely quoted some sources/quotes/info I found. I have accepted that there a number of discrepancies in the facts - this is inevitable in history and in particular when the Indian Government had imposed a MEDIA BLACKOUT. I have PREVIOUSLY said that the sources/quotes say that the gurdwara in Patiala and the gurdwara at Chowk Metha were attacked. THAT IS 2 NAMED gurdwaras. I am sorry I cannot state anymore from any named sources but I am sure other people with more knowledge than me will be able to produce a list - I am pretty sure a list has already been made but again I have not seen a list so am unable to verify this, however - see the paragraph below about the fairy tales you keep mentioning. fairy tales? - if you read what i wrote, the GOVERNMENT'S OWN WHITE PAPER admits other gurdwaras were attacked at the same time. The clean up operation was called OPERATION WOODROSE. Please do some research. I mentioned the 84 riots as YOU said that why do some Khalistanis sit in UK USA Canada and moan, why dont they goto India and seek JUSTICE? My point is that INDIA HAS NO JUSTICE FOR SIKHS. The leaders of the 84 riots are MP's at this point in time. KPS Gill is President of the Hockey Federation. How many CBI cases have been issued against him and Tytler? I answer (or try to) your questions directly. You do not answer anyone's questions - you need to learn how to argue effectively. Please answer my questions.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 20 Jan 2008

dashmesh regiment what question of mine did you answer, this is why i get mad everyone avoids my questions first of all thats not a real government white paper and i tried researching the two gurdwaras that you claimed were attacked and nothing, ive always tried finding evidence and nothing, from books internet anything asking ppl at the gurdwara who make the same claims if 40 gurdwaras were attacked could you name a few and they can't name one. Tell me what makes you think thats the governments own white paper?????? Please provide evidence without using a khalistani website. look at this website do you believe what this website claims while it provides wittnesses who saw bhindranwale make terrorist like threats http://www.sikhtimes.com/bios_060604a.html once again http://www.sikhtimes.com/bios_060604a.html

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 20 Jan 2008

Myth #1: Bhindranwale Was Not a Terrorist In 1985, Citizens for Democracy (C.F.D.), founded by Jayaprakash Narayan and chaired by the noted civil libertarian Justice V.M. Tarkunde, produced a report on the Punjab crisis. The report, banned in India because of its strong indictment of the state, has received wide acceptance within the diaspora Sikh community despite its acknowledgement of 'Bhindranwale's role in inciting violence.'50 Violent thoughts seemed second nature to Bhindranwale. He often made extremely cruel remarks with utmost sincerity, 'If a true Sikh drinks, he should be burnt alive.'51 Tavleen Singh discovered that in Bhindranwale's darbar (court), 'concepts like non-violence were mocked and sneering remarks made about Gandhi.'52 Perhaps Khushwant Singh said it best, 'He well understood that hate was a stronger passion than love.'53 Although the 'mad monk'54 was politically astute enough to recant vicious statements made in the heat of the moment, it is instructive to note just how bellicose he was when aroused. Harmit Singh Batra was in the Darbar Sahib complex on April 13, 1978 and quotes Bhindranwale, 'We will not allow this Nirankari convention to take place. We are going to march there and cut them to pieces!'55 Following the clash with the Nirankaris on April 13, 1978, the 'Sant' and his cohorts were always armed. Bhindranwale often publicly recited his mantra, 'being armed, there is no sin greater than not seeking justice.'56 And they perceived plenty of injustice all around, which they rectified with the use of illegal force. After the assassination of the Nirankari leader Gurbachan Singh on April 24, 1980, Bhindranwale is universally acknowledged to have remarked that if he ever met Ranjit Singh, the suspected killer, he would weigh him in gold (i.e. reward him with his weight in gold).57 On October 22, 1982, Bhindranwale made a public statement threatening the 'political and physical end' of anyone who didn't press for the full implementation of the Anandpur Sahib Resolution.58 On August 17, 1983, Bhindranwale asked Sikh youth to buy a motorcycle and a revolver and threatened to kill 5,000 Hindus in an hour if the police delayed the minibus he had sent to fetch Amrik Singh who had just been released from police custody.59 During a speech on September 20, 1983, Bhindranwale stated clearly that he would 'embrace' Sikhs who exacted revenge upon those who were guilty of torturing, killing, or humiliating Sikhs. He said, 'Getting away from there is your job, protecting you here [in the Darbar Sahib complex] is mine.'60 On November 17, 1983, Bhindranwale bluntly demanded 'that all Hindus should leave Punjab.'61 During a public speech delivered on May 24, 1984 at the Darbar Sahib complex, Bhindranwale openly admitted his complicity in the gruesome beheading of Surinder Singh Chinda for his role in the elimination of Bhindranwale's leading hit man, Surinder Singh Sodhi.62 Even Bhindranwale's staunchest supporters only go as far as stating, 'Bhindranwale consistently opposed violence against any innocent person.'63 The autocratic Bhindranwale had assumed singular jurisdiction over the guilt and innocence of a good portion of India's citizens. And to him lethal violence was a justified means of punishment for those whom he considered culpable. He was the legislature, executive and judiciary all rolled into one with complete disregard for the democratic concept of the separation of powers. The result was nothing short of 'ethnic cleansing.'64 Dilbir Singh (see above) related the following account of how masterfully Bhindranwale ordered the killing of Lala Jagat Narain, proprietor-editor of the Hind Samachar group of newspapers: And in one edition Lala had written in an editorial comment that Taura [Tohra, then president of the S.G.P.C.] and Ajnoha [then jathedar of the Akal Takht] are traitors. On that day in a great fury he [Bhindranwale] called upon someone to read aloud what Lala had said. There was quiet. 'Our turban has been torn from our heads,' he proclaimed. Then one of his followers asked, 'What are your orders?' Again in anger, he said 'Orders, you need orders! What orders? Are you blind?' Now you see he did not say anything. And they said it. 'O.K.' meaning thereby, we'll finish this man. So, then, 3-4 days later, Lala was coming from Ludhiana and they fired upon him.65 According to Chand Joshi, a veteran correspondent for The Hindustan Times, 'In the Nirankari Baba murder case, for instance, the C.B.I. claimed to have pin-pointed four suspects including Jarnail Singh Brar alias Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. The arrest warrants had been given to the Punjab police but were not served because of 'orders from the highest quarters.' '66 It is worth noting, 'The decision to release Bhindranwale was taken by the [Indira Gandhi and Zail Singh] government. It was not the verdict of a court.'67 Finally, it is impossible to accept that the people closest to Bhindranwale could consistently perpetrate monstrous violence without his endorsement. Nachhatar Singh, arrested by the police for the murder of Lala Jagat Narain, is said to have fingered Bhindranwale for ordering the killing.68 The hijackers of an Indian Airlines plane on September 20, 1981 claimed to be members of the Dal Khalsa and demanded the release of Bhindranwale, who had been arrested in connection with the murder of Lala Jagat Narain.69 In a speech, Bhindranwale 'praised his young lieutenants' for the hijacking.70 On July 18, 1982, a police party from the Beas Thana in Amritsar district stopped a jeep. Most of the occupants were residents of Bhindranwale's gurdwara Gurdarshan Parkash at Chowk Mehta. They attacked the police and were arrested. No case was initiated.71 The next day, Amrik Singh, Bhindranwale's most trusted lieutenant, and six close associates of Bhindranwale, including Bhindranwale's personal driver Kulwant Singh, were arrested for an attempt on the life of Joginder Singh Sandhu, the Nirankari Mandal's propaganda secretary.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

dashmesh_regiment · 20 Jan 2008

i have tried to answer your questions directly. are you unable to read? which question do you want an answer to? i have referred you to the GOVERNMENT'S WHITE PAPER ON BLUESTAR. is that a khalistani website? you have tried researching it have you?! thats very quick since it is over 1500 pages long. your research no doubt consists of "googling it". The governments white paper says that 59 people were killed and 35 were wounded during the attacks on other gurdwaras. 20 people were killed at Gurdwara DUkh Niwaran in Patiala. did you read that part? probably not. You say i only use khalistani websites? you have only quoted from ANTI KHALISTAN SOURCES! Khushwant Singh for example claims to have met Sant Ji but it is clear from Sant Ji's speeches that he has never ever met him - he says i dont like him or his writings but i have never met him. Khushwant Singh was lying. i have seen those quotes before. one mans terrorist is another man's hero. i am not denying that sant ji most probably gave orders to kill lala jagat narain. that man publicly abused the gurus. he took that risk himself. sant ji also most likely gave orders to kill many others. whether or not they were innocents is a matter of debate. no doubt some innocent people were most likely killed. only a fool would deny this. is seeking revenge on those who have abused your gurus, your family etc a bad thing? if the government or police cant protect you - what are you to do? sit there and take someone killing your family, robbing your house? would you take that? sikhi teaches to raise the sword after all others means are exhausted. in my opinion, the violence was a matter of self defence. lala abused the gurus. he was killed. nirankari sant pretended to be a guru, he was killed. you may think this is bad. others do not. if someone was to kill the dera sacha sauda sadh - would you call that man a terrorist or would you call him a shaheed. are sukha singh and mehtab singh (who killed massar ranga) terrorists? the murder of shinda was an act of personal revenge for sant ji. this i cannot deny. shinda killed sodhi, sant ji ordered the killing of shinda.i have heard the speech of sant ji after shinda was killed. is this terrorism? that is for you to decide. if someone killed your friend and you knew the police would do nothing about it, what would you do? i cannot justify what sant ji said about the 5000 hindus. he tried to justify it by saying he wanted to attract the governments attention, i personally think he said it in anger as the police had burned the guru granth sahib ji. i do not think this statement was right and was full of hatred. i accept this. however when innocent sikhs and hindus were killed - ie taken off buses and trains and shot - that is wrong. no one cany deny that. however just because the government said it was sikh militants who did it doesnt mean it was. we all know what confusion was created when 35 sikhs were killed in kashmir 5 years back. bill clinton himself thought it was a propaganda stunt pulled by the indian government. india is an untrustworthy and corrupt society and government - we all know this. we all know that CATS existed during the movement. even KPS Gill and DGP Virk have admitted this. CATS created confusion and killed innocents blaming it on the militants. however im sure some sikh militants did kill innocents. this is wrong. sant ji did say that killing innocents is wrong but killing guilty people is not wrong. this obviously would lead to violence. i cant deny that either but tell me how is it not in accordance with sikh principles?

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 21 Jan 2008

why is it no one else knows about those white papers, ive tried finding info about those white papers and no results. Have you read those white papers? could you reference anything from those white papers? COULD YOU TELL ME A MIDDLE SOURCE THAT WOULD PROVIDE THE SAME FACTS. I don't do my research on sikh websites or authors or indian and if i have to i look at both sides of the story, as well i look for middle men who pick no sides to get my facts. here are my questions you think you answered but i don't think you did so ill ask it again dashmesh_regiment do you believe the congress party was going to order attacks on harmandar sahib for no reason if bhindranwale and his followers were not inside? if yes then what would indira gandhi told the world to explain her actions and what would she tell the 10-15% of the indian army who consisted of sikhs, and how would this shown india that she is a strong leader by going and killing inocent sikhs for no reason and proving at that point to the world sikhs were discriminated against. I know sikhs were discriminated against but congress was smart and made sikhs look like terrorists in front of the world, now if congress had no excuse and just killed inocent sikhs what would they tell the world.??

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 21 Jan 2008

i think were both misunderstanding eachother I believe sikhs face and have faced prejidice in ways in india, some of the prejidice we face like the jokes made about sikhs is brought on by ourselves but what congress did and what rss and bjp are doing is pure prejidice, for congress it was for money and power, for bjp and rss its to create a talibon style hindu india. I believe bhindranwale was not a good or capable leader but he did a good job talking about are rights being violated for political gains reason i don't think he should be admired for what happened in operation bluestar and why i don't think he was a good leader was cause when india's govt was threatening to attack him in harmandar sahib he shouldn't of brought weapons in he and his followers should of gone underground and picked a different battle ground to take on the indian govt, If he went underground india's govt would of bin forced to leave harmandar sahib alone, and for anyone who believes they would attack it for no reason answer this first, what would indira gandhi told the ppl of india what would she told the sikhs in india and in the army and government and especially what woudl she told the international community. Bhindranwale and his followers were one of two reasons india's govt planned operation blue star and the second reason was to teach sikhs a lesson. Looking from an accountable point of view both indira gandhi and congress party and bhindranwale and his followers are responsible for operation bluestar. Alot of ppl fail to explain if indira gandhi just wanted to destroy sikhs why would she keep two sikh body guards?? for her it was money and power and in punjab she saw both and she did not like being disrespected and wanted to keep this image of a strong leader for her ppl and anyone who challenged her she would attack. Like i said many books written by pro bhindranwale supporters and you claim those white papers are real then why hasn't anyone and i mean anyone bin able to name the gurdwaras attacked yet you got these guys saying 42 gurdaras were attacked or 74 were attacked, i use to believe this to but till this day no one has mentioned names of these places.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 03 Mar 2008

dashmesh_regiment dude nothing say's those white papers exsist, and nothing about those two gurdwaras being attacked lol, oh man your sources are khalistani websites, name the gurdwaras and give me a reference which talks about this, tell me why the rest of the world and india itself doesn't know about these white papers.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

sidhu.hcl · 07 Mar 2008

I Believe Srimaan Sant BAba JArnail Singh Bhindranwale BAbaji was a great leader to sikhs. He was the single person of the time after Maharaja RAnjit Singh who had the calibre to put all sikhs altogether. Under his regime every sikh was drown away by his words. This kind of leadership we require.. Im not in favour of the method he adopted. but yes even if u listen him now u can see howmuch LEADERSHIP QUALITY he was having in him. moreover he directed sikhs to not to hurt anybody's religious sentiment but also he said this doesn't mean tht anyone can hurt ours. He cald everyone to unite under one roof and asked the sikhs residing outside Punjab to always be equipped with Kirpans or hathyaars .. coz anything can happen anytime moreover selfdefence is not a crime. i believe he was a prefect LEADER of his time.. we should all respect the great personality.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

dashmesh_regiment · 18 Mar 2008

mandeep: this article refers to the goverments white paper. it exists. unlucky mate. http://www.india-today.com/webexclusive/dispatch/20010609/vinayak.html

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 19 Mar 2008

but dashmesh_regiment coudl you tell me what the 40 other gurdwaras were that were attacked? cause till someone names them its an urban myth sidhu.hcl bhindranwale should of stayed out of harmandar sahib and kept weapions out instead of turning it into a place of politics and he was political if you check earlier in the post i provide evidence. If he stayed out of harmandar sahib then india wouldn't bin able to attack it. maharaja ranjit singh would of bin ten times more smarter then bhindranwale Why congress attack sikhs? if congress attack sikhs for just hating sikhs and made it obvious how would they reacted to trying to handle 10-15% of their army that consisted of sikhs

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

dashmesh_regiment · 19 Mar 2008

if you could read, you would see that i already named chowk mehta and dukhniwaran in patiala as 2 other gurdwaras attacked. i am unable at this point to name a third which you previously asked for. now you ask for all 40 (the number is in dispute in an case). you change the goal posts again - shows you cant debate.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

dashmesh_regiment · 19 Mar 2008

oh and by the way - do you want to apologise for implying that i and several others lied about the existence of the governments white paper? as the government white paper was a "urban myth" it must be the case that the fact that other gurdwaras were also attacked is another "urban myth" because YOU (someone who has been shown to be factually inaccurate) says so! mandeep you need to read some books and think before you write.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

inderjeet1012 · 20 Mar 2008

mandeep man get a life and start discussing issues that are going to help your and others sikhi............you may say a few clever comments here and there ....... so what???? calm down and think if all this really taking you anywhere........... and trying to undermine the gurmukhs of the past and present wont help you............

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 21 Mar 2008

dashmesh regiment i also asked to show me references to those two gurdwaras attacked and i mean credible, also start naming the gurdwaras with evidence, tell me were in those white papers it says 40 gurdwaras were attacked please. Could you give me any reference that names the 40 gurdwaras attacked cause till this day no one has bin able to proving that this is an urban myth about 40 other gurdwaras being attacked and once again proving that bhindranwale and indira gandhi were both causes of operation bluestar. dashmesh regiment you havn't provided any evidence as of yet, your debate is dumb, so if i said in the white papers it says no other gurdwaras were attacked would it make it true?? PPl would be stupid if they believed me if i said that the indian army never attacked harmandar sahib instead fed the militants and the ppl ladoo's and thats true cause its what it says on the whtie papers,yet i wouldn't be able to provide evidence, same goes for the two gurdwaras you claim to be attacked cause im waiting for you to provide credibile evidence just give me anything on top of that no one till this day bin able to name any of the 40 gurdwaras so i personally believe ppl who believe this myth are stupid.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 21 Mar 2008

dashmesh_regiment actually i can debate and trying to insult me doesn't work im not going to let you bail that easily, remember i asked for you to provide references about the two gurdwaras taht you claim were attacked, you know evidence cause i could tell you that soldiers came into operation bluestar delivering ppl ladoo but you would know thats false cause their no evidence. Forget the 40 gurdwaras named give me evidence for the two you named. You know something i can research to confirm is true.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 21 Mar 2008

dashmesh_regiment i have read books thats why i schooled you and everyone else in here. Ill admit that i was wrong on the white papers being myth but can't blame me with so many urban myth regarding the 80's around, especially the myth between the relationship between indira gandhi and rss cause more then one sikh website makes these claims and make fake newspaper articles trying to say that rss loved indria gandhi like god and wanted to kill the sikhs for killing her, funny thing was rss always wanted to kill her. But sikhlionz and sikhhistory and other websites would make fake newspapers for idiots like you who believe them. inderjeet, bhindranwale stayed out of harmandar sahib indira gandhi would of bin forced to abort operation bluestar, now a 5 year old would know that indira gandhi could not attack harmandar sahib for no reason cause it would make the 15% of her military revolt which consisted of sikhs and since i read books and don't believe in urgan myth's like dashmesh_regiment i look for evidence. Oh yes if you read on indira gandhi and check at how so many in the world review her as a hero even though she wasn't, it is cause she cared about her reputation, she wanted the world to think of her as a fair just women she was hell bent on this, she threw ppl in jail who would insult her reputation, so its common sence to know that she wouldn't attack harmandar sahib for no reason and just kill inocent ppl and blow up gurdwaras she needed an excuse and she made bhindranwale her puppet and her excuse. Another thing i keep forgetting to ask but now i remember, didn't indira gandhi bring bhindranwale into politics, cause i got an answer with evidence to this one that none of you guys talk about. Does anyone know how close he was with some congress leaders that ppl from his village talked about. Basicully ppl believe that bhindranwale protected harmandar sahib cause they say indira gandhi was leader of rss or whatever and they wanted a bramin world order this is 80% of khalistanis thinking and every khalistani website and ill post them talk about indira gandhi and rss being in bed with eachother to creat bramin india and apparantly indira gandhi and rss hate sikhi cause it opposes caste but then again guys dumb as dashmesh regiment believe these claims then cry. also they say 40 other gurdwaras were attacked, ppl at gurdwaras in vancouver ask the khalistanis and babbar khalsa guys about the 40 gurdwaras and they dont' give names but they'll start screaming and then crying or whatever but then you get those fights involving khalistanis were they start pulling on eachothers hair over 5 bucks. Dashmesh i need some evidence about the two gurdwaras and reliable evidence please. Cause i tried hunting the names of those two gurdwaras you named and asked ppl and no one has a clue.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 21 Mar 2008

forget all my other questions just give me reference of two gurdwaras and tell me, why indira gandhi would launch missiles into punjab and blame pakistan, and also why she would attack harmandar sahib and 40 other gurdwaras for no reason??

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

inderjeet1012 · 21 Mar 2008

"have read books thats why i schooled you and ""everyone"" else in here. " so u wanna school the people on this forum ..........hahaha..........man u really high on haumai..... i told u before stop trying to be a judge of gurmukhs........u see all those events from a worldly perspective.........only if u get the love for sikhi like those gurmukhs had, will u come to know how much it aches when people try to undermine sikhi...............but u r hard-headed..... try this....... dissociate with the whole issue of 1984 temporarily and try focussing on ur sikhi instead........u create such a furore on social/political topics but never seen u posting even once on gurmat articles...........i am telling u like a brother all this is nothing but feeding ur ego by arguing/citing facts/analyzing/concluding and then feeling happy....."oh man......i made that guy shut up"..........think about it

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

sidhu.hcl · 21 Mar 2008

Sant Bhindrawala babaji was a great leader to sikhs. and He did a lot for the community and religion.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

kpsingh · 03 Apr 2008

Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh Saadh Sangat ji Here is one account of Jeevan of Sant Baba Jarnail Singh ji by Giani Thakur Singh ji http://gurmatveechar.com/katha.php Present Day Katha--> Giani Thakur Singh (Patiala Wale) --> Sant Da Jeevan.mp3 From listening to katha one will know Sant ji had ucha sucha jeevan.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

nobody · 03 Apr 2008

mandeep Wrote: ------------------------------------------------------- > dashmesh regiment i also asked to show me > references to those two gurdwaras attacked and i > mean credible, also start naming the gurdwaras > with evidence, tell me were in those white papers > it says 40 gurdwaras were attacked please. > > Could you give me any reference that names the 40 > gurdwaras attacked cause till this day no one has > bin able to proving that this is an urban myth > about 40 other gurdwaras being attacked and once > again proving that bhindranwale and indira gandhi > were both causes of operation bluestar. > > dashmesh regiment you havn't provided any evidence > as of yet, your debate is dumb, so if i said in > the white papers it says no other gurdwaras were > attacked would it make it true?? > > PPl would be stupid if they believed me if i said > that the indian army never attacked harmandar > sahib instead fed the militants and the ppl > ladoo's and thats true cause its what it says on > the whtie papers,yet i wouldn't be able to provide > evidence, same goes for the two gurdwaras you > claim to be attacked cause im waiting for you to > provide credibile evidence just give me anything > on top of that no one till this day bin able to > name any of the 40 gurdwaras so i personally > believe ppl who believe this myth are stupid. Research all you like because for every answer you will ask 2 more questions, just try not to run out of swaas too soon :) The post bluestar white paper released by the gov't stated that 42 gurdwaras had been raided. sangat singh ex intel agent mentions moga, mukatsar, faridkot, patiala, ropar and chowk mehta (sikhs on history 2002)

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

confused · 04 Apr 2008

Mandeep Veer/Bhenjee (Sorry not sure which one) You're being very ignorant about this whole issue. I don't believe anyone really has much time to name every 40 or 70 Gurughar that was attacked at the time. I used to be very involved in this defending Sant Jee and other characters. Over time, I realized there is no point. I've come to accept only defending a select few. That includes, Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee and any other person in need of my defending. You will never get anywhere in your jeevan by judging individuals regardless of who they are. Yea, sure, the Gandhis had done some bad things but you don't see everyone of us coming on this forum every hour of everyday to talk about how evil she was. You must realize that you have to leave this judging of characters behind. You have to stay involved in this political matters only minimally. Instead of coming on here and talking trash or researching about this stuff. Why not work to make sure this never happens again. Why not do simran with every breath that you have just wasted reading this. Why not let others have nothing to do on this forum but give you advice on how to live your life better, find time to do more simran, find time to read more bani, learn how to correct read or interpret bani. A note to Admin, this topic should be closed down, it's obviously not gaining any ground.

SIKHS AND KHALISTAN DEBATE ON BBC

gb2000 · 16 Apr 2008

SIKHS WIN KHALISTAN DEBATE ON BBC HINDU FANATICS LOSE ARGUMENT AND RESORT TO SWEARING, NASTINESS AND TERRORISTS THREATS On Monday 14 April the BBC decided to hold a debate on whether or not there should be a separate Sikh State, Khalistan. Nihal presented the show on BBC Asian Network between 9-10am. The two invited to speak on the subject were Jagdeesh Singh, a Sikh activist from Slough and Deshpal Panesar, an employment law barrister from London. Jagdeesh Singh put the case for the break up of India and gave a historical Sikh perspective. Whereas Deshpal Panesar – an Indian nationalist - argued Sikhs had flourished in India, although he later admitted Sikhs had ‘had a hard time’. In total there were 19 other contributors that took part in the discussion or sent texts or emails that were read out on air. The BBC tried to ensure a balance between those for and against a separate Sikh State, but the Khalistanis clearly came out on top. Gurjeet Singh a leading figure in the Sikh Federation (UK) and from Leicester was the first caller and described the discrimination Sikhs have experienced since 1947 and the lack of justice for the last 30 years since 13 April 1978. One thing that is often misinterpreted that both Gurjeet Singh and Jagdeesh Singh explained was that a sovereign Sikh State would be a home where people of all faiths have freedoms. Hardeep Singh from Berkshire a graduate in Medical Biology from Brunel University in London and a media correspondent for Panjab Radio then explained the significance of the actions taken by the Indian authorities in 1984 in advancing the case for Sikh independence and Khalistan. He also corrected Nihal who in the introduction referred to Hindu/Sikh riots instead of state sponsored pogroms. Someone from Leicester named Jagdeesh then explained he was against India breaking up and believed the status quo must be maintained. He was a poor speaker with a limited knowledge of freedom movements who not surprisingly refused to accept Sikhs and others should have the freedom to secure their independence. Dabinderjit Singh then spoke of the broken promises to Sikhs following Indian independence and the Sikhs refusal to sign the Indian constitution that does not even recognise Sikhs as a separate faith. He argued the continued gross violation of the human rights of Sikhs in the last 30 years reinforced the need for Sikh independence. He also explained the paramount importance in the 9/11 era of Sikhs throughout the world having a Sikh voice to represent their interests. This in part addressed the presenter who asked a number of the callers if they would go and live in an independent Sikh State if it was created. Other pro-Khalistan speakers before the debate was due to end at 10am included Harbhajan Singh from Leicester, Jagvir Singh from Bristol and Hardeep Singh from Walsall. The only other two callers were a Muslim Panjabi called Ross who argued Panjabis were already independent and someone who called himself Daljit Sahota from Derby. He said he was not in favour of Sikh independence, but also admitted he or his family had not really been impacted on by the events of 1984. The BBC took the unusual step to extend the debate beyond 10am and invited two controversial callers called Ash and Paul. Ash a Hindu Panjabi was clearly upset and said he was opposed to the carving up of India. He said he had a nasty side and ‘pledged’ to take up arms that would ‘make Al Qaeda look like a little baby’. Paul then continued with a barrage of abuse towards Sikhs that had spoken in favour of Sikh independence. He called them ‘crazy’, ‘nutters’, accused them of ‘talking bloody nonsense’, said they should have their ‘heads examined’ and that they had ‘mental problems’. People can listen to the programme and decide for themselves on the BBC web site by visiting: http://www.bbc. co.uk/radio/ aod/asiannet_ ao.../asiannihal _mon The BBC also read out 6 email messages that were mostly in support of Sikh independence and the arguments that had been put forward. The debate was ended by the BBC reading out an emailed statement from Bhai Amrik Singh, the Chair of the Sikh Federation (UK), which is reproduced below: ‘The Indian authorities have systematically discriminated against the Sikhs since 1947 and subverted or suppressed all legitimate political demands for greater autonomy. In the last 30 years the Indian authorities have unleashed a rein of terror through gross violation of human rights of Sikhs in an attempt to extinguish the calls for freedom and Sikh independence. Sikhs first secured political power in the form of an independent state in 1710, after suffering centuries of foreign invasions and alien domination. The larger sovereign Sikh state was established in 1799 and was recognised by all the world powers. The Sikhs, after the two Anglo-Sikh wars, lost their kingdom and the Punjab came under British rule in 1849. However, in giving up power Sikhs were party to several Treaties with the British. Sikhs are clear about their nationhood, but it is denied by the Indian State and the Indian political class which are not prepared to allow the Sikhs their national rights.’ Given what Nihal, the presenter who is Sri Lankan and a Buddhist, had just heard from Ash and Paul after 10am he finished by saying Bhai Amrik Singh had put the Sikh case very eloquently.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 17 Apr 2008

nobody thanks for mentioning those gurdwaras but their's no book or any evidence that those gurdwaras were attacked, could you please tell me what reference i can read or give me a amazon book link so i can buy the book that explains these gurdwaras being attacked. Like i said real evidence

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

mandeep · 17 Apr 2008

confused reason im responding is for the sikhs who think anyone who goes against bhindranwale is wrong, well ppl have good reason to go against bhindranwale, and for bhindranwale supporters i have few questions theirs also a myth a very powerfull urban myth with no evidence that bhindranwale went into harmandar sahib to protect it couple of questions about this urban myth that bhindranwale went into harmandar sahib to protect it, questions of what would congress do if bhindranwale wasn't in harmandar sahib and they attacked it my first question to that is what would indira gandhi and congress tell the world to protect their reputation and from being called nazis if they killed inocent sikhs and attacked harmandar sahib for no reason? what would congress tell 15-20% of the indian army at that time which consisted of sikhs if they attacked harmandar sahib for no reason and just killed inocent sikhs. Why would congress attack harmandar sahib for no reason and kill inocent sikhs for no reason and if you read any biography of indira gandhi or listen to what other world leaders have said about her or read why bbc made her a candidate of being the 20th century's greatest women its cause she protected her reputation with fire, she would not let anything hurt her reputation, she wanted a reputation of a strong women who loved her ppl, so tell me if she attacked harmandar sahib and killed inocent sikhs for no reason what would she done to save her reputation??? another question some may say if india's govt wasn't going to attack harmandar sahib for no reason then why did they attack 40 other gurdwaras to that i like to ask what 40 gurdwaras? could anyone name me these gurdwaras cause every khalistan website ive bin to claims their were 40 other gurdwaras attacked but won't name them,?

Re: SIKHS AND KHALISTAN DEBATE ON BBC

mandeep · 17 Apr 2008

being a sikh i believe we need to fight for are rights and justice for 78 and 84 and for the crimes commited by security forced in 80's-90's, but i believe the reason's we didn't get justice is cause we were to focused on khalistan and feeling like victims, basicully what i would here is we need khalistan cause we can't get justice in india, but never did i hear khalistanis talk about getting justice for 78 and 84 and what the indian security forced did in the 80's and 90's. also look at the corruption in punjab today what type of corruption would exsist in khalistan, especially if we can't run gurdwaras without fighting were ever we live thirdly drug addictions are at 50% in punjab, 1 in 2 youth have a drug addiction how to deal with that fourth, economically how would we run economically fifth everyone wants to move out who would stay and live in khalistan sixth india would want khalistna back and pakistna might want to take shots at us to, how would we do stuck between these two countrys seventh everyone wants to leave punjab how many ppl would actually want to go live in khalistan, who would want to move back, especially when the economy wouldn't be stable and corruption ppl wouldn't raise their kids their eighth, jews are discriminated against in america but are a powerhouse in that country, they are the most successfull ppl, sikhs are successfull were ever they go and even though we have had it hard in india we are still successfull, but the biggest problem facing now is parants won't teach their kids hard work and determination instead just spoil them, rather then cause even bigger problems by becoming are own country we need to get stronger within india so we can get justice, more and more sikhs no less and less about sikhi in punjab and more youth are cutting their hair and dropping out of school so how would khlaistan survive with all these problems how would khlaistan survive.

Re: SIKHS AND KHALISTAN DEBATE ON BBC

Harinder Singh · 17 Apr 2008

<< though we have had it hard in india we are still successfull,>> All practicing strong honest sikhs WERE MASS MURDERED. So called sikhs who have accepted slavery are "successful". even today sikhs who want to live with DIGNITY are targeted, mocked, Spy cops after them.

Re: SIKHS AND KHALISTAN DEBATE ON BBC

Harinder Singh · 18 Apr 2008

Not only sikhs, MUSLIMS are genocided too. INDIAN police and INDIAN army in reality IS BAMMAN POLICE AND BAMMAN ARMY.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

nobody · 18 Apr 2008

i haven't got the time or patience to try and convince a nindak such as yourself about sant jarnail singh ji. sant ji did everything in the hukam and aagya of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj, anyone who sincerely looks into his jeevan and actions can see that. however the nindak will be filled with shanka and hatred and will continue to ask questions even though the answer lies in their gaze. some gurdwaras that have been attacked have been named, as has the source. the evidence of what occurred in 1984 lies in history and not in propaganda. my advice is that you should do your own honest research before reaching a conclusion happy hunting

Re: SIKHS AND KHALISTAN DEBATE ON BBC

scimitar · 18 Apr 2008

mandeep states "feeling like vitims?" the sikhs faced mass murder rape police brutality if they were not victims during 80s and 90s what were they? there is a clear difference between feeling and actually being victims when sikhs were clearly marked out in state pogroms.. it is the sikh community who after who decided to move on, recrate their lives in their forgive and let liv eand start again after suffering the deafening silence of the world. The fanatical rss were still hell bent well after the 90s into the new millenium, the bollywood film industry continually targets the sikh identity, sikhs were denied the free democratic right of protest to march in india against dera sacha sauda. The sikh stands in the midst of it all with only his her rehat as their support. Thats hardly a comparable scenario with jews and america. jews and america have a different relationship to the relationship sikhs and india have. This is a relationship that india should encourage and foster with the sikhs, after the damage it caused to punjab and the sikh community. On the one end of it an organised country with state resources experience of 50 years on the other the sikh. Most of us have no problems with indians any religions, we respect everyones right to live in dignity and exerience equality and free right to breathe be that a sikh hindu muslim indian american.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

scimitar · 18 Apr 2008

singh move on with your life! paat simran karlah! a lot of people will not waste their time on the net answering questions we are here to make our jeevans better. Hatt jhor keh behnti mittrah shootih kuhr sammah toh odhai khutt eh! One thing that stands out is indian nationalists continually feel sant bhindawala was the start and cause of khalistan. He was a speaker with some influence, the Indian authorities layed a heavy hand on the sikh community since 1947 that only got worse, and thus the sikhs reacted with or without sant bhindrawala. Thus tensions simmered from many decades. Hence sant bhindrawala was not the cause of khalistan . As can be seen with the inceptions of militant movements preceding 1984. There you go! Most of us are not politically natured people here we do not have hidden plots bhai we are just here to improve our lives, work and then pass on. What are you trying to gain by asking silly questions? any person that does an indepth unbiased analysis has their own conclusion. Wy should i or anyone listen to you? move on brother and make use of the valuable time for it wont come again.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

scimitar · 18 Apr 2008

i should not use the word forgiveness,That would be an understatement of someones suffering.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

scimitar · 19 Apr 2008

my last recorrecting post should have gone to the sant bhindrawala thread. apologoy for confusion.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

oothpathang · 21 Apr 2008

Mandeep wrote: ****************************** what would congress tell 15-20% of the indian army at that time which consisted of sikhs if they attacked harmandar sahib for no reason and just killed inocent sikhs. ******************************** That is the thing. Indira Gandhi was smart enough to not use Sikh soldiers in the attack because she and everyone knew that Sikh soldiers would rather kill fight the Indian army than let an inch to be captured. In fact, any Sikh who calls himself Sikh would do the same thing. So they deployed Sikh regiments far away from Punjab state as possible. After the attack on the Golden Temple hundreds of Sikh soldiers are known to have mutinied and were rushing their way towards Punjab, but being separated from Punjab at such a long distance these unknown heroes of our Panth were crushed. Mandeep, we should care less of what BBC, or what the world thinks of the issue. The world supports the likes of Indira Gandhi, Nehru who were nothing but power hungry hyenas who caused India considerable pain. India could have been a great country right after Independence, but these power hungry politicians just ended up making India even more corrupt. The contemporary world will condemn the likes of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawalay just as the world condemned heroes of the Panth like Baba Banda Singh Bahadur and Akali Phula Singh during their times. These unpopular heroes of the Panth are not in a popularity contest for world opinions. These men lived and died in accordance to how a Khalsa should live and ideally die. Who cares about world opinion. For the World opinion, charlatans like Mahatma Gandhi is a hero, while genuine heroes like Udham Singh, Bhaghat Singh, Chandar Shekhar Azad were considered terrorists during their times. Times just like world opinion is subject to fallacy and change in any direction the wind blows Sant Jarnail Singh Jee is one of the greatest Sikhs of the 20th century. He was no politician, but just a simple man who knew how to be a great Khalsa. They say if you repeat a lie a 1000 times, people will eventually start believing it. The greatest success of the Indian media has been to brainwash 99% Indians that this brave Khalsa warrior was an evil villain, a terrorist. I’m no Khalistani, but I certainly know a hero when I see him. If he talks like a Hero, looks like a Khalsa Hero, lived like a Khalsa Hero, and died like a Khalsa Hero, then chances are that person is a Hero. At least in my books despite what the world thinks of him.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Gyani · 24 May 2008

It was Goebells.... Hitler's media Man who coined the phrase..tell a LIE a thousand times and people will begin to beleive in it as TRUTH. We SIKHS must NOT let LIES be turned into "TRUTH" just by repetition. These Lies has been repeated since 1984 and go on being repeated 24 years after.. we have to keep REFUTING THE LIES and keep repeating the TRUTH even if it takes another 25 years. We must keep the FAITH with the TRUTH we know. Some of us didnt follow Gurbani which says..SACH SUNAISEE SACH KEE BELA- meaning even for TRUTH..there is a Specific TIME. If we let that time pass...then even the TRUTH loses its shine. No matter Truth remains TRUTH and will surface even if buried a thosuand miles underground.. Dhan Dhan Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaj.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

roopin · 09 Jun 2009

I am not here to say that sant. B wale was a terrorist, nor to rally support for the formation of khalistan. I would like to point out the unneccessary violence that erupted from the bluestar operation. If the Indian army was only after Sant B. wale, why were the innocent ppl inside the gurdwara killed. Was it neccessary to kill the women and the children. Why was this specific date chosen, a date which ensured that a larger population would be present inside the temple. Why was there a media blackout, why were independent media outlets shutdown. Sant B. wale (there is plenty of evidence) that he was walking about in amrtisar, why was he not arrested then, in the streets of amritsar. Even in those small crowded streets, a well orchestrated army plan would have been able to capture him. There was no need to bomb, the golden temple, if a bank is being robbed, with hostages inside, the SWAT team ensures that the least amount of innocent life is lost. WHy weren't steps taken, to address the issues of what had been done, by indira gandhi. If she had justified her actions (no justification would have been good enough to explain what she had done), why were sikhs being killed everyday. Why were these needless killing allowed to go on for years, and on record till 1994! Why is there no death toll, no one cared to count the bodies? There may be no proof that other gurdwaras wre simultaneously attacken in june 1984, but there is evidence that more gurdwaras were attacken afterwards, example november 1, 1984rakab ganj gurdwara in new delhi. WE need an account of why this was done to us. It is dismal to say the least, that we sikhs today are fighting amongst ourselves to determine if SAnt. B wale was a saint or sinner, and due to political backlash we are afraid to stand together on this issue. When instead we should be united, to question and pressurize not only the indian govenment, but foreign governments to help us sikhs find answers, to all the missing pieces of this puzzle. On a personal note, whether or not Sant. B wale knew of the forthcoming attack, and was trying to prepare for it with guns, has yet to be proved, that he was puppet of the congress party is also up for debate. That he was a revolutionary preacher to the sikhs is undeniable. That he stood up for the sikhs, he raised his voice to the oppression by the government, is not debatable. He encouraged the sikhs to again return to their roots, to become sache sikhs. Nayar, informs us that 245 : 'Bhindranwale asked Longowal to give a call to the Sikh masses to purchase motorcycles and revolvers to kill Hindus in Punjab IN the following link it clears SAnt. B wale's apparent claim to kill hindu's, a man named nayar went on record to claim that Sant b. wale claimed this, but sant b. wale clears it on record as well saying that he never said this. http://74.125.113.132/search?q=cache:s3q0p76vjf0J:www.sikhcoalition.org/SantJarnailSingh.pdf+sant+bhindranwale+said+kill+hindu&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=ca The following link provides human rights violations by the indian goverment, specified towards the sikhs http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=41562 While the following link provides translations into english, of speeches made by sant B. wale http://www.sikhlionz.com/sant.htm While futher inhumane behaviour by the indian goverment towards the sikh is in the following link: http://forum.pz10.com/showthread.php?t=21582 I strongly believe that if the sikh nation (those belonging to the sikh faith) were to rally together, stand united we would find anwers directly from the people responsible. I believe those responsible for these heinous crimes should be brought to justice. violence and raising arms is not the answer, dialogue is, courts, evidence (which there is plenty) should be used to bring justice. I hope that we can do this before those who have witnessed these crimes are no longer.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

scimitar · 11 Jun 2009

41 India Today, 31 December 1983, page 36. "Why, one might ask would Bhindranwale present himself, along with over fifty of his supporters, at the Deputy Commissioner's residence on the day he moved to Guru Nanak Niwas, if his purpose was to hide from the law? Gurdev Singh, District Magistrate at Amritsar until shortly before the invasion, is on record as having assured the Governor of the state that he could arrest anyone in Darbar Sahib at any time. " "Gurdev Singh: Letter addressed to I.K. Gujral, dated 26 January 1996, published in Abstract of Sikh Studies, Chandigarh, October-December 1996, pp. 106-111 In December 1983, a senior officer in Chandigarh confessed: "It's really shocking that we have so little against him while we keep blaming him (Bhindrawale ) for all sorts of things. "41 The fact is that when the Government was in the process of training army units in the planned invasion of Darbar Sahib, the only charges against Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale were that his speeches were 'objectionable'. retired Lieutenant General Jagjit Singh Aurora aptly pointed out in a report by James M. Markham, 'only last month Mrs. Gandhi's son Rajiv had praised him [Bhindranwale] as a man of religion.' A piece by James Traub further lambasted Gandhi, 'The root of India's problem is that Mrs. Gandhi seems unable to accept the legitimacy of any opposition: Compromise is foreign to her nature.' An editorial referring to Gandhi's 'credibility problem' hammered the final nail into her integrity coffin: 'the Prime Minister appears to disdain conciliation.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

13khalsa · 11 Jun 2009

There are wide range of views on Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale from one extreme calling him a terrorist and then on the other end people calling him a Braham Gyanee. So what will history call him, more importantly what will Sikh History call him. For this answer we just need to look at what an average/neutral Sikh thinks of him, someone that does not belong to his jatha or works for the authorities. A Sikh outside his circle of followers will first see him as a human, so therefore they acknowledge it will be inevitable that he will be prone to mistakes as only Guru Jee is perfect. There are lot of people that have said that the approach, the language and general intellect could have been better. It is always easy to say things in hindsight, we have to remember the environment in which this all evolved and its constraints. After all we are really talking about a few simple (not in a bad sense) Sikhs taking on a so called World Power. However one thing everyone agrees on is that Sant Jee’s intentions were honest and his passion for Sikhee was unmatched and only some one with honest intentions can sacrifice his life. After all he did not do this to gain any worldly rewards. The picture and history of Sant Jee would be very different if he didn’t sacrifice his life. I believe Sikh history will see him as an honest man trying do defend Sikhee in whatever way he could with whatever little he had.

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

scimitar · 11 Jun 2009

(Admin - We have edited this post and allowed on material that has not been repeated) Operation Bluestar Created New Crusaders for Sikh Cause" Dr Subramaniam Swami - Ex-Member of Parliment "The ugly situation prevailing in Punjab would not have taken place if the legitimate demands of the Sikh community had been conceded. In fact, there should have been no need for anyone to have agitated for these demands in the first place if events had moved on the principle of justice and fair play." (Bharat Kumar Baweja, India Abroad Weekly, New York, June 29, 1984) "I (Subramanium) visited Punjab on numerous occasions specially during critical months preceding ill-fated Operation Blue Star to evaluate the situation first-hand I lived inside the Golden Temple on three different occasions including a stay of three days just prior to the Temple invasion. After extended discussions with key figures like Sant H.S. Langowal, G.S. Tohra, Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, Hindu community leaders, police and administrative officials, press and people at large" "over 100,000 sikhs have been arrested. This high number of arrests is undoubtedly, a national record and so has been the peaceful nature in which the Satyagrahas (protests) of this magnitude have been handled by the Sikhs, with extreme tolerance." (S.M. Sathananthan, et. a1., Hindu-Sikh Conflict in Punjab: Cause and Cure, London: Transatlantic India Times, 1983, p. 15) "The Akali Dal (the Sikh Organization) is in the hands of moderate and sensible leadership...but givin anyone a fair share of power is unthinkable politics of Mrs. Gandhi... Many Hindus in Punjab privately concede that there isn't much wrong with these (Sikh) demands. But every time the ball goes to the Congress Court, it is kicked out one way or another because Mrs. Gandhi considers it a good electoral calculation." (Pran Chopra, Wall Street Journal, September 26, 1983) F.Versey October 31, 2004 "deconstructing durga" "She had mastered the act of playing both victim and rescuer Pupul Jayakar, a friend and biographer of Indira Gandhi has revealed that "a few days after the army attack writes, "she had aged. There were lines on her forehead and a supreme gravity in her eyes. She did not wish to speak of Punjab and I asked no questions." "For over a year, the Indian army had been preparing for an attack on the Darbar Sahib. To legitimize the attack, according to Subramaniam Swami—-a member of the Indian Parliament—-the central government had created a disinformation campaign. In his words, the state sought to "make out that the Golden Temple was the haven of criminals, a store of armory and a citadel of the nation's dismemberment conspiracy" "In these days, the news has followed the ever more serious events in the state of Punjab. I do not want to go into the delicate and complex motives behind these disturbances in a great nation. But the sad fact is that the place where so many people met a tragic death is a temple where men gather in prayer." Pope John Paul II

Re: Sick Of Anti-Sant Bhindranwale "Sikhs"

admin · 13 Jun 2009

This thread is now closed. Nothing new has been submitted that we don't already know. The thread had gone on long enough and it was with reluctance that we allowed new posts on it. If there is something new you want to share then please start a new topic.